From Nonsense to Number Sense: Enumeration of Numbers in ...
SENSE AND NONSENSE - JurisPro
Transcript of SENSE AND NONSENSE - JurisPro
SENSE AND NONSENSE IN MEASURINGSPONSORSHIP CONFUSION
JACOB JACOBY, PH.D.*
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION ............................................... 63I. THE RELEVANT STATUTE .................................. 64
II. CONSIDERATIONS IN MEASURING SPONSORSHIP
CONFUSION ........................................... 64A. What Language Should be Used? .................... 66B. Should the Question Focus on Whether Permission was
"Obtained" or Whether Permission was "Required"? ... 68III. CASE LAW ON MEASURING SPONSORSHIP CONFUSION ... 70IV. THE "HAD TO GET (OBTAIN/RECETVE)" VERSUS "DID
GET (OBTAIN/RECEIVE)" CONTROVERSY ................... 75A. Novo-Nordisk v. Eli Lilly ........................... 75B. NFL Properties Inc. v. ProStyle Inc ................... 77C. The "Posing a Legal Question" Objection is Predicated
Upon Invalid Assumptions .......................... 80D. Revising the Permission Question .................... 85E. Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Dooney Burke ............. 92
V. WHERE Do WE Go FROM HER ...................... 93A. So What is Sense and What is Nonsense? ............ 95B. Closing Comments .................................. 96
INTRODUCTION
Examination of case law reveals emerging disagreement acrosscourts on what needs to be assessed when measuring "sponsorship"confusion. Various issues, including the logic underlying suchmeasurement, are discussed. In the process, the author explainswhy, from the perspective of both science and law, one approachaccepted by courts makes sense while another does not.
* Merchants Council Professor of Consumer Behavior and Retail Management,Leonard N. Stern School of Business New York University and President of Jacob JacobyResearch, Inc. Although no implication should be drawn that the following individualsnecessarily "approve of or sponsor" the views expressed herein, gratefully acknowledgedare helpful comments on earlier drafts of this manuscript from the following: Leon B.Kaplan, Ph.D. (Princeton Research & Consulting Center), Richard Z. Lehv Esq. (FrossZelnick et al., N.Y.), J. Thomas McCarthy (University of San Francisco School of Law) andPasquale A. Razzano Esq. (Fitzpatrick, Cella et al., N.Y.).
HeinOnline -- 24 Cardozo Arts & Ent. L.J. 63 2006-2007