Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

download Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

of 63

Transcript of Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    1/63

    RESEARCH PROJECT

    On

    Relationship between Exchange rate and Stock Indices

    Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for MBA

    Degree of Bangalore University

    BY

    Girija K N

    Registration Number

    05XQCM6026

    Under the guidance of

    Dr. Nagesh Malavalli

    M.P. Birla Institute of Management

    Associate Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan

    Bangalore-5600012005-2007

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    2/63

    2

    DECLARATION

    I hereby declare that the research project titled Dynamic

    Relationship between Exchange rate and Stock Indicesis prepared under

    the guidance of Dr. Nagesh Malavalli in partial fulfillment of MBA degree

    of Bangalore University, and is my original work.

    This project does not form a part of any report submitted for

    degree or diploma under Bangalore University or any other university.

    Place: Bangalore Girija K. N.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    3/63

    3

    GUIDES CERTIFICATE

    I hereby declare that the research work embodied in this

    dissertation entitled Dynamic Relationship between Exchange rates and

    Stock Indices has been undertaken and completed by Ms Girija K.N. under

    my guidance and supervision.

    I also certify that she has fulfilled all the requirements under the

    covenant governing the submission of dissertation to the Bangalore

    university for the award of MBA Degree.

    Place: Bangalore Dr. Nagesh MalavalliDate: Research Guide

    MPBIM, Bangalore

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    4/63

    4

    PRINCIPALS CERTIFICATE

    This is to certify that Ms. Girija K. N., bearing Registration No:

    05XQCM6026 has done a research project on Dynamic relationship

    between Exchange Rates and Stock Indicesunder the guidance of

    Dr. Nagesh Malavalli, M P Birla Institute of Management, Bangalore.

    This has not formed a basis for the award of any degree/diploma for any

    other university.

    Place: Bangalore Dr. N. S. MALLAVALLIDate: PRINCIPAL

    MPBIM, Bangalore

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    5/63

    5

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

    I am thankful to Dr. N. S. Malavalli, Principal, M.P.Birla

    institute of management, Bangalore, who has given his valuable support

    during my project.

    I am extremely thankful to Prof. T. V. Narasimha Rao,

    M.P.Birla institute of Management, Bangalore, who has guided me to do this

    project by giving valuable suggestions and advice.

    Finally, I express my sincere gratitude to all my friends and well

    wishers who helped me to do this project.

    Girija K. N.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    6/63

    6

    Table of Contents

    Chapter No. Particulars Page number

    I Introductiono Backgroundo Purpose of the studyo Problem statemento Objectives of the studyo Hypothesiso Limitations of the studyo Theoretical frame work

    09-22

    II Review of Literatureo Theoretical literatureo Empirical literature

    23-27

    III Data analysis andInterpretation

    28-50

    IV DISCUSSIONS ANDCONCLUSIONS

    51-55

    V BIBLIOGRAPHY 56-58

    VI ANNEXURE 59-64

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    7/63

    7

    List of tables

    Table number Particulars Page no

    1 Global Forex Turnover 17

    2 Constituents of BSE 32

    3 Constituents of NSE 33

    4 Unit root test NSE 38

    5 Unit root test Exchange rate 39

    6 Unit root test BSE 40

    7 Test for distribution BSE 44

    8 Test for distribution Exchange 45

    9 Test for distribution Nifty 46

    10 Test for co integration 50

    11 Regression BSE and Exchange 59

    12 Regression NSE and Exchange 60

    13 Stationarity test BSE 61

    14 Stationarity test NSE 62

    15 Stationarity test Exchange rate 64

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    8/63

    8

    Executive Summary

    Stock market and foreign exchange market are the barometers of the Economy

    and both the markets are sensitive segments of the economy. Any changes in the policies

    of the country are quickly reflected in these markets. There are different factors, which

    affect the stock markets like interest rates, company performance, future growth

    prospects, inflation, political stability, exchange rates etc. There are different factors,

    which affect the Exchange rates are like the flow of capital between nations, inflation,

    interest rates, faith in government's ability to protect the value of currency, speculation

    etc.

