Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf ·...
Transcript of Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf ·...
![Page 1: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Subsidy Calculations
1
![Page 2: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Finding Subsidies
Notifications of subsidies (to be filed annually
with the WTO – ASCM Article 25.1);
Gov’t Ministries, Departments and Agencies;
Legislation;
Internet;
Stock exchange;
Credit agencies;
Filings with relevant regulatory bodies.
2
![Page 3: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Signs Of A Subsidy
Financial contributions from government or a
public body such as grants, loans, revenue
foregone, equity injection and input subsidies;
A benefit is conferred. The cost (by itself) to
government or the public body is not sufficient;
Subsidy is specific and not generally available;
Pass through benefits can also be signs of a
subsidy. This is an indirect form of subsidy.
3
![Page 4: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Subsidy Test
WTO Agreement on Subsidies & Countervailing
Measures (ASCM) Article 14 requires calculation
of the amount of a subsidy in terms of the benefit
to the recipient. In summary, test for subsidies:-
1. Establish that there was a financial
contribution by government or a public body;
2. Establish that a benefit was conferred;
3. Establish that 1 & 2 are specific;
4. Calculate the amount of the subsidy.
4
![Page 5: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Case Study – Orange Industry
A case study of the orange juice industry
demonstrates subsidy calculations for:
– Grants;
– Loans;
– Revenue Foregone;
– Equity Injection; and
– Input Subsidies.
5
![Page 6: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
BoDMAS
Sequential order of a formula:
1. Brackets ( )
of
2. Division /
3. Multiplication x
4. Addition +
5. Subtraction - 6
![Page 7: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Case Study – Orange Industry
In 2012, members of the Jamaica Orange
Industry (JOI), who are Jamaican manufacturers
who produce orange juice for sale on the
domestic market, complained to Jamaica’s
Subsidies Investigative Authority (JSIA) that
subsidized orange juice imported in 2010 and
2011 (2 years) from Juice Supreme (JS) in
Bahar, adversely affected their sales and profits
and appears to be threatening further injury.
7
![Page 8: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Case Study – Orange Industry
It takes 1/4 gallon of puree to produce one
gallon of orange juice;
A 1/4 gallon of puree costs $80 but subsidies
from the Bahar Government lowers it to $30;
JS produced 100,000 gallons of orange juice;
Production cost was $178/gallon;
JS sales were 100,000 gallons at $250/gallon;
30,000 gallons of orange juice were exported
to Jamaica at a reduced price of $200/gallon.
8
![Page 9: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Case Study – Orange Industry
BElec is the monopoly supplier of electricity in
Bahar and is 100% owned by the Government;
Electricity sales: 60% to Industry at $10/kwh &
40% to others at a profitable rate of 40/kwh;
BElec buys gas to produce electricity from
BGas - also 100% owned by Government;
BElec has settled 5% of its BGas Receivables;
BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec
a loan below market rates to repay BGas debt. 9
![Page 10: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Grants
JSIA’s investigation found that during 2010
and 2011 in Bahar, Jamaica’s second largest
trading partner, Juice Supreme (JS) received
a grant of $1,000,000 from the Government of
Bahar to modernize its Production Plant. The
prevailing commercial bank interest rates in
Bahar were 12% and the average life cycle of
JS’ Production Plant is 10 years.
10
![Page 11: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Grants
The following equation can be used to calculate
the amount of subsidy provided by a Grant:
11
i 1
i ] l)– y/n)(k (– [y y/n Sk
Where:
Sk = the amount of subsidy countervailable in year k K = number of years under review y = the face value of the grant n = the average life cycle of the plant i = the standard (prevailing) market interest rate
![Page 12: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Grants
The calculation of a cash value subsidy in 2011
of a 10 year Grant begun in 2010 is:
12
714,185$1.12
208,000 Sk
0.12 1
1)]0.12-/10)(2(1,000,000– [1,000,000 101,000,000/ Sk
![Page 13: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Grants
The subsidy as a percentage of sales:
100,000 gallons x $250/gallon
= $25,000,000. Therefore,
13
%74.010025,000,000
714,185 cent per Subsidy
![Page 14: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Loans
Further investigations found that JS received:
A $3,000,000 loan in 2010 at a preferential
rate of 6% from a government owned bank;
The standard market interest rate was 12%;
The loan is repayable over a period of 10
years in equal instalments.
14
![Page 15: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Loans
Benefits from loans under circumstances
that they would not normally be granted
may be deemed to be a subsidy;
Loans made at preferential rates,
compared to market rates, can be deemed
to be a subsidy;
The subsidy is the difference in the market
and preferential interest rate annualised
over the loan term at the discount rate.
