Sample Collapse 167183
-
Upload
pouya-darvish -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of Sample Collapse 167183
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
1/20
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
2/20
-
:
:
:
:
1390
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
3/20
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
4/20
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
5/20
University of Tabriz
Faculty of Civil EngineeringDepartment of Structural Engineering
Dissertation
In partial Fulfillment of the Requirments for the Degree of
Master of Science in Structural Engineering
Assessment of progressive collapse behavior of
steel moment frames
Supervisor
Dr. Ali Hadidi
Advisor
Dr. Kambiz Kohestani
By
Sajad Mahmoudi
September 2011
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
6/20
I
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
: :15/06/1390 :140
:
:
.
) (
.
.
.
.
)DOD( )GSA(
.
.
.
SAP2000
)UFC 4-023-03( 10
)8 .(
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
7/20
II
)
(
:
.
))DCR .
.
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
8/20
III
...................................................................................................................................................................I
..................................................................................................................................................III
................................................................................................................................................VIII
...................................................................................................................................................IX
:
.................................................................................................................................................1
.............................................................................................................................................................1
1-1 ..........................................................................................................................................3
1-2 ..........................................................................................................................................4
: ..............................................................................................................................8
.................................................................................................................................................................8
2-1
........................................................................................................................8
2-2 .........................................................................................................10
2-2-1 ............................................................................................................10
2-2-1-1 )WTC(..........................................................................................10
2-2-1-2 Ronan Point..........................................................................................................13
2-2-1-3 Kansas City.....................................................................................................14
2-2-1-4 L,AmbiancePlaza..................................................................................................14
2-2-1-5
Alfred P. Murrah................................................................................................16
2-2-2 .......................................................................................17
2-2-2-1 Pentagon...............................................................................................................17
2-2-2-2 LibertyStreet130..................................................................................................18
2-2-3 ..................................................................19
2-2-3-1 Khobar...................................................................................................................19
2-3
...................................................................................................21
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
9/20
IV
2-3-1 )DIF(........................................................................................................21
2-3-2 )DCR(.........................................................................................................22
2-3-3 ...........................................................................................................................22
:
.............................................................................................................24
..............................................................................................................................................................24
3-1
.............................................................................................................................24
3-1-1 ....................................................................................................................................25
3-1-2 ........................................................................................................................25
3-2
..................................................................................................................26
3-2-1 ................................................................................................................................27
3-2-1-1 ...............................................................................................................................27
3-2-1-2 .............................................................................................................................28
3-2-2 .............................................................................................................................29
3-2-2-1 ...........................................................................................................................29
3-2-2-2 .....................................................................................................................30
3-2-3
.............................................................................................................................................30
3-2-4 ......................................................................................................................30
3-3 ........................................................................................................30
3-3-1 .....................................................................................................................................33
3-3-2 ........................................................................................................................................31
3-3-3 ........................................................................................................................................31
3-3-4 ....................................................................................................................................31
3-3-5
..................................................................................................................32
3-3-6 ..........................................................................33
3-4 .........................................................................................................33
3-4-1 ..........................................................................................34
3-4-2 ......................................................................................................................35
3-4-2-1 )ALP(...................................................................................................35
3-4-2-2 ..................................................................................................36
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
10/20
V
3-4-3 ................................................................................................................37
3-4-3-1 ) (.....................................................................................................37
3-4-4 .................................................................................................................................39
3-4-4-1 .............................................................................................................................39
3-5 .....................................................................................40
3-5-1 ...............................................................................................................40
