SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline -...

34
SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management of Abnormal Cervical Cancer Screening and Histology These Clinical Practice Guidelines have been prepared and approved by the Executive and Council of the Society of Canadian Colposcopists (SCC). These guidelines have been approved by the SOGC/GOC/SCC Policy and Practice Guidelines Committee, the Society of Gynecologic Oncology of Canada (GOC) and the Executive and Council of the Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists of Canada. Principal Author James Bentley, MB ChB, Halifax, NS The Executive Council of the Society Of Canadian Colposcopists James Bentley, MB ChB, Halifax, NS Monique Bertrand, MD, London, ON Lizabeth Brydon, MD, Regina, SK Helene Gagne, MD, Ottawa, ON Brian Hauck, MD, Calgary, AB Marie-Helene Mayrand, MD, Montreal, QC Susan McFaul, MD, Ottawa, ON Patti Power, MD, St. John’s,NL Alexandra Schepanski, MD, Edmonton, AB Special Contributors Lucy Gilbert, MD, Montreal, QC Jill Nation, MD, Calgary, AB Michael Shier, MD, Toronto, ON Laurette Geldenhuys, MD, Halifax, NS Linda Kapusta, MD, Mississauga, ON Terry Colgan, MD, Toronto, ON Roberta Howlett, PhD, St Thomas, ON Joan Murphy, MD, Toronto, ON Rachel Kupets, MD, Toronto, ON DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Disclosure statements have been received from all members of the committee(s). DISCLAIMER

Transcript of SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline -...

Page 1: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

SOGC/SCCClinicalPracticeGuideline

ColposcopicManagementofAbnormalCervicalCancerScreeningandHistology

TheseClinicalPracticeGuidelineshavebeenpreparedandapprovedbytheExecutiveandCounciloftheSocietyofCanadianColposcopists(SCC).TheseguidelineshavebeenapprovedbytheSOGC/GOC/SCCPolicyandPractice

GuidelinesCommittee,theSocietyofGynecologicOncologyofCanada(GOC)andtheExecutiveandCounciloftheSocietyofObstetriciansandGynaecologistsofCanada.

PrincipalAuthorJamesBentley,MBChB,Halifax,NS

TheExecutiveCounciloftheSocietyOfCanadianColposcopistsJamesBentley,MBChB,Halifax,NSMoniqueBertrand,MD,London,ONLizabethBrydon,MD,Regina,SKHeleneGagne,MD,Ottawa,ONBrianHauck,MD,Calgary,AB

Marie-HeleneMayrand,MD,Montreal,QCSusanMcFaul,MD,Ottawa,ONPattiPower,MD,St.John’s,NL

AlexandraSchepanski,MD,Edmonton,AB

SpecialContributorsLucyGilbert,MD,Montreal,QCJillNation,MD,Calgary,AB

MichaelShier,MD,Toronto,ONLauretteGeldenhuys,MD,Halifax,NSLindaKapusta,MD,Mississauga,ONTerryColgan,MD,Toronto,ON

RobertaHowlett,PhD,StThomas,ONJoanMurphy,MD,Toronto,ONRachelKupets,MD,Toronto,ON

DISCLOSURESTATEMENT

Disclosurestatementshavebeenreceivedfromallmembersofthecommittee(s).

DISCLAIMER

Page 2: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

2of34

Thisdocumentreflectsemergingclinicalandscientificadvancesonthedateissued,

andissubjecttochange.Theinformationshouldnotbeconstruedasdictatingan

exclusivecourseoftreatmentorproceduretobefollowed.Localinstitutionscan

dictateamendmentstotheseopinions.Theyshouldbewelldocumentedifmodified

atthelocallevel.Noneofthesecontentsmaybereproducedinanyformwithout

priorwrittenpermissionoftheSOGC.

ABSTRACT

Objective:Todefineaguidelineformanagingabnormalcytologyresultsafterscreeningforcervicalcancerandtoclarifytheappropriatealgorithmsforfollow-upaftertreatment.

Options:Womenwithabnormalcytologyareatriskofdevelopingcervicalcancer;appropriatetriageandtreatmentwillreducethisrisk.

Outcomes:AqualityguidelinewillfacilitateimplementationofcommonstandardsacrossCanada,movingawayfromthecurrenttrendofindividualguidelinesineachprovinceandterritory.

Evidence:PublishedliteraturewasretrievedthroughsearchesofPubMedorMEDLINE,CINAHL,andTheCochraneLibraryinOctober2008usingappropriatecontrolledvocabulary(e.g.,colposcopy,cervicaldysplasia)andkeywords(e.g.,colposcopymanagement,CIN,AGC,cervicaldysplasia,LEEP,LLETZ,HPVtesting,cervicaldysplasiatriage).Resultswererestrictedtosystematicreviews,randomizedcontroltrials/controlledclinicaltrials,andobservationalstudies.Therewerenodateorlanguagerestrictions.SearcheswereupdatedonaregularbasisandincorporatedintheguidelinetoDecember2011.Grey(unpublished)literaturewasidentifiedthroughsearchingtheWebsitesofhealthtechnologyassessment(HTA)andHTA-relatedagencies,clinicalpracticeguidelinecollections,andfromnationalandinternationalmedicalspecialtysocieties.Expertopinionfrompublishedpeer-reviewedliteratureandevidencefromclinicaltrials(whereavailable)issummarized.Consensusopinionisoutlinedwhereevidenceisinsufficient.

Values:ThequalityoftheevidenceisratedusingthecriteriadescribedbytheCanadianTaskForceonPreventiveHealthCare(Table1).Thetaskforcehasrecentlyreconvenedandnonewrecommendationshavebeenreleased.

Benefits,HarmsandCosts:Theintentistopromotethebestpossiblecareforwomenwhileensuringefficientuseofavailableresources.

Validation:Thisguidelinehasbeenreviewedforaccuracyfromcontentexpertsin

Page 3: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

3of34

cytology,pathologyandcervicalscreeningprograms.GuidelinecontentwasalsocomparedtosimilardocumentsfromotherorganizationsincludingtheAmericanSocietyforColposcopyandCervicalPathology,BritishSocietyforColposcopyandCervicalPathology,andtheEuropeanCancerNetwork.

Sponsors:None

KeyWords:CervicalCytology,CervicalCancer,Colposcopy,Treatment,Follow-up,Abnormalities,Guidelines

Recommendations

WaitTimesforColposcopy1. WomenwithHSILareideallyseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin4weeksof

referral.(III-C)

2. WomenwithASC-HorAGCshouldbeseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin6weeksofreferral.(III-C)

3. WomenwithaPaptestsuggestiveofcarcinomashouldbeseenwithin2weeksofreferral.(III-C)

4. Otherresultsshouldbeseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin8weeksofreferral.(III-C)

TheColposcopyExam1. Colposcopicfindingscanbedescribedaccordingtotheterminologydefined

bytheInternationalFederationforCervicalPathologyandColposcopy.(III-C)

2. Atcolposcopy,twoormorebiopsiesshouldbetaken.(I-A)

3. AnECCshouldbeperformedwhencolposcopyisunsatisfactory,withanAGCpapandinolderwomenwithhigh-gradecytology.(II-2B)

4. RoutineHR-HPVtestingforallcolposcopyreferralsisdiscouraged.(III-C)

ManagingwomenwithASCUSorLSILonreferraltoColposcopy1. Acolposcopicallyidentifiedlesionshouldbebiopsied.(III-C)

2. Ifnolesionisidentified,arandombiopsyofthetransformationzonecouldbeconsidered.(III-C)

ManagingASC-H1. AwomanwithanASC-HPaptestshouldhavecolposcopytoruleoutCIN2/3

and/orcancer.(II-2A)

2. WithanASC-HPaptest,thefindingofnegativecolposcopydoesnotautomaticallywarrantadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(III-B)

Page 4: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

4of34

ManagingHSIL1. AllwomenwithanHSILtestresultshouldhavecolposcopy.(II-2A)

2. Intheabsenceofanidentifiablelesionatcolposcopyandunsatisfactorycolposcopy,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.(III-B)

ManagingAtypicalGlandularCytology(AGC-NOS,AGC-N,AIS)1. ThefindingofanAGCPaptestwarrantscolposcopy.(II-2A)

2. AnAGC-NPaptestwithoutanidentifiablelesionatcolposcopyshouldbefollowedwithadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(II-2A)

ManagingSCCandAdenocarcinoma1. Womenwithacytologicdiagnosissuggestiveofcarcinoma,withorwithouta

visiblelesion,shouldhavecolposcopy.(IIIA)

ManagingthePatientwithAbnormalHPVTestandNormalCytology1. WomenwhotestpositiveforHR-HPVandhavenegativecytologyshould

haverepeattestingat12months.PersistentpositiveHR-HPVtestswarrantcolposcopy.(IA)

ManagingAbnormalCytologyinPregnancy1. WomenwithanASCUSorLSILtestresultduringpregnancyshouldhave

repeattestingpostpregnancy.(III-B)

2. WomenwithHSIL,ASC-HorAGCshouldbereferredpromptlyforcolposcopyinpregnancy.(III-B)

3. ECCisnotrecommendedduringpregnancy.(III-B)

ManagingAbnormalCytologyintheAdolescent1. Screeningshouldnotbeinitiatedinwomenlessthan21yearsofage.(II-2A)

2. Ifscreeningisdone,andanASC-USorLSILresultisreported,cytologyshouldberepeatedinoneyear,withreferraltocolposcopyifalow-gradetestresultcontinuesfor24months.(III-B)

3. CytologyresultsofASC-H,HSIL,andAGCintheadolescentshouldbereferredtocolposcopy.(III-B)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalities

ManagingCIN11. BiopsyprovenCIN1shouldbeobservedwithrepeatcolposcopyat12-month

intervals.Persistencebeyond24monthsmaybetreatedorobservedwithrepeatcytologyand/orcolposcopy.(II-1B)

2. Biopsy-provenCIN1afterHSILorAGCcytology,anexcisionalprocedureshouldbeconsidered.(III-B)

Page 5: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

5of34

ManagingCIN2/31. CIN2or3shouldbetreated;excisionalproceduresarepreferredforCIN3.