    But in this era of financial integration, there is a lot of movement of funds between

    the markets and have ushered in a sea change in the financial architecture of the Indian

    economy.

    This study attempts to analyze the interlinkages between exchange rates and stock

    prices. The study is conducted by considering exchange rates and various indices form

    2001 to 2006. This is analyzed by using statistical tools like Augmented Dickey Fuller

    Test and Johnsons Co-integration test by taking 4 day lag. From the results it is clear that

    there is no significant relationship between the exchange rates and index values.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    9/63

    9

    CHAPTER I

    INTRODUCTION

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    10/63

    10

    Introduction

    Globalization and financial liberalization in India have brought about battery of

    changes in the financial functioning of the economy, as a result of which, the resultant

    gain of the global integration of domestic and foreign financial markets has thrown open

    new opportunities but at the same time exposed the financial system to significant risks.

    Consequently, it is important to understand the mutual relationship between the

    financial markets from the standpoint of financial stability. Though the inception of the

    financial sector reforms has taken place initiated in the beginning of the 1990s,

    particularly since 1997, there has been a dramatic change in the functioning of thefinancial sector of the economy.

    The recent emergence of new capital markets, the relaxation of foreign capital

    controls and the adoption of more flexible exchange rate regimes have increased the

    interest of academics and practitioners in studying the interactions between the stock and

    foreign exchange markets. The gradual abolition of foreign exchange controls in

    emerging economies like India has opened the possibility of international investment and

    portfolio diversification. At the same time, the adoption of more flexible exchange

    rate regimes by these countries in the late 1980's and early 1990's has increased the

    volatility of foreign exchange markets and the risk associated with such investments.

    The advent of floating exchange rates, opening up of current account,

    Liberalization of capital account, reduction of customs duties, the development of 24-

    hour screen based global trading, the increased use of national currencies outside the

    country of issue and innovations in internationally traded financial products have led tothe cross Country linkages of capital markets and international integration of domestic

    economy.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    11/63

    11

    Altogether, the whole gamut of institutional reforms, introduction of new

    instruments, change in procedures, widening of network of participants, call for a

    reexamination of the relationship between the stock market and the foreign sector of

    India.

    The process of economic liberalization and thrust on reforms in the financial sector

    and the foreign exchange market in particular that was initiated in India in early nineties

    has resulted into increasing integration of the Indian FX market with that of the global

    markets. With a large number of foreign funds and foreign institutional investors now

    actively participating in the Indian financial markets (foreign exchange reserves standing

    at about USD118 bn), the style of functioning of the market itself has undergone a lot of

    change and result of microstructure changes are visible. Today the Indian FX market,

    which was insulated from outside impacts, has been getting integrated with the world

    markets.

    In the present scenario, interesting results are emerging particularly for the

    developing countries where the markets are experiencing new relationships between

    money markets, forex markets, capital markets, international events, oil prices, WTO

    agreements etc which were not perceived earlier. The analysis on stock markets is

    important as it is considered as the most sensitive segment of the economy and through

    this segment the countrys exposure to the outer world is most readily felt. The impact of

    fluctuation in exchange rate on domestic companies, companies

    importing or exporting and on multi national corporations with the degree of exposure is

    increasing in each case respectively. The movements in exchange rate indirectly affect

    the value and hence the stock prices of these companies. The value of the company is

    affected due to the forex exposures namely Transaction exposures, translation exposure

    and economic exposure.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    12/63

    12

    An exchange rate has two effects on stock prices, a direct effect through Multi

    National Firms and an indirect effect through domestic firms. In case of Multi National

    Firms involved in exports, a change in rate will change the demand of its product in the

    international market, which ultimately reflects in its B/S as profit or loss. Once the profit

    or loss is declared, the stock price will also change for a domestic firm.

