SUBJECT Page DATE OF DECISION OF THE BOARD O...

1

Press and Registration Appellate Board

S.NO

SUBJECT Page No.

DATE OF ORDER

DECISION OF THE BOARD

1 Appeal of Editor, Golden World weekly published from Pilibhit. U.P. vs. order dated July 15, 1982 passed by SDM, Pilibhit.

2(a) November 22, 1982

Cancellation of the declaration set aside.

2 Appeal of Shri Karunesh Chandra Pandey, Owner and Editor, Saptahik Vindhyavani, Shehdol, M.P. against the order dated 17th May, 1982 passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sohagpur, District Shehdol, Madhya Pradesh.

3(a) November 22, 1982

Appeal allowed and directed the SDM inter alia authenticate the declaration.

3 Appeal of Shri S.C. Upadhyaya, Proprietor, Chief Editor and Publisher of Yuva Gandhi, Bareilly against the order dated 17th February 1984 passed by the District Information Officer, Bareilly.

6(a) January 18, 1985

The Board directed the respondent to authenticate fresh declaration filed by the appellant.

4 Appeal of Shri Narain Das, Editor, Chakrash, Orai vs. order dated April 16, 1983 passed by the Pargana Magistrate, Orai.

4(a) January 18, 1985

The Board set aside the order.

5 Appeal filed by Shri Sudhir Yadav, Owner, Publisher and Printer of ‘Insat Times’, a Hindi weekly against the orders dated April 17, 1984 passed by the District Magistrate, Rampur, U.P.

5(a) January 18, 1985

Dismissed.

6 Appeal filed by the Editor & Proprietor, Gajashakti, Sangli, Maharashtra against the order of the District Magistrate, Sangli, Maharashtra.

10(a) December 2, 1985

Directed the District Magistrate to authenticate the fresh Declaration filed by the appellant.

7 Appeal of Shri Ram Pyare Rasik, Editor, ‘Surguja Sandesh’ against the order dated 24.12.82, Ambikapur, U.P. of Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Ambikapur, Madhya Pradesh.

10(a) December 16, 1985

Set aside the order dated 24.12.1982 passed by the SDM, Ambikapur, M.P.

8 Appeal filed by the Editor and Publisher of Weekly Chambal Kesari, Dholpur, Rajasthan against the orders of the District Magistrate, Dholpur, Rajasthan.


Dismissed.

9 Appeal filed by the Editor, Printer and Publisher of Bilari Mail Weekly, Moradabad, U.P. Vs. District Magistrate Moradabad and Deputy District Magistrate, Moradabad U.P.


Disposed of

2

10 Appeal filed by Shri Ram Dayal Bharagava, Chief Editor, Printer and Publisher of the Journal ‘Vishva Manav’, Bareilly against the order dated April 22, 1985 of District Magistrate, Bareilly, U.P.

21(a) February 4, 1986

Dismissed

11 Appeal filed by Mrs. Kavita Gavali, Printer, Sangli Darshan, against order dated March 30, 1985 of District Magistrate, Sangli


Publication not in conformity with the declaration. Upheld the orders passed by Magistrate.

12 Appeal filed by the Editor, Vindhya Lehri, Panna, M.P. against order dated December 13, 1984 of the Collector, Panna.


Dismissed.

13 Appeal filed by Mr. R.N.Raghuvanshi, Editor, Swaran Avam Pichhara Varg Vara, Bareilly against District Magistrate, Bareilly, U.P.


Appeal allowed: Yellow Journalism no ground for cancelling declaration.

14 Appeal filed by Smt. Asha Pandey, Editor & Owner, Journal of Plant and Nature, Kanpur, U.P. vs. order dated June 21, 1985 of City Magistrate, Kanpur.


Dismissed.

15 Appeal filed by Editor, Saket Sobha, Faizabad, U.P. vs. District Magistrate Faizabad, U.P.


No proper appeal filed-Dismissed

16 An appeal file by Shri Ramasrey Gupta, Editor, Nishant India, Panna, M.P. against order of District Magistrate, Panna cancelling the declaration of the paper.


Civil Suit Pending-Dismissed the appeal.

17 Appeal filed by Shri Uttamchandra Sharma, Eitor-in-chief, Muzaffarnagar Bulletin, Muzaffarnagar, U.P. vs.City Magistrate Muzaffarnagar, U.P.

13(a) July 21, 1986 Outside Jurisdiction - Dismissed.

18 Appeal filed by Shri Ramji Lal, Printer/Publisher/Owner/ Editor ‘Dubal Ki Awaz’, Rampur (U.P.) against the order dated 1.7.1986 of City Magistrate Rampur.

11(a) Nov 5, 1986 Dismissed

19 Appeal filed by Editor, Suryajagran, Jalaun, U.P. vs.order of Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jalaun, U.P.

25(a) July 31, 1987 Outside Jurisdiction- Dismissed

20 Appeal filed by Editor, Garm Khabar, Dadri District, Gaziabad U.P. vs. Sub-Divisional Magistrate Dadri, U.P.

24(a) July 31, 1987 Directed to authenticate the declaration

21 Appeal filed by Shri Jai Dev Sharma, Printer, Publisher and Proprietor of Daily Shivalik Sandesh vs. order-dated 7.11.85 passed by District Magistrate-cum-Deputy Commissioner, Chandigarh.

28(a) Nov. 9, 1987 Appeal allowed and the interim order dated July 31, 1987 passed by the Board, shall continue to remain in force as long as application for authentication is not disposed of.

3

22. Shri M P Vijayachandra Babu, Kerala vs. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Quilon, Kerala & Shri G Venugopalan on a judgement dated Dec. 17, 1986 passed by High Court of Kerala.

39(a) March 28, 1988 Appellant to approach authorities after disposal of Civil Case.

23. Appeal filed by Printer/Publisher/Editot of Bharat Mani, Hindi fortnightly, Bahraich, U.P.vs. an order dated July 1, 1986 passed by City Magistrate, Bahraich.

37(a) March 28, 1988 Impugned order set aside

24. Appeal filed by Shri Shamkant Gajanan, Editor, Marga Darshak, Dhule, Maharashtra vs. order dated May 4, 1987.

38(a) March 28, 1988 Appeal dismissed

25. Appeal filed by Shri V S Desai, Gwalior vs. Shri R C Agarwal and ADM, Gwalior order dated 23.7.87.

36(a) March 28, 1988 Disposed off. The ADM, Gwalior directed to deal with the application in light of the observations made by the Board..

26. Appeal filed by Principal, Jain Inter College, Muzaffarnagar vs. an interim order dated 13.10.87 passed by D.M., Muzaffarnagar.

34(a) March 28, 1988 Appeal dismissed. DM directed to dispose of the application of respondent in which he passed interim order expeditiously.

27. Editor, Dainik Vishwa Kampan, Fatehgarh, U.P. vs. an order dated 16.10.87 passed by City Magistrate, Farrukhabad.

32(a) March 28, 1988 The Board directed the respondent to give reasonable opportunity of hearing to the appellant,

28. Appeal filed by Shri Om Prakash Agarwal, Journalist and Shri Ghanshyam Jugalkishore Agarwal, advocate, Wardha, Maharashtra vs. an order dated June 20, 1986 passed by D.M., Wardha.

48(a) June 30, 1988 Appeal allowed and set aside the impugned order.

29. Appeal filed by Owner,Printer and Publisher, Barmer Express, Barmer vs. an order dated 1.12.1987 passed by Magistrate, Barmer.

46(a) June 30, 1988 Authorities directed to consider the case on merits.

30. Appeal filed by Proprietor of Dainik Pratidhawani, District Sangli, Maharashtra vs. an order-dated 20.4.1987 passed by ADM, Sangli, Maharashtra.

44(a) July 10, 1989 Impugned order stayed to remain operative till order passed on fresh declaration filed by appellant.

