Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
-
Upload
nehapatel20 -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
0
Transcript of Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
1/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 321
CHAPTER 9
GIVING THE RURAL INDIA A FAIR DEAL
STUDY FEEDBACK, LIVE EXPERIENCES,
RECOMMENDATIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
"Give a hungry man fish for a day, he will eat it and the next day, he would be
hungry again. Instead if you taught him how to fish, he would be able to feed
himself and his family for a lifetime."
- Mr. Aditya Vikram Birla, Former Chairman, Aditya Birla Group
SYNOPSIS:
This chapter focuses on the various Recommendations and Suggestions
given by the Researcher. The chapter starts with a brief note on various
Private and Government Initiatives. It then explains the impact of
mobiles in Agriculture, Possible strategies for Rural Education and
Health and the various constraints related to the operators and thesurvey. Later, the various recommendations include an Education model,
following the concept of Animator with examples. And finally, the
chapter ends with the concluding remarks and the final conclusion.
9.1 INTRODUCTION
Economic growth and social equity are both needed to bridge
international and domestic digital divides. However, no consensus exists
on exactly what policies are needed for either of these goals.
Governments face constituencies with radically different perspectives on
how to bridge the divides, ranging from labor unions to international
businesses to government regulatory agencies. Numerous governments,
private businesses, civil society members and international organizations
have turned their collective attentions to bridging these divides, and havelaunched a variety of initiatives to shape policy.
A1
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
2/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 322
9.2 RURAL INDIA AND PRIVATE TELECOM OPERATOR
INITIATIVES
In regards with the digital divide, it may be noted that the next wave of telecominfrastructure growth is likely to come from the rural areas. Network rollout in
rural regions accounted for 70 percent of the capital expenditure earmarked for
2008 by the countrys largest private operator, Bharti Airtel. Other existing
operators and new licensees have planned similar expenditure outlays for the
rural areas.A4
This presents a huge opportunity for vendors struggling in a
global market that is showing few signs of growth. Industry stalwarts such as
Ericsson, Nokia Siemens Networks and Alcatel-Lucent are positioning
themselves to benefit from this wave of investment for rural upliftment.
9.2.1 The Launch of 3G and WiMAX services will also play a key role in
increasing rural telephony and thus the options for Rural Education.
While globally 3G is viewed as a service primarily for the urban areas,
in India, 3G will become the predominant platform to achieve the
governments broadband objectives as well as to undertake key social
initiatives such a as e-education and telemedicine. WiMAX offers a
robust and scalable last mile solution for these areas and is expected to
make an invaluable contribution. The technology can be deployed
rapidly in remote location and will be able to support the minimum
capacity and speed requirements that will be laid down by the
government in its National e-Governance Plan initiatives.B1
9.2.2 As discussed before also, the next level of growth will come from the
rural areas and positive sign for the rural upliftment is: over the past two
years, telecom operators have increased their focus on these regions and
have customized their strategies to target rural users.B2
They are, for
instance, offering local language-based subsidized handsets, lower
tariffs and applications that are of use to farmers and village
communities.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
3/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 323
Many operators are also selling handsets with their Value-Added
Services (VAS) content are embedded in the phones and are devising
consumer-friendly VAS applications that can be accessed by just two
three keys since complicated applications disturb rural consumers.
In order to expedite network rollout in the rural regions at reduced costs,
operators are opting for infrastructure sharing in a big way. Bharti
Airtel, Vodafone, Essar and Idea Cellular have formed a common tower
infrastructure company, Indus Tower, at an enterprise value of Rs. 150
billion, has come up with the primary focus on building telecom towers
in small towns and rural areas.
The rural areas are clearly a strong focus area for telecom operators.
With specific strategies drawn up for this key segment, the momentum
for rural connectivity is all set to grow.B4
9.2.3 Rural India and Government Policy Initiatives
i) Backed by the initiatives of the government and private operators,
rural connectivity in the country has grown at a rapid pace over the
past two to three years. While private operators are expediting
rural network rollout and actively targeting rural customers, for the
government, providing telecom facilities in rural India has been the
highest priority for some time now.A5
The rural regions,
comprising 600,000 villages and a population of over 809 billion
(over 70 percent of the countrys population), are the focus areas
as the government works to bridge the digital divide.
ii) The Universal Service Obligation (USO) Fund, set up by the
government especially for this purpose, has played a key role in
driving rural connectivity. For instance, as of March 2009,
57,181 of the 66,822 Village Public Telephones (VPTs) to be
installed under the Bharat Nirman programme had been provided
through Digital Satellite Phone Criminals (DSPCs).A6
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
4/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 324
iii) The Bharat Nirman programme envisages setting up VPTs in all
inhabited villages in the country except those with a population
of less than 100 or ones that are affected by insurgency or are
situated in deep forests. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL)
will set up VPTs in these remaining villages with subsidy support
from the USO Fund by March 2011. The USO Fund is also
being used for the maintenance of about 558,000 existing VPTs.
iv) Apart from USO Fund initiatives, the governments Batuibak
e-Governance Plan, which envisages setting up common service
centers (CSCs), state wide area networks (SWANs) and state data
centers (SCDs), will play a key role in increasing broadband
penetration in the rural areas, For instance, the CSCs run to
equip Panchayat in villages with advanced computerized systems
and trained IT representatives.
v) Government policies have played a key role in increasing
connectivity in the rural areas. For instance, in September 2008,
the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) decided to waive
the license fee on rural landline telephones to step up rural
penetration. Ub Addutuib, the Telecom Commission decided to
reduce the USO Fund Levy to 3 percent of adjusted gross revenue
from five percent for service providers that have a presence in
over 95 percent in the rural areas. However, since these decisions
have revenue implications for the exchequer, the finance ministry
demanded a review of these decisions.
vi) The government has been proactive in its efforts to promote rural
telecom penetration and has taken several steps to bridge the
digital divide. However, much still remains to be done in order to
achieve the rural teledensity target of 25 percent and 200 million
rural connections by the end of the Eleventh Plan period.B5
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
5/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 325
HARVEST &
TRANSPORT OF
PRODUCE facilitation
PRODUCTION
RISK COVERAGE
& PRICE RISK
COVERAGE
INPUT facilitation
Seeds, Fertilizers,
Pesticides, Farm
Machinery, Soil Testing
KNOWLEDGE /
Extension ServicesFacilitation/
Alternate farming
FARMERSTORAGE
facilitation
CREDIT
facilitation
IRRIGATIONfacilitation
MARKET INFO
&
Linkage facilitation
9.3 IMPACTS OF MOBILES ON AGRICULTURE AND FARMERS
The following figure F 9.1 suggests the various needs of the farmer where ICT
can play a vital role in educating the rural masses.
Figure F 9.1: Needs of the Farmers
Impact on Farmers
1. During the field survey and subsequent visits to the targeted villages,
namely Village Kurkheda of Buldhana District of Maharashtra and
Village Rameshwar of Latur District of Maharashtra, most farmers
reported that they used their mobile phones primarily for social
purposes, almost all interviewees also used it for agricultural activity,
with some respondents citing significant productivity gains as a result.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
6/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 326
Table T 9.1 ranks the information accessed by interviewees on their
mobile phones and compares it with information accessed from other
sources as reported in the NSS (National Sample Survey) 59th round
survey.C3
Table : T 9.1 Ranking of the use of modern technology by farmers
to access agricultural information
2. The farmers of the region strongly felt that use of mobile technology
will certainly help them in increasing the convenience and cost savings
from using their mobile phones as basic communication devices to seek
information such as input availability or to check on market prices.
