SatoshiHIGUCHI - Hiroshima Universityhome.hiroshima-u.ac.jp/higuchis/Violence and Education.pdf ·...
Transcript of SatoshiHIGUCHI - Hiroshima Universityhome.hiroshima-u.ac.jp/higuchis/Violence and Education.pdf ·...
●
HIGUCHIiS htaos
fruahesrociti
dWufp
n is accmp d mi
itono
orrdm rs saef medvamimecp ess ;tesmeist eoll
l
ihlse
ik
o
tpo
iod teuca
f
ltpercepua
Vi eadEd nf m t Viwp fMime
hei
iss
ermnJ su yb nc dat lt nthiecnca
eofa da
Oltone
dereions
he
ee
ro
llsua
itucao
ha
nloenc
apanI
iscoursd icitstr
heeyoniottaylnimi nb dt
d despreaitt tracnnfimi elmlglSa gwieaivtta
anWeCl lususu,dan
dn
laotea
h ・o narau,
leveope
a
b trevera ages,
is
drea
fmimesd dbyGEBAUERa
gr de
Al yinp ls
nt tnerpreeisi d asa
niottaylnimi na
tspecs,ivtios ea
dt bdoheani;cshtetes
iss,mime
dren,lih
●●
・ Curr eq nofteb
na
dohituesoh
ni
l ty,tenicshtetes
wu
att yt
sno eme gOfJ ew ss hamoucdorapanes
h houg ,i lng
iann
no
heJt etapanes
・ Ⅰt t ten neres
fhi ttexenso
ion
fnveisAnd〟mimesisamo meto
nilvoenceflebrohlolayishtatgesugfs tmi sp sarei ep mo ・ Ime nt
fheorhaseiod tuca
h ieoresohirzllsuy,icfipec
de nb dontet yo
all Iwi mma etet ft danhlscoars,Japanesehe
dt tuenstn oihunsCa●
h Iys●・・ Pe, lp me fs
h lil ・oovoenceCd i Stepcshtalifilt trecenconroversaf teerhet mtnr oa
●●Olnh l il fcoo voence re,eiscikahosSil locoogThes tY iKAMEYAMA d ussss errgt
ノ heiecognzehiekrennIlsofEmieDURKHEM adR dGIRARD. Du m r st
hesioitdd ntot ep
ls eo
whn tsterm,ih
lty
e
ionadtrai
iespec"t all nyamogc
・leopen
itproprap
hing
gl eada ebn
enb nt dp nate
anguag
iotiprox
l iearnn
H Ima we saap
1
Hh i ・eavor
dap ewihtet yoheor
WUL
hti fton o convergenc
F.
inf
・lly
hat
itca
tu
me
nloencflebro m ovi ea
,Hmimeiss
iod terad inercons
"
hepltquI lper cr, et
●
nbeaueraG
l●●
dWunbeaueraG
nisiotcrea
sanietiliba
eatrs,inf
issmime . S
paisht
oiolteaanihuns
or
h iysca
ia
h lcoo,
ro
pearanc
iod tuca
p
tcuso
h
ltrua
hange
heacers
otn
isnc
u
h ieore
iaten
ie
v
ht
c
c
et
ess lmo fab nsme mi
arrdotbyt ・ T ea eofp lp methsar nt
iil eitc se nf m l mp
Andas m isf
・liuson
dedemhmedintemo i z
lcoionaf tuncfi tare o-ssez
isd luaiivdni ilrncphasetd iarlo yb dontep eofi●●
ion,i tza
-38-1
i
d l・uasiividn
oll ivetecs a c
es itocey
i
htftoin
sisiht
,
ismd luaiVTidnihiem,kr
フionsittu
Acc g to Du
otemimumuinht
in
ih t tgesrespec
dor
h■
nWh hE
itocey.
