Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education)sspnsamiti/web_fra/uploads/10894-sss_med-17… · Minutes...
Transcript of Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education)sspnsamiti/web_fra/uploads/10894-sss_med-17… · Minutes...
Minutes of the meeting of the Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) held under the Chairmanship of Justice P.S. Patankar (Retd.) on Friday, the 17'~ May 2013 at 11.30 a.m. in the Conference Hall, Office of the Samiti, 3rd floor, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Khenvadi, Bandra (E), Mumbai 400 051. Draft Minutes:-
Following Members and Officers were present:
1. Shri S.B. Bhagwat, GA : Member
2. Dr. A.S. Vyas : Member
Invitees:
IYs. Meeta R. Lochan, Member Secretary and Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department, God. of Maharashtra couldnlt remain present. Hence, leave of absence granted.
Dr.(Mrs.) Snehalata Deshmukh, Member Shikshan Shulka Samiti couldn't remain present. Hence leave of absence granted.
Shri P.E. Gaikwad, Office Secretary, Shikshan Shulka Samiti was present in the meeting.
Mrs. K.V. Sane, Desk Officer, Shikshan Shulka Samiti, Mumbai was present in the meeting.
The copies of the agenda along with copies of the relevant documents were circulated to the Members.
I tem No. 1: To confirm and approve the Minutes of the Meetins o f Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) held on Thursdav the 25th April 2013 at Conference Hall. Office of the Samiti, 3rd floor, Government Polvtechnic Buildins, 49, Kherwadi, Bandra (EL Mumbai 400 051.
Minutes of the Meeting of Shikshan Shulka Sarr~iti (Medical Education) held on 25th April 2013 are confirmed and approved.
I tem No.Z(a): To review actions taken bv office on decisions arrived at in the previous meetinqs.
2 SSS - Medical 1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
Meeting of 25th April ,,-
' Item No.1:
b) To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies were pointed out and are cleared by the Colleges/Institutes.
-- Item No. 2: (a 84 b)
Item No. 3:
Item No. 4
Adionable Points
To convey the approval and confirmation of the Minutes of the Samiti dated 27th Feb. 2013 and lst April 2013. To appraise of the action taken by office and review of disposal of work for AY 2012-13 27th Feb. 2013 and l* April 2013.. decide on the proposals received for approval of the fee structure for the courses started during AY 2012-13: a) To consider and decide on proposals where
there are no discrepancies.
I c) To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are yet to be pointed to the Colleges/Institutes.
Action Taken by OHice
Minutes of the Samiti Published on the website of the Samiti on 2/5/2013
d) To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are not cleared by the Colleges/Institutes.
To discuss & finalize the drafa: of form A,B,C,D,E to be obtained from Institute along with their fees approval proposal for AY 2013-14.
The copy of said minutes is also put up on the Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of Colleges are published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective colleges by a separate letter dated 7/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of Colleges are published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Item No. 5:
a) b)
Item No. 6(a):
consider and decide the Review Application received from following colleges for fixation of fees for AY 2012-13 :
1) MKSS1s Smt. Bakul Tarnbat Institute of Nursing Education, Pune
Decision of the Samiti in respect of colleges are published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective I
Letter dated 20/2/2013 received from Vidarbh Vibhagiy Private Nursing School and Colleges Management Association, Nagpur related to approval of final fee structure for RGNM course for academic year 2012-13 (As per decision taken in Minutes 10/1/2013).
2) MKSS1s Smt Bakul Tambat Institute of Nursing Education, Pune
1
Decision of the Samiti in respect of college are published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
colleges by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Item No.6 (b): Letter dated 21/2/2013 received from Rajmata Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm 1 3ijau Shikshan Prasarak Mandal's School of 1 is published on the website & Notice Nursing, Pune regarding fixation of fee structure for the academic year 2012-13.
Board on 2/5/2013.
Meeting sf 25th April
Item No. 6 (c) r Item No. 6 (d) r Item No. 6 (e)
Item No. 6 (g) r-
Letter dated 3/1/2013 received from D.P. Nursing School & Research Institute, Seloo regarding fixation of fee structure for the AY 2012-13.
Letter dated 22/2/2013 received 'from Acharya Vinoba Bhave Nursing School, Katol for fixing of the Tuition fee in respect of WNM course for the year 2012-13.
Letter dated 16/2/2013 received from Sai Nursing School, Bhandara for fixing of the Tuition fee for the AY 2012-13 in respect of WNM Course.