(II-1A)

2. Womenwhohavepositivemarginsshouldhaveclosefollow-upwithretreatmentwithexcisionforpersistentdisease.(II-1B)

ManagingCIN2/3intheAdolescent1. CIN2intheadolescentpatientshouldbeobservedwithcolposcopyat6-

monthintervalsforupto24monthsbeforetreatment.(II-2B)

2. CIN3shouldbetreatedintheadolescentpatient.(III-B)

ManagingAdenocarcinomainSitu(AIS)1. IfAISisdiagnosed,treatmentneedstobedonewithadiagnosticexcisional

procedure,ortype3TZexcision.(II-2A)

2. Ifmarginsarepositiveafterdiagnosticexcisionalprocedure,asecondexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.(II-2A)

3. IfaftertreatmentforAISawomanhasfinishedchildbearing,ahysterectomyshouldbeconsidered.(III-B)

4. IfAISisdiagnosedafterLEEPisperformedforCINinawomanwhohasnotcompletedherfamilyandmarginsarenegative,itisunnecessarytoperformafurtherdiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(II-2A)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesDuringPregnancy1. IfCIN2orCIN3isdiagnosedduringpregnancy,treatmentshouldbedelayed

untilafterdelivery.(II-2A)

Follow-upPostTreatment1. Post-treatmentforCIN2or3:womenshouldbefollowedwithcytologyand

colposcopyat6monthintervalsfortwovisits,aslongasbothcytologyandanybiopsiesarenegative.(II-2B)

2. Post-treatmentforCIN2or3:HPVtestingat6or12monthscombinedwithcytology.IfbothcytologyandHPVtestingarenegative,returningtoannualorbiannualcytologyisareasonableoption.(II-2B)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesinHigh-RiskIndividuals1. Immunocompromisedwomenshouldbescreenedannuallybutnotwith

colposcopy.(II-2B)

2. Immunocompromisedwomenshouldbetreatedwithanexcisionalproceduretakingcaretominimizepositivemargins.(II-2B)

Page 6: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

6of34

Table1:Keytoevidencestatementsandgradingofrecommendations,usingtherankingoftheCanadianTaskForceonPreventativeHealthCare

QualityofEvidenceAssessment* Classificationof

Recommendations‡

I: Evidenceobtainedfromatleastoneproperlyrandomizedcontrolledtrial

II-1: Evidencefromwell-designedcontrolledtrialswithoutrandomization

II-2: Evidencefromwell-designedcohort(prospectiveorretrospective)orcase-controlstudies,preferablyfrommorethanonecentreorresearchgroup

II-3: Evidenceobtainedfromcomparisonsbetweentimesorplaceswithorwithouttheintervention.Dramaticresultsinuncontrolledexperiments(suchastheresultsoftreatmentwithpenicillininthe1940s)couldalsobeincludedinthecategory

III: Opinionsofrespectedauthorities,basedonclinicalexperience,descriptivestudies,orreportsofexpertcommittees

A. Thereisgoodevidencetorecommendtheclinicalpreventiveaction

B. Thereisfairevidencetorecommendtheclinicalpreventiveaction

C. Theexistingevidenceisconflictinganddoesnotallowtomakearecommendationfororagainstuseoftheclinicalpreventiveaction;however,otherfactorsmayinfluencedecision-making

D. Thereisfairevidencetorecommendagainsttheclinicalpreventiveaction

E. Thereisgoodevidencetorecommendagainsttheclinicalpreventiveaction

L. Thereisinsufficientevidence(inquantityorquality)tomakearecommendation;however,otherfactorsmayinfluencedecision-making

*ThequalityofevidencereportedintheseguidelineshasbeenadaptedfromTheEvaluationofEvidencecriteriadescribedintheCanadianTaskForceonPreventiveHealthCare.

†RecommendationsincludedintheseguidelineshavebeenadaptedfromtheClassificationofrecommendationscriteriadescribedinTheCanadianTaskForceonPreventiveHealthCare.

IntroductionOverthelast30yearscervicalcancermorbidityandmortalityrateshavedroppedsignificantlyinCanada,fromapproximately30per100,000to7per100,000

Page 7: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

7of34

women(1).Thischangehasbeenwidelyattributedtotheavailabilityofcervicalscreeningviacytologicsampling(2).

Colposcopyhasevolvedtoevaluatethosewithabnormalcytologyandprovideahistologicalsamplebybiopsy.Treatmentoflesionscanthenbeperformed,usuallypreservingfertilityandavoidingmajorsurgery(3)(Ch1,p6).Numerousjurisdictionshavedevelopedguidelines(4-8)forcolposcopy1andthesehavebeenreviewedindevelopingthisdocument.

CervicalcancerscreeningisorganizedwithineachprovinceandterritoryinCanada.ScreeningProgramsissuescreeningandfollow-uprecommendationsforabnormalscreeningresults,includingreferraltocolposcopy.ThediversityandstatusofcervicalscreeninginCanadahasbeensummarizedelsewhere(9).

Theageforinitialscreeninghasbeenre-evaluatedrecently.ThisreviewofscreeninginitiationwaspioneeredbytheAmericanSocietyofColposcopyandCervicalPathology(ASCCP),whichconvenedaconsensuspracticeimprovementconferenceinJune2009.StakeholdersfromtheUnitedStates(USA)andCanadawereincluded.Outcomesfromthismeetingincludedarecommendationtostartscreeningatage21(10).ThisrecommendationhasbeenincorporatedintonewguidelinesfromQuébec(11)andAlberta(12).

Canadiancolposcopicpracticeisuniqueinseveralways.Colposcopyisperformedpredominantlybygynecologistsinbothhospitalclinicsandprivateoffices.AccesstoHPVtestingiscurrentlylimitedoutsideofteachinghospitals.TheprimaryaimoftheseguidelinesistostandardizethecolposcopiccareprovidedforwomeninCanada.

MethodsTheseguidelinesweredevelopedthroughtheleadershipoftheSocietyofCanadianColposcopy.Inputwassolicitedfromvariousorganizationsincluding;SocietyofGynecologicOncologyofCanada(GOC);SocietyofObstetriciansandGynecologistsofCanada(SOGC);CanadianAssociationofPathologists(CAP);CanadianSocietyofCytopathology(CSC);and,representationfromprovincialscreeningprograms.Aface-to-facemeetingofcontributorswasheldinDecember2008forthefollowingpurpose.Relevantliteraturewasreviewed,includingguidelinesrelatedtocolposcopicmanagementofabnormalcytologyandhistology.Clinicalquestionsweredevelopedanddiscussed.Whereevidencewasincomplete,consensusopinionprevailed.Guidelinesexistbothasformallypublishedandweb-baseddocuments;themostcommonlyreferencedarethosepublishedbytheAmericanSocietyforColposcopyandCervicalPathology(ASCCP)formanagementofcytologicalandhistologicalabnormalities(13,14).

1GuidelinesfrombothwithinandoutsideCanadahavebeenreviewedandwillbereferenced,whereappropriate,throughoutthedocument.

Page 8: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

8of34

TheBethesda2001classificationsystem(15)isthecytologicalterminologycommonlyusedinCanada;thisterminologywasusedheretorepresentcytologicaldiagnosesandCINterminologywasemployedforhistologicaldiagnoses.(SeealsoTable2)

ColposcopicManagementofCytologicalAbnormalitiesScreeningandcolposcopyrecommendationsvaryacrossprovincesandterritoriesandhavebeendocumentedelsewhere(9).Currentguidelinesforcolposcopicreferralscanbesummarizedasfollows:referraltocolposcopyisrecommendedforpersistentASCUS,persistentorincidentLSIL,ASC-H,HSIL,andAGC2aswellasforPapanicolaou(Pap)teststhatsuggestsquamousorglandularcarcinoma.HPVtestingisnotwidelyavailable;however,whenreflexHPVtestingshowsthepresenceofoncogenic(orhighrisk)HPV(HR-HPV)withASCUScytology,referraltocolposcopyisrecommended.

WaitTimesforColposcopyPatientswithabnormalscreeningtestsshouldbeseenincolposcopywithinareasonabletime,giventheriskofhigh-gradechangesandpsychologicalstressassociatedwithanabnormalcytologyresult(16).Becauseofthis,theSOGCwaittimesstatementrecommendscolposcopicassessmentwithin3weeksforHSILcytology;6–8weeksforASC-HorLSIL;and6weeksforanAGCcytologyresult(17)TheserecommendationsaresimilartotheUKrecommendationthat90%ofcaseswithhigh-gradecytologyshouldbeseenwithin4weeksand90%ofalltestsshouldbeseenwithin8weeksofreferral(7).

TheimportanceofguidelinestodirectreferraltimestocolposcopywasillustratedinanOntariopopulation-basedreview(18).ReferralswerereviewedforPaptestresultsofHSIL,AGCandASC-Hbetween2000and2006.WomenwithHSILresultswereseenincolposcopyatamediantimeof67days,AGC108daysandASC-H80days.Invasivediseaseofthelowergenitaltractwasdetectedin2.4%ofASC-Hcases,3%ofAGCand3.12%ofHSIL.Unfortunatelyinthispopulationtherewasa26%losstofollow-up,i.e.,womenwhodidnothavecolposcopywithin24months.

Itisrecognizedthattheseareguidelinesandmaybedifficulttoachieve;however,triageeffortsshouldensurethatthosewithmoresignificantcytologicabnormalitiesareseenfirst.

Recommendations:

1. WomenwithHSILareideallyseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin4weeksofreferral.(III-C)

2. WomenwithASC-HorAGCshouldbeseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin6weeksofreferral.(III-C)

2SeeTable2fordescriptionoftheseterms.

Page 9: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

9of34

3. WomenwithaPaptestsuggestiveofcarcinomashouldbeseenwithin2weeksofreferral.(III-C)

4. Otherresultsshouldbeseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin8weeksofreferral.(III-C)

TheColposcopyExamColposcopyistheexaminationofthelowergenitaltractandcervixusingmagnificationfromacolposcopewithagoodlightsource.Thesquamo-columnarjunctionandtransformationzoneshouldbeidentified,determiningwhethertheexamissatisfactoryornot.Aceticacidisthenusedtoassessthesize,shape,marginandlocationofanyneoplasticlesion.ThesefindingscanthenbedescribedaccordingtothenomenclatureoftheInternationalFederationforCervicalPathologyandColposcopy(19).

Whenanylesionisidentified,recentevidencesupportsthepracticeoftakingatleasttwobiopsiestoimprovetheaccuracyofcolposcopy.Abiopsyshouldbetakenofthemostsevereareafoundoncolposcopicexamination,eithertoconfirmorruleoutmalignantlesions(20,21).AnalysisoftheALTSdatashowedthat,takingtwobiopsiesforalow-gradecytologyreferralatinitialcolposcopy,improvedthesensitivity(todetectCIN2orgreater)to81.8%,comparedto68.3%withonebiopsy(20).

ArecentreviewoftheutilityofendocervicalcurettagewaspublishedusingdatafromCalgary.Basedonover13,000examinations,theauthorsshowedthat99ECCspecimenshadtobetakentodetectoneadditionalcaseofCIN2orhighergradelesion.Thelargestbenefitwasinolderwomenreferredafterhigh-gradecytology(22).AnECCshouldthusbeperformedwithunsatisfactorycolposcopy,anAGCsmear,andinolderwomenwithhigh-gradecytology

Alowthresholdisrecommendedforundertakingabiopsy.Ifanylesionisseen,biopsyshouldbecompleted.Ifonlymetaplasiaisinquestion,abiopsyshouldbeconsidered.Unlessdictatedbytheappropriatealgorithm,thereisnoroleforroutineHR-HPVtestinginthecolposcopyclinic.