3. The farmers also strongly felt that the areas where they may get
benefited are improved access to information included seed variety
selection, best cultivation practices, protection from weather-related
damage, handling plant disease and price realization.
4. The Investigator also observed that market information influenced
farmers to alter where and when they sold their crop in order to
maximize revenues and in some cases, provided ammunition to farmers
to negotiate better pricing terms from local traders.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
7/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 327
5. As with the farming community investigation, the researcher noticed a
differential in the impact, depending on whether a mobile will be used as
an information platform or will be used merely as a communication
device. In several cases, the value of the mobile as an information
platform was greatly enhanced because it could be used as a means to
communicate newly accessed information to others.
6. The most important components of the agriculture market are Traders
and commission agents. Researcher would like to bring to the notice the
fact that these components comprised of a segment making daily use of
their mobile phones and offered some evidence that their mobile use was
improving overall market efficiency. A large part of agricultural produce
goes through traders/brokers at government-regulated markets. These
players control the final sale of goods by most farmers in India and thus
are critical for market information and market transactions farmers.
They use their phones to contact a host of players (farmers, traders,
employees/partners posted at other markets) in order to gauge current
pricing information, market supply and demand conditions and to obtain
produce for sale.A8
7. In addition to this primary function, the villagers also cited a number of
other examples where mobile telephony can make an impact. This
included dealing with truck breakdowns, shifting crops en route
according to the supply and demand situation and communicating
instructions to staff both locally and at significant distances. The
traders have historically played a one-stop shop information roleA9
for
many small farmers in ways similar to the desired role of mobile-
enabled information service providers. The relationship has often been
cemented by the extension of credit.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
8/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 328
9.4 THE MODEL OF EDUCATION FOR ANYBODY, ANYTIME,
ANYWHERE USING MOBILE TECHNOLOGY
9.4.1 Nature of Benefits Conferred by Mobile Telephony
1. The nature of the reported positive economic impact of mobile
phones by interviewees can be categorized in one of three ways:
a. Easy access to customized content,
b. Mobility and
c. Timesaving or convenience.
2. It also indicated how customized content enables farmers to avert
losses, improve yields and increase information relating to
various agricultural practices. Thirty of the farmers were
interviewed, out of which were able to offer quantitative
estimates of the economic benefits of using one of the
information services. The size of the benefit they reported ranged
from 5-25 per cent of earnings, with the larger gains typically
attributable to the adoption of better planting techniques.A11
3. The second categorymobilityis unique to the use of mobile
phones. The others reflect the fact that the mobile has become the
primary (or only) communication mode for many farmers.
However, as the Researcher notes later, the beneficial
productivity impact of mobile telephony depends also on other
basic infrastructure.
4. Mobile users can determine when and where they can
communicate and access information. Benefits from mobile
phones are as a means of two-way communication as well as a
means of access to the information service.A14
The access to
mobile communications amplified the value of the information
provided by farmers by enabling information sharing between
subscribers and non-subscribers.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
9/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 329
5. Farmers also reported benefits from being able to make and
receive calls while working on the farm. This included the ability
to describe plant diseases from the field to experts and to co-
ordinate better with their hired labor.
9.4.2 Improved Convenience, Time and Travel Savings
1. Almost all of the farmers interviewed reported some benefits in
terms of greater convenience such as timesaving by using the
mobile as a basic phone. For some of the farmers interviewed, the
mobile represented the only convenient access to communication
facilities. This is not surprising, as fixed line communication in
rural India remains extremely poor.
2. For many of the small farmers in our survey who said they
benefited from greater convenience, the savings stemmed
typically from avoiding local travel and could range from Rs.
100-200 per trip.A12
A smaller minority said they had derived
greater benefits from the ability to make better decisions aboutwhere to sell their output after getting market prices for a variety
of local and distant markets.
3. Mobile use also delivered convenience benefits to farmers who
were starting to substitute some physical meetings with mobile
phone conversations. It was noted that the mobile was essential
when the village suffered power shortages and the rural
connectivity was not available.
4. Mobile phones did not totally substitute face-to- face
communication. It was reported that farmers often need highly
personalized solutions that benefit from back and forth dialogue
in person with the Sarpanch as well as the larger farming
community. Many of the queries from farmers could not be fully
resolved through the phone alone.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
10/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 330
9.5 POSSIBLE STRATEGIES FOR PENETRATION OF MOBILE
TECHNOLOGY
As per the data provided by the service providers, around 407112 villages are
having mobile coverage i.e. about 69% of villages are having the coverage. Taking
around 180 million as the targeted rural subscribers in the country, as on Sep 2008,
there are 90.76 million rural subscribers. Therefore, there is a need to plan for
converting an additional 90-100 million population as subscribers.C4
The strategy for increasing the telecom penetration in rural areas can be
classified in two categories:
9.5.1 Areas without mobile coverage
1. Creation of infrastructure for provision of Mobile Services in
rural and remote areas
(a) The assets constituting the infrastructure for provision of
mobile services shall be determined by the Central
Government from time-to-time.
(b) A percentage of the Capital Recovery for the infrastructure
for provision of mobile services shall be taken into
account to determine the Net Cost.
2. Provision of Broadband connectivity to villages in a phased
manner
A percentage of the Capital Recovery for the infrastructure for
broadband connectivity shall be taken into account to determine
the Net Cost.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
11/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 331
3. Creation of general infrastructure in rural and remote areas
for development of telecommunication facilities
(a) The items of general infrastructure to be taken up for
development shall be determined by the Central
Government from time to time.
(b) A percentage of the Capital Recovery for the development
of general infrastructure shall be taken into account to
determine the Net Cost.
4. Induction of new technological developments in the telecom
sector in rural and remote areas
Pilot projects to establish new technological developments in the
telecom sector, which can be deployed in the rural and remote area,
may be supported with the approval of the Central Government.
9.5.2 Areas already having mobile coverage
As the reasons for owning a mobile phone in urban and rural areas are very
different, for attracting rural people to subscribe to mobile phones, there is
a need to increase its cost effectiveness.C4
Some of the methods could be:-
1. Lowering the cost of the handsets
2. Evaluate the design and specifications of handsets3. Reduce complexity and subsequent servicing costs
4. Bundling of handsets
USO Fund should look into this aspect and in consultation with DoT
should devise a scheme for setting off the cost of the bundled handset
provided to rural subscribers.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
12/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 332
9.5.3 Incentivizing a new mobile connection subscription:
Telecom service providers should come up with innovative concessional
schemes for new subscribers
1. Providing locally relevant applications on Mobile
This could include applications on mobile regarding health,
education, farming and other local trade.
2. Mobile Banking for Rural India
In many developing countries, lack of banking facilities in the
rural area combined with a proliferation of mobile services has
created a unique opportunity for providing financial services over
the mobile network. Mobile phones are being used to transfer
funds between people. These applications are driven by rural
people who are looking for:
A safe place to keep money Accessibility / liquidityThe ability to turn electronic money
into hard cash and vice versa at convenient locations
(agents/ATMs)
Ability to transfer money To and from the financialinstitution, to make payments and to remit money to friends
and relatives.
3. Overcoming the language barrier
The literacy levels are very low in rural India. Majority of the
handsets are in English. So we should concentrate on region wise
manufacturing of handsets in accordance with the needs and
wants of the target customers and manufacture handsets in the
major acceptable languages which will provide an ease in
operation to the customers.C4
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
13/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 333
4. Tie-up with Department of Post
Increasing the customer outlets for mobile
payments/recharging: Rural post offices should be allowed to
work as customer outlets for the telecom companies.
