RUDOLPH AGRICOLA’S DE INVENTIONE DIALECTICA (1479) AS AN INTEGRAL AND PRAGMATICAL THEORY OF...

8/13/2019 RUDOLPH AGRICOLAS DE INVENTIONE DIALECTICA (1479) AS AN INTEGRAL AND PRAGMATICAL THEORY OF ARGUMENTATION

1/27

RUDOLPH AGRICOLASDE INVENTIONE DIALECTICA(1479) AS ANINTEGRAL AND PRAGMATICAL THEORY OF ARGUMENTATION.

PAULAOLMOSUNIVERSIDADNACIONALDEEDUCACINADISTANCIA

po!o"#$"o$.%&'.'"

Abstract

A" *'+* *,* ""%!'" *,' -'&' "*&po/&* o$ *,' $/"* H%!&/"*" 0/*/%' -/&"* *,'S0,o"*/0 %&'"*&/&- o$ *,' o' & "0op' o$ Lo-/0 2/*,/& *,' '%0*/o& "3%"5R%op, A-/0o"De inventione dialectica (ca. 14795 $/"* p/&*' '/*/o& /& Lo%6/&511)5 /" 2/'3 0o&"/'' *,' $/"* po"/*/6' popo" $o 'o-&/8*/o& o$ *,' "/0

p/&0/p'" o$ *,' /"0/p/&' *,* /!" * $%*,'/&- *,' "p'0/$/03 p-!*/0 &,'*o/0 *'&" '3 p'"'&* /& *,' G'' */*/o& o& -%!'&**/o& & '"o&/&-5

" oppo"' *o *,' $o! "p'0*" "3"*'!*/03 **'&' *o /& *,' "3o-/"*/0 & *,'*,'o3 o$ '!o&"**/o& o$ *,' Analytics. A-/0o:" 1*, 0'&*%3 *'+* 2o% ''+*'&"/6'3 %"' /& *,' 1;*,0'&*%3 & ,/" /'" 2o% /&$%'&0' *,' !o"* /&&o6*/6''%0*/o& popo"" o$ R!/"*" & P,//p/"*" /& /"*/&0*3 '0'0*/0 & *&"/*/o&

p'/o *o2" &'2 %&'"*&/&- o$ *,' o-&/8*/o& o$ "0/'&0' & p,/o"op,3. '0* FFI @B=B o$ *,' Sp&/", M/&/"*3 o$ S0/'&0'& I&&o6*/o&.


2/27

'/-/o& & '%0*/o&5 /& *,' po'!/0 231. Lo-/0 , *,'& '0o!' "/0 p* o$

,/-,' '%0*/o&5 *,' /&/*/*/&- * 3 !'&" o$ 2,/0, "*%'&*" 2'' */&' /& *,' /&

o$ &3*/0 '+!/&*/o& & 0o&0'p*% /"p%*' *,* p'"/' o6' *,' 0%'&* ppo0,

*o *,' !o' "%"*&*/6' p*" o$ p,/o"op,3 & *,'oo-3. Co&"/"*'&*35 o&- *,' 1 *,

0'&*%35 2' 0& $/&5 !o&- 0'*/& 0/0'"5 & "p'0/3 (*,o%-, &o* '+0%"/6'3) /&

I*35 & '+p/0/* **/*%' o$ ,o"*/' /!p*/'&0' /'0*' *o2" *,' "**' & *,'

p*/0% 0,/'6'!'&*" o$ "%0, /"0/p/&' " 2" *,'& *%-,* /& %&/6'"/*/'" *,o%-,o%*

E%op'. O&' o$ *,' !/& po/&*" o$ 0/*/0/"! ,' 3 '6'& 6'3 '3 H%!&/"* %*,o"

-/&"* *3p/0 S0,o"*/0 '%0*/o& 2"5 *,%"5 p'0/"'3 /'0*' *o2" *,' o'5 *,'

"0op' & *,' 0,0*' o$ *,' * o$ o-/0@. A" '/&- /&*''0*% o$ *,' *' 14*,

0'&*%35 F&0'"0o P'*0 , '3 **0' /& ,/" 2oDe sui ipsius et multorum

ignorantia *,' o-/0 & $o!/"*/0 '!p,"/" o$ *,' %&/6'"/*3 *" 0%/0%%!4.

P'*0 0o&'!&' 2,* ,' "2 " *,' /'0*/0o%! -%/*" & /*" '$$'0*"5

"p'0/3 *,' ,/* o$ /"0%""/&- o& &3 o00"/o&5 $o /*" pp'&* %"''""&'"" $o /$'

& p0*/0 2/"o!5 /*" '$/&/*'3 %&-o3 & o%" 0$*/&'"" & /*" $o!/"*/0

/&/$$''&0' *o2" *%3 '/-/o%"5 *,* /" '*,/05 /""%'". Goo C,/"*/& p/'*3 &

!o/*3 2'' &o* *o ' $o%& !o&- "op,/"*/0 0%&&/&- & !%0, '"" '&* o

'&0o%-' 3 "%0, !'&". I&"*' o$ 2"*/&- *,'/ */!' & 2/*" /& '&'""

*'0,&/0/*/'" & "p'0%*/o&" o%* "'!&*/0 p%88'" 2,/0,5 /& ,/" op/&/o&5 , &'6'

o*,'' *,' ,'*,3 /"0o%"' o$ -oo A&0/'&* %*,o" o '3 C,/"*/& F*,'"5

P'*0 & o*,' 0/*/0" *,o%-,* *,* *,' "*%'&*" -o /& '&/&- *,' *" o$ *,'

trivium ",o% ' *,' 0,/'6'!'&* o$ 0/6/5 p0*/0 & 2'=!'&/&-

1R%!!' (1995 C,. 7 1=19@).@I& ,/" 0""/0 2o o& H%!&/"* o-/05 V"o/ (19;B @@=1) /&"/"*" o& *,' /' *,*5 $o *,'"' 0/*/0"5*,' 2o"* '$$'0* o$ $o!/"*/0 S0,o"*/0 /'0*/0 2" /*" 0o&*!/&*/o& o$ *,' 2,o' 0%/0%%!.


3/27

'"o&'&'""5 *,' "/" o$ C""/0 'o%'&0'.


4/27

p'/o" " H'!-o" o$ T'!&o" (@& 0'&*. .C.)5 H'!o-'&'" o$ T"o" (@& 0'&*.

.C.)5 o Ap,*,o&/%" o$ A&*/o0, (4*, 0'&*. .C.)5 2'' " /&$%'&*/ " o3 "0,o3 & '&' '/&- &

2/*/&-5 2/*, *,' "/0 ,'p o$ *,' *" o$ &-%-'5 *,'studia humanitatis5 %&'"*oo

" *,' "/0 o' *,* ",o% ' ",' 3 '6'3 0/6//8' p'"o& & &o*5 /& *,/" 0"'5 "

*,' "6' /"0/p/&'" $o ,/-,' p,/o"op,31@. T,/" /& o$ ppo0, 2" "p'0/3

'*' *o *,' &'2 /&*''"*" o$ 0/6/ /$' (*,* /"5 po/*/05 0o!!'0/ /$')5 0o&0'&/&-

/*"'$ 2/*, "'0% & 2o3 /""%'" ,/"*o35 '*,/0" & p0*/0 p,/o"op,31.