lvesOtconcep
n s
ic
Asi m isap eall gr etwadilnsroitessanclnowilplCrnisd luaiivdn
ioitorganza
rmoeor
ap
フelossoftet S"heacerh i lonatra
ylnit tsoceite
b touiol txpanaet snoe nah ierebecausフ
S'drar
lsol
dtnroucehe. Kame mat ni sGiya
iesre.fmimesortet ed dWufai lrang
ilausesvoence
his
・iloenced v
icthiesrean,db フerstfo dtemime
i・esitoce
ftd lariloss yO
focuderel dreaavheor'drarmsofGi St yh ebeena yoff . Thef soiicstir
・ioni tzalenera
he
n
f
u
heor'drar
n
lt t tnasrucur
le
he
t
dunahn
iloence
iloence
u
fsug
u
l
taur
ar
ht
beaueran
f
ec
i
ar
h it tcaracers
iigouslre
AsG dWu
co en eofhmanv . T dt
en ess ytohmanv . A dtef me eofhma
hesfa
noft Gi st yo
t toranoniesfid ten eimp
f
hte
yini ilonrvaryan, ,tite df all
iesreh
nitsord luacaseiiv
ntoted
sinh yads
t
roup
idn
ioca
biekr
i lcua
hta
tar
l te,
dins
xafotu,
f ioconscousn
itoni kgehS iTOMINAGAp sO re mp Du m f si
essi eap rs lg
inhtito w
nbeaueG ra
drer,iocaecoven
obou
iloenc
isAcc gtoGi mand eia mimeso
lngnoatt eadbe br Sa tcmp
s
itzao. Top ttema mi nofv eadr rs lo
h iavor
iesr
ix
n
h
u
dtui
dhrar,
reven
fio
in
ltpropra
dor
ilvoence
ap
nacrehti fonsotnois,hta es da
dt b teco ojhe
ga ecass masroolhtb touinkla
eme mofhwa iec
yofted eo
e Gi St yofter p bii honslteah
nom
heor
o
'
iesr
drar
h
h icans
i tncorpora
heor
ht
t
nisheveen mi same
ihiserhbusntoa eo et me ntsgna ft mmi si
uinanhd trs,her
sso
t
dian,im
ino wo eu mo
. "lliyngbu"lldeca
ioitzaleneradenenc'drar
s,a
s
yp sas . Thti
irze
tcapegoa
iteno
ec mma daGi st ytog
a
hsadtn
ls
drouce
mime es
Wes da yattop
tec
is
6luh
itsoce
ollhtec
ht
fo
heor'drarver,フhotges we Gi St yi
miei ec m me stnt ass hanroolh
-
dneyonheorttcapegoa yb di
stheory'hiem
■
■
nted luaiivdn sb wee
●
wmieins ・ Titocey
Whhb
me mac
i b iltrngsaouvoence.ic
ya
ty,
Ka
"h lortau
esstec eo
swa tea
fla
noh
aus
フy
h
ih
l
t
sDukiiczetir
h itevcdtetwaroilsvoenc'ive
it tu exs,itonnagTtaeveras o,rCIilToeiesroionsltrea fd eorv eO Wh mi ap sO sn
ing"l leve"hedeionsti l t rtrreevan oc●
Samlme
umscnbes
V iarousc
iics atir
il itocoogseshT
S.IS
ioit ttnerpreaheion
ioltea
toran
hfbu,
sai
ltsele
iss
htesfi tinter nofi
mime ・ Thsi nimp tp tint
ilvoence.
-48-1
l
dofame mar reet fv nt ass mcSt so ei ec
rads mt os ms stot
oroolh
dt tuen
iloenc
frodt tuens,
pey
h teacer
hZe
fro
lecogn
dt t:uens
ya
n
aK
hteace
mpose
dt tuensds
neconhh il ihspyscapunspittrs y
heaceran,
ilef ei 叫 t doeisvoencme es ea tlSgan
S。iryaaligads alldbtlll . WheKme matiyngec-oninihtg
S iocalHitsory ofb koo
tlihnsmetnsinsh lcoos
ihpunsmetn.
Hitsoryofed tucaionshlcoar, inhisIhciro EMORI,
Ph iyscalPum I tnvesi tgaesthereasonwhyph iyscalp● ● ● ●
'hsmetn,
d luas.iivdn
i dtonanitrenvedoe nt m wihacmmons ma ywesall ea 田e wpktahdtoa,llceothelixpat
・denceiv
os ・ Th
dtet doeisf1-irhhan
dt tuens
hteacer,
t
henexa
rnsire
itounres
an
tser
apan,der
haweep dbylw e rinJ nt ninWe nc ・ Hee mi stapa
lma sofa me mo nJ dt stoa we wh
ie
i tncen,
lara
ilterai itsorca
r
h herte
fleop
t
ohh l tcoo or
わdnnco
tnar
ho
le
idtero,
i trva
ht
an
f
dinp ee me ys sf ecmmonp eo
lpeophetor eo eEdop os wtomuhf essoc
y
leope
fare
h
apanes
in
o
te
i itnves
eEd ei sbee・ E ioff th:sop mo sac nc
iespec
ne
itrnegave
h lcoo n
a
itltna
a
h
h
・ Hec ulleo
er
tn
inc
ha
ihuns
lioncuson
l ioncuso
Cah Iys
iフr
Stes fp lp me nt ga ntso si es di edion
l.
itueso
t tuah
idero
allyf
av
l tgae
apan.
ht
inJ
ha
Weh etoq nEmo sc nt tteme yofJ ep
sbeen a
nb weeni
lyia
1】apa,
dndrelih na
fdehll itto aa serousertnswme en ・ T ei ao
leopehftohost ep
iloencehararihnsghi dsregarbecausil tvoen,itn- eitd stei tofGi dt tv
isfitus
h
d trer
ounh
tn
htatievesbleir
me sino oJ yh
mo ef dtee
oatnsihunsh iyscainj tecboor gtop lp me ・ Hehst
●●
mmoninJ
●
stayei llonatidtralrue ys da
ivtisposdegarei itsorcallyr dahre
iolteahroubtuirduaiivdn latt ebtf m ter
i leva,d
■ me wetnsh i l ihpyscapuns
●
mi lpetor
dregar gp sa
ihunsh ipysca
tnCl ihapunsh Iys
he
in
ias
me sc
t
● licassra ,
ly,dl tnugen
hsCltapfh Ipys
tiirerequs
i ilbtsorcaasenc
ica
h
ro
trac
tor
o
ar
iv
tgenerae
dencin
E
f
sntf m i
moihsap lp ef
de ef eh eo mi
musahte
●
teibihro
feofil
Japan.
