Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal §...

40
Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities Michel Ragot October 2017

Transcript of Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal §...

Page 1: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

SettingBreedingObjectivesandPrioritiesMichelRagot

October2017

Page 2: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

2

SettingBreedingObjectivesandPriorities– Why?

§ The« ultimate »goalofbreeding:valuecreation§ Breedingbeforebreeders§ Theriseofbreedersandthecallforobjectives§ Modernityandthecryforpriorities

Page 3: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

3

StudyApproach

§ Generalsurvey(SurveyMonkey)– 110responses§ Casestudies– Fewresponses,moderatedepth§ Othersources

Page 4: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

4

GeneralSurveyResponses

Page 5: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

5

GeneralSurveyResponses

Page 6: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

6

GeneralSurveyResponses

Page 7: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

7

GeneralSurveyResponses

Page 8: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

8

SurveyApproach

§ Agree/Disagree§ Testingoffacts’intensity§ Generalbiastowardsagreement

Page 9: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

9

Definitions– BreedingCustomers

§ Growers:individualsororganizationswhogrowplantsorraiseanimalswiththeaimofharvestingorcollectingoneormorespecificproducts(grain,wholeplant,tubers,milk,meat,wool,etc.).

§ Productchain:individualsororganizationswhotakeproductsharvestedorcollectedbygrowers,possiblytransformthem(althoughnotnecessarily),andprovidethemtoend-useconsumers.Insomecases,growerscanalsobeconsideredasproductchain.

§ End-useconsumers:individualsororganizationswhouseproductsforfood,feed,orenergy.Insomecases,growerscanalsobeconsideredasend-useconsumers.

Page 10: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

10

Definitions– Markets

§ Marketsegment:ageographicareaoragroupofpeoplehavingarelativelyhomogeneousdemandforacommodity(herecropvarietiesoranimalbreeds).Thepopulationofuserswhomakeupamarketsegmentmayallbelocatedinasingleagro-ecologyorthispopulationmaybedistributedacrossseveraldifferentagro-ecologies.Theextenttowhichanagro-ecologyandamarketsegmentcoincidewilldependontheextenttowhichuserdemand(preferences)forabreedingproductaredeterminedbyclimate,soilsandland-useconstraints.

Page 11: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

11

Definitions– Products

§ Productprofile:setoftargetedattributeswhichanewplantvarietyoranimalbreedisexpectedtomeettobereleasedontoamarketsegment.Attributesmustbeunderstoodastraitswithaspecificvalue,thisvaluebeingdefinedeitherinabsoluteorrelativeterms.Forinstance,aproductprofilemaylistgrainyield(11tons/hectareormore),ortolerancetodownymildew(sameasorbetterthanvarietyX),totaloilcontent(nolessthanvarietyY).

Page 12: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

12

ConnectingNeedsandActions

§ Processperceivedasbeingformal§ Absenceofmanyandessentialformalelements

Page 13: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

13

DefiningMarkets

Page 14: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

14

DefiningMarkets

§ Mostdataisqualitative

Page 15: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

15

DefiningMarkets

§ Heavyrelianceoninternalsources

Page 16: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

16

DefiningMarkets

§ Heavyrelianceoninternalsources

Page 17: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

17

DefiningMarkets

§ Precisemarketanalysesnotgeneralized.§ Nospecificmarketdatasources/exampleshave

beenprovided.§ Marketknowledgeoften“collected”directlyby

breedersthroughinteractionswithmarketactors(growers,chain,end-users),especiallyinsmallerorganizations.

§ Marketdefinitionchargedtomarketinggroupsinlargerorganizations.

