Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

download Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

of 9

Transcript of Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    1/9

    Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd': The Case for the DefenceAuthor(s): Carey BlytonSource: Tempo, New Series, No. 149 (Jun., 1984), pp. 19-26Published by: Cambridge University PressStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/945080.

    Accessed: 22/05/2014 13:50

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at.http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    .JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of

    content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms

    of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    .

    Cambridge University Pressis collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Tempo.

    http://www.jstor.org

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=cuphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/945080?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/945080?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=cup
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    2/9

    SONDHEIM'S

    'SWEENEY

    TODD'

    The

    Case

    for the

    Defence

    CareyBlyton

    As

    BOTH LYRICIST

    AND

    COMPOSER,

    Stephen

    Sondheim

    has

    proved

    to be the

    most

    original

    and innovative

    force on

    Broadway

    since

    the late

    I950's,

    when

    he

    first

    attracted attention

    as

    the

    lyricist

    for some

    of

    the

    songs

    in Leonard Bernstein's West

    Side

    Story

    (1957),

    including

    'Maria' and

    'Tonight'.

    Few

    composers

    for the

    musical

    stage

    have

    such a record

    of success

    as

    Sondheim.

    In addition to these

    lyrics

    for

    Bernstein,

    he

    also wrote all

    the

    lyrics

    forJule

    Styne's Gypsy

    (1959);

    then,

    as

    composer

    as well as

    lyricist,

    he wrote a number of musicals over the next two decades:A

    Funny

    Thing Happened

    on the

    Way

    to the Forum

    (1962),

    Anyone

    Can Whistle

    (1964),

    Company

    (1970),

    Follies

    (197I),

    A Little

    Night

    Music

    (I973),

    Pacific

    Overtures

    (1976),

    Sweeney

    Todd

    (1979),

    and

    Merrily

    We

    Roll

    Along

    (198I).

    From

    Anyone

    Can

    Whistle

    onwards,

    Sondheim

    has

    pushed

    the

    frontiers

    of the

    Broadway

    musical

    further and further

    outwards,

    exploring

    harmonically

    and

    structurally

    in a series of

    highly

    original

    works,

    of which

    Sweeney

    Todd

    is the most

    remarkable.

    After

    its

    opening

    in New

    York,

    many

    of the audience considered

    the

    work to

    be an

    opera,

    not a musical.

    Sondheim

    himself had said beforehand:

    'I had

    wanted to write a ballad opera, and here it is, with 26 numbers'. Harold Prince, the

    producer

    with

    whom

    Sondheim

    has worked

    fruitfully

    for

    the

    past

    14

    years,

    had

    referred

    to the work as 'music theatre'.

    The

    printed programme

    called

    the

    piece

    a

    'musical

    thriller'. After detailed

    study,

    perhaps

    all one can

    say

    is that

    is

    is not

    a musical

    in

    the

    generally

    accepted

    meaning

    of

    the

    word,

    i.e.

    a

    Broadway

    'show'.

    The work

    is based on

    a

    play

    by

    the British

    playwright Christopher

    Bond,

    adapted

    by

    Hugh

    Wheeler.

    Between

    them,

    they

    made

    a

    powerful

    and dramatic

    story

    out

    of what had hitherto

    been,

    in

    numerous

    previous

    versions,

    no more than

    a

    Grand

    Guignol

    melodrama

    with cardboard characters.

    Sweeney

    Todd is

    given

    a

    strong

    reason for

    his

    appalling

    anti-social activities:

    revenge.

    Transported

    for life

    by

    a

    wily

    and devious Judge Turpin, who lusts after Todd's beautiful young wife Lucy, he

    manages

    to

    escape

    from down-under and

    returns

    swearing vengeance

    for

    all his

    wrongs

    at the hands of the

    judge

    and his

    obsequious

    beadle,

    Bamford.