i il d it t tsorcasanpon・ E
fierohetsht ta
hin
wa Edop do
lt kt
twStn
ro
illuns
t
im,
iiprerequs
F hor
h ipysca
ef mah
lp me ・ I
orontorfihrgihtcoomlpimkaitpropranapitihta si etOt eas ed yo wr gf
drenlihec
●
ktnillunsCah h Itapysecloudbecorr tt lp me Sma
-185ー
it w emo all ntec
lp me sinac nd reeaen ess yf ema eofs iloca
・ T ep m ist 0facc
me saeemp do 。 I dbeton
itnenanchtorar
tepanc
o
ecr
lou
h
tw
O
eg
t tconex
itera
he
trnooye
y.
]
tn
le
ion
ihuns
t
bro
r
h
tn
dra●Ca
h
h Ipys
dorer
ihpuns
w itwo dbeaocorr tthtaeclsluフ-yLlltonrn
h i lyscae orsuccess,w rphehte
Howeverフ
htehtal te,
hefroiervesnw yJ ep edon eofp lp me sd mt
n ofr st
tn
OKUGAWAin1
ihunsCah Iysprovtoapleopapanes
ihgt
h
io
reaso
tno
T
i
os mpfay orexa,tve1a ''
hsunayosd by teAnmalP n Acti dby Tssueiottroecihiefiyp
taci itsorcaverhem・ E nt yh lfvei itaransilga
y
apanese
l iogc
ibh is eavor
adbye ylws all
tbihro
lar
hi ・ IfJt
le
toun,tntnCl ihapunsfh Iopysh ilevoence me sioacctf
tgess,sug
biotiliy frterrbio poss
・awhetitb mbylihro
r
has essytop
dp lp sadt eweenher
ti
n
ilocanec
tenihunsm
suc
Cah Iyskeiils
●
tcibih
eeJapanesフorsay,
me sins weepOTrh lcoostnh h il ihtapyscapunst
herofferen
io
i
iscit
heacer
hce
ans
ya
hie
lpoye
Whnwe ea yo
kr
a
m
fome sb donadh Du m' dGi
ti
isuse
dt tuen
ltcua
i nK cdsionerma meq me ma ma ussss ss no
fp lp fs db msd tfyt mtme so se ssee
tues
kt tae
n
tn
h
o
ase
ihuns
in
e
tn
e
h iysca
her
ihpuns
t
o
● Clah Iysnp
iloenceh ieores'tsdrar ・ Thev
d iesr
hs . Wh gi ddnt osmer
hrmi lpat te taeace eap me same
hwh ha ti sNo ELASa di fhet t tpe er me sc rn mso
叫 a amiprocess ep me wo
b ucc
dore
eason,
t
sa
o
tern
tue
rgue
filtnoracovoence,
itnenance
ize
ans
I
ltsnorea
s
drer
b ter
n
in
n
・l
h
n
h hteeac
ihuns
a
Cl ihapuns
lu
to,
e
t
lu
h iysca
h Iys
lrueo
teco
tn
h
ve
t
dt tuens
fmi ;P dbeo me me wo eoea
n
ihuns
ixercs
arges
i itnane
S
WihGi
ihuns
Is
hg
ht
T h teacerseac
flu,
ien
t
es ess el teff fiwo dbeteo ma . Asfra
risb gma de ns
'
5,86
ed
me t yddntoihetns,Cl ihapuns
lpeop
h Ipys
ewasherthtai tng,kspea●
●
●
・i Ctnenanerma
iveltea
dlu
hte
ln・ Itiso yr
fioteneraheturtesraally,iicafuper Wecnr inf rg no
forilvoence
he
ge,
itp
doer
saga
i
hiis
i ionnif tsunc
ns eoft
ntem na
・avagerya
iloence,
hdne
is
h
fa
tacor
fiyni
tns
l
h
ihuns
iloenc
n
itnenance
aw
le
h iysca
bta
ver
t
dre
iio
ver,
bto
tnae
b
we
i
an
hpro
i
ht
ho
ca
le
eo rma ・ Th
nbyl
me sofp lp me ・ As ra tisv
nn es . O eoftef softeu
mi se yv eb ass tu rten fsyc gl meo
●
dororeanina●
df lme sf
h i・tpo essylcwnhfet oll gh
tnh il ihepyscapunsbiengih tef torilvoence me ・ Th me
tn,ihunsiloenioi tnuatonec nofv tp me
ti ionnglCtn ・ I
dvancecad,min we nad ieasnis'drar
d brer yi iltnannlfeveoheyonitcaelompecoh it tasocet yb mesc db dtel ma gO
oftisstihtatfproolouw, dbea
fioni tzalfiiocv . I
needtop
drer
ihc
h i lsy ca
n
itnenanc
derh
ht
tiliibalnre
ema eofo
yi emo dwhst nmi
P
-68-1
di ki sovj be meon dadmadenlceaeccoloencefdnff terentubフpear
easyti】s
me di
. T ek ec muhmo
mp dwihme wllhs ms moesi ilerousvoence,r
i dreserous
aee
c
ic
ause
l iltnavoence,
id filnsovoenc
sap
t
hos
are
tns
b
ihpuns
i iilnvs e
Co
i tsasers.
