STRATEGY FORMULATION AND IMPLEMENTATION IN NON- … · 2018. 1. 8. · STRATEGY FORMULATION AND...
Transcript of STRATEGY FORMULATION AND IMPLEMENTATION IN NON- … · 2018. 1. 8. · STRATEGY FORMULATION AND...
STRATEGY FORMULATION AND IMPLEMENTATION IN NON-
PROFIT ORGANISATIONS IN THE NELSON MANDELA
MUNICIPALITY
BY
LAUREN BUTLER
Paper submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for a Master’s Degree in
Business Administration at the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University.
PROMOTOR: Prof. J.J. Pieterse
April, 2015
i
DECLARATION
I, Lauren Butler, hereby declare that:
- This research study is my own work;
- That all sources have been reported and acknowledged; and
- This treatise has not previously, in part or full, been submitted to any
institution of higher learning in order to obtain an academic qualification.
…………………………………. …………………..
Lauren Butler Date
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Although there are no words to express my gratitude, a humble and truly heartfelt
thank you is extended to my husband, Charles. You are the reason I am able to write
this today; without you, my successes mean nothing. Your belief has shaped the
woman, wife, and mother I am today.
To my mother, who gave up so many hours to allow me the time to work on this
project. Your prayers, example and presence in my life have paved the way for me to
grow and be the best I can be. My heart is filled with gratitude by the thought of all
that you do, and are to me.
To my sisters, my family and my friends, every single word of encouragement has
given me hope, strengthened my faith, and increased my confidence that I am able
to do this. I know a thank you is simply not enough, but with it I hope you all know
that you have an immense impact in my life.
Above and beyond all others, this project was completed purely by the grace of God;
and the strength he granted me to see this journey to its end. All the honour is
granted unto him.
iii
ABSTRACT
Literature indicates that the sustainability of Non-Profit Organisations (NPOs) is
important as they provide pivotal services to the community. In this study, the
researcher investigates common problems associated with strategy formulation and
implementation in NPOs in the Nelson Mandela Metropole.
The researcher reports on the importance of strategy within all organisations and
outlines a strategy process that can be used as a guide to measure strategic
planning in NPOs. In pursuit of conducting qualitative research, a self-constructed
questionnaire was used to perform telephonic interviews with managers of NPOs.
The study yielded a low response rate, but based on the analysis of the data
collected, findings indicate that the main problem is not with strategy formulation or
implementation, but with the understanding of the concept of strategic planning.
During the interview process, it became evident that there is a common
misconception that the annual operations planning constitutes a strategic plan.
A major limitation to this study was the absence of a benchmark against which to
measure success. Unlike a for-profit organisation where success is measured by
profit margins, NPOs have different priorities and therefore successful strategic
planning differs from one organisation to another.
A recommendation for managers at NPOs is that they start thinking strategically
about their organisation, its planning, and methods for doing so (which is discussed
in Chapter Five).
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION ........................................................................................................... i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................... ii
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................ iii
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ................................................. 1
1.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT ..................................................................................... 2
1.3 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES .................................................................................. 5
1.3.1 Primary objective ........................................................................................... 5
1.3.2 Secondary objectives ..................................................................................... 5
1.3.3 Research design objectives ........................................................................... 6
1.4 METHODOLOGY OF THE STUDY ...................................................................... 6
1.4.1 Research paradigm ........................................................................................ 6
1.4.2 Data collection procedure .............................................................................. 7
1.5 DEFINITION OF CONCEPTS .............................................................................. 7
1.5.1 Non-profit organisation ................................................................................... 7
1.5.2 Strategy .......................................................................................................... 7
1.5.3 Strategy formulation ....................................................................................... 8
1.5.4 Strategy implementation ................................................................................ 8
1.6 OUTLINE OF THE STUDY .................................................................................. 8
1.7 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER ........................................................................... 9
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ............................................................... 10
2.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 10
2.2 WHAT IS STRATEGY ........................................................................................ 10
2.3 THE IMPORTANCE OF STRATEGY ................................................................. 11
2.3.1 Benefits of strategic planning: ...................................................................... 12
2.4 A STRATEGY-MAKING and STRATEGY-EXECUTING PROCESS .................. 13
2.4.1 Phase 1: Developing a strategic vision ........................................................ 14
2.4.2 Phase 2: Setting objectives .......................................................................... 17
2.4.3 Phase 3: Crafting a strategy to achieve the objectives and vision ............... 18
2.4.4 Phase 4: Implementing and executing the strategy ..................................... 21
v
2.4.5 Phase 5: Monitoring developments, evaluating performance, and making
corrective adjustments .......................................................................................... 22
2.5 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER ......................................................................... 24
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ......................... 25
3.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 25
3.2 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY .......................................................................... 25
3.3 RESEARCH METHOD ....................................................................................... 27
3.3.1 Advantages of questionnaires ...................................................................... 27
3.3.2 Disadvantages of questionnaires ................................................................. 28
3.3.3 Question design ........................................................................................... 29
3.3.4 Guidelines for conducting interviews ............................................................ 29
3.3.5 Interview probes ........................................................................................... 29
3.4 RESEARCH POPULATION AND SAMPLE ....................................................... 30
3.5 MEASURING INSTRUMENT ............................................................................. 31
3.5.1 Questioning techniques................................................................................ 33
3.6 THE RELIABILTY AND VALIDITY OF THE STUDY .......................................... 34
3.7 COMPILING THE NARRATIVE.......................................................................... 34
3.8 SUMMARY OF CHAPTER ................................................................................. 35
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS .............................................................. 31
4.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 36
4.2 BIOGRAPHICAL DETAILS RELATED TO THE SAMPLE ................................. 36
4.3 EMPIRICAL RESULTS: ..................................................................................... 41
4.3 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER ......................................................................... 54
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSION, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS .... 33
5.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 55
5.2 FINDINGS: ......................................................................................................... 55
5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS: ..................................................................................... 59
5.4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY.......................................................................... 59
5.5 FUTURE RESEARCH ........................................................................................ 62
5.6 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER ......................................................................... 62
CONCLUSION ......................................................................................................... 62
LIST OF REFERENCES ............................................................................................ 1
vi
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2.1: Strategy process diagram
Figure 2.2: A Strategy-making and strategy-executing process
Figure 5.1: Improvement planning process
LIST OF CHARTS
Chart 1.1: Growth of NPOs registration over past five years
Chart 4.1: Gender
Chart 4.2: Age
Chart 4.3: Education level of Manager
Chart 4.4: Manager Tenure
Chart 4.5: Years in operation
Chart 4.6: Organisation size
Chart 4.7: Social sector
Chart 4.8: Statement 1 - The organisation has a strategic vision
Chart 4.9: Statement 2 - The organisation’s vision provides a broad overview of
where the business is going
Chart 4.10: Statement 3 - The organisation’s vision communicates management’s
goals
Chart 4.11: Statement 5 - The organisation’s vision is continuously and effectively
communicated down the hierarchy to all levels of staff
Chart 4.12: Statement 6 - The organisation has a mission statement
Chart 4.13: Statement 10 - Management has set out organisational objectives
Chart 4.14: Statement 11 - The organisational objectives convert the strategic vision
into specific performance targets
Chart 4.15: Statement 12 - Performance targets are set for each of the organisation’s
services
Chart 4.16: Statement 13 - The organisational objectives consist of financial and
strategic objectives
Chart 4.17: Statement 14 - The organisational objectives are measurable
vii
Chart 4.18: Statement 15 - The organisation objectives contain a deadline for
achievement
Chart 4.19: Statement 16 - The objectives contain both long-term and short-term
performance targets
Chart 4.20: Statement 17 - When trade-offs have to be made between achieving
long-term and short-term objectives, long-term objectives take precedence
LIST OF ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A: Research questionnaire covering letter
ANNEXURE B: Measuring instruments
ANNEXURE C: Ethical clearance form
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
1
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The National Register of Non-Profit Organisations (NPOs) (2011-2012, in South
African Department of Social Development, 2012) states that “NPO is a term used
for public organisations that range from faith and community based organisations,
charities, and a host of development and social organisations working determinedly
to serve public need”. These organisations are commonly referred to as non-
governmental organisations (NGOs), community based organisations (CBOs), and
faith based organisations (FBOs).
The South African Department of Social Development (2012), in terms of section 1 of
the NPO Act, define a non-profit organisation as:
… a trust, company or other association of persons established for a public purpose and of which its income and property are not distributable to its members or office bearers except as reasonable compensation for services rendered. NGOs and CBOs are collectively known as NPOs. In some instance, NPOs are also referred to as Civil Society Organisations (CSO).
Bryson (1988) explains that NPOs are often called on to take up the slack in the
system left by failing public organisations. For this reason, sustained operations of
NPOs are pivotal as they provide much needed services to disadvantaged groups
and communities.
The primary research question to be addressed in this study is:
a. Can problems be identified in formulating and implementing strategy in NPOs
in the Nelson Mandela Metropole?
This research will be conducted in the Nelson Mandela Metropole by outlining a
strategy forming process from literature reviewed, and using it as a guide to
investigate common problems in formulating and implementing strategy in NPOs. By
means of an interpretive study, the researcher aims to gain an understanding into
the nature of these problems so that executives could gain a greater understanding
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
2
and awareness of the issues contributing to unsuccessful strategy formulation and
implementation.
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT
NPOs render needed services to the community at no charge and therefore rely
purely on sponsorship from the public and corporate funders to sustain its
operations. In addition to this, Berg (2013) states that non-profit organisations
contribute to the economy in the following ways:
NPOs operate very similarly to for-profit businesses. They are a steady
source of employment to the economy, which also requires specialised skills
and capabilities such as accountants and marketers.
NPOs use third party goods and services in their daily operations. This
generates revenue for the third party businesses.
In recent times, the economy has taken steep downturns to an extent that
companies and consumers alike are tightening their budgets and, as a result,
availability of funding for NPOs is decreasing whilst the need for these organisations
is increasing.
Based on statistics provided by the National Register of NPOs (2011-2012, in South
African Department of Social Development, 2012 ), since the inception of the NPO
Act of 1997, growth in the registration of NPOs is recorded at a rate of almost 14%;
however, during the same period, 12.1% of registered NPOs have been de-
registered. Chart 1.1 below illustrates the increase of NPO registration for the last
five years (2008 to 2013).
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
3
Chart 1.1: Growth of NPOs registration over past five years
Source: Adapted from Department of Social Development (2013)
A major concern is that managers of non-profit organisations are principally focused
on, and driven by, the social cause, which does not always translate into good
management practices. With scare resources - no long-term strategy, poor planning,
and budgeting constraints - these NPOs are left with limited or no alternative but to
close down. The shutdown or downscaling of NPOs, same as any commercial
organisations, leads to the retrenchment of employees and essentially an inability to
serve the public’s need. According to the Department of Social Development (2013),
by the end of October 2012, 36 428 NPOs were deregistered due to non-
compliance. This is a direct reflection on the management of the NPOs and indicates
a need to investigate and suggest initiatives to assist NPOs to become compliant
and sustainable.
The problem statement for this research document is formulated as follows:
To what extent is strategy in NPOs in the Nelson Mandela Metro successfully
formulated and executed?
Research conducted by Kaplan and Norton (2008) investigated whether or not
organisations had a formal execution process in place and 54% respondents stated
yes, while 46% responded that their organisations did not have a formal strategy
execution process in place. The results of this study also discovered that
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
NP
Os
dat
abas
e
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
4
organisations that had a formal execution process outperformed organisations
without one (Kaplan & Norton, 2008).