Recommendations:

1. ColposcopicfindingscanbedescribedaccordingtotheterminologydefinedbytheInternationalFederationforCervicalPathologyandColposcopy.(III-C)

2. Atcolposcopy,twoormorebiopsiesshouldbetaken.(I-A)

3. AnECCshouldbeperformedwhencolposcopyisunsatisfactory,withanAGCpapandinolderwomenwithhigh-gradecytology.(II-2B)

4. RoutineHR-HPVtestingforallcolposcopyreferralsisdiscouraged.(III-C)

Page 10: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

10of34

ManagingwomenwithASCUSorLSILonreferraltoColposcopyManagementoflow-gradeabnormalitiesremainscontroversial.AlargerandomizedtrialintheUSAconcludedthatwomenwithLSILcytologyresultswerebestmanagedbyimmediatereferraltocolposcopy;itwasnotedthat83%werepositiveforHR-HPVandthusHPVtriagewouldnotbeeffective(23).ThesamestudyreportedthatwomenwithASCUSresults,butnegativeforHR-HPV,couldsafelybetriagedawayfromcolposcopy(23).ThisapproachrequiresavailabilityofreflexHPVtesting;unfortunately,thisisnotwidelyavailableinCanada.ArecentmulticenterstudyintheUKevaluatedthemanagementofsimilarlowgradecytology.Outcomesindicatedthatapolicyofimmediatecolposcopyledtoincreasedreferralstocolposcopywithnoclearbenefitandpotentialharm(24).

Withlow-gradelesions,colposcopyisdonetoruleoutpotentiallypre-malignantchangesi.e.,CIN2or3;ifthisisdetected,managementisundertakenaccordingtotheappropriateprotocol.Ameta-analysisreportedCIN2+ratesof10%andCIN3+of6%withanASCUSreferral(25,26).WithanLSILreferral,theratesofCIN2+are17%andCIN3+12%(27,28).IfCIN1isthehighestgradeidentifiedatcolposcopy,conservativemanagementisrecommended.Ifnolesionisidentifiedatcolposcopy,arandombiopsyatthetransformationzoneshouldbeconsidered.Asperconsensusopinion,ifnodysplasiaisidentifiedatcolposcopy,annualscreeningwiththereferringhealthcareproviderisrecommended,untilthreenegativePaptestshavebeenreported.Ifallcytologyisnegative,womenmaythenbefollowedevery2to3years,consistentwithprovincial/territorialguidelines.

Recommendations:

1. Acolposcopicallyidentifiedlesionshouldbebiopsied.(III-C)

2. Ifnolesionisidentified,arandombiopsyofthetransformationzonecouldbeconsidered.(III-C)

ManagingASC-HWithanASC-HresultonthePaptest,significantpathologyistypicallyfoundinthemajorityofcases.Inastudyof517casesfromEdmonton,Alberta,CIN2orgreaterwasdetectedin70%ofcases(29).MostcaseswereCIN2;however,invasivecarcinomawasreportedin2.9%ofcasesandAISin1.7%(29).AsimilarOntariostudyshowedCIN2orgreaterin59.4%ofcaseswithastrongercorrelationinwomenyoungerthan40years(30).AllwomenwithASC-Hshouldhavecolposcopytoruleoutsignificantpathology.Ifcolposcopyisnegative,recommendationsincludecolposcopy,repeatcytologyand,ideally,HR-HPVtestingtwice,atsixmonthintervals,toavoidmissingasignificantlesion.Iftheserepeattestsarenegative,womenmayreturntoregularscreening,asperprovincial/territorialprotocol.ThefindingofASC-Hwithnegativecolposcopydoesnotwarrantaconebiopsyordiagnosticexcisionalprocedurefordiagnosticpurposes.

Recommendations:

Page 11: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

11of34

1. AwomanwithanASC-HPaptestshouldhavecolposcopytoruleoutCIN2/3and/orcancer.(II-2A)

2. WithanASC-HPaptest,thefindingofnegativecolposcopydoesnotautomaticallywarrantadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(III-B)

ManagingHSILTheriskofasignificantlesionishighwithHSILcytology.StudieshaveshownCIN2orgreaterin53-66%ofcaseswhencolposcopicbiopsiesaretaken,andupto90%ifanimmediateLEEPisperformed(31,32).Becauseofthishighrateofsignificanthigh-gradehistology,allwomenwithanHSILresultshouldhavecolposcopy.AvisualassessmentandLEEPapproachmaybeappropriateinsomecircumstances,butacolposcopicallydirectedbiopsyandtailoredtreatmentispreferred.

Ifalesionisnotdetectedatcolposcopy,andcolposcopyisnotsatisfactory,thenadiagnosticexcisionalprocedureshouldbedone.Thiscanbeachievedwithaconebiopsy,orLEEPusingalargeloop,orasecondendocervicalpass.However,ifnolesionwasdetected,andcolposcopywassatisfactory,combinedcolposcopyandcytologyisappropriateatsix-monthintervalsfortwovisits.Thissituationisrare.Amongwomenwhohavefinishedchildbearing,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureshouldbeconsidered.

Recommendations:

1. AllwomenwithanHSILtestresultshouldhavecolposcopy.(II-2A)

2. Intheabsenceofanidentifiablelesionatcolposcopyandunsatisfactorycolposcopy,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.(III-B)

ManagingAtypicalGlandularCytology(AGC-NOS,AGC-N,AIS)ThefindingofAGC-NOS,AGC-NorAISalwayswarrantspromptreferraltocolposcopyintheabsenceofothersymptomatology.Neoplasticlesionsotherthanfromthecervix,includingendometrium,ovaryandfallopiantube,havebeenidentifiedwithAGCcytology(33-35).InaCanadianreport456casesofAGCorAGUSwereidentifiedoutofadatabaseofover1millionPaptests(0.043%)(34).Onfinalhistology7%werefoundtohaveCIN1,36%CIN2or3,AISwasidentifiedin20%,carcinomaofthecervixin9%,andendometrialpathologyin29%,includingcarcinomaoftheendometriumin10%.ItshouldbenotedthatCINisconsistentlythemostfrequentfindingacrossmanystudies(33,34,36,37).ThishighrateofpathologyprecludesanyattempttotriageusingrepeatcytologyorHPVtesting.

ThediagnosisofAGC-Nisassociatedwithhigherratesofabnormalitiesandthus,intheabsenceofanabnormalityfoundbycolposcopy,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed(38,39).Adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureincludesacoldknifeconebiopsy,laserconebiopsyandmayincludeaLEEPifthespecimenisofsufficientsize.Ahysterectomyisnotconsideredasadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.Endocervicalcurettage(ECC)shouldbedoneinallwomen,andendometrialsamplingshouldbeperformedinwomenover35yearsorifthereisahistoryofabnormalbleeding,includinganovulation.

Page 12: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

12of34

However,withAGC-NOScytologyandtheabsenceofanidentifiedlesion,womenarestillatriskofdevelopingalesion.Inthissituation,follow-upassessmenteverysixmonthsfortwoyearsincludesrepeatcytology,colposcopyandECC.IfHR-HPVtestingisavailableandwasdoneattheinitialcolposcopyvisit,womenwhotestnegativeforHR-HPVmayhaverepeatassessmentwithcolposcopy,cytology,ECCandHR-HPVtestingat12months.Ifalesionisidentified,treatmentisguidedbythespecificguideline.Ifacarcinomaisidentified,referralshouldbemadetoagynecologiconcologist.Ifallfollowupisnegativeaftertwoyears,routinecytologictestingmayberesumed.

Recommendations:

1. ThefindingofanAGCPaptestwarrantscolposcopy.(II-2A)

2. AnAGC-NPaptestwithoutanidentifiablelesionatcolposcopyshouldbefollowedwithadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(II-2A)

ManagingSCCandAdenocarcinomaWomenshouldbereferredpromptlytocolposcopyiftheirPaptestissuggestiveofcarcinoma,withorwithoutavisiblelesion.AssessmentshouldincludecolposcopyanddirectedbiopsywithconsiderationofECC.Ifnoabnormalityisdetected,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureisrecommendedtoruleoutoccultcarcinoma.EndometrialbiopsyshouldalsobecontemplatedintheworkupofwomenwithadenocarcinomaonaPaptest.

Recommendation:

1. Womenwithacytologicdiagnosissuggestiveofcarcinoma,withorwithoutavisiblelesion,shouldhavecolposcopy.(IIIA)

ManagingthePatientwithAbnormalHPVTestandNormalCytologyForthosewomenwithASCUSandpositivereflexHR-HPV,womenshouldbereferredtocolposcopy.However,noprovincialguidelinesaddressmanagementofnegativecytologyfindingscombinedwithapositiveHR-HPVresult.

WomenwithnegativecytologyandpositiveHPVresultsshouldhaverepeatsofbothtestsaftertwelvemonths(40,41),withtheirprimaryhealthcareprovider.Ifbothtestsarenegativeat12months,womenshouldreturntoscreeningasperprovincial/territorialguidelines.Womenwithacytologicalabnormalityshouldbemanagedaccordingtothecytologicaldiagnosis.IfthereispersistentHR-HPVontwotestsoneyearapart,referraltocolposcopyisrecommendedtoruleoutthepossibilityofahigh-gradelesion.

Recommendation:

1. WomenwhotestpositiveforHR-HPVandhavenegativecytologyshouldhaverepeattestingat12months.PersistentpositiveHR-HPVtestswarrantcolposcopy.(I-A)

Page 13: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

13of34

ManagingAbnormalCytologyinPregnancyTheindicationsforcolposcopyduringpregnancyareessentiallythesameasfornon-pregnantwomen.Ifalow-gradelesion(ASCUSorLSIL)isfoundduringpregnancy,thePaptestshouldberepeatedatleastsixweekspostpartum.Thispracticeissafeastherateofcancerinthisgroupisverylow(42).IfHSIL,ASC-HorAGCisfound,promptevaluationwithcolposcopyisessential.Ifcolposcopyisunsatisfactoryinthefirsttrimester,itshouldberepeatedafter20weeksgestationwhen,becauseofthephysiologicalchanges,thecervixevertsitselfandthesquamo-columnarjunctionmaybecomevisible.

IfCIN3orcarcinomaissuspected,biopsyisrecommended.Thereisevidencethatbiopsyinpregnancyisnotharmful(43).Womenwithhigh-gradedysplasiainpregnancyshouldbeseenbyanexperiencedcolposcopist.

