Study of Fumihiko Maki and Group Form

7/24/2019 Study of Fumihiko Maki and Group Form

1/14

AR2226 HISTORY AND THEORY OF MODERN ARCHITECTURE

REPUBLIC POLYTECHNIC AND FUMIHIKO MAKI:

THE COLLISON OF GROUP FORM AND TOP DOWN APPROACH IN SINGAPORE

Tutorial Grou !

Lee Jin Ting A0126360

Lect!e!" T#t$ S%&%'$t$

Te%c(ing A##i#t%nt" C(eng )*+i L,nn

30 Oct$-e! 201.


2/14

"# I$tro%u&tio$

In t(e !e%/' $ '$e!n %!c(itect!e F'i(i&$ M%&i -$!n Se4te'-e! 6 152 in T$&,$7 i#

$ne $ t(e %!c(itect# 8($ int!$ce Met%-$/i#' % 8($/e ne8 ie% in !-%ni#' %n %!c(itect!e t$

t(e 8$!/ in 1560#9 O!igin%ting !$' J%4%n t(e ie$/$g, 8%# intene t$ /e% J%4%ne#e #$ciet, int$ %ne8 $!e! %# % !e#4$n t$ ,n%'ic !-%ni:%ti$n %n t!%n#$!'%ti$n $ J%4%ne#e citie# %te! Sec$n

W$!/ W%! Lin 2010 179 In 1563 M%&i int!$ce ;g!$4 $!'< %# (i# %44!$%c( in Met%-$/i#' in

(i# -$$&Investigation of Collective Forms9 In 2002 $!t, ,e%!# %te! Met%-$/i#' 8%# int!$ce

M%&i i'4/e'ente t(e ie% $ g!$4 $!' in Sing%4$!e t(!$g( '%#te! 4/%nning $ Re4-/ic

P$/,tec(nic9 F!$' J%4%n t$ Sing%4$!e %c!$## $! ec%e# it i# 'e%ning/ t$ in=e#tig%te ($8 M%&i>#

ie$/$g, i# -eing %$4te in ie!ent !egi$n %n e!%9 M$#t i'4$!t%nt/, i# t(e ie% $ G!$4 F$!'

eecti=e/, t!%n#/%te in Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic t$ 4e!$!' 8(%t t(e ie$/$g, i# t!,ing t$ %c(ie=e9

T(e e##%, e?%'ine# Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic t(!$g( 2 i'4$!t%nt %#4ect# in M%&i># T(e$!, $

C$//ecti=e F$!'" S$ci%/ eng%ge'ent in e#ign %n ##t%in%-i/it, in %%4ting t!e c(%nge#9In $!e!

t$ te#t $n t(e %!g'ent %n t$ '%int%in t(e e4t( $ i#c##i$n %n$t(e! M%&i># 4!$@ect S(in@&

St%ti$n P!$@ect n!e%/i:e7 (%# -een #tie in c$'4%!i#$n 8it( Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic9 T(e !e%#$n $

c($$#ing S(in@& St%ti$n P/%n i# t(%t t(e t8$ 4!$@ect# #(%!e t(e #%'e $!' %n (%=e t(e #%'e

t,4$/$g, %# % '%#te! 4/%nning 4!$@ect9 A4%!t !$' t(%t it i# %/#$ % c$'4%!i#$n -et8een t(e ie%/

$tc$'e %n t(e !e%/it, in c$nte?t9 A// $ t(e !e#e%!c(e# %-$=e (%# /e t$ t(e -$!n $ '%in %!g'entB

M%&i># ie$/$g, $ Met%-$/i#' i n$t //, t!%n#/%te int$ Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic c$'4%!e t$

S(in@& St%ti$n De=e/$4'ent in J%4%n e t$ t(e /%c& $ #$ci%/ eng%ge'ent %n c$n#ie!%ti$n in

e#ign 4!$ce##9 G!$4 F$!' i# % ;-$tt$'*4< %44!$%c( 8(ic( ;e'%n%te# !$' t(e 4e$4/e t(e'#e/=e# $

4e$4/e 8($ eng%ge in !et%i/ing 8($/e#%/ing 8in$8 #($44ing !in&ing e%ting c(%tting %n

4%##ing< M%&i 156 .79 T(e $ice t$8e! i# e#igne 8it( t(e c$n#ie!%ti$n $ =i#t% %n

e=e/$4'ent $ inte!e#ting =i#t% !$' t(e -i/ing 8in$8 8(ic( #t!e##e ('%n># %##$ci%ti$n

