SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length...

28
SHUTTLE &CIRCULATOR SERVICES Review & Evaluation Submitted by: October 2008

Transcript of SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length...

Page 1: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

SHUTTLE & CIRCULATOR SERVICES Review & Evaluation 

  

            

       Submitted by:  

  

 

October 2008 

Page 2: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    1 

Shuttles and Circulators Review  1. What is a Shuttle or Circulator? RTD  currently  classifies  its  transit  service  into  seven  categories,  including  CBD  Local,  Urban Local, Suburban Local, Limited, Express, Regional, and skyRide services.   Shuttle and circulator routes are not currently defined as a separate class of service (most are considered Urban Local routes), but RTD is considering separating these services as a category.  Shuttle and circulator routes are generally defined by the following characteristics: 

• They are usually shorter than regular line‐haul routes, usually less than 10 miles long.   

• They run on local streets as well as arterial roadways. 

• They may serve special destinations or areas, such as universities, employment centers, or shopping districts. 

• Passenger trip lengths are usually shorter than on Urban or Suburban Local routes. 

• Circulators  especially  serve  local  trips within  a  single  community,  and  are  often  loop routes connecting key destinations.   

• Shuttles especially provide  connecting  services between major  activity  centers.    They often  serve as  the  initial  (“first mile”) or  final  (“last mile”)  link  in  the  transit network, providing the station‐to‐home or station‐to‐work linkage. 

 The shuttles and circulators studied here  involve routes which comply with most,  if not all, of the above characteristics.  Their widely differing performance relates to differences in the areas and destinations the routes serve, as well as their service spans and headways.    2. Methodology This review presents analysis of various factors that influence the performance of shuttles and circulators in the RTD system.  The review objective is to identify market conditions and service design  variables  related  to  successful  shuttles  and  circulators  through  evaluation  of  existing RTD service as well as industry best practices.  The attributes associated with successful routes can  then be  applied  to new‐route proposals,  in order  to estimate  likely performance before funding  and  implementation.    The  variables  considered  in  the  analysis  are  readily  available, allowing them to be applied in a wide variety of circumstances.    Industry review indicates that key service performance metrics include both ridership per mile of route (independent of length, speed, and frequencies) and a basic productivity measure like boardings per revenue hour (or in‐service hour for RTD).  As a result, market performance was evaluated  using  boardings  per  route  mile,  while  service  productivity  was  measured  using boardings per in‐service hour.    The  key  market  variables  identified  as  possible  predictors  of  route  performance  include population and employment densities, senior and youth population densities, concentrations of zero‐vehicle  households,  and  median  income.    These  attributes  are  often  associated  with 

Page 3: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    2 

transit ridership.  They also tend to demonstrate collinearity – i.e., not only are they associated with  route performance,  they are also associated with each other.   Areas of high population density, for example, are likely to have more zero‐vehicle households and lower income levels than less dense areas.    Service  characteristics  evaluated  for  their  effect  on  performance  include  peak  headways, service spans, and fares.  These factors, however, are not only predictors of good performance, they may come as a result of good performance.  For example, high ridership may be a product of  short  headways,  but  short  headways  may  be  implemented  due  to  crowding  on  high‐performing lines.  Service characteristics may therefore be viewed as both a cause and effect of service performance.   Routes reviewed  include RTD shuttles and circulators running today, as well as two that have been discontinued.  These include: 

• Hop. The Hop, Skip, and Stampede are part of the City of Boulder’s Community Transit Network.  The Hop is a circulator that loops around downtown Boulder. 

• Skip.  This  route  runs  along  Broadway  St,  a major  north‐south  thoroughfare  through Boulder.   While the Skip  is 10 miles  long, the major destinations of downtown Boulder and the University of Colorado are in the middle of the route, effectively making it two 5‐mile shuttles joined together.  A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. 

• Stampede.  The  Stampede mainly  serves  the University  of  Colorado,  Boulder  campus area. 

• ART  Shuttle. Running within  the City of Englewood  south of Denver,  the ART  shuttle connects many local destinations. 