    On the other hand, currency devaluation could either raise or decrease a firms stock

    prices. This depends on the nature of the firms operations. A domestic firm that exports

    part of its output will benefit directly from devaluation due to an increase in demand for

    its output. As higher sales result in higher profits, local currency devaluation will cause

    firm stock price to rise in general.

    On the other hand, if the firm is a user of imported inputs, currency devaluation will

    raise cost and lower profits. Thus, it will decrease the firms stock price.

    Exchange Rate:

    The Exchange rate or FX rate is the rate between two currencies specifies how

    much one currency is worth in terms of the other. For example an exchange rate of 33

    Indian Rupees (IND, Rs.) to the United States Dollar (USD, $) means that IND 33 is

    worth the same as USD 1. The foreign exchange market is one of the largest markets in

    the world. By some estimates, about 2 trillion USD worth of currency changes hands

    every day.

    The Spot exchange rate refers to the current exchange rate. The forward

    exchange rate refers to an exchange rate that is quoted and traded today but for delivery

    and payment on a specific future date.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    13/63

    13

    Quotations

    An exchange rate quotation is given by stating the number of units of a price

    currency that can be bought in terms of 1 unit currency (also called base currency). In

    a quotation that says the JPN/USD exchange rate is 120 (USD per JPN), the price

    currency is USD and the unit currency is JPN.

    Quotes

    Direct quote is a quote using a countrys home currency as the price currency (e.g.,Rs.33

    = $ 1 in India) and is used by most countries.

    Indirect quote is a quote using a countrys home currency as the unit currency (e.g, $

    0.03 = Rs. 1 in India) and is used in British newspapers and are also common in

    Australia, New Zealand and Canada.

    Appreciation/depreciation of currency:

    While using direct quotation, if the home currency is strengthening (i.e.,

    appreciating, or becoming more valuable) then the exchange rate number decreases.

    Conversely if the foreign currency is strengthening, the exchange rate number increases

    and the home currency is depreciating.

    Exchange rate regime:

    The exchange rate regime is the way a country manages its currency in respect to

    foreign currencies and the foreign exchange market. It is closely related to monetary

    policy and the two are generally dependent.

    A floating exchange rate or a flexible exchange rate is a type of exchange rate

    regime wherein a currency's value is allowed to fluctuate according to the foreign

    exchange market. A currency that uses a floating exchange rate is known as a floating

    currency.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    14/63

    14

    A pegged float is pegged to some band or value, either fixed or periodically

    adjusted. Pegged floats are Crawling bands, Crawling pegs and Pegged with horizontal

    bands.

    A fixed rate is that rate that have direct convertibility towards another currency.

    Here, the currency is backed one to one by foreign reserves.

    Foreign Exchange Market:

    The foreign exchange market exists wherever one currency is traded for another.

    It is by far the largest market in the world, in terms of cash value traded, and includes

    trading between large banks, central banks, currency speculators, multinational

    corporations, governments, and other financial markets and institutions. The trade

    happening in the forex markets across the globe currently exceeds US$1.9 trillion/day (on

    average). Retail traders (individuals) are currently a very small part of this market and

    may only participate indirectly through brokers or banks.

    The foreign exchange market provides the physical and institutional structure

    through which the money of one country is exchanged for that of another country, the

    rate of exchange between currencies is determined, and foreign exchange transactions are

    physically completed.

    The retail market for foreign exchange deals with transactions involving travelers

    and tourists exchanging one currency for another in the form of currency notes or

    travelers cheques. The wholesale market often referred to as the interbank market is

    entirely different and the participants in this market are commercial banks, corporations

    and central banks.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    15/63

    15

    Functions of foreign exchange market:

    The foreign exchange market is the mechanism by which participants

    Transfer purchasing power between countries,

    Obtain or provide credit for international trade transactions, and

    Minimize exposure to the risks of exchange rate changes

    Foreign Exchange Market participants:

    The foreign exchange market consists of two tiers:

    the interbank or wholesale market and

    the client or retail market.