Recommendations:

1. WomenwithanASCUSorLSILtestresultduringpregnancyshouldhaverepeattestingpostpregnancy.(III-B)

2. WomenwithHSIL,ASC-HorAGCshouldbereferredpromptlyforcolposcopyinpregnancy.(III-B)

3. ECCisnotrecommendedduringpregnancy.(III-B)

ManagingAbnormalCytologyintheAdolescentThereislittleevidencethatscreeningbycytologyinadolescents(lessthan21yearsold)isbeneficial.Theincidenceofcervicalcancerisverylow.SEERdatafromtheUSAshowedarateof0.1/100,000inwomen15-19yearsoldand1.6/100,000inwomen20-24yearsold,comparedto15.5/100,000inwomen40-45yearsold(44).AlthoughHPVinfectionandlow-gradePaptestsarecommoninthisagegroup,mostoftheseinfections,andrelatedcytologicalchanges,willresolvewithoutintervention(45,46).Screeningisinvasiveandcanhaveadversepsychologicalsequelaeespeciallyifitleadstocolposcopyreferral(10,47).

Ifthisscreeningleadstotreatment,treatmentbyLEEPcanlaterbeassociatedwithaslightlyincreasedriskofprematureruptureofmembranesandpretermdelivery(48,49).HPVvaccinationhasrecentlybeeninstitutedinCanadaandthehighefficacyagainstHPV16and18shouldlikelyresultinfewerhighgradelesionsneedingtreatment(50-54).ThiscollectiveevidencehasledtheAmericanCollegeofObstetricsandGynecology,aswellastheprovincesofAlbertaandQuébectorecommendanolderageforscreeninginitiation–until21yearsofage(11,12,55,56).

Amongwomenyoungerthan21years,ifaPaptesthasbeendoneandabnormalitiesaredetectedatscreening,managementshouldbeconservativetoavoidharm.Low-gradechanges,i.e.,ASC-USandLSILregressinupto93%ofcaseswithconservativemanagement.Thuswomenlessthan21yearswithASC-USandLSILresultsshouldhaverepeatcytologyinoneyearwithreferraltocolposcopyonlyifabnormalities

Page 14: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

14of34

persistfor24months(10).Womenyoungerthan21years,withASC-H,HSIL,orAGCresults,shouldbereferredtocolposcopy.

Recommendations:

1. Screeningshouldnotbeinitiatedinwomenlessthan21yearsofage.(II-2A)

2. Ifscreeningisdone,andanASC-USorLSILresultisreported,cytologyshouldberepeatedinoneyear,withreferraltocolposcopyifalow-gradetestresultcontinuesfor24months.(III-B)

3. CytologyresultsofASC-H,HSIL,andAGCintheadolescentshouldbereferredtocolposcopy.(III-B)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesOncealesionhasbeenidentifiedoncolposcopy,andbiopsycompleted,adecisionmustbemaderegardingmanagement.Theaimoftreatmentistoremoveapotentiallyprecancerouslesiontoavoiddevelopmentofcarcinoma.TheinitialclassificationofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaasCIN1,2or3wasproposedbyRichartin1973andsubsequentlyreinforcedbytheWorldHealthOrganizationin1994(57).TherateofprogressionofthesedysplasticlesionshasbeenwellreviewedbyOstor(58)(Table3),andovertimethetherapeuticapproachhasbeenadaptedtoavoidharmwhenlesserCINgradesareunlikelytoprogresstoinvasivecancer.

Treatmentmodalitiesincludeeitherexcisionalorablativeapproaches(cryotherapyorlaserablation).ThefavouredmethodinCanadaisexcisional-theloopelectrosurgicalexcisionprocedure(LEEP).Althoughrelativelyeasytoperformintheoutpatientsetting,therecanbecomplications.Arecentmeta-analysisestimatedthat,afteraLEEPprocedure,theriskforpretermdeliveryinasubsequentpregnancyoflessthan32-34weeksgestation,was1in143treatments(48).Thesameresearchgroupsuggestedthatadepththresholdof10mmisalsoavariableinreducingharm.Consequently,ifthecolposcopistisabletoadjusttheproceduretothelesion,futurenegativesequelaeinpregnancymaybeminimized(59).

Treatmentistailoredtothelesionidentifiedonthecervix,byeitherremovingorablatingtheentiretransformationzone.TheInternationalFederationofCervicalPathologyandColposcopy(IFCPC)hasclassifiedthetransformationzone(TZ)intothreecategories(60).Atype1TZiscompletelyectocervical,andfullyvisible.Atype2TZisfullyvisible,hasanendocervicalcomponentandmayhaveanectocervicalcomponent.Atype3TZispredominantlyendocervical,notfullyvisibleandmayhaveanectocervicalcomponent(Figure1).

Usingthisclassification,ablativemethodscanbeusedforatype1or2TZifrecognizedcriteriaaremet(Table4).IfexcisionwithLEEPisutilizedthesizeofloopelectrodemustbeadjusteddependingonthelesion,i.e.,atype2TZrequiresalargerloopelectrodethanatype1TZtoensurethelesionisfullyexcised.Ifthelesionisnotseeninitsentirety,colposcopyisunsatisfactoryandablativetherapiesshouldnotbeused(60,61).Careshouldbetakentoavoidremovalofexcessive

Page 15: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

15of34

cervicalstromawhichwouldpredisposewomentopretermdelivery,especiallyifusingverylargeloopsortakingmultiplepasses.

Atype3TZwithalesionthatextendsintotheendocervicalcanal,oraglandularlesion,requiresalargerorlongerexcisionforadequateevaluationortreatment.ThisdocumentadoptedthenewIFCPCterminologytoidentifythisprocedureasatype3excisiontoavoidthecurrentconfusioninterminology(62).Currently,conebiopsy,diagnosticexcisionalprocedure,laserexcisionandLEEPmaybeusedbuthavedifferentmeaningstoindividualcolposcopists(61).

ManagingCIN1EvidencefromtherecentALTStrialhasconfirmedsignificantinter-observervariabilityinthehistologicaldiagnosisofCIN1,withtheoverlapoftenobservedwithbenignHPVinfection(63).OurcurrentunderstandingisthatCIN1seldomprogressestoinvasivediseaseandthatitwillregresswithouttreatmentwithin2-5yearsin60-80%ofallcases(58,64).Regressionratesareevenmorepronouncedinadolescents,withregressionoflow-gradesquamousintra-epitheliallesionsinupto91%ofcasesoverathree-yearperiod(65).ThisknowledgehasledtoachangeinthetreatmentphilosophyforCIN1.

ConservativemanagementwithobservationispreferredforCIN1.Womenshouldbefollowedwithrepeatcytologyandcolposcopyat12-monthintervals;ifnolesionisidentifiedshemayreturntoroutinescreening.Ifthelesionpersistsfor24monthsorlonger,treatmentisacceptable.Ifcolposcopyissatisfactory,treatmentmaybebyablativemodalities.Howeverinacompliantpatient,longerfollow-upispossible,especiallyinwomenwhohavenotcompletedchildbearing.

TheexceptiontoaconservativeapproachoccurswhenadiagnosisofCIN1isprecededbyHSILorAGCcytology.Inthesesituations,histologicalfindingshavenotadequatelyexplainedtheabnormalcytologyandanexcisionalprocedureshouldbeconsidered.

Recommendations:

1. BiopsyprovenCIN1shouldbeobservedwithrepeatcolposcopyat12-monthintervals.Persistencebeyond24monthsmaybetreatedorobservedwithrepeatcytologyand/orcolposcopy.(II-1B)

2. Biopsy-provenCIN1afterHSILorAGCcytology,anexcisionalprocedureshouldbeconsidered.(III-B)

ManagingCIN2/3PathologicallyconfirmedhighgradedysplasiaincludesCIN2andCIN3,thesearetreatedinthesamefashioninmostjurisdictions(7,13,66-69).Therearehoweverdifferencesintheratesofregression.TheclassicalreviewbyOstorshowedthatCIN2regressesin43%andprogressedtoCIN3+in27%thiscomparestoregressionof33%persistenceof52%andprogressiontoinvasioninatleast12%ofCIN3cases(58).(SeeTable3.)ThetruemalignantpotentialofCIN3hasbeendemonstratedinNewZealandbylong-termfollow-upofCIN3thatwasnottreated.Thisshowedthat

Page 16: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

16of34

theinvasiveriskinuntreatedCIN3is31%over30years,alsonotingthatpatientswithdocumentedpersistentCIN3for2yearshadariskofsubsequentinvasionof50%(70).

ForthesereasonsmostwomenwithCIN2or3shouldbetreated3.Ifcolposcopyissatisfactory,i.e.,atype1or2TZ,excisionandablativetherapyarebothacceptable;however,anexcisionalprocedureispreferredforthetreatmentofCIN3.IfCIN2or3isidentifiedandcolposcopyisunsatisfactory,anexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.Ifattreatment,marginsarepositiveforCIN,ortheECC(ifdone)ispositive,thesewomenareatincreasedriskofpersistentdysplasia.Inameta-analysisofexcisionaltreatment,theriskofpost-treatmentdiseasewas18%forincompleteexcisionand3%forcompleteexcision(71).Ifthedeepmarginsareinvolved,considerationshouldbemadeforrepeatexcision.Mostwomenshouldbefollowedwithrepeatcolposcopyat6months(72).HysterectomyisnotrecommendedasinitialtherapyforCIN2or3butmaybeperformedforwomenwithpersistentCIN.

Recommendations:

1. CIN2or3shouldbetreated;excisionalproceduresarepreferredforCIN3.(II-1A)

2. Womenwhohavepositivemarginsshouldhaveclosefollow-upwithretreatmentwithexcisionforpersistentdisease.(BII-1B)

ManagingCIN2/3intheAdolescentAsdiscussedearlierthereislittleevidencetojustifyroutinescreeningintheadolescentpatient.Ifhowever,Papscreeningiscompleted,thesepatientsmaybereferredforcolposcopy.Managementmustbemodifiedtoavoidharm.RecentevidencesuggeststhatregressionofCIN2inthispopulationoccursataratesimilartoCIN1(10,46,73,74).

Basedontheevidence,thisgroup’sconsensusopinionisthatCIN2intheadolescentcanbeobservedwithrepeatcolposcopyandcytologyevery6monthsforupto24months.Ifdysplasiapersiststhepatientshouldbetreated,eitherwithablativemethodsoraLEEP.Thisisconditionalonasatisfactorycolposcopy;ifitisunsatisfactory,treatmentshouldbeperformedwithanexcisionalprocedure.ArecentstudylookedatregressionratesofCIN2inwomenlessthan25yearsold,mostwere20-25yearsold,theoverallregressionrateoveramedianof8monthswas62%.Thissuggeststhatobservationmaybereasonableinyoungwomenlessthan25yearsold(20).Insomecenters,high-gradehistologyisdesignatedasHSIL,i.e.,CINterminologyisnotused.IfthebiopsyisreportedasHSILinanadolescentwomanwesuggestareviewofthehistologyusingCINterminology.IfreclassifiedasCIN3,treatmentbyanexcisionalmethodispreferred.