• ZIP Shuttle. The ZIP runs exclusively within  the Flatirons Crossing development, which includes many shopping and dining destinations. 

• Link. No  longer  in  service,  the Link connected areas  in  southern Denver  including  the Denver Tech Center and the Greenwood Plaza developments.  Like the Skip, the Link is a 10‐mile route that functions as two 5‐mile routes joined together, serving both sides of I‐25. 

• Gus. The Gus bus ran within the City of Golden on Denver’s eastern edge, and ceased operation in 1997.  The Gus is included in this analysis as the City of Golden is proposing to develop a new shuttle service. 

 Maps of each route are included as Appendix C.    Two shuttle routes, the 16th St. Mall Shuttle and the B‐Line, were studied but not  included  in the following statistical analysis.  Their structures and market roles place them in substantially different  categories  than  the  routes discussed  above.    These  routes will be discussed  in  the context of the statistical analysis further along in the report. 

Page 4: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    3 

• 16th  St Mall  Shuttle:  This  is  a  short,  very  high‐frequency  route  (every  75  seconds) providing  both  “last mile”  and  internal  circulation  to  thousands  of  riders  per  day  in downtown Denver.   While  its  length (just over a mile) makes  it appropriate to class as shuttle,  its very high volume of  service and very  specialized  role places  it  in a unique classification in terms of comparative analysis to the other shuttles and circulators. 

• B‐Line.   The B‐Line ran  from downtown Denver to Southmoor, and operated between 1999 and 2006.  It is among the longer routes in the study, along with the Skip and the Link.  The B‐Line, however, which ends in downtown Denver, is a true 10‐mile route, and not a combination of two shorter routes.  The B‐Line essentially filled the role of a local overlay to the core urban route network rather than a shuttle.   

 3. Markets and Service Performance The following matrices show the values for each variable across all routes.  Routes are listed in order or descending performance, based on both boardings per route mile and boardings per in‐service hour.  Densities are given on a per‐acre basis.    

Demographic Information 

Route Population Density 

Zero Vehicle Household Density   Median Income 

Employment Density   Senior Density  Youth Density 

SKIP  10  0.6  $56,000   13  0.6  1.1 HOP  15  1  $34,000   10  0.6  0.5 ART  11  1  $31,000   19  2.8  1.5 STAMPEDE  15  1  $33,000   11  1.1  0.9 ZIP  2  0  $71,000   10  0  0.3 LINK*  6  0.2  $71,000   23  0.8  1 GUS*  4  0.1  $43,000   10  0.5  0.6 MALL  17  5  $32,000   141  3.4  0.3 B‐LINE*  12  1.8  $53,000   37  1.6  0.9              

*Discontinued  

Performance Data  Service Characteristics 

Route 

Boardings Per Route 

Mile 

Boardings Per In‐Service Hour 

Route Length (miles) 

Peak Headway (minutes) 

Weekday       Service Span 

Weekend Service  Fare 

SKIP  660  60  10.2  7  5am ‐ midnight  Yes  $1.75  HOP  590  40  5.2  7  7am ‐ midnight  Yes  $1.75  ART  376  35  2.1  15  6:30am ‐ 6:30pm  No  $1.75  STAMPEDE  207  32  4.3  10  7am ‐ 7pm  No  $1.75  ZIP  109  7  2.5  20  7:30am ‐ 10:30pm  Yes  $0.00  LINK*  55  5  10.0  10  6am ‐ 6:30pm  No  $0.00  GUS*  30  7  5.0  20  7am ‐ 8pm  Saturday  $0.50  MALL  34546  168  1.3  3  5am ‐ 2am  Yes  $0.00  B‐LINE*  52  20  9.9  15  6am ‐ 6pm  Saturday  $1.15  