    Five broad categories of participants operate within these two tiers:

    Bank and nonblank foreign exchange dealers:

    Banks and a few nonblank foreign exchange dealers operate in both the interbank

    and client markets. They profit from buying foreign exchange at a bid price and

    reselling it at a slightly higher ask price. Dealers in the foreign exchange departments oflarge international banks often function as market makers.

    Currency trading is quite profitable for commercial and investment banks. Small

    to medium sized banks are likely to participate but not as market makers in the interbank

    market. Instead of maintaining significant inventory positions, they buy from and sell to

    large banks to offset retail transactions with their own customers.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    16/63

    16

    Individuals and firms conducting commercial or investment

    Transactions:

    Importers and exporters, international portfolio investors, Multi National

    Enterprises, tourists, and others use the foreign exchange market to facilitate execution of

    commercial or investment transactions. Some of these participants use the market to

    hedge foreign exchange risk.

    Speculators and arbitragers:

    Speculators and arbitragers seek to profit from trading in the market itself. They

    operate in their own interest, without a need or obligation to serve clients or to ensure a

    continuous market. A large proportion of speculation and arbitrage is conducted on

    behalf of major banks by traders employed by those banks. Thus banks act both as

    exchange dealers and as

    speculators and arbitrages.

    Central banks and treasuries:

    Central bank and treasuries use the market to acquire or spend their countrys

    foreign exchange reserves as well as to influence the price at which their own currency istraded. They may act to support the value of their own currency because of policies

    adopted at the national level or because of commitments entered into through

    membership in joint float agreements.

    Foreign exchange brokers:

    Foreign exchange brokers are agents who facilitate trading between dealers.

    Brokers charge small commission for the service provided to dealers. They maintain

    instant access to hundreds of dealers world wide via open telephone lines.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    17/63

    17

    Foreign exchange transactions

    Transactions within the foreign exchange market are executed either on a spot

    basis, requiring settlement two days after the transaction, or on a forwardorswap basis,

    which requires settlement at some designated future date.

    To be successful in the foreign exchange markets, one has to anticipate price

    changes by keeping a close eye on world events and currency fluctuations.

    Global foreign exchange market turnover:

    Components are:

    $621 billion in spot

    $1.26 trillion in derivatives

    $208 billion in outright forwards

    $944 billion in forex swaps

    $107 billion in FX options

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    18/63

    18

    Factors affecting Exchange rates:

    The prime factor that affects currency prices are supply and demand forces. The

    three factors include:

    Economic factors:

    Government budget deficits or surpluses

    Balance of trade levels and trends

    Inflation levels and trends

    Economic growth and health

    Political conditions:

    Political upheaval and political instability

    Relation between two countries

    Market psychology:

    Flights to quality

    Long-term trends

    Economic numbers

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    19/63

    19

    Stock Exchange:

    A stock market is a market for the trading of company stock and derivatives of

    same; both of these are securities listed on a stock exchange as well as those only traded

    privately.

    Functions of stock exchanges:

    Most important source for companies to raise money

    Provides liquidity to the investors

    Acts as clearing house for transactions

    Provides realistic value of companies

    India has 22 stock exchanges and the important stock exchanges are Bombay Stock

    Exchange and National Stock exchange at Mumbai. Established in 1875 BSE is one of

    the oldest stock exchanges in Asia and has seen significant development ever since.

    The regulatory agency which oversees the functioning of stock markets is the

    Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), which is also located in Bombay.

    Classification of financial markets

    i) Unorganized Markets

    In these markets there a number of money lenders, indigenous bankers, traders

    etc. who lend money to the public.

    ii) Organized Market

    In organized markets, there are standardized rules and regulations governing their

    financial dealings. There is also a high degree of institutionalization and

    instrumentalization. These markets are subject to strict supervision and control by the

    RBI or other regulatory bodies.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    20/63

    20

    Organized markets can be further divided into capital market and Money market.