Porter and Kramer (2006) suggest that if proper strategy frameworks are being used
by NPOs, corporate social responsibility (CSR) can be more than just a constraint for
corporates; it can be an opportunity and source of competitive advantage. Strong,
well-functioning organisations will provide corporates with a platform to give back to
the community in a sustained and strategic method and increase the likelihood of
organisations receiving continuous funding and support.
Based on the literature reviewed, many researchers agree that strategic planning
within NGOs is problematic. However, research in this field has produced business
models and strategy frameworks that can be implemented by NPOs to improve their
operations and sustainability without investigating the underlying nature or
fundamental problems in strategic planning.
Considering the above, the purpose of this research is to investigate common
problems in strategy formulation and implementation in NGOs. By doing so, the
researcher aims to create awareness amongst executives regarding the nature of
these problems in an attempt to help prevent them from repeating errors that
compromise the continuity of the organisation.
This introduces the primary research question that will be addressed by the
research:
- What problems can be identified in formulating and implementing strategy in
NPOs in the Nelson Mandela Metropole?
This research question is divided into secondary research questions:
- What is the significance of strategy formulation and implementation in NPOs?
- How can a strategy framework be used as a benchmark for successful
strategy formulation and implementation in NPOs?
- What problems can be identified in strategy formulation and implementation in
NPOs?
- What recommendations can be made for improving strategy formulation and
implementation in NPOs in the NMM?
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
5
According to the National Register of NPOs (2011-2012, in South African
Department of Social Development, 2012), registered organisations are grouped in
terms of the International Classification of Non-profit Organisations (ICNPO).
According to the ICNPO (in South African Department of Social Development, 2012),
there are 11 categories of NPOs, with social services being the leading sector
comprising 40% of total registered NPOs. The social services category is further
divided into subject areas referred to as themes, namely:
- Child welfare, child services, day-care
- Disaster/emergency prevention and control
- Family services
- Income support and maintenance
- Material assistance
- Refugee assistance
- Self-help and other personal social services
- Services for the elderly
- Services for the disabled
- Temporary shelters
- Youth services and youth welfare
For this study, the researcher will focus on strategy formulation and implementation
within the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropole social services sector as classified by the
ICNPO.
1.3 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
1.3.1 Primary objective
The primary objective of the study is to identify problems that hinder the successful
formulation and implementation of strategy in NPOs.
1.3.2 Secondary objectives
In pursuit of the primary objective, the following secondary objectives have been
formulated:
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
6
- To highlight the importance of strategy formulation and implementation in
NPOs.
- To identify a strategy framework that can be used as a benchmark for strategy
formulation and implementation in NPOs.
- To investigate the problems in strategy formulation and implementation in
NPOs based on the framework identified by means of an empirical study.
- To propose recommendations for improving strategy formulation and
implementation in NPOs.
1.3.3 Research design objectives
In order to attain the above-mentioned objectives, the following research design
objectives are pursued:
- conducting a secondary literature review on the variables being explored
- constructing a questionnaire consisting of open and closed questions for the
collection of empirical data
- distributing the questionnaire to a sample of 15 identified executives of non-
profit organisations within the Nelson Mandela Metropole
- capturing the data of the completed questionnaires
- analysing the data of the completed questionnaires
- interpreting the results and drawing conclusions
- providing recommendations to management
1.4 METHODOLOGY OF THE STUDY
1.4.1 Research paradigm
Two main research paradigms exist, namely positivism and interpretivism. For this
study, the researcher will be using a mixed modal approach to the research design,
in other words, following a mixture of both the positivistic and interpretive
approaches. The dominant paradigm will, however, be that of an interpretive
paradigm as the aim of the study is to gain an understanding of what causes the
problem, and to offer possible solutions as to how the problem could be addressed.
Thus, the nature of the problem will be investigated.
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
7
1.4.2 Data collection procedure
1.4.2.1 Approach
The research methodology or approach for the data collected in this study is an
analytical survey by means of semi-structured interviews with managers of non-profit
organisation in the Nelson Mandela Metropole.
1.4.2.2 Data collection method
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with the identified sample during which
open and closed questions were posed to these managers.
1.4.2.3 Data analysis
Once the interviews were completed, the data was transcribed into an in-depth
narrative. A thematic analysis approach was used to interpret the collected data to
identify the common issues that recur and identify the main themes that summarise
all the views that were collected. The data from the closed questions were captured
and analysed using statistical software.
1.5 DEFINITION OF CONCEPTS
This section provides definitions of key concepts pertinent to this research. To this
end, four concepts are defined: NPO, strategy, strategy formulation, and strategy
implementation.
1.5.1 Non-profit organisation
NPOs are organisations established to serve a public need. These organisations
render needed services to the community at no charge and therefore rely purely on
sponsorship from the public and corporate funders to sustain its operations. These
income and/or property/assets are not distributable to its members or office bearers
except for compensation for services rendered as approved by the governing body.
1.5.2 Strategy
A comprehensive strategy outlines management’s plan to grow the business, stake
out a market position, attract and please customers, compete successfully, conduct
operations, and achieve targeted objectives.
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
8
1.5.3 Strategy formulation
Formulating a company’s strategy starts with articulating the company’s strategic
vision and mission statement, and effectively communicating these down the
hierarchy to all levels of management and staff. A company’s strategy consists of an
outlined statement of values that management identify as key attributes for
personnel to display and, very importantly, setting objectives in order to convert the
strategic vision into specific performance targets that are measurable and contain a
deadline for achievement.
1.5.4 Strategy implementation
Strategy implementation is an operations-orientated activity aimed at the execution
of core business activities in a strategy supportive manner and should be launched
and managed on all organisational levels. The effective implementation of strategy
requires executives to continually evaluate if the company’s direction and strategy
are well matched to the industry and competitive conditions and if performance
targets are being met.
1.6 OUTLINE OF THE STUDY
Chapter Description
Chapter One
This chapter provides an introduction and
the outline of the study. The chapter
provides the problem statement, the
main research question and sub-
questions, research objectives, sample,
measuring instruments, and definitions of
the key concepts used in this study.
Chapter Two
This chapter focuses on the literature
study that underpins the research
problem.
Chapter Three This chapter focuses on the methodology
of the study. This includes the research
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY ___________________________________________________________________
9
paradigm, the sample, measuring
instruments, and data analysis
procedures.
Chapter Four
This chapter focuses on the empirical
results which will be reported and
interpreted.
Chapter Five
This chapter focuses on the empirical
results and conclusions drawn. The
chapter also includes recommendations
to managers, limitations of the study, and
highlights areas for future research.
1.7 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER
This chapter has provided an introduction to NPOs and the significant role they play
in society. The main research problem underpinning the study has been identified
and the sub-problems have been stated. The primary and secondary research
objectives have been formulated and the research design objectives have been
listed.
The methodology for the study was summarised and definitions of the fundamental
concepts pertaining to the study was provided. The chapter is concluded with a list of
the chapters outlining the structure of the document.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
10
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Bryson (1988) forewarned decades ago that strategic thought and action are
increasingly important to the continued viability and effectiveness of governments,
public agencies, and non-profit organisations. Without strategic planning it is unlikely
that these organisations will be able to successfully meet the numerous challenges
that face them.
By reviewing the literature, the researcher aims to address the first two sub-
problems:
a. To highlight the importance of strategy formulation and implementation in
NPOs.
b. To identify a strategy framework that can be used as a benchmark for strategy
formulation and implementation in NPOs.
This chapter will:
outline what strategy is;
discuss the importance of strategy; and
provide an in-depth analysis of the strategy-making and strategy-executing
process.
2.2 WHAT IS STRATEGY
Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2005) outline a company’s strategy as
management’s game plan for:
growing the business;
staking out a market position;
attracting and pleasing customers;
competing successfully;
conducting operations; and
achieving targeted objectives.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
11
In order to devise this game plan, Hough, Thompson, Strickland, and Gamble (2011)
state that managers face three central questions in thinking strategically about their
company’s present circumstances and prospects: What’s the company’s present
situation? Where does the company need to go from here? How should it get there?
In a quest to answer these questions, it is essential that management conduct both
an external environmental assessment as well as an internal environmental
assessment. As described in Bryson (1988), an external environmental assessment
is performed to explore the environment outside the organisation in order to identify
the opportunities and threats the organisation faces; and an internal environmental
assessment is an assessment of the organisation itself to identify its strengths and
weaknesses.
This process is referred to as a SWOT analysis, which Bryson (1988) states is very
important because every effective strategy will build on strengths and take
advantage of opportunities while it overcomes or minimizes weaknesses and threats.
The heart and soul of any strategy are the actions and moves managers take to gain
a competitive edge over competitors. Hough, Thompson, Strickland, and Gamble
(2011) argue that if a competitive edge holds promise for being durable and
sustainable, then so much better for the strategy, revenue growth, and future
survival. Hough, Thompson, Strickland, and Gamble (2011) adds that what makes a
competitive advantage sustainable, are actions and elements in the strategy that
cause an attractive number of buyers, in the case of NPOs – sponsors, to have a
lasting preference for a company’s products or services as compared to offerings of
competitors.
2.3 THE IMPORTANCE OF STRATEGY
Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2005) state that crafting and executing strategy
are vital managerial tasks for two reasons: Firstly, it is essential for managers to
proactively shape how the company’s business will be conducted and secondly, a
strategy focused organisation is more likely to be financially strong.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
12
2.3.1 Benefits of strategic planning:
Waechter (2011), among others, suggests that successful strategic planning in
NPOs can provide the following benefits:
- Bring clarity and agreement on organisation mission and vision: Agreement
on the mission is extremely important for the organisation to be effective, and
defining a shared vision is essential for identifying the desired outcome and
planning to achieve it.
- Help organisations prepare for the future: A strategic plan serves as a
roadmap to achieve the desired future for an organisation. It helps the board,
staff, and volunteers prioritise the work that needs to be done and facilitates in
making short-term decisions based on their long-term implications.
- Help organisations anticipate and manage change: By anticipating and
planning for change, organisations can prepare for it instead of merely
reacting to it in a startled way.
- Improve the decision-making processes: With a strategic plan in place, day-
to-day decision making and problem solving will be based on the
organisations short-term and long-range goals. When making choices within
the context of the strategic framework, the organisation’s direction is clearly
defined.
- Align the board and staff: A shared purpose and direction provides a platform
for high performing teams.
- Educate participants about institutional history: By understanding the
organisation’s past, better choices can be made about the organisation’s
future.
- Identify existing strengths in the organisation: Providing consistent feedback
on how well the organisations is meeting its objective according to the plan
set out serves as a source of motivation and inspiration for staff to continue. In
addition, it provides direction on which efforts best contribute to the success of
the organisation.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
13
2.4 A STRATEGY-MAKING and STRATEGY-EXECUTING PROCESS
Henry Mintzberg (in Gopinath & Siciliano, 2013), provides five definitions – the “Five
Ps” - of strategy:
1. Strategy as a plan. This plan documents a consciously intended course of
action and could take the form of a set of guidelines or a written report that
managers use to guide their decisions.
2. Strategy as a pattern. This is an after-the-fact view of strategy where the
organisation is looked at over a period of time and a “pattern in a stream of
actions” can be identified. Consistency in decisions suggests a direction and if
the pattern was not originally intended, then the realized strategy is called the
“emergent strategy”.