Letter dated 20/2/2013 received from S.R.V. Nursing School & Research Institute, Chandrapur for fixing of the Tuition fee for the AY 2012-13 in respect of WNM Course.
Letter dated 7/2/2013 received from Jijamata Nursing School, At~mednagar for issuance of Adhoc fee structure of WNM Course for those who joined the courses started during AY 2012- 13.
SSS - Medical May 2013
Action Taken by Office
college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2813.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
SSS - Medical 17'~ May 2013
Meeting of 2sth April 2013
Item No. 6 (h)
Item No. 6 (j) r-
Item IVo. 7 r Item IVo. 8 . r-
Adionable Points
Letter dated 13/3/2013 received from lY aharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik forwarding complaints received from the students of Swa. Dadasaheb Kalmegh Dental college, IVagpur for collection of fees from repeater students.
Letter dated 23/3/2013 received from Maharashtra Institute of Medical Sciences & Research, Latur seeking clarification of Solo increase in fees in each Subsequent year
Complaints received from the students of Panjabrao Deshmukh Medical College, Amravati about collection of penalty for various reasons.
Complaints received from students of Ulhas Patil Medical College, Jalgaon citing collection of excess fees from the students who joined the course for AY 2009-10.
Letter dated 30/2/2013 received from Dr. J.D. Foundation, Navi Mumbai in connection with repayment of interest on loan taken for addition to fixed asset other than building.
Letter received from Akhil Bhartiya Vidyarthi Parishad, Mumbai conveying suggestion for fixation of fees.
Action Taken by Office
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firin is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective MUHS by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 4/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/51 2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Decision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated 4/5/2013.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & IVotice Board on 2/5/2013.
3ecision is conveyed to the respective college by a separate letter dated
5 SSS - Medical
A&ionable Points Adion Taken by Office
To consider letter dated 4/3/2013 received from Mr. Vivek Velankar, President Sajag IVagrik Manch, requesting to display the proposals on received from colleges for fixation of fees, on official website of Samiti.
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013.
Item No. 9
Decision is conveyed to the respective Parishad by a separate letter dated 4/5/2613.
Item No. 10 Any other matter with the perrr~ission to the chair
Decision of the Samiti in respect of firm is published on the website & Notice Board on 2/5/2013, The fee with held in the meeting held on
27/2/2013 (at Item No. 3 [a] & 3 [b]).
The Samiti noted it.
Item No.Z[b): To review dis~osai of work - resent Scenario for Academic Year 2012-13.
Chart Showing No. of fees approval proposals received from the Institutes of Medical Courses for Academic Year 2012-13.
No of Proposals Final Fees declared ( A.Y. 201 2-1 3)
Yo.
No. of Colleges
who fialed to submit
proposals
No. of Pending Proposals Streams
Total Pendancy Proposals
I 1
Adhoc Fees (A.Y. 2012-13)
12)
No Of expected Colleges
(A.Y.2011-
Under Verified Scrutinized 1 1 by C.A.
No.of Proposals received
Declared
0
0
0
0
0
1 3 1 PG Dental 1 15 14
1
2
1 4 1 BDS
0
0
0
0
0
O 0
MDIMS (PG)
MedicalIMBBS
w m e o p a t h i c :: 40 Phyisiotherapy 18
0
0
5
6 0
12
11
0
0
0
0
0
11
11
PG- A y u ~ e d
A y u ~ e d 0
O
0 12
40
Rs.496120 I- Rs.330750 1- Rs. 176400 1- Rs. 148840 I-
Rs.992201-
3
12
37 Rs.771801-
6 SSS - Medical
The Samiti noted it
12
13
14
15
16
l7
18
19
20
21
22
Item No. 3: To decide on the proposals received for approval of fees structure for the courses started durina Academic Year 2012- 13: -
Item No. 3(a) : To consider and decide on ~ r o ~ o s a l s where there are no discrepancies.
MP-TH (PG.- Phisiotherapy)
- Occupational Therapy
P.G.Occupational Therapy
PG .. Unani
Unani
BASLP
IVI.Sc.Nursing
P.B.B.Sc. Nursing
B.Sc.Nursing
RANM Nursing
RGNM Nursing
Dental Hygienist
Dental Mechanic
Total
and
Item No. 3[bI : To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies were pointed out and are cleared by the Colleclesf Institutes.