    Capital market

    Capital market is a market for financial assets which have a long or definite

    maturity.

    Which can be further divided into

    Industrial Securities Market

    Government Securities Market

    Long Term Loans Market

    Industrial Securities Market

    It is a market where industrial concerns raise their capital or debt by issuing

    appropriate Instruments. It can be subdivided into two. They are:

    Primary Market or New Issues Market

    Primary market is a market for new issues or new financial claims. Hence, it is also

    called as New Issues Market. The primary market deals with those securities which are

    issued to the public for the first time.

    Secondary Market or Stock Exchange

    Secondary market is a market for secondary sale of securities. In other words,

    securities which have already passed through the new issues market are traded in this

    market.

    Such securities are listed in stock exchange and it provides a continuous and regular

    market for buying and selling of securities. This market consists of all stock exchanges

    recognized by the government of India.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    21/63

    21

    Importance of Capital Market

    Absence of capital market serves as a deterrent factor to capital formation and

    economic growth. Resources would remain idle if finances are not funneled through

    capital market.

    It serves as an important source for the productive use of the economys

    savings.

    It provides incentives to saving and facilitates capital formation by offering

    suitable rates of interest as the price of the capital

    It provides avenue for investors to invest in financial assets.

    It facilitates increase in production and productivity in the economy and thus

    enhances the economic welfare of the society.

    A healthy market consisting of expert intermediaries promotes stability in the

    value of securities representing capital funds.

    It serves as an important source for technological up gradation in the industrial

    sector by utilizing the funds invested by the public.

    The major stock indices also have a correlation with the currency rates. Three major

    forces affect the indices:

    1) Corporate earnings, forecast and actual;

    2) Interest rate expectations and

    3) Global considerations.

    Consequently, these factors channel their way through the local currency.

    In an increasingly complex scenario of the financial world, it is of paramount

    importance for the researchers, practitioners, market players and policy makers to

    understand the working of the economic and the financial system and assimilate themutual interlinkages between the stock and foreign exchange markets in forming their

    expectations about the future policy and financial variables. The analysis of dynamic and

    strategic interactions between stock and foreign exchange market came to the forefront

    because these two markets are the most sensitive segments of the financial system and are

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    22/63

    22

    considered as the barometers of the economic growth through which the countrys

    exposure towards the outer world is most readily felt.

    The present study is an endeavor in this direction. Before going to discuss further

    about the interlinkages between the stock and foreign exchange market, it is better to

    highlight the evolutions and perspectives that are associated with both the markets since

    liberalization in the Indian context.

    In the literature, there is theoretical consensus neither on the existence of

    relationship between stock prices and exchange rates nor on the direction of relationship.

    In theory there are two approaches to exchange rate determination. They are-

    Flow oriented- are considered as the traditional approach and assume that the exchange

    rate is determined largely by countrys current account or trade balance performance. The

    model posits that changes in exchange rates affect international competitiveness and trade

    balance, thereby influencing real economic variables such as real income and output

    (Dornbusch and Fisher, 1980). This model represents a positive relationship between

    stock prices and exchange rates with direction of causation running from exchange rates

    to stock prices.

    Stock-oriented - models put much emphasis on the role of financial (formerly capital)

    account in the exchange rate determination. These Models can be distinguished as

    portfolio balance models and monetary models (Branson and Frankel, 1983). They

    postulate a negative relationship between stock prices and exchange rates and come to the

    conclusion that stock prices have an impact on exchange rates.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    23/63

    23

    CHAPTER II

    LITERATURE SURVEY

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    24/63

    24

    Literature survey:

    The possible interlinkages between stock prices and exchange rates suggested by

    several arguments/hypothesis, particularly those identified in goods market approaches

    explaining likely impact of exchange rate on stock prices and portfolio balance

    approaches for justifying impact in reverse direction.