    Todd takes

    up

    residence

    once more

    in

    the

    barbershop

    above Mrs. Lovett's

    pie-shop

    in

    Fleet

    Street.

    Mrs.

    Lovett,

    a widow who

    still

    remembers the

    'beautiful

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    3/9

    TEMPO

    barber'

    with

    more

    than

    a little

    affection,

    does not

    recognize

    Todd at

    first,

    but

    when

    she

    does

    so,

    she tells

    him

    that

    his

    wife,

    Lucy,

    is

    dead,

    and that

    his

    beautiful

    young

    daughter, Johanna, is now living with Judge Turpin as his ward. The Judge has

    developed

    an

    all-consuming

    lust for the

    daughter.

    Romantic interest

    is

    provided

    by

    a

    young

    sailor,

    Anthony,

    who

    has saved Todd from

    drowning

    when their

    ship

    was

    wrecked

    on its

    return to

    England

    from Australia. Todd's

    plan

    is

    quite

    simple:

    he

    intends

    to

    kill

    theJudge

    and

    the

    Beadle for the

    wrongs

    they

    have

    done

    to

    him

    and

    his

    family.

    But because

    things

    do

    not

    go

    according

    to

    plan straightaway,

    Todd

    is

    forced

    to

    practise

    on 'less

    honourable throats'. . . and his

    desire

    for

    revenge

    and

    his

    madness

    grow.

    So the

    story

    is

    simple

    and

    powerful,

    with

    excellent

    dramatic

    shape,

    and

    many

    opportunities

    for a

    composer

    to

    write

    very many

    different kinds of music:

    Sondheim

    rises without fail to each challengeof the libretto, and, as one writer put it: ' "Sweeny

    Todd" rushes

    hell-bent

    through mounting

    dissonances

    to a

    shattering

    finish.'1

    As

    the work

    begins,

    with

    its

    harshly

    dissonant music

    'played'

    on

    stage

    by

    a small

    pipe

    organ

    (though actually

    in

    the

    pit by

    a

    Hammond

    organ),

    and

    as

    Sweeney

    Todd

    makes

    an

    unnerving

    and sudden

    appearance

    from out of

    his

    own

    open grave,

    we

    know we are not

    in

    for some

    cosy

    family

    entertainment

    along

    the

    lines

    of

    The

    King

    and

    I or The

    Sound

    of

    Music. The chorus

    sings

    the violent and

    harmonically

    disorientated

    'Ballad of

    Sweeney

    Todd'

    (whose

    second half

    is

    based

    on the 'Dies

    Irae'),

    and then the

    events

    of Todd's dark

    and sinister life are re-enacted

    before

    our

    eyes

    (and

    ears).

    The

    work's

    uncompromising

    drama,

    which deals with

    the

    less attractive

    aspects

    of the

    human psyche-deceit, lust, violence, murder, etc.-places it unequivocally in the

    same

    area

    as

    the

    Brecht/Weill

    collaborations like

    Mahagonny

    and

    The

    Seven

    Deadly

    Sins.

    Virtually

    all the

    apparently conflicting descriptions-ballad opera, opera,

    music

    theatre-seem

    justified:

    there

    are

    very

    few lines of the libretto which are

    not

    sung

    or

    spoken

    over musical

    accompaniment.

    Those

    lines which

    are

    spoken

    without

    any

    music,

    like Mrs.

    Lovett's

    hoarse,

    whispered:

    'So it is

    you,

    Benjamin

    Barker ',

    when

    she

    finally recognizes

    Todd,

    are

    electrifyingly

    effective-Sondheim

    clearly

    knows the

    dramatic

    effectiveness of silence. The

    chorus

    is used

    both

    in

    the normal 'musical'

    manner

    (here,

    as London

    townspeople)

    and-a

    purely operatic

    device-as

    a

    Greek

    chorus,

    commenting

    on

    the action at

    intervals

    throughout

    the work: the

    all-important

    'Ballad of

    Sweeney

    Todd'

    occurs,

    either

    in

    full or

    in

    part,

    seven

    times,

    with

    differing

    words: its

    first

    appearance

    gives

    the whole tenor of the

    ensuing

    work: 'Attend the

    tale

    of

    Sweeney

    Todd/His

    skin was

    pale

    and

    his

    eye

    was

    odd/He

    shaved

    the faces

    of

    gentlemen/Who

    never

    thereafter were heard

    of

    again'.

