Services Marketing (SEM001) Services Marketing...
Transcript of Services Marketing (SEM001) Services Marketing...
Services Marketing (SEM001)
Services Marketing (SERM)
The copyright of all IMM Graduate School of Marketing material is held by the
IMM GSM. No material may be reproduced without prior written permission
from the IMM GSM.
Revised: September 2010
IMM GSM© Page 2 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Table of Contents
SECTION A
1. Word of welcome…………………………………………………………….... 3
2. How to use this guide………………………………………………………..... 4
3. Purpose and overall learning outcomes………………………………......... 5
4. National Qualifications Framework specifications………………….………. 6
5. Pre-knowledge……………………………………………………………........ 6
6. Relationship with other modules……………………………………………... 6
7. Prescribed textbook…………………………………………………….……... 7
8. Curriculum……………………………………………………………..….……. 8
9. Specific learning outcomes……………………………………………........... 8
10. Critical cross-field outcomes……………………………………………......... 12
11. Assessment details……………………………………………………........... 13
SECTION B
Study Unit 1..…………………………………………………..……………........... 15
1.1 New perspectives on marketing in the service economy……………....... 16
1.2 Customer behaviour in service encounters……………………………….. 23
1.3 Positioning services in competitive markets…………………………........ 27
Study Unit 2..…………………………………………………………………......... 34
2.1 Developing service concepts………………………………………….......... 35
2.2 Distributing services through physical and electronic channels…...……. 38
2.3 Pricing and revenue management……………………………………......... 41
2.4 Educating customers and the value proposition………………………….. 42
Study Unit 3…………………………………………………………...................... 46
3.1 Designing and managing service processes………………………………. 48
3.2 Balancing demand and productive capacity…………………………......... 50
3.3 Service environment………………………………………………………..… 56
3.4 Managing people for service advantage………………………….….......... 57
Study Unit 4……………………………………………………………………….... 62
4.1 Implementing profitable service strategies .………………….……….......... 64
4.2 Service recovery and obtaining customer feedback…………..…..………. 66
4.3 Improving service quality…………………………………………….............. 70
4.4 Service leadership……………………………………………………….......... 73
IMM GSM© Page 3 of 77 SEM001/SERM
SECTION A
1. Word of welcome
Welcome to the fast paced and competitive field of services marketing!
Marketing, and services marketing in particular, is an art as well as a science!
Studying it is the science – practising it is the art. Services marketing is also
an evolving science and it is important that you become aware of the
developments and changes taking place in marketing in today’s dynamic
markets.
Services marketing is a well-established discipline of marketing with its own
theories and body of knowledge. Throughout this module you will be made
aware of the unique challenges of marketing a service that is essentially an
intangible entity within the increasingly competitive environment that
businesses operate in.
The ultimate objective of this module is to equip you to analyse situations and
develop workable services-marketing strategies. By the end, you will have a
good feel for a market-directed system and how to develop it, or assist a
company to perform better.
To reach this objective this module includes aspects such as the quality of the
service, what the customer expects compared to his/her perceptions, the
value created for the customer, building demand, customer relationships and
how to communicate the service to the customer.
The module in services marketing is an excellent foundation for you to
understand the unique challenges of marketing a service. Hopefully you will
enjoy the practical application of the theory within the services industry to
such an extent to actually pursue a career in this sector.
IMM GSM© Page 4 of 77 SEM001/SERM
2. How to use this guide
As the global economy has changed focus from agriculture to manufacturing
to service-dominated economies, knowledge of this particular sector has
become imperative.
The textbook provides in-depth material on newer trends, however the
Services Marketing learner guide has been designed to assist you to apply the
material practically. It focuses on the application of the theory rather than the
theoretical depth of services marketing.
The learner guide is especially designed for distance education students. The
guide will provide an overview of the total curriculum and will indicate the
learning outcomes, which are essentially the core of this guide. It will provide
you with each major topic that has to be covered, along with the learning
outcomes for each topic, which are systematically explained. The guide will
also indicate how the learning material must be prepared for examination.
The learner guide should be studied in conjunction with the textbook and does
not replace the textbook.
At the end of each study unit you will find some typical examples of
examination questions which should be used for self-evaluation.
The following icons appear in all of the learning guides of the IMM Graduate
School of Marketing:
indicates learning outcomes
IMM GSM© Page 5 of 77 SEM001/SERM
indicates the sections in the prescribed textbook that you
need to study.
indicates the self-evaluation questions.
3. Purpose and overall learning outcomes
The emphasis of this module in services marketing is to introduce you to the
principles and practice of services marketing. You will be exposed to the
philosophies, elements and concepts and, through this, will develop an
understanding of the functions and role of marketing in service businesses in
the world today. It will be reinforced by examining the way in which services
marketing interrelates with other factors, both inside and outside the
marketing organisation.
You will also be made aware of the terminology of services marketing and the
importance of the definitions in the associated context that they are used.
Once you have completed this module you will be able to demonstrate:
An understanding of what is meant by service products, consumers
and markets.
An understanding of how service organisations create value for
consumers.
An ability to distinguish between the 8Ps of services marketing.
An ability to develop a marketing communications strategy for services.
A capability to explain how marketing, operations, human resources
and other functions must be integrated to facilitate service delivery.
An ability to implement service marketing concepts.
IMM GSM© Page 6 of 77 SEM001/SERM
4. National Qualifications Framework specifications
This module forms an elective module for the Diploma in Marketing
Management and the BBA in Marketing Management.
In terms of the new National Qualifications Framework (NQF) it is designed as
a 20-credit module offered on NQF level 7.
The IMM Graduate School of Marketing regards Services Marketing as an
elective module in year 2 or 3.
5. Pre-knowledge
Services marketing requires a thorough understanding of the principles and
practice of marketing. You can also apply the knowledge you have gained
from all your studies with the IMM GSM, especially the Marketing
Communications, Business Management and Marketing Research modules.
It is also assumed that you will be sufficiently computer literate and that you
will be able to operate the Internet when attempting this module. It is further
assumed that you have had sufficient experience in producing advanced
assignment reports integrating diverse information in a coherent purposeful
report.
A sound knowledge of the use of the Harvard Referencing System is
compulsory before attempting this module.
6. Relationship with other modules
Services marketing is an elective that supports and augments the core and
fundamental modules offered by the IMM GSM. It enables you to apply
services marketing principles and helps to develop a thorough understanding
of the principles and practices of services marketing. It is therefore a
requirement that you successfully complete principles of marketing before
IMM GSM© Page 7 of 77 SEM001/SERM
commencing your studies of services marketing. What is taught in principles
of marketing is applied and expanded upon in this course.
The prescribed textbook focuses on the application of marketing theory in
service businesses and introduces issues unique to service establishments.
This textbook also focuses on the relationship between marketing, operations
and human resources management. You will be confronted with many new
concepts, many of which you would not have generally associated with
marketing management. The scope of services marketing is very wide
indeed, making it a very exciting area of specialisation.
7. Prescribed textbook
The prescribed textbook for this module is:
Lovelock, C., and Wirtz, J. 2011. Services Marketing: People, Technology,
Strategy. 7th edn. Pearson Prentice Hall.
You will find that there is a substantial overlap between the curriculum of the
IMM GSM and the content of the textbook, but you must be aware of the fact
that the learner guide is the most authoritative document about the scope,
nature and content of the curriculum.
The textbook is written in a clear and systematic manner. Always start your
studies by consulting the learner guide and then study the relevant sections in
the prescribed textbook. It is unlikely that you will pass this module if you have
only consulted the learner guide without studying the content of the textbook.
The following textbook is also recommended:
Boshoff, C. and du Plessis, F. 2009. Services Marketing: a Contemporary
Approach. 1st edn. Cape Town: Juta.
IMM GSM© Page 8 of 77 SEM001/SERM
8. Curriculum
This section addresses the overall content of the module. The Services
Marketing curriculum is divided into four study units. The four study units with
the corresponding chapters in the prescribed textbook (Lovelock & Wirtz
2011) are as follows:
Study
Unit Description Relevant chapters
1 Understanding service products,
consumers and markets
Lovelock & Wirtz 2011 –
Chapters 1, 2, 3 and 12
2 The key elements of services
marketing
Lovelock & Wirtz 2011 –
Chapters 4-7
3 Managing the customer interface Lovelock & Wirtz 2011 –
Chapters 8-11
4 Implementing services marketing Lovelock & Wirtz 2011 –
Chapters 12-15
9. Specific learning outcomes
There are a number of specific learning outcomes for this module, as
indicated per study unit in the table below.
Unit Description Learning Outcomes
1 Understanding
service products,
consumers and
markets
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
Explain why services dominate the modern
economy.
Identify the key driver of service innovation.
Define a service.
Distinguish between goods and services.
Explain why service businesses need to
integrate marketing, operations, human
IMM GSM© Page 9 of 77 SEM001/SERM
resources and other functions and how this is
achieved in different types of service
businesses.
Use a flow chart and describe how customers
are involved in the service process.
Identify and describe the steps involved in the
process of acquiring a service.
Discuss the service business with special
reference to the following three elements:
service operations, service delivery and service
marketing.
Describe the basic focus strategies for services.
Explain your understanding of the use of
marketing segmentation as the basis for focused
strategies.
Conduct internal, market and competitive
analysis.
Use positioning maps to plot competitive
strategy.
2 The key elements
of services
marketing
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
Define the nature of service offerings.
Illustrate ‘the flower of service’.
Discuss the different supplementary services as
illustrated by ‘the flower of service’.
Explain the planning and branding of services.
List and practically explain the hierarchy of new
services.
Discuss the role of communication when
marketing a service.
Use examples to illustrate the many challenges
in communicating services.
Draw up a checklist that can be used to set
communication objectives.
IMM GSM© Page 10 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Identify and discuss the elements of the
communication mix.
3 Managing the
customer interface
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
Design a service blueprint and reflect on its
complexity and divergence.
Discuss the re-engineering of service processes.
Evaluate the customer’s role in the service
delivery as being passive or active.