Local schools and community centers can provide the training
needed to help local residents and businesses in rural areas
and take advantage of new information technology.
The Dept of Posts has a presence in every corner of the
country. The Postman is a known and recognized entity in
even the smallest of human settlements. He personally knows
every resident of his Beat, and in smaller towns/villages,
probably is familiar with the people, their financial status,
their needs, and requirements for communication services
based on the letters / money orders being sent/received. ThePostman can therefore be effectively used to educate the
potential Customers and First-Time Users about the uses
and benefits of the Services being offered. Also, there can
be no better system for address verification and credit
verification than the Postal Dept and more specifically the
Postman himself. No agency can claim a similar level of
familiarity with the Local residents and this knowledge
that the Postman has built over many years of doing his
Beat can never be replicated. This makes him the ideal
agency for any kind of verification.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
14/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 334
Photo P 9.1: Post Office at Rameshwar Village of Latur District
Photo P9.2: Post Man from Rameshwar Village
Marathwada Region, Maharashtra
9.6 CONSTRAINTS IDENTIFIED BY THE RESEARCHER IN
THE PENETRATION OF RURAL TELECOM
9.6.1 Problems faced by Telecom Operators in successfully implementing
the concept of Rural Education
1. Some of the constraints to ICTs in rural areas require a shift in
both human and organizational communication and working
patterns which may take longer to change.A15
2. ICTs rely on physical infrastructures (electricity,
telecommunications) and even when such infrastructures are in place,
difficulties arise when they are poorly maintained or too costly to use.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
15/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 335
3. ICTs are dependent on national policy and regulation for
telecommunications and broadcasting licenses. They require
initial capital investment for hardware and software. They also
are dependent on the skills and capacity necessary to use, manage
and maintain the technology effectively.
4. Matching the most appropriate communications technology with
people's needs and capabilities is a crucial task for ICT providers.
9.6.2 Constraints Identified by the Researcher in the context of
operational implementation.
1. Acquisition of Land
The first major hurdle in the proliferation of towers in the rural
areas is that acquisition of land for BTS takes very long time.
2. Right of Public pathways
In the rural area, for providing backhaul connectivity, if fiber or
cable is to be laid then even though the laying is along kuchha
roads or through forest, but as the route involves jurisdiction of
multiple state and municipal agencies/Panchayat, therefore to
coordinating different agencies and getting the requisite
permission is time consuming.
3. Backhaul connectivity
Unavailability of cheap and fast backhaul connectivity is one of
the major hurdles in faster proliferation of telecom in rural areas.
Unlike urban areas where optical fibre is largely deployed to
provide the backhaul connection, about 80% of the rural BTS are
on microwave system.A16
Though, at many places OFC
connectivity has been provided but the provisioning cost is
prohibitory high and as discussed subsequently, providingbackhaul using the satellite link is a cumbersome process.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
16/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 336
4. Lack of Infrastructure sharing
According to industry estimate, cost of setting up a cellular tower
(BTS) is varies from around Rs 3-4 million inclusive of
equipment, power plant, etc. Though significant number of
existing cell sites are already being shared by competing
operators across the country, however, this is mainly in urban
areas. In rural areas, sharing of infrastructure is yet to be attained
at a significant level/rate.
5. Power Supply
In a number of villages the power supply is either not available or
is available only for few hours. As a result even if battery backup
is provided for the BTS, due to availability of electricity for a very
short duration, the batteries are not able to get fully charged.
Further due to frequent interruption of power supply the life of
these batteries get shortened which in turn increases operational
cost to run services in rural areas. Unavailability of reliable power
supply in semi-urban, rural and remote areas increases operational
costs further because sufficient backup systems have to be
maintained. As per the statistics, out of 5, 93,731 inhabited villages
(as per2001 census), 4, 73,136 (almost 80 %) have been electrified
Upto March 2008. The remaining villages are to be covered by
2009 as per Bharat Nirman Programme under Rajiv Gandhi
Grameen Vidhutikaran Yojna.C2 However, in practice, the frequent
and long interruptions in the electricity supply put a large number
of these villages at par with the non-electrified ones.
6. High Operation and Maintenance cost
Maintenance costs of the network in rural areas are high as
compared to urban areas because of several factors such as poor
transportation systems, difficulty in supply of spare parts and non
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
17/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 337
availability of skilled manpower etc. Due to lack of reliable
power in rural areas there is substantial increase in the cost of
diesel for running of the engine alternators for keeping
exchanges, transmission equipment and BTSs in the live
conditions.C5
7. Low Average Revenue per User (ARPU)
As per the license conditions the service providers are mandated
to provide service to all without any discrimination. All
subscribers, big and small, rich and poor, are entitled to get the
same quality of service, tariffs and other conditions. However it
is seen that Service Providers do not fulfill this license condition
or at least are reluctant to venture into the interior rural areas
where expected ARPUs are low. The profit motive being of
primary importance to all, the low ARPUs expected in the rural
areas do not provide sufficient motivation for the Service
Providers to provide service in these areas.
8. Unaffordability of Services
Though the provisioning cost of telecom services has come down
significantly in India, however in terms of purchasing power of
individual, these are still high particularly in terms of cost of the end
equipments i.e. Cost of handsets, Modem, PC, UPS etc. As a large
proportion most of the rural population is having low income, the
present cost of telecom services is still prohibiting to them.
9. Low literacy levels and Technology Appreciation
The literacy levels are very low in rural India. No matter how
wired or connected a rural community is, no matter GSM or
CDMA, WiMax or 3G, broadband or dial-ups are in place,
without appropriate literacy to utilize the technology or the value
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
18/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 338
added services that it provides, the connectivity will have no
value. Presently, more than 98% of computer work is done in
English. Apart from the issue of lack of skills in English, a large
percentage of the rural masses do not even have even sufficient
reading and writing skill in their own language. In order to help
develop the habit of using the opportunities that a Broadband
offers, there is a need to develop content that is relevant, usable
and understandable by the local people. All the support and
incentives offered for rural penetration would be of consequence
only if the content provided is relevant and usable. It is therefore,
of utmost importance that the contents developed should be in the
vernacular language and the application software should largely
be menu driven and graphic as far as possible in order to
overcome the issue of illiteracy. In absence of these, there will be
lack of demand generation in rural areas, leading to a failure of
the entire initiative.
10. Unavailability of locally relevant customized applications
India being a multi diverse country has different requirement
from one geographical area to the other area. However, the
content being developed at present are meant to be used
universally even though it fulfils the requirement of a particular
geographic area and not all the whole country.. Therefore unless
content developer understands the local requirement and develop
customized contents, the demand for tele-communication will not
increase. The processing of information and converting it in such
a form which become useful to the end user and to transport such
information through a reliable, accessible and convenient
transportation system are two requirements which can help in
generation of demand for telecommunications services and
content services.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
19/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 339
9.6.3 Constraints Identified by the Researcher in the context of ICT in
Agriculture.
The survey revealed that in some cases, small farmers and villagers
found the lack of infrastructure, their lack of knowledge regarding the
cultivation and marketing of non-traditional crops and their inability to
access credit major hindrances to realizing the full benefits of mobile
Telephony.C6
1. Infrastructure Constraints
Investigator highlighted infrastructure gaps that affected their
ability to realize productivity gains through improved yields and
higher prices. In order for farmers to realize the full potential of
access to new information, they must be able to use it effectively.