3Remainingwomen–thosewhoareyoungerorpregnant–aremanagedasoutlinedelsewhereinthisdocument.

Page 17: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

17of34

Recommendations:

1. CIN2intheadolescentpatientshouldbeobservedwithcolposcopyat6-monthintervalsforupto24monthsbeforetreatment.(II-2B)

2. CIN3shouldbetreatedintheadolescentpatient.(III-B)

ManagingAdenocarcinomainSitu(AIS)InCanadatheratioofadenocarcinomatosquamouscarcinomaofthecervixisincreasing;adenocarcinomacomprises20-25%ofallcervicalcancer(75).ThisislargelyafunctionofasignificantdecreaseinsquamouscellcancersduetowidespreadavailabilityofscreeningbyPaptestsoverseveraldecades.Nevertheless,implementationofcytologyqualityassuranceinitiativesinrecentyearshasbeenassociatedwithadecreaseinadenocarcinomaofthecervix.

Incontrast,diagnosisofpremalignantadenocarcinomainsitu(AIS)occursataratioof1:50,whencomparedwithseveresquamousdysplasia(76).ConsequentlyacolposcopistwillnotoftenseeAISandthetreatmentremainscontroversial.Colposcopicfeaturescanbedifficulttoidentifyandlesionsoftenextendhighinthecanal(77).Bertrandandcolleaguesshowedthatin78%ofcasesthehighestlesioninthecanalwaslessthan20mmfromtheexocervixandnonewerehigherthan29.9mm(78).Subsequenttoadiagnosisofadenocarcinomainsitueitheronpunchbiopsyorendocervicalcurretage,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedure,ortype3TZexcisionshouldbeperformed.Marginstatusisanimportantpredictorofresidualdisease,andthusthemethodchosenfortreatmentmustpreservetheabilitytoassesstheendocervicalmargin.Arecentmeta-analysisof33studiesshowedthattheriskofresidualdiseasewas2.6%withnegativemarginsand19.4%withpositivemargins.Invasivecarcinomawasalsomorefrequentlyassociatedwithpositivemargins(5.2%)comparedwithnegativemargins(0.1%)(79).Thus,ifmarginsarepositive,asecondexcisionisrequired.

IfAISisdiagnosedaftercompletingaLEEPprocedure(becauseofaCINfinding),themarginsneedtobecarefullyexamined.IftheAISissmallandmarginsareclear,thereisnoneedtoperformanexcisionalprocedureunlesschildbearingiscomplete,whenhysterectomyshouldbeconsidered(80).

Iffertilityisnotanissueoronecannotachievenegativemargins,ahysterectomyisrecommended(79).

AftertreatmentforAIS,ifthewomanwishestopreserveherfertility,shecanbecloselyobservedinthecolposcopyclinic.Sheshouldbeseenforcolposcopy,ECCandcytologyevery6to12months,foratleast5years.HR-HPVtestingcanbeutilizedtoaidreassurance.Thereafterthepatientshouldhaveannualcytology.

Recommendations:

1. IfAISisdiagnosed,treatmentneedstobedonewithadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure,ortype3TZexcision.(II-2A)

Page 18: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

18of34

2. Ifmarginsarepositiveafterdiagnosticexcisionalprocedure,asecondexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.(II-2A)

3. IfaftertreatmentforAISawomanhasfinishedchildbearing,ahysterectomyshouldbeconsidered.(III-B)

4. IfAISisdiagnosedafterLEEPisperformedforCINinawomanwhohasnotcompletedherfamilyandmarginsarenegative,itisunnecessarytoperformafurtherdiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(II-2A)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesDuringPregnancyTheaimofcolposcopyinpregnancyistoruleoutadiagnosisofinvasiveormicro-invasivecarcinoma.Ifdiagnosed,thesecasesshouldbepromptlyreferredtoagynecologiconcologist.IfCIN2orCIN3isdiagnosedduringpregnancy,theavailableevidencewouldsuggestthattreatmentcanbedelayeduntilafterdelivery.TheriskofprogressionisnotaffectedbythepregnancyandregressiontoCIN1ornormalpostpregnancyisbetween31and47%(81,82).

Recommendations:

1. IfCIN2orCIN3isdiagnosedduringpregnancy,treatmentshouldbedelayeduntilafterdelivery.(II-2A)

Follow-upPostTreatmentOncetreatedforCINorAIS,awomanremainsatriskofpersistenceorrecurrenceandatlong-termriskofinvasivecarcinoma(13,83,84).FailureratesfollowingtreatmentforCINdonotvarysignificantlywiththetreatmentmethodusedandinpublishedseriesarebetween5%and13%(85,86).Theaimoffollow-upistodetectpersistentorrecurrentdysplasia.

ConventionallyinCanada,womenarefollowedaftertreatmentwithcolposcopyandcytologyat6monthintervalsfor1to2years,priortoreturningtocytologyonanannualbasiswiththeirprimaryhealthcareprovider.InrecentyearstheavailabilityofHR-HPVtestinghasraisedthepossibilityofitsusetofollowwomenandpotentiallydetectrecurrenceorpersistenceearlier.Reviewsandmeta-analyseshaveevaluatedthisapproachanddemonstratethatHPVtestingmaybemoresensitivefordetectingrecurrence(87-91).Ithasbeennotedthatanadequatelypoweredprospectivetrialisneededtotrulyevaluatethisissue(91,92).SuchatrialisunderwayinseveralCanadiancenters(93).

Recommendations:

1. Post-treatmentforCIN2or3:womenshouldbefollowedwithcytologyandcolposcopyat6monthintervalsfortwovisits,aslongasbothcytologyandanybiopsiesarenegative.(II-2B)

2. Post-treatmentforCIN2or3:HPVtestingat6or12monthscombinedwithcytology.IfbothcytologyandHPVtestingarenegative,returningtoannualorbiannualcytologyisareasonableoption.(II-2B)

Page 19: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

19of34

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesinHigh-RiskIndividualsNumerousmedicalconditionsreportedlyaffecttheabilitytolimitprogressionofHPVinfectiontodysplasia,andhenceareassociatedwithdysplasia.Theseincludetransplantationwithassociatedimmunosuppression,medicationforconditionssuchasCrohn'sDisease,rheumatoidarthritis,diabetesorHIVinfection.MostavailableinformationrelatestotransplantandHIVpatients.Inareviewfrom1995,144womenwerefollowedafterrenaltransplant.Therewasa17.5%incidenceofdysplasia(94).Similaroutcomeswerereportedafterlivertransplantaswellas13%incidenceofHSIL(95).ThelinkbetweencervicalcancerandHIViswelldocumented.Therateofcervicalcancerisupto4-6timeshigherinHIV-positivewomen(96).Inrecentyearsimprovedsurvivalhasbeenattributedtotheavailabilityofhighlyactiveantiretroviraltherapy(HAART)(96).Inareviewof400womenwhowereHIV-positiveinCapeTown,high-riskHPVwaspresentin68%ofthesewomenand55%hadabnormalPapsmears.MostPaptestresultswerelow-gradechanges,ofwhichonly4%progressed,13%wereHSIL(97).InonereviewfromNorthAmericatheratesofCIN2+withanASCUS/LSILreferralwere13.3%inHIV-negativewomenand15.3inHIV-positivewomen(98).ThereisnogoodevidencetorecommendroutinecolposcopyinthisgroupandtheycanbescreenedwithannualPaptests(99).IfatcolposcopyCIN1isdiagnosedthesewomencanbeobservedandtreatedforpersistentdisease.CIN2/3needtobetreatedandexcisionalmethodsarepreferred.Thereisahighrateofrecurrencethusawideexcisionshouldbeused(100).HAARTtherapyseemstodecreaserecurrence.Recommendations:

1. Immunocompromisedwomenshouldbescreenedannuallybutnotwithcolposcopy.(II-2B)

2. Immunocompromisedwomenshouldbetreatedwithanexcisionalproceduretakingcaretominimizepositivemargins.(II-2B)

Recommendations

WaitTimesforColposcopy5. WomenwithHSILareideallyseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin4weeksof

referral.(III-C)

6. WomenwithASC-HorAGCshouldbeseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin6weeksofreferral.(III-C)

7. WomenwithaPaptestsuggestiveofcarcinomashouldbeseenwithin2weeksofreferral.(III-C)

Page 20: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

20of34

8. Otherresultsshouldbeseeninacolposcopyclinicwithin8weeksofreferral.(III-C)

TheColposcopyExam5. Colposcopicfindingscanbedescribedaccordingtotheterminologydefined

bytheInternationalFederationforCervicalPathologyandColposcopy.(III-C)

6. Atcolposcopy,twoormorebiopsiesshouldbetaken.(I-A)

7. AnECCshouldbeperformedwhencolposcopyisunsatisfactory,withanAGCpapandinolderwomenwithhigh-gradecytology.(II-2B)

8. RoutineHR-HPVtestingforallcolposcopyreferralsisdiscouraged.(III-C)

ManagingwomenwithASCUSorLSILonreferraltoColposcopy3. Acolposcopicallyidentifiedlesionshouldbebiopsied.(III-C)

4. Ifnolesionisidentified,arandombiopsyofthetransformationzonecouldbeconsidered.(III-C)

ManagingASC-H3. AwomanwithanASC-HPaptestshouldhavecolposcopytoruleoutCIN2/3

and/orcancer.(II-2A)

4. WithanASC-HPaptest,thefindingofnegativecolposcopydoesnotautomaticallywarrantadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(III-B)

ManagingHSIL3. AllwomenwithanHSILtestresultshouldhavecolposcopy.(II-2A)

4. Intheabsenceofanidentifiablelesionatcolposcopyandunsatisfactorycolposcopy,adiagnosticexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.(III-B)

ManagingAtypicalGlandularCytology(AGC-NOS,AGC-N,AIS)3. ThefindingofanAGCPaptestwarrantscolposcopy.(II-2A)

4. AnAGC-NPaptestwithoutanidentifiablelesionatcolposcopyshouldbefollowedwithadiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(II-2A)

ManagingSCCandAdenocarcinoma2. Womenwithacytologicdiagnosissuggestiveofcarcinoma,withorwithouta

visiblelesion,shouldhavecolposcopy.(IIIA)

ManagingthePatientwithAbnormalHPVTestandNormalCytology2. WomenwhotestpositiveforHR-HPVandhavenegativecytologyshould

haverepeattestingat12months.PersistentpositiveHR-HPVtestswarrantcolposcopy.(IA)

Page 21: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

21of34

ManagingAbnormalCytologyinPregnancy4. WomenwithanASCUSorLSILtestresultduringpregnancyshouldhave

repeattestingpostpregnancy.(III-B)

5. WomenwithHSIL,ASC-HorAGCshouldbereferredpromptlyforcolposcopyinpregnancy.(III-B)

6. ECCisnotrecommendedduringpregnancy.(III-B)

ManagingAbnormalCytologyintheAdolescent4. Screeningshouldnotbeinitiatedinwomenlessthan21yearsofage.(II-2A)

5. Ifscreeningisdone,andanASC-USorLSILresultisreported,cytologyshouldberepeatedinoneyear,withreferraltocolposcopyifalow-gradetestresultcontinuesfor24months.(III-B)

6. CytologyresultsofASC-H,HSIL,andAGCintheadolescentshouldbereferredtocolposcopy.(III-B)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalities

ManagingCIN13. BiopsyprovenCIN1shouldbeobservedwithrepeatcolposcopyat12-month

intervals.Persistencebeyond24monthsmaybetreatedorobservedwithrepeatcytologyand/orcolposcopy.(II-1B)

4. Biopsy-provenCIN1afterHSILorAGCcytology,anexcisionalprocedureshouldbeconsidered.(III-B)

ManagingCIN2/33. CIN2or3shouldbetreated;excisionalproceduresarepreferredforCIN3.

