S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

18
<9-;-79<< < Dl{hmdlo Lclk`jx mf @dbhd``whdb * GJ@K K`c`jg`w 7995 rrr$m`$`d`wbx$bmv P$S$ K`ylw{j`d{ mf @d`wbx – <999 Hdk`y`dk`dc` Lv`$/ SR Rlsehdb{md/ KC 79050 Khs{whgp{`k ldk Gpoa Ymr`w Sxs{`j  Hjylc{s mf W`d`rlgo` @d`wbx  S`y{`jg`w 79<< Kld [md Ywmbwlj Jldlb`w/ Sjlw{ Bwhk W&K

Transcript of S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

Page 1: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 1/18

<9-;-79<< <

Dl{hmdlo Lclk`jx mf @dbhd``whdb * GJ@K K`c`jg`w 7995

rrr$m`$`d`wbx$bmv

P$S$ K`ylw{j`d{ mf @d`wbx – <999 Hdk`y`dk`dc` Lv`$/ SR Rlsehdb{md/ KC 79050

Khs{whgp{ k ldk Gpoa Ymr w Sxs{ j 

Hjylc{s mf W`d`rlgo @d wbx 

S`y{`jg`w 79<<

Kld [mdYwmbwlj Jldlb`w/ Sjlw{ Bwhk W&K

Page 2: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 2/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Yw`s`d{l{hmd Mp{ohd`

Cmdshk`wl{hmds fmw Hd{`bwl{hmd mf 

W`d`rlgo` @d`wbx

Bwhk Hd{`bwl{hmd Ldloxshs – Khs{whgp{`k

 – Gpoa Ymr`w Sxs{`j

@uljyo` mf KM@ Ywmn`c{s

Hjylc{s ldk G`d`fh{s

7

Page 3: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 3/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Cmdshk`wl{hmds fmw K`v`omyhdb

Cmpd{wx @o`c{whclo Bwhks

Sxs{`js lw` mf{`d {wldsjhsshmd cmds{wlhd`k

‐ Omdb wlkhlo {wldsjhsshmd ohd`s jlx w`|phw`

vmo{lb` spyymw{

Olca mf `o`c{whch{x jlwa`{s fmw w`bpol{hmd ldk

omlk fmoomrhdb jla` w`oxhdb md md`‘s

d`hbegmw fmw ldchoolwx s`wvhc`s jmw` khffhcpo{

B`d`wl{hmd khsyl{ce jlx g` ohjh{`k1 f`r`w

b`d`wl{mws md lp{mjl{hc bmv`wdmw cmd{wmo

LBC( cld jla` w`bpol{hmd celoo`dbhdb

3

Page 4: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 4/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Jps{ Ldlox~` @d{hw` Sxs{`j

B`d`wl{hmd[`cedmombh`s

@dk Ps`[`cedmombh`sldk {e` Gpho{@dvhwmdj`d{

[wldsjhsshmdSxs{`js ldk[`cedmombh`s

Khs{whgp{hmdSxs{`js ldk[`cedmombx

Ldlox~` gm{e khs{whgp{`k ldk gpoa ymr`wsxs{`j hjylc{s

‟Sxs{`j mf Sxs{`js‚ 

;

Page 5: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 5/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Bwhk Hd{`bwl{hmd mf W`d`rlgo`s ldk K@

Olwb` rhdk flwjs/c`d{wlo s{l{hmd YV/

CSY/ ghmymr`w/exkwm/ b`m{e`wjlo/

exkwmahd`{hc/hd{`wcmdd`c{ l{

{wldsjhsshmd ldkspg*{wldsjhsshmd

o`v`os

C`d{wlo S{l{hmd

Khs{whgp{`k

Khs{whgp{`k YV ommas oha`d`bl{hv` omlk md omclo

f``k`ws/ sjloorhdk/ V7B hd{`wcmdd`c{l{ {e` khs{whgp{hmd o`v`o

0

Page 6: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 6/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