Researcher found, consistently, that inadequate infrastructure
prevented this. Four specific infrastructure constraints limit the
ability of farmers to leverage information:Insufficient availability of critical land resources (reduces
yield)
Inadequate irrigation (reduces yield)
Poor physical access to markets (reduces realized prices)
Inadequate crop storage facilities (reduces realized prices)
There are difficulties in sourcing critical resources such as
fertilizer, seed and medicine. One major problem they faced was
that counterfeits were sold in many local markets and the farmers
had no way of distinguishing them from the genuine product. In
several groups, the farmers noted that they needed information
that would help them identify these counterfeit goods that lead to
productivity losses.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
20/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 340
Also, there was lack of irrigation as a significant constraint and two
of them noted that it had affected the sustainability of growing
desired crops. One farmer noted that the scarcity of water is the
main hurdle for the development of agriculture in the region.C8
Farmers reported poor road infrastructure and lack of refrigerated
transport as problems affecting their access to markets. Many of
the small farmers typically used small carts powered by animals
or small engines to deliver their goods to the market and said that
transport costs represented a prohibitive barrier to access more
distant markets. This limited their opportunity to profit from
market price differences by selling in markets where higher
prices may be available. As one small farmer from Kurkheda
village commented, even if he knew the prices in the larger
regional market, there are no roads that go there.
Lack of storage facilities was cited as curtailing farmers ability
to choose when to sell their crop, limiting their ability to
maximize price realization. One group of farmers said that the
lack of storage facilities contributed to the effective monopoly of
local commission agents, which they believed caused them to
receive lower prices for their produce.
ITCs internet kiosk service is one attempt to overcome some of the
challenges presented by inadequate infrastructure (Table T 9.2).
This has been done by combining the provision of information with
other services such as the direct sale of critical resources.
Recognizing the problems faced by small farmers in their supply
chain, the internet kiosk model includes information delivery,
input provision and direct procurement.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
21/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 341
Farmers we interviewed in villages said that with successful ICT
programmes may report improved yield and better price
realization. The primary benefits may report the introduction of
hybrid seed varieties and adoption of new farming practices,
leading to productivity gains of between 10 and 40 per cent.
Farmers noted that by receiving comparative market pricing
information as well as a firm price offer in advance from ICT
initiatives, they can have greater ability to choose when and
where to sell their products. They can also get benefit from being
able to sell to the community locally and getting transport costs
reimbursed.C3
Table T 9.2: Example of the ITC e-choupal model
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
22/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 342
9.6.4 Constraints Identified by the Researcher in the context of
financial aspects of the farmers.
1. Access to creditNon-availability of credit at reasonable rates is a persistent
problem for small farmers. Although rural borrowing from
institutional agencies has doubled in the last three decades,
the share of rural credit from non-institutional agencies is still
above 40 percent.
Farmers are in a vicious circle where lack of credit leads to lower
output and lower output lead to a loss of income, which in turn
pushes them out of the organized credit system.
Lack of access to credit from the organized banking system also
reduces the farmers chances of getting the best price because of
restrictions (explicit or implicit) on where he can sell his crop.Access to credit was a problem raised by a majority of small
farmer focus groups, although researchers were unable to
quantify the extent to which farmers lost in terms of price
realization. Researcher heard many contradictory responses as to
whether or not farmers were bonded and thus had to sell to a
specific trader, commission agent or moneylender who had
extended them credit earlier in the year.
Therefore, systemic deficiencies that lead to the exclusion
of small and marginal farmers from the organized credit system
are an issue that needs to be tackled to ensure high productivity
growth.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
23/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 343
2. Capacity for risk-taking
Farmers, in general, are naturally conservative. However, in order
for information to drive agricultural productivity, farmers must be
willing to try new strategies, which may include new farming
techniques. While the researcher found a small number who
were willing to make changes based on the information they
received via their mobile phones, there were some who expressed
reluctance to try new approaches even when they had access to
relevant information. The Researcher found that persuading small
farmers to adopt new seed varieties or farming methods often
requires a combination of approaches: repeated dissemination of
information, demonstration plots and farmer dialogues.
9.7 NEED FOR A UNIQUE INTERACTIVE MULTIMEDIA
BROADCASTING MECHANISM
After a thorough study based on the primary and secondary data, theResearcher arrived on a unique model which suggests the creation and
broadcast of Multimedia content related to topics which would arouse the
interest of the rural populace mainly in three targeted areas i.e. Education,
Agriculture & Health. The researcher suggests the adoption of a Mobile
broadband technology option MobiTech to facilitate the delivery of such
Multimedia content broadcasts to Mobile handled devices possessed by the
rural community. The researcher suggests the following multimedia content.
1. Multimedia Video CD on: The Animator and Rural Education
What is the new National Policy on ICT in Education? What
does it seek to do for educating illiterate villagers and
children out-of-school?
1. Arouse and educate everyone to live and work better.2. Womens education and empowerment.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
24/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 344
3. National Literacy Mission to remove illiteracy4. Non-formal Education for agriculture working children5. Health, Education and Productivity co-ordination for
improving the quality of life
6. Promote science and technology for better future especiallyby strengthening the poor in thought an action
Teaching-Learning techniques:
1. Role play (How to communicate with the supporting authoron one hand, and to communicate with the community,
VEC(Villagers Education Committee) the villager learners
on the other hand, etc)
2. Discussion: questions such as : why is womens educationnecessary? What is the meaning of womens empowerment?
Is the administrative set up of the whole structure of how
can it be used by the Animators? Etc.
3.
Evolving case-reporting and further discussion pointsthrough Animators interaction.
4. Using puppets for awareness building
Local resources for training:
1. Various groups of villagers (particularly women)2. Village Education Committee3. Village Panchayat4. Functionaries of Development Departments5. Professionals6. Natural and status leaders in the community.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
25/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 345
2. Multimedia Video CD on : Methods of Imparting Literacy and
Numeracy: Different Approaches
1. Literacy and numeracy as visualized
2. Formal and Non-formal methods
i. A) Difference between teaching- learning methods forvillagers and children
B) Formal Schooling
C) Informal and Non formal learning
D) Self learning
E) Participative learning and group techniques
F) Cultural contexts of learning
ii. The primer and the reader prepared by the State ResourceCentre for Non-formal Education, Maharashtra. (Each
lesson to be discussed with the animators for
(a) exposition of the structure of the lesson derived from
research on reading, (b) the value-orientation of the
lesson)
iii. Along with this process, pre-literacy material (Video CDcontent development) such as posters, charts, discussion-
pictures, etc. to be explained and its use demonstrated
iv. Use of co-literacy material(Video CD contentdevelopment) such as folder in particular cards, etc for
accelerating absorption of information and desire to read.
v. Methods of imparting numeracy based on theknowledge already acquired by villagers through daily
transactions and problems of living
vi. The Numeracy book prepared by the State Resourcecentre for Non-formal Education, Maharashtra (Each
lesson to be discussed and Video CD content
development).
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
26/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 346
3. Discussion of post-literacy and follow-up video programmes
in the above manner.
4. Preparation of Schedules (Weekly and monthly) for activities
in the Centre- based programme. Linkage of literacy
numeracy with social and cultural activities in monthly
programmes. Schedules and seasonal adjustments of
activities.
5. Evaluation of video CD contents with the help of villager
learners.
6. Stimulating Animators to prepare literacy numeracy
lessons, teachinglearning contents and followup contents
7. Preparation of video CD contents for literacy-numeracy
achievement tests.
3. Multimedia Video CD on : Health
1. Health for all as visualization in National policy on Health
i) The NLM objective of literacy leading to the Health for
All concept. (What is the meaning of Health? who is
this All? The ways to make it successful with the help of
locally available resources. The Animators role as a
communicator, coordinator and organizer in the health
matters) (Video CD content development)
ii) Health problems in the villages, with emphasis on women
and child-care: immunization, personal and community
hygiene, food supply, nutrition, water supply, sanitation,
environment and superstition. Use of tobacco and
narcotics. Addiction to drinking, Cancer causing eating-
habits.