(II-1A)

4. Womenwhohavepositivemarginsshouldhaveclosefollow-upwithretreatmentwithexcisionforpersistentdisease.(II-1B)

ManagingCIN2/3intheAdolescent3. CIN2intheadolescentpatientshouldbeobservedwithcolposcopyat6-

monthintervalsforupto24monthsbeforetreatment.(II-2B)

4. CIN3shouldbetreatedintheadolescentpatient.(III-B)

ManagingAdenocarcinomainSitu(AIS)5. IfAISisdiagnosed,treatmentneedstobedonewithadiagnosticexcisional

procedure,ortype3TZexcision.(II-2A)

6. Ifmarginsarepositiveafterdiagnosticexcisionalprocedure,asecondexcisionalprocedureshouldbeperformed.(II-2A)

7. IfaftertreatmentforAISawomanhasfinishedchildbearing,ahysterectomyshouldbeconsidered.(III-B)

Page 22: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

22of34

8. IfAISisdiagnosedafterLEEPisperformedforCINinawomanwhohasnotcompletedherfamilyandmarginsarenegative,itisunnecessarytoperformafurtherdiagnosticexcisionalprocedure.(II-2A)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesDuringPregnancy2. IfCIN2orCIN3isdiagnosedduringpregnancy,treatmentshouldbedelayed

untilafterdelivery.(II-2A)

Follow-upPostTreatment3. Post-treatmentforCIN2or3:womenshouldbefollowedwithcytologyand

colposcopyat6monthintervalsfortwovisits,aslongasbothcytologyandanybiopsiesarenegative.(II-2B)

4. Post-treatmentforCIN2or3:HPVtestingat6or12monthscombinedwithcytology.IfbothcytologyandHPVtestingarenegative,returningtoannualorbiannualcytologyisareasonableoption.(II-2B)

ManagingHistologicalAbnormalitiesinHigh-RiskIndividuals3. Immunocompromisedwomenshouldbescreenedannuallybutnotwith

colposcopy.(II-2B)

4. Immunocompromisedwomenshouldbetreatedwithanexcisionalproceduretakingcaretominimizepositivemargins.(II-2B)

References

(1)CanadianCancerSociety'sSteeringCommittee.CanadianCancerStatistics.2009.

(2)InternationalAgencyforResearchonCancer,WorldHealthOrganization.IARCHandbooksofCancerPrevention:CervixCancerScreening.Lyon:IARCPress;2005.

(3)FerrisDG,CoxJT,O'ConnorDM,WrightVC,FoersterJ.ModernColposcopyTextbookandAtlas.:Kendall/HuntPublishingCompany;2004.

(4)WorkingGroupofCervicalScreenSingapore.ManagementGuidelinesforAbnormalPapSmear&InvasiveDiseaseoftheCervix.2002.

(5)AustralianNationalHealthandMedicalResearchCouncil.Screeningtopreventcervicalcancer:guidelinesforthemanagementofasymptomaticwomenwithscreendetectedabnormalities.2005.

(6)WrightTC,Jr,MassadLS,DuntonCJ,SpitzerM,WilkinsonEJ,SolomonD,etal.2006ConsensusGuidelinesfortheManagementofWomenwithCervicalIntraepithelialNeoplasiaOrAdenocarcinomainSitu.JLowGenitTractDis2007Oct;11(4):223-239.

(7)NationalHealthService.ColposcopyandProgrammeManagement:GuidelinesfortheNHSCervicalScreeningProgramme,2ndEdition.2010;Availableat:

Page 23: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

23of34

http://www.cancerscreening.nhs.uk/cervical/publications/nhscsp20.html.Accessed02/28,2011.

(8)ArbynM,AnttilaA,JordanJ,RoncoG,SchenckU,SegnanN,etal.EuropeanGuidelinesforQualityAssuranceinCervicalCancerScreening.Secondedition--summarydocument.AnnOncol2010Mar;21(3):448-458.

(9)MurphyKJ,HowlettRI.ScreeningforCervicalCancer.JOGC2007;29(8):S27-S36.

(10)MoscickiAB,CoxJT.Practiceimprovementincervicalscreeningandmanagement(PICSM):symposiumonmanagementofcervicalabnormalitiesinadolescentsandyoungwomen.JLowGenitTractDis2010Jan;14(1):73-80.

(11)InstitutnationaledesantepubliqueQuebec.RecommendationsonoptimizingcervicalcancerscreeninginQuébec.2009;Availableat:http://www.inspq.qc.ca/pdf/publications/1081_CervicalScreening.pdf.Accessed03/11,2011.

(12)AlbertaHealthServices.AlbertaCervicalCancerScreening:ClinicalPracticeGuidelinesandManagementofAbnormalCytology.2009;Availableat:http://www.screeningforlife.ca/_files/file.php?fileid=filenrNvasUkRV&filename=file_CC_CPG_Summary_Chart_LowR_Mar_2010.pdf.Accessed03/11,2011.

(13)WrightTC,Jr,MassadLS,DuntonCJ,SpitzerM,WilkinsonEJ,SolomonD,etal.2006ConsensusGuidelinesfortheManagementofWomenwithAbnormalCervicalCancerScreeningTests.AmJObstetGynecol2007Oct;197(4):346-355.

(14)WrightTC,Jr,MassadLS,DuntonCJ,SpitzerM,WilkinsonEJ,SolomonD,etal.2006ConsensusGuidelinesfortheManagementofWomenwithCervicalIntraepithelialNeoplasiaOrAdenocarcinomainSitu.AmJObstetGynecol2007Oct;197(4):340-345.

(15)SolomonD,DaveyD,KurmanR,MoriartyA,O'ConnorD,PreyM,etal.The2001BethesdaSystem:terminologyforreportingresultsofcervicalcytology.JAMA2002Apr24;287(16):2114-2119.

(16)LeT,HopkinsL,MenardC,Hicks-BoucherW,LefebvreJ,FungKeeFungM.Psychologicmorbiditiespriortoloopelectrosurgicalexcisionprocedureinthetreatmentofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia.IntJGynecolCancer2006May-Jun;16(3):1089-1093.

(17)FarrellS,RoyeC,CraneJ,DavisD,HeywoodM,LalondeA,etal.Statementonwaittimesinobstetricsandgynaecology.JObstetGynaecolCan2008Mar;30(3):248-270.

(18)KupetsR,PaszatL.HowarewomenwithhighgradePapsmearabnormalitiesmanaged?Apopulationbasedstudy.GynecolOncol2011Jun1;121(3):499-504.

(19)WalkerP,DexeusS,DePaloG,BarrassoR,CampionM,GirardiF,etal.Internationalterminologyofcolposcopy:anupdatedreportfromtheInternational

Page 24: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

24of34

FederationforCervicalPathologyandColposcopy.ObstetGynecol2003Jan;101(1):175-177.

(20)GageJC,HansonVW,AbbeyK,DipperyS,GardnerS,KubotaJ,etal.Numberofcervicalbiopsiesandsensitivityofcolposcopy.ObstetGynecol2006Aug;108(2):264-272.

(21)ZuchnaC,HagerM,TringlerB,GeorgoulopoulosA,Ciresa-KoenigA,VolggerB,etal.Diagnosticaccuracyofguidedcervicalbiopsies:aprospectivemulticenterstudycomparingthehistopathologyofsimultaneousbiopsyandconespecimen.AmJObstetGynecol2010Oct;203(4):321.e1-321.e6.

(22)GageJC,DugganMA,NationJG,GaoS,CastlePE.Detectionofcervicalcanceranditsprecursorsbyendocervicalcurettagein13,115colposcopicallyguidedbiopsyexaminations.AmJObstetGynecol2010Aug26.

(23)ASCUS-LSILTriageStudy(ALTS)Group.Arandomizedtrialonthemanagementoflow-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesioncytologyinterpretations.AmJObstetGynecol2003Jun;188(6):1393-1400.

(24)TOMBOLAGroup.Cytologicalsurveillancecomparedwithimmediatereferralforcolposcopyinmanagementofwomenwithlowgradecervicalabnormalities:multicentrerandomisedcontrolledtrial.BMJ2009Jul28;339:b2546.

(25)ArbynM,DillnerJ,VanRanstM,BuntinxF,Martin-HirschP,ParaskevaidisE.Re:Haveweresolvedhowtotriageequivocalcervicalcytology?JNatlCancerInst2004Sep15;96(18):1401-2;authorreply1402.

(26)ArbynM,BuntinxF,VanRanstM,ParaskevaidisE,Martin-HirschP,DillnerJ.VirologicversuscytologictriageofwomenwithequivocalPapsmears:ameta-analysisoftheaccuracytodetecthigh-gradeintraepithelialneoplasia.JNatlCancerInst2004Feb18;96(4):280-293.

(27)ArbynM,ParaskevaidisE,Martin-HirschP,PrendivilleW,DillnerJ.ClinicalutilityofHPV-DNAdetection:triageofminorcervicallesions,follow-upofwomentreatedforhigh-gradeCIN:anupdateofpooledevidence.GynecolOncol2005Dec;99(3Suppl1):S7-11.

(28)ArbynM,SasieniP,MeijerCJ,ClavelC,KoliopoulosG,DillnerJ.Chapter9:ClinicalapplicationsofHPVtesting:asummaryofmeta-analyses.Vaccine2006Aug31;24Suppl3:S3/78-89.