3-5-2 ...........................................................................................................41
3-5-3 ...........................................................................................................41
3-5-4 .....................................................................................................................42
:
...........................................................................................................43
..............................................................................................................................................................43
4-1 .....................................................................................................43
4-1-1 .....................................................................................................................43
4-1-2 .................................................................................................................44
4-1-3 .....................................................................................................................45
4-1-4 ) (.......................................................................................45
4-2 ..............................................................................46
4-2-1 SAP2000,ETABS, PERFORM 3D.......................................................................47
4-2-2 FLEX................................................................................................................................47
4-2-3 LS-DYNA.......................................................................................................................47
4-2-4 ELS..................................................................................................................................48
4-3
......................................................................................................................48
4-3-1 (BS)...........................................................................................................48
4-3-2 )GSA 2003(........................................................................48
4-3-3 )DODUFC(..................................................................................49
4-3-4 )NIST(..........................................................................49
4-3-5 )ASCE(...............................................................................49
4-3-6 )ACI 318(............................................................................................50
4-3-7 )NYC(.........................................................................................50
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
11/20
VI
4-3-8 Eurocode.....................................................................................................................50
4-3-9 )NBCC(.............................................................................................50
4-3-10 ................................................................................................50
4-3-11 .............................................................................................52
:
.........................................................................................................................53
..............................................................................................................................................................53
5-1 .................................................................................................................................................54
5-1-1 ....................................................................................................................54
5-1-2 ............................................................................................................55
5-1-3 ............................................................................................................................55
5-2
............................................................................................................................56
5-3 ................................................................57
5-3-1 )LS(.............................................................................................................57
5-3-1-1 ........................................................................................................59
5-3-1-2 .....................................................................................................................59
5-3-1-3 .........................................................................................................60
5-3-1-4 ....................................................................................................................61
5-3-1-4-1 ....................................................................62
5-3-1-4-2 ..........................................................................64
5-3-2 )NS(.......................................................................................................69
5-3-2-1 .........................................................................................................................69
5-3-2-2 )AnalysesPushdown(.............................................................70
5-3-2-3 ....................................................................................................................71
5-3-2-3-1 )COL1-G(..............................................................................71
5-3-2-3-2 )COL1-V(..............................................................................75
5-3-2-3-3 )COL1-T5(...............................................................................79
5-3-2-3-4 )COL1-V-T5(............................................................................82
5-3-2-3-5 )COL1,2-G(.................................................................85
5-3-2-3-6 )COL1,2-V(..................................................................88
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
12/20
VII
5-3-2-3-7 )COL1,2-T5(...................................................................92
5-3-2-3-8 )COL1,2-V-T5(................................................................95
5-3-2-4 ..............................................................98
5-3-3 )ND(.....................................................................................................102
5-3-3-1 )AnalysesTime History(.......................................................102
5-3-3-2 ..................................................................................................................103
5-3-3-2-1 )COL1-G(....................................103
5-4
..............................................................................107
5-4-1 ......................107
5-4-1-1 ...............................................................................................107
5-4-1-2 DCR ............................................................................................108
5-4-1-3 .......................................................................................112
5-4-1-4 ................................................................................................113
5-4-2 ......................................................................114
: .......................................................................................................................115
6-1
...........................................................................................................................................115
6-2 .............................................................................................................................................117
................................................................................................................................................................118
ABSTRACT) (........................................................................................................................A
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
13/20
VIII
3-1- ( 2001](197[.................................................................................................27
4-1- ...................................................................................53
4-2- ...............................................................................54
5-1-
]213[................................................................................................57 5-2- ..............................................................................................................58
5-3- .....................................................................................................................58
5-4- ............................................................................60
5-5- ............................................................................................................61