2. Problem of epidemics; endemic diseases
3. The human body. Its structure and functions.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
27/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 347
4. Personal and social aspects of health. Growing and using health-
giving foods.
5. Health Services available in the villages
i) Primary Health Centre, sub-centersii) Health Workers: Doctor, ANM, CHGsiii) The Animator as stimulator for the participation of the
health personnel in AE activities.
6. General Health-oriented attitude (Video CD content
development)
i) Health-consciousness in the family and communityii) Organization of health-oriented programmes with
community involvement.
iii) Counteracting superstitions, irrational belief and treatmentof mental and physical illness by magic and sorcery. The
role of science-consciousness in this effort.
7. Problem of populations-limitation. Population education forvillagers, especially women
8. Physical fitness for the family: Division of labour, good exercise,and relaxation.
Local Resources:
1. Primary Health centers
2. Village Health Worker
3. Village Education Committee
4. Locally accepted medical professionals
5. Jan Shikshan Nilyam
6. Science teachers from local schools
7. Personnel of khadi & Village industries
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
28/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 348
4. Multimedia Video CD on: Status of Women
1. Indian cultural background, womens status in it. The efforts madeby great thinkers and social workers to change the situation (girls
education, marriage-act, etc) (Video CD content development)2. Educational backwardness, the problem caused by this
advantages of education (What kind of education? How? Why?)
3. Health problems of girls and women due to fasting, observancemeaningless rituals, etc.
4. Social problems: In all classes of the society: special problems ofdestitute women and widows.
5. Economic responsibility: cultural responsibility; householddrudgery; lack of information on (and skills in) use of science
and technology and ICT in daily life and in occupations.
6. Socialization of the girl-child; role ascription; social andfamilial barrters in womens empowerment and decision making.
Womens invisibility in economic and political activities.
Teaching-learning techniques:
1. Puppet plays
2. Folk-drama and folk songs (Video CD content
development)
3. Role play
4. Games
5. Free discussion with villagersboth men and women
6. Discussion with personnel of Development Departments
Local Resources:
1. Mahila Mandals2. Youth Clubs3. Village Panchayat4. Development Personnel5. Jan Shikshan Nilayam6. Local Leaders
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
29/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 349
5. Multimedia Video CD on : Legal Literacy
1. Rules, regulation and norms: Importance of these three as far asthe personal and social securities are concerned. Some important
laws and acts (land, inheritance, marriage, divorce, dowry, age of
marriage, MTP, accidents and compensation, house and land
ownership, labour laws, child labour, equal wages, etc) (Video
CD content development)
2. General court procedures: Paper and duplicate copies of thepapers, bail, registration of birth, marriage, and death, free legal
aid, lokanyalayas.
3. Fundamental rights given by the constitution to every citizen.Making of laws : state and central administrative structures,
elections, right to vote, etc. Local administration & its functions.
4. Police : the responsibilities and the rights of the citizen in policematters.
Teaching-learning techniques:1. Case-studies, newspaper reports; articles; photographs;
(Video CD content development)
2. Discussion with legal experts (especially on womens law)
3. Brain-storming session
Local Resources:
1. Visit to court2. Local lawyers3. Legal experts near village4. Local police authorities5. Panchayat Members6. Local MLA/MP (if possible)
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
30/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 350
6. Multimedia Video CD on : Scientific Literacy
1. Social and seasonal events and activities. Their origin. Relationwith natural phenomena.
2. Social and superstitions.3. A womans various rituals and their examination from the
standpoint of science and technology.
4. How should binoculars, microscopes, charts, map, news, etc beused in inculcating the scientific temper?
5. Everyday Science :i. Days nights and seasons : festivals related with the
seasons.
ii. Ecology; protection of environment.iii. Science in social forestry, horticultural, sericulture,
agriculture, floriculture, post-harvest technology, food-
processing, food preparation, etc. (According to local
contexts)
iv. Daily use of science and technology. Significance ofcommonly used terminology; electricity (Switch, bulb,
pin, plug wire, tube, socket, etc.), radio, TV, bus, truck,
tractor, pump, motor, train, photo, camera, doctor, X-ray,
operation, hospital, etc) (Video CD content development)
v. Technology for reducing womens drudgery (biogas,gobar gas, flour-mill, water pump, smokeless Chula, hot-
box, cookers, etc.) (Video CD content development)
vi. The structure and operation of machines used in daily life,repairs and maintenance; handymans jobs)
Teaching learning techniques:
1. Experiments: Air and water purification magic-tricks todemonstrate use of chemicals, principals of physics, etc.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
31/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 351
2. Discussing the solar system, the eclipse, the earth space-ships, etc. with the help of models and pictures.
3. Interaction with workers of Lok Vidnyan group.4. Interaction with technology groups/ organizations.5. Stories of deception by God-Men, Sadhus, Magic-healers
witch-doctors, etc. (Video CD content development)
6. Environmental observation & discussion.
Local Resources:
1. Teachers2. Doctors3. Village Panchayat4. Meeting village people cheated by sadhus5. Womens help group6. Youth centre7. Library (if any)8.
School-equipment
7. Multimedia Video CD on : Daily Affairs
1. General alertness and security in day-to-day affairs:i. Post-office procedures
ii. Banks (Saving, loans, other developmental schemes)iii. Co-operative movement (milk, land, house, fertilizers, etc)
2. Checking weights and measures. Consumer-protection.3. Daily house-keeping and accounts.4. Travel and transport (rates, rules, etc)5. Rationing, Groceries6. Different types of applications (how to write and send to and
through whom, etc.)
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
32/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 352
Teaching-learning techniques:
1. Visits to the nearby government and other concernedoffices.
2. Posters: Safe travel, rationing information, etc.3. Exhibitions, discussion informative folders. (Video CD
content development)
4. Visits and discussions with government officers, bankmanagers, etc.
Local Resources:
1. Officials, traders, knowledgeable person, etc2. The village Panchayat
8. Multimedia Video CD on : Responsible Parenthood
1. The role of parent and guardians, particularly the mother, in thechilds upbringing.
2. Child-development cognitive, affective, psycho-motor factors;linguistic skills; social skills. The role of the parents and the
community in the upbringing of a child. The community as a
socializer.
3.
Right and wrong beliefs about child- specialization (Punishment,
awards, expectations form a child, etc)
4. Spacing between two children, population control and familywelfare; decisions taken by women of the household and the
mother; community participation in this decision-making process,
the role of the Animator in this process.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
33/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 353
5. Education
Importance of girls education. Misconceptions about it.
(Animator should give the examples of well-educated women and
their success stories).
6. Playing with the children: songs, stories, small toys (how to makehome-toys for children), the role of the parents, parent training in
play-way methods of brining up children. Special attention to
girl-child. (Video CD content development)
7. The role of the parents in upbringing of the physically andmentally handicapped children.
8. Putting an end to sex-discrimination between boys and the girls.Scientific facts about male and female biology, intelligence,
physical, temperament, etc.