31 Appeal filed by Shri Gautam Chand Jain against the order of Sub Divisional Magistrate, Barmer dated 8.8.1988.

1 21st day of August, 1989

Dismiss for Non-Prosecution

32 Appeal against the order-dated 16.1.1990 passed by District Magistrate, Datia on the declaration of Shri Ashok Kumar, Proprietor Datia, Madhya Pradesh.

3 April 2, 1991 Impugned order set aside. District Collector to consider fresh declaration in accordance with Law.

33 Appeal of Shri Gautam Chand Jain, Proprietor, Publisher and Editor of Barmer Express against

7 April 16, 1991 Directions given to DM, Barmer

4

the order dated 3.11.1990 of Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Barmer regarding cancelling the declaration.

34 Appeal of Ajit Singh M/s Sunder Printers against the order-dated 2.12.1991 passed by DCP Licensing, Delhi.

11 February 28, 1992

Disposed of as not maintainable.

35 Appeal of Shri Bishambhar Dayal Agrawal against Shri Sudhir Agarwal, Shri Warka Prasad Agarwal, Shri Ramesh Chandra Agrwal and Additional District Magistrate Jabalpur (M.P.)

12 March 27,1992 Dismissed as Withdrawn

36 Appeal of Shri Ishwar Ramchandani against order of SDM, Mandsaur, M.P. passed on 2/1/1992, cancelling declaration of his newspaper Paatal Lok, published from Mandsaur.

13 May 25, 1992 Fresh declaration authenticated. Disposed of.

37 Appeal of Shri Pitabasa Mishra, Publisher, The Kurukshetra, Rourkela, Orissa against Shri Chittaranjan Mishra and ADM, Cuttack.

17 August 24, 1992 Impugned order dated 7.6.1991 set aside . Case sent to ADM (Relief), Cuttack with directions

38 Appeal of Shri Raj Hans Sharma against Additional District Magistrate City, Alwar, Rajasthan.

20 August 24, 1992 Dismissed

39 Appeal filed by Shri Raj Hans Sharma. against the order dated 1/4/1992 of the District Magistrate, Ajmer,

22 August 24th, 1992

Dismissed

40 Appeal of Shri Sudhir Agarwal, Proprietor, Printer and Publisher, Nav Bhaskar, Raipur Durg against the order dated 21/4/92 passed by the learned respondent no.2, Sub Divisional Magistrate, Durg.

25 May 11, 1992 Adjourned. The impugned order stayed till further orders.

41 Application of Shri G.C. Jain, Proprietor, Editor and Publisher, Barmer Express, against Shri Fateh Krishna Kala, SDM, Barmer, regarding non-compliance of order of Appellate Board dated 16.4.1991.

28 July 27, 1992 Directions given to SDM, Barmer, Rajasthan

42 Appeal of Editor, Printer, Publisher Owner, Subji Lahav, Badaun against the order of District Magistrate, Badaun.

29 August 24, 1992 Dismissed as Withdrawn

43 Appeal of Editor, Barmer Zile Ki Awaz, Barmer against the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Barmer for not authenticating the declaration of fortnightly newspaper.

33 17th May, 1993 Directions given to SDM, Barmer to authenticate the declaration.

5

44 Appeal against an order dated 20.2.1991 of the District Magistrate, Nanded, Maharashtra, Cancelling the declaration of Daily Satyaprabha (Marathi), Nanded, Maharashtra

66 June 15th, 1993 Appeal admitted – the question, which are left open, to be decided after hearing the other side.

45 Appeal of Shri Prabhakar Nanasaheb Rawke ‘Stayaprabha’, Gowardhan Ghar, Naded, Maharashtra against District Magistrate Nanded , Maharashtra.

67 8th November, 1993

Dismissed as Withdrawal

46 Appeal of Shri V. Venu Gopala Charyulu S/o Shri Kohama Charyulu, Executive Director against Deputy Commissioner of Police S.B. City and Additional District Magistrate (Executive) Hyderabad and Shri P. Venkateshwatulu, Managing Director, Krishna Patrika Publications Pvt. Ltd. Chikkadpalli, Hyderabad

69 8th March, 1994 Impugned order dated 16.8.93 set aside remitted the case to ADM (Executive), Hyderabad. Status Quo to be continued

47 Appeal of Shri Satyendra Pal, Managing Editor/Printer/Publisher of “Hindi Dainik” Gorakpur v/s. 1. Shri Markendaya Prasad Singh, 2. Smt. Moti Devi and 3. City Magistrate, Gorakpur

76 26th July, 1999 Dismissed

48 Appeal filed by Shri Mahavir Jain, Editor, Maru Lehar, Fortnightly, Barmer, against Shri Mahender Parekh, SDM, Balotra, Rajasthan.

78 10th June, 1996 Disposed of

49 Appeal filed by Sh. Mahavir Jain, Editor, Maru Lehar, Hindi Fortnightly, Barmer against Sh. Mahender Parekh, SDM. Balotra, Rajasthan.

80 22nd June, 1995 Appeal disposed of with observations and direction.

50 Appeal filed by Sh. Mahavir Jain, Editor, Maru Lahar, Barmer against SDM, Barmer.

87 22nd June, 1995 Set aside the impugned order with direction to SDM, Barmer.

51 Appeal filed by Sh. T Ramesh U Pai and Sh. Sanjeeva Kamath against The Secretary, The Academy of Manipal, General Education, Manipal

91 27th June, 1996 Dismissed

52 Appeal of Miss Alka C Shah against the order dated 9th October 1995 passed by the Learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate IIIrd Court Esplanade Bombay.

95 27th June, 1996 Dismissed

53 Appeal of Shri V. Chakrapani, Managing Director, Printer and Publisher, Andhra Patrika, Vijaywada against Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad, Shri S. Nageshwara Rao, Madras, Shri M. Mastan Reddy, Hyderabad.

100 18th September, 1996

Order dated 24/12/94 and 29.11.95 cancelled and appeal disposed of.

54 Appeal of Shri B. Ramachandra Adityan against order of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate passed on 12/7/1996


Dismissed

55 Appeal of Printer and Chief Editor, Magadh Ki 106 7th April, 1997 Set aside impugned order.

6

Pukar Hindi Weekly, published from Nawada, Bihar. against Sub Divisional Magistrate Nawada, Bihar.

Matter sent to DM, Gaya for hearing and final disposal according to law.

56 Appeal of Mr. V. Vanajakshan, Printer and Publisher ‘Homeguard’ against the Additional District Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram

107 23rd January, 1998

Disposed of with observations.

57 Appeal of Mirza Khairullah Baig Editor, Aaj Ki Sultanat, Hyderabad against the Deputy Commissioner of Police and Additional District Magistrate, Hyderabad.


Set aside impugned order

58 Appeal of Mr. Satya Prakash Gupta, Owner and Editor of Mathura Refinery Darpan Mathura against District Magistrate and Executive Director, Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., Mathura Refinery, Mathura


Set aside impugned orders dated 30.9.97 and 6.10.97

59 Appeal of Shri Jaspal Chadha, Mangal Bhoomi Times, District Udham Singh Nagar, U.P. vs. P.S. Kotwali Kashipur, Distt. Udham Singh Nagar, U.P. and Sub Divisional Magistrate, Kashipur.


Set aside impugned order dated 29/9/97 passed by SDM, Kashipur. Matter sent to DM, Udham Sigh Nagar for deciding the matter.

60 Appeal of Shri Pradeep Joshi, Owner and Printer, ‘Khula Panna’ P.J.House New Bundi, Rajasthan against DM Bundi, Rajasthan


Disposed of with directions to DM.