The Samiti considered the proposals of the following Colleges/Institutes for finalization of fee structure for the students who joined the course started during Academic Year 2012-13. After deliberations, The Samiti decides to approve the final fee structure of the following Colleges/Institutes for the students who joined the course started during Academic Year 2012-13, subject to final approval/affiliation/perrnissions from respective Authorities. Figures are arrived at after considering the calculations drawn in the worksheet - calculation sheets of the respective colleges/institutes prepared by a Chartered Accountant. The students admitted in Academic Year 2012-13 and there after continuing their studies will pay an enhanced fee of 5% each successive year as per the norms for 2012-13 till completion of the course. For example if the fee approved is Rs. 1,00,000/- then 2" year, 3rd year and 4th year's student of the Health Science Colleges will
8
2
1
4
6
2
7
19
5 4
430
164
886
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
69
91
0
0
162
7
--
3
1 -
7
19
51
430
7
3
1
7
18 pppp---
50
36 1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 -
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
2 1
16
39
73
-
858
1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
696
Rs.606401-
Rs.385901-
Rs.551201-
Rs.551201-
Rs.463001-
Rs.496101-
0
0
0
0
0
0
-
1
2
1
4
3
1
0
0
0
48
75
123
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
28
Rs.441001-
Rs.367501-
Rs.367501-
Rs. 157501-
Rs. 157501-
7 SSS - Medical 1 7 ~ ~ ~ a y 2013
be Rs. 1,05,000/-. (Assuming course is of 4 years). Worksheet - Calculation sheets are available in the office.
17/05/2813 - Item No. 3(a) (b)
Gangapur Nursing School, / , , Gangapur, Aurangabad
1 "I ". Peth Nursing School,Peth, I I 1 Nashik
1 3 1 RANM I Navin Nursing College , Osmanabad
Final
Name of the Institute 1 Fees for course
starting fmmAY 2012-12
Ad hoc 60800
Final Fees for course starting h m AY 2012-13
4
~nstitute Demands
I I 1 RANM I Jijamata Nursing School, 35000
Chincholiraowadi,Latur I (Adhod I
RGNM 35000
(Adhoc)
RANM &
RGNM
123111 (1 Year)
Saraswati Nursing College, Deoli, Wardha
50000 (RANM Final
201 1-12)
Maharashtra College of i 6 i
With held list in the meeting held on 14'~ December 201 2 /
60000
9
10
11
l2
l3
(1 year for RANM)
& 60000
55000 ,
RANM
1 RANM
* RANM &
RGNM
RANM &
RGNM
RANM
"OoO
14 / RANM
72165 ( lyear)
Swami Vivekanand School of Nursing,Renapur.Latur
Rayat AlVM Training School, / Nanded
Soniya Nursing School,Gondia
Swa. Bhau Daji patil Deshmukh Gramin Vikas Pratishthan,Kotul, Akole. Ahrnednagar Shri Jayramseth Chaudhari Institute of Nursing and ParamedicalScience,Murbad, Thane Maa Gayatri School of Nursing ,Amravati Shri Venkatesh Nursing & Paramedical Institute,Beed Acharya Vinoba Bhave Nursing School,Katol,Nagpur
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 ( Adhoc )
55000 (Collect Fees)
55000 (Collect Fees)
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 (Ad hoc)
82812 60000 1 (1 year)
50040
55000
60000
45000 )
55000
59000
55000
60000
60000
67871 (1 year)
50000 1 Year 58400
(1 Year)
68893 (1 Year)
78000 (1 year)
70000 (1 year) 73976
(1 Year)
8 SSS - Medical - 1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
Sr. no. Name sf the Institute
--
Gurumauli Institute of Nursing Science,Amravati
Code No.
