Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside...
Transcript of Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside...
![Page 1: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay
Angela Kluge
SIL International
APLL 10
Guildford
4-5 May 2018
![Page 2: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay
2
Pseudo question
(1) a, sembu apa?
ah be.healed what
[Nephew: ‘(I already) recovered’] Aunt: ‘ah, (from) what
(have you) recovered?’
Stimulus question
(2) jadi akirnya apa yang terjadi?, de biking malam
so finally what REL happen 3SG make night
[About an ancestor:] ‘so finally what happened?, he created
the night!’
![Page 3: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Outline
Introduction
Syntactic and phonological features
Pragmatic uses
Pseudo questions
Stimulus questions
Quantitative analysis
Summary
3
Introduction
![Page 4: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Papuan Malay [pmy]
LWC in coastal West Papua
1,100,000 or 1,200,000 speakers (Kluge 2017: 37)
Recorded corpus
16-hour of spontaneous
conversations and narratives
231 identified rhetorical
questions
4
Introduction
![Page 5: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Introduction
Rhetorical questions (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315)
Question format
No request for information
Basic types of rhetorical questions (Hackstein 2004)
Pseudo questions
Stimulus questions
5
![Page 6: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Introduction
Pseudo questions with social functions (Bussmann 1996: 1009; Frank
1990: 737; Hackstein 2004)
Provide indirect way to imply more than is said
Declare an expectation or point of view
Strengthen or soften a statement
Answer is obvious and implicit
Example
“Are you crazy?”
Emotive meanings (Schmidt-Radefeldt 1977: 389; Beekman and Callow 1974; Larson 1998)
Express the speakers’ propositional attitude
Dismay, emphasis, indignation, perplexity, protest,
reproach, wonder, etc.
6
![Page 7: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Introduction
Stimulus questions with discourse-marking functions(Hackstein 2004)
Raise an issue for discussion
Signal clarification, conclusion, or explanation
Announce new topic or new aspect of same topic
Answer is provided by the speaker
Example (Larson 1998: 260)
“Why is there so much unemployment these days?”
7
![Page 8: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Introduction
Interpretation of rhetorical questions (Frank 1990)
Difficult to define
Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head
Impossible to know with certainty their intent
Analysts’ subjective judgments
Speakers’ true intent
Speakers’ underlying emotions
As non-participant observers, analysts make best guesses
regarding intent and effect
8
![Page 9: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Introduction
Present study
16-hour corpus of spontaneous conversations and narratives
Analysis based on analyst’ subjective judgments
Experience as participant observer in Papuan household
231 rhetorical questions identified and analyzed
Outsider’s perspective
Not perspective of Papuan speakers of Papuan Malay
9
![Page 10: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Syntactic and phonological features
Rhetorical questions versus content questions
No formal, linguistic signals
Same syntax
Same intonation patterns
10
![Page 11: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Pragmatic uses
Pseudo questions with social functions
Stimulus questions with discourse-marking functions
11
![Page 12: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Social functions
Negative and positive assertions
Negative evaluations
Statements of incertitude
12
![Page 13: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Realization
Polar questions
“Didn’t you listen to …? (≈ “You didn’t listen to …!”)
Content questions
Polarity
“Who told you to …”? (≈ “Nobody told you to …!”)
Neutral polarity
“Why did you come”? (≈ “You shouldn’t have come!”)
13
![Page 14: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Assertions
Functions
Express speaker’s certitude
Challenge interlocutors
Rebuke interlocutors
Tease interlocutors good-naturedly
Make thoughtful statements
Realization
Polar questions
Content questions
14
![Page 15: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Assertions
Functions
Express speaker’s certitude
Challenge interlocutors
Rebuke interlocutors
Tease interlocutors good-naturedly
Make thoughtful statements
Realization
Polar questions
Content questions
15
![Page 16: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Assertions
(3) Challenge
a, sembu apa?
ah be.healed what
[Nephew: ‘(I already) recovered’] Aunt: ‘ah, (from) what
(have you) recovered?’
16
![Page 17: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Assertions
(4) Good-natured banter
ko su bosang bicara deng bapa ka?
2SG already be.bored speak with father or
[Phone conversation between a father and his daughter:] ‘do
you already feel bored talking with me (‘father’)?’
17
![Page 18: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Evaluations
Functions
Express opinions as to whether an action, utterance, or
attitude is good or bad, right or wrong
Express disapproval
Realization
Content questions
18
![Page 19: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Negative evaluations
Content questions
(5) Disapproval
kamu ana skola itu makang pinang untuk apa?
2PL child school D.DIST eat betel.nut for what
‘what for are you school kids (EMPH) chewing betel nuts?’