61 Appeal of Mr Satish Kumar Arya, Press Reporter Saharanpur, U.P. against DM Saharanpur U.P. and Registration Supervisor, R.K. Puram , New Delhi


Dismissed

62 Appeal of Shri Mukund Hari Kadam, Editor, Daily Sindhudurg Samachar (Maharashtra) against Shri Kiran Dhendopant, Editor Daily Tarun Bharat, Belgaun (Karnataka)


Disposed of

63 Appeal of Shri M.A. Krishnamurthy, Advocate against 1. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai 2. Shri. P. Devakadaksham, Chennai


Order of CMM, Egmore, upheld

64 Appeal of Sh. Pradeep Bahl, Owner, Printer, Editor, Publisher Supreme Law Today, Delhi against D.C.P (Licensing) Delhi and Mr. Vinod Nijhavan, Vikas Books Unlimited, Delhi


Set aside a impugned order dated 8.5.98

65 Appeal filed by Mr. Baber Siddique , Editor, ‘Aaj-Aur-Kal’, Hyderabad and Mr. M. Sikandar

133 1st March, 1999 Dismissed with observations

7

Siddique, Advocate against the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Spl. Branch City, Hyderabad and Additional District Registrar, (Executive), Hyderabad.

66 Appeal of Sh. N.D.Sharma, Editor, and ‘Diplomat International’ against order passed by Deputy Commissioner, Panipat ordering closure of his paper for violation of provision of PRB Act.

135 1st March, 1999 Appeal dismissed as not being maintainable.

67 Appeal filed by Dr. Nasim Ahmed Thanvi, Editor/Publisher/Distributor of ‘Thanvi Muzaffarnagar Times’ against the order dated 21.11.1998 of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Muzaffarnagar refusing to authenticate the declaration filed before him on 3.11.1998

138 1st March, 1999 Copy of the order sent to disciplinary authority and Chief Justice Allahabad High Court for such action as deemed fit.

68 Appeal filed by Mr. Narayan Roy, Hony Associate Editor North-East Echo against order dated 3.10.97 passed by Mr. L.C.Singhi, D.M. Dhubri, Assam closing his newspaper “North-East Echo”.

142 3rd May, 1999 Sub-judice. Disposed of

69 Appeal filed by Shri Raghunath Behare, Printer/Publisher, The Swarjya, Khurda published from Orissa against the order-dated 26.3.1998 passed by Additional District Magistrate, Khurda cancelling his declaration.

147 03 May, 1999 Dismissed

70 Appeal of Shri Chandrakant Ashok Patil, Shri Samudragupta Ashok Patil and Miss Padma Balasaheb Patil-Owners, Printers/Publishers ”Daily Satyawadi” against Shri Deelip Vidhyadhar Patil

150 03 May 1999 Directions to RNI and DM, Kolhapur.

71 Appeal of Publisher, Wisdom Chennai against order dated 28.8.98 of RNI, New Delhi.

152 1st March, 1999 Disposed off with directions to the appellant.

72 Appeal of Smt. Prema S. Shetty, Printer/Publisher, “KARAVALI MITHRA”V/s order dated 23.4.99 of District Magistrate, Dakshin Kannada, Mangalore

155 26th June 1999 The application for impleadment rejected

73 Appeal of Smt. Md. Iqbal Hassan, Owner/Publisher/Printer and Editor of “SAPTAHIK RASHTRIYA JUNG TIMES” Muzaffarnagar Vs. D.M Kairana Muzaffarnagar

159 26th July, 1999 The impugned order of, SDM dated 16/2/99 cancelled.

74 Appeal filed by Mr. Daljit Singh, Editor, Amar Haryana Newspaper, Karnal, V/s. State of Haryana through Collector Karnal and Shri Rajiv Arora, IAS, Deputy Commissioner, Karnal.

164 6th August, 1999 Dismissed

8

75 Appeal of the Publisher, “Wisdom”, Chennai against order of the Deputy Commissioner of Police, (Licensing), New Delhi and “Wisdom Today”, New Delhi.


Dismissed

76 Appeal of Shri Chandrakant Ashok Patil, Shri Samudragupta Ashok Patil & Miss Padma Balasahib Patil, Owners, Printers and Publishers Satyawadi against Shri Deelip Vidyadhar Patil and District Magistrate Sangli.

173 9th June, 2000 Contempt notice to both respondents. Directions dated 3.5.99 should be complied with immediately.

77 Appeal of Shri Jaspal Chadha against Shri Ashok Sharma, Kashipur, Additional District Magistrate, Kashipur and District Magistrate, Kashipur, Udham Singh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh.

178 9th June, 2000 Upheld the impugned order and disposes of both appeals.

78 Appeal filed by Shri Gopal Kishan Premi against Sub Divisional Magistrate, Guna, M.P. and Shri Tarun Gupta reg order dated 18.10.1999 of S.D.M., Guna

182 9th June, 2000 Disposed of

79 Appeal of Shri Vijay Kumar Varshney, Journalist ‘United Asia’, Hindi daily Aligarh Vs. District Magistrate, Aligarh.

185 9th June 2000 Appeal upheld and disposed of with directions.

80 Appeal of Saiyed Hashim Ali, Editor ‘Business Today’, Hindi Monthly against Deputy Commissioner of Police, (Licensing) and Registrar for Newspaper of India.

191 9th June 2000 Disposed of

81 Appeal of Shri Tilak Raj Sukhija, Editor ‘Udham Singh Nagar Ka Darpan’ against Sub Divisional Magistrate, Rudrapur, Udham Singh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh.

195 9th June 2000 Set aside the impugned order dated 1/3/2000

82 Appeal of Shri Suresh Shukla, Editor Owner ‘Indrapuri Samachar’ Amravati against Sub Divisional Magistrate, Amravati & Ors.

200 9th June, 2000 Stay granted to appellant by Board on 11/4/2000 to continue till final decisions in Civil Suit.

83 Appeal of Shri Thyagaraj Vara Kumar, Shimoga, Karnataka V/s Shri N. Manjunath, Shimoga Karnataka and Deputy Commissioner/ District Magistrate, Shimoga Karnataka, Registrar of Newspaper for India, New Delhi and Smt. Kamala Ramappa, Shimoga, Karnataka.

204 9th June 2000 Disposed of

84 Appeal of Shri Chandrakant Ashok Patil, Shri Samudragupta Ashok Patil and Miss Padma Balasaheb Patil, Printers and Publishers ‘Daily Satyawadi’, Kolhapur, Maharashtra against 1. The District Magistrate, Sangli, Maharashtra. 2. Shri Deelip Vidyadhar Patil 3. The RNI, New Delhi.

207 30th January, 2001

Show Cause Notice issued to DM, Sangli for contempt of the Board.

9

85 Appeal of Smt A.D. Likhariya, Owner, Printer,

Publisher, Bharat Apradh Samachar, Hindi Weekly Jhansi, Smt. A.D. Likhariya, Owner, Printer, Publisher, Bharat Apradh Samachar, Hindi Fortnightly, Jhansi and Shri Ramesh Chandra Likhariya, Owner, Printer, Publisher of Mahakaal Bharat Samachar, Hindi Weekly against The City Magistrate, Jhansi, U.P. and the Registrar of Newspaper for India, New Delhi.

209 12th March, 2001 Disposed of

86 Appeal of Shri Chandrakant Ashok Patil, Shri Samudragupta Ashok Patil & Miss Padma Balasaheb Patil, Owner, Printer, Publisher, Satyawadi, Sangli, Maharashtra vs. D.M. Sangli, Maharashtra.

210 12th March, 2001 The ADM, Sangli directed to inform DM, Sangli to appear before Board personally.

87 Appeal of Shri Kailash Dhondu Mali, Editor, Mosam Girana, Malegaon, District Nasik, Maharashtra.against The SDM, Malegaon, District Nasik, Maharashtra and The Registrar of Newspapers for India, New Delhi

212 12th March, 2001 Set aside impugned order of SDM dated 20/12/2000

88 Appeal of Shri Manshukhbhai G. Raval, Publisher, ‘Prakash’, Weekly, Amreli Gujarat against SDM, Amreli, Gujarat.

214 5th July, 2001 Order of SDM upheld. Appeal dismissed.