1'""' (1999) 0o!!'&*" o& *,' &'2 R'&/""&0' -'&'" (p*/0%3 &'2 *3p'" o$ 0o!!'&*/'") "p0*/0' 3 0%'" L'$6' E*p'" J14=1;K5 2,o , "*%/' /& I*3 2/*, A&-'o Po/8/&oJ144=1494K5 ,' "o !'&*/o&" A-/0o " p' $/-%'. P'$'**/ (@@)5 !'" "/!/ 0o!!'&*" o&*,' 2o o$ G/%/o C'"' S0/-'o J14B4=1BK.11S''


5/27

T,' 0o&*'+* /& 2,/0, S0,o"*/0 o-/0 2" 0/*/0/8' 0o/&0/'5 *,%"5 2/*,

'6/6 o$ *,' *,'o'*/0 /&*''"* /& ,/"*o3 & '*,/0"5 "p/&-/&- $o! 0'*/& '6/6

o$ 0/6/ /$' (* '"* /& "p'0/$/0 0/0'" & p0'"). T,* /"5 '6/6 o$ *,' 6'3 /""%'"

& *,'!'" o$ C""/0 ,'*o/0 (/"0%""/o&" o%* *,' -oo & *,' 5 *,' >%"* &

*,' %&>%"*5 *,' /&/6/%3 o 0o'0*/6'3 p'$''). A& "o o$ /'0*/05 /& /*"

'"*/0*' "'&"'5 " *,'o3 o$ %"'$%5 '6'33 -%!'&**/o& (*,* /"5 p%"/'5

/&$o!5 %&/!/*')5 *,' /& o$ *,'o3 o !'*,o *,* /" *,' '-' 0o&0'& o$ *,'

A/"*o*'/& Topics& *,'/ *' */*/o&. Mo'o6'5 *,' 'p%*' %*,o/*3 o$ C/0'o5

& ,/" o2& /&*''"* /& !'*,o/0 /&6'&*/o& Qi.e.5 *,' $/&/&- o$ -%!'&*"5 $o

p%"/' /"0%""/o& & 0'/' /"0o%"'Q 3 *op/0 !'&"145"o '&0o%-' *,o"'

/&*''"*' /& 0,&-/&- *,/&-" /& *,' /"0/p/&' o$ o-/0 *o oo *o2" topical

argumentation " "%/*' "o%0' $o 2,* *,'3 2'' "'0,/&- 2/'3 %"'$%

-'&' *,'o3 & !'*,o $o '"o&' -%!'&**/o&. Top/0 -%!'&**/o& &

,'*o/0 /""%'" '0!'5 /& *,/" 235 0'&* $o *,' &'2 ppo0, *o /'0*/0 &5

00o/&-35 A/"*o*'" Topics&!hetoric5 "o!' o$ *,' !/& "o%0'" $o *,o"' 2,o

*,o%-,* *,* "%0, p*" o$ *,' Organon" 0o% po6/' o' & !o' %"'$%

*,'o3 o$ /&$''&0' 2'' '/&- '/*,' &'-'0*' o !/"'p'"'&*' 3 0%'&* S0,o"*/0

A/"*o*'/&/"!.

A Dialectical Invention as the Basis for an Integral Theory of Argumentation

So!' o$ *,' /&-'/'&*" & */*" o$ *,' &'2 H%!&/"* ppo0, *o /'0*/0 12''5

*,''$o'5 p'"'&* /& I*/& 0/0'" o%& *,' $/"* ,$ o$ *,' 1*, 0'&*%3 *,'

2/'"p' p/"' o$ C""/0 "*3' & 'o%'&0'5 *,' /&*''"* /& *,' '0o6'3 o$ *'+*"

& */*/o&" o& ,'*o/0 & /'0*/0 Q &'2 00%*' *&"*/o& o$ A/"*o*'"

14A" '+po"' /& C/0'o" De inventione rhetorica& *,' Topica ad Tre"antium5 "p'0/35 %* "o /&De Oratore(II 99=177).1A" "*%/' 3 V"o/ (19;B) & /&' (19B7).


6/27

!hetoric2" 0/0%*' 3 G'o-' o$ T'/"o&5 2,o "o 2o*' o/-/& 2o" o&

,'*o/0 & /'0*/053 144;1;Q & *,' 0/*/0 ppo0, *o 0%'&* p,/o"op,/0

A/"*o*'/&/"!5 "p'0/3 'p'"'&*' 3 Lo'&8o V" !epastinatio dialecticae et

philosophiae (149)17. I& *,/" 2o5 V "**' "3"*'!*/0 **0 o& *,' *'0,&/0

"/" o$ *,' 0%'&* ppo0, *o o-/05 0/*/0/"/&- *,' "*0* %"' o$ *,' 0o&0'p* o$

essentia5 '%0/&- *,' A/"*o*'/& 0*'-o/'" *o >%"* *,'' /&" Q"%"*&0'5 %/*3

& 0*/o& 0""/$/0*/o& *,* 2o% /&$%'&0' A-/0o" o-&/8*/o& o$ *,' *op/0"

(L$$&0,/5 1999 )Q &5 "p'0/3 '$'&/&- *,' ''6&0' o$ C""/0 ,'*o/0"

'$'0*/o&" o& -%!'&**/o& $o *,' 0o&"/'*/o& o$ *,' >%"*/$/0*o3 "p'0*" o$ &3

/"0o%"'5 /&0%/&- *,' "0/'&*/$/0 & 0'!/01B.

%-'!'&*.

1;Fo *,' /!po*&0' & /&$%'&0' o$ T'/8o&" *&"*/o&5 "'' L'* (19B9).17Mo'& '/*/o& /& V (19B@).1BN%* (@9 +) ," '0'&*3 6/&/0*' V" o>'0*/o&" *o "0,o"*/0/"! " p,/o"op,/03 ''6&*"%ppo*/&- ,/" 0o&6/0*/o& *,* V" ,%!&/"* 0/*/%' o$ "0,o"*/0 *,o%-,* '+'!p/$/'" $%&!'&*5 p''&&/ /""%' o%* *,' "*'&-*, and /!/**/o&" o$ p,/o"op,/0 &3"/".19O& A-/0o" "*3 /& I*35 "'' So**// (19BB).@T,' *' %"%3 0&o2'-' $o *,/" 2o /" 1479 %* /* 2" $/"* p/&*' /& Lo%6/& /&115 *,&"

*o *,' '$$o*" o$ *,'' o$ A-/0o" D%*0, /"0/p'" M*/& 6& Dop5 G', G''&,%' & A%"o$ A!"*'!. A%" 2" "o *,' '/*o o$ o&' o$ /*" !o"* "%00'""$% '/*/o&"5 & 195 2,/0, /" *,'

"/" o$ *,' !o'& 0/*/0 o&' 3 L. M%&* (A-/0o5 199@ J19K)5 $o! 2,/0, %o**/o&".