19
![Page 20: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Statements of incertitude
Functions
Express incertitude in various forms
Doubt and uncertainty
Perplexity
Deliberation
Realization
Content questions
Polar questions
20
![Page 21: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Statements of incertitude
Functions
Express incertitude in various forms
Doubt and uncertainty
Convey perplexity
Communicate deliberation
Realization
Content questions
Polar questions
21
![Page 22: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as pseudo questions
Statements of incertitude
Content question
(6) Expressions of doubt and uncertainty
a, bulang depang nanti bagemana?
ah month front very.soon how
adooo, bagemana ini?
oh.no! how D.PROX
[Insufficient financial support:] ‘ah, how (are things going to
be) next month?, oh no! how (EMPH)?’
22
![Page 23: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as stimulus questions
Discourse-marking functions
Cross-linguistically
Signal clarification, conclusion, or explanation
Announce new topic or new aspect of same topic
Papuan Malay
Announce new aspect of same topic
23
![Page 24: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Pragmatic uses as stimulus questions
Announce new aspect of same topic
(7) siapa yang bawa dorang dari sana?, saya dengang Domi
who REL bring 3PL from L.DIST 1SG with Domi
[Preparations for a youth retreat:] ‘who’s going to (pick them
up and) bring them from over there?, I and Domi!’
24
![Page 25: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Quantitative analysis
Identified rhetorical questions 231 tokens
Pseudo questions 197 tokens (85%)
Stimulus questions 34 tokens (15%)
25
![Page 26: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Quantitative analysis of pseudo questions
Pseudo questions types across functions
26
Functions
Question types Assert Eval
(neg)
Incert Total
Polar 43 6 49
Content (polarity) 71 71
Content (proper) 41 36 77
Total 114 41 42 197
![Page 27: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Quantitative analysis of pseudo questions
Pseudo questions types across functions
27
Functions
Question types Assert Eval
(neg)
Incert Total
Polar 43 6 49
Content (polarity) 71 71
Content (proper) 41 36 77
Total 114 41 42 197
![Page 28: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Quantitative analysis of pseudo questions
Pseudo questions across functions and underlying emotions
28
Underlying emotions
Functions Neg Pos Neut Total
Assertion 96 6 12 114
Evaluation (neg) 41 41
Incertitude 28 4 10 42
Total 165 10 22 197
![Page 29: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Quantitative analysis of stimulus questions
Overview
Frequency
34/231 (15%)
Function
Introduce new aspect of same topic
Question type
Content question
29
![Page 30: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Summary
Formal characteristics
No formal, linguistic signals
Context determines interpretation as rhetorical question
Functions
1. Pseudo questions with social functions
2. Stimulus questions with discourse-marking functions
30
![Page 31: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Summary
Pseudo questions
Functions
1. Assertions
2. Expressions of incertitude
3. Negative evaluations
Underlying emotions
1. Negative
2. Neutral
3. Positive
31
![Page 32: Rhetorical questions in Papuan Malay · (Abrams and Harpham 2009: 315) ... Impossible to get inside the speakers’ head Impossible to know with certainty their intent Analysts’](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040400/5e6fe70db5d8e42ea06ff494/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
References
Abrams, Meyer H. & Harpham, Geoffrey G. 2009. A glossary of literary terms, 9th edn. Boston:
Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
Bussmann, Hadumod. 1996. Routledge dictionary of language and linguistics. London: Routledge.
Beekman, John & Callow, John. 1974. Translating the word of God, with scripture and topical indexes. Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House.
Frank, Jane. 1990. You call that a rhetorical question?: Forms and functions of rhetorical
questions in conversation. Journal of Pragmatics 14(5): 723–738.
Hackstein, Olaf. 2004. Rhetorical questions and the grammaticalization of interrogative pronouns
as conjunctions in Indo-European. In Rasmussen, Jens Elmegård & Hyllested, Adam (eds.), Per aspera ad asteriscos: Studia Indogermanica in honorem Jens Elmegard Rasmussen sexagenarii Idibus Martiis anno MMIV (Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Sprachwissenschaft 112). Innsbruck: Institut
fur Sprachen und Literaturen der Universitat Innsbruck, 167–186.
Kluge, Angela. 2017. A grammar of Papuan Malay (Studies in Diversity Linguistics 11). Berlin:
Language Science Press. Online URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.17169/langsci.b78.35; http://langsci-
press.org/catalog/book/78.
Larson, Mildred L. 1998. Meaning-based translation: A guide to cross-language equivalence, 2nd
edn. Lanham: University Press of America.
Schmidt-Radefeldt, Jürgen. 1977. On so-called ‘rhetorical’ questions. Journal of Pragmatics 1:
375–392.