(29)BarrethD,SchepanskyA,CapstickV,JohnsonG,SteedH,FaughtW.Atypicalsquamouscells-cannotexcludehigh-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesion(ASC-H):aresultnottobeignored.JObstetGynaecolCan2006Dec;28(12):1095-1098.

(30)MokhtarGA,DelatourNL,AssiriAH,GilliattMA,SentermanM,IslamS.Atypicalsquamouscells,cannotexcludehigh-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesion:

Page 25: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

25of34

cytohistologiccorrelationstudywithdiagnosticpitfalls.ActaCytol2008Mar-Apr;52(2):169-177.

(31)MassadLS,CollinsYC,MeyerPM.BiopsycorrelatesofabnormalcervicalcytologyclassifiedusingtheBethesdasystem.GynecolOncol2001Sep;82(3):516-522.

(32)DunnTS,BurkeM,ShwayderJ.A"seeandtreat"managementforhigh-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesionpapsmears.JLowGenitTractDis2003Apr;7(2):104-106.

(33)TamKF,CheungAN,LiuKL,NgTY,PunTC,ChanYM,etal.Aretrospectivereviewonatypicalglandularcellsofundeterminedsignificance(AGUS)usingtheBethesda2001classification.GynecolOncol2003Dec;91(3):603-607.

(34)DanielA,BarrethD,SchepanskyA,JohnsonG,CapstickV,FaughtW.Histologicandclinicalsignificanceofatypicalglandularcellsonpapsmears.IntJGynaecolObstet2005Dec;91(3):238-242.

(35)CastlePE,FettermanB,PoitrasN,LoreyT,ShaberR,KinneyW.Relationshipofatypicalglandularcellcytology,age,andhumanpapillomavirusdetectiontocervicalandendometrialcancerrisks.ObstetGynecol2010Feb;115(2Pt1):243-248.

(36)ZhaoC,FloreaA,OniskoA,AustinRM.Histologicfollow-upresultsin662patientswithPaptestfindingsofatypicalglandularcells:resultsfromalargeacademicwomenshospitallaboratoryemployingsensitivescreeningmethods.GynecolOncol2009Sep;114(3):383-389.

(37)CastlePE,FettermanB,PoitrasN,LoreyT,ShaberR,KinneyW.Relationshipofatypicalglandularcellcytology,age,andhumanpapillomavirusdetectiontocervicalandendometrialcancerrisks.ObstetGynecol2010Feb;115(2Pt1):243-248.

(38)SchnatzPF,GuileM,O'SullivanDM,SoroskyJI.Clinicalsignificanceofatypicalglandularcellsoncervicalcytology.ObstetGynecol2006Mar;107(3):701-708.

(39)UllalA,RobertsM,BulmerJN,MathersME,WadehraV.Theroleofcervicalcytologyandcolposcopyindetectingcervicalglandularneoplasia.Cytopathology2009Dec;20(6):359-366.

(40)CuzickJ,SzarewskiA,CubieH,HulmanG,KitchenerH,LuesleyD,etal.Managementofwomenwhotestpositiveforhigh-risktypesofhumanpapillomavirus:theHARTstudy.Lancet2003Dec6;362(9399):1871-1876.

(41)CastlePE,FettermanB,ThomasCoxJ,ShaberR,PoitrasN,LoreyT,etal.Theage-specificrelationshipsofabnormalcytologyandhumanpapillomavirusDNAresultstotheriskofcervicalprecancerandcancer.ObstetGynecol2010Jul;116(1):76-84.

Page 26: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

26of34

(42)WettaLA,MatthewsKS,KemperML,WhitworthJM,FainET,HuhWK,etal.Themanagementofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaduringpregnancy:iscolposcopynecessary?JLowGenitTractDis2009Jul;13(3):182-185.

(43)KohanS,BeckmanEM,BigelowB,KleinSA,DouglasGW.Theroleofcolposcopyinthemanagementofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaduringpregnancyandpostpartum.JReprodMed1980Nov;25(5):279-284.

(44)RiesL,MelbertD,Krapcho,M.(eds.),etal.SEERCancerStatisticsReview,1975-2004.2007.

(45)MountSL,PapilloJL.Astudyof10,296pediatricandadolescentPapanicolaousmeardiagnosesinnorthernNewEngland.Pediatrics1999Mar;103(3):539-545.

(46)MoscickiAB,MaY,WibbelsmanC,DarraghTM,PowersA,FarhatS,etal.Rateofandrisksforregressionofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia2inadolescentsandyoungwomen.ObstetGynecol2010Dec;116(6):1373-1380.

(47)LeT,HopkinsL,MenardC,Hicks-BoucherW,LefebvreJ,FungKeeFungM.Psychologicmorbiditiespriortoloopelectrosurgicalexcisionprocedureinthetreatmentofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia.IntJGynecolCancer2006May-Jun;16(3):1089-1093.

(48)ArbynM,KyrgiouM,SimoensC,RaifuAO,KoliopoulosG,Martin-HirschP,etal.Perinatalmortalityandothersevereadversepregnancyoutcomesassociatedwithtreatmentofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia:meta-analysis.BMJ2008Sep18;337:a1284.

(49)SamsonSL,BentleyJR,FaheyTJ,McKayDJ,GillGH.Theeffectofloopelectrosurgicalexcisionprocedureonfuturepregnancyoutcome.ObstetGynecol2005Feb;105(2):325-332.

(50)FUTUREIIStudyGroup.Quadrivalentvaccineagainsthumanpapillomavirustopreventhigh-gradecervicallesions.NEnglJMed2007May10;356(19):1915-1927.

(51)KohliM,FerkoN,MartinA,FrancoEL,JenkinsD,GallivanS,etal.Estimatingthelong-termimpactofaprophylactichumanpapillomavirus16/18vaccineontheburdenofcervicalcancerintheUK.BrJCancer2007Jan15;96(1):143-150.

(52)CuttsFT,FranceschiS,GoldieS,CastellsagueX,deSanjoseS,GarnettG,etal.HumanpapillomavirusandHPVvaccines:areview.BullWorldHealthOrgan2007Sep;85(9):719-726.

(53)RogozaRM,FerkoN,BentleyJ,MeijerCJ,BerkhofJ,WangKL,etal.Optimizationofprimaryandsecondarycervicalcancerpreventionstrategiesinaneraofcervicalcancervaccination:amulti-regionalhealtheconomicanalysis.Vaccine2008Sep15;26Suppl5:F46-58.

(54)PaavonenJ,NaudP,SalmeronJ,WheelerCM,ChowSN,ApterD,etal.Efficacyofhumanpapillomavirus(HPV)-16/18AS04-adjuvantedvaccineagainstcervical

Page 27: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

27of34

infectionandprecancercausedbyoncogenicHPVtypes(PATRICIA):finalanalysisofadouble-blind,randomisedstudyinyoungwomen.Lancet2009Jul25;374(9686):301-314.

(55)ACOGCommitteeonGynecologicalPractice.ACOGcommitteeopinionNo.431:routinepelvicexaminationandcervicalcytologyscreening.ObstetGynecol2009May;113(5):1190-1193.

(56)ACOGCommitteeonPracticeBulletins--Gynecology.ACOGPracticeBulletinno.109:Cervicalcytologyscreening.ObstetGynecol2009Dec;114(6):1409-1420.

(57)ScullyRE.Histologicaltypingoffemalegenitaltracttumours1994:189.

(58)OstorAG.Naturalhistoryofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia:acriticalreview.IntJGynecolPathol1993Apr;12(2):186-192.

(59)KyrgiouM,TsoumpouI,VrekoussisT,Martin-HirschP,ArbynM,PrendivilleW,etal.Theup-to-dateevidenceoncolposcopypracticeandtreatmentofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia:theCochranecolposcopy&cervicalcytopathologycollaborativegroup(C5group)approach.CancerTreatRev2006Nov;32(7):516-523.

(60)WalkerP,DexeusS,DePaloG,BarrassoR,CampionM,GirardiF,etal.Internationalterminologyofcolposcopy:anupdatedreportfromtheInternationalFederationforCervicalPathologyandColposcopy.ObstetGynecol2003Jan;101(1):175-177.

(61)PrendivilleW.ThetreatmentofCIN:whataretherisks?Cytopathology2009Jun;20(3):145-153.

(62)BornsteinJ.PersonalCommunicationRegardingManuscriptSubmittedforPublication.July2011.

(63)StolerMH,SchiffmanM,AtypicalSquamousCellsofUndeterminedSignificance-Low-gradeSquamousIntraepithelialLesionTriageStudy(ALTS)Group.Interobserverreproducibilityofcervicalcytologicandhistologicinterpretations:realisticestimatesfromtheASCUS-LSILTriageStudy.JAMA2001Mar21;285(11):1500-1505.

(64)PetryKU.Managementoptionsforcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia.BestPractResClinObstetGynaecol2011Oct;25(5):641-651.

(65)MoscickiAB,ShiboskiS,HillsNK,PowellKJ,JayN,HansonEN,etal.Regressionoflow-gradesquamousintra-epitheliallesionsinyoungwomen.Lancet2004Nov6-12;364(9446):1678-1683.

(66)TheSocietyforColposcopyandCervicalPathologyofSingapore.Structuredcolposcopytrainingprogrammeandregistrationforms.Availableat:http://www.sccps.org/training.htm.Accessed02/13,2006.

Page 28: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

28of34

(67)JonesRW,BestDV,CoxB,FitzgeraldNW,HillM,JenningsP,etal.Guidelinesforthemanagementofwomenwithabnormalcervicalsmears1998.NZMedJ2000May12;113(1109):168-171.

(68)RoyalCollegeofObstetriciansandGynaecologists.Standardsincolposcopy.Availableat:http://www.rcog.org.uk/index.asp?PageID=1170.Accessed02/13,2006.

(69)NationalCervicalScreeningProgram(Australia).ScreeningtoPreventCervicalCancer:GuidelinesfortheManagementofAsymptomaticWomenwithScreenDetectedAbnormalities.2005;Availableat:http://www.health.gov.au/internet/screening/publishing.nsf/Content/guide.Accessed03/16,2011.

(70)McCredieMR,SharplesKJ,PaulC,BaranyaiJ,MedleyG,JonesRW,etal.Naturalhistoryofcervicalneoplasiaandriskofinvasivecancerinwomenwithcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia3:aretrospectivecohortstudy.LancetOncol2008May;9(5):425-434.

(71)Ghaem-MaghamiS,SagiS,MajeedG,SoutterWP.Incompleteexcisionofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaandriskoftreatmentfailure:ameta-analysis.LancetOncol2007Nov;8(11):985-993.

(72)Ghaem-MaghamiS,SoutterWP.Re:EffectofmarginstatusoncervicalintraepithelialneoplasiarecurrencefollowingLLETZinwomenover50years.BJOG2009Feb;116(3):465.