b danne.
hel・ AIdastlebiis
ettioreasosagoohert ei dr nf ob
ose
he
tp
ha
ihuns
tn
Jdo ug
●l
h
nJ nLOCKE dpmeT sC gEd so
nien ne me mep
tc
dart st et eter wr sopu me we
dwr lp ・ I lpso swe we
f "w db"yt ttwa es ec ro ermo es me
ihns
r
tn
budve,
iton
lhtnernasa
ilysca
f
ihuns
i
e
an
h lemseves,
h iysca
btua
lou
h itereexssno
tn,
tn
tns
h i lpysca
ioncernn
ihns
r
ll
ihuns
tn
f
t
lh i l ihtxernapyscapuns
h houg
ne
ihuns
ong
Ch Iays
h tarace
et vi mito つswi・ T ph pu me whbsu
h iysca
dtsan
furac
Ss o'
Jme . r lp me saeap
to a
ihg
ong
tns
h
h
he
n
lon
sa fp me fp me es
if L ksor oc
purpos
ihpuns
,
ho
forc
idcons e
ihtrg
y
i
a
ipngiphtattu wh
h i lyscataurlouhaT・lSan tw d bean eofp
totnme
e
e
o
h lou
iou
bu
apanofp lp me sbylw inJ nw dntb
ts db
atnihunsh iyscaiotibihro
iloence,eofaJ eme yt td sntt evl toeraooehatiltnaapanesdenciev
oavtnsan,ihslluとoLia fp me dwewillh et
he ●
ll●●
dwi・ Ift
Clah Ipysing,kpea
■
nnhtemida
● ipngiphfwnoiol tevauahei l tonexpores,ashl fd tcoaro eucaHi ERASAKI,Tikroa■
oethatsme
as
apanesedwhylnJ
eitisvbecaus
●●
omaer sa tP lv
ei ad fd
iloence,Cah Iys
angero
lSgan
ldncues
ionltegua
epht
h i lilpyscavoenc
h fereore,
kt
T
ion,tuca
re
eason
ll,'ne
h
leop
pos
lixpa
up
bu
an
te
lou
l
idero,
b
l iogc
taw
ionltea
lu
i ltonro
ih tuns ns,
ユu
kore er
apan
dh
i hc
hg
tns
tn
Ca
ary
tn
iero
'
ihuns
h Iys
Cl ihapuns
itoce
nnec
ihuns
h
hou
eco
h Iys
hd iurn
ha
o
h iysca
t
Ca
f h Ipys
ize
e
lea
lu
tns,
ac
i
ha
te
ea
iv
f
ttns
tns
he
ihuns
ltea
t
ihpuns
lou
ihpuns
h
der
ia
tsyse
hsa
f tor
itsoce
me oi wo dr
Ther lam ofp lp me stoc
m c dber dwi tp lp me allys
me wo db meu ess ・ Wewo dbea etos
m o rt np lp me sw dv ywelltos mito swi
mep me eEd di ・ Th de ntgt op nJ er
er el ko me sinteEop
ylSO ncallds mes ylnWh hter sb weenp ewe
mo nJ ntec ml
ianem
no nmidn.doerhemtf
htea ,
●
llsnelnttibsumdnuce gO wi
Cah Iyslneisto g eo yp lpiv
■
mtoi
da ;Lsadereicons iol tecara
nncreasetnihunsh iyscahtatp lp me si di
●
fereore,t toransttobemotimp ・ Th
nlecanturluhahttgesSugt eS mec eb ei,tonrarydo,Eterfapana,
-78-1
h hougt
● ●
ionlteayrbdo-aofani emidnlbnseparadeLietei aofs e,teE nitaserhhamdehk
lony.name
he
he
sta
dii ntspresuppose")
ts
f
ni
yhugnofE nt so es , nt hs owemu
ee eo na eo
nrw sap metoftemida tisa
het
n
fle
h
htf
n
s
h itaser eore
fh l ]i 】pyscapaxperenc
ll
ihuns
i
a
thus
hroug
emidadwi T i sd・ フn
ht
n
it tnerpre
hteace
ht sauctnihunsttot kofp lp me ss hah iyscainhi lcuffi
fno
icefS iacr・tcapegoaasa ,
tultponuIMAMICHI, SO
f ionucus.l taec
an
hhrougd tnersooh loup
in
sI-
sa
arh
es
htattep to "hee"s dbeu dt hteAn sofC
Th heepwa na ma
dt
iniilscpd-ff lorse
he
se
ingt
in
her
pro
t
d dtnersan
h
sensedern
ai
iftus
ou
lc nors I Thswyofu gt
we フ wsu oJ yo eteo wi
yo
ts
r mo , mo
hug
Hao
io
ver
i tvaltu
ho
mi tf ri eteJ ev fp lp me ・ I,f
oYUASAs H
tnsihunsh iyscao
ltcu
iewapanes
layspersona,
hluencfnhetur
l h Yosoper asu
hg
ihp n(hsugyooji tva
her,tadw ;rill
mometnC d tenenlSnitr●
gaS ,dt tuenllpriph
feoicancfi ign
heュactiasiei bspropaperishti ft trsparofhe ・ Th mh eisp nt
● bnoToC
●h Itapysn
ics.htef taes
sadme S, mo
oiteno
stes
s
pay
h
ver