    From

    a

    purely

    musical

    point

    of

    view,

    the

    most

    interesting thing

    about

    Sweeney

    Todd

    s

    that Sondheim reveals in it that

    he

    is

    very

    much aware of what has been

    going

    on

    in

    'serious' music

    since

    the turn

    of

    the

    century.

    His harmonic

    language

    is

    frequently

    highly

    dissonant,

    and

    many

    passages

    show

    clearly

    identifiable

    models.

    The

    handling of the choral lines (for three tenors), in the 3rd statement of'The Ballad of

    Sweeney

    Todd',

    is

    very

    reminiscent

    of

    the

    writing

    for male voices

    in 'The

    Family'

    sections of Weill's

    The

    Seven

    Deadly

    Sins.

    Other

    parts

    remind

    one

    of

    Britten's

    vocal

    writing

    in

    early

    works like Let's Make an

    Opera.

    Orchestral

    passages

    owe a debt here

    and there to

    such

    diverse

    composers

    as

    Stravinsky

    ('No

    Place like

    London',

    b.256

    et

    seq.),

    Bliss

    ('Green

    Finch

    and

    Linnet

    Bird'-especially

    bb.

    50-54),

    and

    Sousa

    (the

    piccolo counterpoints

    in

    'Pirelli's Miracle

    Elixir'),

    to name

    just

    a few.

    1

    TV

    Times,

    31

    July

    1980.

    20

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    4/9

    'SWEENEY TODD'

    However,

    like all

    good composers,

    Sondheim

    has taken

    what

    he

    requires

    for

    his

    own

    expressive

    ends

    from

    the

    sound-worlds

    of other

    composers,

    and

    adapted

    them

    in

    such

    a

    way

    that

    they

    end

    up

    as

    sounding highly original:

    echt-Sondheim,

    in fact.

    Any

    hint

    of

    plagiarism

    is

    finally dispelled

    by

    Jonathan

    Tunick's

    always

    effective

    and

    imaginative

    orchestrations,

    arrived at after

    consultation with the

    composer.

    These use

    a

    28-piece

    orchestra

    comprising

    I.I.

    I.I.

    (with

    the

    usual

    doublings)-

    I.2.3.o-Perc.-Harp-Organ--4.4.2.2.I,

    an

    ensemble

    giving

    an infinite

    variety

    of

    timbres

    and

    orchestral

    'weights'.

    The libretto

    afforded

    Sondheim

    a

    number of

    opportunities

    for

    pastiche,

    which

    he

    seized

    to

    great

    effect.

    (He

    had

    already

    shown

    a

    real

    flair for

    pastiche

    in

    previous

    works,

    c.f.

    the

    brilliant G

    &

    S

    'patter song',

    sung

    by

    the British

    Admiral,

    in

    Pacific

    Overtures.)

    The

    'Parlor

    Songs',

    sung by

    Beadle

    Bamford,

    accompanying

    himself

    on the

    harmonium, are amusing copies of'ye olde Englishe ballad', and the I8th-century

    minuet

    in 'Poor

    Thing'

    is

    effective,

    despite

    its

    brevity.

    The

    musical

    digs

    at Verdi

    and

    Puccini

    in

    'Pirelli's

    Miracle

    Elixir',

    a virtuoso

    song

    for a

    very high

    Italian

    tenor,

    are

    both clever

    and

    witty.

    These

    pastiches give

    further evidence

    of

    Sondheim's

    awareness

    of

    music

    outside that

    of

    the

    Broadway

    musical

    and its traditions.