Page 18: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

18

MarketSegmentsandSocio-EconomicClasses

§ Relativelyhomogeneousapproachacrossorganizationtypes

Page 19: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

19

MarketSegmentsandSocio-EconomicClasses

§ NorthAmerica,leastconcernedbysocio-economicsegmentation

Page 20: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

20

MarketSegmentsandGender

§ Tremendousdifferencebetweenpublicandprivateorganizations

§ Mostlyapublic“concern”

Page 21: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

21

MarketSegmentsandGender

§ Hugevariationacrossregions(headquarters)§ MostlyanAfrican“concern”§ Almostignoredinthedevelopedworld

Page 22: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

22

FromMarkettoBreeding– ProductProfiles

§ Slightlystrongerinprivatethanpublicorganizations§ Perceptionmostlikelyaheadofreality

Page 23: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

23

FromMarkettoBreeding– ProductProfiles

§ Slightlysimplerobjectivesinpublicthaninprivateorganizations

Page 24: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

24

FromMarkettoBreeding– ProductProfilesTrait Reference Priority Selection Objective Desired Impact

Yield Check1+5% 1 Maximize 3

Lodging resistance <20% 2 Reach threshold 2

Plant height 90-110 2 Reach threshold 7

Maturity Early 3 Reach threshold 9

Protein content >7.5% 1 Maximize 1

Oil content Check2 3 Reach threshold 10

Fiber content >=Check3 2 Reach threshold 5

Mildew resistance Resistant 2 Maximize 8

Virus resistance >Check4 1 Reach threshold 4

Smut resistance Intermediate 3 Opportunistic 11

Drought tolerance Check5 2 Opportunistic 6

Al soil tolerance Moderate 3 Opportunistic 12

§ Marketdemands1. Must-have; 2. Important; 3. Nice to have

Page 25: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

25

FromMarkettoBreeding– ProductProfilesTrait Reference Priority Selection Objective Desired Impact

Yield Check1+5% 1 Maximize 3

Lodging resistance <20% 2 Reach threshold 2

Plant height 90-110 2 Reach threshold 7

Maturity Early 3 Reach threshold 9

Protein content >7.5% 1 Maximize 1

Oil content Check2 3 Reach threshold 10

Fiber content >=Check3 2 Reach threshold 5

Mildew resistance Resistant 2 Maximize 8

Virus resistance >Check4 1 Reach threshold 4

Smut resistance Intermediate 3 Opportunistic 11

Drought tolerance Check5 2 Opportunistic 6

Al soil tolerance Moderate 3 Opportunistic 12

§ Breedingopportunities1. Must-have; 2. Important; 3. Nice to have

Page 26: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

26

BreedingandTraits

(1) Plant Breeding: Past, Present, and Future. TM Crosbie et al. (2006) Plant Breeding (1)

Page 27: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

27

FromMarkettoBreeding– ProductProfilesTrait Reference Priority Selection Objective Desired Impact

Yield Check1+5% 1 Maximize 3

Lodging resistance <20% 2 Reach threshold 2

Plant height 90-110 2 Reach threshold 7

Maturity Early 3 Reach threshold 9

Protein content >7.5% 1 Maximize 1

Oil content Check2 3 Reach threshold 10

Fiber content >=Check3 2 Reach threshold 5

Mildew resistance Resistant 2 Maximize 8

Virus resistance >Check4 1 Reach threshold 4

Smut resistance Intermediate 3 Opportunistic 11

Drought tolerance Check5 2 Opportunistic 6

Al soil tolerance Moderate 3 Opportunistic 12

§ Strategy1. Must-have; 2. Important; 3. Nice to have

Page 28: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

28

FromMarkettoBreeding– ProductProfiles

§ Hugediversityinwhatisunderstoodbyproductprofile(andresultingdocuments)

§ Productprofilesarenotbreedingstrategieso Lackcurrentperformancecontexto Lacktermeddecisions