・.tars
hoi
fto
hc ,I
itconsssfoh taracerinesicefisacr . TheCh ec "莱" wop =羊"(hee
mami we , satt nt
"大"dan)p
iodtounahtfh ieoretaseriasical hosopihep lb sofE nt so ef
has"義"
i itnsssi
f heacl legnnnh beltuasaidog sinr tt gO
uch taracerhteniannoht tnerprenps"hee"adi stecmmonme gamogo rc ss
hcmami
htflebpro mo es
)psfotarhi ldncuillcdgoodnicej tus( )a "善"( )wh etep "辛"(hee 。 I
iei lmp)
izi lonatrra
b teauyh taracerinesht trucurhttes eofteCh ec "莱"(hta
in
opp yfrp
eo m
f p l p me ,tnsihunsh iysca
la
ersona
lp ,
o
f h ipysca
ot
le
itorun
iexperenc
bitaunsu
hct treurnsusfilvoenceyo otr)(hte
Ⅳ
i ・neiilscpdflse-
Th ga htb tou
,
wh llWa dinti dtsnrouce
hlcoaro
inikn
het
On
f
yo
es fa
lsehe
ic
dtsu
t
heicefl isacr dtot
fuib teau
ichtetes
sheepi
lf iodtounaical hosopihp
iiesfl itsgn Habgs
use
)igb( ・ I l・"
lleCh ユysPta
hay
hc
ice
hc
f
I
f iosacr
I
188-
icancefi isgnhetas フ
mami is steb
mami sme fti' SO
t tsrucurehte・eh fIereo
heifteau ulort
isdooheyonih ltgesvau
i
ishta
lltsillte
tn
fo
taes
mo h. T ,
sabgs
ci eh eb dteg ・Th フ
htesheeph
yihicefiacr ・ Intswa,
-
ielpim"莱"
●●
yofP eb ds eo eGreek
hdtean
htfensroahtlt:aol hosopih′ αdev,γ
nw htit ep
iscorr g v eTb αlauindespont
h
dl bv,Lα<
・tαOαγαLKoα
ac
sn rn nT
no mK
io
ou
tonnec
teue
hetf
has
t
′
● ic,htetaes
ioi tcafiun
0,6九Iα(
he
f
i
race
hsnoi itew nt
in
luenc
deagogsinJ ・ Int dofp
fn
i sfdtwe wesmeme sot
ile
o
ha
h fe
ver,
apan
ho
ichtetes
・iceff isacrO
hisichw
ydeagog
apanesei llcuartar
teer
inlba
ar
ci nOnt ea
Snec
Ol
re,
tur
hame
n
oJ ・ Wea ofdap yJrt etsp
h
ics
t
ht 】apyscs,
lhl h d・ F Od miewhtt t yteroac ersuyapp ess
l apanecu
hh i btt t t t tacaracers sracconcep
Sae
i
iSe
ia
suc
i
hproacisap
an
h
dp
ht te er
ddsregareingdliu Hi
tylmmun●●
asienu
i
ih ltgesvau
hc
etohmanb gh
・ Imami sme icshteh ilt tapyscaaes
y,
tr,eo nc dtoapareomtefaritesiivi l tonaacf d toreuca
othtaiilcasyfiacres mp ywihc
h taracehumanc rb"f
dneasoii itngusheyonnyharaof"wa"( mo )b dtel cr na
apanese. ItisaJ
loehtorancih ltapacest mp eontewhapanese,hl iexcusvbt tuno one etoteJty,ilibisens●
tllprhbsaseiノf il fvoence or. ti dontes
ih ltgesvauelli
dacre
htetes
h
h
n
in
iigou
he
ar pwihter sadtesle
mutbetdwihGi
h
lonceae
t
ei db dt ehstev sc ea ca
t
i
ie
i hons
iloenc
ltea
s
hT
l ・easureihtetessana cp
flruolslou
hlohdrero
ihI
hjoynd ユuaaniiv de steo ftew ea
ftss
sw daobeapwe
hehrougiefitus dt ht
he
dniloencbou
ha
li
orw
apanes
raica
in
h teore
h koc
hn
fee
k leepnginmidtet lfme kt tIo t
Iwillr rtoas gJ efm a tv ea
ini dneltu
'
sImami S,ihca '
hts
hli dtytap ao
ihte
ionan,
citontsp ea
mi nO ehtesma sc ea caht
fd teuca
f
de
●iotoncep
de
i
Ca
hte
lyp
tesh
i
lecu
u
d liiuav
I
ilar
ty.d
as
i
in
tilibiens ywasJ
ichtetes
ion.d tuca
ics,htetes
ics,htetes
ess,hltnevere●
t
n
f ilvoencheor
fillュOvoencnayss
ht
hf torltooi lcaitcr
et yo ewiha
ea eade
●
iyng.fbull
hame la
ta micc sofa
allyq ed tf m aro
h itapysca
ilrce
itsanitu
dcae
Suc
ioni
presen
itttns u
heor'tsdrar yo
●
dnhrtnteihahetra
ics,htetes
'ihc
betolstisaoah dohaT
indprocee gs
,ally1】iF
iitsd leai ca
ions,tec
tiod tucai dsoreiloen
n
l lncreasng
i treceloyae
iero
Re
on
iBs
.
