Risks and Best Practices Associated with Syngas in Drum Dryers · Risks and Best Practices...
Transcript of Risks and Best Practices Associated with Syngas in Drum Dryers · Risks and Best Practices...
Risks and Best Practices Associated with Syngas in Drum Dryers
Prepared by Aon Risk Solutions / Cariboo Biomass Consulting ServicesGlen Visser, P.Eng, Aon Risk Control Services / Kevin Ericsson, PE, Chief Engineer, UNBCPresentation to Wood Pellet Safety Conference and Workshop – Safety in Action
Aon Risk Solutions (Mandatory) | Department/Practice (Optional)Proprietary and Confidential (Optional) | Date (Optional) 2
Biographies
Glen Visser, P.Eng., ARM, Sr Risk Control ConsultantAon Risk Solutions, VancouverConsiderable design and consulting experience in Pulp and Paper, Biomass Systems, Mechanical Systems, Fire Suppression, and Risk Management.
Aon Risk Solutions 3
Syngas
Aon Risk Solutions 4
Definitions
“A definition is the enclosing a wilderness of idea within a wall of words.” Samuel Butler, 19th Century English author and poet.
§ Syngas (EnggCyclopedia) - Syngas is a mixture of Carbon Monoxide and Hydrogen which is the product of steam or oxygen gasification of organic material such as biomass. After clean up, syngas can be used to produce organic molecules such as synthetic natural gas (SNG-methane (CH4)) or liquid biofuel such as synthetic diesel. Syngas is the term generally used for mixture of combustible gases. So typically a syngas mixture will constitute of only hydrogen and carbon monoxide, with possibility of having carbon dioxide content sometimes. If the gasification product contains significant amount of non-combustible gases such as nitrogen and carbon dioxide, the term used for such mixtures is 'Producer Gas'.
– * note: The heating value of syngas varies from 11 to 18 MJ/m3 depending upon its constituents.
§ Producer Gas (EnggCyclopedia) - Producer gas is a mixture of combustible (Hydrogen, Methane and Carbon Monoxide) and non-combustible (Nitrogen, Carbon dioxide) gases. The heating value of producer gas varies from 4.5 to 6 MJ/m3 depending upon its constituents. Similar to syngas, producer gas is also produced by gasification of carbonaceous material such as coal or biomass. When atmospheric air is used as gasification agent, the producer gas consist mostly of carbon monoxide, hydrogen ,nitrogen, carbon dioxide and methane.
** note: heating value of natural gas varies from 35 to 43 MJ/m3
Aon Risk Solutions 5
Definitions
§ Biomass Gasification (GSTC – Gasification and Syngas Technology Council) - The conversion of biomass or biosolids (sewage) into a gas that can be used to produce electricity and products. Biomass gasification differs in several aspects from traditional gasification. The plants are generally smaller in scale, use air instead of oxygen (or use plasma gasification) and require that the biomass be dried before being gasified.
§ Pyrolysis (Wikipedia) - Pyrolysis is a thermochemical decomposition of organic material at elevated temperatures in the absence of oxygen (or any halogen). It involves the simultaneous change of chemical composition and physical phase, and is irreversible. The word is coined from the Greek-derived elements pyro "fire" and lysis "separating". Pyrolysis is a type of thermolysis, and is most commonly observed in organic materials exposed to high temperatures. It is one of the processes involved in charring wood, starting at 200–300 �C (390–570 �F)….