3. Strategy as a position. Managers see their firm as occupying a place within an
environment – this is its position in the market in relation to its competition.
4. Strategy as a perspective. This perspective is how the organisation sees itself
and expresses its way of doing things.
5. Strategy as a ploy. This is a short-term tactic that is intended to outwit or pre-
empt competitive strategic moves.
For this study, the researcher refers to strategy as a plan, and this section of the
report highlights the steps involved in crafting this plan.
Consequent to the above-mentioned information regarding strategy, the researcher
bases the following section on the work of Hough, Thompson, Strickland and
Gamble (2011) who describe the managerial process of crafting and executing a
company’s strategy in five interrelated and integrated phases:
1. Developing a strategic vision of where the company needs to head and what
its future product or market focus should be. This should be based on a
thorough external and internal analysis.
2. Setting objectives and using them as a benchmark for measuring the
company’s performance and progress.
3. Crafting a strategy to achieve the objectives and move the company along the
strategic course that management has charted.
4. Implementing and executing the chosen strategy efficiently and effectively.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
14
5. Evaluating performance and initiating corrective adjustments in the company’s
long-term direction, objectives, strategy, or execution in light of actual
experience, changing conditions, new ideas, and new opportunities.
Van Buren (2010) states that the best strategic plans have both a soft and hard
composition with the softer side including the vision, mission, values, and beliefs and
the harder side including the goals, strategic objectives, and milestones. Within the
process selected by the researcher, Phase 1 will provide greater depth into the soft
side of strategic plans, and Phase 2 will provide insight on the hard side.
2.4.1 Phase 1: Developing a strategic vision
Fundamental to crafting a strategy is to articulate the company’s strategic vision.
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) state that a strategic vision
describes the aspirations management has for the business by providing a broad
view of where the business is going and a rationale for why it makes good business
sense for the company. A strategic vision thus points an organisation in a particular
direction, outlines a strategic path, and shapes organisational identity. A clear and
well-structured vision communicates management’s goals to everyone involved and
directs the energy of the staff in one direction.
A well-crafted vision statement is distinctive and specific to the organisation and
does not include broad and generic feel-good statements. For a strategic vision to be
a valuable tool, it must include the following:
provide a clear understanding of what management wants its business to look
like;
provide management with a reference point in making decisions and
preparing the company for the future; and
it must include descriptions about how management plan to position the
company beyond where it is today.
A good vision should be beyond the company’s reach so that progress towards the
vision unites the efforts of staff.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
15
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) describe eight characteristics of a
well-worded strategic vision for businesses:
1. Graphic – Describes the image of the company that managers aim to create.
2. Directional – Should be forward-looking; outlines the strategic path managers
had set out to follow and the adjustments needed to prepare for the future.
3. Focused – It should be specific enough to provide managers with guidance in
making decisions and allocating resources.
4. Flexible – It should not be rigid and eternal; mangers have to be able to adjust
it as circumstances change.
5. Feasible – It should be realistic of what the company can reasonably expect
to achieve.
6. Desirable – It should indicate why this is the best path for the company to
take.
7. Easy to communicate – It should be explainable in 5-10 minutes and, ideally,
can be reduced to a simple, memorable slogan.
A strategic vision is a tool management can use to give the organisation a sense of
direction. However, like any other tool, this can be used incorrectly. As outlined by
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) below, there are common
shortcomings in company vision statements:
Vague or incomplete – Does not provide specific information on the direction
the company is headed or what preparations are being made for the future.
Not forward-looking – Does not describes management’s plan to alter the
company’s current focus.
Too broad – Provides no clear direction.
Bland or uninspiring – Does not motivate staff or inspire shareholder
confidence about the company’s future.
Not distinctive – Does not provide a distinctive company identity.
Too reliant on superlatives – Does not provide information on the company’s
strategic course beyond the pursuit of accolades such as best, most
successful, leader etc.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
16
In contrast to the strategic vision, the company mission statement provides a brief
overview of its present business purpose. It also may or may not include the
company’s present products and/or services, the buyers’ needs it is seeking to
satisfy, the customer groups it serves, or its business capabilities. In essence, the
company mission statement depicts “who they are, what they do, and why they are
here” whereas the strategic vision describes “where they are headed”.
As important as crafting the strategic vision, effectively communicating it down the
hierarchy to all levels of management and staff is just as vital. In order to get the
organisation to move in the intended direction, all staff need to believe that senior
management knows where it’s trying to take the company, understand what changes
lie ahead, and understand why the course that management has set out is
reasonable and beneficial.
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) state that an engaging and
convincing strategic vision has enormous motivational value. Ideally, executives
should present their vision for the company in a manner that reaches out and grabs
people. The more a vision evokes positivity, the greater its impact in rallying the staff
to move in a common direction. Thus, executives’ ability to paint a convincing and
inspiring picture of the company’s journey and destination is a crucial element of
effective strategic leadership.
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) list five benefits of a well-
conceived and effectively communicated strategic vision:
1. It crystallizes senior managers’ own views about the company’s long-term
direction.
2. It reduces the risk of rudderless decision making.
3. It is a tool to get staff support on changes that will help realise the vision.
4. It provides a beacon for lower-level managers in forming departmental
missions, setting departmental objectives, and crafting functional and
departmental strategies that are in sync with the company’s overall strategy.
5. It assists the managers in preparing for the company’s future.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
17
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) state that effectively conveying
the strategic vision to staff can also be supported by capturing it in an easily
remembered slogan. The creation of a short slogan highlights the company’s
purpose and by using it consistently, it aids as a reminder of where they are headed
and why. In addition, it helps staff to overcome obstacles and maintain focus.
Lastly, Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) point out that companies
should develop a statement of values to guide the pursuit of its vision and mission,
strategy, and ways of operating. Values, in this instance, are the beliefs, traits, and
ways of doing things that management has determined should guide the staff
behaviour in working towards its vision. A typical statement of values consists of
around four to eight traits.
2.4.2 Phase 2: Setting objectives
Aliyeva (2012) states that strategic thinking is a broader and innovative way of thinking
on a daily basis about overall goals of your job, team, and organisation with a more
systemic and holistic approach to your environment. It is the responsibility of
management to set objectives in order to convert the strategic vision into specific
performance targets. These performance targets are the results and outcomes that
management want to achieve. Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011)
describe a well-stated objective as one that is quantifiable, or measurable, and
contains a deadline for achievement. These objectives are valuable as they serve as
yardsticks for management to track the company’s performance and progress.
Van Buren (2010) describes goals and objectives as outcome statements that define
what an organisation is trying to accomplish. As with Hough, Thompson, Strickland
and Gamble (2011), Van Buren (2010) states that these need to be SMART –
specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, and timely.
In addition, Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) distinguish between
financial and strategic objectives, defining financial objectives as “financial
performance targets set by management for the company to achieve”, and strategic
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
18
objectives as “target outcomes that indicate a company is strengthening its market
standing, competitive vitality, and future business prospects”.
It is imperative for a company to achieve acceptable financial results. Without
financial health, a company’s pursuit of its strategic vision as well as long term
survival is put a risk.
When objectives are set, managers need to outline both short- and long-term
performance targets. Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) state that
quarterly and annual objectives focus attention on delivering immediate performance
improvements whereas three to five year targets prompt managers to consider what
to do now to put the company in a position to perform better later.
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) recommend that when trade-offs
have to be made between achieving long-run objectives and achieving short-run
objectives, long-run objectives should take precedence. This is of particular
importance for NGOs as these organisations are there to serve public need, so often
when issues arise that are out of their scope of service, management or staff would
compromise their efforts in working towards the long-term objectives to provide
immediate assistance to the problem at hand.
Finally, Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) indicate that company
objectives need to be broken down into performance targets for each of the
organisations’ separate businesses, product lines, functional departments, and
individual work units. This provides a platform for all units to pursue performance
targets that contribute directly to the desired company-wide strategic and financial
objectives. In observing the general spread of work within a NGO,
departmentalisation is based on either the target’s markets and/or the barrier being
addressed.
2.4.3 Phase 3: Crafting a strategy to achieve the objectives and vision
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) describe the task of crafting
strategy as answering a series of “hows”: How to grow the business; how to please
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
19
customers; how to outcompete rivals; how to respond to changing market conditions;
how to manage each functional piece of the business and develop needed
competencies and capabilities; and how to achieve strategic, financial, and
operational objectives. It also means choosing among the various strategic
alternatives and proactively searching for opportunities to do new things or to do
existing things in a new way.
It is impossible to formulate an effective strategy without engaging in strategic
thinking. Abrahams (2005) suggests that managers explore the following approaches
to improve strategic thinking:
Being successfully different
Emulating entrepreneurs
Finding new opportunities
Being future oriented
Being collaborative
Abrahams (2005) further suggests that managers should learn to view the world with
entrepreneurial eyes. Strategic thinking not only requires managers to decide on
what will make a business unique, but also requires them to identify alternative
scenarios to generate customer value. Managers of NPOs need to become like
entrepreneurs and start questioning how business processes and daily operations
can be done better, quicker, cheaper, differently, more conveniently, faster, and
more reliable.
. Donovan (2013) describes the symptoms of a poor strategy to be as follows:
Vague business goals
Unclear operational objectives
Inadequate action plans
Irrelevant performance measurements
Effective strategic planning requires a dynamic, methodical process that keeps an
organisation constantly focused on the right issues and actions (Donovan, 2013).
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
20
Donovan (2013) recommends that management focus on the following four
components to improve strategy:
Strategic goals, which are brief statements of what senior management
aspires to achieve in terms of growth, services, profits, etc.
Improvement objectives, which need to be specific, measurable, achievable,
realistic, time bound, and linked to specific strategic goals.
Action plans, which transform objectives into a specific set of steps,
responsibilities, schedules to execute the agreed strategy.
Performance measures, which provide precise and accurate quantitative data
and information for reviewing, evaluating, and updating actions plans.
Figure 2.1 below summaries this process.
Figure 2.1: Strategy process diagram
Source: Adapted from Donovan (2013)
1. Strategic
goals
2. Improvement
objectives
3. Action plans
4. Performance
measures
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
21
Donovan (2013) adds that taking the steps discussed above requires courage,
confidence, hard work, and persistence, but the reward is executing a winning
strategy that enables the organisation to achieve its goals and ultimately its vision.
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) state that a company’s senior
executives have important strategy-making roles and hold the ultimate responsibility
for leading the strategy-making, strategy-executing process. A CEO-centred
approach to strategy development is characteristic of small owner-managed
companies, as is the case with majority NPOs. However, this does not mean that
executives should exclude other levels of staff to have input in strategy formulation. It
is the responsibility of executives to provide strategy-making direction and clearly
articulate key strategic themes that paint the white lines for lower-level strategy-
making efforts. Staff of NPOs are energised in working towards a greater cause.
Allowing them to steer their efforts, in a well guided and managed way, in directions
that they feel will render maximum benefits to the organisation and to the public,
brings great fulfilment and reward.
2.4.4 Phase 4: Implementing and executing the strategy
Managing this phase of the strategy management process is an operations-
orientated activity aimed at the execution of core business activities in a strategy
supportive manner. Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) describe this
to be the most demanding part of the process which has to be launched and
managed on all organisational levels. Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble
(2011) propose that converting strategic plans into actions and results tests a
manager’s ability to:
direct organisational change;
motivate people;
build and strengthen company competencies and capabilities;
create and nurture a strategy supportive work climate; and
meet or beat performance targets.