    Perhaps

    of the

    greatest

    interest to musicians

    is the actual harmonic

    language

    that

    Sondheim

    employs

    at certain

    times,

    often

    harshly

    dissonant, and,

    at

    times,

    clearly

    bitonal.

    Ex.

    I,

    taken

    from

    'The Ballad

    of

    Sweeney

    Todd'

    (first

    statement),

    shows how

    Sondheim

    achieves

    the musical

    equivalent

    of Todd's cut-throat

    razor about

    its

    grisly

    business

    'floating

    across

    the throats

    of

    hypocrites':

    Ex.

    I

    Ad

    Lh

    3

    nJr

    slJ

    ie

    d

    ntrM

    1

    And what if none of their

    souls

    were

    saved?

    They

    went

    to their

    Mak- r im

    -

    pec-ca-bly

    shavedd

    (

    *

    ^-

    -

    E

    qv

    I

    I

    .)

    VLS

    r

    T

    r

    r~

    I

    7r

    rr rr

    r

    rrrr-

    r

    r

    -r

    fr

    %47-

    '

    ._L--

    4

    Ps

    4

    '~

    Ex.

    2,

    from

    the same

    song,

    is a

    good example

    of some of the

    choral

    writing,

    which would

    no

    doubt

    stump many

    a chorus

    singer

    in

    a

    repertoire

    musical,

    while

    Ex.

    3

    is

    an

    example

    of

    bitonality resulting

    in a

    texture-and

    an

    emotional

    impact-reminiscent

    of

    parts

    of

    Berg's

    Wozzeck.

    Sondheim's

    vocal

    writing

    is

    wonderfully

    fluid,

    the

    underlaying

    following

    the

    stresses

    and internal

    rhythms

    of the words

    very

    closely.

    A

    good example

    (Ex.

    4)

    comes from

    'No

    Place

    like

    London',

    where the metre

    changes restlessly:

    21

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    5/9

    TEMPO

    Ex.

    2

    (J.

    =c120)

    1

    f

    '~"

    k

    130

    f,-

    1

    -1.

    1: 4

    S.

    :

    l

    |Swee

    -

    ney

    Swee

    -

    ney

    Swee

    -

    B.

    )

    F

    P

    *

    f

    f

    |

    f'

    |

    ff;'

    f

    _

    ff

    ft-

    f

    ''

    >

    >> >>>

    >>

    >>>i

    W.W.,

    Tpts.

    >-

    Ss.

    Hn.,Vlns.,Vlas.

    Tpts.|

    j:t

    __

    +

    Organ

    '

    s

    t

    A.

    ~

    #_

    I

    -

    _

    ney

    iB..y

    'r--

    T--

    -

    -

    I

    \lll#

    nlf

    ^

    if

    rfi

    frrrfrrr

    ^'

    ,

    J

    III

    I

    I> I>

    I>

    > >

    L> I>

    >

    I>

    I

    I

    a

    M

    Bsn. lc.(pizz.)

    *,i

    ._

    ,

    >

    -

    (

    gpff

    ~r

    c.* '`q

    IF

    4* *

    kJ.

    )

    (Strs.)

    >

    ;

    >

    Ex.

    3

    Strs.

    Organ

    Xylo.

    Tpts.

    Hn.

    Presto

    (=

    11-2).

    Tpts.

    ^

    ^^^^^^^^(^^1^_^

    Hn.)

    '

    V

    '

    I

    L-

    ,

    _

    W

    f

    6

    L.

    t

    ,

    L

    ,

    L_ .

    L

    _

    k

    ,

    L._

    .

    L

    f

    Organ

    Ped.