* RANM 40000
(Collect fees)
Fees for course sta*ing "Om '' 2011-12
* RANM
* RANM
Final Fees for course
from AY 2812-13
40000
Indira Bahuuddeshiya Shikshan Santha A.N.M.Nursing School, Malkapur,Buldana
* RANM
* RANM &
RGNM
* RANM
Demands
39956
Indira Gandhi Nursing School, , Parner, Ahmedngar
* RANM
* RANM
60000
Late Bhawandas T. Chhabada School of Nursing, Satara
MGM's Institute of Nursing Education,CIDCO, Aurangabad
* RANM
52000
Mother Teresa RANM Nursing Institute,Udgir, Latur
Navjivan School of Nursing ,Shahapur, Thane Rajai Nursing Institute of RAIVIY, CIDCO, Nanded
Saraswati Nursing School, Junnar, Pune
* RANM &
RGN M
65000
55000 (Collect fees)
40000 (Collect fees)
776 19
56000
55000 (Collect fees)
45000 (Collect fees)
Deshmukh School of Nursing,Mayani,Satara Spandan Nursing School,Vaijapur, Aurangabad Pravara Medical Trust's School of Nursing, Shevgaon,Ahmedngar Parshuram lY edical & Research Foundation,Sushila Nursing School, Daund, Pune
57000 I
Shree Vithalrao Joshi Charitable Trust's Smatrh Nursing College,Chiplun, Ratnagiri
Smt.Indumati Ramchandra * RANM
65000
50000
50000
45000
* RANM
94403
61000
Rs.31000 (RGNM), Rs.27500 (RANM)
60000
68808
50008
47200
* RANM
71160
95000
50000
47200
37000
35000 (Collect Fees) 54000
(Collect fees)
* RANM
40585
51330 54000 ~ 24800
58500
* RANM
* RANM
Sau.Hemlatabai IYotilalji Patni Nursing College, Aurangabad Late Anusaya Savitri Mani krao Thakrao School of Nursing .Maval. Pune
43000
60000
50000
65008
60860
96164
Sr. no.
17
l8
l9
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Llf 1
Code No.
-
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
* RANM
RANM
* RANM
RANM
* RANM
* RANM
Name of the Institute
Swami Vivekanand Sanstha's School of Nursing, Malegaon, Nashik
Kalwan Nursing School, Kalwan, Nashik
Jalna Nursing School RANM, Badnapur, Jalna Uma Institute of IVursing Education, Jath,Sangli D.P.Nursing School €4 Research Institute, Seloo,Wardha Shri Goraksha Nursing School ,Aurangabad
Savitribai Phule Nursing School Kannad, Aurangabad Smt. Sumitrabai Thakare Training College of Nursing,Yavatmal
Yeola Nursing School ,Yeola, Nashik
Dindori IVursing School , Dindori, Nashik
Aurangabad Nursing School, Aurangabad
S.R.V.Nursing College Dawki, Gondia Smt.Shardaben Champaklal Nanavati Institute of Polytechnic School of Nursing, Matunga, Mumbai
Late Raghunathraoji Kendre Nursing School, Parli Vaijnath.
Jay Institute of Nursing , Indapur, Pune
Sai Nursing School, Shevgaon, Ahmednagar
SSS - Medical 17'~ May 2013
9
60000 (Collect fees)
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 (Ad hoc) 40000 (Collect fees) 60000 (Collect fees)
35000 (Collect fees)
43600 (Collect fees)
35000/- (Ad hoc) (50000 Collect Fees)
35000 (Ad hoc)
Fees for course starting
2011-12
65000
Final Fees for course
fmm starting AY 2012-13
69000
60000
Institute Demands
106675
80905
66413
50000
88195
74803
773 19
38128
78725
94556
62 126
79033
43600
82217
85000 (1 €4 112
Year)
86292
52830
40000
60000
60000
85000
1 60000
50000
60000
60000
60000
40000
65000
65000
50000
65000
43600
60000
$5000 (1 & 112
Year)
60000 1
Sr. no.
1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
-.
33
34
Code No.
17/05/2013 - Item No. 3(a) (b)
Fees 'Or
course starting
2011 -12
Name of the Institute
* RANM
* RANM
Name of the Institute
Jijamata Nursing School,Chincholiraowadi,Latur
Final Fees for course starting fmm AY 2012-13
Matoshree Hirai Deshmukh Nursing Institute , Shirala,Sangli Late Narayandas Bhawandas Chhabada School of Nursing Jaoli,Satara
Tuljabhavani Adivasi Shikshan Krida Dansrutic Seva & Nursing 1nstitute.Suraana.Nashik
Institute Demands
55000 (Collect fees)
35000 (Adhoc)
35000 (Ad hoc)
SSS - Medical
With held list in the meeting held on 14'~ December 2012
Final Fees for cou rse starting from AY 2011-12 35000FY 60000 SY onwards 35000FY 60000 SY onwards
S P.
no.
1
2
3
4
I
Code No.