5-6- ) LS(.........................................................................................................63
5-7- ..................................................................................................................63
5-8- ..............................................................................................................65
5-9- ) NS(.......................................................................................................72
5-10- ........................................76
5-11- ........................................80
5-12- ........................................83
5-13- ........................................86
5-14- ........................................89
5-15- ........................................93
5-16-
........................................96 5-17- ........................................99
5-18- ..................................................................................................................110
5-19- .......................................................................111
5-20- ........................................................................114
5-21- ................................................................................115
5-22- .........................................................................116
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
14/20
IX
-2-1 ......................................................................................................................................9
-2-2 ........................................................................................................11
-2-3 ...............................................................................................11
-2-4 ....................................................................................................................................12
-2-5 Ronan Point 18..............................................................14
-2-6 L,AmbiancePlaza.......................................................................................16
-2-7 Alfred P. Murrah .............................................................................................17
-2-8 .......................................................................................................................................17
-2-9 .......................................................................19
-2-10 130 23............................................................20
2-11-
.................................................................................................................21
-2-12 Khobar ..............................................................22
-2-13 ...................................................................................................24
-3-1 ]202[.......................................................................................................29
-3-2 ......................................................................................................................30
-3-3 .......................................................................................................34
-3-4 ........................................................................36
-3-5 ........................................................................................37
3-6-
...........................................................................39
-3-7 ......................................................................................................................40
-3-8 ......................................................................41
-5-1 4 10 ..................................................................................................................56
-5-2 ................................................................................................................................56
-5-3 ...............................................................................................................60
-5-4 ........................................................................................................60
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
15/20
X
-5-5 ) LS(.............................................................62
-5-6 ) ( ( ( ...................63
-5-7 ) ( ( ( .......................64
)-5-8 DCR ( DCR ...................66
)-5-9 DCR ( DCR ................67
)-5-10 DCR ( DCR ...................68
)-5-11 DCR ( DCR ................69
-5-12 DCR2.1 ........................................................................70
5-13-DCR ..........................................................................................70
5-14-
(
(
......................74
-5-15 - .......................................................................................................................75
)-5-16 ( ......................77
-5-17 - .......................................................................................................................79
)-5-18 ( ......................81
-5-19 - .......................................................................................................................83
)-5-20 ( ......................84
-5-21 - .......................................................................................................................85
5-22-
(
(
......................87
-5-23 - .......................................................................................................................88
)-5-24 ( ......................91
-5-25 - .......................................................................................................................90
)-5-26 ( ......................94
-5-27 - .......................................................................................................................95
)-5-28 ( ......................97
-5-29 - .......................................................................................................................99
-5-30 4 ......................................................................................................................100
-5-31 2 ......................................................................................................................100
-5-32 4 ....................................................................................................................101
-5-33 2 ....................................................................................................................101
-5-34 3 ......................................................................................................................102
-5-35 2 ....................................................................................................................102
-5-36 3 ....................................................................................................................103
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
16/20
XI
-5-37 2 ....................................................................................................................103
-5-38 ................................................................................................................................................104
-5-39 )ND(...........................................................................................106
-5-40 .......................................................................................................106
5-41-
.............................................................................................................107
-5-42 3 ..................................................................................................108
5-43-
3
....................................................................................................109
-5-45 DCR2.1 .............................................................................112
5-46-DCR ......................................................................................112
5-47-DCR ) (...............................................................113
5-48-DCR ) (.................................................................113
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
17/20
1
.
.
.
Ronan Point 1968 11 2001
.
.
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
18/20
2
.
)GSA1,DOD
2(.
.
...
.
.
.
.
.
1General Service Administration
2Department of Defence
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
19/20
3
.
.
1-1
.
)ALP1
(
)
(
.
))ALP
.
( (
1Alternate Load Path(ALP)
-
7/25/2019 Sample Collapse 167183
20/20
4
1-2
22
Ronan Point
1968
.[[1
[2] .
BS5950[4,3] )i(
(ii)
(iii)
.
.
Taylor DAPopoff AJBreen JE 1975
[8-5]. 19731976
[.[12-9 Ellingwood BR
[14-13]. 1983
GroosMcGuire
.[15]
Pekau OA 19821988
[18-16].Krawinkler H
[19].Pretlove 1991
[20].Sucuoglu H 3
[21].
90
)DOD(
[24-22].
1995 Alfred P. Murrah
.
)FEMA(