SIX SIGMA를위한...

47
SIX SIGMA를 위한 통계기초 및 공정능력

Transcript of SIX SIGMA를위한...

  • SIX SIGMA

  • . ?

    1. SIX-SIGMA ?

    6 ( : Process) .

    6

    Tool.

    (Ideal Process)

    Improvement

    Avenue(6)

    Q P

    Q P

    Q P

  • 2. SIXMA (PPM)

    6 .

    (Sigma) % CpkPPM

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    95.45%

    99.73%

    99.994%

    99.99994%

    99.9999998%

    45,000PPM

    2,700PPM

    63PPM

    0.6PPM

    2PPB

    Cpk = 0.67

    Cpk = 1.00

    Cpk = 1.33

    Cpk = 1.67

    Cpk = 2.00

    *PPB : Parts Per Billion( )*6 : 6-Sigma (2PPB = 0.002PPM)

    *DPU : Defects Per Unit ( = /)

    *DPMO : Defects Per Million Opportunities

    (100 = /TOP)

    *TOP : Total Opportunities = Units op/Unit

    ( = )

    (+1.5 SHIFT )

    (K = 0 )

  • 3. PPM

    PPM

    () TV

    PPM .

    , TV PPM ?

    TV 1 = 500EA

    (AQL) = 10PPM

    TV (, TV = 0% )

    , TV

    = 100 1 .

    10

    1,000,000( ) 500 = 1/200

    World Class Car = 1,000 DPTV/Year Warranty (35PPM)

    1 = 15,000, AQL = 10 DPTV

    ,

    World Class Car Level 1,000 DPTV ,

    Maker = (70PPM/2) = 35PPM

    , Cpk = 1.33 .

    10

    1,000P=( ) 15,000 = 150/

    10DPTV

    150( ) = 0.067DPTV 70PPM

  • 4. () (m- )

    6 ,

    , ,

    ,

    .

    A-Type B-Type C-Type

    ?

    B-Type ?

    C-Type ?

    Spec : m A-Type B-Type C-Type

    (m-X bar)

  • 5. (Statistical) ?

    , ( = Sample)

    ( = Population) .

    (Statistics) .

    6 .

    .

    , .

    UCL

    CL

    LCL

    ,

    ,

    (X bar) (R) ,

    , (=Plot) .

    UCL(Upper Control Limit = )

    CL(Center Line = )

    LCL(Lower Control Limit = )

    (Su, SL or USL, LSL)

  • 6. (Process) ? (6 Process .)

    (Output=, ) ,

    (Input=4M) .

    .

    < >

    *

    ()*

    */4M=Man+Machine+Material+Method

    Process = ( = ) =

    (, ) ,

    Process .

    , ( = = .)

    *Six Sigma Process !

  • 7. (Control) ?

    4 .

    < >

    (Change)

    /

    (Observe and

    or Measure)

    (Investigate)

    (Decide)

    (Compare)

    .

    .* ., . * .

  • 8. Six Sigma (MAIC-CYCLE)

    ControlMeasure

    (*Define )

    Improve Analyze

    MAIC

    (Deming-cycle)

    SPC // /

    Improve Quality Increase Productivity Reduce Cost

    Lower Price More Competitive Capture More Market

    Share Create More Jobs

  • 9. (QE) Six sigma

    (, Taguchi )

    , (Loss)

    Quality Engineering

    OFF-Line-QC ON-Line-QC

    (Robust-Design Of

    Experiments)

    (SPC)

    SIX SIGMA TOOL

  • . Data ( )

    1.

    * N=(//)* (/)

    * n

    DATA

    *

    Action

    Tool :

    * : , * : X bar, s,* : Cp, Cpk, Z, DPO, DPMO, etc

    * : Histogram* : Control-Chart* : Six Sigma

    * N = n =

    * RS = Random Sampling ( )

    * M = Measurement () T = Testing ()

    RS M

    T

  • 2. (MSA) .

    SPC , (Gage)

    (Measurement Method) , 6

    .

    (Measurement System analysis)

    (, Bias) , .

    , . . , .

    , , .

    , .

    1.

    (Accuracy)

    2.

    (Repeatability or

    Precision)

    3.

    (Stability)

    4.

    (Reproducibility)

    * R&R .

    * Six Sigma Measure .