7/27

T,/" /6/"/o& 2" &o* &'2 /& /*"'$5 /* 2" p'"'&*' /& C/0'o" Topica ad Tre"antium@1

& 2" 'p'*'3 !'&*/o&' %/&- *,' M/' A-'"@@5 %* /* 2" A-/0o 2,o

0,!p/o&' *,' 'o-&/8*/o& o$ *,' 2,o' /"0/p/&' o$ o-/0 o%& /*. T,/" '$''&0'

*o -'&' po0'%'5 6/ $o any /& o$ '"o&/&-5 ' /* "0/'&*/$/0 (*,* /"5

&'0'""3) o p%"/' o '6'& "op,/"*/0 (/& *,' C/0'o&/& */*/o& o$ %&/%' ars

disserendi)5!'&" *,* 2' ' &o* >%"* 2/*&'""/&- 0,&-' o$ '!p,"/" $o! o&' p*

o$ *,' Organon*o &o*,' Q$o! *,* '6o*' *o "0/'&*/$/0 poo$5 *,' "3o-/"*/0 o$ *,'

Analytics5 *o *,' o&' '/&- 2/*, p%"/' & '$'"/' -%!'&**/o&5 *,' /'0*/0

o$ *,' Topics. ' '5 /& $0*5 $0' 2/*, '3 &'2 ppo0, /& 2,/0, -%!'&*"

"' o& *op/0" ' &o* &3!o' 0o&"/'' " !/&o 23 o$ '"o&/&-5 0o!p' *o

*%3 $o! poo$" Q/& *,' "'&"' o$ A'" /!p'$'0* /&$''&0'" o *,' *'

*/*/o& o$ !*'/5 *,* /"5 &o&=$o! 0o&"'%'&0'"@Q %* " !o"* -'&'

"0,'!' p'"//&- o6' any/& o$ -%!'&**/o&.

A-/0o" %&p'>%/0' %"' o$ *,' C""/0 "o%0'" $o *,' '0o&"*%0*/o& o$ &

/&*'- *,'o3 o$ -%!'&**/o&5 /& *,/" "'&"'5 2" p'"/' 3 ,/" o2& Q"o *,'

/&*'-Q 0o&0'p* o$ 'o%'&0' " '+po"' /& ,/" 147; p/'0' In laudem philosophiae

et reliquarum artium oratio@4. H''5 A-/0o op*' *,' */*/o& /6/"/o& o$

p,/o"op,3 /&*o */o&5 p,3"/0 & !o & 0,0*'/8' *,' $/"* p* "

p'*/&/&- &-%-' P,/o"op,3 "0/'" *,'' /"0/p/&'" *o *,'"' *,'' ''!'&*"

sc. /&*'/-'&0'5 '"o&'&'""5 &-%-'5 o$ 2,/0, *,' o&' '*' *o &-%-' /"

0' o-/0 3 *,' G''" & */o& p,/o"op,3 3 %" @. A00o/&- *o *,' *'+* o$

@1Topica ad Tre"antium @5 ;.


8/27

*,/" oratio5 */o& p,/o"op,3 2o% 0o&*/& *,' *,'' *" o$ *,' trivium 2,o"'

p*/0% /!" 2'' *o 0o&$' &%!' o$ 6/*%'" %po& o% /"0o%"' "o *,* *,'/

%&/*' -o 2o% ' %&/$/' 0o&0'p* o$ 'o%'&0'5 /'&*/$/' " *,' 0p0/*3 *o

p'"%'

A" o&- " *,'"' *,'' sc. -!!5 /'0*/05 ,'*o/0 2o /' o&' & 00o!p/",

*,' o3 o$ 'o%'&0'5 '* !' >%"* ""'* *,* "%0, /" *,' po2' o$ 'o%'&0' *,* /* &o*

o&3 o!/&*'" !'&" $o*%&'" & o/'"5 %* "o *,'/ $$'0*/o&" & '6'& -o6'&"

*,'/ 2/5 2,/0, "''!" "o /!p'6/o%" *o &3 %'@;.

T,' -o o$ */&/&- $o "%0, /& o$ 'o%'&0' 2o% '5 *,%"5 ",' 3 *,'"' *,'' *"

2,o"' /&&' /!/*" '-& '/&- '0o&"/'' /& *,/" p/'0' 2,'' 2' '3 $/&

A-/0o" !/& popo" o$ %&/$3/&- /&6'&*/6' po0'%'" '+*0*' $o! o*, ,'*o/0

& /'0*/0 "o%0'" /& o' *o %/ "/&-' 00o%&* "0/'5 /& ,/" 0"'5 *o /'0*/0@7.

R%op, A-/0o" !/& 2o5 0o!po"' ",o*3 $*' *,' oratio QDe

inventione dialectica(ca. 1479)Q & o$*'& /&*'p'*' " & **'!p* *o ,'*o/8' *,'

/"0/p/&' o$ o-/0 /!"5 ,o2'6'5 " 2' "''5 * '0o6'/&- *,' /'0*/0 o!/&/o& o6'

*,' C""/0 *,'o/'" & *oo" o$ /&6'&*/o& Q*,* /"5 !/&3 *,' "3"*'!" $o *,'

0""/$/0*/o& o$ *,' quaestioo po/&* *o ' po6'5 /"0%""' o >%"*/$/' & *,' *op/0"5

" "%/*' *'0,&/%' *o $/& & ""'" -%!'&*". H/" !/& po/&* /"5 *,%"5 *,* /*

",o% ' *,' /'0*/0/& & &o* *,' ,'*o/0/& 2,o o%-,* *o *' 0' o$ *,/"

%&6o/' p* o$ -%!'&**/o&@B. A& *,' 23 ,' >%"*/$/'" ,/" op*/o& /" 3 0/!/&-5

/& $0*5 *,' -'&' pp/0//*3 o$ o*, /'0*/0 & ,'*o/0 (p* $o! -!!) *o

@;V'%! %/ *'" "/!% %&%! p'$/0/%&* "o6%&*%' 'o%'&*/' 0op%"5 "*/" $%'/* /+/""' *&*" '""'6/'" 'o%'&*/'5 %* &o& $o*%&/" ,o!/&%! 0opo/%"%' o!/&'*%5 "' /p"/" $$'0*/%" '*5 %' o!&/"/!p'// 6/'*% /!p*/'&"5 /!p''* 6o%&**5 A-/0o (1997 J111K =1).@7V& ' Po'5 *,' !o'& '/*o o$ *,/" 2o5 0o&"/'" *,' 147; oratio" *,' -'! o$ A-/0o"/&*'- popo" $o *,'o3 o$ -%!'&**/o& ''6&* $o any *3p' o$ /"0o%"' Co!/&'" *,' *,''*" o$ *,' trivium5 ''" "o&* "/-&'" p ' 0o&0'p* o%'&0' 5 %/ 0,'8 A-/0o5 %&'"/-&/$/0*/o& p%" -' %' 0''5 0o%&*'5 ' /'& p' '& p%/0. C' 0o&0'p* "pp/%' *o%* W $/* W "*,o/' %&/6'"'' ' -%!'&**/o&5 %/ '"* %*//"' po% *o%* "%>'*5 &" *o%*'" "o*'" ' /"0o%"5'p%/" po"' "0/'&*/$/%' '"*/&' %+ 0o&/"0/p'" "p0//"" ' %&/6'"/* >%"%% "'!o& '