    Ex. 4

    F2151

    SWEENEY

    TODD

    6

    Meno

    mosso,^

    mp

    t4^^c?~1

    Ii-uT-]

    IIjI

    .

    i

    IL?8

    -W

    ;

    There was a

    bar-ber and his

    wife,

    And she was

    beau-

    ti-ful,_

    20

    '-

    ih

    b

    r

    ad

    hs

    wif,

    e wshs

    ren

    ad

    If

    fool-ish

    bar-ber and his

    wife,

    She was his

    rea-son

    and his

    life,

    22

    Tb.?

    .(-R)

    ,

    p

    ,

    VcI

    rF

    af

    I

    r

    V

    I

    m)fP

    6J

    -

    b

    J

    6

    a)

    >

    >

    -I,

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    6/9

    'SWEENEY TODD'

    23

    B^

    1

    .

    KJ?

    g .

    I$r

    r

    F,i?

    .

    6-

    P

    1t

    And

    she

    was

    beau-ti-ful,_

    And she

    was vir

    -

    tu-ous,_

    J

    2251J

    And he

    was

    na- ive.

    Similar

    examples

    of

    constantly shifting

    metres occur

    it

    many songs,

    most

    notably

    in

    Mrs. Lovett's 'Worst

    Pies in

    London',

    where the dislocations in the

    metre

    give

    emphasis

    to her

    attempts

    to

    swat

    and

    thump

    the

    flies

    that

    plague

    her as

    she kneads

    dough:

    4/4 2/4

    4/4

    3/4 5/4

    3/4

    4/4

    3/4

    5/4 3/4

    5/4 4/4

    etc.

    We

    are a

    long

    way away

    from the sound

    of hills alive with music.

    Occasionally,

    the American roots of

    Sondheim's

    music

    become

    apparent

    in

    the

    syncopations

    in

    such

    songs

    as

    Anthony's

    'Ah,

    Miss'

    (note

    the

    rhythm

    of

    the

    Charleston

    in

    the

    accompaniment):

    Ex.

    5

    a

    tempo

    Look

    at me ook at me

    miss,

    oh

    look

    at me

    please

    oh,

    Fa vor

    me

    fa

    -

    vor me

    with

    your

    pa

    tempo

    l)^-

    t^

    C^r- f

    f

    A f_

    glance.

    Ah,

    miss,

    6$

    8

    J-

    r

    r

    I

    As

    his own

    lyricist,

    Sondheim

    is

    able to

    arrive at the

    precise

    words he

    requires

    to

    marry

    to the music he

    has in

    mind,

    and we

    are

    constantly

    reminded

    of his

    brilliant

    way

    with words

    by

    many

    felicitous

    and

    witty

    lines.

    Perhaps

    the

    most

    outstanding,

    among

    many

    excellent

    songs,

    is 'A

    Little

    Priest',

    the

    marvellously

    black

    ending

    to Act

    I,

    where

    Mrs. Lovett is

    tempting

    Sweeney

    Todd to

    sample

    different

    pies,

    each flavoured

    by

    a different

    profession:

    TODD

    Anything

    that's lean.

    MRS. LOVETT

    Well, then,

    if

    you're

    British and

    loyal,

    You

    might enjoy Royal

    Marine.

    (TODD

    makes

    a

    face)

    Anyway,

    it's

    clean

    Though,

    of

    course,

    it

    tastes

    of

    wherever it's been.

    And later:

    MRS.

    LOVETT

    Since

    marine doesn't

    appeal

    to

    you,

    how

    about rear admiral?

    TODD

    Too

    Salty.

    I

    prefer general.

    MRS.

    LOVETT

    With or without his

    privates?

    'With'

    is

    extra.