  • 3. .

    (Random Sampling)

    *, .

    *()=

    ( = = Stratified Sampling)

    * , .

    ( = = Cluster Sampling)

    *.* .

    ,, ., ,

    .

  • 4. Pareto()

    Vital - Few ( = )Trivial - Many ( = )

    Vital-Few

    Trivial-Many

    * Paretos Diagram J.M.Juran .

    * QC 7 Tools .

    * , ABC

  • 5. ( )

    Sample

    < Population Parameters > < Sample Statistics >

    * Inferences(or Estimation)

    S or

    1) () =

    * N= * n=

    = NX

    X bar = n

    X

  • 2) () =

    (Sum Of Squares) = = ()

    S = (Xi - X bar) 2 = Xi 2 - ( Xi) 2 / n

    = s2 = () = 2

    * Sample Mean Of Squares

    s2 = nS

    * Unbiased Variance

    2 = = n-1S

    = s

    * Sample Standard Deviation

    s =

    * True Standard Deviation

    = S2

    (Unbiased Estimator) =

    (Degrees Of Freedom) = = (n-1)* : (Xi - X bar) = 0 *

    = () = 25

  • 6.

    DATA : 25, 40, 35, 10, 17, 15 ( )

    Xi Xi2

    25625

    401600

    351225

    10100

    17289

    15225

    xi = 142Xi2 = 4064

    (X bar)

    X bar = 6

    142= 23.67()

    (S)

    S = 4,064 -1422

    = 703.336

    (s)

    s = 703.336

    = 10.83 ()

    ()

    = 703.335

    = 11.86 ()

    * 6

    *

    * 6

    4

  • . Histogram

    1.

    .

    * (Spray or Dispersion)

    .

    *(Distribution)

    .

    * (Spray or Dispersion)

    * .

    * (Normality-Study) .

    * N-Study ( Six Sigma measure )

    Location Spread Shape

  • 2. Histogram

    (Freqency Distribution)

    KS A 3001 ,

    ,

    (, Class) ,

    .

    Histogram,

    () .

    Histogram

    .

    .

    () () .

    * (Normality-Study)

    () () .

    * = X bar =

    (6) .

    * Cp, Cpk, Cpu, Cpl, PP%, Ppk .. .

    Six Sigma Z-value .

  • < >

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    9

    No (Class) (Xi) Check fi

    20.5~25.5

    25.5~30.5

    30.5~35.5

    35.5~40.5

    40.5~45.5

    45.5~50.5

    50.5~55.5

    55.5~60.5

    60.5~65.5

    25

    28

    33

    38

    43

    48

    53

    58

    63

    4

    8

    15

    18

    24

    17

    10

    3

    1

    100

    < Histogram >

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    20.5 25.5 30.5 35.5 40.5 45.5 50.5 55.5 60.5 65.5

    sL = 25.0 m = 37.5 Su = 50.0

  • < Histogram >

    * *

    *

    *

    * , *

    * , 2

    *

    *

    * 50 , 100 , .

    * A ?

  • . (Normal-Distribution)

    1.

    .

    (Parttern)

    .

    ,

    , .

    , ?

    (pdf =Probability Density Function)

    f(X) = 2

    122 ~ N (, 2)

    -e(- )2

  • 100, 5 ?

    f(X) = 5 2

    1 (X-100)2

    ~ N (100, 52)

    =0.5

    ,

    ,

    =1.0

    =1.5

    =-2 = 0 = 2

    = X bar(Mean)=X median = X mode

    -e50

  • 2. (Standard Normal Distribution)

    U = p.d.f.,

    X-

    f(U) = 2

    12U2

    ~ N (0, 12)

    3 0.27%. (1 = )

    -3 -2 -1 +1 +2 +3

    68.26%

    95.44%

    99.73%

    ,

    68.26% 1

    95.44% 2

    99.73% 3

    . Minitab u Z

    -e

  • X-Z = U = , OK!

    N(1,4), Pr(1X7) ?

    () Pr(1X7)= 0.5 - Pr(X7)= 0.5 - Pr(U )= 0.5 - Pr(U3)= 0.5 - 0.0013 = 0.4987

    27-1

    Pr ?

    0.0013

    1 7

    , Pr(-3X7) ?