Aon Risk Solutions 6
General Hazards
Off-Gassing (Low temperature)§ Any mass of wood accumulation
– Chip piles, Silo storage, Transport– In process – conveyors, dryers, metering and surge bins
§ Enhanced risks:– Species– Particle size– Biological processes / Microbial decay– Residence time– Heat, moisture– Containment
§ Hazards– Environmental – VOC release– Oxygen depletion– Toxicity– Fire / explosion– Buildup of tars
Aon Risk Solutions 7
General Hazards
Gasification (High Temperatures)§ Pyrolysis / Combustion
– Produces …§ Enhanced risks:
– Heat, moisture content– Presence of air / oxygen– Fuel concentration (LEL/UEL)
§ Hazards– Environmental– Oxygen depletion– Toxicity– Fire / explosion– Hot exhaust gases
Aon Risk Solutions 8
General Hazards
Wood Dust§ As produced
– Hammer mill– Saws
§ Wood breakdown– Long resident times in dry conditions
§ Hazards– Fire / Explosion (secondary & primary)– Layering causes over heating of electrical
equipment– Plugging of equipment / expansion when
moisture added
Aon Risk Solutions 9
General Hazards
Ignition Sources§ Sparking
– Metals / stones / debris carried through ducting– Mechanical failures
§ Static Discharge– Ungrounded/unbonded equipment / ducting
§ Mechanical Equipment– Hot operating surfaces
§ Electrical Equipment– Over heating
§ Smoking– By employees, contractors, truck drivers
§ Smouldering / Fire flareups– Chip / hog / sawdust piles– Carried forward into process
§ Direct Firing – burners– Open flames or hot gases
HowisSyngasrelatedtothePelletindustry?Whyimportanttoday?
• NotjustPelletindustry– anyprocesswhereheatisappliedtowood.Plywooddryers,OSB&MDFdryers,evenindustrialwoodfurnaces.
• HistoryofA.S.M.E.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Equipmentmaintenance
WoodPelletPlantProcess
GasBurner
• Safetyinterlockscanbebypassed.EG:Flamedetectorunreliable.
• Gasburnerassemblynotinspectedregularlybyregulators.
• Combustionairsupplydamperscanovertimebecomeoutofcalibration.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
WoodFiredEnergySystem
• Combustionairsupplyportscanbecomecloggedduetoslag/klinker buildup
• Causesthecombustortoburninefficiently• Sendsmorethannormalsparkstobecarriedoverintothedryingsystem
• Causesissueswiththedryingsysteminthatmorethannormalsparkscanbedetectedbythedryersparkdetectionsystemcausingextrawatertobesprayedintothedryeroutlet.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
WoodFiredEnergySystem(continued…)
• Extrawaterresultsin…• Woodfiberthatisoutofspecortoomoist,whichinturncancausethedryeroperatortoaddmoreheattothedryerinanattempttodryoutthefiberandgetthemoisturebackwithinspec.
• Woodfiberthatwilllaydowninsidethedryerdischargepiping,causingadominoeffectandincreasedbuilduptothepointthatthedryerhotgasflowbecomesrestrictedcausingfibertostayinthedryerdrumtoolongwhichwillcauseadryerfire.
• Toomuchwateraccumulatinginthedryerdrumfromthedryersystemdelugewillcausethedryerdrumdrivetotriponoverload.Thiscancausethedryerdrumtowarpduetometalfatiguefromoverheating.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Dryerinfeed airlock
• Airlockcanjamsuddenlyfromtoomuchfeedorabigpieceofwoodormetal.Thiscanbeanissueifthedryeroperatordoesn’tgettheheatsupplytothedryershutoffimmediately.ItcouldleadtoadryerfireinthedryerdrumorinthecycloneandductingbetweenthecycloneanddryerIDfan.
• Airlockwipescanbecomeworntothepointwhereexcessiveamountsof“Trampair”cangetintothedryerprocessgasstream,causingahigherthannormaloxygenconcentration.Thiswillpromotesparklifeandfiresaswellascausemoreheatthannormaltoberequiredtomeetdryeroutputandfibermoistures.
• In-consistentwoodmix(Reallygreentosuddenlyreallydry)cancausedryerfires.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Dryerhotgasinlet
• Inletdelugeandorloadspraynozzlescanbecomedisconnected(Expansion/contraction)orwornoutwhichmakesatomizationofwatersprayin-effective.
