Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free...

24
Revised Destination in Parking Management Kyle Karwowski Ryan Cook Valerie Smith Gwen Webster Alex Flood Shakeel Balroop George Doo April 21 2008

Transcript of Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free...

Page 1: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Kyle Karwowski

Ryan Cook

Valerie Smith

Gwen Webster

Alex Flood

Shakeel Balroop

George Doo

April 21 2008

Page 2: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Project Introduction

Purpose

Examine parking in downtown East Lansing

Analyze free parking

– Effect to Business

– How and When

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 3: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Project Clients

City of East Lansing, Michigan– Daniel O’Connor, Parking Department

– Timothy H. Dempsey, Department of Planning &

Community Development

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 4: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Presentation Overview

Current Situation

and System

Practices in Parking

Management

Recommendation

on Free

Implementation

Phases

Problems

Findings

Solutions

Improvement

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 5: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Current Situation and System

Page 6: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Who parks downtown

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 7: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

How users think of downtown parking

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 8: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Source: City of East Lansing

West area Core area East area

N

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 9: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Utilization throughout day

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 10: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Fees and enforcement

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 11: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Signage and Way-finding

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 12: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Practices in Parking Management

Page 13: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Provides attractive system for shopping

Free period varies by cities

Free parking findings

Incentivize parking in certain locations

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 14: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Innovations– Cash key

– Pay by cell

– Vehicle detection technology

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 15: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Innovations– Signage and Way-finding

– Marketing and branding

– Customer service

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 16: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Recommendation on Free

Page 17: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

“Free” parking, free?

Free parking needs proper implementation

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 18: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

“Free” parking is viable for East Lansing

Considerations of free parking

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 19: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Implementation Phases

Page 20: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Phase one: Groundwork

Improve user awareness

Increase parking turn over

New parking payment options

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 21: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

21

Phase two: Implement free parkingMinimize direct user expense

Free parking in ramps after 4 p.m.

Cost for free parking $288,000 Annually

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 22: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

22

Two funding mechanisms

Special Assessment, Indirect

Requires $0.25 per square

footRaise user fees, Semi-Direct

Requires $0.05 per half hour

increase

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 23: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

23

Summary

Current system has opportunity

Practices can be enhanced

Free parking–feasible and wise

Must occur after system changes

Revised Destination in Parking Management

Page 24: Revised Destination in Parking Management · Revised Destination in Parking Management. Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in Parking Ramps and Garages N 9 Free parking locations Revised

Free Parking from 4 pm to Close in

Parking Ramps and Garages

N

Lo

t 9

Free parking locations

Revised Destination in Parking Management