Describe the levels of customer participation
across various services.
Evaluate the saying: ‘Customer is King’ by
referring to customer misbehaviour.
Discuss the implications of variations in demand
relative to capacity using a diagram.
Discuss organisation capacity constraints.
Explain how demand levels can be managed.
Explain why waiting lines occur.
Use drawings to configure different queue
alternatives.
Discuss propositions on the psychology of
waiting lines.
Describe the service environment or
servicescape.
Indicate how the service environment and
atmosphere impacts on buying behaviour.
Briefly describe how environmental psychology
studies can be linked to the servicescape.
Describe the dimensions of the service
environment.
Design a guide (questions) that can be used as
a tool when designing the servicescape.
Discuss the importance of frontline staff in a
service organisation.
IMM GSM© Page 11 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Describe the stressors in the service industry
that could affect frontline staff negatively.
Discuss the important role of human resources
management to hire, motivate and retain
frontline staff.
Evaluate the importance of culture in a service
organisation.
4 Implementing
services marketing
Illustrate the importance of customer loyalty.
Describe the customer/organisation relationship
using distinct types of marketing.
Identify the correct customers for the service
organisation.
Describe the customer pyramid.
Discuss the wheel of loyalty.
Describe relationship management systems.
Identify the customer response categories to
service failure.
Describe how customers react to service
recovery.
Discuss the components of an effective service
recovery system.
Define a service guarantee.
List the reasons for promoting service
guarantees.
Identify and give examples of service
guarantees.
Evaluate the importance of customer feedback.
Define service quality.
Illustrate the Gap model.
Summarise how service quality can be
measured and improved.
Discuss how marketing operations and human
resources should be integrated.
IMM GSM© Page 12 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Identify and discuss the four levels of service
performance.
Differentiate between management and
leadership.
You are encouraged to use the above information for the planning of your
studies and to avoid ‘cramming’. It is always wise to set up your own study
timetable so that you can manage your time effectively. When planning your
studies, please keep the submission date for the assignment in mind.
10. Critical cross-field outcomes
The critical cross-field outcomes, also known as transferable skills as
identified by the South African Qualifications Authority (SAQA), are essential
for your development as a student within the education and training system,
regardless of the specific area of learning. It is these outcomes that are
deemed critical for your development in the capacity of life-long learning.
The critical cross-field outcomes adopted by SAQA are as follows:
(1) Identify and solve problems in which responses display that
responsible decisions using critical and creative thinking have been
made.
(2) Work effectively with others as a member of a team, group,
organisation and community.
(3) Organise and manage oneself and one’s activities responsibly and
effectively.
(4) Collect, analyse, organise and critically evaluate information.
(5) Communicate effectively using visual, mathematical and/or language
skills in the modes of oral and/or written presentation.
(6) Use science and technology effectively and critically, showing
responsibility towards the environment and health of others.
(7) Demonstrate an understanding of the world as a set of related systems
by realising that problem-solving contexts do not exist in isolation.
IMM GSM© Page 13 of 77 SEM001/SERM
(8) Reflecting on and exploring a variety of strategies to learn more
effectively.
(9) Participating as responsible citizens in the life of local, national and
global communities.
(10) Being culturally and aesthetically sensitive across a range of social
contexts.
(11) Exploring education and career opportunities.
(12) Developing entrepreneurial opportunities.
The transferable skills identified in this module are as follows:
Taught Practised Assessed
Problem solving X X X
Working in teams X
Self-management X
Information gathering/research
skills
X X X
Communication skills X X X
Analytical skills X X X
Learning strategies X X X
Responsible citizenship X X
Cultural sensitivity X
Career development X
Entrepreneurship X
11. Assessment details
There are two assessments involved in terms of the Services Marketing
module:
Assignment: The assignment contributes 20% to the overall mark for
the module. Assignments will focus on selected chapters, and need to
be typed. Please ensure that you adhere to the general rules of the
IMM Graduate School of Marketing pertaining to the style and format of
assignments. You will be issued with a separate brief in this regard.
IMM GSM© Page 14 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Examination: The exam incorporates all content covered in the learner
guide and constitutes 80% of the final mark for the Services Marketing
module. The duration of the examination is three hours and the paper
will count 100 marks. The examination paper will consist mainly of
paragraph and essay type answers. Examination results are usually
released within six weeks of sitting the examination.
The final mark, consisting of an assignment mark and an examination mark, is
released in the form of a final percentage (mark out of 100). The grading
system is as follows:
Percentage Scale Description
75% or more Pass with Distinction
50% - 74% Pass
0% - 49% Fail
A timetable of the assessment programme for the semester, including dates
for the assignment to be submitted during the course of the year, is available
in the Calendar of Events for that year. Please refer to the current issue of the
IMM GSM Prospectus. This document and the Student Yearbook provide
details of the IMM GSM assessment policy.
IMM GSM© Page 15 of 77 SEM001/SERM
SECTION B: Study Units
Study Unit 1: Introduction to services marketing
In Study Unit 1 you will deal with the nature of services marketing, the
challenges for services businesses, the characteristics of services, its
marketing implications and customer behaviour. It is absolutely essential that
you have a clear idea of all of these topics as they form the foundation for the
rest of the course.
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), define a service as:
Economic activities between two parties.
Services are performances that are time-based.
Purchasers are buying services because they want certain desired
results.
Buyers expect to obtain value in exchange for money, time and effort.
Value is created through value-creating elements rather than transfer of
ownership.
In basic language, this means that an intangible (can’t be touched) product is
given by one person and received by another, and once the service is
received, it brings a change to the receiver of the service who wanted it to
begin with. Because there is no tangible product, there is no physical object
that is owned by the receiver.
You need to have an understanding of what services marketing is and what
the marketing and management implications are within a services marketing
environment.
IMM GSM© Page 16 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Specific learning outcomes
1.1 New perspectives on marketing in the service economy
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 1.
After studying this unit, you will be able to:
Explain why services dominate the modern
economy.
Identify the key driver of service innovation.
Define a service.
Distinguish between goods and services.
Explain why service businesses need to integrate
marketing, operations, human resources and other
functions and how this is achieved in different types
of service businesses.
Use a flow chart and describe how customers are
involved in the service process.
Identify and describe the steps involved in the
process of acquiring a service.
Discuss the service business with special reference
to the following three elements: service operations,
service delivery and service marketing.
Describe the basic focus strategies for services.
Explain your understanding of the use of marketing
segmentation as the basis for focused strategies.
Conduct internal, market and competitive analysis.
Use positioning maps to plot competitive strategy.
IMM GSM© Page 17 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Services form part of our everyday lives, from watching television to
using a cell phone and banking our money. The quality of service
varies from one service provider to another and we, as customers of
these various services, have become very critical and have come to
expect a high standard of service delivery. Some customers are
prepared to pay a higher price for better service.
On the one hand you have the customer always complaining and
demanding better and more, and on the other hand you have the
service provider trying to save costs in order to make a profit. The two
are clearly in conflict. Finding the balance is what will make a
successful service business.
As customers’ needs demand more service, more manufacturers are
adding value to their products through enhanced services. For this
reason, the distinction between services and manufacturing is
becoming blurred. Theodore Levitt, one of the world’s best-known
marketing experts, commented: “There are not such things as service
industries. There are only industries whose service components are
greater than those of other industries. Everybody is in service.”
This may be true, as we move towards an era driven by service
excellence, no matter what the product offering. However, you need to
understand the difference between an organisation that offers a
service as its core product and one that offers a manufactured product
with service strategies to better market its physical goods.
Services dominating modern economies
Change has become a constant in the world of trade and
business. Innovation is the norm and a means to business survival.
Everyday we see new service companies emerging and long-standing
companies closing down. You are required to know the facts of this
section and specifically why services dominate the modern economy.
IMM GSM© Page 18 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Here are a few facts to get you started. Be sure to read up on each of
these in Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) and try to associate each with a real
life example in South Africa.
Services make up the bulk of today’s economy.
The service sector is very diverse with a wide array of industries
supplying businesses, governments, non-profit organisations
and the man on the street.
In most economies across the world, growth or value added is
as a direct result of services.
Services account for most of the growth in new jobs.
The dominance of the service sector is not limited to highly
developed nations.
Significant service output is created by undocumented work in
domestic jobs and small cash based businesses.
Services organisations range in size from huge internationals to
small locally owned operations.
Governments and non-profit organisations are also in the
service business.
There is a hidden service sector – those services found
internally within an organisation. With the trend to outsource
these services (accounting, payroll, legal, garden, cleaning),
they are becoming part of the competitive market-place and
therefore contribute to the services component of the economy.
The evolving environment of services
Service innovation becomes a topic for discussion in this
section. The services environment is constantly innovating and
evolving itself. You will need to explain this phenomenon and give
examples of such innovations. Several factors have contributed to and
stimulated the transformation of the service economy:
IMM GSM© Page 19 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Changes in regulations, privatisation of previous government
services, new rules that protect customers, employees and the
environment and new agreements on trade in services have led to
accelerated change. Barriers to competition have been removed and
new entrants, big and small, have emerged into the arena.
Social changes, such as rising customer expectations, increased
affluence, shortage of time, desire for buying experiences and a rising
ownership of technology, have produced a more sophisticated
customer.
In turn, business trends have changed dramatically to meet the
increased demands of customers. We have seen an increase in
strategic alliances, an emphasis on quality, added value through
service, marketing, productivity and cost savings and a general
relaxation of professional association standards. Franchising has
increased and organisations have become more innovative in their
hiring practices.
Advances in information technology, such as increased bandwidth,
miniaturisation, wireless networking, faster and more powerful
software, increased awareness and usage of the Internet, digitalisation
of text, graphics, audio and video and the convergence of computers
and telecommunications have radically altered the way in which
service organisations conduct business. Technological advancement
results in cost savings, re-engineered processes for better efficiencies
and increased speed of execution, all in the name of ‘customer
service’.
Internationalisation and globalisation are making our world smaller.