9. Anganwadis, Balwadis, Day-care centers, pre preschools.Teaching-learning techniques:
1. Role play2. Discussion with the experts3. Exhibitions and Discussion pictures4. Slide-show, audio-cassettes, Video-cassettes5. Discussion with health-personnelLocal Resources:
1. Village Panchayats2. Mahila Mandal3. Youth Club4. Teachers5. Preschool/Anganwadi/Balwadi6. Jan Shikshan Nilayams
Boys
Girls
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
34/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 354
9. Multimedia Video CD on : Recreation and Social Life
1. Importance of recreation and social life in day-to-day life(physical/ psychological/social), the present situation and
recreation (want of recreation and its disadvantages).2. How recreation increase the creative ability.3. Traditionally ways of rural recreation (for men and women),
Games, sports, athletics, yogasanas.
4. How to use traditional games of recreation in a new way.5. How the community can be a source of recreational activities.6. Mass media and folk-media as recreation7. Social and national values through recreation and social life
events
Teaching-learning techniques:
1. Getting acquainted with the festivals, songs, plays, folk-artand folk-media, Bhajani Mandals, etc. in the community
(Video CD content development)
2. Performance by local folk-artistes and womens groups.3. Traditional games4. Simple Yogasanas5. Audio-visual aids6. Performance by Animators and TrainersLocal Resources:
1. Local folk artistes2. Mahila Mandals3. Bhajani Mandals4. Youth clubs5. Village panchayat6. Schools (Primary, secondary)7. Libraries8. Gymnasia9. Jana Shikshan Nilayam
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
35/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 355
9.8 FUTURE PERSPECTIVES AND EXPECTATIONS OF THE
RURAL COMMUNITY
The interviewees stressed that for a true revolution to occur, farmers must be
able to get information delivered to them at a time and place of their choosing.
Mobile telephony, as our survey bears out, can be a powerful tool to help meet
this need. The survey, of course, has been more in the nature of an initial
impact study and a more rigorous assessment of the benefits of mobile
telephony with a much larger sample size is necessary to help provide policy
inputs. Nevertheless, it is indicative of the contribution that mobile telephony
can make towards improving not only agricultural productivity in the country
but also Rural Formal Education at large. The farmers benefit from the
introduction of mobile enabled information services is also borne out by the
increasing number of subscribers.
Over the course of the study, the researcher found a number of emerging ideas
and applications for mobile phones that showed potential for the future.
One example involved the use of camera phones to photograph crop
diseases/pest infestations and send them to experts immediately
(www.esagu.com). This visual information can improve diagnosis and advice
SMS messages are sent to users mobile phones every morning with the offers
and grades available for purchase on that day (www.smsone.com). At the end of
the day, users receive a text message with details of what actually took place.
9.9 RECOMMENDATIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
1. Since the rural areas still not covered are in very remote regions in thecontext of connectivity, the government should provide a higher subsidy
to the operators or else set up the telecom infrastructure in these areas
itself and then lease it out to operators. More projects need to be
implemented on a public private partnership basis, such as BOT (Build,
Operate, Transfer) since it will expedite the provision of telecomservices in the rural areas.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
36/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 356
2. All telecom stakeholders, including the government, operators,equipment vendors and local bodies, need to collaborate to tap this
market. Operators need to collaborate with companies in other
industries, such as financial services and consumer goods, to develop
innovative offerings and extend their traditional distribution channels.
Operators also need new marketing strategies and customized products
to tie up more rural subscribers.
3. 3G Proliferations will happen first in urban areas and slowly the servicewill penetrate the rural and remote regions as 3G applications suitable
for the rural perspective are yet to be developed. Another key barrier is
the high cost of handsets. Telecom companies should actively work on
some solutions so that handsets are available at affordable costs to the
rural consumer.
4. Despite rural teledensity having risen considerably over the past fewyears through the efforts of the government and private companies, the
urban-rural divide continues to widen. 3G is the technology likely to
expedite rural telephony. 3G uptake in rural areas will be based on the
mobile broadband connectivity offered in future.
Researcher also recommends that the various government functioning
arms, including Ministry of Information Bureau, and journalists can use
3G as a substitute to satellite phones. This can also be used for tele-medicine, tele-education, etc.
5. The industries, non-governmental agencies and private enterprisesshould provide the necessary equipment, infrastructure and supply of
ICDs (Information and Communication Devices) to facilitate ICT and
for effective teaching and learning in primary and secondary schools in
India.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
37/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 357
6. Companies, government and other international organization shouldprovide fund and take the social responsibility for providing ICT
equipments, computer systems and related programmes to improve the
poor state of instruction delivery in schools.
7. The government should post a minimum of three trained ICT expertsand technical teachers to the secondary schools to enable them make
effective use of the available ICI' equipment and seek the advice from
qualified teachers for effective implementation of the course curriculum.
8. Supervisors and inspectors from ministry of education should be sent forinspections and ascertaining the degree of utilization of the ICT
equipments and related programmes provided by the government and
other private organizations.
9. Computers, equipments, tools, gadgets provided by the governmentshould be installed in different locations will enable the teachers to use
ICT for teaching during the practical classes/demonstrations. The
rehabilitation of the secondary school buildings and provision of ICT
equipments and facilities should be carried out to improve the learning
environment.
10. The Researcher highly recommends the proven role of TelecomTechnology Options in promoting Rural Education (Basic Education,
Primary Health Awareness and Agricultural Information Updates).
9.10.1 Education
a) Distribution of multimedia contents to remote areas (CD-ROM,
video films).
b) Use of the videoconference system in classroomsc) Use of wireless mobile broadband for rural penetration
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
38/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 358
d) On-line access to the academic data bases and library information
e) Establishment of a telecommunications network designed
exclusively for exchanging e-mails and holding on-line dialogue-
style discussions with educational experts.
f) Broadcasting of educational programs on mobile (educational
contents, such as those on Basic education, agriculture
environment, Public health and science).
g) Submission of examination answers by using e-mail.
h) Supply of educational contents on Web sites.
9.10.2 Public Health and Medical Treatment
a) Broadcasting of primary health programs on mobile and
distribution of information on public health to rural medical
institutions like primary health center.
b) Distribution of information on prevention of diseases to ruralcommunities.
c) Input of patients data into a database for remote areas.
d) Access to medical experts through the remote consulting system.
e) Distance X-ray examination, distance ultrasonic-wave
examination, distance Electrocardiogram Monitoring, etc.
The Researcher would also like to propose certain schemes to
overcome the rural networking problems:
Necessary conditions for rural communication system
a. The system can be constructed at a low cost.b. It is desired that the system is flexible and can be expanded
easily.
c. The power source can be secured. (This is a major problem.)
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
39/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 359
The Systems that can be considered appropriate under ordinary
circumstances
a. To establish a multi-purpose center in the most conspicuousplace in the community (a Mobile System is also appropriate).
b. To create, according to the situation in each community, aone-way or interactive network by making the center the base
of the network.
c. To form a cable or wireless local loop as a network.d. To apply the mobile telecommunications technology to the
wireless network.
e. To use the wireless mobile broadband technology and VSATto the nearest telephone office.
The Researcher would also like to recommend the New Futuristic
Telecom Technologies
a. To establish the Internet Protocol (IP)-based network (IPtelephone).
b. Application of the IMT2000 (the third-generation mobilecommunications system) (WCDMA).
Further, the Researcher would also like to propose the following educational
model for the rural based education program:
It is estimated that in a village of 1500, one can earn a minimum of Rs.4500 per
month with these services.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
40/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 360
Education Model :
Basic computer course:-
SHISHU (6-9yrs): 6 hrs, BAL VIKAS (6-9 yrs), certified: 26 hrs, YUVA
(10-17yrs), certified: 20 hrs, TARUN (17+yrs), certified: 72 hrs
Mobile based 9th and 10th Std Online Test and Tutorial (TN):-
- Focused on passing exams- Mobile based Spoken English on video (TN)New multimedia options:-
MITRA English Programme, Childrens Club and Computer Graphics
Tutorial
Potential for Vocational Courses:-
Audio/video editing, Graphics and animation, Web development
9.11 MAIN FRAMEWORK FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF ICT
BASED RURAL EDUCATION PROGRAM:
9.12 THE RESEARCHER PROPOSES THE MOBITECHPROJECT FOR THE ICT BASED RURAL EDUCATION
PROGRAMME.