'00"/"*/%' '* '""/ 0/*/%' ' /&*''0*%' (A-/0o5 1997 J111K @).@BS'' "p'0/3


9/27

&-%-' %"' & 0o!!%&/0*/o&5 */&- '0, o$ *,'"' *" 0' o$ /$$''&* "p'0*" o$

/"0o%"'

T,'' ' *,'' po/&*" *o ' o"'6' /& &3 "p''0, *,* /* /" po""/' *o %&'"*&

2,* *,' "p'' 2&*" *o "35 *,* *,' ,'' 2o% ' 2//&- *o /"*'& *o 2,* ",' /"

*o5 & *,* 2,* /" "/ 2o% "''! p%"/' & 0'/'. G!! *'0,'" *,' $/"*

JK *,' "'0o& '-" ,'*o/0 JK I* "''!" *,* /'0*/0 0& 0/! 2,* /" '$*5 *,*

/"5 "p' /& p%"/' 23 o$ &3*,/&- 2,/0, 0& ' '* 2/*, /& /"0o%"'@9.

I* /" o&3 p-!*/0 %'"*/o& ('6'& ,/"*o/0 00/'&*5 00o/&- *o A-/0o ) *,*

*,'"' *" ",o% ,6' ''& /'&*/$/' 2/*, /$$''&* "%>'0* '" o-/0 2/*, "0/'&0'5

/'0*/0 Q/& *,' '"*/0*' "'&"' o$ *,' * o$ p%"/' '"o&/&-Q 2/*, *,' civiles

quaestioneso ,'*o/0 2/*, >%/0/ 0*/o&. Ho2'6'5 /* !/-,* "''! /& p/&0/p' *,*

*,'' ' "o!' /!/*" *o 2,* 0o% ' 0o&"/'' dialectical%'"*/o&5 "/&0' *,'' /"

&o* !%0, po/&* /& -%/&- o%* 2,* /" /&/"p%*3 00'p*' o '>'0*' 3 '6'3o3.

%"* $*' "**/&- *,* /*

/" '6'& po""/' *o /"0%""5 /& 0o&6/&0/&- 235 op/&/o&" " /&0'/' " *,o"' o$H'/*%" o *,' S0'p*/0"5 ,' -/6'" &'2 -'&' '$/&/*/o& o$ ,/" o2& /' o$ /'0*/0

T,' * o$ */&- /& p%"/' 23 o%* &3 popo"' "%>'0*5 *o *,' '+*'&* *o 2,/0,

*,' &*%' o$ *,' /""%' 2o% o2 0o&"'&*1.

So5 $o A-/0o5 /'0*/0 (,/" /'0*/05 /& *,' "'&"' o$ o-/0) 2o% ' ''6&*

$o any /"0o%"' (o& 2,*'6' /""%') " /* 2o% *' 0' o$ /*" '$$'0*/6'

0o!!%&/0*/o& & p'"%"/o& (docere)5 2,/' ,'*o/0 2o% "p'0//8' o& *,'

*'0,&/0 !'&" $o !o6/&- & p'"/&- (muovere et delectare)5 /'3 2/*,o%*

$$'0*/&- *,' "/0 "*%0*%' o$ /"0o%"' /!p'!'&*' 3 !'&" o$ /'0*/0 /&6'&*/o&.

@9*'"%' po/&' /& /0'&o o"'6*/o&'"5 %* p'0/p/ po""/* %/ "// 6'/* %/ /0/*5 %* 0%p/' %/* 0%//0/*%5 %* po/' "/* ,'*%%' $/'" '/ %o /0/*%. P/!%! -!!*/0' o0'*5 JK po+/!%!,'*o/0' JK %o '/%%! /-/*% '"* 6/'/*% "// /'0*/0' 6'&/0'5 po//*' /0'' ' %/'*'5 %' '%0/*% /& o*/o&'!5 A-/0o (199@ J19K @B=@1).

A-/0o (199@ J19K 7;=B).1" po//*' ' %/'* ' popo"/* /""''&/5 po%* 0%/%"%' &*% 0p+ '""' $/'/ po*'/*A-/0o (199@ J19K @1@).


10/27

T,/" "* po/&* /" '+*'!'3 /!po*&* $o A-/0o" p%po"'" '0%"' /* 2" p'0/"'3

*,' o%' */*/o& o$ *,' *op/0" (2/*, /'0*/0 & ,'*o/0 6'"/o&) *,* ,

po6' "p'0/3 p'>%/0/ $o *,'/ "'/o%" 0o&"/'*/o& 3 *,o"' '/0*' *o o-/0.

T,* /" 2,3 ,' '/0*'" *2o "p'0/$/0 0,p*'" /&


11/27

*,' $/"* "*-'" o$ *'+*oo". ' 2/ * o%* "o!' "p'0*" o$ *,' '$$'0*/6' %"' o$

-%!'&*" " '+po"' /&


12/27

0o% ' >%"* 2,* 2" &''' $o o & -'&'3 pp/0' ppo0, *o

-%!'&**/o&

T,/" !'*,o o$ *,' p0'" po6'" /*"'$ %"'$% $o !o"* ,%!& "0/'&0'" JK *,o%-, /*

/" *%' *,* /* !/&3 'o&-" *o *,o"' *,* 0o&"/' 2,* /" &o* 0o&"/'' 3 &3 *

JK I* po6/'" &o* o&3 *,' $0%*3 o$ "p''0, & %&&0' o$*,/&-" *o "3 %* "o

"''!" *o !' po""/' "'&"/' /&*''0* & 0o'0* '"o&/&-B.

,'& */!' 0o!'" *o -/6' ,/" o2& "3"*'! o$ *op/0"5 /* /" "o /!po*&* $o A-/0o *o

"%ppo* /*" -'&' pp/0//*35 *,*5 ,' 0/*/0/8'" A/"*o*'" ppo0, /& Topics $o

2,* ,' "''" " o>'0*/o&' /!/**/o&"

H' 2o*' '/-,* oo" o& *op/0"5 '%/*' & p'"%"/6'5 /' *,' '"*5 %* /* "''!" *,* ,'

0o&$/&' *,'/ !**' 2/*,/& *oo 0o&"*/0*' /!/*" JK L'* /* ' ' *,* ,' / &o*

0o&0'/6' %* 6'3 '"*/0*' /! $o /'0*/0 " ,' "0/' >%"* $o% '&%//'" *o /*

JK /& !3 op/&/o&5 /* /" 6'3 /$$/0%* & '!&/&- *o o*/& *,' $0%*3 o$ %&&*

& p'*/&'&* "p''0, $o! A/"*o*'" "3"*'! o$ *op/0"9.