hta
n
o
h
ion
fsas
d teuca
lif
・ T alll d dbyKi
mi ollws
Atteedofal gp dofi yv td rine na
ishtfeoinltuUKASAKU. TheoFij
●
-98-1
i
● ●
・dB eR eLaw]oyalttalleCa-o
yearidr-hfto
eNewhTsofb g;dv etwadt sjns
yEd nR m Lw ise . Iti hes
h lcoos,heacerr
ts
o一enc
dtnace
io・n.
a
Hiuyn
feor
d ten
io
i inc
tuca
ions,ltu.i tns
C tenur
Un hy ar md wlglSh ehme mcasslrooodon,lenradanoeareac,law
hihs
is
g
hd ter
J iunor●
as,Japansi malteJ hjhs sinh lcoogiunorhlfh roscosen,dt tsuenユhcoo
h l dt tcoosuens・ Th hsighiunorje
dandoo ,
C tapeS
n
anno
nWe sadfapon
heT yC te he
Velg
h
e
t
a
leh kac
ha7e、
llancean,
l ixpos
ds dwi
he St tcnb
lnyhl dsanhscapttp oe etei . Teoem
tsno
ionllte
kacgroun
nmi
iocatibtuittng, ss lb di
bto
yd da dssat ga
i l tnacouner asure,
l d】ou oveic
i
h
h
ef hs ebykoe
i tsgus
th dt ・ Tde d dt ef memp unre
ef hc dnnt es ms ew es
sitsyc me er sp
dtt truansuens
f h lilo scoovoenc
e
h iersurvv
bn sur
housan
le
● ln
ti
i berouspro
h
its
l
asure
dt tuen
ihg
ht
an
i lona
i
iar
i
hicoc oreac
hifi derrens.
h horoug
necess mp
l dune oye,
h lm,
うV tnen(
t
i
b
dbylleike
nrevengフsleope eo
dnio
isson,
ittnsra
cen
o
,
d
itnsr
Oy n
ftae
hlea
il
h
bu
aw,
o
ionat
he
tven
in
h
n
ht
d dtorunersan
enc
lm,ih
fens
nua
l ef mint m t :tyc ee ssee or ea na
h
delicav
nbyt eAg dt lP cS yCeDe ya heNa mmiio
teJ nbyteMi yofEd
o
lunru
texecu
ecmi oma lf gt BRL es eaht
the
ion,tuca
htet
you
hifi d terrensor
t
t
ituersurve
harge
db eket ya mp ecmpo
hs dwidwi dcst taee sa
db das attyrmoec
gall ob
n
lte
dt tuen
ensort
dtepunerco
lh ltonrosou
Ppelqu
rhe
r
te
ecaus
ha
ilsan
klnec ace
dt teonae
oinitsrュユ-hsota dbed essgt
tisity,ilea
dtoay,"says
%,5t tnraloyune-ltee mp me eis1
di dfrtreed
heei yoes i ・urvvor
ays,
n
h
111
o
so
in
r
とls
tlitn
inafdan, ll
tI"・
iscousarec"t:oemandwr We on
ingi tsgusei sd nrti . I
df gw meadltushloesoiirasnoricefiacr
inlli
Tik haesh lteacerpaye,icliht
hera
f
hot
b l legnnn
lleacik
gO efm inwh ha dbyT KI
ohyImposs urr ytecltenl:ecbil
dltustsron"ilfevvao ga
ioitcidurs●
teiihbnna
ttee,oatn oihsme fBRLwCmmilbtesa
●
ss
el ttoanu
tscapegoa
hurougar
●
●
tlSagan
dren.lih
dtokille theruhac oforce
ecauslnliihtj tece sfmo yb
〟t.ilbtteil
hehaitssuias
li
ttaies
iloence
ih
7ltea
i its prase,
i bt txsence u,
i
love
hti tgans
u
,
i
htruos
ihs g o
dtunus
htat
Ha iFUKUIan dtsf
wemutf tfrore weh etor eorf . T tist
mothmaeatt ea er yof、 ・ Wh
tI
ANO,
ijinhStSil loogC
lebtaitsnosuliifshthtad teiec mi
anllya,tua
Oa7er,、owe
Ac manc
SSlhasesn
f
fkin
beht ts o
ikcsu
beco
ln
hta
tdlu
i ton,
hos
el koac
f d toreuca
h
u
t
sist ea swhor
me eh do
・ Amano yp pa eads ・ H
whod
"inquency.le
dltus,
liuvenj ed
-091-
hh tosedencifcon-ff lse eint ea