The objective of this Research is to help in finalizing the scope of the Mobile
Base Technology Solution for Indian Rural Farmers. It is necessary to keep
track of time and changes in technology. It is always a challenge to keep pace
with the ever-changing expectations of the farmers and end users amid new
ICT channels and technologies. Today farmers are aware of what they want.
They also have a variety of options. Now it has become important for the Rural
Farmers to understand their end customers better and use this understanding to
cultivate superior quality crops, agro-based products and services as per the
changing customer needs. This is to build abiding relationships, that extend
beyond the product/offering to the end users as well.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
41/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 361
It is also necessary to understand the competitors, customers and vendors
who already have started deploying such technologies to boost their sales
in the market.
Guidelines adopted for the MobiTech Project:
During our visit and detailed discussions with the Sarpanch/Mukhiya, the
research team focused on MobiTech solutions and carried out Preliminary
studies. While developing the solutions of MobiTech, two main criteria were
taken into account:
1. Farmers are located in remote areas where power is not available.2. No Technology infrastructure like Internet, PC, Server is available resulting
in communication problems.
Infrastructure requirements of MobiTech Project:
During our visit we had a meeting and detailed discussion to identify the key
features of MobiTech from the rural perspective:
Web enabled multimedia interface systems for providing basic education onMobile
Support for Basic Individual Health & Medication. Web based procurement & distribution of Agro based commodities. Web enabled updates of Weather and Crop Related Information Access to web based Agro Expert Consulting
Potential bottle necks for MobiTech implementation
Farmers are not educated Farmers are Poor and unaware of technology Acute Power Shortages No developments in village being in remote areas.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
42/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 362
Scope of the MobiTech Project:
Based on the understandings, the researcher focused on specific areas like
Web based MobiTech Solution system which gets integrated with the Weather
Forecasting, Food Index, Health and Insurance, Agro portals where by the
required information for theses specific villages (Buldhana/ Latur) could be
extracted and made available to the farmers.
Feasibility of Solution implementation:
The Researcher as discussed before identified 2 villages and worked with 50
farmers each for the pilot project. Upon successful implementation, the
MobiTech Solution can become a National Model. The solution provides a
competitive edge and enables MobiTech to be the first Web based solution that
integrates
50 Farmers from village Rameshwar, District Latur, Maharashtra
50 Farmers from village Kurkheda, Taluka Shegaon, District Buldhana,
Maharashtra
The farmers in this project are using Java Enabled phones which has a facility
of Support GPRS, GIS Technologies and selection of local language. These
Mobile Handsets will be useful for them to get used with the technology.
Considering the power shortage, the researcher has identified Mobile Sets
which have Solar Charging batteries capacity. As a Pilot project the Researcher
will try to cover the following areas in the Feasibility Study of Implementation:
1. Providing basic education of Mobile Operations.2. Providing Health Information to Individual Farmer/Family Members3. Crop Information and preventive measures.4. Mobile based Agro Information and awareness programme during
Lunch/Dinner Time
5. Import / Export related information (BajarBhav) on agriculturalcommodities.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
43/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 363
The information flow in MobiTech will only be through the mobile handset and
Servers located at district levels using SMS, MMS and Video Transmission
Technology whereby the Farmers can get continuous feeds from the main
server. The data related to their farming will be kept on servers and time to
time information about crops, soil condition, weather condition will be stored,
updated and Broadcasted at regular intervals. This information will be useful
for the Farmer as well as the Agro exporter who will be working remotely
through MobiTech.
9.13 PROPOSED SOLUTION FOR RURAL EDUCATION
MANAGEMENT
Figure 9.2 PROPOSED SOLUTION FOR RURAL EDUCATION MANAGEMENT
Buldhana
district
Mobile UsersMIT Pune
Latur District
Mobile Users
Internet
Third party
Server
Centralized InformationApproval from any location
Health Education
Agro Education
Bringing Farms Together by
Uplifting them economically
Co-Op Banks,
Fertilizer Dealers,
Agro Expert,
Finance, Weather
Forecasting
Internet
Internet
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
44/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 364
9.14 RECOMMENDATIONS PUT FORTH BEFORE THE POLICY
MAKERS AND REGULATORY AUTHORITIES OF INDIA
Policy thrust - A Rural ICTEducation programme should be initiatedby the government committed to the following:
1. Develop and sustain a modern information and communicationtechnology to support private sector-driven growth and economic
development and to improve the quality of life and reduce the level of
poverty significantly.C3
2.
Improve access to internet connectivity, and raise the level of mobileand computer usage and literacy.
3. Facilitate the development of a national multimedia super corridor,including provision of appropriate incentives for private sector
involvement.
4. Aggressively promote information and communications technology asan instrument of mass education, growth, and rural development.
Targets - Rural ICT Education programme should set the following
targets:
1. More increase in telephone density to one telephone per 5 people.2. Make telecommunication accessible to a wider range of Indians,
regardless of where they live.
3. Develop a national communications and telecommunication backbone,inducing a national multimedia super corridor.
Strategies - Rural ICT Education programme should adopt the
following strategies :
1. Use a combination of fiscal and financial incentives to encourage privatesector investment in service provision in the industry.
C3
2. Enforce intellectual property rights, and property entrepreneurship,training, and partnerships.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
45/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 365
3. Pursue a local content policy in the manufacture of electrical andelectronic' equipment and communications and telecommunications
equipment, including handsets, accessories, and components.
4. Facilitate access to special financial support through co-operative banks,SIDBI, IDBI and other institutions, for private sector-driven wireless
telephone and internet connectivity development in rural areas.
5. Foster an enabling environment for developing software and hardwarecapacity.
6. Provide incentives to develop industrial parks in informationcommunications technology.
9.15 CONCLUSIONS
1. The Indian web based distant learning market is slated to grow to Rs.1,092 crores by 2012.
2. Low mobile penetration and relatively higher IT costs have contributedto a rural-urban divide.
3. The government's focus area should be to shore up IT infrastructure inrural areas, while at the same time bringing service costs down. This
will help in the free flow of knowledge from qualified urban
academicians to the needy rural knowledge seekers.
4. Future telecom technology options for the Indian Rural Education canbe e-Learning 2.0 which has the potential to transform the learning
environment from the prevalent "instructional" mode to more interactive
and participative mode.
5. Resources pointed out that information and communication technologyas well as, all that is involved in gathering and processing information
using modern communication technologies such as computers, mobiles
and other related equipments, generated services that can reach all at
reasonable cost and in proper time to the overall benefit of mankind.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
46/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 366
6. The training of rural youth in the schools is aimed at equipping themwith useful skills and at improving the knowledge in their desired areas
of study. To facilitate effective training of the rural youth in acquiring
knowledge and skills, it should be the desire of the government to
integrate ICT in the rural education systems.
9.16 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
ICT in Rural Education Perspective:
1. The present application of Information and Communication technology(ICT) to all the activities of the world confirmed the fact that the use of
ICT is becoming an indispensable tool for modern advancement in
knowledge and skills. With the present day computerizations of the
activities in education, the focus is now on introduction of ICT in
schools at all levels.
2.