Co&"'%'&*35 ,/" "/0 /' 2o% ' *o op'& *,' &-' & '&-' *,' /"* o$ ''6&*

/&" " !%0, " po""/' (2,/' *3/&- *o !/&*/& *,' "*%0*%' o$ 0o,''&* "3"*'!)5

&o* 00'p*/&-5 /& *,' $/"* p0'5 *,' */*/o& /6/"/o& '*2''& -'&' & p*/0%

(*,* /" /'0*/0 & ,'*o/0) topoi5 *,o%-, /* /" /& $0* *,' $o!'5 *,' dialectical

topoi5 *,* !' *,' 0o&' o$ ,/" 00o%&* (o3 "' o&


13/27

No* '6'3*,/&- /" 00'p*' " poo$ $o &3*,/&- '"' JK A*,o%-, /* /" /& A/"*o*'

*,* '6'3 *%*, -''" 2/*, 2,* /" *%' & *,* *,'' 0&&o* ' /"0'p&0/'" '*2''&

/"*/&0* *%*,"5 /* /" o&' *,/&- *o -'' 2/*, "o!'*,/&- & &o*,' *o "%ppo* /*"

0'///*341.

T,''$o'5 A-/0o /" &o* o&3 /&- po""/' 6/ (/& *,' "'&"' o$ %"') "0,'!'"

'3o& p'6/o%" !o' $o! "3"*'!" %* "o "'**/&- "o!' /!/*" *o -%!'&**/o&

$o! *,' po/&* o$ 6/'2 o$ ''6&0'. H' /" 0o"/&- *,' oo *o $o! po+'" &

*/0"5 & op'&/&- /* *o 0/0%!"*&*/5 /&0o&0%"/6' & '$'"/' '"o&'&'"". H/"

$/& /"* o$ *op/0" ("'' T' I) /" >%"* o&' po""/' /"* !o&- o*,'" (,' ,/!"'$ !/*"*,' po""///*3 o$ $oo2/&- o*,' %*,o"4@). I* '" "o!' /&*''"*/&- $'*%'"5 *,o%-,5

2,/0, 0& ' '*' *o ,/" '-' /!"

)U&/' o*,' %*,o"5 /* !/*" *op/0" */*/o&3 0o&"/'' " ,'*o/0

(p*/0%5 p'"o& *op/0")5 '&0o%-/&- %&&0' /& "p''0, (copia

rerum). I* /" 0o!p*/6'3 o&- (copiosa) /"*.

)I* /" "o *,' 0%!%*/6' & *,''$o' *,'o'*/03 op'&4/"* 2/*, /& o$

"%p'/!po"' %* &o* 6'3 "*/0* o >%"*/$/' "*%0*%'. M/23" '*2''&

"/!p' '&%!'*/o& (/' A/"*o*'" /&!hetoric 197=14) & "3"*'!

"%ppo"'3 '+,%"*/6' & '+p/0/*3 '%0' $o! %&0, o$ p/&0/p'"

(/' A/"*o*'" /& Topics 15 o *,' $%*%' R!/"* "3"*'!).

0) A"o /& oppo"/*/o& *o *,' 2' &o2& R!/"* "3"*'!5 *,* 2o% !'

0%"' /*" 0'&* o0%"5 /* ''p" *,' */*/o& 0'&* o' o$ '$/&/*/o&

(& '*' 0o&0'p*") " *,' !o"* /&*/&"/0 & '""'&*/ $'*%' o$ &3

41 N'0 *!'& o!&/ po&/" o!&/%" 0o&6'&/%&* JK %&%! %*'! "/* p% A/"*o*''! o!&'6'%! 6'o 0o&"'&*/' &'%' po""/&* p% 6' /"0'p&*/ '""'5 /% *!'& '"* 0o&"'&*/' /p"5 /%$/'! "*%''5 A-/0o (199@ J19K 1@=14). C$.rior Analytics47.4@A-/0o (199@ J19K ;).

4T,' op'&'"" o$ A-/0o" /"* o$ *op/0" /" "o '!p,"/8' 3 P.M0 (19BB @;) T,' *op/0" o &o*po""'"" *,' 0,0*'/"*/0" o$ 0o"' "3"*'!.


14/27

/&%/3. T,* "''!" *o /&/0*' *,* 2,/' o*, 2o% '&0o%-' %&/$/'

ppo0, *o -%!'&**/o&5 $o A-/0o /* 2" '"0/p*/6' & p0*/0

/""%'" *,* 2'' 0'&* o *3p/05 2,''" $o R!%" /* 2o% '

'+p&*/o& & "0/'&*/$/0 00o%&*.


15/27

TA


16/27

Pragmatical asects of Agricola!s Theory of Argumentation

A" 2' ,6' !'&*/o&'5 '0* 2,*'6' *,* sc. 2,* 2' 2&* *o "3 /"44.

T,' !/& po/&*" o$ ,/" p'"'&**/o& 2/ ' *,''$o'

) /'0*/0" !**'5 o '**' /*" "**/&- po/&*5 *,' /"0%"/6' /*'! 2,o"'

'+/"*'&0' /0**'" *,' &'0'""/*3 o$ /'0*/05 *,* /"5 *,' quaestio 2,* 2'

2&* *o /"0%"" o * o%*5

) /'0*/0" /&"*%!'&*5 2,* *,' dialecticadocens*'0,'" ,o2 *o %/ &

*,' dialecticautensp%*" /&*o %"'5 *,* /"5 /"0o%"' /*"'$ (oratio) *,o%-,

2,/0, 2' '+po"' 2,* 2' 2&* *o "3 o%* *,' quaestio5 &

44S**%*%! '"* /-/*% &o/" ,o0 /o %"%! *'' o0o%!5 ,o0 '"*5 %* /'! p'*/o/%" /0!%" 6'/"5'+p/0' %o p0*o p& "/* /""''&/ $0%*" /5 %! /'0*/0'& 6o0&*. I 0o!!o/""/!' $0*%/

6/'!%5 "/ o"*'&'/!%" %' "/* !*'/ '/%"5 %o /&"*%!'&*%!5 %/" '%! *0**%". M*'/! /0o'!5 ' % /""'/!%"5 /&"*%!'&*%! o*/o&'!5 % %o /0*%! '""' ' ' ' 6o%!%" '+p/0!%"5*0**%! %o!oo ,'0 p& "/&* '* %' 0%/%' '/ p*&5 A-/0o (199@ J19K @;)


17/27

0) /'0*/0" pop' *'*!'&* o *'0,&/%'5 *,* /" *,' '+p'* %"' o$ *,'

*op/0" $o *,' '%*' /"0%"/6' po0'""/&-5 2/*, p'"%"/6' /!"5 o$

p*/0% %'"*/o&.