89 Contempt proceedings in the appeal of Shri Chandrakant Ashok Patil, Shri Samudragupta Ashok Patil and Miss Padma Balasaheb Patil, Printers, Owners and Publishers, ’Satyawadi Sangali’, Maharashtra against Shri Deelip Vidhyadhar Patil, Sangli and District Magistrate, Sangli, Maharashtra

216 1st August, 2001 Contempt proceedings dropped

90 Appeal of Smt. Kalpana Ratnakar Halwe, Editor, ’Apla Bhandara’, Weekly newspaper, Bhandara, Maharashtra.versus District Collector, Bhandara, Maharashtra.

218 1st August, 2001 Order dated 27/3/2001 set aside with directions to restore declaration within 7 days.

91 Appeal of Shri T.P. Nandakumar Chief Editor, Crime & Crime Star, Kozhikode and Shri Suresh Nambiar, Editor, Crime Star, Ernakulam against Shanavas, Editor/Printer/Publisher Periyar Group of Publications, Aluva East and ADM, Ernakulam, Kerala

219 18th February, 2002

Not a fit case for admission-dismissed.

92 Appeal of dated 13.3.2001 against the order dated 24.2.2001 of the Additional District

221 27th February, 2002

Dismissed being withdrawn

10

Magistrate, Bhopal and Shri Ramesh Chandra Pandey Editor/Publisher/Owner/Printer, Bhartiya Jan Vichar, Hindi Daily, Bhopal

93 Appeal of Shri Rameshwar Tripathi, Bhopal against 1. Additional District Magistrate Bhopal 2. Shri Ashok Kumar Jain, Editor, Nari Swar Darpan, Hindi Daily, Bhopal, (M.P.)

222 16th July, 2002 Dismissed being Withdrawn

94 Appeal of Shri P.V.Dakshinamurthy, General Secretary, Chennai Magana Karuneegar Sangam, Chennai against order-dated 22.5.2001 passed by the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai.

224 12th August, 2002

Dismissed as withdrawn

95 Appeal of Managing Director, Janmadhyama Prakashan Ltd. Printer, Publisher & Owner, Janavahini, Kannada daily Mangalaore against 1. Deputy Commissioner, Davangere; 2.Prof. H S Patel, Prabhudha Akhila Karnataka Janavahini, Kannada daily, Davangere; 3.Shri M Jaya Kumar, Printer/Publisher/Owner, Prabhudha Akhila Karnataka Janavahini, Kannada daily,

225 12th August, 2002 Dismissed

96 Appeal of Shri Manshukhbhai G.Raval, Publisher, ‘ Amreli Ni Arsi’ Weekly, Amreli Gujarat. against 1. SDM, Amreli Gujarat 2. Shri Gordhandas J. Sorathia Amreli 3. The Registrar of Newspaper for India, New Delhi

226 2nd September, 2002

Disposed of with modification to the order of SDM, Amreli.

97 Appeal of Shri Dharmender Singh Rathore, Chief Editor, “Rathore Bandhu”, Hindi Monthly Magazine, Jabalpur (M.P.) against order dated 11/10/02 passed by Sub Divisional Magistrate, Jabalpur, Madhya Pradesh.

228 23rd July, 2003 Set aside the impugned order dated 11/10/02

98 Appeal of Shri Mahesh Desai, Editor, “Bindu”, Gujarati Daily Ahmedabad against the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Ahmedabad.

229 6th Jan, 2004 Appellant directed to file a fresh declaration. Ad interim order dated 5.4.2002 to continue in meantime

99 Appeal of Shri Satish Kumar, Publisher, “Mazdoor Morcha”, (Daily) Faridabad against District Magistrate, Faridabad, Haryana.

231 6th Jan, 2004 Ad-interim order to continue

100 Appeal of Shri Jaspal Singh Heran, Chief Editor/Owner/Publisher, “Pehredar”, Punjabi Weekly, Jagroan District Ludhiana, Punjab against Additional District Magistrate, Ludhiana, Punjab.

234 6th / 7th Jan, 2004 Directions given to appellant

11

101 Appeal of Shri Chandra Mohan Sahu,

Publisher/Editor, “Shree India”, Hindi Daily, Banda,(U.P.) against City Magistrate, Banda (U.P.)

236 7th Jan, 2004 Disposed of with observations.

102 Appeal Shri Shushil Chowdhary M/S Pioneer Offset Printing Works, Agarta against (i) Publishers, Tripura Times; (ii) D.M. & Collector, Tripura West, Agartala; and (iii) RNI.

238 17th May, 2004 No cause of action as DM and Collector issued revised certificate to Tripura Times.

103 Appeal of Sh. Santosh Kumar Agarwal, Editor/Publisher, Dainik Bharti, Katni, M.P. against SDM, Katni, M.P.

241 17th May, 2004 Dismissed

104 Appeal of Sh. Ando Paul Puttur, Publisher, Puttanga Patrike, Mangalore against (i) District Magistrate/Dy. Commissioner, Dakshin Kannada, Manglore, Karnataka; and (iii) RNI, New Delhi.

242 17th May, 2004 Impugned order stayed and appeal is disposed of with observations.

105 Appeal of Sh. N.P. Shankarankutty, President, Akhila Kerela VishwakarmaMaha Shabha & Publisher, Karmayugam Malayalam Monthly Chengannor (Kerela) against (i) Sh. P.R.Devadas, Ayathil, P.O. Kollam; (ii) SDM, Mavelikara, Kerela; and (iii) RNI, New Delhi.

244 17th May, 2004 Disposed of

106 Appeal of Dr. Jitendra Singh, Publisher/Editor, Yogeshwar Manthan, Burhanpur, M.P. against (i) Sh. Ahkam Ansari, Chief Editor, Chautha Paigam; (ii) Sh. Vijay Kumar Singh Sindhe, Printer, Chautha Paigam ; (iii) Sh. P.Chand, Printer, Chautha Paigam; and (iv) SDM, Bhuranpur.

245 17th May, 2004 Dismissed

107 Appeal of Shri Mahesh Desai, Editor, Bindu, Ahmedabad against SDM, Ahmedabad.

248 30th April, 2004 Ad interim stay vacated Fresh declaration authenticated. No further orders necessary.

108 Appeal of Shri Satish Kumar, Publisher, “Mazdoor Morcha, Faridabad against (i) District Magistrate, Faridabad.

249 30th April, 2004 Ad interim stay vacated

109 Appeal Shri Birendra Prasad Tewari, Allahabad against (i) District Magistrate, Allahabad (2) Additional District Magistrate, (City), Allahabad and (iii) Shri P.K. Ghosh, Allahabad.

250 30th April, 2004 Dismissed for non-prosecution

110 Caveat under Section 8C of Press & Registration of Books Act 1867 by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Mandsore, (M.P.)

251 30th April, 2004 Closed

12

regarding cancellation of declaration of the “Dainik Rashtriya Ekta Sandesh” vide his order dated 21.7.2003.

111 Appeal of Shri Delip Vidhyadhar Patil of Sangli against (i) District Magistate, Kolhapur (ii) Shri Chandrakant Ashok Patil (iii) Shri Samudragupta Ashok Patil and (iv) Smt. Padma Basso Patil, Kolhapur, Maharashtra.

252 30th April 2004 Dismissed for non prosecution

112 Appeal of Shri M.D. Sheikh, Owner/Editor, Daily “Bandhu Prem” Solapur Maharashtra against (i) Additional District Magistrate, Solapur Maharashtra (ii) RNI, New Delhi and in the matter of Shri S.D.Shaikh, Editor, Weekly “Bandhu Prem”, Solapur against (i) Sub Divisional Magistrate, Solapur, Maharashtra (ii) RNI, New Delhi.

253 17th May, 2004 Direction to Magistrate, Solapur, Maharashtra

113 Appeal of Shri Arvind Chopra, Jallandhar; Shri Ashwini Chopra, New Delhi and Smt. Sudharshan Chopra, Jallandhar Vs. (1) SDM, Ludhiana; (2) RNI, New Delhi and (3) Shri Vijay Kumar Chopra, Jallandhar.