More companies are able to operate on a transnational basis, resulting
in increased international travel and increased international mergers
and acquisitions. The drive for innovation and new markets is
IMM GSM© Page 20 of 77 SEM001/SERM
increasing competition globally. Organisations are seeking
international best practices and synergies.
With all of the above factors stimulating change in the services sector,
it is no wonder that service organisations have to continuously
innovate and adapt themselves in order to survive.
Important differences amongst services
There are some key differences amongst services. You will
need to gain a clear understanding of these differences and must be
able to explain these differences. In addition to this, you will need to
identify the differences between goods and services and be able to
clearly define a service. There are eight basic differences between
goods and services (Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: table 1.2), namely:
Service products cannot be inventoried.
Service products are intangible performances.
Many services are difficult for customers to evaluate and
understand.
With services, there is greater involvement of customers in the
production process.
With services, people may form part of the product.
With services, there is more variability in operational inputs and
outputs.
With services, the time factor is relatively more important.
With services, delivery systems may involve non-physical
channels.
Although these differences do not apply equally to all services, they
should give you a good understanding of the key managerial
implications of marketing a service compared to a product.
IMM GSM© Page 21 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Categories of services
As a marketer, it is vital to understand that there are different ways to
market different types of goods and services. We therefore should
classify services into market-relevant groups. Be sure to understand
and be able to distinguish the difference between core products and
supplementary services. Most core services have a number of
supplementary services attached to them. For example, you stop at a
petrol station for petrol. You receive the core service of getting your
car tank filled up, but in addition, you receive supplementary services
such as window cleaning, tyre pressure checks and battery water top
ups.
Different services require different service processes and different
service processes directly affect the role of employees and the
experience of customers. Understand the following ways in which
services can be grouped or classified:
People processing
Possession processing
Mental processing
Information processing.
The service classifications above will help you, as a marketing
manager, to better understand what your service operation actually
does, what types of processes are actually involved in creating the
core product for your customers and how customers fit into your
organisation.
The expanded marketing mix for services
Essentially, there are eight components to integrated
service management, known as “The Eight Ps Model of Integrated
Service Management”. This model highlights the strategic decision
variables facing managers of service organisations including:
IMM GSM© Page 22 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Product elements
Place, cyberspace, and time
Process
Productivity and quality
People
Promotion and education
Physical evidence
Price and other user costs.
Once you have an understanding of how a successful service business
is able to synergise and integrate each of the eight Ps, you will realise
that marketing cannot operate successfully in isolation from other
functions in a service business. The three functions that play central
and interrelated roles in meeting customer needs are marketing,
operations and human resources.
Integration with other functions
Services marketing is much broader than activities and
outputs of a traditional marketing department as there is a close
relationship required between operations, human resources and
marketing. In this section, you will begin to understand how marketing
interacts with these other functions. You must understand why these
interactions are important and should be able to describe how
marketing contributes or adds value to these various functions.
It’s no longer good enough to run a slick and efficient operation. It has
become essential to adapt service products to customer needs, have
employees that are customer service-focused and concerned with
efficient operations. Customers have come to expect realistic pricing,
convenient distribution and active promotion. Instead of being all
things to all people, many new market entrants are positioning
IMM GSM© Page 23 of 77 SEM001/SERM
themselves exclusively to a select market segment, with specific and
tailored pricing, promotion and delivery strategies.
1.2 Customer behaviour in service encounters
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 2.
Customer needs, expectations and involvement
As discussed above, classifying services will help you, as a marketer,
to tailor your marketing actions so as to aim at satisfying customer
needs, demands and preferences. Just as when you are marketing a
product, you will need to appreciate what your customer wants;
otherwise, you will create opportunities for your competitors. Once you
know what category your service belongs to, you will be able to design
a service process that is suitable to the organisation and your
customer. Of course, you will be interested in whether the experience
of receiving the service and its benefits has met the customer’s
expectations. These expectations are based on what the customer
expects to receive in return for his/her purchase, which he/she
undertook to meet his/her specific needs. You must know this section
well enough to apply the principles of customer needs and
expectations using examples.
Maslow identified five categories of human needs; physiological,
safety, love, esteem and self-actualisation. He proposed that basic
needs, such as food and shelter had to be fulfilled first before any other
needs can be fulfilled. Needs are deeply rooted in our subconscious
minds and when people feel a need, they react by taking some kind of
action to fulfil that need.
Expectations of customers will differ from one service in the same
industry to another, from one industry to another and even from one
IMM GSM© Page 24 of 77 SEM001/SERM
country to another. Expectations usually reflect a customer’s past
experiences and reputations formed from word-of-mouth, news articles
and marketing messages. Customer expectations touch on several
different elements as discussed in Lovelock & Wirtz (2011).
Desired service levels related to the type of service that customers
hope to receive. It’s based on a customer’s belief that a certain level of
service could and should be delivered.
Adequate service levels are lower than the desired service levels, but
are tolerated because customers are realistic about an organisation’s
ability to deliver excellent customer service all of the time. This is the
minimum level that customers are prepared to accept before feeling
unsatisfied.
Predicted service is an anticipated service. These customer
predictions are situation-specific and, depending on the predicted level
of service, the adequate level will either be higher or lower.
Zone of tolerance refers to the extent to which customers are
prepared to tolerate variations in service levels within an organisation.
The zone of tolerance can increase or decrease, depending on factors
such as price, competition and service attributes.
The model of service consumption
There are three stages to service consumption that a
customer goes through when deciding to purchase a service; the pre-
purchase stage, the service encounter stage and the post-purchase
stage. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), illustrate these three stages of the
service consumption process and the steps within each stage.
The pre-purchase stage is when the decision to buy is made.
Customers are influenced by their own needs and expectations. For
IMM GSM© Page 25 of 77 SEM001/SERM
routine, low risk purchases, customers usually choose a service
provider quite quickly. On the other hand, more risky purchases will
result in customers undertaking an information search until they are
satisfied with the service provider. In these instances, purchases take
longer, especially for first time users of a particular service. Customers
naturally seek to reduce their discomfort with risks in several ways.
Refer to the Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) for a list of reduction strategies.
The service encounter stage takes place once the customer has
selected his/her preferred service provider. A series of service
encounters will take place between the customer and the service
provider. These could be personal exchanges between people or
impersonal interactions with machines or computers. Out of these
encounters, the customer will create his/her own perceptions of the
level of service quality provided by his/her chosen service provider.
There are a few important elements to read about and take note of
during this stage; the service environment, service personnel and
support services. Make sure you understand the importance of
contingency plans, especially with reference to people-processing
services, where customers find themselves in close proximity to other
customers.
The post-purchase stage is a continuation of a process that began in
the service encounter stage. Here the customer will evaluate his/her
experience and encounter with the service received, which will
ultimately influence any future buying behaviour. A customer
measures the service received against his/her expectations in the pre-
purchase stage. If the customer is dissatisfied with the service, he/she
may choose to switch to a different service provider.
IMM GSM© Page 26 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Customer involvement
In this section, the service operation relates to the core
product. You need to know this section well enough to be able to use
a flow chart to describe how customers are involved in the service
process. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), define a process as “a particular
method of operation or a series of actions, typically involving multiple
steps that often need to take place in a defined sequence.”
In simple language, a process is a number of step-by-step
actions done in a particular order. It requires inputs that get turned into
outputs. Two things get processed in services; people and objects.
Sometimes a customer is the input (e.g. a manicure) and other times
an object is the input (e.g. a PC that requires repairing). Understand
the differences between tangible actions and intangible actions, as
each one requires a different process, which impacts on marketing,
human resources and operations. Refer to figure 2.1, four categories
of services, to gain more clarity on this topic.
Once you have gained an understanding of the four service
processes – people processing, possession processing, mental
stimulus processing and information processing – you will begin to
realise how each type of process has distinctive implications for
marketing, human resources and operations strategies. In addition to
this, the customer’s involvement with the service varies according to
each process. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: figure 2.11) use a script to
illustrate a customer’s involvement for teeth cleaning and a simple
dental exam. Make sure that you can create a similar script to show
the examiner that you understand the various ways in which a
customer can become involved in different service processes.
IMM GSM© Page 27 of 77 SEM001/SERM
How a service business can be seen as a system
The service system of a service organisation can only be
defined once the required level of contact with the customer has been
determined. A service system includes three sub-systems, i.e. service
operations, service delivery and service marketing. These cover all
points of contact with the customer. Some parts of this system are
visible (front stage) to the customer while other parts are invisible
(backstage).
Service delivery refers to where, when and how the service product is
delivered to the customer.
Service operations can be divided into those that are visible to the
customer and those that are invisible to the customer. If the backstage
(invisible) operations are not performing well, it will impact the front
stage (visible) operations that the customer encounters.
Other contact points contribute to the customer’s overall view of the
service business through advertising, communication efforts, sales,
telephone calls, letters, invoices and other random exposures.
You need to know this section well enough to discuss the service
business with special reference to the three service elements
mentioned above.
1.3 Positioning services in competitive markets
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 3.
Four distinct types of marketing
Mass marketing is no longer a popular term. Today,
marketing is about focus and targeting the right, potential customers. It
IMM GSM© Page 28 of 77 SEM001/SERM
is important to know then what type of customer is desired by the
business looking to market its services. The key is to not only attract
the right customers, but also to retain them. This is where relationship
building and customer loyalty come in. As a marketer of a service
business, you will need to concern yourself with the following:
Who your customers are.
How to obtain the most desirable customers.
Which customers offer the organisation the most value in terms
of frequency and spend on premium services.
How to keep your customers loyal.
There is a distinct difference between marketing strategies that intend
to bring about a single transaction and those that are designed to
create extended relationships with customers. Research by Coviello,
Brodie and Munro suggests that there are four distinct types of
marketing. These include transactional, database, interaction and
network marketing (Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 12). Be sure to
understand these four marketing strategies with specific relevance to a
services business as discussed.
Transactional marketing refers to a discrete exchange of value that
does not result in or constitute a meaningful marketing relationship.
There is no long-term record kept of the customer’s purchasing history.