Page 5: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    4 

Each demographic variable was plotted against both boardings per  route mile and boardings per  revenue  hour,  to  determine  the  level  of  correlation  between  each  variable  and  route performance.    These  graphs  are  shown  in Appendix A.    The R  squared  value  represents  the amount  of  variation  in  the  route  performance which  can  be  explained  by  the  demographic characteristic  studied.    An  R  squared  value  of  around  0.5  or  higher  shows  some  significant correlation between the variables.  The Mall Shuttle and B‐Line are not included in the analysis as they are substantially different from the other routes, as discussed above.  The  strongest  correlation  appears  between  population  density  and  performance,  and prevalence of zero‐vehicle households and performance.  There is strong relationship between these two variables,  in that  it  is usually more possible to complete trips without using cars  in dense areas.    All routes showing over 10 boardings per in‐service hour correlated with a population density of over 10 people per acre.    A weaker  correlation  exists  between median  income  and  performance, with  routes  serving moderate‐income areas more successfully  than high‐income areas.   Variables of employment density, senior density, and youth density appear to have little effect on shuttle and circulator productivity.   Areas  of  high  employment  concentration were  somewhat  inversely  correlated and may be the result of lower density “office park” type environments, which include little in the way of residential development or other destinations such as shopping or entertainment.    Peak headways and fares for each route were also plotted against route performance.   These graphs are shown  in Appendix B.   Peak headways  showed a  strong negative correlation with route productivity, with the most successful shuttles running at sub‐10 minute headways during some portion of the day.   Low headways are needed to generate spontaneous, short “walk‐up” trips, where passengers do not need  to plan ahead  in order  to use  transit.    Industry  studies show  that  at  intervals  between  buses  of  13 minutes  or  longer, most  passengers  consult  a published schedule.  The days of the week when the routes run varied little among the routes surveyed, but the two most successful routes run all week, and until at least midnight.  Fare seemed to have no effect on ridership, with the high‐performing routes charging more than the low‐performing routes.    4. On‐Route Destinations The  differing  performance  of  routes  with  similar  land  use  and  demographic  characteristics shows that other factors contribute to route success.  Each route serves a different type of role within its community, and includes various destinations.  The matrix below shows the types of destinations served along each route.    The most productive route, the Skip, includes a wide variety of destinations, such as downtown Boulder  including  the  shopping district,  the University of Colorado at Boulder, a high  school, and a hospital.  Combined with higher residential population densities, this allows the route to 

Page 6: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    5 

serve many different roles within the community and attract a wide ridership market which can complete many types of trips without transfer.  The successful Hop and Art shuttles also include a variety of destination types.   The Stampede boasts among the highest population density of the routes studied, but runs mainly within the University area and does not serve downtown Boulder or other destinations and as a result performs less successfully.  The Gus  shuttle  in Golden, which  demonstrated  the  lowest  productivity  level  in  the  group, served as many different types of destinations as the top performers.    Its population density, however,  is the  lowest  in the group, while the Skip, Hop, and Art routes all run  in areas with over 10 residents per acre.  This finding suggests that population density is a primary factor in route  success – only when density  is established, do  the destinations along  the  line begin  to affect route performance.  

Route  Productivity 

Regional Bus Transportation Connections  Shopping   Town Center  Universities 

Other Entertainment 

SKIP  High  ● ● ● ●   

HOP  High  ● ● ● ●   

ART  Medium  ● ● ●      

STAMPEDE  Medium  ●       ● ● ZIP  Low  ● ●         

LINK*  Low  ● ●       ● GUS*  Low  ● ● ● ● ● MALL  High  ● ● ● ● ● B‐LINE*  Low  ● ● ● ●                 