I& o' *o ppo0, *,' /""%' o$ *,' /'0*/0 quaestio5 A-/0o *'" oo *

A/"*o*'" /&/0*/o&" /& Topics (111$$)5 2,'' ,' *" o%* *,' "'" o$

-%!'&*" " /'&*/0 *o *,' "%>'0*" o$ '"o&/&- & /'&*/$/'" o*, 2/*, '/*,'

popo"/*/o&" (rotaseis) Q""'*/o&" (po""/*/6' o &'-*/6')5 "o /&*'p'*' "

3'"=o=&o '&%//'"Q o po'!" (robl"mata)5 2,/0, '+p/0/*3 '+p'"" *2o

*'&*/6'"4.Fo A/"*o*'5 !o'o6'5 /'0*/0 %'"*/o& /" p-!*/03 '"*/0*'

*o 2,* /" "%/*' $o /"0%""/o&5 *,o"' *,/&-" $o 2,/0, /& p/&0/p' 2' 0& 0o&0'/6'

"'6' p%"/' &"2'" $o &o !& o$ "'&"' 2o% p%* /&*o popo"/*/o& *,* 2,/0,

/" &o o&'" op/&/o&5 &o /&*o po'! *,* 2,/0, /" !&/$'"* *o '6'3o&' o *o !o"*

p'op' $o *,' **' /"'" &o %'"*/o&5 2,/' *,' $o!' &o o&' 2o% 00'p* (Topics

14$$). '0*=!**' $o /'0*/0 ppo0,5 "**/&- o&0' -/& *,' /&*'- 0,0*' o$ ,/"

6/'2 o$ *,' /"0/p/&'

4A-/0o (199@ J19K @@)4;N'!o '&/! '! p'*!5 %*'&%" '"* p'*5 "%!/* o0'&!5 "' %* 0o&*'&/ ' ' '* !/-/ po""/*5A-/0o (199@ J19K @).


18/27

S*/5 "/&0' $o! */!' *o */!'5 '6'& *,o"' op/&/o&" $o 2,/0, /* "''!" /$$/0%* *o $/&

&3 pop' "%ppo*5 ' '/'*'3 popo"' $o /"0%""/o&5 2' 2/ *,' 0o&"/'

po' &3*,/&- *,* /" '-' /& 0o'0* !&&' & 0o&0'&" *,' po/&* /&

%'"*/o&47.

A-/0o 2/ *' 0' o$ *,' */*/o& /""%' o$ *,' 0""/$/0*/o& o$ *,' quaestio /&

0,p*'" B=14 o$ '0*=' ('+ /6'"o -'&'' */%!). H/"

0o&0%"/o& T,'' /" &o "/&-' 23 *o 0""/$3 quaestiones4B.

R'-/&- &o2 /'0*/0" /&"*%!'&* Q2,/0, /"5 /& $0*5 >%"* *,' *oo o$

dialectica utens& *,' o>'0* o$ "*%3 & &3"/" o$ dialectica docensQ 2' "''

*,* /* /" /'&*/$/' 2/*, *,' 2,o' /"0o%"' (oratio) & &o* 2/*, *,' popo"/*/o& o *,'

"3o-/"!5 " 2" %"%3 *,' 0"' /& 0%'&* S0,o"*/0 !'*,ooo-349. T,'propositio

/" &o* 0o&"/'' p/6/'-' ''!'&* $o /'0*/0 &3"/" & *,' *'! /" >%"*

!'&*/o&' " L*/& *&"*/o& $o rotasis " oppo"' *orobl"ma5 /& *,' '3

!'&*/o&' /"0%""/o& o%* *,' /'0*/0 %'"*/o&. A" $o *,' "3o-/"! & /*" *3p'"

(A-/0o p'$'"5 /& &3 0"'5 *,' L*/& *'! ratiocinatioop*' 3 C/0'o)5 *,'"' 2/

47S' %o&/! 0o&"%*o &o&&%&%! */ /0'&%! "%!%&*%5 %* /$$/0/' "/* ,%/%"!o/ %/0%!'/" 00o!o/5 /& ,/" /-/*% %&' &o/" '/* po/' %o p*' 0o&"'&*&''%' ' ' popo"/*/0'*%5 A-/0o (199@ J19K @1)4BD/6/%&*% %*'! %'"*/o&'" &o& %&o *&*%! !oo5 A-/0o (199@ J19K @44).49A "/!/ '! o& V" /'0*/0 /" o$$'' 3 N%* (@9 @11) ,* /" /!po*&* /" 2,'*,' &-%!'&* 2o"5 *,* /"5 2,'*,' /* /&%0'" 0o&6/0*/o& /& *,' ,''. Fo! 6//*3 /" o&3 o&' 23 o$oo/&- * -%!'&**/o&5 & *,' &o2 23 * *,*. R'>'0*/&- *,' $o! ppo0, o$ *,'

"0,o"*/0"5 V 2&*" *o "' /'0*/0 o& ' &-%-' 3 "*%3/&- -%!'&*" /& 0o&*'+*5 & 2,*0o%&*" " 0o&*'+* /" !%0, o' *,& *,' "/&-'="'&*'&0' "*%0*%' o$ *,' "0,o"*/0 '+!p'.


19/27


20/27

*,' '+po"/*/o& o$ $0*" &5 o$ 0o%"' o*, 0& pp' /& *,' p'!' o *,' 'p/o-%'.

F%*,'!o'5 *,' "%*' /"*/&0*/o& '*2''& 2,* 2' 0& /'&*/$3 " *,' '+po"/*/o& o$

'"o& & *,' -%!'&**/6' %"' o$ & '+p&*/o& !%"*5 %&6o/35 !' %"' o$ *,'

'$$'0*/6' '*/o& '*2''& *,' "p'' & ,' %/'&0'5 " pp'&*3 o*, !3 '"/3

,6' *,' "!' 0o&*'&* *,' "!' *,/&- J*%!K 0& ' *'&*/6'3 *,' 0%"' o *,'

'+p&*/o& o$ "o!'*,/&-@. I* /"5 *,''$o'5 >%"* *,' 0*% p'"'&0' o$ *,' /&*'&*/o& *o

p'"%' & %/'&0' o$ "o!'*,/&- *,*5 /& p*/0% 0o&*'+*5 0&&o* ' ""%!' "

/'0*3 '6/'&*5 *,* 2/ '*'!/&' *,'' '/&- & -%!'&**/o&. Fo '+!p'5 A-/0o

0/!" *,* *,' $oo2/&- p""-' $o! *,'Aeneid (II5 1=1) /" -%!'&**/6'

A""'&"'' o!&'" '* %' "// %/"%' */!'*5

U&/%" /& !/"'/ '+/*/%! 0o&6'" *%''.

A& ,' >%"*/$/'" ,/" op/&/o& /& *,' $oo2/&- 23. T,' po'* 2&*" *o 0o&6/&0' %" o$ *,' $0*

*,* ,6' "/&0''3 ""'&*' ("o!'*,/&- o%* 2,/0, 2' 0o% ' /& o%*) & ,/"

poo$ 0o&"/"* o$ -/6/&- %" *,' p"30,oo-/0 '"o& $o *,/" "%'& -''!'&*. I* /'*'"

*,'! $o! $'5 0o&0'&**/&- !/"'3 %po& o&' /&/6/% ,* 0o% ' !o'

0o&6/&0/&- o$ *,'/ 0o'0*/6' ""'&* *,& *,' $0* *,* /* 2o% o$$' *,'! "'0%/*3Z 4. T,'

p""-'5 *,o%-,5 '" &o $o! "/-& o$ /&0%/&- & -%!'&**/o& o /&$''&0'. I* /" &

'+!p' o$ 2,* A-/0o 0" & -%!'&**/o& 0"* /&*o & '+po"/*/o&.