(73)ASCUS-LSILTriageStudy(ALTS)Group.Resultsofarandomizedtrialonthemanagementofcytologyinterpretationsofatypicalsquamouscellsofundeterminedsignificance.AmJObstetGynecol2003Jun;188(6):1383-1392.

(74)MooreK,CoferA,ElliotL,LanneauG,WalkerJ,GoldMA.Adolescentcervicaldysplasia:histologicevaluation,treatment,andoutcomes.AmJObstetGynecol2007Aug;197(2):141.e1-141.e6.

(75)HowlettRI,MarrettLD,InnesMK,RosenBP,McLachlinCM.DecreasingincidenceofcervicaladenocarcinomainOntario:isthisrelatedtoimprovedendocervicalPaptestsampling?IntJCancer2007Jan15;120(2):362-367.

(76)EtheringtonIJ,LuesleyDM.Adenocarcinomainsituofthecervix-controversiesindiagnosisandtreatment.JLowGenitTractDis2001Apr;5(2):94-98.

(77)CullimoreJE,LuesleyDM,RollasonTP,ByrneP,BuckleyCH,AndersonM,etal.Aprospectivestudyofconizationofthecervixinthemanagementofcervicalintraepithelialglandularneoplasia(CIGN)--apreliminaryreport.BrJObstetGynaecol1992Apr;99(4):314-318.

Page 29: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

29of34

(78)BertrandM,LickrishGM,ColganTJ.Theanatomicdistributionofcervicaladenocarcinomainsitu:implicationsfortreatment.AmJObstetGynecol1987Jul;157(1):21-25.

(79)SalaniR,PuriI,BristowRE.Adenocarcinomainsituoftheuterinecervix:ametaanalysisof1278patientsevaluatingthepredictivevalueofconizationmarginstatus.AmJObstetGynecol2009Feb;200(2):182.e1-182.e5.

(80)BrysonP,StulbergR,ShepherdL,McLellandK,JeffreyJ.IselectrosurgicalloopexcisionwithnegativemarginssufficienttreatmentforcervicalACIS?GynecolOncol2004May;93(2):465-468.

(81)SeratiM,UccellaS,LaterzaRM,SalvatoreS,BerettaP,RivaC,etal.Naturalhistoryofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaduringpregnancy.ActaObstetGynecolScand2008;87(12):1296-1300.

(82)FaderAN,AlwardEK,NiederhauserA,ChiricoC,LesnockJL,ZwieslerDJ,etal.Cervicaldysplasiainpregnancy:amulti-institutionalevaluation.AmJObstetGynecol2010Aug;203(2):113.e1-113.e6.

(83)SoutterWP,SasieniP,PanoskaltsisT.Long-termriskofinvasivecervicalcanceraftertreatmentofsquamouscervicalintraepithelialneoplasia.IntJCancer2006Apr15;118(8):2048-2055.

(84)MelnikowJ,McGahanC,SawayaGF,EhlenT,ColdmanA.Cervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaoutcomesaftertreatment:long-termfollow-upfromtheBritishColumbiaCohortStudy.JNatlCancerInst2009May20;101(10):721-728.

(85)SoutterWP,deBarrosLopesA,FletcherA,MonaghanJM,DuncanID,ParaskevaidisE,etal.Invasivecervicalcancerafterconservativetherapyforcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia.Lancet1997Apr5;349(9057):978-980.

(86)MitchellMF,Tortolero-LunaG,CookE,WhittakerL,Rhodes-MorrisH,SilvaE.Arandomizedclinicaltrialofcryotherapy,laservaporization,andloopelectrosurgicalexcisionfortreatmentofsquamousintraepitheliallesionsofthecervix.ObstetGynecol1998Nov;92(5):737-744.

(87)ParaskevaidisE,ArbynM,SotiriadisA,DiakomanolisE,Martin-HirschP,KoliopoulosG,etal.TheroleofHPVDNAtestinginthefollow-upperiodaftertreatmentforCIN:asystematicreviewoftheliterature.CancerTreatRev2004Apr;30(2):205-211.

(88)ArbynM,ParaskevaidisE,Martin-HirschP,PrendivilleW,DillnerJ.ClinicalutilityofHPV-DNAdetection:triageofminorcervicallesions,follow-upofwomentreatedforhigh-gradeCIN:anupdateofpooledevidence.GynecolOncol2005Dec;99(3Suppl1):S7-11.

(89)CuzickJ,ArbynM,SankaranarayananR,TsuV,RoncoG,MayrandMH,etal.Overviewofhumanpapillomavirus-basedandothernoveloptionsforcervical

Page 30: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

30of34

cancerscreeningindevelopedanddevelopingcountries.Vaccine2008Aug19;26Suppl10:K29-41.

(90)MeijerCJ,BerkhofJ,CastlePE,HesselinkAT,FrancoEL,RoncoG,etal.GuidelinesforhumanpapillomavirusDNAtestrequirementsforprimarycervicalcancerscreeninginwomen30yearsandolder.IntJCancer2009Feb1;124(3):516-520.

(91)ChanBK,MelnikowJ,SleeCA,ArellanesR,SawayaGF.Posttreatmenthumanpapillomavirustestingforrecurrentcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia:asystematicreview.AmJObstetGynecol2009Apr;200(4):422.e1-422.e9.

(92)KitchenerHC,WalkerPG,NelsonL,HadwinR,PatnickJ,AnthonyGB,etal.HPVtestingasanadjuncttocytologyinthefollowupofwomentreatedforcervicalintraepithelialneoplasia.BJOG2008Jul;115(8):1001-1007.

(93)MayrandMH,AbrahamowiczM,JamesBentleyJ,BessetteP,CoutléeF,EhlenT,ElitL,Fung-Kee-FungM,LauS,PlanteM.Colposcopyvs.HPVtestingtoidentitypersistentpre-cancersposttreatment:theCoHIPPtrial.HPV2010Conference2010June2010.

(94)terHaar-vanEckSA,Rischen-VosJ,Chadha-AjwaniS,HuikeshovenFJ.Theincidenceofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiaamongwomenwithrenaltransplantinrelationtocyclosporine.BrJObstetGynaecol1995Jan;102(1):58-61.

(95)DavidM,OlbrichC,NeuhausR,LichteneggerW.Occurrenceofsuspiciouschangesincervixcytologyinwomenafterlivertransplantation.GeburtshilfeFrauenheilkd1995Aug;55(8):431-434.

(96)CliffordGM,FranceschiS.CancerriskinHIV-infectedpersons:influenceofCD4(+)count.FutureOncol2009Jun;5(5):669-678.

(97)DennyL,BoaR,WilliamsonAL,AllanB,HardieD,StanR,etal.Humanpapillomavirusinfectionandcervicaldiseaseinhumanimmunodeficiencyvirus-1-infectedwomen.ObstetGynecol2008Jun;111(6):1380-1387.

(98)BoardmanLA,CotterK,RakerC,Cu-UvinS.Cervicalintraepithelialneoplasiagrade2orworseinhumanimmunodeficiencyvirus-infectedwomenwithmildlyabnormalcervicalcytology.ObstetGynecol2008Aug;112(2Pt1):238-243.

(99)KitchenerH,NelsonL,AdamsJ,MesherD,SasieniP,CubieH,etal.ColposcopyisnotnecessarytoassesstherisktothecervixinHIV-positivewomen:aninternationalcohortstudyofcervicalpathologyinHIV-1positivewomen.IntJCancer2007Dec1;121(11):2484-2491.

(100)FoulotH,HeardI,PotardV,CostagliolaD,ChapronC.SurgicalmanagementofcervicalintraepithelialneoplasiainHIV-infectedwomen.EurJObstetGynecolReprodBiol2008Dec;141(2):153-157.

Page 31: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

31of34

Table2:The2001BethesdaSystemTerminologyforCytology(permissionrequested)

AdaptedfromSolomonDetal.(15)

SquamousCell

¨ Atypicalsquamouscells

o Ofundeterminedsignificance

o Cannotexcludehigh-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesions

¨ Low-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesions-encompassinghumanpapillomavirus,milddysplasiaandCIN1

¨ High-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesions-encompassingmoderateandseveredysplasia,carcinomainsitu,CIN2andCIN3

¨ Squamouscellcarcinoma

GlandularCell

¨ Atypicalglandularcells(specifyendocervical,endometrial,ornototherwisespecified)

¨ Atypicalglandularcells,favorneoplasia(specifyendocervicalornototherwisespecified)

¨ Adenocarcinoma

Page 32: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

32of34

Table3:EvolutionofCervicalCancerPrecursors(58)

CINgrade Regression Persistence ProgressiontoCIN3

Progressiontowardsinvasivecancer

CIN1 57% 32% 11% 1%

CIN2 43% 35% 22% 5%

CIN3 32% <56% - >12%

Table4.CriteriaforAblativeMethodsofCINTreatment

ModifiedfromPrendiville2009(61)(permissionrequested)

Ø Thetransformationzone(TZ)mustbefullyvisible

Ø AcolposcopicallydirecteddiagnosticbiopsymustbetakenfromthemostdysplasticareaintheTZ

Ø Theremustbenosuspicionofinvasivedisease

Ø Theremustbenosuspicionofglandulardisease

Ø Thereshouldnotbecytological/histologicaldisparity

Ø Thepatientshouldnothavehadprevioustreatment

CryotherapyisnotrecommendedfortreatmentofCIN3

Page 33: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

33of34

Figure1.TransformationZoneCategories

Type I Type II Type III

completely ectocervical

fully visible

small or large ectocervical component

has an endocervical component

fully visible

may have ectocervical component which may

be small or large

has an endocervical component

is not fully visible

may have ectocervical component which may

be small or large

Page 34: SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline - IFCPCifcpc.org/newWP/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Colposcopy-Guidelines... · SOGC / SCC Clinical Practice Guideline Colposcopic Management

34of34

Glossary

AC AdenocarcinomaAGC-N Atypicalglandularcells-favorneoplasiaAGC-NOS Atypicalglandularcells-nototherwisespecifiedAGUS AtypicalglandularcellsofundeterminedsignificanceAIS AdenocarcinomainsituASC-H Atypicalsquamouscells-cannotexcludehigh-grade

squamousintraepitheliallesionASCUS AtypicalsquamouscellsofundeterminedsignificanceCIN(1,2,3) Cervicalintraepithelialneoplasia(1,2,3)ECC EndocervicalcurettageHPV HumanpapillomavirusHSIL High-gradesquamousintraepitheliallesionLEEP/LLETZ Loopelectrosurgicalexcisionprocedure/largeloop

excisionofthetransformationzoneLSIL LowgradesquamousintraepitheliallesionSCC Squamouscellcarcinoma