Reporting on Programme of Measures (Art. 13)

WG DIKE

Dr. Jan Cools(29-30/9/2014, Brussels)

-Introduction

Principles & Lessons learned• Re-use of data and information• Reduce duplication of reporting• More clarity on expected products• Aim for more consistency and comparability• Link reporting and assessment methodology

Based on following documents• MSFD reporting on monitoring• MSFD PoM Recommendation• WFD 2016 Reporting Guidance, incl. pre-defined ‘key types

of measures’ (KTM’s)

Categories of measuresCategory of measures Reporting needs

1. Existing measures under other policies (mostly WFD)• 1a. Fully implemented• 1b. Not yet (fully) implemented

LIMITED• Concise overview of current and future contributions to marine GES and targets• Gap analysis• Reference to source doc

2. Additional measures• 2a. Extension of existing measures

MORE EXTENSIVE• Reference to original measure• Additional aspects needed to achieve GES and targets

• 2b. Completely new measures DETAILED REPORTING• Not elsewhere reported

Key Type of Measures (WFD)

KTM (WFD) Relevance for MSFD1 Construction or upgrades of

wastewater treatment plants Reduction of nutrient loads & solid particles (D5, D10)

2 Reduce nutrient pollution from agriculture

Reduction of nutrient loads (D5)

3 Reduce pesticides pollution from agriculture.

Reduction of contaminants loads (D8, D9)

• 25 KTM’s• Measures for MSFD categories• 1a, 1b : existing measures• 2a : extend existing measures

Examples of the relevance of WFD KTM’s to MSFD

Key Type of Measures (MSFD)

• 12 additional KTM’s• Measures under MSFD category 2b (new)

• KTM’s selected to cover• Main pressures to the marine environment (not covered

under WFD KTM’s)• Cross-cutting measures (e.g. research, economic incentives)

Proposed new KTMs for MSFD reporting26. Address physical loss of seabed habitats in the marine environment27. Address physical damage to the marine environment28. Address inputs of energy to the marine environment, incl. underwater noise29. Address marine littler 30. Address interferences with hydrological processes in the marine environment31. Address contamination by hazardous substances (synthetic substances, non-synthetic substances, radio-nuclides) and the systematic and/or intentional release of substances in the marine environment from sea-based or air-based sources

32. Address nutrient and organic matter inputs to the marine environment from sea-based or air-based sources33. Address the introduction and spread of non-indigenous species34. Address biological disturbances in the marine environment from the selective extraction of species including incidental non-target catches35. Address other types of biological disturbance, including death, injury, disturbance and translocation of marine species, introduction of genetically-modified individuals and introduction of microbial pathogens 36. Spatial Protection Measures for the marine environment 37. Economic incentives (Annex VI MSFD)38. Research, improvement of knowledge base reducing uncertainty in the marine environment

Expected productsFrom PoM reporting

National fact sheets

(descriptive)

Assessment report (Art.16)

Reporting sheets (data-based, quantitative)

Extended WFD reporting (to cover

MSFD needs)MS

COM

KTM List of specific measures

Pre-defined quantitative indicators

Targets (Art.10) & Pressures

Gap analysis

Exceptions(art. 14)

Type of measures

(1a, 1b, 2a, 2b)

Reporting sheets: KTM level

Indicator values

i.e. monitor progresstowards• achieving targets• reducing pressures• Implementing

measures

Value of 0= target achieved= measure implemented

Reporting fields on individual measures based on fields in WFD reporting sheets

• Under WFD, info on individual measures available at national level; Not reported to COM

• Fields to be covered:– Measure Code / Measure Name– Type of measure (1a, 1b, 2a, 2b)– Geographic coverage of the measure– Measure description (if needed)– Expected contribution to MSFD GES, Targets and Pressures– Any potential obstacles to its successful implementation– Lead organisation for implementation of the measure– Partners assisting in the implementation of the measure – Cost and financing of measure (has financing been secured)– Sources of Funding

Outline for national fact sheets

For each descriptor and associated targets

• General questions• Specific questions• Identification of new measures• Other questions

+Extended reporting

under WFD for MSFD

Schema element: MSFDRelevanceField type / facets: Yes, No, UnclearGuidance: Required: Is this measure relevant for the purpose of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive?

• Fit MSFD needs into WFD 2016 Reporting Guidance• 6 questions already in WFD guidance• 3 additional questions proposed – link measure to

descriptor, Annex III categories (pressures, impact, features) and MSFD targets

• How?: By proposing « reporting boxes » to WFD guidance

-Outcome of WG DIKE

• OVERALL: Approach welcomed, with a need to clarify following:• Who is filling the boxes: WFD or MSFD unit?• Discrepancies with PoM recommendation• KTM approach for MSFD – List of KTM's – Illustrate with examples – Add

coordination measures, awareness raising, …• Clarify how to assign a measure to a specific KTM• Format of national / regional fact sheets• How to phase in measures from other policies than WFD? (fisheries, off-

shore pollution, natura2000) - Look for solution on management measures, licenses etc…

• Financing of measures• KTM Art. 16 assessment – sufficient to achieve targets (more flexible

than WFD KTM "indicators") – Illustration by case studies• Regional cooperation better in paper• Timeline after Nov 2014 up to 2016 (road map)

-PoM concept paper: timing

• 17 Oct 2014 Written comments on concept paper• Oct / Nov 2014 Present outcomes of WG DIKE at WG

ESA, WG GES and WG POM (WFD). Check with WG DIS and SCG??

• End Oct 2014 Small drafting team meeting (BRU), revising the PoM concept paper during meeting

• End Oct 2014 Send revised PoM concept paper to MSCG• 10-11 Nov 2014 MSCG (Agree on principles)• 24-26 Nov 2014 WD-MD (agree on outstanding issues)

Thank you!!Questions?

ContactJan.cools@milieu.be