FinalFees for
course starting from AY 2012-13
60000
60000
* RGN M
Institute Demands
165700
71153
Name of the Institute
Holy Spirit Institute of Nursing Education, Andheri , IYumbai
* RGNM
* RGNM
--
* RGNM
1 Navjivan School of Nursing ,Shahapur, Thane
Pravara Medical Trust's College of General Nursing,Loni , Rahata, Ahmedngar
College of Nursing , Wanless Hospital , Miraj, Sangli
55000 (Collect fees)
Final Fees for course Starting
fmmAY 1 2012-13 2011-12
Final Fees
from AY
17250 (Collect fees)
42000 (Collect fees)
~nsti tute Demands
35000
36000
41144
36750
SSS - Medical 1 7 ~ ~ Mav 2013
--
35000 (Ad hoc)
50000 (Collect fees)
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 (Ad hoc)
6
- -
65762
44000
63328
67712
70295
69585
45000
69795
69829
68851
57286
2013
51790
35040
35000FY 60000
SY onwards
35000FY 60000
SY onwards 35000FY 60000
SY onwards
35000FY 60000
SY onwards 35000FY 60000
SY onwards 35000FY 60000
SY onwards 35000FY 60000
SY onwards
held on
55000
40000
60000
60000
60000
60000
45000
60000
60000
60000
57250
26th April
- * RGNM
- .
* IXGNM
* RGNM
13
l4
l5
School of nursing Krishna Hospital & MRC,Karad, Satara Mahatma Gandhi Mission's Floerence Nightingale Institute of IVursing Education, Komothe, Navi Mumbai
Dhanvatari RGNM Nursing School, Nashik
* Global Healthcare Institute School of Nursing (RGIVIY),
lo
List pending due to paucity of time in the meeting
* RGNM
* RGNM
* RGNM
* RGNM
* RGNM
Aurangabad Training School of IVursing R.G.N.M.,Aurangabad
Kalvan Nursing School, Kalwan, Nashik
Dhareshwar Institute of Nursing , Dhayari, Pune
Yeola Nursing School RGIVM,Yeola, Nashik
Shri Goraksha Nursing School,Aurangabad
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 (Ad hoc)
35000 (Ad hoc)
Sr. no.
1 2
10
l1
l2
l3
l4
SSS - 17'~
Final Fees for course
starting fmm AY 2012-13
32000
' 35000
60000
60000
60000
46000
60000
60000
70000
55000
55000
70000
60000
60000
'Ode
No.
RGNM
RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
Medical May 2013
Institute Demands
35059
1 36000
75206
126576
66089
50000
97346
77729
86627
98920
70000
119434
100967
81773
12
Final Fees for course starting fmm AY 2011-12
--
35000FY 60000 SY onwards 35000FY 60000 SY onwards
Name of the Institute
--
Suretech College of Nursing (RGNM),Nagpur Fp
Pad. Dr.D.Y.Patil Institute of Nursing Education, Pimpri, Pune
Yeshwant Institute of Nursing, Aurangabad
Shivprasad Nursing Institute, Mukhed,Nanded
Sai Nursing Institute,Rahata,
26500 (Collect Fees) 25000
(Collect Fees)
35000 (Adhoc)
35000 (Adhoc)
45000
Ahmednagar
Bhalchandra School of Nursing, Pune
Swami Vivekanand School of Nursing RGNM, Udgir,Latur
Pooja Nursing Institute (RGNM), Bhandara
Late.Vijay Makhamale Institute of Nursing,Buldana
At-jun School of I\lursing,3alna
L.D.H.T.Nursing School,Sawad, Hingoli
Saraswati Institute of Nursing School, Amravati
Rajiv Gandhi RGNM School of Nursing,Udgir,Latur
Apurva Nursing Institute, Sailu, Parbhani
Fees 45000 (Collect Fees)
35000 (Adhoc)
71000 (Collect Fees) 62000
(Collect Fees) 50000
(Collect Fees) 33420
(Collect Fees) 60000
(Collect Fees)
35000 (AdhOc)
35000 (Adhoc)
35000FY 60000 SY onwartis
,
35000FY 60000 SY onwartis 35000FY 60000 SY onwads
13 SSS - Medical 1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
I l6
l7
l8
l9
20
Final Final Fees Fees for for course course
Institute starting starting Demands fmm AY fmm AY 2011-12 2012-13
70000 97000
no.
21
1 25 1 #RGNM ( Mauli Nursing School, Beed ( El", 1
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
22
23
24
'Ode
No.