§ Strategiesoftenundeterminedordeterminedbynonvaluecreation-drivenelements

§ Bewareofchangingmarketdemands

Page 29: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

29

TraitPrioritization

§ Moredirectinvolvementofallstakeholdersinpublicthaninprivatebreedingprograms

Page 30: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

30

Decision-Making

§ Oftenbreeder,alone§ Cropteamswithrepresentativesfrommarketing,

development,breeding

Page 31: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

31

TraitPrioritization

§ Growersareastrongfocusforallregions

Page 32: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

32

TraitPrioritization

§ End-consumersaremostimportantforprogramsbasedinAfricaandLatinAmerica

Page 33: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

33

TraitPrioritization

§ Socio-economicfactorsmostlytakenintoaccountindevelopingcountries

Page 34: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

34

TraitPrioritization

§ Realityoftenquitedifferentfromintentions§ Tremendousimpactofoperationalconstraints

o Earlybreedingstageso Latebreedingstages

Page 35: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

35

TraitPrioritization

§ Unresolvedcomplexityoftenleadstolackofdemonstrablegainso Selectionindices

§ Prioritizationbasedonvaluecreationo Increasedgrowingarea(“marketshare”)o Increasedincome

Page 36: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

36

MarketsandTypesofVarieties

§ Significantdifferencesbetweenpublicandprivateorganizations

Page 37: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

37

BreedingTechnologiesandApproaches

§ Significantdifferencesbetweenpublicandprivateorganizations

Page 38: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

38

ConsiderationforGender

§ Ofallthefactorsthatwerepresented,genderistheleasttakenintoconsideration,overall

Page 39: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

39

Conclusions&Learnings

§ Settingbreedingobjectivesandprioritiesalmostunanimouslyrecognizedasdesirable/goodpractice

§ Factsoftenlaggingbehindintentions§ Numerous“parasitic”elements/constraints

o Changingmarket“pull”o Operationalconstraints

§ Mostsuccessfulbreedingprogramsgenerallyhad/haveclearandpersistentobjectivesandpriorities

Page 40: Setting Breeding Objectives and Priorities - RTB-CGIAR · § Process perceived as being formal § Absence of many and essential formal elements. 13 Defining Markets. 14 Defining Markets

40

Conclusions&Learnings

§ Notobvious/certainiftherearebestpractices

§ Marketknowledge§ Realisticambition§ Significantimprovements/deliveries


World Precious Metal Markets - LBMA · Precious Metals London’s defining role in the precious metals markets May 2011 Jeremy Charles Global Head of Precious Metals World Precious

World Precious Metal Markets - LBMA · Precious Metals London’s defining role in the precious metals markets May 2011 Jeremy Charles Global Head of Precious Metals World Precious

The Theory of Contestable Markets - Purdue Krannert · Hans Christian Anderson, The Emperor’s New Clothes ... formal sense, the theorems provided by the theory of contestable markets

The Theory of Contestable Markets - Purdue Krannert · Hans Christian Anderson, The Emperor’s New Clothes ... formal sense, the theorems provided by the theory of contestable markets

Economic Reforms, Labour Markets and Formal Sector ...India through the 1990s, these estimates suggest that ceteris paribus, following the reforms, employment in the average formal

Economic Reforms, Labour Markets and Formal Sector ...India through the 1990s, these estimates suggest that ceteris paribus, following the reforms, employment in the average formal

Formal and Informal Credit Markets and Rural Credit …ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/61339/2/Formal and Informal Credit... · Formal and Informal Credit Markets and Rural Credit

Formal and Informal Credit Markets and Rural Credit …ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/61339/2/Formal and Informal Credit... · Formal and Informal Credit Markets and Rural Credit

第E、P82c號通告-2017至2018年度終期試 - 中三家長 · 2018. 5. 20. · Defining & non-defining relative clauses Conditionals Connectives (formal) Adjective patterns Pa

第E、P82c號通告-2017至2018年度終期試 - 中三家長 · 2018. 5. 20. · Defining & non-defining relative clauses Conditionals Connectives (formal) Adjective patterns Pa

Labor Flows in Formal and Informal Labor Markets in · PDF fileThis paper compares hiring and separations over the business cycle in formal and informal labor markets in Brazil. ...

Labor Flows in Formal and Informal Labor Markets in · PDF fileThis paper compares hiring and separations over the business cycle in formal and informal labor markets in Brazil. ...