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
22
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) list the following principal aspects
in managing the strategy execution process:
Staffing the organisation with essential skills needed to build competencies
and competitive capabilities.
Allocating resources to activities vital to strategic success.
Drafting policies and procedures that promote effective strategy execution.
Using best practices to perform core business activities.
Installing information and operating procedures that facilitate greater
efficiencies in work tasks.
Motivating people to do their best to execute the strategy successfully.
Link rewards and incentives directly to performance.
Create a company culture and work climate that is conducive to successful
strategy execution.
Displaying the internal leadership required to drive implementation forward
and improve the execution of the strategy.
Van Buren (2010) puts forward that to make the plan operational, management need
to attach specific time lines, assign responsibilities to people, and create a budget.
This phase in the process can be considered successful if the company meets or
beats its strategic targets and achieves management’s strategic vision.
2.4.5 Phase 5: Monitoring developments, evaluating performance, and making
corrective adjustments
The fifth phase of the strategy management process entails monitoring new external
developments, evaluating the company’s progress, and making corrective
adjustments to the company’s vision, objectives, strategy, or strategy execution
methods.
Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) describe this as an on-going
process where company executives continually evaluate if the company’s direction
and strategy are well matched to the industry and competitive conditions, and if
performance targets are being met. If the vision and strategy is still current, simply
fine-tuning the strategic plan and continuing with efforts to improve its execution are
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
23
sufficient; however, if it is not yielding results on its objectives, then executives will
need to re-evaluate or modify its strategic vision or execution methods.
Figure 2.2: A strategy-making and strategy-executing process
Source: Adapted from Hough, Thompson, Strickland, and Gamble (2011).
Van Buren (2010) states that in the end, management should ask themselves the
following questions:
Is the organisation thinking strategically?
Are strategies being created from a shared vision?
Are we learning from the past and gathering information from and about the
external environment?
Do we have measurable goals in place?
Are individuals or teams accountable to the plan?
1. Develop a strategic vision
2. Set objectives
3. Craft a strategy4. Implement the
strategy
5. Evaluate the strategy and make
adjustments
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ___________________________________________________________________
24
2.5 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER
This section of the study reviewed literature to outline what strategy is and why it is
important for businesses to participate in strategic planning. The benefits of strategic
planning were discussed and an in-depth analysis of a strategy-making, strategy-
executing process was completed.
In this process, the essential aspects of crafting a strategic vision and mission
statement were outlined and the importance of setting objectives was stated. Factors
to consider when crafting a strategy were reviewed and the importance of
communicating, measuring, and revising the strategy was discussed.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
25
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
3.1 INTRODUCTION
This study aims to identify the managerial problems that are faced by non-profit
organisations in formulating and implementing strategy. The previous chapter
reviewed literature to outline the importance of strategy formulation.
Research by Hume and Hume (2008) indicates that:
Managers within non-profit organisations are principally focused on, and
driven by, the social cause of the organisation.
This focus and drive does not always translate into good management
practices, including strategy formulation and implementation.
In consideration of these factors, and based on the literature reviewed, the
researcher identified a suitable strategy process that can be used as a guide to
understand what aspects of strategy have to be in place for NPOs to succeed.
This chapter will:
outline the planned research methodology;
describe the research method; and
provide brief insight into the construction of the measurement instrument used
to conduct this research.
3.2 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Collis and Hussey (2009) identifies a research paradigm is a framework that guides
how scientific research should be conducted. Based on the literature, two main
research paradigms exist, namely positivism and interpretivism. Positivism focuses
on measuring social phenomena, and interpretive studies focus on exploring the
complexity of social phenomena with a view to gaining interpretive understanding.
Based on the methodological assumption of interpretivism, in the analysis of the
findings, the researcher seeks to understand what is happening in a situation and
looking for patterns which may be repeated in other similar situations. In this study,
the researcher will take a mixed modal approach to data collection; however, the
dominant approach will be an interpretive one.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
26
As identified by Collis and Hussey (2009), the main features of interpretive studies
are listed as follow:
The goal is to gain rich and detailed insights into the complexity of social
phenomena. For this reason, researchers in this paradigm can conduct their
research with small samples.
The researcher will not attempt to control any of the characteristics of the
phenomena and therefore will conduct the research in a natural setting rather
than an artificial location.
The investigation is conducted to describe different patterns that is perceived
in the data or to construct a new theory to explain the phenomenon without
being restricted by existing theories.
There is no intention of analysing data statistically and therefore no desire to
quantify qualitative research data. The aim is to produce ‘rich’ and subjective
qualitative data.
Findings generally have low reliability but high validity (this will be discussed
later in this chapter).
Findings can be generalised from one setting to an additional similar setting.
Generalisation is concerned with the application of research results to cases
or situations beyond those examined in the study.
Once the paradigm is selected, the researcher will select a methodology and
supportive method/s for collecting and analysing the research data that meets the
philosophical assumptions of the chosen paradigm.
Collis and Hussey (2009) describe a research methodology as an approach to the
process of the research, encompassing a body of research methods and a research
method as a technique for collecting and/or analysing data.
For this study, the researcher collected primary research data. Collis and Hussey
(2009) identify primary data as data generated from an original source, such as your
own experiments, questionnaire surveys, interviews, and/ or focus groups.
For this study, the researcher selected a survey as a methodology of choice to
collect the primary data. Collis and Hussey (2009) identify a survey as a
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
27
methodology designed to collect primary or secondary data from a sample with the
objective to analysing the data and generalising the results to the population.
Surveys are more commonly associated with positivistic studies; however, it may
also be used in interpretive studies.
As outlined by Collis and Hussey (2009), based on their purpose, surveys can be
divided into two types, descriptive surveys and analytical surveys. Collis and Hussey
(2009) describes a descriptive survey as a method that provides an accurate
representation of phenomena at a specific point in time, whereas an analytical
survey is a method conducted to determine whether there is a relationship between
pairs of variables or multiple variables. For this study, the researcher conducted an
analytical survey by means of a semi-structured telephonic interview. A
questionnaire was used so that all participants were asked the same prepared
questions, but the interviewer was also able to add additional questions in order to
obtain more detailed information about a particular answer or to explore new,
relevant issues that came about from a particular answer.
3.3 RESEARCH METHOD
Interviews are a method for collecting data in which selected participants are asked
questions to find out what they do, think, or feel. In a semi-structured interview, some
of the questions are prepared in the form of a questionnaire.
According to Wilson (2010), questionnaires are valuable tools for collecting primary
data. By incorporating different questioning techniques within the questionnaire, the
researcher is able to gather a wide range of data.
3.3.1 Advantages of questionnaires
As with all data collection methods, a number of advantages and disadvantages are
associated with questionnaires. Wilson (2010) lists the following advantages:
They allow you to obtain accurate information.
They provide a cost-effective and reliable means of gathering feedback that
can be qualitative as well as quantitative.
A survey questionnaire can provide accurate and relevant data through
thoughtful design, testing, and detailed administration.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
28
In order to facilitate the collection of accurate data, Wilson (2010) states that the
researcher needs to take into account two key issues:
1. An appropriate set of questions needs to be included within the main body of
the questionnaire. These questions can be delivered using a range of
techniques that can allow both qualitative and quantitative analysis to take
place.
2. The questionnaire must be aimed at the right target audience. A poorly
selected sample can lead not only to a set of biased results, but also to a high
response rate.
Dillman (1978, in Wilson, 2010) describes three ways to best maximise the response
rate of participants in questionnaire and telephone surveys:
1. Cooperation is in some sense rewarding for them.
2. The rewards outweigh the costs to them in terms of money, time, and effort.
3. They are convinced that they can trust you to keep your side of the transition.
3.3.2 Disadvantages of questionnaires
Although the advantages outweigh the disadvantages, Wilson (2010) lists the
following noteworthy disadvantages:
Unlike personal interviews, the way questionnaires are administered often
means that they are impersonal. Researchers are not at hand to clarify any
questions that the respondents might have and this might lead to inaccurate
data or the respondent simply not answering the question.
In addition to this, if a respondent misinterprets a question, the response
cannot be included in the final analysis. In most cases, this is not the fault of
the respondent, but the consequence of a poorly designed questionnaire of
the researchers’ inability to explain the question clearly.
Finally, and perhaps the leading disadvantage of using a questionnaire, is the
difficulty associated with questionnaire design.
By using the questionnaire as a basis for a telephonic interview, these
disadvantages will not be an imminent factor in this research.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
29
3.3.3 Question design
Collis and Hussey (2009) listed the following general rules for designing the
questions for a questionnaire:
Provide a context by briefly explaining the purpose of the research
Only ask questions that are needed for analysis
Keep each question as short and simple as possible
Only ask one question at a time
Avoid jargon, ambiguity, and negative questions
Avoid leading questions and value-laden questions that suggest a ‘correct’
answer
Avoid questions that could cause offence or embarrassment
3.3.4 Guidelines for conducting interviews
In addition to designing the questions appropriately, it is also essential for the
researcher to take note of how to ask the questions during an interview.
Brikci and Green (2007) list the following general guidelines for conducting an
interview:
Start with a general question to orientate interviewee to the topic
Gauge the level at which you need to express yourself - the type of language
that you should use so that the people you speak to understand you and do
not feel intimidated by complex vocabulary or patronised by a simplistic one
either
Use everyday vocabulary – do not use technical words or overcomplicated
phrases
Put more sensitive questions towards the end
Ask open questions, i.e. requiring more than ‘yes’ or ‘no’ in answer
Ask neutral questions
Use concrete rather than abstract questions
Use concrete events to help people remember
3.3.5 Interview probes
To ensure that the interviewer gains maximum information, it is essential that the
researcher probes the interviewee by asking questions that require them to elaborate
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
30
on their initial statement. Collins and Hussey (2009) define probes as questions you
ask in response to what the interviewee has said. These questions are asked so that
the researcher can gain a greater understanding of the issue under study. Collins
and Hussey (2009) recommend that probes can be used to gage the following
qualitative characteristics:
Gain clarity on a response
Establish relevance of the response to the topic or to other variables
Expand depth into a response
Establish significance of a topic or situation
Draw comparison
Test possible bias
3.4 RESEARCH POPULATION AND SAMPLE
The population for this study comprises all social service NPOs in the Nelson
Mandela Metropolitan area.
Brikci and Green (2007) state that it is important to select a sample in a systematic
way in order to ensure that the sample is seen as credible and indicative. Samples
for interpretive, or qualitative research, are usually purposive. This means
participants are selected because they are likely to generate useful data for the
project. To ensure that the sample is credible and covers the main groups the
researcher was interested in, the strategy for this study was to select a maximum
variation sample. This sample selection involves selecting key demographic
variables that are likely to have an impact on the participants’ view of the topic.
For this study, the researcher identified the following five (5) variables as being likely
to have an impact on the research:
1. Gender
2. Age
3. Education level
4. Size of the organisation
5. The sector the organisation services
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
31
In order to select this sample, the researcher identified all the registered social
service NPOs in the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan area. Telephonic interviews were
conducted with the manager of each organisation in order to gain information on the
required variables as identified by the researcher as likely to having an impact on the
research. The process of selecting a maximum variation sample was then conducted
to identify appropriate participants for the study.
A total sample of 30 social service NPO managers were selected for this study.