    TODD

    chortles)

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    7/9

    TEMPO

    If

    anything

    gives

    full

    weight

    to

    the

    description

    of

    the work as an

    opera,

    it is

    the

    way

    in

    which the

    music is

    unified and

    given

    dramatic

    cohesion

    from

    song

    to

    song,

    and

    from act to

    act,

    by

    a host of

    technical means:

    (I)

    canon

    (2)

    the

    derivation

    of

    accompanimental

    figures

    in

    one

    song

    from

    the

    music of

    another

    (3)

    the

    interjection

    of

    previously

    heard

    music into

    the

    on-going,

    foreground

    music

    (4)

    the use of

    orchestral

    solos,

    derived from

    previously

    heard

    songs,

    in

    the

    accompaniment

    of other

    songs

    (the

    possibilities

    for

    irony

    here

    are not

    missed)

    (5)

    the use of the 'Dies

    Irae'

    (within

    'The Ballad of

    Sweeney

    Todd')

    in various

    guises throughout

    the whole work

    (6)

    the use of

    previously

    heard music with new

    words,

    sung

    either

    by

    the

    same

    character,

    or

    by

    a

    different one

    (7)

    the use

    of

    pregnant

    melodic/harmonic

    fragments

    or

    motifs,

    which occur

    at

    salient

    points

    in

    the drama

    (with

    all their associations

    from

    previous

    occasions)

    (8)

    polyphonic

    ensembles for

    the main

    protagonists,

    in a

    truly

    operatic

    fashion,

    the

    voices

    singing

    simultaneously fragments

    of

    music

    they

    had

    sung

    previously

    (9)

    the use of the chimes of

    Big

    Ben

    (the

    'London

    Connection')

    throughout

    the

    work, in various (and sometimes highly dissonant) harmonizations

    (Io)

    the use of an

    ear-piercing

    factory

    whistle

    at

    the

    point

    of most

    (but

    not

    all)

    the

    murders: this was an

    idea of the

    producer,

    Harold

    Prince,

    and the use

    of this

    at the start of the work is

    one

    of

    the

    most

    genuinely shocking

    moments

    in

    the theatre

    All

    in

    all,

    the work is so

    tightly

    knit and

    unified,

    both

    musically

    and

    dramatically,

    and

    examples

    of the above

    technical means are so

    numerous,

    that it would be

    impossible,

    within the

    scope

    of

    a

    short

    article,

    to

    list

    them all.

    However,

    a few

    examples

    may

    give

    some idea of the hand

    of

    a

    master craftsman of

    the

    theatre

    at work.

    When

    Anthony

    asks

    the

    Beggar

    Woman

    who the

    young

    woman is

    that

    lives

    in

    Judge Turpin's house, we hear, as an oboe solo marked triste,a minor variant of

    Johanna's

    song,

    'Green

    Finch and Linnet

    Bird'.

    During

    Judge

    Turpin's

    song,

    'Mea

    Culpa'-a

    truly

    horrendous

    musical

    representation

    of an

    old

    man's

    lust for a

    young

    woman-we hear the minuet

    again.

    This

    first

    appeared during

    Mrs. Lovett's account

    of

    Judge

    Turpin's rape

    of

    Todd's

    young

    wife,

    Lucy,

    at the

    masked

    ball,

    just

    after Mrs. Lovett

    had

    recognized

    the

    'stranger'

    (Todd).

    ('Of

    course

    when

    she

    goes

    there,

    poor thing, poor

    thing/They're

    having

    this ball all

    in

    masks').

    The minuet is in fact a clue to the

    Beggar

    Woman's

    identity,

    being

    the tune

    of

    her

    raunchy

    song

    in

    the

    opening

    scene,

    when she

    offers

    herself for

    money

    to Todd and

    Anthony.

    Sweeney

    Todd's

    'My

    Friends',

    sung

    to his cut-throat razors

    nestling

    in their

    velvet-lined

    box,

    which Mrs.

    Lovett

    has

    kept

    from

    the old

    days-possibly

    the

    most

    chilling

    'love

    song'

    ever written-is

    heard

    again during

    the

    duet

    between

    Sweeney

    Todd and

    Judge Turpin, 'Pretty

    Women'.