Database marketing involves the exchange of information. Through
technology, marketers are able to form relationships with targeted
customers. The aim is to retain patronage over an extended period of
time. This type of relationship is not a close one, as most
communications are automated through technology.
Interaction marketing involves face-to-face or ear-to-ear (over the
phone) encounters with customers. In these situations, closer
IMM GSM© Page 29 of 77 SEM001/SERM
relationships exist and value is added through social experiences and
people.
Network marketing occurs mainly in a business-to-business context,
where companies commit resources to develop positions in a network
of relationships with customers, distributors, suppliers, the media,
consultants, trade associations, government agencies, competitors and
even customers of their customers.
Segmentation strategies
One of the challenges when running a services business is
finding enough customers to use the service offered at any given time
or place. It is not advisable to fill capacity with just any willing and able
customer. Attracting the wrong customers that are not in the right
place at the right time could cause conflicts and chaos. All businesses
have patterns where demand fluctuates. In off-peak times, it becomes
tempting to attract any customer segment. Often, the wrong customer
is attracted and is damaging to the company’s image.
On the other hand, restricting service to customers who do not fit the
market position is not always possible. While there are ways to
discourage unwanted people from purchasing services, this is not
always ethical.
Searching for a competitive advantage
Every service business is trying to compete for market share. As a
marketer, you need to be asking yourself what it is exactly that makes
customers select and remain loyal to one service provider. In order to
develop a competitive strategy, there are a few fundamentals that you
will need to understand. Differentiation from competitors is critical in
today’s highly competitive service environment. In certain economies,
the only way to show corporate growth is to take market share away
IMM GSM© Page 30 of 77 SEM001/SERM
from domestic competitors. Alternatively, service companies can
expand their service offerings internationally. Either way, they need to
know and understand who their customers are and who they want their
customers to be.
There are essentially four focus strategies available to
marketers seeking competitive advantage. In marketing terms, focus
means providing a relatively narrow product mix for a particular market
segment that shares common characteristics, needs, purchasing
behaviour or consumption patterns.
Figure 3.1 in Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), illustrates the four
basic strategies for services; namely, focused, unfocused (everything
for everyone), fully focused (service and market focused) and market
focused. For your exam you need to be able to describe these four
basic strategies for service.
Positioning a service in relation to competitors
Positioning is the process of establishing and maintaining a
distinctive place in the market for an organisation and its individual
product offerings.
The four principles of positioning (Trout) include:
Establishing a position in the minds of targeted customers.
A position that is singular, providing one simple and consistent
message.
A positioning that sets the company apart from competitors.
A company cannot be all things to all people – it must focus its
efforts.
IMM GSM© Page 31 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Internal, market and competitive analysis
Positioning links market and competitive analysis to internal
corporate analysis. Resulting from these three, a positioning
statement can be developed that clearly states what the product of the
service business is, as well as what the business wants to become and
how it is going to get there.
When analysing competitors, it is important to not only focus on direct
competitors, but also those that offer generic services that could
impact your business. You need to know and be able to apply these
basic steps involved in developing a competitive strategy:
Market analysis
Here the overall level and trend of demand and the geographical
location of such demand is determined.
Internal corporate analysis
This type of analysis requires the organisation to identify its resources,
any limitations or constraints and the values and goals of its
management.
Competitive analysis
Through this process, competitors are identified and analysed in order
to identify the business’s strengths and weaknesses, which may later
translate into opportunities for differentiation.
By gaining an understanding of these three steps you should be able
to conduct a market, internal corporate and competitive analysis on a
services business.
IMM GSM© Page 32 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Positioning maps for competitive strategy
Positioning maps, also referred to as perceptual mapping,
are used to locate competitors in a market, according to consumer
perceptions. Competitors and their products are usually plotted on
graphs and their positions are related to two or three features that are
important and relevant to specific target customers. From this type of
mapping, managers can decide if they want to maintain their current
positioning, or if they want to reposition the business. As a services
marketer and for your exam, you need to know how to plot a
positioning map to determine competitive strategy.
Self-assessment exercise
The following are some of the typical questions from Study Unit 1 that you
can expect in the assignments and examination. For your convenience the
mark allocation is also indicated at the end of each question.
1. In your own words define services marketing and explain the key words
in the definition. (5)
2. List the characteristics of goods and services. Use this list and identify
the difficulties of marketing services compared to products. (15)
3. Identify the forces that influence an organisation, such as kulula.com.
Use EBSCOHost and research this company to ensure that you consider
all relevant information. (20)
4. Use your own script to describe how customers are involved in the
services process. (15)
5. Choose a services organisation of your choice.
5.1 Explain the different ways in which a customer can interact with the
specific service organisation. (10)
IMM GSM© Page 33 of 77 SEM001/SERM
5.2 Write a brief report on how the 8Ps are implemented in the
specific organisation. (20)
5.3 Explain the relevance of internal, market and competitive analysis
when the company develops a competitive strategy. (18)
6. Draw a positioning map of the telecommunications industry in South
Africa, using cost and age as an axis. (10)
IMM GSM© Page 34 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Study Unit 2: The key elements of services marketing
This section focuses on four key elements: the nature of the service product,
marketing communications, pricing of the service product, and delivering the
service. The nature of service consumption is considered with special
reference to how value can be added as well as designing the service
product. We also address the issues of pricing the service product and
guidelines to develop effective pricing strategies. Later, we focus on the
scope of marketing communications and modern technology available for
effective communication and the role of delivering services, and the influence
of technology and globalisation.
IMM GSM© Page 35 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Specific learning outcomes
Reading reference
2.1 Developing service concepts
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 4.
Core and supplementary elements
A service product is not a physical object and is intangible.
Sometimes, there is a small part of the service that is a physical,
tangible item, such as this learner guide when you registered for the
Services Marketing module with the IMM Graduate School of
After studying this unit, you will be able to:
Define the nature of service offerings.
Illustrate ‘the flower of service’.
Discuss the different supplementary
services as illustrated by ‘the flower of
service’.
Explain the planning and branding of
services.
List and practically explain the
hierarchy of new services.
Discuss the role of communication
when marketing a service.
Use examples to illustrate the many
challenges in communicating services.
Draw up a checklist that can be used
to set communication objectives.
Identify and discuss the elements of
the communication mix.
IMM GSM© Page 36 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Marketing. However, this is usually a small portion of the price paid by
customers. The customer has to remain the most important focus
when planning a service product. Far too often, operational
convenience is allowed to dominate and take preference to what is
best for the customer.
The best case scenario is to develop a partnership type relationship
between marketing, operations and human resources. In this way,
marketers won’t be working in isolation from the rest of the business.
There are several steps in creating and planning a service.
Planning and creating services
There are three components or parts to any service offering.
These are the core product, the core delivery process, and
supplementary processes. Below is a brief description of each, using
the service of a hairdresser as an example.
Core product is the part of the service offering that the customer is
really purchasing. This would be the haircut and colour treatment.
Core delivery process is the ‘how’ of the way in which the service is
delivered to the customer, how long it lasts. This would be the
consultation about the haircut required, the type of hair colour to be
used, shampoo and the advice given on what would best suit the
customer.
Supplementary services are the extra things that are offered to the
customer to make the experience more fulfilling. These extras
facilitate the delivery of the service and add value. Examples would be
a neck massage, hair wash, tea or coffee and magazines to read.
IMM GSM© Page 37 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: figure 4.3) refer to an example of
the service offerings of an overnight hotel stay. Flowcharting service
delivery could clarify product elements as illustrated.
Supplementary services
Most services have much in common when we take a closer
look at their supplementary services. For this reason, they have been
classified into eight clusters, each falling under either facilitating or
enhancing supplementary services. These eight clusters make up the
‘flower of service’. Refer to Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: figure 4.4) that
clearly displays these eight clusters in the form of a flower with eight
petals. The middle of the flower represents the core product.
Important to note, however, is that not all core products are
supplemented by all eight supplementary services. In fact, high-
contact services tend to have more supplementary services than low-
contact services. You must be able to illustrate ‘the flower of service’
and discuss the different supplementary services in your exam.
Branding service products
Most service businesses have tried to broaden their product range and
market coverage by offering a line of service products, rather than just
a single product. Each of these will no doubt differ substantially from
the others. In some instances, products are differentiated by different
positioning strategies. An example of this in South Africa would be
British Airways and Kulula. Both brands are owned by the same
company, yet each offers its own unique positioning, pricing and
service offering, thus attracting different customer segments. The
brand of a service business must be well-recognised and understood
by both employees and customers alike. Sub-brands should reflect the
values of the corporate brand. The brand must translate into every
IMM GSM© Page 38 of 77 SEM001/SERM
touch point with customers. A customer’s experience of a service is
actually an experience of the brand delivering the service.
New service development
Innovation is the key to the ongoing success of any service
business today. Customers are becoming more and more educated.
With this come greater customer needs and demands on service
providers. There are seven categories of new service innovations.
You will need to be able to list and practically explain these seven
categories, commonly referred to as the hierarchy of new services.
2.2 Distributing services through physical and electronic
channels
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 5.
Distribution in a service context
The distribution strategy for a service business is by no means generic.
The type of service will have a great influence on the delivery system.
Often, when contact with customers is high, the service and the
delivery become completely entwined and the customer views them as
one and the same thing. On the other hand, customers engaging with
a service at a distance are mainly concerned with speedy delivery to a
suitable and convenient place.
Innovation is often driven through delivery processes. An example
would be new Internet businesses and retailers looking to e-commerce
for additional sales channels. Now is the age of automated logistics,
bar-codes, same day deliveries, home shopping and wireless
communication. All this has had a massive impact on the way services
are delivered.
IMM GSM© Page 39 of 77 SEM001/SERM
You will recall the ‘service flower’, where we separated the core
product out from the supplementary products. In this same way, you
need to plan your delivery system, starting with your core product and
then extending it to your supplementary products. Using the
hairdresser example referred to earlier, it is all fine and well offering tea
as a supplementary service, but no good if there is nobody to make the
tea and serve it to your customers.