I& &3 0"'5 o% %*,o5 */'"5 /& p/&0/p'5 *o /"*/&-%/", '*2''& o*, *3p'" o$

/"0o%"' '+po"/*/6' & -%!'&**/6'. T,' $o!' p'"'&*"5 *,o%-,5 *,'' '-''"5 *,'

"* o$ 2,/0, 0o&6'-'" *o2" -%!'&**/o&. A-/& *,' 0/*'/ $o "%0, /"*/&0*/o&" '

@0%! po"/* / /p"%! '* 0%" '/ '""' '* */o5 A-/0o (199@ J19K 4). o,& D3'&" *&"*/o& o$ *,/" p""-' 6'-'" *o2"5 * '"*5 *,' '+p/0*/6' 3 !'&" o$"%o/&*/&- *,' "'0o& 0%"' A p/"' *,' "'&*'&0'5 p'"' *,' "*o! ",o% $ [ O& o&' o&'52,o"' $%3 *,'*'& . T,'oo' C. //!" 6'"/o&5 0,oo"'"5 /&"*' *o "'p*' 0o!p'*'3 o*,0%"'" 3 "*op No / o&' 6o/0' oppo"'. T,' !o* "*o' [ ,o/3 ,&-/&- o' '0, 0o2,' [ 2" 0,&-' *o o&' !&" %/&5 & *,'/ ,'*" [ '&%' /* 2'.

4%o !-/" '&/! po*%/""'* po' o!&'" ""'&"/""'5 %! %o -%'* "'0%/**' "%Z5 A-/0o(199@ J19K ;).6/'*% &o&&%&%! /& '+po"/*/o&' 6'&/' -%!'&**/o&'5 A-/0o (199@ J19K 4)


21/27

p-!*/0. A "p''5 2/*'5 0& %"' & '+po"/*/o& /& o' ) *o p'"' & %/'&0'5 )

*o &*' "o!' $0*" & 0) *o "'' 0o&6/0*/o& *,o%-, *,' p%"///*3 o$ 2,* /"

p'"'&*'. T,' p/-!*/0 0"'" o$ *,'"' *,'' '-''" 0o'"po& '"p'0*/6'3 *o *,'

/"0o%"' o$ *,' po'*"5 *,' ,/"*o/&" & *,' p,/o"op,'". S%0, /"*/%*/o& 0o% "%--'"*

*o %" (o *o A-/0o" !o' 0o&6'&*/o& 0o&*'!po/'") "o!'*,/&- /' -*/o& /&

*'!" o$ &'0'""/*3 po'* 0& * o%* *,' %&'5 o%* $/0*/o&" 0o&*/&-'&03 2o% '

*,' '! o$ ,/"*o3 & &'0'""/*3 *,* o$ *%' p,/o"op,3.


22/27

I& o% op/&/o&5 *,o%-,5 "%0, "*3/"*/0 0/*'/ !%"* $/&3 ' /&' 2/*, *,' ' 0o&/*/o&"

o$ /"0%"/6' %"'5 & *,' /$$''&* po"/*/o&" & **/*%'" o$ "p'' & %/'&0'

'-/&- *,' p*/0% 0o&*'&*" o$ "p''0,.

A-/0o 2/ $/&3 p'"'&* *,' 0,0*'/"*/0" o$ -%!'&**/6' /"0o%"' pop'

& '$' 6'3 /'$3 *o /*" !o"* */*/o& "0,'!'" (ratiocinatio o "3o-/"!5

enumerationeo /&%0*/o&5 enthymema & e'emplum) '6/&- *,oo%-, *'*!'&* o$

*,'"' *o o-/0" "'0o& p* o >%-'!'&* 2,/0, /" &o* '* 2/*, /& ,/" *'+* B. R'>'0*/&-5

/& &3 0"'5 *,' ""/-&!'&* o$ *,' "o 0' p'$'0* & /!p'$'0* $o!" o$ -%!'&**/o&

*o /$$''&* $/'" & "*&" o$ /-o5 A-/0o "3" p/&3 *,* '&*,3!'!'" ' &o*

o&3 %"' 3 o*o"5 %* "o 3 /'0*/0/&"5 !*,'!*/0/&" & p,3"/0/"*5 2,/' o$

*,'!5 /&0%/&- o*o"5 0& '0/' *o %"' plena ratiocinatio9 00o/&- *o *,'/

p*/0%5 /"0%"/6' & p-!*/0 &''".

So5 $o A-/0o5 *,' * o$ /'0*/05 " -'&' *,'o3 o$ -%!'&**/o&5 /" o&3

o&' & pp/'" *o &3 !**' o$ /"0o%"' & &3 23 o$ %"/&- &-%-'5 ' /*

0o&*/&%o%"5 " /& "p''0,5 o /"0o&*/&%o%"5 " /& /o-%' o /"0%""/o&. I& *,' "!' 235

/'0*/0 2/ ,6' *o ' o*, 2/*, /"0o%"'" *,* *'& *o ' '+p/0/*3 -%!'&**/6' &

2/*, *,o"' *,* "''! *o ' !'' p'"'&**/o&" o '+po"/*/o&". Fo A-/0o *,' /6//&- /&'

/" &'6' '3 &'*. T,''$o' 2' o &o* ,6' *o oo $o "p'0/$/0 "0,'!'"5 " "%0,5 o

"p'0/$/0 $o!%*/o&" /& o' *o $/& o %/ *,' o>'0* o$ /'0*/0 '"'0,5 2,/0, /"

-%!'&**/o&. I* /" !o' o '"" o!&/p'"'&* /& &3 /"0o%"'. I* /" %p *o %" *o &3"' /*5

*o /'&*/$3 & %&'"*& /* ('/*,' " 0o!po"'" o /"*'&'"[''") %"/&- *,' *oo"

BT,'' ,6' ''& !&3 /"0%""/o&" o%* *,' 0 o$ "'0o& *'*/"' 3 A-/0o o& >%-'!'&*.Op/&/o&" &-' $o! P. M0" p%'&* ""%!p*/o& o$ *,' $0* Q*,/" '6'" %&'"o6' *,' %'"*/o&2,'*,' A-/0o /&*'&' *o 2/*' &o*,' *'*/"' o& >%-'!'&*. T,' >%-'!'&* *'*/"' 2o% &o* $/**,' ppo0, o$ *,/" oo. O& *,' o*,' ,&5 /&*''0*% "p0' ," ''& '$* $o /* (199 @1)Q *oO&-" /&*'p'**/o& o$ A-/0o" 0o&0'p*/o& o$ *,' /"0/p/&' " p0'=o-/0.