Route Retirement Communities  Hospitals 

Light Rail Connections  Office Parks  Schools  Malls 

SKIP     ●    ●   HOP                   

ART  ● ● ●         STAMPEDE                   

ZIP                 ● LINK*           ●      

GUS*  ●               

MALL        ●       ● B‐LINE*  ● ●       ● ●             * Discontinued   

Page 7: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    6 

5. Regional Connections One of the key design roles of shuttles and circulators is to provide “first‐mile” from home and “last‐mile” to destination connections to the regional network.   Regional routes may serve 90 percent of a passenger’s  trip, but completing  that extra mile  to a  residence or place of work often  requires  supplemental  service,  especially  in  the  suburbs.    All  of  the  RTD  shuttles evaluated connect with regional routes at at  least one  location.   While  these  transfers play a part  in generating  ridership,  the data  shows  that  successful  shuttles are built on  strong  local trip‐making first, with regional connections playing a support role in overall success.    Passenger boarding data for the Skip, for example, shows strong activity at the Broadway/27th St. Park n Ride, a hub connecting many RTD services.  However, boarding activity is as strong or stronger around downtown Boulder and the University of Colorado.  The line is well‐used along its entire  length.   The  largest boarding  location along the Link  line, a poor performer, was the Arapahoe Park n Ride lot at Caley Avenue and Yosemite St., with little activity along the rest of the line.  This suggests that the Link was mainly used as a first‐mile or last‐mile connection for long‐distance transit riders, and not as a way to make internal community trips, again indicating that the regional connection role is secondary in generating success.  6. Related RTD Services While  all  of  RTD’s  current  shuttles  and  circulators  are  included  in  this  study,  several  of  the discontinued  lines are not  included.   These  include the Cultural Connection Trolley, the Ranch Rider, and community circulators in Aurora, Arvada, and Broomfield.  The  Cultural  Connection  Trolley  ran  only  during  the  summer months,  and  provided  tourist access  to venues such as museums, amphitheaters, and other attractions.    It did not provide the type of daily trip‐making capabilities of the other routes.  The local area circulators mainly connected local destinations and ran infrequently (such as every 60 minutes).  They tended to perform poorly and were converted into demand‐responsive call‐n‐Ride service.   In many ways, the performance of the 16th St. Mall Shuttle confirms many of the findings in this study.   With the highest population density,  large amounts of zero‐vehicle households,  low to moderate  income  levels, and very frequent service,  its high productivity seems appropriate to its surroundings.  The  B‐Line  also  ran  through  areas  of  high  population  density  and  many  zero‐vehicle households, and served many popular destinations.   On those measures alone, the route had every chance for success.  The main downside of the B‐Line is that it did not fill a unique market niche.  Its length, and the fact that much of the route was covered by other RTD services, made it more of a local route overlay than a shuttle filling a unique role.  Additionally, while it served many highly populated areas, a significant portion of its service area was low‐density.    The B‐Line could be considered a  shuttle with a particular market niche,  if  it had  served  the portion of the route from Colorado Station to the Cherry Creek Shopping District.   This three‐

Page 8: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    7 

mile section includes high‐density areas, and B‐Line rider surveys indicated that the majority of passengers used the route to access shopping destinations.  7. Industry Research While few transit systems include specific shuttle and circulator information within their service standards, some TCRP reports provide case studies of high and low‐performing routes and their associated characteristics.   TCRP Report 55, Guidelines for Enhancing Suburban Mobility Using Public Transportation, dedicates several chapters to shuttle and circulator services.  This report finds certain factors linked to success: operating environment, markets, cost control measures, vehicle types, linked services, small innovations, and public‐private partnerships.    The  findings  stress  the  importance  of  serving  “hub”  areas,  either  for  people  (such  as employment centers) or for transit (such as transfer centers).  Aside from hubs, however, high‐performing  suburban  routes  also  operated  along moderately  dense  corridors with  a mix  of uses.    TRCP  Report  116,  Guidebook  for  Evaluating,  Selecting,  and  Implementing  Suburban Transit  Services,  finds  that  shuttles  and  circulators  are  most  effective  when  serving  more “urban,” mixed‐use areas where residents do not require cars to reach many destinations.  This report describes an area’s transit affinity  in terms of the “four D’s”: density, diversity, design, and deterrents to driving.  TRCP Report 55 states that shuttles and circulators can be successful either in serving transit’s more traditional markets, such as  lower  income and transit‐dependent riders, or by attracting “choice”  customers with  high‐quality,  frequent  service.    This  study  of  RTD  routes  reinforces these  findings, by showing a strong correlation between density and performance, but only a moderate correlation between performance and income.  Other  elements  of  success  outlined  in  the  studies  involve  fitting  the  transit  product  to  the market.  Each shuttle or circulator’s service area is unique, and may require a different service approach.  In lower‐density areas, flexible service types which allow route deviations provide a way of competing with car  travel.   Routes which  fill a  specific  service niche,  such as  running solely within an entertainment complex, require special branding and high‐quality connections to  regional  service.   Within  dense, mixed‐use  areas,  routes  can  run  at  high  frequencies  and perform many different roles.  This is also confirmed for RTD’s shuttles and circulators.  8. Recommended Service Warrants The  results  of  the  analysis  suggest  that  several  factors  are  critical  to  shuttle  and  circulator success.   While  this  study does not  show  that a  statistical model  can be used  to  specifically predict  route performance, general correlations exist which allow  transit agencies and Board members to make informed decisions on shuttle and circulator implementation.  The following characteristics are listed in order of importance in determining route success.  • Step 1 – Population Density.  A sustained average population density of at least 10 people 