Options for service delivery
There are numerous options available to service businesses
to deliver services to customers. Face-to-face contact, technology
available, types of transactions required and other factors all play a
role in determining the best delivery solution. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011:
Table 4.1) look at the possible options, combining both face-to-face
and arm’s length types of contact and the number of sites. Make sure
you are familiar with this table for your exam as you may be required to
discuss the various options available for service delivery, based on the
type of contact.
Place and time decisions
Clearly, the time and place decisions of service delivery
should take into consideration customer needs and wants. In addition,
the type of service, as we have already established, will also influence
time and place decisions. Cost, access to labour, accessibility and
location all become extremely important in deciding where a service
should be delivered. Refer to Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), to gain a clearer
understanding of place and time decisions and the many factors
influencing them.
IMM GSM© Page 40 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Cyberspace and services delivery
E-commerce brings with it a whole new world of opportunity for
businesses. Over thousands of years people have engaged in
commerce with one another, but they have always been restricted by
the barriers of time, resources and physical location. The fact is that no
one sleeps in cyberspace and the store is always open. The Internet is
the most significant development since the industrial revolution and it
has changed consumer behaviour and disrupted the norms of traditional
business.
It comes as no surprise then that selling goods and services through
the Internet is a major trend. Customers are shopping on the Internet
for convenience (24 hour service), ease of research, better prices and
broader selections.
The role of intermediaries
Intermediaries play an important role in delivering services.
It is often cost-effective for service organisations to delegate certain
tasks. Most often, this relates to the supplementary services rather
than the core service. However, through a franchising model, even the
core product could be delivered through intermediaries. Suppliers of
services form partnerships with other service providers (intermediaries)
to be able to deliver a more complete service package. Lovelock &
Wirtz (2011: figure 4.3) illustrate the splitting of responsibility for
supplementary service elements. Make sure you have a clear
understanding of this section and are able to replicate the splitting
responsibilities for supplementary service elements figure.
IMM GSM© Page 41 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Distributing services internationally
Marketing services internationally is a fast growing segment
of international trade. There are various ways that services can be
exported, but this depends on the processes and delivery systems.
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) discuss various ways that processes influence
international market entry. Ensure that you understand this section.
2.3 Pricing and revenue management
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 6.
Objectives for setting prices
There are three categories of pricing objectives: revenue-oriented
objectives, user-based objectives, and patronage objectives.
In Chapter 6, Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) have listed the
characteristics and differences between these three alternative
objectives for pricing in table 6.1. Use this table to discuss each of the
three pricing objectives.
Different approaches to pricing a service
When looking into the foundations of pricing strategy, you should
picture a three-legged chair. Each leg represents a piece of the
foundation to a pricing strategy – costs to the provider, competition and
value to the customer.
Costs to the provider represent the costs that need to be recovered
and is therefore the minimum price that a service can be sold for.
Value to the customer represents the customer’s perceived value of
the service and what they would be prepared to pay for the service.
IMM GSM© Page 42 of 77 SEM001/SERM
This is then the maximum price that the provider can charge for the
service.
Competition exists in every industry and especially so in the services
arena. The price that competitors charge for a service represents the
approximate pricing level, which will be somewhere between the
minimum (cost to provider) mark and maximum (value to customer)
mark.
Each one of the above legs represents a few possible pricing
strategies for service providers to choose from:
Cost based pricing
Competition based pricing
Value based pricing.
2.4 Educating customers and the value proposition
Study references: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 7.
The role of communication in marketing
Marketing communication takes many forms and is an important part of
the overall marketing strategy, as it facilitates the moving of customers
through the consumption decision process. Marketing communications
reinforces the brand and educates customers about products and
services and their specific features and benefits.
The role of marketing communications, simply put, is to inform and
educate potential customers, persuade target customers, remind
customers, motivate action and to maintain contact with customers.
IMM GSM© Page 43 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Challenges in designing marketing communication programmes
for services
Since services differ from products, so should marketing
communication strategies for services differ from that of products.
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) list five major differences between products
and services, namely:
Intangible nature of services
Customer involvement in production
Services are harder for customers to evaluate
The need to balance supply and demand
The importance of customer contact personnel.
You must be able to list and discuss each of these and use them as
examples to illustrate the challenges involved in designing marketing
communications strategies for services.
Setting marketing communication objectives
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) refer to the ‘5Ws’ model as a useful
checklist when planning marketing communications. Refer to the 5Ws
and answer the five questions and you should be able to set clear
objectives. It is important to have clear objectives, as these will help
you to plan your messages, communication tools and channels.
The marketing communication mix
Before you can plan your marketing communications mix, you need to
have a clear understanding of the following:
The service product
The extent to which prospective buyers are able to evaluate the
service product’s characteristics in advance of purchase
IMM GSM© Page 44 of 77 SEM001/SERM
The target market segments
Awareness of the service product amongst target market
segments
Exposure of different media to the target market segment.
The marketing communication mix for services can broadly
be divided into personal type communication and impersonal type
communication. There are many different elements to the marketing
communication mix for services. In Chapter 7, Lovelock & Wirtz (2011)
have clearly laid out the various elements in figure 7.6. You must be
able to identify and discuss each one of these elements for your exam.
Self-assessment exercise
The following are some of the typical questions from Study Unit 2 that you
can expect in the assignments and examination. For your convenience
the mark allocation is also indicated at the end of each question.
1. Explain how you would design a service concept considering the
customer experience. (9)
2. Illustrate ‘the flower of service’ and discuss the different
supplementary services, referring to practical examples. (18)
3. Explain the planning and branding of services and the importance of
partnering with operations and human resources. (12)
4. Customer expectations, especially in the service industry, increase
daily. How can a cellular network provider innovate its service
delivery to maintain a competitive advantage? (10)
5. Discuss the nature of service interaction by distinguishing between
the types of contact during service delivery. (10)
IMM GSM© Page 45 of 77 SEM001/SERM
8. If you owned a service business, what factors would you need to
consider before making time and place decisions? Use a table to
support your answer. (15)
9. You are the owner of a bed & breakfast. Explain how you would use
computer technology to deliver your service. (10)
10. How has technology impacted the service and, more specifically, the
retail industry? (10)
11. Distinguish between cost-based, competition-based and value-based
pricing. (6)
12. Explain the concept customers’ perception of value. (4)
13. Discuss the different strategies that an organisation can follow to
address the customer’s perception of value. (10)
14. How would you go about setting marketing communication
objectives? Refer in your answer to the ‘5Ws’ model. (10)
15. Consider a specific organisation and research its marketing
communication mix. Comment on the effectiveness of its integrated
marketing mix. (20)
16. Find an advertisement for a service in a magazine or newspaper.
Discuss the following:
- How it attempts to make the service more tangible
- The effectiveness of the marketing communication message.
(8)
IMM GSM© Page 46 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Study Unit 3: Managing the customer interface
In this module, we address the concerns of customer misbehaviour and
debate the concept of ‘the customer is King’. We also discuss the benefits of
services blueprinting and how it facilitates the coordination of activities
between the various areas of the services business. The role of the customer
in designing the service process is considered, as well as customer
participation across different levels. Later, we look at the importance of how
the service process works and where customers fit into this process.
Balancing demand and capacity is a major challenge for service
organisations, so we will consider this aspect with special reference to the
demand and supply in the service industry. The service environment shapes
the service experience and we explore this important aspect, also referred to
as the servicescape. Finally, we will focus on the people side of service
management, as staff play an important role in the delivery of services.
IMM GSM© Page 47 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Specific learning outcomes
After studying this unit, you will be able to:
Design a service blueprint and reflect on its
complexity and divergence.
Discuss the re-engineering of service processes.
Evaluate the customer’s role in the service
delivery as being passive or active.
Describe the levels of customer participation
across various services.
Evaluate the saying: ‘Customer is King’ by
referring to customer misbehaviour.
Discuss the implications of variations in demand
relative to capacity using a diagram.
Discuss organisation capacity constraints.
Explain how demand levels can be managed.
Explain why waiting lines occur.
Use drawings to configure different queue
alternatives.
Discuss ten propositions on the psychology of
waiting lines.
Describe the service environment or
servicescape.
Indicate how the service environment and
atmosphere impact on buying behaviour.
Briefly describe how environmental psychology
studies can be linked to the servicescape.
Describe the dimensions of the service
environment.
Design a guide (questions) that that can be used
as a tool when designing the servicescape.
.
IMM GSM© Page 48 of 77 SEM001/SERM
3.1 Designing and managing service processes
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 8.
Blueprinting services
Blueprinting is a type of flow chart used to design a service. It
identifies all the key activities that are involved in delivering the service
to customers and the links, sequences, relationships and
dependencies between each of these activities. Blueprinting is much
more detailed than a flowchart. Customers are impacted on by what
they can see front-stage and also by what they cannot see backstage.
Blueprinting records activities from both areas, giving managers a clear
line of visibility. Paying too much attention to one or the other will
result in a poor or faulty service delivery and an unhappy customer.
The most important aspect of blueprinting is its ability to
show relationships between employee roles, operational processes,
information technology and customer interactions. Blueprinting
facilitates the integration of marketing, human resources and
operations. You may be required to design a blueprint for a service
business in your exam, showing its complexity and divergence.
Discuss the importance of frontline staff in a
service organisation.
Describe the stressors in the service industry that
could affect frontline staff negatively.
Discuss the important role of human resources
management to hire, motivate and retain frontline
staff.
Evaluate the importance of culture in a service
organisation.
.
IMM GSM© Page 49 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: Figure 8.4) provide an example of a full-
service restaurant experience.
Service process redesign
All businesses have to monitor costs and seek better ways
of doing things, in order to save costs. In a service business, the cost
in a process is usually measured by the time it takes to complete each
step in the service process. In order to save costs, the overall process
needs to be sped up by shortening it, or simplifying it. The analysing
and redesigning of processes, in order to improve time and cost
efficiencies, is referred to as re-engineering. You need to understand
what re-engineering means, with specific reference to a service
business. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: Table 8.1) provide examples of
types of service redesign. Remember, re-engineering can impact on
delivery methods for services.