    () Pr(1X7)= 1 - - = 1 - - Pr(X-3)= 1 - - Pr(U )= 1 - - 0.0228= 1- 0.0013 - 0.0228 = 0.9759

    Pr ?

    =0.0013

    1 7

    2-3-1

    0.0228=

    -3

    , SL = 3, Su = 7,

    () = + = 0.0013 + 0.0228

    (, )

    (Normality - Study)

  • 3. (U Pr )

    Pr ?

    O U

    N(0,1) Pr = 2

    1U e 2

    U 2 du

    U

    0.0*0.1*0.2*0.3*0.4*0.5*

    0.6*0.7*0.8*0.9*1.0*

    1.1*1.2*1.3*1.4*1.5*

    1.6*1.7*1.8*1.9*2.0*

    2.1*2.2*2.3*2.4*2.5*

    2.6*2.7*2.8*2.9*3.0*

    .5000

    .4602

    .4207

    .3821

    .3446

    .3085

    .2743

    .2420

    .2119

    .1841

    .1587

    .1357

    .1151

    .0968

    .0808

    .0668

    .0548

    .0446

    .0359

    .0287

    .0228

    .0179

    .0139

    .0107

    .0082

    .0062

    .0047

    .0035

    .0026

    .0019

    .0013

    .4960

    .4562

    .4168

    .3783

    .3409

    .3050

    .2707

    .2389

    .2090

    .1814

    .1562

    .1335

    .1131

    .0951

    .0793

    .0655

    .0537

    .0436

    .0351

    .0281

    .0222

    .0174

    .0136

    .0104

    .0080

    .0060

    .0045

    .0034

    .0025

    .0018

    .0013

    .4930

    .4522

    .4129

    .3745

    .3372

    .3015

    .2676

    .2358

    .2061

    .1788

    .1539

    .1314

    .1112

    .0934

    .0778

    .0643

    .0526

    .0427

    .0344

    .0274

    .0217

    .0170

    .0132

    .0102

    .0078

    .0059

    .0044

    .0033

    .0024

    .0018

    .0013

    .4880

    .4483

    .4090

    .3707

    .3336

    .2981

    .2643

    .2327

    .2033

    .1762

    .1515

    .1292

    .1093

    .0918

    .0764

    .0630

    .0516

    .0418

    .0336

    .0268

    .0212

    .0166

    .0129

    .0099

    .0075

    .0057

    .0043

    .0032

    .0023

    .0017

    .0012

    .4840

    .4443

    .4052

    .3669

    .3300

    .2946

    .2611

    .2296

    .2005

    .1736

    .1492

    .1271

    .1075

    .0901

    .0749

    .0618

    .0505

    .0409

    .0329

    .0262

    .0207

    .0162

    .0125

    .0096

    .0073

    .0055

    .0041

    .0031

    .0023

    .0016

    .0012

    .4801

    .4404

    .4013

    .3632

    .3264

    .2912

    .2578

    .2266

    .1977

    .1711

    .1469

    .1251

    .1056

    .0885

    .0735

    .0606

    .0495

    .0401

    .0322

    .0256

    .0202

    .0158

    .0122

    .0094

    .0071

    .0054

    .0040

    .0030

    .0022

    .0016

    .0011

    .4761

    .4364

    .3974

    .3594

    .3228

    .2877

    .2546

    .2236

    .1949

    .1685

    .1446

    .1230

    .1038

    .0869

    .0721

    .0594

    .0485

    .0392

    .0314

    .0250

    .0197

    .0154

    .0119

    .0091

    .0069

    .0052

    .0039

    .0029

    .0021

    .0015

    .0011

    .4721

    .4325

    .3936

    .3557

    .3192

    .2843

    .2514

    .2206

    .1922

    .1660

    .1423

    .1210

    .1020

    .0853

    .0708

    .0582

    .0475

    .0384

    .0307

    .0244

    .0192

    .0150

    .0116

    .0089

    .0068

    .0051

    .0038

    .0028

    .0021

    .0015

    .0011

    .4681

    .4286

    .3897

    .3520

    .3156

    .2810

    .2483

    .2177

    .1891

    .1635

    .1401

    .1190

    .1003

    .0838

    .0694

    .0571

    .0465

    .0375

    .0301

    .0239

    .0188

    .0146

    .0113

    .0087

    .0066

    .0049

    .0037

    .0027

    .0020

    .0014

    .0010

    .4641

    .4247

    .3859

    .3483

    .3121

    .2776

    .2451

    .2148

    .1867

    .1611

    .1379

    .1170

    .0985

    .0823

    .0681

    .0559

    .0455

    .0367

    .0294

    .0233

    .0183

    .0143

    .0110

    .0084

    .0064

    .0048

    .0036

    .0026

    .0019

    .0114

    .0010

    *=0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

    -

  • 4.