23/27

po6/' 3 *,' *. A& "o5 /$ *,'' ' !&3 23" *o '+p'"" -%!'&**/o&5 '6'& "

p'*'&/&- *o ' &o -%!'&**/o& * 5 & /'0*/0/&" !%"* ' 2/*, *,'! (2/*,

&3 /&-%/"*/0 !'&" o$ po6//&- '"o&"5 '+p&*/o&"5 !/&- o /&"/&%*/&- /&$''&0'"5

'/*,' '/&- *o $%*,' &o2'-' o *'&*/6' 6/'2po/&*")5 *,'&5 2' ' &o* &3!o'

*/&- o%* $o! /"0/p/&' "' o& *,' /"*/&0*/o& '*2''& $o! & 0o&*'&*5

'*2''& "3&0*'-o'!*/0 & 0*'-o'!*/0 *'!"5 o '*2''& p'$'0* & /!p'$'0*

/&$''&0'" ('/*,' /& *,' "'&"' o$ 0o!p'*' 6". /&0o!p'*' o $o! 6". !*'/).

Conclusion

De inventione dialectica2" *o '0o!' '+*'!'3 /&$%'&*/ /& *,' 1;*,0'&*%3 " P'*'

M0:" "*%/'" o& /*" /$$''&* '/*/o&" po6';. M&3 o$ /*" op*/o&" 2'' *,'& "/03

00'p*' 3 /'0*/0/&" *,* 2''5 !o' o '"" "%00'""$%35 "%ppo*/&- 0%/0%

'$o!" o6' E%op'. Fo! *,' $/"* '0'0*/0 &5 "o 0'5 po"*=-/0o&

/'0*/0/&";1 Qo,&&'" C'"/%" J14B=1K5 C,/"*op,o%" H'-'&o$

J1=14K o F&0/"0%" T/*'!&" J1@=17KQ *o *,' 6'3 /&$%'&*/ P,//pp

M'&0,*,o& J1497=1;K o '& S*%! J17=1B9K 2,o '0*%' /& P/" o%& *,'

1:" & , 3o%&- P'*%" R!%" J11=17@K " p%p/. I& 0o%&*/'" /' E&-&

o Sp/&5 o-/0 *'+*=oo" o3 "' o& A-/0o:" ppo0, '-& *o pp'

*o2" *,' !/' o$ *,' 0'&*%35 /& !&3 0"'"5 ""o0/*' 2/*, *,' "p'/&- %"' o$

*,' 6'&0%. ' 0& !'&*/o& T,o!" /"o&" The !ule o# !eason conteinyng the

Arte o# Logique (11);@5 2,o $oo2" '+0*3 A-/0o:" /"* o$ *op/0"5 o Rp, L'6':"

The Art o# !eason$ rightly termed )itcra#t (17);. T,'/ Sp&/", 6'&0%

0o%&*'p* 2o% ' P'o S/!o& A/:" rimera parte de la #iloso#*a llamada la

;M0 (1995 0p. XIII).

;1O&- (19B5 1@=;).;@Mo'& $0"/!/' '/*/o&5 /"o& (197).;Mo'& $0"/!/' '/*/o&5 L'6' (197@).


24/27

l+gica ((irst art o# hilosophy named Logic) (1B9). A o$ *,'! /6/' o-/0 /&*o

/&6'&*/o& & >%-'!'&*5 '&o%&0' *o *,' M'/'6 *,'o/'" o$ insolu"ilia5

o"ligationes5 osuppositio5 " 0o&"/'' '+*'!'3 "%*'5 */$/0/ & '*0,' $o!

*,' 0o!!o& %"' o$ &-%-' &5 !o"* /&*''"*/&-35 '&o%&0' *o *,' p'6/&-

/"*/&0*/o& '*2''& 0*'-o'!*/0 & "3&0*'-o'!*/0 *'!"5 po/&*/&- *o2"

o-/0 /"0/p/&' &o o&-' "' o& $o!.

I& '"po&"' *o ,/" o2& */!'" %&'"/&'"" 2/*, 0%'&* o-/0 "*%/'"5 A-/0o"

2o op'&' !'*,ooo-/0 '*' o%* *,' '!0*/o& o$ o-/0 & *,' /!/*" &

'$/&/*/o& o$ /'0*/0. H' (" !&3 o*,' H%!&/"*") / &o* -'' 2/*, *,' o%&/'"

"'* o& o-/0 3 S0,o"*/0 %*,o"5 2/*, *,'/ -'& & /&*''"*" & oo' $o !o'

-'&'5 0o!p','&"/6' & p0*/0 *,'o3 o$ -%!'&**/o&. So ,' "o!'2,* '-&

-/&5 &o* '+0*3 $o! "0*0, %* $o! 6'3 "/05 -'&' *,/&-". A& *,* /" 2,35 $o

!&3 ,/"*o/&" o$ o-/05 *,/" 6'3 '*' "''!' /' "*'p 02"5 "/!p/$/0*/o&

op'*' -/&"* 6'3 6&0' /"0/p/&';4.

%"* " /* ,pp'&" *o35 $o! o-/05 " p0*/"' 3 *,' S0,o"*/0"5 2" 6'3

*'0,&/0 $/'5 /& 2,/0, "p'0/$/0 *,'o/'" 2'' '/&- po-'""/6'3 '$/&'. A-/0o

"*'pp' o%* o$ /*5 *o *' oo * /*" 6'3 oo*"5 /*" !o"* "/0 /!"5 p/&0/p'" &

/"*/&0*/o&"5 & ,' "2 "o!' po'!" 2/*,/&5 2,/0, ,' */' *o *0'. A" M0F&'

(@) po/&*" o%*5 *,' '!0*/o& o$ o-/0 Q*,' 6'3 "'&"' o$ *,' 0o&0'p* $o!Q

/" po'! *,* ," ''& 'p'*'3 '*' *,o%-,o%* ,/"*o3 $o! *,' 6'3

'-/&&/&-" o$ *,' /"0/p/&'. I& '0/"/6' !o!'&*"5 !o!'&*" o$ po-'""/6' -'&

2/*,/& $o! o-/05 *,'' ," ''& /& o$ /%"/o& *,* "%0, '!0*/o& 2" "'**'.


25/27


26/27

= (1999) I&*o%0/&- A/"*o*' *o *,' "/+*''&*, 0'&*%3 *,' L'$6' '&*'p/"' /&hilosophy in the &i'teenth and &eventeenth Centuries. Conversations Bith Aristotle5'. C. -* ('".)

Roop,%" A-/0o P,/"/%" (1444=14B).roceedings o# the International Con#erenceat the =niversity o# %roningen. >:9?@ Oct. 7:;(pp. @7=@;9). L'/'& E. . -* ('".) !odolphus Agricola hrisius 67888978:;:9?@ Oct.7:;(pp. @19=@@B). L'/'& E. .


27/27

/"o&5 T,. (197) The !ule o# !eason 67;;7

RUDOLPH AGRICOLA’S DE INVENTIONE DIALECTICA (1479) AS AN INTEGRAL AND PRAGMATICAL THEORY OF...

Documents

Transcript of RUDOLPH AGRICOLA’S DE INVENTIONE DIALECTICA (1479) AS AN INTEGRAL AND PRAGMATICAL THEORY OF...