255 17th May, 2005 Remedy, if any, for the appellant may be elsewhere on preliminary object of respondent no. 3 on maintainability of appeal, the appeal is disposed of.

114 Appeal of Shri Jawahar Lal Kori, Editor, Damoh Ki Takat, Damoh, M.P. Vs. S.D.M. Damoh.

256 17th May, 2005 No interference called for in the order of SDM, Damoh. M.P.

115 Appeal of Shri Mahesh Prasad Sharma, Editor; Ab Hoga Insaf, Hindi Weekly, Lalitpur, U.P. against order dated 24.10.2003 of Sub-Divisional Magistrate Lalitpur, U.P.

257 17th May, 2005 Disposed of

116 Appeal of Shri I. Gopalsami @ Ayygo Kalunguvilia Post, Tamil Nadu Vs. the Revenue Divisional Officer, Thiruchandur, Orissa.

258 17th May, 2005 Adjourned to a future date with directions to RNI.

117 Appeal of Shri Mahendra Kumar Ahirwar, Owner/Publisher, Sachchai Ki Garjana, Chattarpur, M.P. against Collector/District Magistrate, Chattarpur, M.P.

259 17th May, 2005 Adjourned

118 Appeal of Shri Dharmendra Singh Rathore, Chief Editor, Rathore Bandhu, Jabalpur, M.P. against SDM, Jabalpur, Shri Omkar Prasad Rathore and RNI.

261 17th May, 2005 Adjourned

119 Appeal of Shri C.H. Ramana Reddy, Owner/Printer/Publisher/Editor, “Samagra


The appellant directed to filed fresh declaration

13

Vartha Vara Patrika, Vijyawada Vs. Sub-Collector and SDM, Vijaywada, Krishna Distt (A.P.)

with all the necessary particulars and the respondent SDM to pass appropriate orders for authentication of declaration.

120 Appeal of Ms. Shanta Dasgupta, Printer/Publisher, The Asian Age, Kolkatta V/S. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Kolkata.


Disposed of

121 Appeal of Shri Sudhir Kochardas Mehta, Editor, “Daily Lokyug”, Ahmednagar Vs. (i) Shri Popat Hastimal Lodha; and (ii) SDM, Ahmednagar, (iii) RNI


Adjourned

122 Appeal of Shri Raj Narayan Arya, Owner/Publisher, Socialist Reporter (Allahabad). V/S Additional District Magistrate (City Allahabad (U.P.)


Disposed of with directions to ADM (City) Allahabad.

123 Appeal of Shri P.G.Mahadevan, Chief Editor, Capital Times, Thiruvananthapuram against (i) ADM, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerela; and (ii) RNI, New Delhi.


ADM, Thiruvanandpuram’s order stayed

124 Appeal of Shri Krishan Chand Dubey, Owner of Hindi Daily “Phir Swaraj” Published from Rajgarh (M.P.) against (i) Orders passed by SDO, (Revenue) Rajgarh and (ii) Shri D.D.Mahant.


Appeal dismissed with the observations that status quo to be maintained till the matter gets settled in Civil Court.

125 Appeal of Shri Jagdish Prasad Jain, Chief Editor and (ii) Shri Pradeep Jain, Publisher, Jaiswal Jain Darpan, Agra against (i) Akhil Bharatvarshiya Shri Digamber Jain Dharamshala Mahaveerji and (ii) ADM (City), Agra.


Dismissed for non-prosecution

126 Appeal of Shri Rohtas Kumar Vicky, Editor/Printer/Owner/Publisher, Hamari Pahal, Hindi Weekly, Aligarh (U.P.) against The City Magistrate, U.P.



127 Appeal of Shri Amar Singh Johri, Journalist, Panipat against the Registrar of Newspapers for India.


Appeal does not lie before the Board and cannot be taken cognisance of.

128 Appeal of Shri Kishan Yashwantrao Jorvekar, Owner, DAILY GRAMASTHA. Jalgaon, Maharashtra against (i) D.M., Jalgaon, Maharashtra and (ii) Sh. Sunil Ratnakar Magar,


Dismissed

14

Editor/Owner/Publisher, SAPTAHIK PRATISAD, Weekly, Maharashtra and (iii) RNI.

129 Appeal of Shri Jawahar Lal Kori, Editor, “DAMOH KI TAKAT”, Damoh Versus the Sub Divisional Magistrate, District Tikamgarh, Madhya Pradesh.


SDM, Tikamgarh’s order dated 10.5.05 set aside

130 Appeal of Shri Mahendra Kumar Ahirwar, Owner/Publisher, “Sachchai Ki Garjana”, Hindi Weekly Published from Chattarpur (M.P.) against (i) the order dated 4.7.2003 of Collector/D.M, Chattarpur and (ii) the RNI.



131 Appeal of Shri Dharmendra Singh Rathore, Chief Editor, “Rathore Bandhu”, Jabalpur Vs. (i) SDM, Jabalpur (ii) Shri Omkar Prasad Rathore, Jabalpur and (iii) RNI



132 Appeal of Shri Ramesh Sharma, Editor, Anokhi Madhur Gathayen, Hindi Monthly Magazine, Delhi against (i) DCP (Licensing), New Delhi order dated 2.8.06 and (ii) RNI, New Delhi

306 4th January, 2007 Appeal dismissed

133 Appeal of Shri Ghanshyam Gupta, Editor, Nohar Times, Nohar, Zila Hanumangarh, Rajasthan Vs. SDM, Nohar order dated 27.11.2006, under section 8B of the Act.

307 4th January, 2007 Impugned order stayed

134 A communication received from Shri Milap Choraria, Delhi Vs. Registrar for Newspapers of India, Delhi for non-verification/ delay in verification of title.

308 4th January, 2007 Application under RTI Act Board cannot take cognisance as mater beyond its jurisdiction

135 Caveat filed by Shri Prakash Abajirao Deosarkar, (Ex-MLA), Maharashtra in A case of Editor ‘JAI RAJSINGHASAN’, Weekly newspaper, Umerkhed, Maharashtra.

309 4th January, 2007 Closed

136 Appeal of Shri Gowardhan Rameshwar Biyani, Printer & Publisher, Daily Prajawani Newspaper, Nanded and Shri Shantanu, Editor of Daily Prajawani Newspaper, Nanded against the District Magistrate/Collector Nanded, order dated 2.12.2006

310 4th January, 2007 Ad-interim order granting stay to appellant is confirmed and stay to continue to till further orders.

15

137 Appeal of Shri Subban Khan, Editor, “Vajravani”, Kannada Weekly, Davangere, Karnataka Vs. (i) the Deputy Commissioner, Davangere, Karnataka (ii) Shri S.S.Saleem, Advocate, Davangere, Karnataka and (iii) Registrar of Newspapers for India, New Delhi. Order dated 16.7.01

311 4th January, 2007 Set aside the impugned order of D.C. Davangere

138 Communication received from Shri Rajeev Makhija on behalf of Health is Wealth Media Pvt. Ltd. For ‘Muscle and Fitness” – Title registration, copyright issue and Trade Mark Violation Complaint.

313 September 7, 2007

Dropped

139 Appeal of Shri Hitender Prasad, Guruprasad, Kadabettu, Udupi, Karnataka agiant order dated 25.3.2004 of the Deputy Commissioner & District Magistrate, Udupi District, Karnataka.


Dropped

140 Appeal of Shri Govardhan Rameshwar Biyani, Printer & Publisher, Daily Prajawani News Paper, Nanded and Shri Shantanu, Editor of Daily Prajawani Newspaper, Nanded against the District Magistrate/Collector, Nanded order dated 2.12.2006.


Ad-interim order dated 5.12.2006 will remain operational until the Board considers the matter again thereafter.

141 Appeal of Shri Sayed Hasim Ali and Mrs. Jamal Afsan, Owners and Publisher, ‘Police ke Dwara” Hindi Magazine, New Delhi Vs. order dated 15.2.2007 passed by DCP (Licensing)


Adjourned with directions to file written submissions within two weeks.