nllik ama
i
1
hthehrougt
diyaaMihtatfk inlliiotios
t叩 withtesff medorleh
mS ws っ we ,rsivehteusholiifsh
MIADAIs , wec mu , eweaeb
hs li wiho ・ T
hrougrbecaus
herst
drer
t
tanno
htnercanges
ays
ioca
Y
hrougt
goea ,
li
ver
dint mi yafms
her
lson
ho
tno
we ,
li
n
fishteCd Ieps ・tory
iih-cKen
tesperaeihtb tousa sd
・yfeeren
i(fnarautoini ldncuiontam(hoo
sinad twa
iit ) gb ho mi
inght011,llareilifis
n
drar
iod tuca
ere
loencean
f ilvoenc
eade nh ec dt ep
h b tsaou
my arr ei di et yo eoff yGisa mb nt db ,heor
twetocnf dtei dcon mp ymy vi de ni
h
hes
de
orar
de
lonceae
te
r
av
ive
tmpace
ta
iod tuca
h
ilcan
in
ht
n
ao
ilvoenc
tgessug
ittenls・ Itisaowr
d toa
Thep ms dtee meS nd dint
tteo sors yisrallyf ・ T ecmm edlonpac
h
o
itepce
h
iot tua
ユngac
i
e
txreh
itoce
inbhe
u
le
ne
bro
hbu f
fl
er
n
i iscourses
beaue
ntmso
us・J tasG radWulemsbro
hooluisoorapanesThemo eJ ew dfrmimeswo dbemlbtaitssu
deuce
ver
s
o
li
apanichte
H
taes
Mime llamotr
sinJ . H we ,
ivetaflopeun
lr
k
h
ni ehwema arr
isylnt wodo
f
h h leseopeson
eve
i tzelea
sp ntee mep no
Thymi yt has na●
txre
it tuaoi
hi
htasuc
tu
tsahg
t.
dl ht taoescencaracer
ihg
e
ti lsquer
h・sf tmy
"isuhs
toncepiashnhodegarsASAKIr mo asoeofteb cc sina
ialpecu
S
●
N toe
)isuhesimL・・(),. ."
tecenilehltari ao oi ef dofrfP ntde
k ktaaana
dan)iotta
t
ia
dian
dkoodersionsgum
hmoo
h itecstaes . Me i SAKABEc m sa
hertno
ehhah ieavoiman・u-hluu orb rt tm tbig
orrapanes)dance(i"ma I A J ewodf
dan・u7reween"hLL "
ichtetes
derionskbaaapaniodtrai ninJ ・ S ec sa
doyicancfi ign eofb ,hh iaszeemp stes
"
b tou
rom
klaapanioti ninJ ・ Het sa
df
te
houc
ioltrea
c
ts
h
u
is
)htour,
no
・ Heassme he nb
metofmimesin teatoft ・ing
ft moncepohd tersi icons ecS kasa
it
f
to
in
h
io
iilscp
ldncue
h
)iss
terar
rom
i
e
(luusu
d ierve
bh ieavo
mime I Hisn nof
seemsnw inted eo
df "
rl yi stemimect
nttaeimi )a
sfm・ Li wi ,
wewo dr
sekel
lu
i'Fk kuasau
to("・uh Ture"dwor
hidn
b ks oo
an
Japanese
・i"hluu , d f stem
MURAKAMl ' A
to("・iurh
draitmimect
i,ltrea y
in Hミ- メ-シス
kaao
b daueran
l
ibss
n T
Mime yGe
rilSneioitta normi so
S
mlcernnt teraureci on gI
ARITOTLE,TARDE,
ho・
T
h Teohnl eT fMoot yO ,
s of BENJAMIN, CANE ltaoIT,P ,
lllenalyife soeoft
-19-1
iod lucIlOnrn
kr
e
h
fsre
a
lWufi errdbr
m oho s te wo
nin
・ Hu nws ma
iod terai l icaconst
]view asf
n te ohO
Hoo
her, 't
nattmp ma
imp ehsad efre tyHquao
d l tunanena
ea
a
base
lus
donaf
iesr ・
Le・・f lto sy'-kisibs oohT
hoo,mfl hosopyoihep
la.teGi フdrarAUERBACH,
treaedcanPluse,liTr
fiaslpusim eisab so
he
leguarhn
h
hed . Iftedtt
leaous
mi dt loei h d ・et ntes rer
mmO db dtdhC tontmmu ypwn ye na ererso
ti ・ Ilew yan eaousy
ori
ver
L.