The inclusion of ICT in Indian education and the National Policy onEducation is highly necessary as we launch into the new millennium and
targeting the millennium development goals.
3. As a telephonic device, the mobile enables access to information sourcesthat may not otherwise be reachable. As an information platform to
receive SMS, menu or voice message information, mobiles provides the
ability to get connected to new knowledge and information sources for
rural education not previously available with the possibility of real-time,
highly tailored information delivery.
4. There is so much that a teacher has to learn to become competent in theuse of ICT for teaching tasks. There is also the prospect of having to
keep up with developments in technology.
5. ICT teacher training should be considered as a continuing process, withthe need for continuing support. The initial training may take place as
part of pre-service training, or it could be part of in-service training.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
47/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 367
6. Teachers must believe that the benefits of ICT for student improvementand teacher fulfillment have been proven through academically justified
studies.
7. The teacher training agencies must concentrate on providingcompetency-based training to the teachers to enable them in acquiring
the technology competencies.
8. Even at this early stage, mobile phones are being used in Indianagriculture and are starting to improve the rural literacy, an impact that
is enhanced by the new mobile-enabled information services. The most
common benefit of mobile telephony found in the research was derived
from the use of mobile phones as a basic communications tool for
educating the rural masses.
ICT in Agricultural Sector Perspectives:
1. The customers are not fully informed about the existing services andvarious facilities under these services. Creating awareness among
farmers regarding the range of services provided may help the service
providers to increase their subscriber base.
2. Greater customization and frequent updating add substantial value.Generic information triggers dissatisfaction and reduces the frequency
with which farmers access the service. The most frequent criticism one
may feel or hear is that information is old and routine.
3. Text messaging offers significant advantage over voice-based deliveryin terms of convenience and content flexibility. Wherever literacy is a
concern, 3G enabled mobile video broadband service is the only answer.
4. Information should be in the local language and easy to understand. Fewof the farmers the researcher interviewed were prepared to pay for
information services as long as they felt that they would get the
information they wanted in a timely and reliable manner.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
48/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 368
5. Policy changes may also be needed to encourage better access to high-quality inputs and credit for small farmers. Increased extension services
and capacity-building efforts can complement information dissemination
via mobile phones and associated services to accelerate the adoption of
new techniques.
6. Social networks may play an important role in building the trust andconfidence required to influence the adoption of new mindsets and
actions by small farmers. Additionally, basic information will need to be
supplemented by a range of other activities such as demonstrations and
broader communication efforts.
7. However, even in the case of poor farmers facing significant constraints,researcher found that there were still opportunities to realize
productivity gains from the adoption of new farming practices and
actions to mitigate crop losses. There were, in addition to economic
benefits, safety benefits and enhanced quality of life from decreased
isolation and vulnerability.
9.17 MANTRA FOR FUTURE OF THE INDIAN RURAL
EDUCATION
To solve the problems of Power Cut-Off, Huge Transportation Costs, Difficulty
in Backhaul Connectivity, Lack of Infrastructure Sharing, High Operation and
Maintenance cost, Low ARPU and Literacy Levels, wireless broadband mobile
technology is the only solution, in the true sense.
Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education based on 3G
technology enabled solar-powered handsets, providing a Mobile
Multimedia Learning (MM-Learning) environment, can offer a perfect
knowledge delivery mechanism suitable for enriching the lives of rural
masses with features of access ANYWHERE, ANYTIME, ANYBODY.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
49/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 369
NOTES AND REFERENCES:
A) Newspaper Articles:
1. A pro-people agenda in telecom TK Arun ; Thursday June 18, 2009,07:17 AM
2. Next ICT wave will optimize life-styles: Padma Warrior; 11 Nov 2009,1621 hrs IST, PTI
3. Can telecom story remain intact?; 16 Dec 2009, 0535 hrs IST, AshwaniWindlass
4. Government of India plans to launch SME helpline; 14 Jul 2009, 1856hrs IST, ECONOMIC TIMES.COM
5. Technology for rural India; 13 Mar 2008, 0232 hrs IST, Kiran Karnik,6. Rural connect: The cooperative way; 15 Jun 2006, 0213 hrs IST, Mohan
Mishra,
7. VidyaGyan: A New Model for Improving Rural Education?; Published:December 17, 2009 in India
8.
It is about Education in Rural Areas; How to take browser basededucation to rural areas
9. Virtual Bus Research Project Description-- Another REVA genome;Thursday, 16. April 2009, Warana Wired Village, Kolhapur,
Maharashtra
10. Impact of ICT on Poverty Alleviation in Rural Pondicherry (India);Project Leader: S. Senthilkumaran.Pandit,
11. Ambika. "Tsunami villages reach out, via ICT." The Times of India.July 11, 2005.
12. Arunachalam, Subbiah. Reaching the unreached: What role can ICTsplay in rural development? Media Lab Asia, New Delhi. (paper
presented at the Asian Regional Conference of UN ICT Task Force on
April 25, 2002)
13. Establish knowledge centres in villages: Kalam; Business Line, NewDelhi , March 7
http://my.opera.com/abhishekshankar/blog/2009/04/16/virtual-bus-research-project-description-another-reva-genomemailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://my.opera.com/abhishekshankar/blog/2009/04/16/virtual-bus-research-project-description-another-reva-genome -
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
50/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
General Fellowship ICSSR, MHRD, Government of India 370
14. Exit PC, enter Mobile: Thomas K Thomas; Business Line : Monday,Nov 16, 2009
15. Telecom: A revolution in progress: T. H. Chowdary; Business Line :Wednesday, May 17, 2006
16. Harnessing IT for Indias growth; 13 Jul 2009, 0145 hrs IST, RajanAnandan,
17. Social sector offers Rs 10k-cr business to IT sector: Study; 14 Dec 2009,0114 hrs IST, N Shivapriya ET Bureau- ET
18. Rural Telecom, The Cable Way.; 17 Jan.2006, 0330 hrs IST,RajeshKalra.
B) Research Articles:
1. S. Cisler,Planning for Sustainability: How to Keep Your ICT ProjectRunning; available from http://www2.ctcnet.org/ctc/Cisler/sustain.doc;
accessed 4 August 2002.
2. International Society for Technology in Education. 2000. NationalEducational Technology Standards for Teachers. International Society
for Technology in Education (ISTE). Eugene, Oregon, USA. [Online].
Available: http://www.iste.org [2002, January 24].
3. Teacher Training Agency. 2002. Information and CommunicationsTechnology (ICT). Teacher Training Agency, London, UK. [Online].
Available:http://www.canteach.gov.ukinfo/ ict/index.htm [2002,
January 24].The British Computer Society. 2002. Home Page of The
British Computer Society, Swindon, UK. [Online]. Available:
http://www.bcs.org.uk [2002, January 24].
4. The Qualifications and Curriculum Authority. 2002. Home Page of TheQualifications and Curriculum Authority (QCA). London, UK. [Online].
Available: http://www.qca.org.uk/ [2002, January 24].
5. UNESCO Institute for Information Technologies in Education. 2000.Informatics for Primary Education. UNESCO Institute for InformationTechnologies in Education, Moscow.
-
7/31/2019 Report chapter on Recommendation and policies
51/51
Regional Study of Telecom Technology Options for Indian Rural Education
C) Websites:
1. www.itu.int2. www.ictineducation.org3. www.icrier.org4. www.airtel.in5. www.bsnl.co.in6. www.mtnl.net.in7. www.ideacellular.com8. www.vodafone.in9. www.rcom.co.in10. www.tataindicom.com11. www.shyamtelecom.com12. www.nokia.co.in13. www.motorola.com