per acre along the length of the route is a key determinant of success.  The shuttles running in areas of at  least  this density – many of  them  in Boulder – perform  significantly better 

Page 9: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    8 

than  those  running  in  less  dense  environments.    This  finding  suggests  that  shuttle  and circulator service require a critical mass of potential riders  in order to succeed.   This  is not surprising  because  compact  communities  are  a  key  ingredient  for  successful  sustainable mobility (walking, bicycling, and transit).  As a result, many smaller communities like Golden can begin to support transit shuttles and circulators as new Smart Growth or New Urbanism densification initiatives are introduced.  There may be opportunities to lead committed and funded  development  by  introducing  externally‐funded  transit  shuttle  and  circulator initiatives during the land use buildout in order to have the mobility options in place as the market matures.    

• Step 2 – On‐Route Destinations.   The analysis also  indicates  that  shuttles and circulators that provide one‐seat trips between community residences and community destinations are significantly  more  successful  than  those  that  do  not.    This  suggests  that  when  higher densities are present, the route design should provide direct connections with many varied community  destinations.    Serving  locations  such  as  schools  (universities,  colleges,  high schools, middle  schools),  shopping districts  (but not  auto‐centric malls), medical  centers, and downtowns (central business district) helps to create routes that appeal to all market segments (youth, families, seniors) and can serve a wide variety of trips.  Routes that cater to more limited market segments (e.g. the Stampede, running largely within the University of Colorado) tend not to perform as well as others such as the Skip and Hop, even with high population density.  

• Step 3 – Transit Friendly Area Characteristics.  Shuttle and circulator service areas with the minimum population density and multi‐use destinations must  still be  “transit  friendly”  in order for a fully successful operation.   Pedestrian friendly environments (walkable streets) are a minimum.   Other associated sustainable mobility characteristics, such as mixed  land uses, areas of clustered shopping or employment, public “exchange space” with available seating, and bicycle  rights‐of‐way, help ensure a  successful  shuttle and  circulator  service.  People  are more  likely  not  to  own  cars  in  such  areas,  and  thus  use  transit  and  other sustainable modes more frequently.   University areas such as Boulder are also particularly conducive  to  transit usage, with  their  relatively high densities and  lower  student  income levels.  They are also more likely to attract pedestrians on short trips.  

• Step 4 – Service Characteristics.  Steps 1‐3 ensure a strong market and service environment for shuttle and circulator success.   The  last critical element  in success  is the transit service itself.  Attributes such as frequency, span, and fare all significantly affect the attractiveness of  the  shuttle  or  circulator.    These  transit modes  will  work  best  as  part  of  an  overall sustainable mobility  initiative  that also  includes walking and bicycling.   As a result,  transit needs to operate frequently enough over a full service span to attract spontaneous walk up use.  Successful shuttles and circulators in the RTD system run at least 15 minute headways, and  the  high‐performing  Boulder  routes  run  headways  under  10 minutes.    In  order  to generate  spontaneous,  short  “walk‐up”  trips,  minimum  headways  of  12  minutes  are required with headways of 10 minutes or less highly desirable.    

Page 10: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

Shuttles and Circulators Review    9 

Fare levels seem to have little effect on ridership, as the most successful routes charge full fares  (although students can ride Boulder routes at discounted rates).   Regular use  for all kinds of community trip‐making makes the “per‐use” pass cost very low.  

