Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant...

22
©2014 MFMER | slide-1 Stenting for Esophageal Cancer David Fleischer MD- Mayo Clinic Arizona NCI-IARC September 2016

Transcript of Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant...

Page 1: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-1

Stenting for Esophageal Cancer

David Fleischer MD- Mayo Clinic Arizona

NCI-IARC September 2016

Page 2: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-2

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Appeal of stents

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 3: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-3

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Appeal of stents

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 4: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-4

STENT

Charles Stent

Dentist

1807-1885

Page 5: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-5

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Appeal of stents

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 6: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-6

Indications for stenting in patients with EC

• Dysphagia

• Maintain nutritional status

• Improve quality of life

• Management of esophago-tracheal fistulae

• Allow eating while other therapies given

• Future: ? to deliver therapy

Page 7: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-7

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Appeal of stents

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 8: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

PLASTIC

STENTS

FIRST

GENERATION

METAL

STENTS

CURRENT STENTS

Taewoong Endomaxx Bonastent Cook Polyflex

Wallflex Ella

Page 9: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

TECHNICAL MATTERS: How to choose a stent

COVERED vs

NON-COVERED

PLASTIC vs

METAL

STABLE vs BIO-

ABSORBABLE

STANDARD vs

ANTI-REFLUX

Page 10: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-10

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Appeal of stents

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 11: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-11

Page 12: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-12

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Appeal of stents

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 13: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

WHY IS STENT PREFERRED

ENDOSCOPIC METHOD?

S T E N T

CLOSEST TO IDEAL

TREATMENT

SINGLE RX

REQUIRED

EASIEST FOR DOC

CAN BE USED IN

MOST PATIENTS

PATIENT

SATISFACTION

Page 14: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

Is stenting effective for palliation

of malignant dysphagia?

Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I)

Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement in dysphagia score

Tolerate at least liquids

Esophageal fistulae = 70-100% (II)

Superior to Plastic Stents (I)

Uncovered SEMS (I)

Dilation, laser, PDT (III)

Operative (II)

No direct comparisons to other therapies XRT, Chemo, combined Chemo/XRT

SAMJ 1999;89:640.

NEJM 1993;329:1302.

GIE 1996;43:478.

GIE 1998;47:113.

EJGH 1998;10:653.

BJS 2002;89:985.

AJG 2001;96:1791.

Endosc 2005;37:329.

Page 15: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-15

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Results

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 16: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

SEMS Complications (II-III)

Early: 8-16%

Migration

Reflux

Aspiration

Perforation

Pain

Late: 9-18%

Tumor in-growth

Tumor overgrowth

Epithelial

hyperplasia (50%)

Structural decay

Migration

Food impaction

Mayoral W, et al. Gastrointest Endosc 2000;51(5):556.

Raijman I, et al. Am J Gastroenterol 1997;92:2192.

• Increased in distal & EGJ tumors

Page 17: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

SITUATIONS WHEN STENT MAY

NOT BE PREFERRED ENDO RX

IV

ENDO

S T E N T

DILATION, LASER, APC,

PHOTODYNAMIC THERAPY, TUMOR

PROBE, INJECTION

NOT CHOOSE

STENT

*HIGH CERVICAL

LESION

*ASYMMETRIC

*COMPRESS TRACH

COST $1500-1900

Page 18: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-18

Page 19: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-19

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Results

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 20: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-20

CONCLUSIONS

• Stents can be useful for patients with advanced esophageal cancer and dysphagia or fistula

• Main clinical limitations are migration and recurrent dysphagia

• Cost is an important limitation to use of stents in most of the world

Page 21: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-21

OUTLINE

• Origin stenting

• Indications for use in esophageal cancer

• Types of stents

• Stenting for esophageal cancer

• Technique

• Results

• Complications/limitations

• Conclusions

• Important questions

Page 22: Stenting for Esophageal Cancer - IARC · Is stenting effective for palliation of malignant dysphagia? Covered SEMS Technical success = 90-100% (I) Functional success = > 90% (I) Improvement

©2014 MFMER | slide-22

IMPORTANT QUESTIONS

• Could technologic improvements be made to address efficacy and safety of stents?

• Could the cost of stents be reduced?

• Could stents be used to deliver therapy as well as providing palliation?