15
![Page 16: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Loans
The amount of subsidy from the loan:
16
ny /)i - (i1
)i - (i l)]-(y/n)(k -[y +y/n Sk
am
am
Where: Sk = the amount of subsidy countervailable in year k k = the year under review y = the face value of the loan n = the period over which the loan has to be repaid im = market interest rate ia = the actual interest rate paid on the loan
![Page 17: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Loans
The subsidy countervailable at year 2 can
be calculated as follows:
17
849,135$Sk
10/000,000,30.06)-(0.12 + 1
0.06)-1)](0.12-/10)(2(3,000,000 - [3,000,000 + 103,000,000/ Sk
![Page 18: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Loans
The Subsidy as a percentage of total sales:
18
%54.010025,000,000
849,135 cent per Subsidy
![Page 19: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Revenue Foregone
JS was also granted “approved entity” status
by the Bahar Government;
As an approved entity, a minimum of 60% of
the value of the company’s raw material used
must be of domestic content;
As a result, JS received a tax credit thus its
export earnings are exempt from corporate tax
but domestic earnings are taxed at 20%;
The export tax subsidy is therefore 20%.
19
![Page 20: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Revenue Foregone
Revenue foregone subsidy formula:
20
tEc) - (Ep S
Where: S = subsidy amount Ep = export price Ec = export cost t = tax rate
![Page 21: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Revenue Foregone
30,000 gallons were exported, so the total
value of the subsidy, or revenue foregone, is
30,000 x $4.40 = $132,000;
Where,
21
gallonper $4.40 20% 178) - (200 S
![Page 22: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Revenue Foregone
The revenue foregone as a percentage of
the export price is:
22
%%
%
20.2200
20)178200( cent per Subsidy
Ep
)( cent per Subsidy
tEcEp
![Page 23: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Equity Injection
The Bahar Government purchased 200,000
ordinary shares at an agreed price of $20 per
share. JS’ share price on the Bahar Stock
Exchange at the time of the transaction was
$18.
23
![Page 24: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Equity Injection
The Bahar Government’s purchase of
200,000 ordinary shares above market
price is an equity injection. The formula is:
24
NeMe) - (Ae Se
Where: Se = Subsidy benefit of the equity injection Ae = Agreed purchase price of the equity Me = Market price of the equity Ne = Number of the equity
![Page 25: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Equity Injection
The value of the subsidy for the equity
injection is:
25
$400,000 200,000 18) - (20 Se
![Page 26: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Equity Injection
The subsidy by equity injection as a
percentage of total sales is:
26
%60.110025,000,000
000,400 cent per Subsidy
![Page 27: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Input Subsidies
A quarter gallon of puree costs $80. The
government subsidises puree used by JS
thereby lowering its purchase cost to $30
per quarter gallon;
This is a financial contribution by the
government and a benefit is conferred via
the lower purchase cost of the puree. This is
an input subsidy to the manufacturer.
27
![Page 28: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Input Subsidies
The formula can be written as:
28
To
PvSc - Mc S%
Where:
S% = Subsidy percentage
Mc = Material cost
Sc = Subsidised cost
Pv = Production volume
To = Turnover (sales revenue)
![Page 29: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Subsidy Calculation: Input Subsidies
The input subsidy percentage is:
29
20% S%
000,000,25
000,100$30 - $80 S%
![Page 30: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Causation
Having established that a subsidy exists and
calculated the amount, before seeking dispute
resolution and countervailable measures, one
must examine other factors causing injury;
Injury causation to the domestic industry may not
be solely attributable to the subsidy;
WTO ASCM Article 11.7: “…subsidy and injury
shall be considered simultaneously (a) in the
decision…to initiate an investigation and
(b)…during the course of the investigation….”
30
![Page 31: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
De Minimis
WTO ASCM Article 11.9: “…There shall be
immediate termination in cases where the amount
of a subsidy is De Minimis, or where the volume of
subsidized imports, actual or potential, or the
injury, is negligible;
…the amount of the subsidy shall be considered to
be De Minimis if the subsidy is less than 1 per cent
ad valorem.” If more, calculate countervailing duty;
ASCM Article 19.4: “No countervailing duty shall
be levied..in excess of the amount of the subsidy..”
31
![Page 32: Subsidy Calculationsjadsc.gov.jm/.../03/...Module-4B-Subsidy-Calculations.March2015.pdf · demonstrates subsidy calculations for: ... BGas pays dividends to Gov’t who gives BElec](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022051719/5a74e1b27f8b9aea3e8c1089/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Countervailing Duty (CVD)
JS Orange Juice Export Volume (Gallons) 30,000
JOI Orange Juice Market Price ($ Per Gallon) 300
Market Value of Imported Orange Juice ($) 9,000,000.00
Subsidies
CVD CVD
% $ $/Gallon
Grants 0.74 66,600.00 2.22
Loans 0.54 48,600.00 1.62
Revenue Foregone 2.20 198,000.00 6.60
Equity Injection 1.60 144,000.00 4.80
Input Subsidies 20.00 1,800,000.00 60.00 Total 25.08 2,257,200.00 75.24
32