#RGNM
~- - ~
Lokseva Nursing College, 35000FY 35000 60000 SY 60000 95663 (Adhoc) onwards
-
lvlalshej IVursing 35000FY 35000 60000 SY 60000 67000
(Adhoc) onwards
l5
Name of the Institute
Jijamata Nursing School, Newasa, Ahmednagar
Oneness Nursing School,Buldana
Spandan Nursing College, Kondha, Bhandara
St.Paul Nursing College,Ballarpur, Chandrapur
Savitribai Phule College, Washim
#RGNM
#RGN M
'RGNM
26
St-~ri Sai IVursing 100000 1
Apex Nursing School, Kolhapur
#RGNM
35000 (Adhoc)
50000 (Collect Fees)
35000 (Adhoc)
60000 (Collect Fees)
35000 (Adhoc)
Jijamata IVursing School, Shevgaon ,Ahmednagar
Sant Eknath Institute of Nursing RGNM,Shevgaon, Ahmednagar
Mother Teresa Nursing School RGNM,Nanded
#RGNM
35000 (AdhOc)
Angel Nursing College,Nandurbar
35000W 60000 SY onwards
35000FY 60000 SY onwards
35000FY 60000 SY onwards
35000 (AdhOc)
35000 (AdhOc)
35000 (Adhoc)
Aastha School of nursing, Osmanabad
65000 (Collect Fees)
35000FY 60000 SY onwards
60000
70000
60000
70000
60000
35000FY 60000 SY onwards 35000FY 60000 SY onwards 35000FY 60000 SY onwards
Fees)
35000
64908
9076 1
86000
91568
67457
43000 45000
60000
60000
60000
(Adhoc) onwards
35000FY 60000 SY
96221
84857
77073
46200 52297
SSS - Medical 17'~ May 2013
7'- Final [ Final Fees I Fees for I I
for course starting fmm AY
Yashwantrao School of
40000 (Collect
,%slampur Fees)
course starting fmm AY
32
33
34
Institute Demands
I 65000
36500
#RGNM
#RGNM
-
121605 --
36535
#RGNM
#RGIYM
#RGNM
37
, 38
39
G.B.Patil Nursing School,Udgir,Latur
Meera bai Kamble Nursing College, Bramhapuri, Chandrapur
Shri Gajanan School of Nursing, Mantha, Jalna
Mother Teresa College of Nursing, Washim
1 35000 AdhOc
#RGNM
40
41
42
43
44 --
35000FY 60000 SY onwards 35000FY Jai Ambe School of Nursing,
Aurangabad
#RGNM
#RGNM
35000 Adhoc
Jagdamba School of RGNM Nursing, Yeola, Nashik
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
#RGNM
*RGNM
(Collect 4500p I
60000
Madhuribai Deshmukh Institute of Nursing Education Dagdojirao Patil RGNM Nursing School, Hadgaon, IVanded
55000
60000
30000
Fees
35000 (AdhOc)
45000 (Collect Fees)
110679
6oooo sy 1 60000 onwards
35000 Adhoc
Kastura bai Nursing School, Udgir, Latur
Swami Vivekanand Sanstha's Nursing School, Nashik
Savitribai Phule RGLIM IVursing College, Shrigonda, Ahmednagar
Lokseva Bahuuddeshiya Sevabhavi Sanstha, Soni Nursing School, Latur
Mauli Shikshan Prasarak Mandal's,Pingali,Parbhani
77043
63421
45000 i 35000FY 60000 SY onwards
86929
33000
37000 (Col Iceted)
35000FY 60000 SY onwards
60000 89542
36840
60000
35000 1 35000FY 60000 SY
AdhOc onwards
37349
70140
60000
60000
50590
60000
60000
35000 Adhoc
35000 (Adhoc)
35000 (AdhOc)
103668
99664
51424
91658
63855
35000FY 60000 SY onwards
50000 (collected)
35000FY 60000 SY onwards 35000FY 60000 SY onwards
SSS - Medical 1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
Final Final Fees Fees for for course course starting starting Institute
from AY from AY Demands
Dr. J.J.Magdum Institute of *RGNM Nursing Education, 1 4 5 1 1 42630 1 45308 1 49719
*lXGNM
*RGNM
Jaysingpur,Kolhapur
Dr. Shivajirao Ghogare Nursing School,Osmanabad
49
50
51
D.Y.Patil Institute of Nursing *RGNMEducation,Kolhapur
Sarojini College of Nursing, Dhule
52
53
Item No. 4: To consider and decide the followins letters
35000 (Adhoc)
*RGNM
*RGNM
*RGNM
1 54
Item No. 4[a): Letter dated 21/2/2013 received from Raimata Jiiau Shikshan Prasarak Mandal's School of Nursinq, Pune for fixation of fee structure for the AY 2012-13. (Ref: Aqenda Item No. 6 fb) of Meetinq dated 25/4/2013).