 

Page 11: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

i

Appendix A – Demographics

R2 = 0.4124

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16

Population Density (Pers/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Art

Hop

Zip

LinkGus

Stampede

Skip

R2 = 0.4194

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

Zero Vehicle Houehold Density (HH/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Zip

Link

Art

Stampede

Gus

Skip

Hop

Page 12: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

ii

R2 = 0.0238

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 5 10 15 20 25

Employment Density (Jobs/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Hop

Art

Link

Zip

Skip

Gus

Stampede

R2 = 0.1283

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

$- $10,000 $20,000 $30,000 $40,000 $50,000 $60,000 $70,000 $80,000

Median Income

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Zip

Hop

Link

Art

Stampede

Skip

Gus

Page 13: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

iii

R2 = 0.0294

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Elderly Population Density (65+) (Pers/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Skip

Hop

Art

Stampede

Zip

LinkGus

R2 = 0.0718

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6

Youth Population Density (18 and under) (Pers/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Hop

Art

Link

Zip

Skip

Stampede

Gus

Page 14: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

iv

R2 = 0.5075

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16

Population Density (Pers/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vice

Hou

r

Skip

Hop

ArtStampede

ZipLinkGus

R2 = 0.5165

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

Zero Vehicle Houehold Density (HH/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vioc

e H

our

Skip

Hop

Art

Stampede

ZipGus

Link

Page 15: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

v

R2 = 0.0226

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 5 10 15 20 25

Employment Density (Jobs/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vice

Hou

r

Skip

Hop

Art

Stampede

LinkZip

Gus

R2 = 0.1993

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000

Median Income

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vice

Hou

r

Link

Skip

Art

Stampede

ZipGus

Hop

Page 16: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

vi

R2 = 0.0743

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Elderly Population Density (65+) (Pers/Acre)

Boar

ding

s Pe

r In

-Ser

vice

Hou

r

Skip

Hop

StampedeArt

GusZipLink

R2 = 0.1809

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6

Youth Population Density (18 and under) (Pers/Acre)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vice

Hou

r

Skip

Hop

ArtStampede

LinkGusZip

Page 17: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

vii

Appendix B – Service Characteristics 

R2 = 0.4713

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

0 5 10 15 20 25

Peak Headway (Minutes)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Zip

Link

Art

Stampede

Gus

Skip

Hop

R2 = 0.6235

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

$0.00 $0.20 $0.40 $0.60 $0.80 $1.00 $1.20 $1.40 $1.60 $1.80 $2.00

Fare

Boa

rdin

gs P

er R

oute

Mile

Skip

Hop

Art

Stamped

Link

Zip

Gus

Page 18: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

viii

R2 = 0.4772

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 5 10 15 20 25

Peak Headway (Minutes)

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vioc

e H

our

Skip

Hop

ArtStampede

Zip

GusLink

R2 = 0.7899

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

$0.00 $0.20 $0.40 $0.60 $0.80 $1.00 $1.20 $1.40 $1.60 $1.80 $2.00

Fare

Boa

rdin

gs P

er In

-Ser

vice

Hou

r

Skip

Hop

ArtStamped

Link

Zip

Gus

Page 19: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

ix

Appendix C – Route Maps

Page 20: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P!P !P

!P

!P!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

RTD ConnectionsC, D, 0, 12, 27, 36, 61, U

W HAMPDEN AVE E HAMPDEN AVE

S BROADWAY

E GIRARD AVE

I-85

I-85

E JEFFERSON AVES BROADWAY

WalmartOrchard Place

Malley Center

Englewood Meridian

Downtown Englewood

Rocky Mountain Medical Center

Swedish Medical Center

Englewood Civic Center

Englewood Light Rail Station

Englewood Station Park-n-Ride

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per Acre

Art Shuttle Legend

0 0.25 0.5Miles°

Shuttle/Circulator Route!P Destination

Connecting RTD Route

City of Englewood

Page 21: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P!P !P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