    Color-TV A =50(), =8()

    . SL=45, SU=62() ,

    ?

    ()Pr(X62) + Pr(X45)= + = Pr(U + Pr(U )

    = Pr(U1.50)+Pr(U-0.63)= 0.0668+0.2643 = 0.3311

    ( 33.11%)O U

    Wafer =3.10(), =0.02()

    , 3.10 0.0392() ,

    ?

    ()

    862-50

    845-50

    Pr(XSU) + Pr(XSL) = Pr(U )

    = Pr(U1.96) 2 = 0.025 2 = 0.05 = 5%

    3.1392-3.100.02

    2

  • . (6) Cp, Cpk

    1. (Process Capability = 6 SIGMA

    6 SIGMA.

    J.M.Juran ,

    ,

    ,

    (Natural Tolerance)

    .

    ,

    = 6 Sigma.

    ()

    ()

    *4M

  • 2. (Process Capability Index)

    = Cp, Cpk, Cpu, CpL

    1) (m) = ( ) m=X bar ( ) = Cp

    6

    SL m SU

    6

    6

    Cp 1.00

    Cp =1.00

    Cp 1.00

    T

    Cp =6T

    (, T=SU - SL = = R bar/d2 )

  • mX bar ( ) = Cpk

    (T/2)

    (m-Xbar)

    SL m X bar Su

    () = Bias = K | m-X bar | / ( ) Cpk

    Cpk = (1-K) Cp = (1-K)

    2T

    6T

    --- Cpk

    Cp = ... K

    m X bar(m=X bar) Cpk.

  • 2)

    Su = ()

    X bar Su

    (Su-Xbar) Cpu = (Su-X bar)/3

    SL = ()

    X barSL

    (Xbar-SL) CpL = (X bar-SL)/3

    3

    3

    --- Cpk

    * Capability Ratio = CR = Cp =

    * Performance Percent = PP % = Cp = %

    (75% Rule !)

  • 3. (Cp, Cpk, PP%) ()

    Cp or Cpk PP% /

    Cp 1.67 59.9%

    * .. , .

    11.67 Cp1.33

    75.2%* ..

    21.33 Cp1.00

    100%

    * .

    .Cp 1 ,

    .

    31.00 Cp0.67

    149.3%

    * .. , , .

    4 0.67 Cp149.3%

    * . . , ,

    . .

    * +1.5 Shift

  • 4.

    * User,

    *

    4M

    /

    Action/

    () () ,

    Action

    ()

    ,

    ,

    ()

    ()

    ,

    /,

    Action

  • 5. Cpk (*PPM )

    (Cp PPM 2)