Consequent to the initial telephonic interviews, the managers of the organisations
(identified as the sample based on the maximum variation sample method)
participated in semi-structured telephonic interviews.
Whilst conducting these interviews during the data collection phase of this study, the
researcher found that the respondents were either very passionate about their work
and eager to participate in the study, or were reluctant to participate in such in-depth
interviews and either declined to participate, or set up interviews but later failed to
avail themselves for the agreed upon times. The low number of interviews conducted
posed a concern for the researcher, however, the findings of this study were not fully
compromised as the aim of qualitative research is to seek an understanding of other
people’s perspectives and motivations, and in so doing, focuses on words and their
meanings. For this reason it is common practise for qualitative researchers to use
small samples sizes.
3.5 MEASURING INSTRUMENT
Designing a questionnaire is not easy and Wilson (2010) lists the following few
factors to consider before commencement:
What is the purpose of your questionnaire?
How can you ensure reliability and validity?
How will the questions help you to answer your research objectives?
What length should your questionnaire be?
All of these factors will be discussed in this section, except for reliability and validity
which will be discussed in the following section.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
32
Wilson (2010) deconstructed the above-mentioned factors into the following
categories:
Theme – Before constructing the questionnaire, it is essential that the
researcher has a clear understanding of the theme of the research. By using
questioning techniques, the researcher should construct clear research
questions respectively.
Layout – It is essential that questionnaires are structured in a clear and logical
manner where each section is based on a particular theme. Questionnaires
that are poorly designed jeopardises the response rate.
Length – It is difficult to establish the ideal length for a questionnaire as
researchers do not want to deter respondents with too many questions, but it
must be long enough to ensure sufficient data is generated. Suggestions are
to review previous research questionnaires in the chosen subject area or to
conduct a pilot study.
Question order – Important to questionnaire design is that the questions are in
a logical order and that all questions relating to a specific topic fall within the
same section. Respondents are more likely to finish a questionnaire if they
have already answered the majority of the questions; therefore it is advised
that sensitive questions be placed closer to the end of the questionnaire.
Coding – Codes are symbols, usually numbers, which are used to identify
particular responses or type of response in questionnaires and similar
instruments. This is used as part of the questionnaire to help process and
analyse data.
Vote of thanks – It is important that you thank your participants for their time
and cooperation. Also, asking them to comment on any aspect of your
research might provide useful information and/or lead to questions that were
not considered or overlooked.
Pilot study – Conducting a pilot study aids in increasing the levels of reliability
and validity before the commencement of the main survey.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
33
3.5.1 Questioning techniques
Wilson (2010) states that the most important aspect of designing a questionnaire is
the formulation of questions through the application of questioning techniques.
Wilson (2010) describes these questioning techniques as different ways of asking a
question to extract the information you need. Important here is that these techniques
dictate the analytical techniques to analyse the findings. Wilson (2010) provides the
following detailed list of questioning techniques:
Multiple choice questions – These questions should be written so that the
selection of answers directly corresponds to the question being asked. Each
response should be mutually exclusive of the others so that there is no
overlap in the choice.
Rank order questions – These are attitude-based questions and require the
respondent to rank an attitude statement in their order of preference.
Semantic differential scale questions – These questions assess how strongly
respondents hold an attitude based on a scale that progresses from one
extreme to another.
Sensitive questions – It is often difficult to gauge the sensitivity of a question,
but it is always advised that researchers keep in mind cultural differences.
Likert scale question – This is another ‘attitude question’ in that it seeks to
determine a respondent’s attitude towards a particular subject. Generally, the
researcher posts a question and requests the respondent to tick a response
that best reflects their opinion.
Open questions – These are questions where the respondents do not have to
indicate a specific response. Respondents often see these questions as an
opportunity to respond in detail, especially if they are passionate about the
topic.
Closed questions – These questions simply request a respondent to respond
to the question by choosing from a limited number of potential answers.
The researcher will be making use of open and closed questions for the gathering of
data for this study.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
34
3.6 THE RELIABILTY AND VALIDITY OF THE STUDY
Reliability and validity are two aspects of the credibility of the findings of research.
Collis and Hussey (2009) refer to reliability as the absence of differences in the
results if the research were to be repeated. Under an interpretive paradigm, reliability
is often of little importance or can be interpreted in a different way. For these studies,
emphasis is placed on establishing protocols and procedures to establish the
authenticity of the findings.
Collis and Hussey (2009) define validity as the extent to which the research findings
accurately reflect the phenomena under study. In an interpretive study such as this
one, the researcher focuses on capturing the essence of the phenomena and
extracting data that provide rich, detailed explanations. The researchers’ aim is to
gain full access to the knowledge and meaning of those involved in the phenomenon
and interpretive studies consequently yield a high validity.
Crouch and McKenzie (2006) state that in a qualitative framework, research based
on interviews seeks to penetrate social life beyond appearance and manifest
meanings. This requires the researcher to be immersed in the research fields, to
establish fruitful relationships with respondents, and through theoretical
contemplation to address the research problem in depth. Therefore a small number
of cases will facilitate the researchers close association with the respondents and
enhance the validity of in-depth inquiry in naturalistic settings.
3.7 COMPILING THE NARRATIVE
There are many ways to analyse qualitative data. These methods include either the
use a thematic, descriptive approach or more in-depth methods. For this study, the
researcher conducted a thematic analysis.
As described by Brikci and Green (2007), a thematic analysis is one that looks
across all the data to identify the common issues that recur, and identify the main
themes that summarise all the views that have been collected. Brikci and Green
(2007) identified the following four (4) key stages in a thematic analysis:
1. Read and annotate transcripts: This is the most basic stage where the
researcher makes preliminary observations on each of the interviews
conducted.
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ___________________________________________________________________
35
2. Identify themes: The next step is to look at the data in detail in order to start
identifying themes and create summaries of what the answers are about.
3. Developing a coding scheme: The initial themes can then be gathered
together to begin to develop a coding scheme. A coding scheme is a list of all
the themes and codes that the researcher then applies to the data.
4. Coding the data: The codes are then applied to the whole set of data. The
patterns and relationships found under the themes will then provide the basis
of the report.
As the researcher will be using a mixed modal approach to data collection, the data
from the closed questions will be captured in an Excel computer software
programme and analysed using the Statistica computer software programme.
3.8 SUMMARY OF CHAPTER
In this chapter the researcher identified two main research paradigms, positivism and
interpretivism, and stated that the study will use a mixed modal approach. Based on
this, the researcher selected an analytical survey as a methodology of choice and
outlined that primary research data will be collected by means of semi-structured
telephonic interviews. A questionnaire will be used as an interview sheet and its
advantages, disadvantages, correct design and guidelines on conducting an
interview was discussed. Techniques used to design the questions were outlined as
open questions and closed questions.
The population for the study was identified as comprising all social service NPOs in
the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan area, which were selected through a maximum
variation sample.
Aspects relating to reliability and validity were discussed as well as the analyses of
qualitative data.
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
36
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS
___________________________________________________________________
4.1 INTRODUCTION
A sample of 30 respective organisations was selected and contacted for an
interview; however, only a total of 14 interviews were conducted, yielding a response
rate of 46.6%. The researcher experienced numerous difficulties in finding
respondents that were willing to talk about this topic and/or have the time to
participate in an interview. Among others, respondents respectfully declined to
participate, set up times for interviews but then were unavailable, or were
unavailable and did not respond to the telephone messages left.
The low response rate compromises the outcomes to a certain extent in that the
conclusion may not be as valid as the researcher hoped it to be. However, the
findings proved to be consistent among the interviews conducted and for this reason
the researcher believes the findings to be reliable.
Based on the research conducted, this chapter aims to address the fourth sub-
question:
a. Can problems in strategy formulation and implementation in NPOs be
identified?
This chapter will:
provide the biographical details of the study respondents; and
outline the empirical results.
4.2 BIOGRAPHICAL DETAILS RELATED TO THE SAMPLE
The researcher wanted to establish if the following five biographical details of the
organisation and its management would have an impact on strategy formulation and
implementation:
1. The gender of the manager
2. The age of the manager
3. The education level of the manager
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
37
4. The number of years the manager has been working for the organisation
5. The size of the organisation
5. The sector the organisation services
This section of the study will thus outline the biographical details as indicated by the
respondents of the study.
Chart 4.1 below illustrates the gender ratio of the interviewees. A total of five males
and nine females participated in the study.
Chart 4.1: Gender
Respondents were asked to state their age in relation to an age group, which is
illustrated in Chart 4.2. Five age groups were listed: Zero participants were younger
than 20 years; participants were between 31 and 40; five participants were between
the ages of 41 and 50; four participants were between 51 and 60; and only two
participants stated that they were older than 60.
36%
64%
Male
Female
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
38
Chart 4.2: Age
Respondents were asked to state their level of education. Most (43%) of the
respondents had a degree; 29% had a post graduate qualification, one of which was
a masters; and 28% only had a matric certificate.
Chart 4.3: Education level of Manager
The respondents were asked to indicate how many years they have been working for
their respective organisations. Five categories were listed and their responses were
as follows: Six managers were employed by the organisation for 0 to 4 years; four
managers were working for 5 to 9 years; three respondents stated they were with the
organisation for 10 to 14 years; zero managers were employed for 15 to 19 years;
and only one manager was with his/her organisation for more than 20 years.
0%
21%
36%
29%
14% Age
21 to 30
31 to 40
41 to 50
51 to 60
60 plus
28%
43%
29%Matric
Graduate
Post Graduate
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
39
Chart 4.4: Manager Tenure
Managers were asked to indicate the number of years the organisation has been in
existence. Five categories were listed and they responded as follows: Five
organisations have been in operation for 0 to 4 years; one organisation has been in
operation for 5 to 9 years; three organisations have been operating for 10 to 14
years; zero organisations have been operating for 15 to 19 years; and 5
organisations have been in operation for more than 20 years. Please see Chart 4.5
below for graphical illustration.
Chart 4.5: Years in operation
The researcher wanted to establish the size of the organisation, therefore
respondents were asked to indicate how many staff are currently working for the
respective organisations, both on a paid as well as voluntary basis. The responses
were as follows and are depicted in Chart 1.6 below: Zero organisations had a staff
43%
29%
21%
0%
7%
0 to 4
5 to 9
10 to 14
15 to 19
20+
36%
7%21%0%
36%
0 to 4
5 to 9
10 to 14
15 to 19
20+
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
40
count of less than 4 employees; four organisations had 5 to 9 staff members; three
organisations had 10 to 14 staff members; and one organisation had 15 to 19 staff
members.
Chart 4.6: Organisation size
The interviewees were asked to identify which sector the organisation serves. It was
found that the majority (69%) of the organisations focused on more than one sector,
indicated by the “combination” section in Chart 4.7 below. These nine organisations
service the abled bodied child and youth sector, abled bodied child, youth and family
sector, or child and youth sector including those that are disabled. One organisation
focused solely on children services and four focused solely on disability services.
Chart 4.7: Social sector
0%
29%
21%
7%
43%
0 to 4
5 to 9
10 to 14
15 to 19
20+
7%
0% 0%
29%
64%
Child
Youth
Family
Disability
Combination
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
41
4.3 EMPIRICAL RESULTS:
This section of the report will discuss the questionnaire that was used as a guide to
conduct the interviews and provide feedback on the interviews conducted.