ioca
l hlanco
lnequa
e
hos
h treae
h
i
ro
o
ba
go me yadofj yint
i iesresn
reven
n
cf l s i11p tf m t eme dj nt
di yo ef lent ma
iesre
l hlanco
pac
O
h
ty,
tesa
h
f
n
ln
i
in
iagans
f lee
duner
h tcao
co
iesre
Hreva
hts
re
isap
lason
bou
eve
ver,
it
o
llir
lquaoiesr
h
i dze
t
ea
ft 。 Thyb tf eieno es yaer ga
ywihcmo ns esss
fe bed ef rdta pearvermens ys re yn
d iwiht ・ H edi esrena na nmu we gas
lsb he fhec ttmo ompen ep
lea
t
lge
r
ttssrug
itoce
lease
h
t
io
ho
dn o
i tenal
n
t
itoce
iipr
as
fferenc
der
dase o
reaso
id
hu
i
tyilnequadi
・ Sothe
danionta
dnlaiitvddll la
hebouirnliarec
dnhtfto
l
iipr
tWilln ess yb ga tt
es ei
iltqua y
heienuieh
i l ltonasyti
dtev w ofhmanb glnt
eo freer
fyoti inversUlS itr ocey, ,・Ae,TtuClu
dern-rehIntep mo
T h b hascenuctlh
,
ingslee
iearnngivttafimi el ,
hesd luaiiv . T ef
ts essadr tt m
orgaf t ma mz
fferenc
hoo
i
he
i
n
h
hu
itesrc
roug
he
n
o
pr
leope
ion
up
itza
n
lpersona
ti
dl
lnequa
Ja
di ・ Th htsdyamogp ean
ioni tzad luaiividn
Rol, wo
dan
homa ・ Asmoitonfreorle-f
leobapa
ntyHorequaiesrhi tesifsta ed ef . I
hfscalGes,S・u77Ktru,lu ell
)
evet ni rche snreaso
h d f feorero eerenceri(Rfeerences nt
i dze,leatr
tif lequaink do ys
,itocey
nisb leraihiiczetir stel ma
nsr naeasod luaiivdn
nfferencihtoriotite nf ed ea
''
ission,ltal San. Mime :
ng.
mo
men
ho
tenihgln
nionadtrai
htabecauster,lll ete
impluse,
'
msoft
sf me ltna
denan
duna
h
'
i itzao
bieng
iHv
ter
C
,itocey
LearmR i levvaos'to fl
isE lng(・299V l 1erag, hT
f,lG・& Wu
ioit t tsrucurza
●
)・5991,f iPorna riC】a ess
mo ns mpco
kraa
wi maeas
sc Mu mict tonex,
k
der
ll
ihL
draapaneshtfertnihtg en
jisu
me . Intmso eJ etE ln
oT mot
7d〃e・(
・26
a,
2-152・p9p,991,
Marr M・Ed)Mo
)Japanese(・5991,rTkoyfti inversUics,lhels yo oPess
iessmC.
f'i Tonatc
bauer,
i,S kasa
Ge Mi : K
K・Di yOAe
apaniodtrai n inJ "
Pri'iaawH ess
iteMimecT
-29-1
fti inversUcs,'httelesJ Aapanese yO●
idkoM・HMo :ThSkbaae,
)Japanese(・989・1,Co・bu
Mi aP .C0bu
)
ihras
Japanese(・79
M・ eint Mi Ch maP
M・Ph
kui7Or r.,heganguaJ Lapanese
losoiSkbaae, )Japanese(・3891・o,C・bu
9・1,
phyoIT wa i Pnami Ing,houc
Co・M・ sofBe wa miPbunah i Iavor,icloeP
Mu kiraam
Skbaae,
Skbaae,
8.991.,
・82-1p.p6,8910,57.No
9.891,.0bCu.hyos-inhS a P
・39-57・pp1,0027,3.No
)・le
●
ta・(Ed
wti lversttaS eUn yOfNe
)Japanese(・09
i,b hoayas
9・1o, )Japanese(・99
9・1o,
,T・AnI n toteT yofMo
M・ f' Ka waP
ho,heor
dkoa
h
'L iearnng
iol d lnrouc
i levvao
)
R
Japanese(
)Japanese(・3791
tn
)
ihuns
Japanese(・6
F kranc
iysca
・ 819,
eVe
lP me "K
C・bu
heorydoB- yT
9.69l 1rag,
,
),Voyage
)Japanese
(
Kame ma
mi
tn,mo .S lHi y Of Ph lPu meihnsiysca・ltsoioca
,
I
naga,
ya
ir,
To
E
maP C・bu
ts,)h houg
Chkui
ho" o (TishS
・,bCu o.
htoug
b・u
dTh sofPh
me aP CoihsiaK
,
ion,i lsaZiv
Y・LieadS fCh
d Mo
li
an
tecreon d,
itpnosm
N.Ub nPr ZiderPozeder e
ic,ltLhls
S・"Hy
)Japanese(
)Japanese(
El
NewT fCh d2yo ,liheor
ias,
moto,ijTsu
H・ Hi yantsor"i,T kerasa
doy
hmi T・Ont Ae Ko aPema
t
eB :T danEa nMi
Sex, kkioa
dn
i
tser
loyae
drer
d hans
l
owar
YbkPess
lill
,
touH・Ab eFmBatteR "(
h
r
T.
H
Mi Mu "Da
r
hic ,
Y Yuasa,
Fkiuu,
diyaa,
I
7.891
le,J iuven"
)Japanese(
・S
-39-1