Fig!e 10 1179 M%&i !ee!!e t(i# %# %n %tte'4t t$ ;c!e%te %n i'%ge t(!$g( g!$4ing $ e/e'ent#

t(%t i# !e/ecti$n $ g!$8t( %n ec%, in $! /ie 4!$ce## % 'et%-$/ic 4!$ce##


9/14

A!c(i=e $ Ainitie# (tt4"%!c(i=e$%initie#9t'-/!9c$'4$#t1.12052'i(i&$*'%&i*4!$@ect*

$!*#(in@&*4/%n*$!*t(e%cce##e 2 Oct$-e! 201.7

# R'u(li& Pol0t'&,$i& a$% S,i$8u-u Statio$ Pro8'&t 9

Su)tai$a(ilit0 i$ A%ati$5 Futur' C,a$5')
http://archiveofaffinities.tumblr.com/post/14581209288/fumihiko-maki-project-for-shinjuku-plan-for-thehttp://archiveofaffinities.tumblr.com/post/14581209288/fumihiko-maki-project-for-shinjuku-plan-for-thehttp://archiveofaffinities.tumblr.com/post/14581209288/fumihiko-maki-project-for-shinjuku-plan-for-thehttp://archiveofaffinities.tumblr.com/post/14581209288/fumihiko-maki-project-for-shinjuku-plan-for-thehttp://archiveofaffinities.tumblr.com/post/14581209288/fumihiko-maki-project-for-shinjuku-plan-for-the


10/14

M%&i># g!$4 $!' i# % 4/%nning #t!%teg, 8(ic( $e!# % '%#te! &e, $! % =i#%/ g!%''%!

;t(!$g( 8(ic( $ne c%n c$4e 8it( %n e?4%ne #c%/e $ $4e!%ti$n# %n !%4i t!%n#$!'%ti$n< Lin

2010 11379 M%&i %=$c%te t(%t g!$4 $!' enc$!%ge# c'/%ti=e g!$8t( t(%t !e#/t# in in % n$n*

(ie!%!c(ic%/ c$//ecti=e $!' 8(ic( i# in c$nt!%#t t$ t$4*$8n 4/%nning9 Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic i n$t

8$!& %# % /e?i-/e e#ign t(%t i# %-/e t$ %%4t t!e t!%n#$!'%ti$n9 T(i# i# e t$ t(e !e#t!icti$n $

'%#te! 4/%nning 8(ic( '%! c/e%! -$n%!, 8it($t g!e, %!e% $! !t(e! g!$8t( 4$##i-i/it,9 At

Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic 11 ini=i%/ /e%!ning 4$# 8(ic( ($#e c/%##!$$'# /ect!e t(e%t!e# %n

$ice# %!e %!!%nge in g!$4 $!' '%nne! $n t$4 $ 2*#t$!e, Ag$!% #4%ce Fig!e 1279 T(e /%,$t c%n

-e !ec$nig!e t$ %%4t /e?i-/, t$ c(%nge in e4%!t'ent%/ $!g%ni:%ti$n i 2013 5379 H$8e=e! it i#

$-#e!=e t(%t in#te% $ #(iting in

e4%!t'ent%/ $!g%ni:%ti$n ec%ti$n%/

in#titti$n# in Sing%4$!e gene!%//, (%=e

g!e%te! nee in e?4%ning t(ei! c%'4# t$

%cc$''$%te '$!e #tent# %n ne8 c$!#e#

in t!e9 A# !e4$!te -, Sing%4$!e St%ti#tic#

t(e 4$4/%ti$n $ Sing%4$!e -, Jne 201 i#

.9 'i//i$n %n it i# e?4ecte t$ (it 69.*695

'i//i$n in 20309 A# t(e 4$4/%ti$n 8i// -e

inc!e%#ing 1*19. 'i//i$n in t!e 16 ,e%!# it

i# /$gic%/ t$ #%, t(%t t(e!e 8i// -e %n inc!e%#e in n'-e! $ #tent $! %// in#titti$n# in Sing%4$!e

inc/ing Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic9 M$!e$=e! %# % 4$/,tec(nic 8(ic( e'4(%#i:e# $n 4!e4%!ing #tent#

t$ 8$!& in in#t!, it i# i'4$!t%nt $! t(e #c($$/ t$ int!$ce c$!#e# t(%t i# 4 t$ t(e e=e/$4'ent $

tec(n$/$g,9 It c%n -e $!e#een t(%t t(e #c($$/ (%# t(e nee t$ int!$ce ne8 c$!#e# %n %c/t, in t(e

t!e9 A# e=ience Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic (%# $e!e t$t%/ ne8 i4/$'%# in 201 %n 201.9