142 Appeal of Shri Ghanshyam Gupta, Editor, Nohar Times, Hindi Weekly, Nohar, District Hanumangarh, Rajashthan Vs. SDM, Nohar District Hanumangarh, Rajasthan order dated 27.11.06


Adjourned

143 Appeal of Shri Ramesh Sharma, Editor and Printer, ‘Madhur Gathayien’, Hindi Monthly order dated 1.9.2006 and 12.9.2006 passed by Registrar of Newspapers and Deputy Commissioner of Police, (Licensing), New Delhi.


No reasons to interfere with the order appealed against and upholds it.

144 Appeal of Shri Sayed Hasim Ali and Mrs. Jamal Afsan, Owners and Publisher, ‘Police ke Dwara” Hindi Magazine, New Delhi Vs. order dated 15.2.2007 passed by DCP (Licensing)

324 October 9, 2007 Appeal allowed. Regarding, the exercise of DCP (licensing) authority, the Board has nothing to say.

145 Communication received from Keshav Dutt Chandola, Publisher, Rajput Maryada, Hindi Weekly, Kanpur against RNI.

325 12th March 2008 Does not fall with in the jurisdiction of the Board.

16

146 Communication received from the Editor, Chimurya Awaz, Chimur, District Chandrapur, Maharashtra in regard to Board’s decision dated March 27, 2006 on Chimurcha Awaz.

326 12th March 2008 No modification in Board’s order.

147 Appeal of Shri Kushalbhai Rambhai Verma, Owner and Publisher, Untold Truth Magazine, Ahemadabad against the order dated 7.7.2005 of the SDM, Ahmedabad.

327 12th March 2008 Directed to call original record from SDM and the appellant should also substantiate the grounds for delay in filing the appeal.

148 Appeal of Prof. Swatanter Kumar, Secretary, Sarvadeshik Arya Pratinidhi Sabha (Regd.) and Shri Vimal Wadhwan Arya, Printer and Publisher, Sarvadeshik Weekly, New Delhi Vs. The Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing), New Delhi order dated 15.1.2008.

329 12th March 2008 Adjourned.

149 Appeal of Shri Narender Jain, Editor, Morning and Evening, Hindi Dainik Samaigati, Indore, M.P. against the order dated 31.8.07 passed by Collector and District Magistrate, Indore, M.P.

331 12th March 2008 Adjourned.

150 Appeal of Shri Editor M/s Thenali Darbar, Tirunelveli District, Tamil Nadu against an order dated 4.7.2007 passed by the District Magistrate-cum-District Revenue officer, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu.

333 12th March 2008 Order set aside with direction for authentication of declaration.

151 Appeal of Shri Vilas Dattarao Chauhan, Chief Editor, Yavatmal Raajsinghasan, Marathi Weekly, Yavatmal, Maharashtra Vs. SDM, Pusad Dist. Yavatmal, Maharashtra Order dated 30.12.2006

334 12th March 2008 Adjourned

152 Appeal of Shri Vilas Dattarao Chauhan, Editor, Jai Rajsinghasan, Marathi Weekly, Yavatmal Maharashtra Vs. Order dated 23.9.2005 SDM, Pusad Dist. Yavatmal, Maharashtra

335 12th March 2008 Disposed of

153 Appeal of Shri Mukund Balveersingh Thakur, Editor, Shivani Samachar, Weekly, Jalgaon, Maharashtra Vs. Order dated 22.2.2007 passed by the sub-divisional Magistrate Jalgaon, Maharashtra - Order dated 22.2.2007

337 12th March 2008 Impugned order set aside.

154 Appeal of Shri Ghanshyam Gupta, Editor, Nohar Times, Hindi Weekly, Nohar, District Hanumangarh, Rajashthan Vs. SDM, Nohar District Hanumangarh, Rajasthan order dated 27.11.06

338 12th March 2008 Impugned order set aside.

155 Appeal of Acharya Madhuvratanada Avadhuta, Printer & Publisher, Prout, an English Fortnightly Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing), Delhi – order dated 6.2.2008.

339 April 23, 2008 Sub-judice, not admitted

17

156 Appeal of Shri Sudesh Kumar, Proprietor & Editor, Karavali Marutha, Kannada Weekly Vs. Deputy Commissioner, Mangalore, Karnataka order dated 27.11.2007

341 April 23, 2008 Ex-parte Stay order declined.

157 Appeal of Ms. Rupali Narasimhan, Owner / Printer & Publisher, Incredible India an English Monthly Magazine Vs. Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing) Delhi order dated 29.2.2008

343 April 23, 2008 Withdrawn

158 Appeal of Shri Sudesh Kumar, Proprietor & Editor, Karavali Marutha, Kannada weekly Vs. Deputy Commissioner, Mangalore, Karnataka – order dated 27.11.2007 under Section 8B of the Act.

345 26th May 2008 Set aside the impugned order.

159 Appeal of Shri C A Iqbal Ahmed, Vellore District, Tamil Nadu regarding the verification and registration of Tamil fortnightly ‘Agni Tharasu’.

346 4th December 2008

Directed RNI to consider revalidation of the title.

160 Appeal of Shri Vilas Chauhan, Editor, Yavatmal Rajsinghasan, Marathi Weekly, Yavatmal Maharashtra Vs. Order dated 30.12.2006 passed by SDM, Pusad Dist. Yavatmal, Maharashtra


Set aside the impugned order.

161 Appeal of Shri Shridhar Sakharam Balki, Editor, Lokshahi, Sarai Ward, Chandrapur, Maharashtra Vs. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jalgaon; (i) Sau Shanta Wani, District Jalgaon, Maharashtra and (ii) RNI, New Delhi.


Disposed of with directions to RNI.

162 Appeal of Shri Narendra Jain, Editor, Morning and Evening Hindi Dainik Samaigati, Indore, M.P. Vs. dated 31.8.2007 passed by the Collector/District Magistrate, Indore, Madhya Pradesh.


Adjourned – to enable the parties to mutually agree on a settlement.

163 Appeal of Shri Mohsin Rana, Editor and Printer, Kalyug Darpan Saharanpur, U.P. Vs. dated 5/10.3.08 passed by District Press Officer / Additional District Magistrate, (Admn.) Saharanpur, U.P.


Rejected.

164 Appeal of Printer, Publisher & Managing Editor, Hindi Daily News Activist, Lucknow against the Order dated 29.8.08 of City Magistrate, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh regarding rejection of authentication of the declaration of newspaper

354 March 16, 2009 Adjourned

18

165 Appeal of Shri Jawaharlal Chavan, Editor, Solapur Putra, Solapur, Maharashtra Vs. order dated 6.9.2007 of SDM, Solapur, Maharashtra.

355 March 16, 2009 Proceedings dropped

166 Appeal of Shri Akhil Singh, Editor, Sting Operation Vigilance, Hindi fortnightly, Bulandshahr, U.P. against (i) order dated 15.12.2008 passed by the Registrar of Newspapers for India, New Delhi and (ii) letter No. 78/ID/Title/208-09 dated June 6, 2008 of District Magistrate, Bulandshahr, U.P.

356 August 7, 2009 Admit the matter and directs to call original record.

167 Appeal of Shri Bipingiri K Goswami, Editor, Goswami Prakash and Shri Baldevgiri M. Goswami, Secretary, Shri Mahagujarat Dashnam Goswami Mahamandal, Gandhinagar, Gujarat vs. order dated 17.7.2008 passed by Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Gandhinagar, Gujarat.

357 August 7, 2009 Directed the appellant to file fresh declaration for authentication by SDM, Gandhinagar.

168 Appeal of Prof. Swatanter Kumar, Secretary, Sarvadeshik Arya Pratinidhi Sabha (Regd.) and Shri Vimal Wadhawan Arya, Printer and Publisher, Sarvadeshik Weekly, New Delhi The Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing), New Delhi order dated 15.1.2008 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing), New Delhi. And Appeal of Shri Prakash Arya, Secretary, Sarvadeshik Arya Pratinidhi Sabha (Regd.), New Delhi vs. The Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing), New Delhi order dated 15.1.2008 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Police (Licensing), New Delhi. .