• Thesolenoidvalvethatturnsthewaterontothedelugeorloadspraynozzlescanleakby– causinganartificialloadonthedryerresultinginin-consistentfibre moistures,whichinturncanresultinthedryeroperatorincreasingtheheatsupplytothedryer,whichcancauseexcesssparkingonthedryeroutlet,whichcouldpotentiallycauseafire.(Tattletale)
• Thewatersupplytothedryerinletdelugeorloadspraycanbecomefrozeninoutdoorapplicationsmakingfireprotectionnon-existent.
• Thedryerdruminletsealcanwearovertimeandstarttoleak.Thiscausesexcessairortrampairtobedrawnintothedryerdrumandhotgasstream.Anelevatedoxygenconcentrationinthesespaceswillonlypromotecombustionandinefficientdryeroperation.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
DryerDrum
• Overtime,dryerflightscanbecomedetachedcreatingacatchpointforfibreandcausesparksand/ordryerfires.
• Ifadryerdrumdriveisofavariablefrequencydrivetype,sometimesafterpoweroutagesthemotordrivesettingscandefaultbacktooriginalcausingthedrumspeedtobeincorrect.Thiscanleadtoexcessivesparkingontheoutletofthedryer.
• Toomuchwateraccumulatinginthedryerdrumfromthedryersystemdelugewillcausethedryerdrumdrivetotriponoverload.Thiscancausethedryerdrumtowarpduetometalfatiguefromoverheating.(Weightinthebottom,heatinthetop)
• Weldingrepairsinthesevesselscanbetrickyduetoconfinedspacerequirementsandlimitedaccessespeciallyontriplepassrotarydryers.Also,ifthereismorethanonedryerinseriesconnectedtothesameheatsource,adequatedoubleblock&bleedmansafeisolationdampersmustbeinplacebeforeaninternalrepaircantakeplaceonanysingledryer.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Dryeroutletductingandelbow
• Theoutletdelugenozzlepipinginsidethedryerductingcanwearfromabrasivewoodfiberwearingthroughthemetalovertime.Thiscancausethepipingtobecomecloggedwithfiberleavingthedelugelineun-useable.
• Typicallytheoutletelbowor“flat-back”iswherefiberwilllaydownfirstinupsetconditionsandoftenwoodfiberwillcatchfireinthislocationfromitsittingthere.
• Anoutletelbowwillusuallyhaveacleanoutaccesshatch.Thishatchistheonethatisopenedmostfrequentlytocleanoutfiberortoinspectforconfirmationofbuilduporafire.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Dryeroutletductingandoverheadducting
• Greconfiberopticsense&extinguish- sense,deluge&abortsensingeyescanbecomedirtyorcoveredoverwithpitchand/ortarmakingthesensingeyeunreliable.Thiscanleadtosparksgettingintothedryercyclone&outletconveyorsand/ordrybins.
• Thewatersupplytothesense&extinguishnozzlescanbecomediminishedifthestrainersonthewatersupplylinesbecomecloggedorifthesolenoidvalvesbecomedysfunctional.TheGreconspraynozzlesalsobecomewornovertimecausingthemtonotfunction(Spray)properlytothepointwherefibre cangetintoanozzleandclogitentirely.
• Dryeroutletthermocouplescanbecomewornfromfibre wearingonthem&fail– causingtheoutletdelugetogooffun-necessarily.Thiswillcausethedryertobeshutdownaswellasfibertoaccumulateintheoutletelbowandoverheadducting,whichwillrequiremanualcleanout.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Dryeroutletductingandoverheadducting(cont…)
• Anywoodfiberlayingdownintheoverheadductingcaneventuallybecarriedoverintothecycloneinlargeclumpsandcausethecycloneoutfeedairlocktoclog&triporcausematerialtobridgeabovetheoutfeedairlockwhichinturnwillcauseacycloneplug.Ifnotdetected– fibercanthenbecarriedoverintothedryerIDfanandeventuallyendupinpollutionabatementequipmentsuchasElectrostaticFilterBeds(EFB’s)orWetElectrostaticPrecipitators(WESP’s).Thisinitselfcancausefiresandawholelistofotherproblems.