    0.30

    .31

    .32

    .33

    .34

    .35

    .36

    .37

    .38

    .39

    .40

    .41

    .42

    .43

    .44

    .45

    .46

    .47

    .48

    .49

    .50

    .51

    .52

    .53

    .54

    .55

    .56

    .57

    .58

    .59

    .60

    .61

    .62

    .63

    .64

    184060

    176186

    168528

    161087

    153864

    146859

    140071

    133499

    127143

    121000

    115070

    109348

    103835

    98532

    93417

    88508

    83793

    79270

    74934

    70781

    66807

    63008

    59380

    55917

    52616

    49471

    46479

    43633

    40930

    38364

    35930

    33625

    31443

    29378

    27429

    0.65

    .66

    .67

    .68

    .69

    .70

    .71

    .72

    .73

    .74

    .75

    .76

    .77

    .78

    .79

    .80

    .81

    .82

    .83

    .84

    .85

    .86

    .87

    .88

    .89

    .90

    .91

    .92

    .93

    .94

    .95

    .96

    .97

    .98

    .99

    25588

    23852

    22216

    20675

    19226

    17865

    16586

    15386

    14262

    13209

    12225

    11304

    10444

    9642

    8894

    8198

    7549

    6947

    6387

    5868

    5386

    4940

    4527

    4145

    3792

    3467

    3167

    2890

    2635

    2401

    2186

    1988

    1807

    1641

    1489

    1.00

    .01

    .02

    .03

    .04

    .05

    .06

    .07

    .08

    .09

    .10

    .11

    .12

    .13

    .14

    .15

    .16

    .17

    .18

    .19

    .20

    .21

    .22

    .23

    .24

    .25

    .26

    .27

    .28

    .29

    .30

    .31

    .32

    .33

    .34

    1350

    1223

    1107

    1001

    904

    816

    736

    664

    598

    538

    483

    434

    390

    350

    313

    280

    251

    240

    200

    179

    159

    142

    126

    112

    100

    89

    79

    70

    62

    55

    48

    43

    38

    33

    29

    1.35

    .36

    .37

    .38

    .39

    .40

    .41

    .42

    .43

    .44

    .45

    .46

    .47

    .48

    .49

    .50

    .51

    .52

    .53

    .54

    .55

    .56

    .57

    .58

    .59

    .60

    .61

    .62

    .63

    .64

    .65

    .66

    .67

    .68

    .69

    26

    23

    20

    17

    15

    13

    12

    10

    9

    8

    6

    6

    5

    5

    4

    3

    3

    3

    2

    2

    2

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    0

    0

    -

    -

    -

    -

    Cpk PPMCpk PPMCpk PPMCpk PPM

    *PPM(Parts Per Million) = DPM(Defects Per Million)

  • 6. Cp, Cpk

    () Cp, Cpk , ?

    (, 500 10)

    bar = 500 (=2.4) bar = 495 (=2.4)

    ()

    Cp =6T =

    62.420 = 1.39

    Cp = 1.39 ,

    ( m=500) X bar=495

    () K .

    2T

    220* K = | m-X bar | / ( ) = | 500-495 | / ( ) = 0.5

    * Cpk = (1-K) Cp = (1-0.5) 1.39 = 0.695 0.7

    SL=490 m=500 =X bar SU=510 SL=490 X bar=495 m=500 SU=510

    ()

    ( x bar m )

  • 7. Cp, Cpk ( )

    X bar m

    SL m SLSU m SU SL m SU

    Cpk = 0.5 Cpk = 1.0 Cpk = 1.5

    SL m SU SL m SU SL m SU

    Cp = 0.5 Cp = 1.0 Cp = 1.5

    , .

    (m-x bar)

  • 8. 6 SIGMA

    , 6 2 6

    . ,

    .

    1.5

    * = 2PPB

    *Parts Per Million

    x bar

    -6 -5-4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 6

    SL Su

    * 1.5 * = 3.4PPM

    x bar

    -6 -5-4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 6

    SL Su

    -1.5 +1.5

    0

  • 9. 4

    6 ( ), 8

    .

    1.5 , 6210PPM

    .

    34

    * = 63 PPM * = 6,210 PPM

    x bar

    -4-3 3 4

    SL SU-4 -3 3 4

    SL SU

    -1.5 +1.5

    6 12

    . * Cp=2.00

    Customer , , .

  • 10. ()

    () X A n=100

    . . , A

    1510().

    No

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    9

    10.5 ~ 12.5

    12.5 ~ 14.5

    14.5 ~ 16.5

    16.5 ~ 18.5

    18.5 ~ 20.5

    20.5 ~ 22.5

    22.5 ~ 24.5

    24.5 ~ 26.5

    26.5 ~ 28.5

    11.5

    13.5

    15.5

    17.5

    19.5

    21.5

    23.5

    25.5

    27.5

    2

    8

    14

    20

    23

    15

    10

    6

    2

    ?

    ?

    %

    ? ( )

    Cp Cpk , ?

  • ( )

    .