Section A of the questionnaire aimed to test whether the organisations had the
fundamental strategic elements in place in order to discuss strategy implementation
and execution within their respective organisation. Statements were posed to the
managers and they were required to respond with a Yes, to indicate that this is true
for the organisation, or No to indicate that it is not true for the organisation.
These responses are descriptively and graphically illustrated in the section below.
Statement 1 required the respondents to state whether the organisation has a
strategic vision. All (100%) of the respondents answered ‘yes’, thereby stating that
the organisation has a strategic vision. This is a very positive response.
Chart 4.8: Statement 1 - The organisation has a strategic vision
However, when asked if the vision provides an overview of where the business is
going, and if the vision communicates the management’s goals, only nine
respondents stated ‘yes’, and a total of five respondents stated ‘no’, the vision does
not provide an overview of where the business is going, and ‘no’ the vision does not
communicate management’s goals.
100%
0%Yes
No
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
42
Chart 4.9: Statement 2 - The
organisation’s vision provides a
broad overview of where the
business is going
Chart 4.10: Statement 3 - The
organisation’s vision communicates
management’s goals
When the interviewees were asked to respond to the statements ‘The organisation’s
vision is continuously and effectively communicated down the hierarchy to all levels
of staff’, majority (86%) stated ‘yes’, and only two (14%) stated ‘no’, it does not get
communicated effectively to all levels of staff.
Chart 4.11: Statement 5 - The organisation’s vision is continuously and
effectively communicated down the hierarchy to all levels of staff
All (100%) managers stated that their organisation has a mission statement. This
statement yielded a very positive response.
64%
36%
Yes
No64%
36%
Yes
No
86%
14%
Yes
No
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
44
Chart 4.12: Statement 6 - The organisation has a mission statement
When the respondents were asked if they have set out organisational objectives,
three (21%) of the managers said ‘no’, they have no set out objectives; however, the
majority (79%) stated that they have.
Chart 4.13: Statement 10 - Management has set out organisational objectives
When asked if the objectives convert the vision into specific performance targets, ten
respondents stated ‘yes’, however, four respondents stated ‘no’, the objectives do
not convert the vision into specific performance targets. This means that in addition
100%
0%
Yes
No
79%
21%
Yes
No
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
45
to the three organisations that do not have set organisational objectives, as depicted
in Chart 4.13, an additional organisation’s objectives are not effectively set.
Chart 4.14: Statement 11 - The organisational objectives convert the strategic
vision into specific performance targets
Respondents were asked to state if performance targets are set for each of the
organisation’s services. Nine of the respondents stated that this is true for their
organisations, whereas five respondents stated that ‘no’, performance targets are not
set for each of the organisation’s objectives.
Chart 4.15: Statement 12 - Performance targets are set for each of the
organisation’s services
71%
29%
Yes
No
64%
36% Yes
No
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
46
When asked if the organisational objectives consist of both financial and strategic
objectives, six respondents stated ‘no’. This means that 43% of the managers did not
set both financial and strategic objectives for the organisation. See Chart 4.16 below.
Chart 4.16: Statement 13 - The organisational objectives consist of financial
and strategic objectives
Respondents were asked if the organisational objectives are measurable and nine of
the respondents stated ‘yes’ they were, but five of the respondents (36%) stated ‘no’,
their organisational objectives were not measurable.
Chart 4.17: Statement 14 - The organisational objectives are measurable
Similar to the previous statement, when the respondents were asked if their
organisational objectives have a deadline for achievement, only nine of the
57%
43% Yes
No
64%
36% Yes
No
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
47
respondents stated ‘yes’ they have, and five of the respondents stated ‘no’, their
objectives do not have a deadline for achievement. See Chart 4.18 below.
Chart 4.18: Statement 15 - The organisation objectives contains a deadline for
achievement
Of the 14 interviewees, only nine managers stated that their organisational
objectives contain both short- and long-term performance targets and the remaining
five managers (36%) did not set both short- and long-term performance targets for
the organisation.
Chart 4.19: Statement 16 - The objectives contain both long-term and short-
term performance targets
Respondents were asked if long-term objectives take precedence when trade-offs
have to be made between long-term and short-term objectives. Four respondents
stated ‘yes’, and ten of the respondents (79%) stated ‘no’, long run objectives do not
64%
36%Yes
No
64%
36% YesNo
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
48
take precedence. This is graphically depicted below and further discussed in Chapter
Five.
Chart 4.20: Statement 17 - When trade-offs have to be made between achieving
long-term and short-term objectives, long-term objectives take precedence
Section B of the questionnaire posed nine open-ended questions to managers to
gain insight into their strategic planning. This section will outline the questions posed
to the managers and a summary of their responses. After each quote, the researcher
indicated the respondent by means of R, followed by his/her interview number as
well as the organisation size by means of OS, and followed by the size category.
Does the organisation have a strategic plan?
Most respondents stated that their respective organisations have a strategic plan.
However, upon further questioning, the researcher discovered that all of these
respondents were referring to their annual year planner and or annual budget.
One respondent answered the following: “Not really, our NPO was designed and
operates on a meeting needs as they arise bases”. This respondent also answered
‘no’ to the organisation having objectives that are measurable and time bound (R8;
OS 10 to 14).
29%
71%
Yes
No
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
49
In contrast to this, one respondent stated ‘yes’, “I believe that a NPO have to be run
like a business, the days where NPOs stand with their hands out are something of
the past. People want a return for their money” (R 2; OS 20+).
Two respondents stated that their organisation had a strategic plan that outlined their
scope of business, their strategic areas, and their short-term and long-term goals
and objectives.
What factors were considered whilst crafting the strategy?
The overarching theme found with this question was that the managers run the
organisation purely based on the community need. None of the organisations
conducted a SWOT analysis; none of the managers stated that they look what other
organisations are doing; and none of the responses included plans for the future.
Only one respondent stated that “We do a feasibility study; we look at our services
individually to measure how feasible they are, what are the challenges, the tailwinds
and headwinds, and measure our core business services and strategy to draw up
long-term requirements” (R 2; OS 20+).
Another respondent said that in addition to community need, “we look at our own
ability to render services in the market” (R 1; OS 20+).
Who was involved in crafting the strategy?
Out of the 14 interviews conducted, none of the managers included any of the staff in
crafting the strategy at their respective organisations. All responses included “The
Board of Directors”, “The Executive Committee”, and/or “Management” or
“Leadership Team”. Based on the literature in Chapter Two, this is indicative of a
CEO-centred approach to strategy creation and is commonly found in small
businesses, or in this case, organisations.
However, a promising response to this question was the following: “It is drawn up by
the manager and head of care. The home has – two committees - board of
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
50
management/directors and the finance committee. I do a presentation to the board
every month and they give the final approval as well as their inputs. One of the main
things, we have about 50 residence, they have a residence committee elected by the
residence, and they give input from ground level. Also, the chairman of the residence
committee sits on the board to give feedback. They have a constitution to guide their
work – it gives them dignity and empowerment (R 2; OS 20+).
How often does the strategy get evaluated or revised? And, what factors are
considered when revising the strategy?
The majority of the managers stated that their strategic plan gets revised annually
with only one respondent stating that their organisation looks at this plan every six
months.
General factors of consideration were found to be:
turnover of staff;
turnover of residence;
availability of resources;
external and internal factors influencing the success of achieving our goals
and objectives; and
needs of the beneficiaries – has it changed or is it still the same.
The respondent that stated that their strategy gets reviewed every six months stated
that in addition to the factors above, the organisation aims to “keep our strategy
realistic and achievable whilst been stretched and keeping up with market trends”.
When asked what market trends she was referring to, she stated “the fees charged
at other homes and the offerings they have for their residence” (R 1; OS 20+).
Excluding the above, one respondent stated that his organisation conducts a
feasibility study on an annual basis – “we draw separate areas of what needs to be
done – needs list, strategise where we going to get the money from, I make a list of
care needs and break it down in each division of the home. And then I measure it
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
51
regularly, and write reports every month – we measure what we have done and how
we are doing in that strategy area” (R 2; OS 20+).
How do you communicate the strategy to staff? How do you measure if this is
effective?
When asked the question ‘how do you communicate you strategy to staff’, one
respondent stated “We live that. By working with the kids you realise this is the
mission. It’s a calling, a God calling, it’s a ministry. You don’t need to remind them.
They just do it. It’s part of their jobs” (R 6; OS 10 to 14).
The remaining 13 respondents stated that their strategy is communicated during
meetings and one respondent added that it is displayed on their notice boards as
well (R 9; OS 20+).
When asked the question ‘how do you measure if the communication plan is
effective’, one respondent stated: “we measure by the home itself, if the residents’
needs are being met, we look at the incredibly long waiting list – that is an indication
that we are doing something right. We have staff that has been here for 40 years,
there is a very small staff turnover and this is an indication that staff is happy. We
also have “Friends at Cheshire” – this is a group of young professionals that meet
every months to discuss how they can help; they also have a monthly braai for the
residence. We have measurable measuring tools in place” (R 2; OS 20+).
Another respondent stated that “It hasn’t been effective as this was an area
highlighted within our performance appraisal process under our management
feedback reviews” R 4; OS 20+).
What factors do you take into consideration when making decisions for/about
the organisation?
General factors that are considered by managers when they make decisions are:
Is it in line with the vision?
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
52
Will it benefit the beneficiaries?
Is it needed?
Does it fit in with the mission statement?
Do we have the finance?
Do we have the infrastructure?
One respondent stated that “needs can be very overwhelming” so it is important to
make decisions carefully (R 7; OS 20+).
When discussing the factors to take into consideration when making decisions
for/about the organisation, one respondent (R 2; OS 20+) stated the following:
“I believe very strongly that a service organisation needs to be run like a business,
we look at what is our business and what can we do to sell our business. We
established that we have the experience to run a school, so we started one in
Walmer Township; then we asked ourselves “what else can we do”? We currently
have several offerings; we have resident that do wheelchair repairs; we loan out
assistive devices; we have two charity shops onsite where we sell various donated
items that cannot be used in the home to generate funds. This is so that there are
accountable governance for people’s donations. Also, we found that events are
becoming more important and people are happy to pay for that, so we started
serving lunch on Sunday every month where families can come eat together for a
small costs. All these offerings we believe provide a value for money. It is important
to sell yourself and services”.
Do you consider the strategy to be effective?
Overall the respondents believed their respective strategies to be effective. Some
responses are quoted below:
“Yes, it gives a plan and direction to work towards, it give everyone boundaries” (R 9;
20+).
“Yes I do but it is important to remember it is a never ending process and one have
to stay pro-active” (R 2; OS 20+).
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
53
“I think it is effective, not perfect but effective. We contribute this to our strong
executive committee and strong management team” (R 2; OS 20+).
“I do believe that our strategy to date has been effective. The company as a whole
has grown substantially in 2014. Our strategy in 2015 will be to sustain this growth
whilst focusing on diversification in the disability sector. This is achieved by the
strong management staff in our academies” (R 4; OS 20+).
If given the resources, what would you do differently?
General findings from the responses to this question were:
Staff that are higher skilled
Increased staff count
Expand the organisation
Expand service offerings
One respondent stated that if not for financial restraints, she would increase staff
salaries to ensure that all packages were market related and inclusive of benefits like
medical aid because “they deserve it” (R 4; OS 20+).
The following response provide insight into why some managers are not thinking
strategically “…employ more people to get more done and have the decision makers
be able to make their decisions without the day to day stress of worrying about
funding, donations, fundraising and putting out fires to get things done ASAP” (R 8;
OS 10 to 14).