• Inmostapplications– theoverheadductinghasaccesshatchesforcleaningoutbuiltupfibre thathasaccumulatedfromexcessiveGrecon“Sense&Extinguish”events.Theseaccesshatchesareusedtogetinandcleanoutthefiber,ofteninaveryhotenvironmentaswellasaveryriskyconfinedspaceenvironment.
• Theoverheadductingsometimeswillhave“ExplosionHatches”.HatchesthataredesignedtoreleaseenergyinaStratificationevent.Althoughtheseeventscanattimesbeminor,theseexplosionhatchessometimesaredamagedfromaneventorarenotcompletelysealedupafterwardscausing“Trampair”togetintothedryerprocessgases.Thiscausestheoxygenconcentrationtobeabovenormal,creatinganenvironmentthatwillpromotesparklifeandfires.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
DryerCyclone
• Woodfiberfineswillaccumulateontothecycloneinnertube.Ifsparksgetthroughtothecyclone,oftenthesparkswillcatchinthefinesandcreateasmouldering event.Thisareacansmolderforhoursduetotheloweroxygenconcentrationintheprocessgasstream.
• Attimes,thedryerwillhavetobeshutdownandanemployeesentuptothetopofthecycloneinanextremelyhotenvironment(Ifthecycloneisinsideabuilding)toopentheinspectionhatchesontopofthecyclonetoextinguishthesmolderingfineswithafirehose.Thisareaisoftenonlyaccessiblebymanliftorshipladders.Ifanemployeewentdownformedicalreasonsontopofacyclone– arescuewouldbeverydifficult.
• Cycloneairlockrubberwiperscanbecomewornovertimeandcontributeto“Trampair”.Wornairlockwipeswillalsocontributetofinescarryover&buildupintodownstreamducting,fans,dampersandpollutionabatementequipmentandbecomepotentialfuelforafire.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
DryerCyclone(cont…)
• Eachcyclonetypicallyhasanexplosionpanelonthetopengineeredtopreventthecycloneitselffromcomingapart.Sometimestheseexplosionpanelscanbeblowncompletelyoffandbecomeaprojectile.Sometimestheseexplosionpanelswillstartleakingfromsmallstratificationeventsandwillberepairedin-house.Theleakingpanelswillcontributeto“Trampair”.
• · Overtime,thecyclonebottomsectionitselfcanbecomewornfromwearandholeswillbecomeevidentandindicatedbyfibre leaks.Theseleaksareoftenpatchedfromtheoutside.Asthecyclonewearsmore&moreiteventuallyhastobere-linedontheinsideorreplacedaltogether.Theproblemcanbethatthestructuralintegrityofthecyclonecanbecomecompromisedifthewearislefttoolong.
• · Ifthecycloneisinanoutdoorenvironment,thereisriskofthedelugelinesbecomingfrozenifthewatersupplylinesarenotheattracedand/orinsulated.Everyfallandatregularintervalsthroughoutthewintermonths,theheattraceshouldbeverifiedtobeworkingandallinsulationisintact.Frozenwatersupplylines=nofireprotection.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Dryercyclonedischargeducting• Finesandtarcanaccumulateinthisductingposingathreatascombustiblematerial.Ifthisductingisnotinsulated,itwillinsulateitselffromtheinsidewithaneventhickerbuildupoffines.
• Potentialsourceofwherefireswillstartandcansmoulder forhoursbeforeittakesoff.