RTD Connections35, 40, 65, 105, 25X, 78X,85X, 89X, D, LINK, E, F, H

RTD Connections2X, 5X, 47X, 48X, 87X, 93X, 100X, 116X, 119X, 122X, OL, 3L, 38L, 44L, 83L, CS, CV, CX, ES, EV, EX, HX, R

RTD Connections1, 2, 3, 46, 3L, 83L

RTD Connections21, 40, 46, DD, E, F, H

COLORADO BLVD

E HAMPDEN AVE

E 1ST AVE

SPEER BLVD

I-25

I-25

E ALAMEDA AVE

E EVANS AVE

State Capitol

Colorado Station

Civic Center Park

Denver CountryClub

Total Longterm Care

York Town University

Civic Center Station

Sunrise Assisted Living

Allied Jewish Apartments

Southmoor Elementary School

National American University

Christian Living Communities

Denver Health Medical Center

Cherry Creek Shopping Center

Southmoor Station/Park-n-Ride

Parkplace Retirement Community

University Hills Shopping Center

Cherry Creek North Shopping District

Van Dellen Christian Elementary School

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per AcreShuttle/Circulator Route

!P Destination

B-Line Legend

0 0.5 1Miles°

Downtown Denver to Southmoor

Connecting RTD Route

(Discontinued)

Page 22: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P !P

!P

¬«GS

¬«17

¬«17

¬«17

¬«16¬«16L

¬«44L

¬«44LJOHNSON RD

HERIT

AGE R

D

W 6TH AVE

S GOLDEN RD

19TH ST

FORD ST

WASHINGTON AVE

I-58

W 44TH AVE

W 32ND AVE

Coors BreweryGolden Library

Downtown Golden

Golden High School

Golden Community Center

Golden Ridge Apartments

Colorado School of Mines

Mitchell Elementary School

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per AcreShuttle/Circulator Route

!P Destination

GUS Bus Legend

0 0.25 0.5Miles°

Connecting RTD Route

City of Golden(Discontinued)

Page 23: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P

!P

!P!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P!P

!P

!P

¬«BOUND ¬«206

¬«JUMP¬«JUMP

¬«BOUND

¬«204

¬«201¬«SKIP

¬«205

¬«204

PEARL ST

PEARL ST

SPRUCE ST30TH ST

CANYON BLVD

ARAPAHOE AVE

COLORADO AVE

FOLSOM ST

COLLEGE AVE

9TH ST

University of Colorado East Campus

Central Park

Pearl St. Mall

Community Plaza

DowntownBoulder

Boulder High School

September High School

Boulder Public Library

Boulder TransitCenter

29th St Shopping Center

University of Colorado

Village Boulder Shopping Center

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per Acre

Hop Legend

0 0.25 0.5Miles°

Boulder Community Transit Network

BOLT, 205, 206

203, 204, DASH, SKIP

STMP, 209

205, BOLT

Shuttle/Circulator Route!P Destination

Connecting RTD Route

Page 24: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P!P!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P!P