In contrast to this, another respondent stated that he would like to expand their
scope of service: “We are trying to raise money to expand the home, I like the idea of
independent living so self-responsibility is an area we looking at. We would like to
build more fully accessible units where individuals or families could stay in and
function completely independently. We would also lift the financial burden on the
families of our residents. With the little support we get from government, the families
of the residents needs to contribute towards the costs of their living in the home. And
we definitely want to continue making this a happy home” (R 2; OS 20+).
CHAPTER FOUR: EMPIRICAL RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________
54
4.3 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER
This chapter has graphically illustrated the biographical details of the respondents in
this study as well as the responses to the closed questions of the study. In addition
to this, the chapter listed the questions asked during the interview process and
provided, by means of summation as well as direct quotes, responses to these
questions.
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
55
CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
___________________________________________________________________
5.1 INTRODUCTION
The previous chapter reported on the direct responses given by the managers during
the interview process of this study. Therein, it highlighted the challenges faced by the
researcher in contacting suitable respondents for the study. However, this chapter
will deduct findings from the responses received in an attempt to address the fifth
and final secondary research question:
a. Can recommendations be made for improving strategy formulation and
implementation in NPOs?
Based on the results reported on in Chapter Four, this chapter will:
outline the findings made from the interviews conducted;
propose recommendations to improve strategy in NPOs in the NMM;
outline the limitations of the study; and
provide suggestions for future research.
5.2 FINDINGS:
The findings are broken up into three different sections. The first section discusses
the biographical factors that influence strategy formulation and implementation; the
second section continues to discuss factors related to strategic planning found to be
hindering strategy execution in NPOs; and the third section presents important
findings that contribute towards successful strategy formulation and implementation.
5.2.1 Biographical factors:
This section of the chapter will discuss the findings related to strategic planning.
Service organisations are largely a female dominated industry so the gender
distribution of 64% females versus 36% males did not yield surprising results.
The response that the majority of the managers were between the ages of 41 to 50,
and that 72% of these managers had at least a degree as a formal qualification, lead
the researcher to conclude that most of the managers have a specialised skill set
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
56
and a fair amount of work experience behind them. This leads the researcher to
believe that the managers of the respective organisations are equipped to be in the
position that they fill, and that they have the cognitive ability to engage in strategic
planning.
There was an equal dispersion between start-up organisations operating between 0
to 4 years and long standing organisations operating over 20 years. The researcher
therefore believes that this is not an influencing factor in strategy formulation and
implementation.
An interesting finding related to the sector the organisation services was that
organisations providing services to the disabled only focused on that specific market,
whereas the majority of the other organisations service a combination of children,
youth and family services. This factor influences strategy creation in that disability
organisations can create a very specific strategy for their specific market, whereas
the other organisations have to cater to various groups of people and in so doing
complicate their strategic planning process.
The above section provided a vague insight into the respondents and their
respective organisations; however, the researcher did not find the biographical
details of the sample of respondents to have a significant impact on strategy
formulation and implementation in NPOs in the NMM.
5.2.2 Factors relating to strategic planning:
This section of the chapter will discuss the findings related to strategic planning.
These findings will be discussed according to the phase it follows in the ‘strategy–
making and strategy executing process’ discussed in Chapter Two.
Phase 1: Developing a strategic vision
The researcher found that all the organisations have a strategic vision; however,
36% of these respective visions do not provide an overview of where the business is
going; nor do they communicate managements’ goals. This leads to the conclusion
that the staff in these organisations are not all clear on what management wants the
business to look like in the future, and how they plan to grow the business.
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
57
More importantly, with an unclear or non-strategic vision, managers do not have a
reference point when making decisions for and/or about the organisation. This leads
to managers making decisions that are not in the best interest of the organisation
and its staff in the long run. This finding is substantiated with the response of 71% of
the managers stating that when they need to make trade-offs between long run and
short run objectives, short run objectives take precedence.
Another finding in relation to the organisations’ strategic vision is that no structured
communication plan was, or is being devised to communicate managements’ vision
and goals. For this reason there is no means to measure if the strategic vision is
being communicated effectively and if staff understand the plan. This could lead to a
misalignment between management and staff.
Phase 2: Setting objectives
What was evident during discussions with the respondents in the interview phase
was that overall, strategic planning is being confused with operations planning. With
the exception of two respondents, all the managers referred to their annual
operations plans as their strategy. The researcher found this to be the most
important finding of this study as this misconception could stymie the growth of the
organisation.
This lack of knowledge and insight regarding strategic thinking could be attributed to
the problems found with the organisational objectives. These include, but are not
limited to, the objectives not being directly related to the vision; performance targets
not being set; organisational objectives not consisting of financial and strategic
objectives; and objectives not being measurable, time-bound, or containing long- and
short-term targets.
Phase 3: Crafting a strategy to achieve the objectives and vision
The researcher found that none of the managers performed a SWOT analysis on
their organisation; therefore, the managers did not create a strategy that builds on
organisational strengths and takes advantage of opportunities, or one that aims to
overcome or minimize organisational weaknesses and threats. This is also a result of
not thinking strategically whilst planning and could be a major factor when sourcing
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
58
funding for operations. NPOs need to state their case as to why they should be the
organisation of choice to receive much sought after funding. If they cannot provide
substantial reasons as to why their respective organisations operate more efficiently
than the next, by default they decrease their chances of receiving sponsorship.
Another finding during this phase of the study was that none of the management
teams included staff in crafting their strategy. This is not uncommon for small
organisations like these, however, if this is the case, organisations should have an
effective communication plan in place to communicate their organisational strategy,
including their goals and objectives, which none of the respondents stated they have.
Phase 4: Implementing and executing the strategy
It was found that by not involving staff in the strategic planning process or
communicating the strategy effectively, management is restrained by having to make
all the operational decisions. This point was clearly demonstrated by the following
response from one of the managers: “…employ more people to get more done and
have the decision makers be able to make their decisions without the day to day
stress of worrying about funding, donations, fundraising and putting out fires to get
things done ASAP”.
When asked what they would do differently if given the resources, all the managers
stated that they would employ more and higher skilled staff. It is evident that these
organisations do not have the essential skills needed to aid in organisational growth.
Staffing the organisation with the appropriate skills is essential to build competencies
and competitive capabilities.
Phase 5: Monitoring developments, evaluating performance, and making corrective
adjustments
Because the majority of the respondents reported on operations planning, all the
organisations’ goals and objectives are set for short run operational performance –
this being their annual planning. If organisations want to achieve long-term
sustainability and grow or expand in the current market, they will need to evaluate
their current position and make adjustments accordingly. In the section for
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
59
recommendations later in this chapter, the researcher will propose a framework to
increase strategic thinking in managers of NPOs.
In conclusion, all of these factors could be attributed to the failure of management to
think and plan on a strategic level. If the strategic vision is well structured, as per the
guidelines identified by Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011) in Chapter
Two, and the objectives and strategic plan are set accordingly and based on the
vision, and a SWOT analysis is performed, the managers will be able to include, and
budget for, the additional costs of employing higher skilled staff and/or the expansion
of its services.
5.2.3 Strategic factors contributing to success in NPOs:
A very important finding discovered by the researcher during the interview process
was that strategic partnerships with private organisations can have a tremendous
impact on the success, the services, and the quality of services offered at NPOs.
Partnering with institutions like universities or colleges could lead to individuals with
essential skills donating their time to the organisation to broaden the organisations’
service offerings or increase the quality of its service offerings. Furthermore,
partnering with networks like The Business Woman’s Association or the Business
Network International could increase the organisations’ success in sourcing new
opportunities for funding and/or improving the standing as an organisation.
5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS:
The researcher proposes the following framework for managers to think strategically
when doing planning:
Step 1: Ask the question “Where do we want to be?”
Do not limit your thinking to what is possible with your current resources; expand
your view. A vision is a grammatical image of where you see the organisation in the
future and it should be specific and future orientated. Write down clear, measurable
goals to achieve this end state and attach specific time frames for its achievement.
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
60
Step 2: Ask the question “How can we get there?”
This is a crucial part in strategic planning. Here you need to challenge yourself to
think beyond the daily operations. Ask questions like:
What are the strategic things I can do to achieve my vision?
Who is fundamental in achieving the organisational goals? What can I do to
get them on board?
Who else could be beneficial to achieving the organisation’s goals? External
organisations and/or institutions?
What are the organisational strengths? How can I use it to gain an
advantage?
Step 3: Ask the question “What must I do to get there?”
This is where you start focusing on operations. Break the goals up into strategic
areas of focus. Set operational objectives and tasks for each of these areas and set
time frames to achieve them. Create task lists and assign responsibilities. Improve
your leadership and managerial skills if necessary. It is important to formally
document this operations plan.
Also important for NPO managers is to ask the following question: “What mustn’t I do
if I want to get there?” This will assist in making decisions that will benefit the
organisation and its staff in the long run.
Step 4: Continuously ask “How are we doing?”
Use structured processes and procedures to hold individuals accountable for their
responsibilities. Set periodic sessions to check whether the game plan is still
effective in achieving the organisational goal. Take note of what is working and what
is not. Check in with other organisations to see how and/or what they are doing.
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
61
Step 5: Ask the question “What changes need to be made?”
Once your plan is in motion, continue to monitor if it is the right course of action and,
very importantly, is your plan growing the business or simply sustaining it - strategic
planning aims to grow the organisation. Based on these assessments, loop back to
Step 2 and revise your plan accordingly. Figure 5.1 below graphically illustrates this
framework.
Figure 5.1: Improvement planning process Source: Adapted from Donovan (2013). It is of the utmost importance that when engaging in successful strategic planning, all
plans need to be documented, specific, measurable, and have a deadline for
achievement.
5.4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
Two very important limitations are discussed here:
1. There were differences in the level of understanding of strategic planning
among the managers at NPOs during the time the study was conducted. This
means that some respondents referred to their operations planning as
strategic planning which skewed the accuracy of their responses to Section A
and Section B of the questionnaire.
2. There is no benchmark against which to measure the success of an NPO.
NPOs differ in many aspects and the size of the organisation plays a big
factor in this. Bigger organisations are generally operated differently to smaller
Where do we
want to be?
What
strategies?
What action
plans do we
need?
How are we
doing?
What changes
need to be
made?
RESULTS
METRICS
GOALS PERFORMANCE
METRICS
OPERATIONAL
PLAN
STRATEGIC
PLAN
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
62
organisations which is evident from the findings in this study, and therefore
there will be differences in their perceptions of success. One organisation
aims to sustain operations and considers themselves successful if this is
achieved, whereas another organisation aims to expand their scope and
services and therefore consider themselves as successful if this is achieved.
Both these organisations are successful in their own right, but these are two
vastly different levels of success.
5.5 FUTURE RESEARCH
The researcher suggests that a qualitative study be conducted to evaluate the level
of understanding of strategic planning in NPO management. In so doing, the
accurateness of the fundamental elements of a strategy may be investigated (i.e. the
strategic vision, the mission statement, and the goals and objectives) in order to
evaluate if these are effectively written to guide the functioning of the organisation.
5.6 SUMMARY OF THE CHAPTER
This is the fifth and final chapter of this report which discussed the findings (which
are divided into three sections) made during the interview process. The first section
of the findings related to the biographical details of the respondents and their
respective organisations; the second section discussed factors related to strategic
planning; and the third section discussed factors that improve the success of
strategy formulation and implementation in NPOs.