    The arguments provided in goods market approaches flow that,

    as many companies borrow in foreign currencies to fund their operations, a change in

    exchange rate affects the cost of funds and value of earnings of many firms, which in turn

    affect the competitiveness of a firm and its stock prices a depreciation (appreciation) of

    local currency makes exporting goods more (less) attractive to foreigners, which resultsin increase (decrease) of foreign demand for goods, which in turn raises (reduces) the

    revenue of the firm, value of firms appreciates(depreciates) and thus stock prices increase

    (decrease).

    The sensitivity of an importing firm to a change in exchange rate is just opposite

    to that of an exporting firm. Therefore, on a macro basis the impact of exchange rate

    fluctuations on stock market seems to depend on both the importance of a countrys

    international trade in its economy and the degree of the trade imbalance.

    To complete the linkage, influence in reverse direction can be justified by

    portfolio balance approaches under the exchange rate regime that allows exchange rate

    to be determined by market mechanism (i.e. the demand and supply conditions). A

    glooming stock market would attract capital flows from foreign investors, which may

    cause an increase in the demand for a countrys currency. Thus, local currency

    appreciates.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    25/63

    25

    The reverse would happen in case of fallen stock prices where the investors would

    try to sell their stocks to avoid further losses and would convert their money in to foreign

    currency to move out of the country. There would be demand for foreign currency in

    exchange of local currency. As a result rising (declining) stock prices would lead to an

    appreciation (depreciation) in local currency.

    Moreover, foreign investment in domestic equities could increase over time due

    to benefits of international diversification that foreign investors would gain.

    Further more, movements in stock prices may influence exchange rates (and

    money demand) because investors wealth (and liquidity demand) could depend on the

    performance of the stock market.

    Empirical results:

    Yamini Karmarkar and G Kawadia tried to investigate the relationship between

    RS/$ exchange rate and Indian stock markets. Five composite indices and five sectoral

    indices were studied over the period of one year: 2000. the results indicated that

    exchange rate has high correlation with the movement of stock markets.

    Ajayi, R A and Mongone M (1996) applied Error Correction Model for the two

    variables namely; stock indices and exchange rates to simultaneously estimate the short

    and long run dynamics of the variables. The tests revealed significant short and long run

    feedback relations between the two financial markets.

    Abhay Pethe and Ajit Karnik (2000), Basabi Bhattacharya and Jaydeep

    Mukherjee (2002), Golaka C Nath and GP Samanta (1999), Naeem Muhammad and

    Abdul Rasheed (2002) by applying the techniques of unit root tests, cointegration and

    long run Granger non-causality test, tested the causal relationships between stock market

    index and exchange rate for India. The results show no long or short run association

    between stock prices and exchange rates for India.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    26/63

    26

    Richard A Ajayi, Joseph Friedman and Seyed M Mehdian (1998) employed

    monthly and quarterly data on a set of advanced and emerging economies from 1973-

    1983 to examine the relationship between real stock return differentials and changes in

    real exchange rates.

    Findings provided evidence to indicate unidirectional causality, in the Granger

    sense; between the stock and currency markets in all the advanced economies but no

    consistent causal relations are observed in emerging economies.

    One existing study which focuses exclusively on South Asian markets is Smyth

    and Nandha (2003), who employ the Engle and Granger (1987) and Johansen (1988)

    methods of cointegration to examine the relationship between exchange rates and stock

    prices in Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka within a cointegration and causality

    framework using daily data for 1995 to 2001. Their main finding was that there is no

    long-run equilibrium relationship between exchange rates and stock prices in these four

    markets.