359-358

August 7, 2009 Remanded back to the DCP(Licensing)

169 Appeal of Shri Narender Jain, Editor, Samaigati, Dainik, Indore, Madhya Pradesh vs. Collector and District Magistrate, Indore, Madhya Pradesh order dated 31.8.2007. passed by the Collector/District Magistrate, Indore, M.P.

360 August 7, 2009 Disposed of

19

170 Appeal of Owner, Publisher & Editor, Kanshi Kiran, Hindi Daily and Kanshi Kiran, Hindi Weekly, Varanasi against Additional District Magistrate (Protocol), Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh .

361 August 7, 2009 Adjourned

171 Appeal of Owner, Printer and Publisher ‘People’s March’, English Monthly, Ernakulam, Kerala vs. District Collector, Ernakulam, Kerala order dated 15.1.09.

363-362

August 7, 2009 Set aside the impugned order

172 Appeal of Printer, Publisher & Managing Editor, Daily News Activist, Lucknow against City Magistrate, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh regarding non authentication of declaration of the newspaper.

366-364

August 7, 2009 Set aside the impugned order

173 Appeal of Shri Bikash Swain, Owner/Publisher, Suryaprava, Oriya daily, Bhubaneshwar, Orissa against order dated 8.9.09 passed by District Magistrate, Khurda, Orissa regarding cancellation of declaration of newspaper.

367 January 18, 2010 Not to take cognizance

174 Appeal of Shri Prakash P Kukreja, Ulhasnagar, Maharashtra against Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Ulhasnagar regarding not cancelling the declaration of Mahraan, Sindhi

Weekly newspaper, Ulhasnagar, Maharashtra.

368 January 18, 2010 Beyond the scope of PRB Act

175 Review Application on order dated 7.8.09 of Press and Registration Appellate Board on appeal of Shri Bipingiri K Goswami, Editor, Goswami Prakash and Shri Baldevgiri M. Goswami, Secretary, Shri Mahagujarat Dashnam Goswami Mahamandal, Gandhinagar, Gujarat vs. order dated 17.7.2008 passed by Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Gandhinagar, Gujarat.

369 January 18, 2010 Admitted

176 Appeal of Shri T J Anil, Shimoga, Karnataka vs. order dated 19.11.09 passed by Deputy Commissioner and District Magistrate, Shimoga, Karnataka.

370-371

January 18, 2010 Allowed impleadment application

177 Appeal of Owner, Publisher & Editor, Kanshi Hindi Daily and Kanshi Kiran, Hindi Weekly, Varanasi against Additional District Magistrate (Protocol),Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh.

373-372

January 18, 2010 RNI directed to issue declaration

178 Appeal of Shri Akhil Singh, Editor, Sting Operation Vigilance, Hindi fortnightly, Bulandshahr, U.P. against (i) an order dated 15.12.2008 passed by the Registrar of

375-374

January 18, 2010 District Magistrate, Bulandshahr, U.P. directed to adopt proper procedure

20

Newspapers for India, New Delhi and a letter No. 78/ID/Title/208-09 dated June 6, 2008 of District Magistrate, Bulandshahr, U.P.

179 Appeal of Shri Sahebrao Budha Bagul (Babar), Editor, Crime Warta, Dhule, Maharashtra Vs. order dated 22.5.08 passed by Additional District Magistrate, Dhule, Maharashtra.

377 January 18, 2010 Appeal allowed and appellant to file fresh declaration

180 Appeal of Mrs. Latha Rangaswamy, owner/printer/publisher, Navika, Kannada daily against order dated 30.11.2009 passed by Deputy Commissioner & District Magistrate, Shimoga , Karnataka.

378 May 21, 2010 Settled as withdrawn

181 Appeal of Shri A Basha, Editor, Neethi Tharasu, Tamil fortnightly, Chennai against order dated 4.7.2008 passed by Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai.

379 May 21, 2010 Dismissed for non-prosecution

182 Appeal of S/Shri Sanjay Aggarwal & Ramesh Chand Tiwari against order dated 27.5.2009 passed by District Magistrate, Dehradun, Uttrakhand regarding cancellation of declaration of Dainik Bhaskar, Dehradun.

380 May 21, 2010 Appeal admitted

183 Review petition dated 10.3.10 filed by Registrar, Registrar of Newspapers of India against the order dated 18.1.2010 passed by Press and Registration Appellate Board on the appeal of Owner, Publisher & Editor, Kanshi Kiran, Hindi Daily and Weekly, Varanasi against Additional District Magistrate (Protocol), Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh.

381 May 21, 2010 Review petition Admitted

184 Appeal of Shri T J Anil, Shimoga, Karnataka vs. order dated 19.11.09 passed by Deputy Commissioner and District Magistrate, Shimoga, Karnataka.

382 May 21, 2010 Adjourned

185 Appeal of Shri Khusalbhai Rambai Verma, Owner and Publisher, Untold Truth Magazine, Ahmedabad against order dated 7.7.2005 passed by Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Ahmedabad.

383 May 21, 2010 RNI directed to renew the title and appellant to file fresh declaration

186 Appeal of Appeal of Shri V Thambumalla, Editor, Idimurasu, Tamil Monthly against order dated 13.7.09 passed by District Revenue Officer, Villlupuram, Tamil Nadu.

384 May 21, 2010 Not interfered the impugned order and the appellant may file fresh declaration

21



Adjourned



Directed to issue fresh notices to all parties

189 Appeal of Shri T J Anil, Shimoga, Karnataka vs. order dated 19.11.09 passed by Commissioner and District Magistrate, Shimoga, Karnataka.


Dismissed

190 Appeal of Shri Jaipal Singh, Editor, Hindustan Bol Raha Hai, Hindi Monthly, Dehradun, Uttarakhand against order dated 13.4.10 passed by Press Registrar/City Magistrate, Dehradun, Uttrakhand regarding cancellation of declaration.

391-390

September 14, 2010

Respondent directed to conduct fresh inquiry

191 Appeal of Shri Akhil Singh, Editor, Sting Operation Vigilance, Hindi fortnightly, Bulandshahr, U.P. against (i) an order dated 15.12.2008 passed by the Registrar of Newspapers for India, New Delhi and a letter No. 78/ID/Title/208-09 dated June 6, 2008 of District Magistrate, Bulandshahr, U.P.

393-92 December 20, 2010

Respondent directed to pass reasoned speaking order

192 Appeal of Mrs. Latha Rangaswamy, owner/printer/publisher, Navika, Kannada daily against order dated 14.12.09 passed by Deputy Commissioner & District Magistrate, Shimoga, Karnataka.

394 December 20, 2010

Closed as withdrawn

193 Appeal of Shri Mansukhbhai Gangashanker Raval, District Amreli, Gujarat vs. order dated 2.11.10 passed by Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Amreli, Gujarat

395 August 23, 2011 Appeal not admitted

22

194 Appeal of Ms. Geeta Handa, Karol Bagh, Delhi vs. Order dated 22.3.2011 passed by Registrar of Newspapers for India, New Delhi

396 August 23, 2011 Outside the jurisdiction of the Board


397-98 August 23, 2011 Adjourned



197 Appeal of Shri Bikash Swain, Owner/Publisher, Suryaprava, Oriya daily, Bhubaneshwar, Orissa against order dated 8.9.09 passed by District Magistrate, Khurda, Orissa regarding cancellation of declaration of newspaper.

403-400

August 23, 2011 Set-aside

198 Appeal of Shri Bharat PralhadraoThroat,

Editor/Publisher, Vrutt Kesari, Marathi Weekly against the Order dated 3.9.2011 passed by Sub-Divisional Officer, Achalpur Amravati, Maharashtra

403-404 January 9, 2012 Stay rejected

198 Appeal of Owner, Publisher & Editor, Kanshi Kiran, Hindi daily and weekly for non-authentication of declaration by the Additional District Magistrate (Protocol), Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh-Reopened the review Petition dated 10.3.2010 of Registrar, Registrar Of Newspapers and allowed by the Apellate Board on 14.9.2010.