~ 35000
(Adhoc)
*RGNM
*RGNM
College to see the Website.
35000W 60000 SY onwards
Shree Sai Nursing RGNM College, Jamkhed, Ahmedngar
Navjeevan Institute of Nursing Scinces, Ahmedpur, Latur
Institute of Nmursing Education & Research,Akola
*RGNM
Item No. 4[b): Com~laints received from the students of Paniabrao Deshmukh Medical Collese, Amravati about collection of penalty for various reasons. [Ref: Aqenda Item No. 6 (fi Meetins dated 25/4/2013).
46220
35000W 60000 SY
, onwards
Rajmata Jijau Shikshan Prasarak Mandal's School of Nursing,Haveli, Pune
Shri Swami Vivekanand College of Nursing,Beed
Maa Gayatri School of Nursing, Amravati
Considered the Complaint made by the students that the college is charging the penalty for late payment of fees. The High Court of Bombay (Nagpur Bench) in Civil Application (W) No. 99 OF 2013 IN WRIT PEmION No. 4353 Of 2012 (the Division
40400
35000 (Adhoc)
35000 (Adhoc)
45000 (Collect Fees)
61066
48150
60000
35000 (Adhoc)
46047 (Co l l ect
48153
98175
35000W 60000 SY
35000 FY 60000 SY onwards
Fees) 1
35000RT 60000 SY onwards
60000
35000
70000
84500
34442
233550
50000
37270
50864
41357
16 SSS - Medical 1 7 ~ ~ May 2013
Bench) in its order dated 8/2/2013 has observed in the last part as under ."However, as time to pay the tuition fees has been extended, as and when the concerned applicants deposit the amount towards the enhanced tuition fees, we direct respondent nos. 4 and 5 to adjust it towards tuition fees. The liability of the petitioners to pay late feeslfine exists and respondent nos. 4 and 5 free to recover it, in accordance with the law. Subject to this direction, we dispose of this civil application. No costs". We asked the Representative of the Institute to show law or rule on the subject of penalty on the basis of which the penalty can be recovered from the students. He admits that there is nothing in the prospectus about it. He only states that it is covered under the right to establish and administer the Institute and notice is given by the college to the students. Prima Facia this cannot be considered as law or rule giving right to the Institute to impose Penalty. However the Institute is free to approach the High Court to get clarification about this. We make it clear that after getting the clarification from the High court, the college can charge fine or late fee and not till then.
Letter received bv email dated 22/4/2013 from Matoshri School of ANM Nursina, Nashik related to refund of penalty amounts.
Considered the Email dated 22/4/2013 along with the letter of tlie Institute dated 24/4/2013. The Institute is right in asking refund of Rs. 40,000/-. From this office. I t is pointed out that there are a part from these 4 colleges from the total amount paid there are 7 other similarly situated colleges. Though they have not come before the samiti asking for refund office of refund the amount in their case also after deducting Rs. 10,000/-.
Letter dated 25/4/2813 from St. Andrews Colleqe of Nursines. Pune raadinq-.toA.collection of f-s_ from ATKT students.
Considered the letter dated 25/4/2013 received from the Institute. The students have to pay fee in respect of subjects in which they got ATKT and required to attend the classes. Therefore Institute can charge proportionately the fee in respect of those subjects in which he/she has failed and has claimed ATKT.
Item No. 5: Anv other matter with the permission of the Chair.
I n view of our norm No. 4.2 approved in the meeting held on 1/04/2013 and our earlier resolution passed on 25/8/2010 regarding giving notice of revision to the other party, it is further made clear where there is delay for filing revision application then copy of the said application is also to be made available to the other side for giving its say.
The next meeting of the Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) would be held on Thursday the 13'~ June 2013 at 11 .30 a.m. in the Meeting Hall, Office of the Samiti at 305, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Khenvadi, Ali Yawar Jung Marg, Bandra (E) Mumbai 400 051.
Z --p ,, 5 ' " \ -J
Date: L.. ~ ( P . s . PATANKAR) CHAIRMAN.