Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
-
Upload
nishantgokhale -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
1/13
- Nishant Gokhale
I.D. No. 206008
Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing
Identity
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
2/13
The Pre-Independence Legal Framework
for the Scheduled Areas
y 1874 - Scheduled Districts Act
y 1918- Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms
y 1919- Government of India Act
y 1930- Simon Commission
y 1931 - Census
y 1935- Government of India Act
y 1936-Wholly & Partly Excluded Areas Order
y 1936- Backward Tribes Order
y 1946- Cabinet Mission Plan
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
3/13
The Post-Independence Legal Framework
for the Scheduled Areas
y Constituent Assembly
yAdvisory Committee on Fundamental Rights and
Minorities
y For Scheduled &Tribal Areas other than in Assam
y For Scheduled &Tribal Areas in Assam
y For Scheduled &Tribal Areas in Baluchistan
yStructure Adopted was that of V
th
& VIth
Schedulewhich created varying degrees of semi-
autonomous structures
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
4/13
Structures in the Vth & VIth
Schedule
y Governor to act as the agent of the Centre in both the Vth
&VIth Schedule areas.
y Tribes Advisory Council to be responsible in the Vth
Schedule areas. Governor has filtering and law-makingauthority.
y Autonomous District Councils to be responsible under
the VIth Schedule. The District Councils have power to
make laws relating to specified matters. Governor canexclude the areas from application of specific
legislations.
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
5/13
Scheduled Tribes
y No definition in the Constitution
y List for each State mentioned under the
ScheduledTribes Order,195
0.y Basis for this Order is the census of 1931 and
BackwardTribes Order, 1936.
y The Order now consists of more than 400 tribal
groups.
y Removal of tribe can only be by Act of Parliament
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
6/13
The Changing Framework
yUnder the British scheme, the policy was that of
protective isolationism. Used as an strategic and
exploitative measure.
yUnder the Constitutional Scheme gradual
integration is sought. However, the framework
does not allow for this.
y Scheduled Tribes are seen largely from theequality lens which is different from the partial
integration model for the Scheduled Areas.
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
7/13
The Problem of Equality- 1
Scheduled Tribe is not a Group
y ScheduledTribe really is not a group, but a grouping.
y Fiss, Owen, Groups and the Equal Protection Clause,Yale Law Journal
y How is a group different from a mere collection of individuals who
happen to arrive at the same street corner at the same moment?
y The characteristics of a group are:
1. The group has an existence apart from its members as well as an
identity.
2. There is an interdependence between the members of the group as
well as the group itself, i.e. the members of the group identifythemselves by reference to their membership of the group.
y Most members of the Scheduled Tribe would identify with their
individual tribe rather than the notion of ScheduledTribe
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
8/13
The Problem of Equality-2
Heterogeneity
y With the focus on aiding the Scheduled Tribes, the
Constitutional scheme largely ignores the heterogeneity
of the tribal groups.
y Intra-tribe conflicts ignored
y Examples from the ConstituentAssembly Debates
y Alcoholic Beverages
y Naga Autonomy
y Categorization is of little help when most of the
conflicting groups are ScheduledTribes
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
9/13
The Problem of Equality- 3
Equality and Similarity
y Demands of the members of the tribal groups losedistinctness when clubbed with other disadvantagedgroupings in the Constitution
y Equality is a comparative analysis. It can only be claimed
when persons can show themselves to be sufficiently alike.y Members of the Scheduled Tribe can only claim equality if
they show similarity to the dominant group which is thegroup of non-tribals. The distinct identity has to beabandoned to claim likeness to the dominant group.
y The rationale of granting some protection or privilege to themembers of the Scheduled Tribe is not that there is anythingmorally worthy about the group, but merely the similar traitsthat they display to the dominant group.
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
10/13
Exclusionary Reasons
y Raz, Joseph, Practical Reasons & Norms, Oxford Univ. Press
y Reasons have of two dimensions:y Weight- It is possible to balance reasons. The reason which prevails is the one
which has more weight
y Authority-This excludes considering the reasons based on weight
y Lack of knowledge or understanding of the belief-
structures and demands of the tribal groups.
y
Relationship of inferiorityy Lack of representation
y Laws made forthe ScheduledTribes and not bythem
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
11/13
Old Wine In A New Bottle?
From Tribe to Indigenous Peoplesy Internationally, there has been an move from the terminology of
tribe to indigenous peoples
y United Nations Declaration on The Rights of Indigenous Peoples,
2007. India is a signatory.
y Advantages:y Move from the stage of development approach to distinct cultural practices
y Abandons the welfarist approach
y Rights-based approach
y Bigger basket of rights
y Problems:y Who is indigenous?
y Is it creating a new class of citizens?
y Can the current legal framework and practical situation cope with the change?
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
12/13
Tentative Proposal
y Rework the notions of Scheduled Tribe & Scheduled Areas
y Comprehensive Legislation
y Greater representation
y Rights based approachy Bigger basket of rights
y Update the list according to existing conditions
y Abandon the equality approach in favour of social inclusion or
anti-discriminationy Identify sensitive areas: forests, property, mining, cultural
property, conflict, sustainable livelihood opportunities
-
8/6/2019 Scheduled Tribe as an Impoverishing Identity
13/13
Thank You