Un$!tn%te/, t(e e#ign $ Ag$!% %n t(e L%8n %# %n e//i4tic%/ 4/%te c$nt%ining t(e 11 -/$c gi=e#

n$ $44$!tnit, $! t(e #c($$/ t$ % in ne8 -/$c in t(e #%'e 8%, %# $t(e! /e%!ning 4$#9 Ne8

#t!ct!e# c%n #ti// -e %e %t t(e #ec$n !ing $ c%'4# t$get(e! 8it( t(e #%te//ite# -i/ing# -t

t(e t$t%/ i'%ge $ ;%g$!% c$nt%ining te%c(ing -/$c< 8i// -e %/te!e in t(i# c%#e9 T(i# i# c$nt!%icti=et$ M%&i># c$nce4t $ g!$4 $!' 8(ic( 8i// ;c!e%te % /e?i-/e !-%n #,#te' '$!e !e#4$n#i=e t$ t(e

/ct%ting c$niti$n $ c$nte'4$!%!, #$ciet,< %n !e'%in ;##t%in%-/e %# %n $4en*ene 4!$ce##


11/14

On t(e $t(e! (%n S(in@& St%ti$n P!$@ect 4$#e# % -igge! /e?i-i/it, %n $44$!tnit, t$

e'-!%ce c(%nge# Fig!e 179 S($44ing %'#e'ent %n $ice -/$c in t(e 4/%nning %!e

e?4%n%-/e9 M%&i c%//e t(e $=e!%// $!' ;'%#te! $!'


12/14

Fig9 19M%#%t$ Ot%&% %n F'i(i&$ M%&i S(in@& St%ti$n P!$@ect 15609 M%#te! 4/%n9 F!$' Lin

($ng@ie9Kenzo Tange and the Metabolist Movement Urban Utopias of Modern !apan9 Ne8 )$!&"

R$t/ege 20109 P%ge 329

!# I%'a ;)# R'alit0 1 Di)arit0 i$ ('t3''$ i%'olo50 a$% r'al li# e=e!,%, /ie in t(e

4!$g!e## $ t$4 $8n %44!$%c( t(e %!c(itect!e /$#e# it# 4e!$!'%nce %n e/ect# !$' M%&i>#

c$nce4t9 In Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic t(e /%8n %!e% $n t(e !$$ $ Ag$!% #e!=e# %# % /in&%ge in -et8een

11 /e%!ning 4$# %n ni,ing e/e'ent $! t(e ie!ent -/$c It i# % (ge $4en t$ #&, /%8n 8it(

c$=e!e c$!!i$!# c$nnecting t(e 11 -/$c Fig!e 1.79 H$8e=e! it i# $-#e!=e t(%t L%8n %!e% i#

#e/$' #e -, t(e #e!# e it# e?4$#!e t$ Sing%4$!e># ($t 8e%t(e!9 Pe$4/e in Sing%4$!e 8$/

4!ee! #(e/te!e #4%ce# 8(ic( 4!$=ie 4!$tecti$n !$' 8e%t(e! !%t(e! t(%n $4en #4%ce#9 A/t($g(

c$=e!e c$!!i$!# %!e 4!$=ie it i# #ti// ne!#e -ec%#e it i# $n/, c$nnecting t$ %@%cent -i/ing#9

U#e!# 8$/ 4!ee! t$ '$=e !$' -/$c& t$ -/$c& -, #ing Ag$!%9 It i# ne!#t%n%-/e t(%t L%8n %!e%i# #44$#e t$ -e $4en e t$ #t!ct!%/ !e%#$n %n %!c(itect># c$nce4t ($8e=e! it (%# -!$g(t $8n

t(e 4e!$!'%nce $ L%8n %!e% %# % /in&%ge in !e%/9 It c%n -e %!ge t(%t t(e L%8n %!e% i# #44$#e t$

-e % c$nce4t%/ e/e'ent 8(ic( /in& ini=i%/ e/e'ent# t$ -e % 8($/e %n $ n$t 'e%n $! /in&%ge in

te!'# $ ('%n ci!c/%ti$n9 H$8e=e! it i# '$!e 'e%ning/ $! %n e/e'ent t$ #e!=e it# c$nce4t%/

ncti$n %n 4!%ctic%/ ncti$n %# 8e//9


13/14

Fig9 1.9 P%n$!%'% $ L%8n %!e%9 P($t$g!%4(9 F!$'" Lee Jin Ting 201.9

=# Co$&lu)io$

F'i(i&$ M%&i># ie$/$g, $ g!$4 $!' in !-%n 4/%nning i# #gge#ting % c$nce4t $ ;$4en