    No

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    9

    10.5 ~ 12.5

    12.5 ~ 14.5

    14.5 ~ 16.5

    16.5 ~ 18.5

    18.5 ~ 20.5

    20.5 ~ 22.5

    22.5 ~ 24.5

    24.5 ~ 26.5

    26.5 ~ 28.5

    11.5

    13.5

    15.5

    17.5

    19.5

    21.5

    23.5

    25.5

    27.5

    2

    8

    14

    20

    23

    15

    10

    6

    2

    Xi fi Ui fiUi fiUi2

    -4

    -3

    -2

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    -8

    -24

    -28

    -20

    0

    15

    20

    18

    8

    32

    72

    56

    20

    0

    15

    40

    54

    32

    100 -19 321()

    = X bar = 19.5 + 2 = 19.12()

    = = 2 = 3.58 ()

    100(-19)

    9999

    321 (-19)100

    Histogram (SL & SU ) :

    SL=5 M=15 SU=25

    27.511.5

    X bar =19.12

    2

  • ,

    , ( )

    Su=25 , 5.05% .

    Cp Cpk

    * 0.67 Cp 1.00 ,

    .

    * m=15 X bar=19.12 ,

    Cpk .

    * K = | m-X bar| / ( ) = 15-19.12 | / ( ) = 0.412

    * Cpk = (1-K) Cp = (1-0.412) 0.931 0.55

    * , , .

    X bar Su ,

    SN(Near) ,

    Cpk =

    *

    * K ,

    . -D.J.Lee

    U =

    X- = 3.58

    25-19.12 1.64 Pr = 0.0505

    Cp = 6SU-SL =

    63.5825-5

    0.931

    2T

    220

    3SN- =

    33.5825-19.12

    0.55

  • 1945 ,

    .

    ,

    .

    *

    (Taguchi Genichi),

    ** Taguchi, (NTT) (ECL)

    1950~1960 ,

    .

    *** 1962 Deming .

    Robust ?

    ()(), ,Strong

    . Taguchi()

    1. Deming() Taguchi

  • , !

    !

    * = = =

    !

    * = + + +

    () ( )

    ( )

    + +

    +

    +

    =

    2. Taguchi

  • 1979 Sony-USA Sony-JAPAN TV

    . (* .)

    TV

    .

    * , ?

    2) 1979 4 17 Asahi (TV )

    1)

    3) ,

    4)

    Sony-JAPANSony-USA

    m-5 m m+5

    Sony-JAPAN = m, = 5/3 0.3% > > >

    Sony-USA m 5 0.0%

    3. !

  • m- m+ m- m+

    * * 2

    2)

    1) Old New

    3) L(y) = k { 2 + ( m - x bar )2 }

    (Norminal-the-best Type Characteristics)

    : , m

    (Smaller-the-better Type Characteristics)

    : , , Su

    (Larger-the-better Type Characteristics)

    : , , SL

    , L(y)

    - Old- - New-

    L(y) L(y)

    4. Taguchi (Quality Loss Function)

    m m

  • FMC W.H.Moor Weather-Strip

    Weather-Strip () : Y = 20 4(mm)

    Weather-Strip Maker 3 :

    Front Door Weather-Strip Door Weather-Strip ()

    1) Cpk

    20 4(mm)

    Maker X bar (mm) (mm) Cpk

    20.0 1.333 1.00251.00

    18.0 0.667 0.99951.00

    17.2 0.400 0.99991.00

    Weather-Strip Maker 3 Cp, Cpk

    16.0 20.0 24. 0m- m m+

    ( )CpkCpkbarXmk

    Cpm

    =

    =

    =

    1

    62

    5. Cpk ? (Ford-Motor )

  • 2) FMC 250,000 (/Year) , ($50/).

    (1)

    Maker = 250,000 0.00270 50$ = 33,750 $ Maker = 250,000 0.00135 50$ = 16,875 $ * Maker = 250,000 0.00135 50$ = 16,875 $ *

    (2) L(Y) = K { 2 + ( X bar - m )2 }

    Maker = L1 = 2.0 { 1.3332 + (20-20.0)2 } = 3.55$/ *Maker = L2 = 2.0 { 0.6672 + (20-18.0)2 } = 8.89$/Maker = L3= 2.0 { 0.4002 + (20-17.2)2 } = 16.00$/

    (3)

    Maker X bar Cpk Taguchi

    20.0 1.333 1.00 0.270% 33,750$ 887,500$ *

    18.0 0.667 1.00 0.135% 16,875$ 2,222,500$ *

    17.2 0.400 1.00 0.135% 16,875$ 4,000,000$ *

    L(y) 250,000

    * , K=2

    * ?