• SomecompanieshaveaddedaGreconsensorinthisductalongwithamanualdelugeforaddedsafety.Thekeythinghereisthatifsparksaredetected,thatanoperatormanuallydelugethisductwithsmallamountsofwater,otherwisetoomuchwaterwilloverloadtheIDfanandcauseittotrip.TheIDfantrippingwillpotentiallycausethefiretoreallytakeoff.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Creosotebuildupinachimney
Conditionsthatcausecreosotebuildup
• Non-insulatedducts.• Highpercentageoffinesintheprocess.• Cycloneairlockwipesnotmaintained.(Airleakingby)• Typeofspeciesbeingprocessed.(Pine,Aspen,Birch,Fir)
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
DryerIDFan
• Finesandtarcanaccumulateonthefaninletdamperscausingthemtojamand/orfail.Today,mostplantshaveanIDfanthatisonavariablefrequencydrivewhichwilleliminatetheneedfordampers.
• Finesandtarcanaccumulateonthefanblades.Overtime,thiswillcausethefantomovelessandlessairthroughtheentiredryingprocessandcaneventuallycausefibertolaydownintheducting,eventuallycausingplugs&fires.Thiswillalsocausethefireprotectionsystem(Sense&extinguish)tobeoutoftime– inthesensethatiftheairintheductingismovingslower,whenasparkissensedtheextinguishingnozzlewillspraytoosoonpotentiallymissingthesparkaltogether.Thebuilduponthefanbladescanalsocausethefanimpellertobecomeoutofbalanceandiflefttoolongwillcausefanbearingstofail.Regularcleaningisamust.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
DryerAbortDamper
• ThisabortdampertypicallyisinstalledasameansofisolatingthedryingprocessfrompollutionabatementequipmentsuchasaWetElectrostaticPrecipitator(WESP)oranElectrifiedFiltrationBed(EFB).
• Ifadryercyclonebridgesundetectedatthebottomandwoodfiberisnolongerallowedtodischarge,itwilleventuallyfillthecyclone(Ifapluggedcyclonedetectorisfaulty– whichiscommon,theabortgatewillnotautomaticallybypassandwillcarrythefiberoverintothepollutionabatementequipment).Thiscanalsocausemajorproblemsinthepollutionabatementequipmentincludingfires.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
PollutionAbatementEquipment
• Iftheinternaltemperatureofthisequipmentisallowedtooperatebelowthedewpointtemperatureoftheprocessgasses– (typically~200’For93.3’C)thetarsandresinswillbuildupinsideonthehighvoltageplatesorgravel.This,overtimewillcausetheequipmenttooperatelessefficientlyandabuildupoftars,resins,andwoodfiberfineswillaccumulatecreatingasourceoffuelforafireandorexplosion.
• Thisequipmentrequiresfrequentinspectionandcleaning– whichrequiresrigidlockoutandconfinedspaceprocedures,especiallywhentheriskofafirestartinginthisequipmentisatitshighestwhenstartinguporshuttingdownadryerordryers.Anin-attentiveoperatorcouldallowthetemperaturesinsidethisequipmenttogettoohotwithnomoistureintheprocessgassestodissipatetheoxygen(>250’for121’C)andcausespontaneouscombustion.Oftenthisequipmentcanbesmouldering whenitisbeinginspected,repairedorcleaned.
• Oftenthisequipmenthasinadequatefiresuppressiontodealwithfiresadequatelyespeciallyinrelationtodealingwithhighvoltage.
• Oftenthevendorsdonotprovideadequatetrainingforoperatingandmaintainingthisequipment.Thisislearnedbytrialanderror.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
PollutionAbatementEquipment(cont…)
• Astheequipmentagesandexperienceswearand/orfiresitbecomessusceptibletoholesandallowstrampairtoinfiltrateintotheunits.Thiscanprovideoxygentopotentialfires.Itwillalsopromotelowerinternaltemperatureswhichinturnwillforceoperationstooperatetheirunitsatbelowdewpointtemperature– whichinturnwillcausefurtherproblemsasmentionedabove.
• Tarsandresinsmixedwithcombustiongasesbecomeacidic,whichovertimewillcorrodethemetalsurfacesofpollutionabatementequipmentunlessstainlesssteelisusedinmanufacturing.