The customer as co-producer in service delivery
Customers who come into contact with your service
operation will be able to influence the process through their physical
involvement. They will be interacting with employees and could have
an impact on productivity. You must be able to point out the different
ways in which a customer can interact with a service organisation; the
organisation can go to the customer, the customer can come to the
organisation or the organisation can interact with the customer at arm’s
length through electronic channels, such as the Internet and
telephones.
There are essentially three levels of customer contact:
High participation services
Moderate participation services
Low participation services.
IMM GSM© Page 50 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Service encounters are measured by the length of time a
customer spends interacting with a service organisation, either through
interaction with service employees, physical service elements, such as
ATMs, or both. Figure 2.9, in Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), very clearly
illustrate the levels of customer contact or interaction with service
organisations. You will need to know these various levels well and
must be able to elaborate on the various levels of interaction between
customers and service organisations.
3.2 Balancing demand and productive capacity
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 9.
Services are non-tangible and, as such, cannot be placed in stock for
sale at a later stage. Services are delivered over a set time and any
time lost or wasted has a direct impact on cost. So, you may be
wondering how this works. Picture a doctor who has eight hours a day
for consulting. He charges his time out at a set rate and an average
consultation takes about fifteen minutes. If a patient does not arrive for
an appointment, his opportunity to charge for that specific time is lost.
He cannot get the time lost back and even if the patient came the
following day, it would not replace the time that was lost the previous
day.
In the same way, any service business that has no customers at
certain times is losing income and incurring cost. On the other hand, a
service business could attract too many customers and not have the
capacity to manage them. Finding a balance between too little and too
much and resourcing the business accordingly is what makes a service
business successful.
IMM GSM© Page 51 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Service productivity influenced by fluctuations in demand
Figure 9.1, in Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), clearly illustrates the
implications of variations in demand, relative to capacity in a service
business. A fixed-capacity business could face one of four conditions:
Excess demand
Demand exceeds optimum capacity
Demand and supply are well-balanced
Excess capacity.
There are two basic solutions to the problem of fluctuating demand:
Adjust the level of capacity to meet variations in demand.
Manage the level of demand by using marketing strategies to
smooth out the peaks and fill in the valleys.
Capacity constraints experienced by organisations
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) define productive capacity as the
term that refers to the resources or assets that a firm can employ to
create goods and services. In a service context, productive capacity
takes at least five potential forms, each of which has their own unique
capacity constraints.
You need to be able to name these forms of productive capacity and
discuss the constraints that each one may have on an organisation
within a service context.
Patterns of demand and factors that govern demand
By determining what factors govern demand, you can begin to control
variations in demand. To do this, you need to conduct research. Your
research needs to answer these four questions:
IMM GSM© Page 52 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Do demand levels follow a predictable cycle?
What are the underlying causes of these cyclical variations?
Do demand levels seem to change randomly? If so, identify the
causes.
Can demand for a particular service over time be disaggregated
by market segment to reflect patterns of use and variations in
net profitability of each completed transaction?
A number of factors could influence demand at the same time. For
example, ice cream sales may increase during summer. More ice
cream is sold in the afternoon, after lunch and on a weekend. So, the
total ice cream sales in the morning, during the week, in winter would
be very different to the total sold on a weekend, after lunch, in summer.
If you keep good records of purchases, it will be easier to analyse
demand patterns in your service business. Once you have identified
patterns, you can very easily match customer segments to these and
then adapt your marketing strategy to target customers more
effectively. In turn, the forecasting of sales and revenue will become
much easier and more accurate.
Managing the levels of demand
Strategically, your service operation should be sufficiently
equipped to meet your demand. This means having the right
equipment, enough employees and a big enough capacity.
Bottlenecks are common in service businesses and can cause
excessive amounts of pressure on employees and discomfort to
customers.
Although there are a number of ways to manage demand levels, no
strategy will succeed unless it is based on one thing – knowing who
your customer is, and why they use the service, when they do. For
example, in South Africa, Thursday is considered pensioner’s day and
IMM GSM© Page 53 of 77 SEM001/SERM
retailers offer specials to cater for the large numbers of elderly people
who are transported to shopping centres by old age homes. If these
retailers did not know who their customers were, but knew there was
an increased demand on a Thursday, they could be advertising the
wrong merchandise, such as a special on sporting equipment.
Five basic approaches
There are five basic approaches to managing demand, which you need
to familiarise yourself with:
Taking no action and leaving demand to find its own levels
Taking active steps to reduce demand in peak periods
Increasing demand when there is excess capacity
Storing demand until capacity becomes available
Creating formalised queuing systems.
Table 9.2 of Lovelock & Wirtz 2011, links these five
approaches to managing demand to the three basic situations of
excess demand – namely, sufficient capacity, excess capacity and
excess demand.
Marketing
In addition to the above, marketing strategies can also be
used to shape demand patterns. One of the more common strategies
is reducing price and other user costs during times of excess capacity,
and increasing costs during peak times. By doing this, consumer
behaviour is altered and capacity and demand even out. The difficult
task is to understand the various demand curves of the service
business at different times. It is always important when altering price
and other costs, to maximise revenues of each segment. Ensure that
IMM GSM© Page 54 of 77 SEM001/SERM
the most capacity is assigned to the most profitable segments
available at any given time.
Changing product elements
Another way of managing demand is to change the product
elements. For example, an ice cream shop would sell soup in winter.
This strategy is usually adopted when reducing prices has little or no
impact on demand. No matter how cheap, nobody is going to want ice
cream on a freezing, rainy, windy day. These types of changes are not
just based on seasons of the year. Some product elements can
change during a 24-hour day. An example would be the changing of
menus from breakfast to hamburgers at a Wimpy restaurant.
Place and time modifications
Instead of modifying the product, some service businesses
choose to modify the time and place of delivery. Three options exist:
No change – keep offering the product at the same time in the
same place.
Vary times – these changes reflect the customers’ preferences.
Change location – offer the service from new locations to bring
the service to customers instead of waiting for customers to
come to you.
Educating the customer
Through efficient and clear communication, customer
demand can be managed. Tell customers when they can avoid peak
times and delays. Communicate changes in pricing, product
characteristics and distribution clearly. Short-term promotions
combining pricing and communication elements, along with other
incentives, can influence and change customer behaviour
substantially.
IMM GSM© Page 55 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Storing demand
Order, predictability and fairness are expectations that customers have
when required to queue. Never leave masses of customers to their
own devices. The formation of queues is an indication of capacity
problems. However, it is not always possible to increase capacity.
There needs to be a balance between customer satisfaction and cost
control. Rather than allow pushing in and chaos, prepare for the event
that you may have queues of people waiting for service. There are two
quick solutions to this:
Ask customers to queue on a first come first served basis.
Offer customers the opportunity to reserve a space in advance.
In the case of queuing, managers of service businesses
should always be evaluating their queuing systems. Processes should
be redesigned to shorten the time of each transaction and customers’
perceptions and expectations need to be managed. Figure 9.7 of
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011), illustrates six alternative queuing
configurations. You should be able to replicate this drawing in your
exam, using it as a basis to explain these various configurations.
Minimising the perception of waiting time
Philosopher, William James, observed: “Boredom results
from being attentive to the passage of time itself”. Davis Maister
formulated eight principles about waiting time. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011)
have examined and reviewed these eight principles and have added
two more. These principles include:
Unoccupied time feels longer than occupied time.
Pre- and post-process waits feel longer than in process waits.
Anxiety makes waits seem longer.
Uncertain waits are longer than known, finite waits.
IMM GSM© Page 56 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Unexplained waits are longer than explained waits.
Unfair waits are longer than equitable waits.
The more valuable the service, the longer people will wait.
Solo waits feel longer than group waits.
Physically uncomfortable waits feel longer than comfortable
waits.
Unfamiliar waits seem longer than familiar ones.
3.3 Service environment
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 10.
The style and appearance of physical surroundings in a service
environment
Firstly, understand what the term servicescape means. Mary Jo
Britner coined this phrase when referring to the style and appearance
of the physical surroundings that customers interact with. This
includes objects, employees, advertising, communications, symbols
and trademarks.
The servicescape can have a positive or negative impact on a
customer’s five senses and, as such, service businesses should pay
careful attention to how the physical environment of their service looks.
Environmental psychological studies
The customer’s feelings and reactions can be shaped
through physical surroundings. The servicescape should enhance the
service offering. A business that is trying to give the impression of low
cost will have a functional environment and will avoid too much
glamour.
IMM GSM© Page 57 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Buyer behaviour can be impacted in three ways:
As an attention-creating medium (customers are attracted and
the service stands out from competitors).
As a message-creating medium (symbolic cues communicate
with the customer about service quality and experience).
As an affect-creating medium (increase customer wants through
colour, texture, scent, sound and design).
Integrating the service environment
Marketing cannot operate in isolation from other functions such as
human resources and operations. Any improvements or changes to
the service process should involve all of these functions, as well as,
where possible, the customer. Value, quality and productivity are
equally important to managers of service organisations. Success will
be dependent on management’s focus on these three aspects of the
business. This is a very important section for you to know for your
exam.
Dimensions of the service environment
Clearly the service environment consists of complex and
many design elements. Refer to Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) where the
focus is mainly on the main dimensions of the service environment.
Also refer to Table 10.1 for design elements used in retail stores.
3.4 Managing people for service advantage
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: Chapter 11).
The importance of frontline staff in the service organisation
In a service business, frontline staff are most important as they
represent the company and will, through their behaviour, leave the
IMM GSM© Page 58 of 77 SEM001/SERM
customer either satisfied or disappointed. Frontline staff are the most
visible and need to have the skills to execute operational tasks
efficiently, while remaining helpful and friendly with clients. Whether
services are delivered face-to-face or ear-to-ear via call centres, the
human resources approach is critical in the successful delivery of
services through frontline staff. In many cases, employees are the
service. The average front-line employee plays several roles – from
advisor to delivery, marketing to teacher.