!P!P

!P

S QUEBEC ST

E BELLEVIEW AVE

S MOMACO ST

E QUINCY AVE

E PRINCETON AVE

S ULSTER ST

DTC Pkwy

E ARAPAHOE RD

S DAYTON ST

E ORCHARD RD

I-225

I-25

I-25

Target

Invesco

JD Edwards

Plaza Tower

Hilton Hotel

Marina Square

Hyatt Tech Center

Coors Amphitheatre

Castlewood Library

Arapahoe Marketplace

Arapahoe Park-n-RIde

Marriott Tech Center

Southmoor Station/Park-n-Ride

Ulster/Tufts Transfer Station

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per Acre

The Link Legend

0 0.5 1Miles°

Shuttle/Circulator Route!P Destination

Connecting RTD Route

RTD Connections66, 77, 105, 121, 6X, 25X, 63X, 66X, 78X, 85X

(Discontinued)Greenwood Village

RTD Connections 35, 40, 65, 105, 25X, 78X, 85X, 89X, D, B-Line, E, F, H

RTD Connections27, 65, 66, 66L, 73, 105, 121, 6X, 25X, 63X, T, U, W, AT

Page 25: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

¬«D

¬«D

¬«C¬«E

¬«F¬«H

¬«F¬«H

University of Colorado- Denver

16TH ST MALL

AURARIA PKWY

E COLFAX AVE

BROADWAYBROADWAY

CHAMPA STTabor Center

State Capitol

Union Station

Larimer Square

Denver Bus Center

Paramount Theater

Civic Center Park

Auditorium Theater

Market St. Station

Civic Center Station

Boettcher Concert Hall

Colorado Convention Center

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per AcreShuttle/Circulator Route

!P Destination

Mall Shuttle Legend

0 0.25 0.5Miles°

Connecting RTD Route

16th St. Mall- Downtown Denver

RTD Connections31X, 40X, 58X, 68X, 72X, 76X, 80X, 82X, 86X, 108X, 120X, B, L, S, AF

RTD Connections31X, 40X, 58X, 68X, 72X, 76X, 80X, 82X, 86X, 108X, 120X, B, L, S, 6, 20

RTD Connections2X, 5X, 47X, 48X, 87X, 93X, 100X, 116X, 119X, 122X, OL, 3L, 38L, 44L, 83L, CS, CV, CX, ES, EV, EX, HX, R

Page 26: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P

!P!P

!P!P!P

!P!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

¬«Y

¬«204

¬«208

¬«201

¬«HOP

¬«205¬«JUMP

¬«GS

¬«204 ¬«206

BROADWAY ST

BROADWAY ST

IRIS AVE

ARAPAHOE AVE

BASELINE RD

S BOULDER RD

DENVER-BOULDER TURNPIKE

Central Park

Pearl St. Mall

Community Plaza

Homeless Shelter

Downtown Boulder/Transit Center

Fairview High School

New Vista High School

Boulder Public Library

Boulder Community Hospital

Table Mesa Shopping Center

Southern Hills Middle School

Broadway and 27th Park-n-RIde

University of Colorado Campus

Church of the Nazarene Park-n-Ride

Boulder County Health and Social Services

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per AcreShuttle/Circulator Route

!P Destination

Skip Legend

0 0.75 1.5Miles°

Boulder CommunityTransit Network

Connecting RTD Route

209, HOP, STMP203, 225, BOUND

AB, B, DASH, DD, DM

Page 27: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P

!P

!P!P

!P

!P

¬«BOUND

¬«BOUND

¬«209

¬«JUMP

¬«HX

¬«HOP

¬«203 ¬«225

COLORADO AVE

COLORADO AVE

ARAPAHOE AVE

30TH ST

FOOTHILLS PKWY

BROADWAY ST

28TH ST

AURORA AVE

BASELINE RD

Boulder High School

New Vista High School

University of Colorado Campus

Village Boulder Shopping Center

University of Colorado East Campus

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per Acre

Stampede Legend

0 0.25 0.5Miles°

Boulder Community Transit Network

204, AB, B, DASH, DD, DM, GS, SKIP

Shuttle/Circulator Route!P Destination

Connecting RTD Route

Page 28: SHUTTLE CIRCULATOR SERVICES - RTD · 5‐mile shuttles joined together. A passenger’s trip length would rarely be longer than 5 miles. • Stampede. The Stampede mainly serves the

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

!P

¬«228

¬«228

DENVER-BOULDER TURNPIKE

Coalition Rd

INTERLOCKEN LOOP INTERLOCKEN BLVD

Walmart

Best Buy

Park-n-Ride

RTD Stop 228

DSW Shoe Warehouse

Renaissance Suites Hotel

Marriot Towneplace Suites

Linens n Things/Nordstrom Rack

Flatiron Crossing Mall South Entrance

Flatiron Crossing Mall Main Entrance

Population Density (by TAZ)0-22-55-1010-1515+

Residents per AcreShuttle/Circulator Route

!P Destination

Zip Shuttle Legend

0 0.1 0.2Miles°

Connecting RTD Route

B, DD, HX

Flatiron Shopping Center