    The main motif of

    'My

    Friends'

    is an

    inversion of the

    figure

    that

    accompanies

    'The Ballad of

    Sweeney

    Todd',

    and

    in

    this

    song,

    Todd's

    promise

    to his

    'friends'

    ('Friends,

    you

    shall

    drip

    rubies.

    You'll soon

    drip

    precious

    rubies')

    seems

    near

    to fulfilment.

    During

    this

    same

    song,

    Todd

    hums a

    variant

    of the Beadle's

    song,

    'Ladies

    n

    Their

    Sensitivities',

    which he

    picks

    up

    from the

    24

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    8/9

    'SWEENEY TODD'

    Judge

    as

    he

    prepares

    to shave

    him,

    while

    a

    derivative

    of

    this same

    song

    is heard

    in

    the

    accompaniment

    as a

    triplet

    figure

    in

    the woodwind.

    Johanna's

    music from

    'He

    means

    to marry me on Monday' also makes a fleeting appearance.

    The now famous

    'Epiphany',

    sung by

    Todd,

    contains

    many

    references

    to

    previously

    heard material: Mrs. Lovett's

    'Wait',

    Todd's own 'There's a hole

    in

    the

    world like a

    great

    black

    pit',

    and

    the 'Dies

    Irae',

    among

    others.

    This

    song

    also

    has

    the

    Ivesian effect of a full orchestral

    tutti

    suddenly

    stopping

    to leave

    a

    'foreign'

    harmony,

    pianissimo,

    held on

    by

    the

    high

    strings

    (cf

    Ives's

    Decoration

    Day).

    The

    following

    two

    melodic/harmonic

    motifs are also

    important,

    and

    occur at

    various

    times

    throughout

    the

    work

    (Exx.

    6

    and

    7):

    Ex.6

    Ex.

    7

    (Sweeney

    Todd's 'madness

    motif,

    heard whenever he

    is

    either

    brooding

    or

    murderously

    inclined.

    It is also

    the

    melodic and harmonic basis of

    such

    passages

    as

    the

    conspiracy

    during

    'God,

    That's

    Good ')

    Act

    II is shorter than

    Act

    I

    (8

    numbers

    compared

    to

    I8):

    it is

    also denser and

    more

    musically

    unified

    than

    Act

    I,

    with

    many

    fragments

    from

    previously

    heard music

    making fleeting appearances, frequently

    in

    contrapuntal

    combinations with

    themselves,

    or with

    new material.

    Perhaps

    the

    most

    interesting-and

    the most

    'contemporary'-is

    the 'Final

    Scene',

    where Mrs. Lovett

    sings,

    with

    new

    words,

    music

    from

    her Act

    I

    song,

    'Poor

    Thing', against Sweeney

    Todd's

    slow-moving

    lament,

    sung

    after he realizes

    that the

    'Beggar Woman'

    he

    has

    just

    killed

    is in

    fact

    Lucy,

    his

    wife,

    whom he

    thought

    had died

    long ago.

    (The

    lament

    is

    in

    fact

    derived

    from the

    'Epiphany';

    its

    original genesis

    going

    right

    back to the

    Beggar

    Woman's

    motif when

    she

    asks

    tor

    'Alms ' at the

    beginning

    of the

    work.)

    (Ex. 8)-there

    are shades

    here,

    perhaps,

    of

    Britten's

    Church

    Parables,

    with

    the

    pitting together

    of

    different

    tempi.

    Ex.8

    A

    (Largo

    (J=

    40))

    MRS. LOVETT

    (No,

    no,

    not)

    lied

    at

    all..

    No,

    I ne-

    ver

    lied. Said

    she

    took

    the

    poi

    A~l

    v.

    i~~~~~i wSWEENEY

    ODD

    Lu

    -

    cy...

    I(8)J-7

    L;J

    JT

    -a

    j

    J

    i

    -son,

    she

    did,

    Ne

    -

    ver said that she

    died.