W@ Hd{`wcmdd`c{hmd> [`cedhclo Cmdc`wds

Rhdk ldk Olwb` Smolw %Gpoa Sxs{`j Cmdd`c{`k B`d`wl{hmd(

S{`lkx s{l{` ldk {wldsh`d{ s{lghoh{x ldloxshs

Omlk-b`d`wl{hmd cmhdchk`dc`

Y`la Omlk ldk Vlwhlghoh{x mf Smpwc`( W`bpol{hmd w`|phw`j`d{s

Hd{`bwl{hmd rh{e Lp{mjl{hc B`d`wl{hmd Cmd{wmo LBC(

Hdcmwymwl{hmd mf w`d`rlgo` w`smpwc` fmw`cls{hdb

@uljhd` cpww`d{ my`wl{hdb ywlc{hc` ldk d`r cmdc`y{s {m

`dlgo` ehbe y`d`{wl{hmd –  fw`|p`dcx w`symdshv` cw`l{` w`bpol{hdb w`s`wv`s(

 – k`jldk shk` cmmwkhdl{hmd

Jms{ {`cedhclo cmdc`wds l{ {e` gpoa o`v`o elv` g``d smov`k rh{e jmk`wd rhdk

{pwghd`s ldk bwhk cmk`s – smolw fmoomrhdb rhdk rh{e d`r hdv`w{`w k`v`omyj`d{s$ 6

Page 7: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 7/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

W@ Hd{`wcmdd`c{hmd> [`cedhclo Cmdc`wds

Khs{whgp{`k Smolw ldk Sjloo Rhdk %Khs{whgp{`k B`d`wl{hmd(

Hssp`s ohs{`k md yw`vhmps sohk`/ yops

Vmo{lb` ldk VLW W`bpol{hmd

Ymr`w \ploh{x Elwjmdhcs/ Fohca`w/ KC Hdn`c{hmd(

Pdhd{`d{hmdlo Hsoldkhdb

Ywm{`c{hmd k`shbd ldk cmmwkhdl{hmd semw{ chwcph{/ w`coms`w/ {c$(

@|phyj`d{ bwmpdkhdb

Omlk ldk b`d`wl{hmd hjgloldc`

B`d`wl{hmd hd{`wlc{hmd rh{e cmd{wmoolgo` omlks KSJ(

S{mwlb` ldk s{mwlb` cmd{wmos

[`cedhclo cmdc`wds l{ {e` khs{whgp{hmd o`v`o elv` g``d hk`d{hfh`k/

gp{ sjloo W@ els dm{ g``d fpoox hd{`bwl{ k hd{m yolddhdb ldk my`wl{hmds$ 2

Page 8: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 8/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Vmo{lb` W`bpol{hmd Mf{`d sh{`k ls {e` ywhjlwx cmdc`wd {m p{hoh{h`s$

P{hoh{h`s lw` w`|phw`k {m a``y vmo{lb` l{ {e`

cps{mj`w omlk rh{ehd l dlwwmr my`wl{hdb wldb`

y`w LDSH C5;$<$

Ywhjlwx mgn`c{hv` mf vmo{lb` w`bpol{hmd hs {mywmvhk` `lce cps{mj`w cmdd`c{`k {m {e` p{hoh{x

rh{e vmo{lb` {el{ cmdfmwjs {m {e` k`shbd ohjh{l{hmds

mf {e` cps{mj`w‘s p{hoh~l{hmd `|phyj`d{$

Vmo{lb` spyyoh`k {m `lce cps{mj`w hs ld hjymw{ld{

j`lspw` mf s`wvhc` |ploh{x$ Sl{hsflc{mwx vmo{lb`

o`v`o hs w`|phw`k {m my`wl{` ohbe{s/ `|phyj`d{/ ldk

lyyohldc`s ywmy`wox$ Hdn`c{hdb ymr`w fwmj l K@W k`vhc` hd{m {e` ymr`w

sxs{`j rhoo mffs`{ omlk cpww`d{ {eps w`kpchdb {e`

vmo{lb` kwmy md {e` p{hoh{x$

[e` K@W k`vhc` jlx hdn`c{ o`lkhdb w`lc{hv` ymr`w

clylch{hv`( hd{m {e` ymr`w sxs{`j mw kwlr olbbhdb

w`lc{hv` ymr`w hdkpc{hv`( fwmj {e` ymr`w sxs{`j/

{eps lff`c{hdb {e` vmo{lb` kwmy md {e` p{hoh{x$

Khs{whgp{hmd Hd{`wcmdd`c{hmd>

[`cedhclo Cmdc`wds

[e` fhbpw` lgmv` semrs {e` vmo{lb` ywmfho` lomdb

{e` o`db{e mf l khs{whgp{hmd chwcph{$

Re`d l K@W hs lkk`k l{ {e` `dk mf {e` chwcph{

{e` vmo{lb` l{ {e` `dk hdcw`ls`s {m l vlop`

mp{shk` mf {e` dmwjlo vmo{lb` wldb`$

KB 

Dmwjlo vmo{lb` wldb` 

r-m K@W 

vmo{lb` rh{e K@W 

K@W

K@W : Khs{w hgp{`k @d`wbx W`smpwc` %h$`$/ YV/ rhdk/ fp`o c`oo/ `{c$(

5

Page 9: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 9/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Jlahdb H{ Loo Rmwa

B`d`wl{hmdYmw{fmohm

My`wl{hmdlo

Hdfwls{wpc{pw`

8

Page 10: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 10/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Hssp`s> Hdfwls{wpc{pw`

B`d`wl{hmdYmw{fmohm

My`wl{hmdlo

Hdfwls{wpc{pw`

Hk`d{hfxhdb hdfwls{wpc{pw`w`|phw`j`d{s – Rel{ {m gphok= Re`d=

 – Rel{ {`cedmombh`s=

Gphokhdb h{ md {hj` – Mg{lhdhdb y`wjhsshmds

 – Gphokhdb

Cmdd`c{hdb b`d`wl{hmd –  Hssphdb cmdd`c{hmd mff`ws

 – Gphokhdb cmdd`c{hmds

<9

Page 11: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 11/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Hssp`s> Ymw{fmohm Y`wfmwjldc`

Hk`d{hfxhdb {e` ywmy`w{h`s mf l cmdv`d{hmdlo fo``{clylgo` mf spyymw{hdb w`d`rlgo` {lwb`{s –  Hd{`bwl{hmd s{pkh`s rhoo |pld{hfx o`v`os mf fo`uhghoh{x

w`|phw`k {m spyymw{ {lwb`{ o`v`os mf w`d`rlgo` `d`wbx

Hdc`d{hvhshdb ldk spyymw{hdb {e` d`c`sslwxfo`uhghoh{x –  K`v`omy l emohs{hc ymohcx fmw `d`wbx/ clylch{x ldk

ldchoolwx s`wvhc`s ylxj`d{s {m `dspw` k`ohv`wx mf {e`s`wvhc`s w`|phw`k

Spyymw{hdb s{ldklwks fmw l celdbhdb

ymr`w sxs{`j –  K`v`omy {e` Bwhk Cmk` {m k`lo rh{e {e`

celdbhdb dl{pw` mf {e` ymr`w sxs{`j

 –  K`v`omy ldk hjyo`j`d{ l y`wfmwjldc` jmdh{mwhdbfwlj`rmwa {m `dspw` loo ps`wsmf {e` Bwhk lw`/ ldk w`jlhd/ cmjyohld{

Hdfwls{wpc{pw`

My`wl{hmdlo B`d`wl{hmdYmw{fmohm

<<

Page 12: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 12/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

My`wl{hmd> Hdcw`lshdb Cmjyo`uh{x

D`r ldk hjywmv`k {mmosldk flchoh{h`s

My`wl{hdb coms`w {m ohjh{s

Kxdljhc wl{hdb mfmv`we`lk ohd`s

Sy`chlo ywm{`c{hmd sce`j`s

K`v`omy ldk o`lwd

 –  [wlhdhdb

 –  S{pkh`s ldk shjpol{hmds

O`lwd fwmj m{e`ws

 –  Hk`d{hfx ldk hjyo`j`d{g`s{ ywlc{hc`

Hdfwls{wpc{pw`

B`d`wl{hmdYmw{fmohm

My`wl{hmdlo

<7

Page 13: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 13/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

My{hjh~` Fo`uhghoh{x ldk S{mwlb`

fmw W@ Hd{`bwl{hmd

@s{lgohse l

fwlj`rmwa {m

pdk`ws{ldk {e`

wmo` mf s{mwlb`hd {e` bwhk ldk

{e` w`ol{hmdsehy

g`{r``d

vlwhlgo`

b`d`wl{hmd ldks{mwlb` ldk

m{e`w smpwc`s

mf sxs{`j

fo`uhghoh{x($

<3

Page 14: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 14/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Sy`chfhc Hssp`s>