405 January 9, 2012 Adjourned

199 Appeal of Shri Sanjay Agarwal & Anr., against the Order dated 27.5.2009 passed by District Magistrate, Dehradun,Uttrakhand regarding cancellation of declaration of Dainik Bhaskar, Dehradun.


23

200 Appeal of Shri M K Siddiqui, Editor/Owner, The Man in the Opposition, (Hindi Weekly) Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh against the order dated 7.7.2011 of the Additional District Magistrate (L&A), Ghaziabad.

408-407 January 9, 2012 Stay granted

201 Appeal of Shri Vishnu Goyal, Editor & Publisher, National Herald, English daily, Indore against the Order dated 29.9.10 passed by the Additional District Magistrate, Indore and Associated Journal, Ltd.

409 January 9, 2012 Stay shall remain

202 Review Application of President/Secretary Maharashtra Gujarat Dashnam Goswami Mahamandal, Gujarat with reference to Order dated 7.8.09 of Press and Registration Appellate Board on appeal of Shri Bipingiri K Goswami, Editor, Goswami Prakash and Shri Baldevgiri M Goswami, Secretary, Shri Mahagujarat Dashnam Goswami Mahamandal Gandhinagar, Gujarat vs. order dated 17.7.2008 passed by Sub-Divisional, Gandhinagar, Gujarat-Intervention application of Shri Baldevgiri M Goswami.

411-410 March 15, 2012 Review application rejected

203 Appeal of Shri Rambhai A Prajapati of Prajapati Manch, Gujarati Fortnightly, Gandhinagar against the order dated 28.2.2008 passed by SDM, Gandhinagar


204 Appeal of Shri Bharat Pralhadrao Throat, Editor/Publisher, Vrutt Kesari, Marathi Weekly against the Order dated 3.9.2011 passed by Sub-Divisional Officer, Achalpur Amravati, Maharashtra

413-414 March 15, 2012 Adjourned

205. Appeal of Shri C A Iqbal Ahmed, Vellore District, Tamil Nadu against The order dated 29.10.2010 of Additional District Magistrate cum District Revenue Officer, Velore.


206 Appeal of Shri Manash Debnath, Publisher, Dainik Arohan, Bengali daily, East Agartala, West Tripura against the o dated 29.11.2010 passed by DM/Collector, West Tripura.


207 Appeal of Shri Vishnu Goyal, Editor & Publisher, National Herald, English daily, Indore against the Order dated 29.9.10 passed


24

by the Additional District Magistrate, Indore and Associated Journal, Ltd.



25

Press and Registration Appellate Board

S.NO

SUBJECT Page No.

DATE OF ORDER

DECISION OF THE BOARD

209 Stay application of Shri J Johnson, Editor & Publisher, Nellai Kathiravan, Tamil daily Against the order dated 17.7.2012 passed by Sub-Divisional Magistrate and District Revenue Officer, Thirunelvely, Tamil Nadu

421 November 30, 2012

Adjourned


422 November 30, 2012

Adjourned


423 November 30, 2012

Adjourned

212 Appeal of Shri Manash Debnath, Publisher, Dainik Arohan, Bengali daily, East Agartala, West Tripura against the o dated 29.11.2010 passed by DM/Collector, West Tripura.

424 November 30, 2012

Dismissed

213 Appeal of Shri Bharat Pralhadrao Throat, Editor/Publisher, Vrutt Kesari, Marathi Weekly against the Order dated 3.9.2011 passed by Sub-Divisional Officer, Achalpur Amravati, Maharashtra

425 November 30, 2012

Dismissed

214 Appeal of Shri Rambhai A Prajapati of Prajapati Manch, Gujarati Fortnightly, Gandhinagar against the order dated 28.2.2008 passed by SDM, Gandhinagar.

426 November 30, 2012

Dismissed

215 Appeal of S/Shri Subhash Chandra and Prakash Chandra, Pune against District Magistrate-cum- Jt. Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad regarding not providing order/complaint number of their complaint on 17.5.2012 for cancellation of declaration of Poddu, Telugu daily newspaper.

427 November 30, 2012

Disposed of

26

216 Appeal of Shri J N Shukla, Printer & Publisher, Nishpaksh Pratidin, Hindi daily, Lucknow

against order dated 6.2.2012 passed by D.M., Lucknow.

428 November 30, 2012

Allowed to rest

217 Appeal of Shri N M Nhavi, district Dhulia, Maharashtra against order dated 11.1.2012 passed by ADM, Dhulia, Maharashtra.

429 November 30, 2012

No action is warranted

218 Appeal of Shri V Arvind, Publisher, Ayutha Eluthu, Tamil Monthly Magazine, Vellore vs. order dated 3.11.207 passed by ADM & DRO, Vellore Chennai.

430 November 30, 2012

Disposed of

219 Appeal of Shri D Thomas Raj, Vellore vs. order dated 26.3.2007 pased by ADM & DRO, Vellore, Chennai.

431 November 30, 2012

Disposed of

220 Status report on determination of ownership of Odia daily newspaper, Suryaprava.

432 November 30, 2012

Directed to expedite the Determination of ownership

221 Appeal of Shri Lokendra Jain, Printer and Publisher, Bandhiya Samachar, Bhopal, M.P. Vs. order dated 20.7.2012 passed by Ld. SDM, Tehsil-Huzur, District Rewa, M.P. and others


222 Appeal of Owner, Publisher & Editor, Kanshi Kiran, Hindi daily and weekly for non-authentication of declaration by the Additional District Magistrate (Protocol), Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh-Reopened the review Petition dated 10.3.2010 of Registrar, Registrar of Newspapers and allowed by the Apellate Board on 14.9.2010- Review application filled by RNI

434 January 9, 2013 The Board directed ADM, Varanasi to take necessary action expeditiously in accordance with law.

223 Appeal of Shri M K Siddiqui, Editor/Owner, The Man in the Opposition, (Hindi Weekly) Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh against the order dated 7.7.2011 of the Additional District Magistrate (L&A), Ghaziabad.

435 January 9, 2013 Disposed of

27

224 Appeal of Shri C A Iqbal Ahmed, Vellore District, Tamil Nadu vs. order dated 29.10.2010 of ADM-cum- DRO, Vellore.


225 Stay application of Shri J Johnson, Editor & Publisher, Nellai Kathiravan, Tamil daily Against the order dated 17.7.2012 passed by Sub-Divisional Magistrate and District Revenue Officer, Thirunelvely, Tamil Nadu.

437 January 9, 2013 Referred to Tamil Nadu Mediation and Conciliation Centre, Chenai




439 January 9, 2013 Adjourned with the Directions to list the Matter after the decision of the Civil Court

228 Appeal of Shri C A Iqbal Ahmed, Vellore District, Tamil Nadu vs. order dated 29.10.2010 of ADM-cum- DRO, Vellore.


229 Appeal of Shri Balaji, Publisher, Muketshwar Samachar, Marathi daily, Latur,Maharashtra Vs. order dated 22.1.2012 pased by SDM, Latur.




231 Appeal of Shri Lokendra Jain, Printer and Publisher, Bandhiya Samachar, Bhopal, M.P. Vs. order dated 20.7.2012 passed by Ld. SDM, Tehsil-Huzur, District Rewa, M.P. and others


232 Restoration application dated 26.12.2012 of Shri Bharat Pralhadrao Thorat, Editor & Publisher, Vrut Kesari, Marathi weekly on Board’s order dated 30.11.2012.


28

233 Restoration application dated 12.2.2013 of Shri Manash Debnath, Publisher, Dainik Arohan, Bengali daily, East Agartala On Board’s order dated 30.11.2012.


SUBJECT Page DATE OF DECISION OF THE BOARD O...

Documents

Transcript of SUBJECT Page DATE OF DECISION OF THE BOARD O...