The stress and demands of front-line work
The multiplicity of roles that frontline staff perform is also
known as boundary spanning. Boundary spanning has its challenges.
Often, because staff are involved in so many roles, there could be role
conflict between employees. The higher the organisation’s service
encounters with customers, the more difficult it is to manage.
Recruiting and training frontline staff is critical and should include
interpersonal skills, personal appearance and grooming, voice, product
knowledge, operational processes, selling capabilities, skills in co-
production, body language and technical skills.
Frontline staff encounter competing demands between management
and customers, long hours, lack of autonomy, insufficient resources,
ongoing demands to meet quotas and goals, burnout and emotional
demands.
Hiring, motivating and retaining front-line staff
Each job is unique and therefore each individual should be
correctly matched to a specific job. You would not, for example, put
someone with a quiet, introverted personality in front of customers. It
is thus important that recruitment criteria reflect the human dimensions
and technical requirements of the job. Although certain skills can be
IMM GSM© Page 59 of 77 SEM001/SERM
taught, others are required from day one of an employee starting a job.
Some characteristics and personality traits, however, cannot be taught,
such as having a good sense of humour or maintaining a steady flow
of energy throughout the day. Attracting and hiring the right people
into frontline positions is extremely important. More important though,
is retaining them.
In Chapter 11, Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) explore the
importance of recruiting the right people for the job in more detail. In
addition, recruitment procedures, recruitment criteria, employee
retention and customer retention are discussed. Know these topics
well and remember that effective management of human resources
includes recruitment, selection, training and retention of staff.
Customer satisfaction and customer retention are as a result of good
human resource management.
The importance of culture in a service organisation
A strong service culture should be cultivated to ensure
service excellence. To achieve service excellence, value-driven
leadership is needed to ensure a passion for service delivery is guiding
service providers. Values can be defined as:
Shared perception of what is important
Shared values of why it is important.
Staff in a service organisation should be kept motivated and
challenged, especially if they are in frontline positions. Be on the
lookout for staff burnout. By allowing staff to voice their opinions, you
allow them to highlight areas that may be causing this burnout. Quite
often, burnout is a result of staff feeling ‘helpless’ or ‘powerless’.
Sometimes, it could be boredom or lack of training. Encourage staff to
speak up and try to bring some fun into their work environment. Don’t
IMM GSM© Page 60 of 77 SEM001/SERM
be afraid to empower and involve staff. Quite often they have the best
solutions, since they are the ones engaging with customers.
Self-assessment exercise
The following are some of the typical questions from Study Unit 3 that you
can expect in the assignments and examination. For your convenience
the mark allocation is also indicated at the end of each question.
1. Select a service business and draw a blueprint that reflects both
front-stage and backstage activities. (20)
2. What is re-engineering and when would a service business
redesign service processes? (6)
3. To what extent can banks actively involve customers in the service
creation and delivery process? (8)
4. How can a service business deal effectively with customer
misbehaviour? (10)
5. Draw a diagram to illustrate the implications of variations in demand
relative to capacity. (10)
6. If you were the manager of a service business, how would you
manage demand levels considering capacity constraints? (15)
7. You are a bank manager. Explain the most effective queue
configuration for service delivery. Also indicate how you would deal
with the customers’ perceived concept of waiting time. (10)
8. What is a servicescape and how does it impact on customer buying
behaviour? (5)
9. Visit your local bank. Choose five design elements and evaluate
the service environment of the bank against these elements. (20)
10. Use your evaluation in question 9 and write a report indicating how
the bank can improve its service environment. (20)
IMM GSM© Page 61 of 77 SEM001/SERM
11. You have been asked by a service organisation to analyse their
frontline staff and to report back on some of the stresses they
encounter in their jobs. List these and explain to the management
team how these can negatively impact the organisation. (20)
12. Use your report in question 11 and recommend HR strategies to the
management team. (20)
13. Explain the concept ‘service culture’. (4)
14. Identify a service organisation with a strong service culture.
Motivate your choice by referring to aspects that you identified as
important in the reinforcement of their service culture. (10)
IMM GSM© Page 62 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Study Unit 4: Implementing services marketing
This study unit explores issues that relate to the delivery of services. Included
are issues such as relationships and loyalty; complaint handling and service
recovery; service failures and the importance of feedback, recovery and
improving services; and leading a market-orientated service business. These
issues are often not seen as the primary responsibilities of marketing, but they
need to be considered by marketers when developing and implementing
marketing strategies.
IMM GSM© Page 63 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Specific learning outcomes
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
Describe the customer/organisation relationship
using four distinct types of marketing.
Identify the correct customers for the service
organisation.
Describe the customer pyramid.
Discuss the wheel of loyalty.
Describe relationship management systems.
Identify the customer response categories to service
failure.
Describe how customers react to service recovery.
Discuss the components of an effective service
recovery system.
Define a service guarantee.
List the reasons for promoting service guarantees.
Identify and give examples of service guarantees.
Evaluate the importance of customer feedback.
Define service quality.
Illustrate the Gap model.
Summarise how service quality can be measured
and improved.
Differentiate between management and leadership.
Discuss how marketing operations and human
resources should be integrated.
Identify and discuss the four levels of service.
IMM GSM© Page 64 of 77 SEM001/SERM
4.1 Implementing profitable service strategies
Study reference: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 12.
The importance of customer loyalty
The days of ‘hit and miss’ marketing are over! Mass marketing, as we
know it, has been replaced by focus, target or customisation marketing
strategies. Customer loyalty, therefore, becomes important. It is far
cheaper to retain a customer than it is to find a new one. Hence, the
desire for organisations is to find the right customer to fit their product
offering. Products are produced and adapted according to customer
needs and customers are becoming brand conscious. A loyal
customer represents future growth for organisations.
Four categories of relationship marketing
There are a number of ways that a service organisation can
stay in contact with its customers, granted of course, that the company
knows who its customers are. Strategies that are designed to build
lasting relationships with customers are different to strategies that are
designed to entice a transaction or purchase. Coviello, Brodi and
Munro suggest that there are four distinct types of relationship
marketing, i.e. database marketing, interaction marketing, relational
marketing and network marketing. In Chapter 12, Lovelock & Wirtz
(2011) elaborate on each of these four types of relationship marketing.
You will need to know and understand these and their differences for
your exam.
Target the right customers
No group of customers is the same. Every so often, all service
organisations should be asking themselves who they are trying to
target. Who is the customer? Customers differ in terms of the value
IMM GSM© Page 65 of 77 SEM001/SERM
they can bring to the company. For this reason, customers should be
divided into groups or segments of similarities. No company should try
to be everything to all people. When segmenting the customer base,
you will need to consider the timing of the service use, the level of skill
and experience required to use the service, the preferred language
and how easily customers can access electronic delivery systems.
Ultimately, the customer must have a good ‘fit’ with the service
organisation.
Forget about quantity and focus on quality! The success of your
service business is not measured in terms of how many customers you
have, but rather by the value of your customer base and your ability to
maximise profits from that customer base. Match your customers to
your service businesses capabilities and be sure to meet the
expectations of your customers by employing the right personnel.
In Chapter 12, Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) review the art of
attracting, retaining and upgrading customers and terminating
relationships with customers. In addition, the concept of creating a
portfolio of market segments is discussed, with particular reference to
how it can significantly reduce the risk associated with a cyclic
business. Ensure that you understand and are able to apply these
principles.
Customer loyalty
Loyalty is an old-fashioned word that has traditionally been
used to describe fidelity and enthusiastic devotion to a country, cause,
or individual. In business language, it refers to the willingness of
customers to return to the same company for goods and services over
a long period of time. Loyal customers use goods and services
frequently, sometimes exclusively, and do not hesitate to recommend
their preferences to friends and family. A loyal customer is worth far
IMM GSM© Page 66 of 77 SEM001/SERM
more than a once-off customer. Loyal customers add value through
increased purchases, reduced operating expenses, referrals to other
customers and price premiums. Of course, there is the exception to
this rule, when the service offered relies on walk-in customers.
Richard Oliver has argued that customers undergo four stages of
loyalty:
Stage one – loyalty in a cognitive sense
Stage two – affective loyalty
Stage three – conative loyalty
Stage four – action loyalty.
4.2 Service recovery and obtaining customer feedback
Study references: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 13.
Customer complaining behaviour
Not all customers complain. This may be because they do
not believe it will make any difference. Some, however, go out of their
way to get hold of the most senior manager in the business to have
their say. There are a few options available to customers when they
experience what is referred to as a ‘service failure’. These include:
Doing nothing
Complaining, one way or another, to the service company
Taking action through a third party
Never use the service company again and make sure you tell as
many people as possible to do the same.
Bad word-of-mouth is the worst possible outcome that a service
company can experience, due to not providing customers with the
service that they expect. In today’s technologically enabled world,
IMM GSM© Page 67 of 77 SEM001/SERM
negative word-of-mouth is easily publicised through the Internet, where
thousands of consumers can view customer complaints.
Learning from customer feedback
When complaining, a customer will automatically assess
what is at stake for them. Their purpose for complaining is either to
recover some kind of monetary loss or to rebuild their self-esteem.
The costs of complaining, be they monetary for phone calls, time for
writing a letter or psychological for having to confront someone, may
cause a customer to rather keep quiet. As a service provider, you
need to create easy and accessible ways for customers to complain.
Make sure you know and understand what problems your customers
face when receiving your services. Use this very important information
to adapt and change your business and to gain competitive advantage.
Customer feedback is extremely important and is likely to be the most
powerful marketing research a business can get.
Customer response to service recovery
If customers are satisfied with the way their complaint was handled,
you will gain their loyalty. Remember, a retained customer is far more
valuable than a new one. The costs associated with obtaining new
customers are much higher than those of retaining old.
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) define service recovery as an umbrella term
for systematic efforts by a firm to correct a problem following a service
failure and to retain a customer’s goodwill. Also, service recovery
efforts play a crucial role in achieving (or restoring) customer
satisfaction. There are a few challenges to service recovery.
