Social Entrepreneurship as “Tipping Point” for Economic Change Brenda L. Massetti, Ph.D. St....
-
Upload
theodore-adams -
Category
Documents
-
view
249 -
download
2
Transcript of Social Entrepreneurship as “Tipping Point” for Economic Change Brenda L. Massetti, Ph.D. St....
Social Entrepreneurship as “Tipping Point” for Economic Change
Brenda L. Massetti, Ph.D.St. John’s University
April 26, 2008
The First International Conference on Social Entrepreneurship, Systems Thinking, and Complexity
Adelphi University
Grounding Perspectives
• Scientific Thinking– In order to meaningfully
study a phenomenon, there needs to be a precise, consistent definition of that phenomenon
• Conceptualizations of social entrepreneurs and the enterprises they create vary greatly
• A more consistent re-conceptualization is needed to further social entrepreneurship research and enhance understanding
Article Definition
Drayton (2002)
Social entrepreneurs see something in society that is stuck, that is not working and envision a systemic change that will allow them to shift society to a new and better way. They have a drive that will not stop until it is done.
Roberts & Woods (2005)
Social entrepreneurship is the construction, evaluation, and pursuit of opportunities for transformative social change carried out by visionary, passionately dedicated individuals.
Korosec & Berman (2006)
Individuals or private organizations that take the initiative to identify and address important social problems in their communities. They exhibit vision, energy, and ability to develop new ways of alleviating social problems.
Social Entrepreneurship Definitions
Definitional Issues
• Social entrepreneurs possess the same traits as traditional entrepreneurs and not-for-profit founders
• The “social” nature of a business mission always has a relativistic, “eye-of-the-beholder” aspect to it
Social Entrepreneurship Re-Conceptualization
• Mission matters, but varies by degree
• Social entrepreneurship exists along a continuum
BalancedMission
Market-drivenMission
•The Red Cross •Grameen Bank •Wal-Mart
Socially-basedMission
•Aurolab •Starbucks
Social Enterprise Definitions
Article Definition
Dart (2004) Differs from the traditional understanding of the nonprofit organization in terms of strategy, structure, norms, values, and represents a radical innovation in the nonprofit sector
(Ligane, & Olsen, 2004)
A seed-stage or early-stage venture that is designed to be profitable and that has an integrated social mission. The social impact of its operations is greater than the industry standard
(Peredo, & Chrisman, 2006)
Entails a community acting corporately as both entrepreneur and enterprise in pursuit of the common good
Definitional Issues
• All businesses exist to benefit society to some extent– The value exchanged
is relative and varies over time
• Profits are a murky means of differentiating success from failure
Social Enterprise Re-Conceptualization
• Profits matter, but vary in how necessary they are for the business to continue
• Social businesses exist along a continuum
SocialBusiness
ProfitRequired
•Aurolab •Grameen Bank •Starbucks
Profit notRequired
Systemic Perspectives• Social entrepreneurs and
the enterprises they create are not mutually exclusive of traditional management and organizational concepts– Combining aspects and
contexts of each broadens perspective
• Exploring the nature of mission and profit orientation together as drivers for enterprise success increases our understanding of business as an agent for social change
The Social Entrepreneurship Matrix
The Social Entrepreneur
Socially-driven Mission
Market-driven Mission
No ProfitRequired
ProfitRequired
II
III IV
I
The Social Entrepreneurship Matrix Defined
• A systemic representation of the core considerations necessary to developing and sustaining a social enterprise– Provides a context for
exploring the many roles for business in society
The Quadrants Considered
• Quadrant IV– The Traditional Business
Quadrant• Firms in this quadrant
have a market-driven mission and must produce profits to sustain themselves
– Social concerns are relevant to the extent that the marketplace desires them to be
» Home Depot
• Profits generated are primarily used to maximize the wealth of stockholders
• Quadrant III– The Transient Organization
Quadrant• Organizations here
respond to a need in the marketplace, but do not seek profits to sustain themselves
– Any proceeds that may be generated go to supporting a social cause
» Live Aid• The organization relies on
public and private donations, grants, and governmental support to achieve variable social causes
• Quadrant I– The Traditional Not-for-
Profit Quadrant• Organizations here are
driven by a social mission and do not need to make a profit to survive
– They perform societal functions the government and traditional businesses let “slip through the cracks”
» MoMA
• They do not pay taxes on surpluses and must only cover expenses to sustain themselves
• Quadrant II– The Tipping Point Quadrant
• Here, organizations are driven by social missions and do need to make profits to survive
– They use profits to expand the social mission of the organization and to ensure a focus on efficiency
» Green-Works UK– Profits are not used to
maximize managers’ or shareholders’ financial wealth
Tipping Point Considerations
• Quadrant IV, traditional approaches to business, are the most common form today– About 95% of all U.S.
businesses in 2006• They have spent the past
few decades externalizing social responsibilities and sharpening their focus on profit maximization– The claim is that profit
maximization is the best way for business to benefit society
– Profit maximization is not a sustainable approach to business and is overwhelming society
• Pollution, corruption and propaganda are increasingly supported while health and human rights are increasingly ignored
• Quadrant II organizations have the potential to tip the scale on profit-only thinking– Their message appeals
to the marketplace • Commitment to
correcting the social problems within our current economic system
– They provide a context for how business, as a value-for-value exchange, has the potential for maximizing more than profits
• They focus on goals that benefit society
• They use profit as an efficiency tool to ensure no resources are wasted
• They apply surpluses to gain independence from the whims of the marketplace, venture capitalists, governments, and bureaucrats