    To examine the dynamic linkages between the foreign exchange and stock

    markets for India, Nath and Samanta (2003) employed the Granger causality test on daily

    data during the period March 1993 to December 2002. The empirical findings of the

    study suggest that these two markets did not have any causal relationship. When the

    study extended its analysis to verify if liberalization in both the markets brought them

    together, it found no significant causal relationship between the exchange rate and stock

    price movements, except for the years 1993, 2001 and 2002 during when a unidirectional

    causal influence from stock index return to return in forex market is detected and a very

    mild causal influence in the reverse direction is found in some years such as 1997 and

    2002.

    Alok Kumar Mishra in his article Stock Market and Foreign Exchange Market in

    India: Are they Related? attempts to examine whether stock market and foreign

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    27/63

    27

    exchange markets are related to each other or not. The study uses Grangers Causality

    test and Vector Auto Regression technique on monthly stock return, exchange rate,

    interest rate and demand for money for the period April 1992 to March 2002. The major

    findings of the study are:

    There exists a unidirectional causality between the exchange rate and interest rate

    and between the exchange rate return and demand for money;

    There is no Grangers causality between the exchange rate return and stock return.

    Through Vector Auto Regression modeling, the study confirms that though stock

    return, exchange rate return, the demand for money and interest rate are related to each

    other but any consistent relationship doesnt exist between them. The forecast error

    variance decomposition further evidences that:

    The exchange rate return affects the demand for money,

    The interest rate causes exchange rate return change,

    The exchange rate return affects the stock return,

    The demand for money affects stock return,

    The interest rate affects the stock return, and

    The demand for money affects the interest rate.

    Apte (2001) investigated the relationship between the volatility of the stock

    market and the nominal exchange rate of India by using the EGARCH specifications on

    the daily closing USD/INR exchange rate, BSE 30 (Sensex) and NIFTY-50 over the

    period 1991 to 2000. The study suggests that there appears to be a spillover from the

    foreign exchange market to the stock market but not the reverse.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    28/63

    28

    CHAPTER III

    METHODOLOGY

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    29/63

    29

    Methodology of Research:

    Problem statement

    There are various studies have been done to study the relationship

    between exchange rates and stock prices by taking various indices. This study explores

    the evidence of relationship between exchange rates and stock prices and also lead lag

    relationship between exchange rates and stock prices.

    Objectives of the study

    To analyze the relationship between stock market and exchange market

    To find out whether the relationship changes with different indices

    To find out which variable is leading and which variable is lagging.

    Hypothesis to be tested

    H0: There is no significant relation between stock prices and exchange rates

    H1: There is significant relation between stock prices and exchange rates

    Data Set

    Data are available on the share price index (SPt) and exchange rate (ERt) for NSE

    (National Stock Exchange) and BSE Sensex of India. We use daily data (excluding

    weekends and holidays) for the period January 2, 2001 to march 31, 2007, which gives a

    total of 1600 observations. We use daily data, which is appropriate for this type of study

    given that a sampling frequency less than one day may introduce spurious statistical

    significance into the tests.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    30/63

    30

    Study Design

    a) Study Type:

    The study type is analytical, quantitative and historical. Analytical because facts

    and existing information is used for the analysis, Quantitative as relationship is examined

    by expressing variables in measurable terms and also Historical as the historical

    information is used for analysis and interpretation.

    b) Study population:

    population is the entire stock market and all indices and exchange rates of rupee

    versus currencies of all the countries.

    c) Sampling frame:

    Sampling Frame would be Indian stock market and rupee versus US Dollar.

    d) Sample:

    Sample chosen is daily closing values of BSE Sensex, CNX Nifty and exchange

    rates of Rupee/Dollar from 1-1-2001 to 31-3-2007.

    e) Sampling technique:Deliberate sampling is used because only particular units are selected from the

    sampling frame. Such a selection is undertaken as these units represent the population in

    a better way and reflect better relationship with the other variable.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    31/63

    31

    Data gathering procedures and instruments:

    Data:

    Historical daily share prices and information about their forex exposure.