• INEFB’s,oftengravelbedswillform“pockets”ofgravelthatstopmovingfromsticktarbuildup.Thisinturnwillforcethehighvoltagecagesto“shift”andcausetheceramicinsulatorstobreak.Thiswilldisablethehighvoltagefortheeffectedbedcausingtheefficiencyoftheunittobecomeverypoor.Thiswillcauseeventualbuildupofwoodfiberinsidetheunit,becomingfuelforanypotentialfire.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
PollutionAbatementEquipmentDischarge
• Becauseoftheductingsometimesnotbeinginsulated,tarandresinsbuildupmorethanusualontheinsideofthedischargeductingprovidingfuelforpotentialfires.Thistarandresinbecomecorrosiveandovertimewillrotoutdischargestacksmakingthemunstableandunsafe.
• Often,firesuppressioninthisdischargeductingisinadequate.
• TheBoosterfansordischargefansneedtobecleanedoftenforreasonsmentionedearlier.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
SafetyInterlocks(Wooddryingequip.)Discussion
• Lowoxygen(Warningthenshutdown)• Hightemperature.(Warningthenshutdown)• Lowairflow.(Differentialpressureacrosscycloneorfan)
• Mandatorycalculated&programmedvesselpurge(Pre-start,post–stop)afterO2isabove10%
• Mandatory2nd operatorduringstart-up&Shut-down.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
OperatorTrainingDiscussion
• Documentedtrainingprocessrequiredthatiseffective.(Testing&demonstratedabilities)
• WatchdogSoftwarerequired(ProcessNet)• ConsequencesforCulpablebehaviorrequired.(Supervisorsincluded)
• ConsequencesforCulpablebehaviourontheTradesside.(Supervisorsincluded)
• Documented&managedprocessforPLC,Ladderlogicquickfixes/changes.
• ConsequencesforCulpablebehaviourontheTradessideforbypassingequipmentsafetyinterlocks.(Supervisorsincluded)
• Overallexperiences.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
FireProtectionMaintenance
Grecon&Firefly• https://youtu.be/OovrSFud2A8 Grecon
• https://youtu.be/BigFGxZewjw Grecon
• https://youtu.be/J7nRCnP1-88 Firefly
Fiberopticandheatsensors Nozzles
DryermaintenanceDiscussionØFancleaning.
ØDampercleaning.ØThermocouplecalibrations.(overdryingofmaterial)
ØMoisturemetercalibrations.(overdryingofmaterial)
ØDamperactuatorcalibration/linkagecheck.ØAirlockwipechangeout.(Finescarryover)ØDryerdruminternals/flightinspection.ØDryerdrumspeedcalibration.ØDryersubstitutionloadanddelugenozzlecheck.ØNewequipmentcommissioning.Ø Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Standards• NFPA67- GuidelineonExplosionProtectionforGaseousMixturesinPipeSystems.
• NFPA68- StandardonExplosionProtectionbyDeflagrationVenting.
• NFPA69– StandardonExplosionPreventionSystems.(Coversthedesign,construction,operation,maintenanceandtestingofsystemsforthepreventionofdeflagrationexplosionsbymeansofthefollowingmethods:(a)controlofoxidantconcentration;(b)controlofcombustibleconcentration;(c)explosionsuppression;(d)deflagrationpressurecontainment;(e)sparkextinguishingsystems)
• Groundwatertestingformethane.• Qualificationsforoperatorswithemphasisonresponsibility&accountability.(SimilartoaPowerEngineerorMechanicalEngineer)
• Insurancecompanies.
• Copyright- CaribooBiomassConsultingServices
Questions/Thank youImportant: This report contains proprietary and original material which, if released, could be harmful to the competitive position of Aon Reed Stenhouse Inc. Accordingly, this document may not be copied or released to third parties without Aon’s consent.