Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

38

Transcript of Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Page 1: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations
Page 2: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

REINVENTING THE 401(K) TO MAXIMIZE EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT

Page 3: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Alvin Rappwww.RPGconsultants.com

Burke Pembertonwww.stok.com@teamstok

Jennifer Andersonwww.sustrana.com@sustranaTalks

R. Paul Hermanwww.HIPinvestor.com@HIPinvestor

Page 4: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

AGENDA401(k) as lever for engagementWhy reinvent your 401(k)?How do you reinvent your 401(k)?What results are possible?Q&A

Page 5: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

• Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/samanthasharf/2014/07/30/the-recession-generation-how-millennials-are-changing-money-management-forever/

Fry, R. (2015, May 11). Millennials surpass Gen Xers as the largest generation in U.S. labor force.

Millennials in USA Workforce

Page 6: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

MILLENNIALS #1 PURPOSE OF BUSINESS IS BUILDING A BETTER WORLD

5

• 80 million Millennials in USA• Inheriting $40 Trillion from Boomers

Source: Deloitte global survey of Millennials

Page 7: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

6https://ngam.natixis.com/us/resources/2016-survey-of-defined-contribution-plan-participants

Page 8: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

401(K)FIDUCIARYDUTY NOWINCLUDESNET IMPACT ON SOCIETY

Page 9: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

8

HIGHER IMPACT = HIGHER POTENTIAL RETURNS

CONFIDENTIAL © 2006-2017 HIP Investor Inc.

Page 10: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

MANY SRI FUNDS RATE HIGHER ON RETURN

http://my.morningstar.com/ods_images/161207_sustainability-02(en).png

Page 11: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

© 2006-2017 HIP Investor Inc. 10* Past 5 years, as of 7/31/2015 HIP Scores (2013/14)

ALL 401(K)FUNDSCAN BERATEDFORIMPACT

Page 12: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations
Page 13: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Why reinvent your 401(k)?

Page 14: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Kristen MagnusonLEED & WELL APMaterials Expert401k Crusader

Page 15: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Walking the Talk

Stronger, more resilientorganizations.

Page 16: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Why would a company create a 401(k) with mutual fund, insurance company or payroll platform that:• Doesn’t allow freedom in investment choices?• Doesn’t have fee transparency?• Doesn’t offer ESG investments that align with values?

Conflict & NeedEDITED: trying yellow color for readability,

Page 17: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

How do you reinvent your 401(k)?

Page 18: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

1 Impact of current plan?

ERISA FiduciaryChampions & InfluencersStakeholder EngagementESG Impact Assessment → HIP Investor

Page 19: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Financial advisorRecord KeeperThird Party AdministratorAcquire Fidelity Bonding

2 Make Changes

Page 20: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Cloud-based Advising & Record KeepingPush Button Fossil Free PortfoliosPayroll Integration & Automation

3 Make More Changes

Page 21: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

401(K) PORTAL, WITH PERSONAL IMPACT METRICS

20

Page 22: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Re-assess Impact & Participation AnnuallyReport results to relevant stakeholdersRefine plan offering

4 Reassess, Report, & Refine

Page 23: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

1 Select the Provider

B Corps first Identify criteriaEvaluate options

Page 24: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Started with all “sustainable choices”Internal dialogue Combined list of 23 funds

2 Select the Funds

Page 25: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

SUSTRANA’S 401(K)

Vanguard LT Gov’t

Vanguard Int. Term Gov’t

Vanguard Short Gov’t

Vanguard IT ETF

T. Rowe Price Health Sciences

Vanguard Total Stock Mkt Idx.

Vanguard Global Equity Inv.

Vanguard Federal Money Market

Calvert US Large Cap Core Index

Parnassus Endeavor

Shelton Green Alpha

Virtus Small

Pax Small

Portfolio 21

Calvert Green Bond

Calvert Global Water

Green Century Balanced

HIP FFF All Equity

HIP FFF Growth

HIP FFF Balanced

HIP FFF Balanced Income

HIP FFF Conservative

Vanguard Info Tech ETF

Page 26: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Roll out planEducate employeesContinue to grow!

3 Implement and Grow

Page 27: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

1 A Superior 401(k) Provider

Page 28: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

2 More Value + More Competitive

SAMPLE:Plan Assets =

$5.5M

Page 29: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

3 ESG Integration ✓ SRI, ESG and FFF Fund Choices

✓ Conflict-Free Philosophy

✓ Partner with Sustainability

Experts

✓ Financial Wellness Education

✓ HIP Fund Ratings

✓ HIP Model Management

Page 30: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

4 The 4 “C”s of a Retirement Plan

✓ Confidence✓ Compliance✓ Cost-efficient✓ Comfort

Page 31: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

What results are possible from reinvented 401(k)s?

Page 32: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations
Page 33: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations
Page 34: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

OUR MILLENNIAL CONTRIBUTIONSIN TOP THIRD OF USA

33

STOK

Page 35: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

“It's really important to me to use my 'spending power' appropriately and invest my money in funds that align with my core beliefs.”

“My last job didn't offer any sustainable 401(k) options so I'm really grateful to work for a company that "walks the walk" with regard to their values.”

LiliUnder 30, Customer Service + Product Content

2nd retirement plan 100% in sustainable funds

Page 36: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

“Investing is not just about getting a return –that’s certainly important – but what your money is doing is also really important.”

“When I have more time to review, I am very interested in moving to fossil fuel free funds.”

“What is great about this is the curation is done for us to find good sustainable funds, which is half the battle.”

JennySoftware Developer, over 55

Previous retirement plan had some ESGInitially 66% in sustainable funds

Page 37: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

Superior QualityInvestment FreedomConflict-Free PhilosophyLow Investment CostsFull Fee TransparencyPayroll Integration & AutomationSustainability RatingsFinancial Wellness & EducationIncreased ParticipationBest-In-Class Client Services

Inferior Consulting & ComplianceInvestment LimitationsSupports Fossil Fuel IndustryHigh Investment CostsRevenue Sharing & Hidden Fees

RPG

Cons

ulta

nts S

usta

inab

le 4

01(k

)Payroll/M

utual Fund/Insurance Company

Page 38: Structuring and Executing Future-Proof Fossil-Free 401k Plans for Employees of All Generations

How will you reinvent your 401(k) to engage your employees?