SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED...

10
SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones, M.A.

Transcript of SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED...

Page 1: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED

Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones, M.A.

Page 2: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Social vs. Solitary Bees

Related bees live together

Infertile females Division of labor A. mellifera, A.

dorsata, A. florea, B. terrestris

Bees are isolated All females fertile Builds own nest N. strigata

Social Solitary

Page 3: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Introduction

Animals rely on cues to avoid predators Avoiding flowers with crushed

“conspecifics” Two types of cues produced by prey

By-products of predation Alarm signals

2-heptanone

2-methylbutyl

Page 4: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Alarm Signals

2 hypothesized functions: Signals nectar depletion

(Balderrama, 1996) Increases efficiency

Marks dangerous flowers

Both social and solitary bees respond to volatile cues Social bees are less wary

Page 5: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Questions

Do bees mark visited flowers to increase efficiency?

Do solitary bees use alarm signals? No studies for the presence of alarm signals

in solitary bees.

Page 6: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Methods

Inflorescence: a cluster of flowers on one stem

Assigned randomly Experimental Control

Experimental: bees grasped over the thorax

Control: bees visit flower and leave

Page 7: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Methods

Record number of bees after that rejecting or visiting the flower Rejection: Bee hovers, then leaves. Accept: Bee hovers and lands.

All conducted during sunny weather Tested social bees and solitary bees

Page 8: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Methods

Experiments in six geographical locations Baza, Spain Almeria, Spain Vulluercas-Ibores, Spain Cannonvale, Australia MacRitchie Reservoir Park, Singapore Xishuangbanna, China

Trials conducted as far away as possible Experimental: 233, Control: 236

Page 9: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

***: Social Bees (P<.0001)

NS: Solitary Bees (P>0.25)

Probability of landing vs. Bee species

Click icon to add picture

Page 10: SOCIAL BUT NOT SOLITARY BEES REJECT DANGEROUS FLOWERS WHERE A CONSPECIFIC HAS RECENTLY BEEN ATTACKED Llandres, A.L., Gonzalvez, F.G., & Rodriguez-Girones,

Discussion

Social bees release alarm signals to warn of predators

Treatment had a strong effect on social bees relative to solitary bees

Solitary bees do not release alarm signals

Limitations: All tests were not run at the same place, at the same time. Different plant species