 –  Pdspw` mf hd{`wcmdd`c{hmdywmc`ss fmw chwcph{s rh{e mv`w

<0% YV Y`la YV-Y`la Omlk(

 –  Vmo{lb` w`bpol{hmd/ chwcph{

wl{hdbs/ compk vlwhlghoh{x

SC@ hs hds{loohdb 099JR mf

cmjj`wchlo wmmf{my YV sxs{`jsmv`w {e` d`u{ 0 x`lws

709JR p{hoh{x mrd`k/709JR HYY

Hd{`wcmdd`c{`k l{ khs{whgp{hmdchwcph{ o`v`o

SC@JR sclo`

wmmf{myhds{lool{hmd

Ehbe Y`d`{wl{hmd YV md {e`

Khs{whgp{hmd> SC@

<;

Page 15: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 15/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

E@CM-J@CM-E@OCM ldk AHPC

low`lkx elv` gm{e {wldsjhsshmd

ldk khs{whgp{hmd o`v`o yolddhdb

ldk my`wl{hmds cmdc`wds fmw ehbe

o`v`os mf YV

Sy`chfhc Hssp`s>

 –  YV Vlwhlghoh{x wljy wl{`s(

 –  Smolw Fmw`cls{hdb sce`kpohdb m{e`w

b`d`wl{hmd(

 –  YV hdv`w{`w jmk`os fmw s{`lkx*s{l{` ldk

{wldsh`d{ ldloxshs

 –  Khs{whgp{hmd ldloxshs fmw mv`w <0%

y`d`{wl{hmd o`v`os

 –  Q@uljyo` md Oldlh hs {el{ dm jmw` YV hs

loomr`k md md` mf {e` 3 chwcph{s rh{emp{ l fpoo

hd{`wcmdd`c{hmd s{pkxZ

Oldlh – <$7JR YV Yold{

Oldlh Scemmo– 7aR YV

Ehbe Y`d`{wl{hmd YV Hd{`bwl{hmd>

E@CM-J@CM-E@OCM

<0

Page 16: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 16/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

DV @d`wbx/ YB&@/ ldk SC@ loo

elv` olwb` %;99JR!( c`d{wlo

s{l{hmd YV hd {e`hw

hd{`wcmdd`c{hmd |p`p`s

Pdspw` mf my`wl{hmdlo hjylc{s Sy`chfhc Hssp`s>

 –  YV vlwhlghoh{x wljy wl{`s(

 –  YV mp{yp{ vs$ b`mbwlyehc khv`wsh{x

 –  Smolw fmw`cls{hdb sce`kpohdb m{e`w

b`d`wl{hmd(

Yw`ohjhdlwx Yold{ Olxmp{ mf SpdYmr`w7<9JR YV Yold{

0 aj

Ehbe Vlwhlghoh{x mf YV mp{yp{fmw l <;JR yold{

Olwb`*Sclo` YV Hd{`bwl{hmd>

DV @d`wbx/ YB&@/ SC@

<6

Page 17: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 17/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

Hjylc{s ldk G`d`fh{s

Clylch{x – W`kpc{hmd hd y`la*omlks rh{e hjyo`j`d{l{hmd mfw`d`rlgo` `d`wbx

Ymr`w |ploh{x & w`ohlghoh{x – Hjylc{ mf ehbe o`v`os mf YV md

`o`c{whc ymr`w sxs{`j w`ohlghoh{x

@d`wbx `ffhch`dcx * Cps{mj`w g`d`fh{ mf omclo vmo{lb` w`bpol{hmd{m w`kpc` ymr`w cmdspjy{hmd

My`wl{hmdlo ffhch`dcx – Hjylc{s mf lkkhdb p{hoh{x cmd{wmo mv`wYV sxs{`js ldk `d`wbx s{mwlb` {m hsoldk ymr`w sxs{`j my`wl{hmds

Co`ld {`cedmombx – Hjylc{s mf hd{`bwl{hdb ehbe o`v`os fmww`d`rlgo` `d`wbx hd{m {e` `o`c{whc ymr`w sxs{`j

<2

Page 18: S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

8/4/2019 S6 Dan Ton (U.S. DOE) - Distributed and Bulk Power System Impacts of Renewable Energy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s6-dan-ton-us-doe-distributed-and-bulk-power-system-impacts-of-renewable 18/18

K`c`jg`w 7995

[elda Xmp

Kld [$ [md

Ywmbwlj Jldlb`w/ Sjlw{ Bwhk W&K

Mffhc` mf @o`c{whch{x K`ohv`wx ldk @d`wbx

W`ohlghoh{x

P$S$ K`ylw{j`d{ mf @d`wbx

797( 056*;6<5

Kld${mdIe|$km`$bmv

Fmw jmw` hdfmwjl{hmd>M@> rrr$m`$`d`wbx$bmv

<5