Sometimes complaints happen during the service. While these are
better, because there is a chance to correct the problem and keep the
customer loyal to the company, there is the risk that customer
complaints could impact service delivery to other customers. On the
IMM GSM© Page 68 of 77 SEM001/SERM
other hand, complaints often happen after the event, making it very
difficult to rectify, unless the customer returns to the service
organisation for a better experience. Often, some form of
compensation can be offered to entice repeat business and to prevent
the customer from moving to a competitor.
Components of an effective service recovery system
In figure 13.5, Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) illustrate the
components of an effective service recovery system. Any service
recovery system should bring a good return on investment to a service
organisation. Investing in customer complaint handling will protect the
long-term profits of the business. The formula to increase customer
satisfaction and loyalty is to try to do the job right the first time and then
add an effective complaint handling system for the times that you don’t
get it right. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) offer guidelines for front-line staff
for effective problem resolution. Refer to these guidelines so that you
can apply these when needed.
Definition of a service guarantee
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) define a service guarantee as an
unconditional guarantee of satisfaction, promising that if a service
delivery fails to meet predetermined standards, the customer is entitled
to one or more forms of compensation – such as an easy-to-claim
replacement, refund or credit.
Reasons for promoting service guarantees
According to Christopher Hart, these service guarantees are powerful
tools for promoting and achieving service quality. Here are some of
the reasons for this:
Services organisations are forced to focus on what the customer
wants and expects.
IMM GSM© Page 69 of 77 SEM001/SERM
What the company stands for becomes clearer to the customer
and its employees.
Systems are put in place to monitor customer feedback.
Reasons for failure are easily identified, giving the organisation
an opportunity to improve.
Services marketers can reduce the risk of purchase decisions
and can build long-term loyalty.
Examples of service guarantees
Almost every service company offers some or other guarantee. To
confirm this, simply pick up a magazine that advertises various
services. For example, browsing through the Homemakers Fair, a
publication of advertisements for the home improvements industry, you
would come across the following guarantees:
Hyper Steel – ’Guaranteed installation within 7 working days of
order’.
Roof Spraying – ‘15 year factory guarantee’.
Multi-Dex – ‘100% waterproof guarantee’.
Access Flooring – ‘Guaranteed, we will beat any written quote’.
The Paving Syndicate – ‘A lifetime guarantee on workmanship
and materials’.
There are challenges for a company to deliver a 100% guarantee,
which require complete buy-in and understanding from staff. Take this
into consideration when designing your guarantee. Make sure that
customers are not able to cheat and use the guarantee to rip the
company off. Make sure your staff won’t just give things away
because it’s the easiest route to customer complaint resolution, and
work out your return on investment, based on the guarantee that you
will be offering. This section on guarantees is very important for you to
know and understand for your exam.
IMM GSM© Page 70 of 77 SEM001/SERM
4.3 Improving service quality
Study references: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 14.
The service quality concept
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) refer to Garvin when defining quality. He
identifies five perspectives, each different, according to the context.
Transcendent view
“Synonymous with innate excellence, a mark of uncompromising
standards and high achievement.”
The product-based approach
“Sees quality as a precise and measurable variable. Differences in
quality reflect differences in the amount of some ingredient or attribute
possessed by the product.”
User-based definitions
“Starts with the premise that quality lies in the eyes of the beholder. It
equates quality with maximum satisfaction.”
The manufacturing-based approach
“Is supply-based and primarily concerned with engineering and
manufacturing practices. It focuses on conformance to internally
developed specifications, which are often driven by productivity and
cost-containment goals.”
IMM GSM© Page 71 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Value-based definitions
“Define quality in terms of value and price. By considering the trade-off
between performance and price, quality comes to be defined as
affordable excellence.”
Identifying the gap
If you understand what the customer’s expectation is, and
you know the level at which you are delivering against this expectation,
then the difference is referred to as the gap. Identifying where you are,
followed by where you want to be, will clearly highlight the gap. As a
manager of a services organisation, you will be required to constantly
monitor this gap and bring the expectation and delivery as close
together as possible, i.e. close the gap.
Ziethaml, Berry and Parasuraman have identified five potential service
shortfalls (or gaps):
Not knowing what customers expect.
Specifying service quality standards that do not match believed
customer expectations.
Service performance does not meet specifications.
Not delivering on the promise given to customers through
marketing communication.
What is perceived by customers does not meet what was
expected.
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) have extended this framework into
seven types of gaps that can occur at different points during the design
and delivery of services. Table 14.4 clearly illustrates these seven
service quality gaps:
IMM GSM© Page 72 of 77 SEM001/SERM
The knowledge gap
The standards gap
The delivery gap
The internal communications gap
The perceptions gap
The interpretation gap
The service gap.
Each of these can severely damage the relationship between the
organisation and customers. You must be able to list and discuss
each of these in your exam.
Measuring and improving service quality
Due to the intangible nature of services, it is fairly difficult to measure
its quality. In addition, because people are often involved in service
production, it is necessary to create the distinction between the
process of service delivery and the actual output of the service.
Quality of a service can be measured by reviewing the customer’s
perception of the service in comparison to what was expected.
Research shows that there are five dimensions used by consumers to
evaluate service quality: tangibles, reliability, responsiveness,
assurance and empathy. The SERVQUAL scale (a survey research
instrument) includes these five dimensions. Within each of these
dimensions, 21 items are measured on a seven-point scale. Another
way of measuring service quality is referred to as the walk-through
audit. Developed by Delvin and Dong, this approach involves taking
the customer through each step of their service encounters. Their view
is that the customer’s voice can be heard at each point of the service
encounter.
IMM GSM© Page 73 of 77 SEM001/SERM
The objective of any of the above, and any other measurement tool, is
to identify the service gap. Improvements in service quality can only
be achieved if the service quality gap identified is closed.
4.4 Service leadership
Study references: Lovelock & Wirtz 2011: Chapter 15.
The role of marketing in a services organisation is much broader than
that of a traditional marketing department. Service leadership includes
both the human resources of an organisation and the organisation’s
vision for being a front-runner in its particular service industry.
Marketers in services industries are responsible for designing,
constructing and maintaining customer, supplier, intermediaries and
other partner relationships.
Services organisations need to be market-oriented businesses. This
means that they are committed to understanding both the expressed
and latent needs of their customers, as well as the capabilities and
plans of their competitors. A market-led business has a longer-term
focus, which comes from broadly scanning their market.
A service leader, therefore, has to have a marketing function that looks
at the market, the customer and competitors all at the same time.
There needs to be a two way flow of information between these three
areas.
The four levels of service performance
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011: table 15.2) have expanded upon
the framework developed by Richard Chase and Robert Hayes and
have categorised service performers into four levels: loser, nonentity,
professional and leader. At each level, they have given a description
IMM GSM© Page 74 of 77 SEM001/SERM
of a typical organisation across 12 dimensions under the marketing,
operations and human resources functions. The 12 dimensions
include:
Marketing
Role of marketing
Competitive appeal
Customer profile
Service quality.
Operations
Role of operations
Service delivery (front-stage)
Backstage operations
Productivity
Introduction of new technology.
Human resources
Role of human resources
Workforce
Frontline management.
By using this framework, marketers can very quickly identify what
needs to be changed in order to perform better and move up the
performance ladder to become a service leader.
Defining a service leader
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) define a service leader as an organisation that
stands out in its respective market and industry. It does, however, rely
on human leaders to direct it and to set the right strategic priorities.
Leadership versus management
The service industry is fast paced and companies wishing to
compete must be willing to innovate and change on a continuous
IMM GSM© Page 75 of 77 SEM001/SERM
basis. Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) state that the primary force behind
successful change is leadership. There are some fundamental
differences between leadership and management:
Leadership
Concerned with the development of vision and strategies
Concerned with the empowerment of people to overcome
obstacles and make the vision happen
Concerned with the emotional and spiritual resources of an
organisation.
Management
Involves keeping the current situation operating through
planning, budgeting, organising, staffing, controlling and
problem solving
Concerned with the physical resources such as raw materials,
technology and capital.
Leadership qualities
Lovelock & Wirtz (2011) list the qualities that are often ascribed to
leaders in general as vision, charisma, persistence, high expectations,
expertise, empathy, persuasiveness and integrity
Leonard Barry argues that service leaders must be able to believe in
the people who work for them, make communicating with employees a
priority and love the business.
IMM GSM© Page 76 of 77 SEM001/SERM
Self-assessment exercise
The following are some of the typical questions from Study Unit 4 that you can
expect in the assignments and examination. For your convenience the mark
allocation is also indicated at the end of each question.
1. How do loyal customers add value to a service organisation? (5)
2. Describe the four different types of relationship marketing strategies.
(12)
3. Research Woolworths and comment on the services that it offers to its
clients. (10)
4. Evaluate the different methods that Woolworths use to retain customers.
(10)
5. What guarantees are offered to customers by Woolworths?
Evaluate the effectiveness of the guarantees. (10)
6. Indicate the benefits to Woolworths by offering customers
guarantees. (5)
7. Pretend that you are a customer and you are unhappy with the service
delivered to you by a cell phone company. Explain what options you
have available to you to lodge a complaint and what the cost
implications are for you as a customer. (10)
8. Customers might be dissatisfied with a service, however they do not
complain. What could be the reasons? (6)
9. What are the components of an effective service recovery system?
(10) 10. Discuss the importance of customer feedback and how a company
should make use of this information. (10)
IMM GSM© Page 77 of 77 SEM001/SERM
11. Explain the meaning of service quality. (4)
12. You are the manager of Cell C, a cellular operator. Explain how you
would measure and improve the services delivered by your company.
(10) 13. The manager of a hotel group asked you to explain the Gap model as
an instrument to measure perceived quality. Write a report explaining
the model and its benefits. (20)
14. Discuss the difference between management and leadership. (6)
15. Visit the website of a world-class organisation with a good service
culture. Comment on its leadership. (10)
16. Discuss the integration of marketing, human resources and operations.
(15)