Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic...

20
Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti - Alloy E.Lacatus 1* , G.C. Alecu 2 , M. Sopronyi 3 1. Polytechnic University of Bucharest (UPB), Assoc. Professor, Ph.D., Email: [email protected] 2. Groupe Renault, Romania 3. National Institute for Laser, Plasma & Radiation Physics (INFLPR), Romania

Transcript of Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic...

Page 1: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal

Field Assisting DMLS

Additive Manufacturing of

Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

E.Lacatus 1*, G.C. Alecu 2, M. Sopronyi 3

1. Polytechnic University of Bucharest (UPB), Assoc. Professor, Ph.D., Email: [email protected]

2. Groupe Renault, Romania

3. National Institute for Laser, Plasma & Radiation Physics (INFLPR), Romania

Page 2: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

Overview

o Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS)

o Use of COMSOL Multiphysics

o DMLS Laser thermal effect - Model I

o DMLS Microwave assisted - Model II (one microwave radiation source)

o DMLS Microwave assisted: Results –Model II

o DMLS Microwave assisted: Results– Model III

o DMLS Microwave assisted - Model IV (two microwave radiation sources)

o DMLS Microwave assisted: Results - Model IV (two microwave radiation

sources)

o Simulation: DMLS Dynamic Thermal Field- Results (Model IV)

o Conclusions2

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Page 3: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

3

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS)

Use of Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS) and Selective Laser

Melting (SLM) Additive Manufacturing (AM) technologies for: • complex 3D biocompatible metallic parts

• high level of customization, used in medical prosthesis / implants

Limitations - DMLS and SLM technologies have:• significant / costly post-processing (support removal ; hot isostatic pressing-HIP)

• quality and precision limitations

• frequent inconsistency and build failure (relative to traditional mfg. methods)

• restricted material choice

• macroscopic properties of AM parts not identical to traditionally manufactured parts

• restricted build volumes and speed limits application to low volume production

Hypothesis for DMLS metal powder printing: • Readdressing the dynamics of Powder Bed Fusion thermal process could improve

the quality of DMLS printed parts and reduce the post-processing operations time

and costs

Page 4: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

4

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Models: Direct Metal Laser Sintering

(DMLS) fused powder bed Ti6Al4V powder volume model

(a) SolidWorks imported CAD model

(b) Mesh of Ti6Al4V ELI Titanium Alloy Powder bed

(c) Laser thermal effect within the powder bed

(a)

(c)

(b)

Model of Laser focused

effect during DMLS

Laser: focus area

during DMLS

Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS) cont. I

Page 5: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

5

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Use of COMSOL Multiphysics

Use of COMSOL on

Thermal Field for

DMLS - AM of

Ti4Al6V powder bed

Page 6: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

6

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

COMSOL model: DMLS of biocompatible

Ti–6Al–4V ELI (powder bed )

Isosurface:

Temperature (K)- [xz] –

beneath laser focus plane

Isosurface:

Temperature (K)-

[xy] section plane

Isosurface:

Temperature (K)-

Z axes on laser focus plane

Isosurface time related

Temperature (K)-

on Z axes during DMLS

DMLS-Laser thermal effect Model I

Page 7: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

DMLS-Microwave assisted Model II (one radiation source)

7

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [xz] Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [yz]

Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [xy]Electric Field norm (V/m) interacts with

powder bed – selective resistive heating

COMSOL Modules used:

• Design Module

• Multiphysics

• Heat transfer in solids

• Electromagnetic waves,

Frequency Domain

Page 8: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

8

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

DMLS-Microwave assisted Model II (cont. I)

Electric Field distribution within one radiation source Microwave Oven : inert gas flux (Argon) (a) ; Ti6Al4V ELI powder bed (b)

Resistive losses (W/m2) on Ti-Alloy powder bed during Microwave Radiations : inert gas flux (Argon) (c) ; Ti6Al4V ELI powder bed (d)

a a

bb

a

c c c

d d d

Page 9: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

9

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

DMLS Microwave assisted Results –Model II

Biocompatible Ti-6Al-4V ELI

powder layers selective response

on Electric Field distribution

Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [yz] Detail: Response of powder bed layers to Electric Field

Page 10: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

10

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

DMLS Microwave assisted Results– Model III

COMSOL Modules used:

• Design Module

• Multiphysics

• Heat transfer in solids

• Electromagnetic waves,

Frequency Domain

Model III: Different Z coordinate for Microwave radiation source

Asymmetrical wave form response of the excited powder layers (electric field, resistive heating)

Page 11: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

DMLS Microwave assisted Model IV (two microwave radiation sources)

11

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

COMSOL Modules used:

• Design Module

• Multiphysics

• Heat transfer in solids

• Electromagnetic waves,

Frequency Domain

Hypothesis for DMLS assisted by two Microwave radiation sources:• Predictable front-wave position during DMLS –AM of Ti-6Al-4V ELI powder

• Progressive symmetrical electromagnetic waves propagate within the powder bed

Page 12: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

12

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

DMLS Microwave assistedResults - Model IV (two microwave radiation sources)

Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [xy]

Model IV: symmetrical wave form response of

electromagnetic microwave excited layers

Page 13: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

13

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

DMLS Microwave assisted Results –Model IV (cont. I)

Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [xz]

- Size-related effects within the powder bed

Electric Field norm (V/m) –plane [xz] few layers depth effects within the powder bed

Page 14: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

14

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Simulation: DMLSDynamic Thermal Field Results –Model IV

Temperature Process

Temperature (ht) DMLS

Resistive heating (deg C) Electric field (3D dynamic array

Page 15: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

15

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Temperature Process

Resistive heating (deg C) Electric field (3D dynamic array

Temperature (ht)) DMLS

Simulation: DMLSDynamic Thermal Field Results –Model IV (cont. I)

Page 16: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

16

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Simulation: DMLSDynamic Thermal Field Results –Model IV (cont. II)

Electric field waves acting beneath the surface layer of Ti-6Al-4V ELI Powder bed

Page 17: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

17

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Simulation: DMLSDynamic Thermal Field Results –Model IV (cont. III)

DMLS (laser heating) and Electric field (Resistive Heating)

acting simultaneously on Ti-6Al-4V ELI Powder bed

Resistive Heating acting effectively on in depth consolidated layer

Page 18: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

18

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Simulation: DMLSDynamic Thermal Field Results –Model IV (cont. IV)

Laser Heating and Resistive Heating acting simultaneouslybeneath the surface layer of Ti-6Al-4V ELI Powder bed

Page 19: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

Conclusions

19

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Microwave Field is readdressing the dynamics of

Powder Bed Fusion during assisted DMLS:

- Progressive uniform heating of consolidated layers

- Pre-heating active layers (before DMLS spot action)

- Predictable (programmable) electromagnetic field properties

- Adjustable process parameters for biocompatible powder

Ti-6Al-4V ELI (size – shape- functionalization)

Page 20: Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS ... · PDF fileSimulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy E.Lacatus 1*,

Simulation of Dynamic Thermal Field Assisting DMLS Additive Manufacturing of Biocompatible Ti-Alloy

20

18-20, October, 2017 || E. LACATUS, et al. Excerpt from Proceedings of the 2017 COMSOL Conference in Rotterdam

Thank you

Q AContact: [email protected]