!egi$n%/i#'# /i=ing %/it, %# 8e// %# c!e%ting #4%ce# 8it( #t!$ng #en#e $ 4/%cene##

8(ic( ie!ent g!$4 $ 4e$4/e c%n -e eng%ge9 In t(e c%#e $ Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic M%&i># c$nce4t

in -$tt$' 4 '%nne! i# '$!e %44!$4!i%te %n !e/e=%nt9 A# %n ec%ti$n%/ in#titti$n 8(ic( %i'e t$

in#4i!e %n 4!$=$&e #tent#> t($g(t t(e #c($$/ #($/ %%4t % -$tt$' 4 %44!$%c( t$ 4!$=ie

$44$!tnit, $! #tent# t$ e?4!e## t(e'#e/=e# in#te% $ e?ecting #t!$ng -!e%c!%c,9 , #t,ing

t(e c$//i#i$n -et8een M%&i># c$nce4t %n Sing%4$!e># c$nte?t t(e e##%, (%# t!ie t$ te#t $n t(e

4$##i-i/it, $ #ing M%&i># c$nce4t in t!e># Sing%4$!e %n t(e 4$##i-/e c(%nge# t$ '%&e 8(i/e

itting int$ t(e c$nte?t9 A# % c$nc/#i$n t(e c$//i#i$n -et8een M%&i># -$tt$' 4 %44!$%c( %n

Sing%4$!e># t$4 $8n e=e/$4'ent '$e (%# c%#e t(e inc$'4/etene## in 4e!$!'ing t(e cent!%/

ie% $ g!$4 $!'9 I M%&i># ie% $ Met%-$/i#' i# t$ -e #e in Sing%4$!e it nee# !t(e!

'$iic%ti$n 8(ic( c%n -e e!i=e !$' /$c%/ #$ci%/ n$!' #$ciet,># nee %n n%ti$n%/ g!$8t( %t t(e

'e%n8(i/e c$'4%ti-/e t$ Sing%4$!e># n%ti$n -i/ing 4$/ic,9

Bi(lo5ra,0

De4%!t'ent O St%ti#tic# Sing%4$!e9 L%te#t e, Inic%t$!#9 L%#t '$iie 25 Oct 201.9

(tt4"8889#ing#t%t9g$=9#g($'e9
http://www.singstat.gov.sg/homehttp://www.singstat.gov.sg/homehttp://www.singstat.gov.sg/home


14/14

DP A!c(itect#9 Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic * DP A!c(itect#9 Acce##e Oct$-e! 25 201.9

(tt4"88894%9c$'9#g4!$@ect#!e4-/ic*4$/,tec(nic9

Lee Jin Ting9 Lie %# % Stent in Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic9 Inte!=ie8 -, %t($!9 Se4te'-e! 20 201.9

Lin ($ng@ie9Kenzo Tange and the Metabolist Movement Urban Utopias of Modern !apan9 Ne8

)$!&" R$t/ege 20109

M%&i F'i(i&$9Investigations in Collective Form9 St9 L$i#" Sc($$/ $ A!c(itect!e W%#(ingt$n

Uni=e!#it, 1569

M%&i %n A##$ci%te#9 Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic9 Acce##e Oct$-e! 25 201.9 (tt4"8889'%&i*%n*

%##$ci%te#9c$9@4et%i/#ine?9(t'/4c69

N%ti$n%/ P$4/%ti$n %n T%/ent Di=i#i$n9F!eent/, A#&e +e#ti$n# $n t(e P$4/%ti$n W(ite

P%4e!9 Acce##e Oct$-e! 25 201.9 (tt4"4$4/%ti$n9#g8(ite4%4e!%#g!$8*4$4/%ti$n

P$/ic, I'4/e'ent%ti$n in Sing%4$!e9 "ingapore Politics #log9 J%n%!, 13 20069

(tt4"#ing%4$!eg$=t9-/$g#4$t9#g2006014$/ic,*i'4/e'ent%ti$n*in*#ing%4$!e9(t'/

Re4-/ic P$/,tec(nic9 P!$#4ect# 201.9 Acce##e Oct$-e! 25 201.9

(tt4"8889!49e9#g4/$%eFi/e#P%ge#17Sc($$/PROSPECTIEQSTUDENTSP!$#4ect# 201.

FINAL /$8!e#Q15912949

S-!%'%ni%' S!%in9 T(e D%/ N%!!%ti=e $ ;G$$ G$=e!n%nce

Study of Fumihiko Maki and Group Form

Documents

Transcript of Study of Fumihiko Maki and Group Form