    Poor

    thing.

    l

    :~(,

    )-

    .o,I've

    cme

    've come

    25

    This content downloaded from 203.78.9.149 on Thu, 22 May 2014 13:50:47 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 8/11/2019 Sondheim's 'Sweeney Todd' - The Case for the Defence

    9/9

    26

    TEMPO

    IP4(R)v

    I

    she lived but it left

    her weak in the head. All

    she did

    for

    months was

    just

    lie

    there

    in

    bed.

    IAAw

    .

    .1.

    -

    -.

    I

    home

    a

    gain.

    2W%

    J

    -tl-

    *18

    \r

    J

    m

    J1lhl'Rli .

    Shouldve

    been in

    hos-pi

    -

    tal,

    wound

    up

    in Bed-lam

    in-stead.

    Poor

    thing.

    Bet-ter

    you

    should

    |^,[~bl2.

    --

    c

    O.

    n.

    -

    -#.

    Lu

    -

    cy

    Oh,

    my

    (God )

    Sweeney Toddran for only about five months in its London production at the

    Theatre

    Royal,

    Drury

    Lane.

    A

    number of reasons have been

    given

    for this:

    it

    was

    too

    'English'

    a

    story

    for the

    English

    to

    accept

    from

    Americans;

    the

    story

    was

    simply

    too

    grisly

    for

    comfort;

    there were not

    enough

    'hummable tunes'

    in the

    piece.

    Perhaps

    the

    reason

    is

    simpler

    and,

    paradoxically,

    not obvious: it was heard

    by

    the

    wrong

    audience.

    The work

    is

    an

    opera,

    and,

    as

    such,

    it did

    extraordinarily

    well

    to

    run

    as

    long

    as it

    did-most

    operas

    have to

    be content

    with

    just

    a

    few

    performances

    in

    any

    one season

    (and

    few new ones

    get

    revived).

    Because

    it is an

    opera,

    and

    a

    very powerful

    and 'difficult' one

    at

    that,

    it

    needs

    to be

    presented by

    an

    opera company

    like

    the

    English

    National

    Opera

    or the

    Welsh

    National

    Opera. Opera

    audiences are

    clearly

    prepared

    to

    accept

    much

    'tougher'

    stories

    for musical

    treatments

    than

    those which

    normally

    support

    musicals: one

    only

    has

    to think of

    Salome and

    Wozzeck

    to

    realize

    this. A

    really good production

    of

    Sweeney

    Todd

    by

    a

    professional opera company

    would

    give

    the

    work

    the chance

    in

    England

    that

    it

    clearly

    deserves.

    Sweeney

    Todd is available

    as

    follows:

    2

    I2"

    LPs

    (or

    double

    cassette)

    from That's

    Entertainment,

    43

    The

    Market,

    Covent

    Garden,

    London

    WC2,

    price

    ?15.99.

    Vocal Score from Chappell & Co. Ltd.,

    129

    Park Street, London WI, price ?45 (Vocal Selection: ?6.95).

    Libretto

    (cased)

    from

    Samuel French

    Ltd.,

    26

    Southampton

    Street,

    London

    WC2,

    price

    ?7.50.

    Acknowledgements

    The

    author wishes to thank Mr.

    Skip

    Humphries,

    Head of Music

    Services,

    London

    Weekend

    Television

    Ltd.,

    for the

    loan

    of

    the

    piano

    conductor

    score of

    this

    work

    used in the

    preparation

    of the edition of LWT's

    'South Bank

    Show'

    devoted

    to

    Sweeney

    Todd-The

    Demon Barber

    f

    Fleet

    Street,

    transmitted

    on

    28/7/1980.

    All music

    quoted

    is

    ?

    1979

    Revelation Music

    Publishing Corp.

    and

    Rilting

    Music Inc. A

    Tommy

    Valando

    Publication.

    Reprinted by special permission.

    Thi t t d l d d f 203 78 9 149 Th 22 M 2014 13 50 47 PM

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp