Results Davidson College Biology Department 1 4 2 3 6 DNA Microarrays: A guide to teaching chips...

1
Results Davidson College Biology Department 1 4 2 3 6 DNA Microarrays: A guide to teaching chips Allison Amore, Sheena Bossie, Max Citrin, Erin Cobain, Megan McDonald, Marieta Solé, Emily Wilson A. Malcolm Campbell 5 • DNA microarrays measure expression level changes across a genome and have the potential to be a powerful diagnostic tool in medicine. • Equipment necessary to print DNA microarrays is expensive & complex • Undergraduates have little experience with this technique • Undergraduates face challenge of learning about DNA microarray technology without hands on experience PROBLEM TO BE ADDRESSED: How can DNA microarray technology be introduced at the undergraduate level in a laboratory setting? POTENTIAL SOLUTION Teaching Chips - provide students with thorough understanding of microarray methodology but do not necessitate the use of expensive RNA samples or genomic DNA. Students learn how to design, print (if the equipment is available) and process chips that are likely to have a high success rate with visible data. Setup M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp M hp idh 1 id h1 idh1 idh1 idh 1 id h1 idh1 id h1 idh 1 idh1 idh 1 id h1 idh1 id h1 idh1 idh 1 idh1 idh 1 id h1 idh1 id h1 idh1 idh 1 idh1 idh 1 id h1 idh1 id h1 idh1 idh1 idh 1 id h1 idh1 id h1 idh 1 id h1 idh1 SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY • We designed a stoplight pattern using three S. Cerevisiae genes (Mhp, Idh1 Idh1, and SHY). • Competent bacterial cells containing plasmids with 500bp fragments of genes were obtained from a previous study (D. Pierce). • Genes were chosen because their probes had been previously shown not to bind to either of the other two genes (D. Pierce). • Design was printed using BioRobotics MicroGrid II Compact •We followed the 2-step 3DNA Genisphere for probe hybridization (previously optimized by E. Oldham) The Microarray Process Cy5 dendrim er 500mertarget 30m eroligo probe 31m ercapture sequence 5’ 3’ Cy3 dendrim er 500mertarget 30m eroligo probe 31m ercapture sequence 5’ 3’ Essential Steps: • grow cells containing RNA of interest • isolate and extract RNA • convert mRNA into cDNA • spot cDNA onto slide • hybridize with Cy3 and Cy5 tagged probes • scan chip to measure fluorescence intensity • analyze data to determine repression and induction patterns from image profiles. 3DNA dendrimer courtesy of Genisphere, Inc. Gene Systematic Name Chromosome Brief Description of Function MHP1 YJL042W X microtubule organization IDH1 YNL037C XIV Regulatory subunit in cellular energy metabolism SHY1 YGR112W VII Codes for a mitochondrial protein required for full expression of cytochrome oxidase (COX) QIAGEN HiSpeed Plasmid Midi Kit Promega PureYield Plasmid Midiprep kit List price $250 for 25 preps List price $180 for 25 preps Requires little centrifugation, Faster Multiple centrifugation steps, Slower Slightly more consistent results Slightly greater variability Introduction Future Work • Perform experiment using oligos with correct capture sequence. • Confirm results using Q-PCR • Analyze data using Magic Tool • Compose a single detailed protocol • Promote the use of teaching chips in undergraduate settings • Publish work in Cell Biology Education Fluorescent labeling process using Cy5 (red) and Cy3 (green) dyes: (Cartoon created by E. Oldham) Part I: Two different plasmid isolation kits were compared: Results Continued Part III: Prepared test slide to determine whether all reagents were functioning properly: Test Slide Design. Anticipated results if all reagents were functioning properly. O = oligo, RT = Reverse Transcript, C = control. Actual Test Slide Results. Only the two positive controls fluoresced as expected. CONCLUSION: All proposed reasons for our negative results were proven false. The unexpected outcome was due to a capture sequence that was not complementary to the dendrimer sequence! Part II: Chips were scanned to visualize stoplight pattern no fluorescence was detected on any of the slides. Potential Reasons for this Outcome: • Fluorescent dyes have degraded and lost ability to fluoresce • Oligos were non-functional or degraded • Plasmid DNA may not have been isolated properly SHY idh1 Mhp SHY Mhp SHY idh1 Mhp SHY Mhp 120 ng/ul 240 ng/ul SHY-O SHY-O Mhp-O Mhp-O idh1-O idh1-O RT-C RT-C Acknowledgements We would like to thank the following people for their invaluable support: Dr. A. Malcolm Campbell Danielle Choi Emily Oldham Davidson College Biology Dept. Dan Pierce Various service technicians Chris Healey

Transcript of Results Davidson College Biology Department 1 4 2 3 6 DNA Microarrays: A guide to teaching chips...

Page 1: Results Davidson College Biology Department 1 4 2 3 6 DNA Microarrays: A guide to teaching chips Allison Amore, Sheena Bossie, Max Citrin, Erin Cobain,

Results

Davidson College Biology Department

1

4

2 3

6

DNA Microarrays: A guide to teaching chips Allison Amore, Sheena Bossie, Max Citrin, Erin Cobain, Megan McDonald, Marieta Solé, Emily Wilson A. Malcolm Campbell

5

• DNA microarrays measure expression level changes across a genome

and have the potential to be a powerful diagnostic tool in medicine.

• Equipment necessary to print DNA microarrays is expensive & complex

• Undergraduates have little experience with this technique

• Undergraduates face challenge of learning about DNA microarray

technology without hands on experience

PROBLEM TO BE ADDRESSED: How can DNA microarray technology be introduced at the undergraduate level in a laboratory setting?

POTENTIAL SOLUTION Teaching Chips - provide students with thorough understanding of microarray methodology but do not necessitate the use of expensive RNA samples or genomic DNA. Students learn how to design, print (if the equipment is available) and process chips that are likely to have a high success rate with visible data.

SetupMhp Mhp Mhp

Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp

Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp

Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp

Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp

Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp Mhp

Mhp Mhp Mhp

idh1 idh1 idh1

idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1

idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1

idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1

idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1

idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1 idh1

idh1 idh1 idh1

SHY SHY SHY

SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY

SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY

SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY

SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY

SHY SHY SHY SHY SHY

SHY SHY SHY

• We designed a stoplight pattern using three S. Cerevisiae genes (Mhp, Idh1Idh1, and SHY).

• Competent bacterial cells containing plasmids with 500bp fragments of genes were obtained from a previous study (D. Pierce).

• Genes were chosen because their probes had been previously shown not to bind to either of the other two genes (D. Pierce).

• Design was printed using BioRobotics MicroGrid II Compact

•We followed the 2-step 3DNA Genisphere for probe hybridization (previously optimized by E. Oldham)

The Microarray Process

Cy5 dendrimer

500mer target

30mer oligo probe 31mer capture sequence

5’

3’

Cy3 dendrimer

500mer target

30mer oligo probe 31mer capture sequence

5’

3’

Essential Steps:• grow cells containing RNA of interest• isolate and extract RNA • convert mRNA into cDNA• spot cDNA onto slide • hybridize with Cy3 and Cy5 tagged probes • scan chip to measure fluorescence intensity • analyze data to determine repression and induction patterns from image profiles.

3DNA dendrimer courtesy of Genisphere, Inc.

GeneSystematic

Name Chromosome Brief Description of Function

MHP1 YJL042W X microtubule organization

IDH1 YNL037C XIVRegulatory subunit in cellular energy

metabolism

SHY1 YGR112W VII

Codes for a mitochondrial protein required for full expression of cytochrome oxidase (COX)

QIAGEN HiSpeed Plasmid Midi Kit

Promega PureYield Plasmid Midiprep kit

List price $250 for 25 preps List price $180 for 25 preps

Requires little centrifugation, Faster Multiple centrifugation steps, Slower

Slightly more consistent results Slightly greater variability

Introduction

Future Work• Perform experiment using oligos with correct capture sequence.

• Confirm results using Q-PCR

• Analyze data using Magic Tool

• Compose a single detailed protocol

• Promote the use of teaching chips in undergraduate settings

• Publish work in Cell Biology Education

Fluorescent labeling process using Cy5 (red) and Cy3 (green) dyes:

(Cartoon created by E. Oldham)

Part I: Two different plasmid isolation kits were compared:Results Continued

Part III: Prepared test slide to determine whether all reagents were functioning properly:

Test Slide Design. Anticipated results if all reagents were functioning properly. O = oligo, RT = Reverse Transcript, C = control.

Actual Test Slide Results. Only the two positive controls fluoresced as expected.

CONCLUSION: All proposed reasons for our negative results were proven false. The unexpected outcome was due to a capture sequence that was not complementary to the dendrimer sequence!

Part II: Chips were scanned to visualize stoplight pattern no fluorescence was detected on any of the slides.

Potential Reasons for this Outcome:

• Fluorescent dyes have degraded and lost ability to fluoresce

• Oligos were non-functional or degraded

• Plasmid DNA may not have been isolated properly

SHY idh1 Mhp SHY Mhp

SHY idh1 Mhp SHY Mhp

120 ng/ul

240 ng/ul

SHY-O SHY-O Mhp-O

Mhp-O idh1-O idh1-O

RT-C RT-C AcknowledgementsWe would like to thank the following people for their invaluable support:

Dr. A. Malcolm Campbell Danielle Choi

Emily Oldham Davidson College Biology Dept.

Dan Pierce Various service technicians

Chris Healey