This chapter also made recommendations to improve strategy in NPOs in the NMM
and also outlined the limitations of the study and provided suggestions for future
research.
CONCLUSION
A strategic plan for an NPO does not have to be a complex document. Staff and
management of NPOs are passionate and eager to do the work of the organisation
and should not be restricted with strict strategic processes and procedures that are
difficult to understand and make operational. However, to remain viable, a strategic
plan needs to be in place to ensure the sustainability of the organisation. For this
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSIONS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ___________________________________________________________________
63
reason, the researcher deemed it suitable to use the five phase strategy creation
execution process as found in Hough, Thompson, Strickland and Gamble (2011).
It was highlighted in this study that if strategic planning is effectively conducted by
NPOs, managers can increase the likelihood of entering into corporate social
responsibility partnerships with businesses as well as various other strategic
partnerships as was substantiated with the discussion and findings with one of the
respondents.
The low response rate of the study comprised the findings and it is therefore not as
accurate and in-depth as the researcher had hoped it to be. Nevertheless the
researcher deems the findings listed in this report to be true for the majority of NPOs
and hopes that the recommendations made will have a positive impact on the
sustainability of these organisations.
1
LIST OF REFERENCES
Abraham, S. 2005. Stretching strategic thinking. Strategy & Leadership, 33(5), 5-12.
Aliyeva, F. 2012. 50 models for strategic thinking or how to start thinking strategically
on a daily basis. [Online]
Available from: <http://www.intelligenthq.com/resources/50-models-for-
strategic-thinking-or-how-to-start-think-strategically-on-a-daily-basis>
[Accessed on 16 October 2014].
Berg, M. 2013. The importance of Non-Profit in our economy. [Online] Available
from: <http://www.borgenproject.org> [Accessed the 14 October 2014].
Brikci, N. & Green, J. 2007. A guide to using qualitative research methodology.
[Online] Available from:
http://fieldresearch.msf.org/msf/bitstream/10144/84230/1/Qualitative%20resear
ch%20methodology.pdf [Accessed the 12 June 2014].
Bryson, J.M. A Strategic Planning Process for Public and Non-Profit Organizations.
Long Range Planning, Vol. 21, No. 1. Pp 73 – 81. [Online]. Available from: <
http://docushare.usc.edu/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-8775/> [Accesses
the 23 November 2014].
Crouch, M. & McKenzie H. 2006. The logic of small samples in interview-based
qualitative research. Social Science Information, 45(4), 483-499. [Online]
Available from:
<http://ssi.sagepub.com/content/45/4/483.short?rss=1&ssource=mfr>
[Accessed on: 3 November 2014].
Collis, J. & Hussey, R. 2009. Business Research: A practical guide for
undergraduate & postgraduate students. 3rd ed. Palgrave MacMillan.
Department of Social Development. 2013. State of South African registered non-
profit organisations 2012-2013. [Online] Available from: <http://www.gov.co.za>
[Accessed 4 September 2014].
2
Donovan, R.M. 2013. Connecting business strategy and operations. R. Michael
Donovan & Co., Inc.
Gopinath, C. & Siciliano, J. 2013. Strategize! Experiential exercises in strategic
management. Cengage Learning.
Hough, J., Thompson, A.A., Strickland, A.J. & Gamble, J.E., 2011. Crafting and
executing strategy. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Hume, C. & Hume, M. 2008. The strategic role of knowledge management in non-
profit organisations. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector
Marketing. [e-journal] 13, pp.129-140. [Online] Available through: Nelson
Mandela Metropolitan University Library website <http://nmmu.ac.za/library>
Kaplan, R.S. & Norton, D.P. 2008. The execution premium: Linking strategy to
operations for competitive advantage. [e-book] Boston: Harvard Business
School Publishing. Available from: <http://books.google.co.za/books>
[Accessed 12 May 2014].
Porter, M.E. & Kramer, M.R. 2006. Strategy and Society: The link between
competitive advantage and corporate social responsibility. Harvard Business
Review.
Thompson, A.A., Strickland, A.J. & Gamble, J.E. 2005. Crafting and Executing
Strategy: The Quest for Competitive Advantage. 14th ed. New York: McGraw-
Hill.
The South African Department of Social Development, 2012.The National register of
Non-Profit Organisations (2011-2012). [Online]. Available from:
<http://www.dsd.gov.za> [Accessed 23 June 2014]
Van Buren, J.A. 2010. Strategic Planning in Non-profit Organisation – a Brief
Overview. Noonmark Non-profit Services. [Online]. Available from: <
http://www.uvm.edu/extension/community/buildingcapacity/pdfs/strategic_plan
ning_nonprofit_org.pdf> [Accessed 23 June 2014]
3
Waechter, S. 2011. Driving Strategic Planning: A Non-profit Executive’s Guide.
[Online]. Available from: < http://www.event360.com/blog/why-nonprofit-
strategic-planning-is-important/> [Accessed 25 June 2014].
Wilson, J. 2010. Essentials of business research: A guide to doing your research
project. London: Sage.
1
LIST OF ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A: Research Questionnaire Covering Letter
Dear Respondent
I am studying towards my MBA (Masters in Business Administration) degree at the Nelson
Mandela Metropolitan University Business School. I am conducting research on factors
influencing the successful formulation and implementation of strategy in Non-profit
Organisations (NPOs) in the Nelson Mandela Metropole. I believe that my study will make
an important contribution to the success of NPOs and the development of communities.
You are part of our selected sample of respondents whose views I seek on the above-
mentioned matter. I would therefore appreciate it if you could answer a few questions. It
should not take more than thirty minutes of your time and we want to thank you in advance
for your co-operation.
There are no correct or incorrect answers. Please answer the questions as accurately as
possible. For each statement, tick yes or no. Please tick only one answer for each
statement and answer all questions. Please note that there are also questions that
require you to write down your views on certain aspects of strategy within your organisation.
We guarantee your complete confidentiality and anonymity.
Please also note that your participation in this study is entirely voluntary and that
you have the right to withdraw from the study at any stage. Your participation in the
study therefore indicates verbal consent.
Thank you very much,
Lauren Butler
To verify the authenticity of the study, please contact Prof JJ Pieterse at 041-5043774 and
1
ANNEXURE B: MEASURING INSTRUMENTS
SECTION A: Please respond to each statement by marking the appropriate response with
an X.
No. Statement
1 The organisation has a strategic vision
Yes No
2 The organisation’s vision provides a broad overview of where the business is going
Yes No
3 The organisation’s vision communicates management’s goals
Yes No
4 The organisation’s vision directs the energy of the staff in one direction
Yes No
5 The organisation’s vision is continuously and effectively communicated down the hierarchy to all
levels of staff
Yes No
6 The organisation has a mission statement
Yes No
7 The organisation’s mission statement outlines the organisation’s present business
Yes No
8 The organisation’s mission statement describes “who we are, what we do, and why we are here”
Yes No
9 The organisation has a statement of values to guide members’ way of work
Yes No
10 Management has set out organisational objectives
Yes No
11 The organisational objectives convert the strategic vision into specific performance targets
Yes No
12 Performance targets are set for each of the organisation’s services
Yes No
13 The organisational objectives consists of financial and strategic objectives
Yes No
14 The organisational objectives are measurable
Yes No
15 The organisation’s objectives contain a deadline for achievement
Yes No
16 The objectives contain both long-term and short-term performance targets
Yes No
17 When trade-offs have to be made between achieving long-term and short-term objectives, long-
term objectives take precedence
Yes No
2
SECTION B
1 Does the organisation have a strategic plan?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
2 What factors were considered whilst crafting the organisational strategy? (Was a SWOT analysis
conducted?)
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
3 Who was involved in crafting the strategy?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
4 How often does the strategy get evaluated and revised? What factors are considered when revising the
strategy?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
5 How do you communicate the strategy to staff?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………….………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
3
6 How do you measure if this communication plan is effective?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
7 What factors do you take into consideration when making decisions for/about the organisation?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
8 Do you consider the organisation’s strategy to be effective? If so, what contributes towards its success? If
not, what hinders its success?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….….…………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………
9 If given the resources, what would you do differently?
Answer:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….….…………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………
Additional comments/questions:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
4
……………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….….…………
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
SECTION C: BIOGRAPHICAL DATA
Please make a cross (X) or enter the relevant information in the blocks provided.
GENDER: Male Female
AGE GROUP: 20 – 29 30 – 39 40 – 49 50 – 59 60+
Please indicate your highest educational qualification:
How long have you been working for the organisation?
0-4 5 – 9 10 – 14 15 – 19 20 +
How many years has the organisation been in existence?
0-4 5 – 9 10 – 14 15 – 19 20 +
How many staff members are working for the organisation (paid and/or voluntary)?
0-4 5 – 9 10 – 14 15 – 19 20 +
What social sector does the organisation serve? (Tick every applicable block)
Children
Services
Youth Services Family Services Disability Services Combination
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR KIND CO-OPERATION!
1
ANNEXURE C: Ethics clearance FORM E
ETHICS CLEARANCE FOR TREATISES/DISSERTATIONS/THESES
Please type or complete in black ink
FACULTY: Business
SCHOOL/DEPARTMENT: NMMU Business School
I, Prof Pieterse, J.J; the supervisor for Mrs Butler, L; 20673657, a candidate for the
degree of Masters Business Administration with a treatise/dissertation/thesis entitled:
“The identification of problems with strategy formulation and implementation in non-
profit organisation in the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan” considered the following
ethics criteria:
YES NO
1. Is there any risk of harm, embarrassment of offence, however slight or temporary, to the participant, third parties or to the communities at large?
x
2. Is the study based on a research population defined as ‘vulnerable’ in terms of age, physical characteristics and/or disease status?
x
2.1 Are subjects/participants/respondents of your study:
(a) Children under the age of 18? x
(b) NMMU staff? x
(c) NMMU students? x
(d) The elderly/persons over the age of 60? x
(e) A sample from an institution (e.g. hospital/school)? x
(f) Handicapped (e.g. mentally or physically)? x
3. Does the data that will be collected require consent of an institutional authority for this study? (An institutional authority refers to an organisation that is established by government to protect vulnerable people)
x
3.1 Are you intending to access participant data from an existing, stored repository (e.g. school, institutional or university records)?
x
2
4. Will the participant’s privacy, anonymity or confidentiality be compromised?
x
4.1 Are you administering a questionnaire/survey that:
(a) Collects sensitive/identifiable data from participants? x
(b) Does not guarantee the anonymity of the participant? x
(c) Does not guarantee the confidentiality of the participant and the data? x
(d) Will offer an incentive to respondents to participate, i.e. a lucky draw or any other prize?
x
(e) Will create doubt whether sample control measures are in place? x
(f) Will be distributed electronically via email (and requesting an email response)? Note:
If your questionnaire DOES NOT request respondents’ identification, is distributed electronically and you request respondents to return it manually (print out and deliver/mail); AND respondent anonymity can be guaranteed, your answer will be NO.
If your questionnaire DOES NOT request respondents’ identification, is distributed via an email link and works through a web response system (e.g. the university survey system); AND respondent anonymity can be guaranteed, your answer will be NO.
x
Please note that if ANY of the questions above have been answered in the affirmative (YES) the student will need to complete the full ethics clearance form (REC-H application) and submit it with the relevant documentation to the Faculty RECH (Ethics) representative.