Beyond ad hocery: Defining Creative Industries · Defining the Creative Industries The formal origins of the concept of the creative industries can be found in the Blair Labour Government’s

Beyond ad hocery: Defining Creative Industries · Defining the Creative Industries The formal origins of the concept of the creative industries can be found in the Blair Labour Government’s

Donna Montgomery ETEC 562 Defining Distance Education Distance education is institution- based, formal education where the learning group is separated.

Donna Montgomery ETEC 562 Defining Distance Education Distance education is institution- based, formal education where the learning group is separated.

Formal and informal markets: A strategic and evolutionary ...MPRA Paper No. 42513, posted 09 Nov 2012 19:18 UTC Formal and informal markets: A strategic and evolutionary perspective∗

Formal and informal markets: A strategic and evolutionary ...MPRA Paper No. 42513, posted 09 Nov 2012 19:18 UTC Formal and informal markets: A strategic and evolutionary perspective∗

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF FORMAL SHIFTS IN ENGLISH … · a comparative analysis of formal shifts in english bible translations with a view towards defining and describing paradigms

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF FORMAL SHIFTS IN ENGLISH … · a comparative analysis of formal shifts in english bible translations with a view towards defining and describing paradigms

Contributions to the Formal Verification of Arithmetic ... · Contributions to the Formal Verification of Arithmetic Algorithms ... (2.4) When defining the (quantum) exponent and

Contributions to the Formal Verification of Arithmetic ... · Contributions to the Formal Verification of Arithmetic Algorithms ... (2.4) When defining the (quantum) exponent and

Defining Reliability for a New Grid - Microsoft · 2018-05-03 · Defining Reliability for a New Grid . Maintaining Reliability and Resilience through Competitive Markets . PREPARED

Defining Reliability for a New Grid - Microsoft · 2018-05-03 · Defining Reliability for a New Grid . Maintaining Reliability and Resilience through Competitive Markets . PREPARED

DASS2017 DRF EN - investor.3ds.com · with the AMF (French Financial Markets Authority) on March 21 , 2018, ... 1.4 Group Organization 19 ... track record of defining new markets,

DASS2017 DRF EN - investor.3ds.com · with the AMF (French Financial Markets Authority) on March 21 , 2018, ... 1.4 Group Organization 19 ... track record of defining new markets,

On Defining and Measuring the Informal Sectorftp.iza.org/dp2473.pdf · On Defining and Measuring the Informal Sector 1. Introduction ... existence of informal and formal sectors is

On Defining and Measuring the Informal Sectorftp.iza.org/dp2473.pdf · On Defining and Measuring the Informal Sector 1. Introduction ... existence of informal and formal sectors is

CARBON TECHNOLOGY EXPORTING SUTTON... · DEFINING THE MARKETS: •“ The emission credit markets are rapidly expanding & are as diverse in their structure as the regulations that

CARBON TECHNOLOGY EXPORTING SUTTON... · DEFINING THE MARKETS: •“ The emission credit markets are rapidly expanding & are as diverse in their structure as the regulations that

Cash Transfers and Formal Labor Markets

Cash Transfers and Formal Labor Markets

Techniques for defining relevant markets and analysing ... · techniques for defining relevant markets and analysing competition. The Panel will select appropriate methods based on

Techniques for defining relevant markets and analysing ... · techniques for defining relevant markets and analysing competition. The Panel will select appropriate methods based on

Formal and Informal Labour MarketsKey words: Formal and informal labour markets, shadow economy, labour market policy, unemployment, employment, wage compensation, labour market regulation

Formal and Informal Labour MarketsKey words: Formal and informal labour markets, shadow economy, labour market policy, unemployment, employment, wage compensation, labour market regulation

Defining relevant markets and assessing SMP in a … · Defining relevant markets and assessing SMP in a converged ... Pakistan and Tanzania. ... •Services available may depend

Defining relevant markets and assessing SMP in a … · Defining relevant markets and assessing SMP in a converged ... Pakistan and Tanzania. ... •Services available may depend

Online Advertising: Defining Relevant Markets - Berkeley Law - Home

Online Advertising: Defining Relevant Markets - Berkeley Law - Home