    Historical daily closing values of BSE Sensex, CNX Nifty, CNX IT, BSE Bankex, import

    index and export index. Direct and indirect quotes of rupee per dollar.

    Data Source:

    Historical share prices of the sample companies and the index points for the

    period has been taken from the database of Capital Market Publishers (India) Ltd.,

    Capitaline 2007 and exchange rates information has been taken from

    www.exchangerate.com.

    An exchange rate has two effects on share prices, a direct effect through Multi

    National Firms and indirect effect through domestic firms.

    Even though exchange rate has effect on stock prices of companies, the study has

    been conducted by considering different indices because index values are nothing but the

    weighted average of different companys share prices and indices are the proxies of stockmarket.

    BSE Sensex is considered as it is a barometer of the state of the economy. It

    follows the free float methodology. The companies in the Sensex are domestic

    Companies, so it has been taken to see the indirect effect of exchange rates.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    32/63

    32

    Table NO.1 Constituents of BSE sensex-

    1 Reliance Industries 16 Satyam computers

    2 ONGC 17 Hero honda

    3 Bharti Airtel 18 Dr Reddys

    4 Tata Consultancy 19 Tata motors

    5 Infosys tech 20 Tata steel

    6 Reliance Communication 21 Bajaj auto

    7 Wipro 22 GAIL

    8 ICICI Bank 23 Maruti udyog

    9 ACC 24 Sun pharma

    10 BHEL 25 Grasim industries

    11 SBI 26 Gujarat ambuja

    12 Hindalco 27 Cipla

    13 HLL 28 Siemens

    14 L&T 29 Ranbaxy

    15 HDFC 30 NTPC

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    33/63

    33

    Constituents of nifty-

    1 Reliance Industries 26 Gujarat ambuja

    2 ONGC 27 Cipla

    3 Bharti Airtel 28 Siemens

    4 Tata Consultancy 29 Ranbaxy

    5 Infosys tech 30 NTPC

    6 Reliance Communication 31 ITC

    7 Wipro 32 VSNL

    8 ICICI Bank 33 Zee Entertainment

    9 ACC 34 MTNL

    10 BHEL 35 HPCL

    11 SBI 36 Dabur

    12 Hindalco 37 IPCL

    13 HLL 38 Jet Airways

    14 L&T 39 Oriental Bank

    15 HDFC 40 Glaxo Smith

    16 Satyam computers 41 Tata power

    17 Hero honda 42 BPCL

    18 Dr Reddys 43 Reliance energy

    19 Tata motors 44 Punjab National Bank

    20 Tata steel 45 ABB

    21 Bajaj auto 46 Hindalco

    22 GAIL 47 National Alu

    23 Maruti udyog 48 M&M

    24 Sun pharma 49 Seagrams

    25 Grasim industries 50 HCL tech

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    34/63

    34

    Tests and Results

    Test for Stationarity-

    A time series is said to be stationary if its mean and variance are constant over

    time and the value of the covariance between the two time periods depends only on the

    distance or gap or lag between the two time periods and not the actual time at which the

    covariance is computed. Tests for stationarity are routinely applied to highly persistent

    time series. Following Kwiatkowski, Phillips, Schmidt and Shin (1992), standard

    stationarity employs a rescaling by an estimator of the long-run variance of the

    (potentially) stationary series.

    Test for stationarity is important in case of time series data because a

    nonstationary time series will have time varying mean or a time-varying variance or both.

    Hence the results cannot be extrapolated for the entire population.

    The test for stationarity can be done using Unit Root Test. It is due to the fact that

    = 1. If however, || 1, that is if the absolute value of is less than one, then it can be

    shown that the time series is stationary.

    Given that in most situations only one observation is available at a given time,

    stationarity ensures that all parts of the series are like the other parts, which allows us to

    estimate the needed parameters. Therefore, the mean, the variance and the covariance of

    the series are not functions of time and depend rather on the lag between the observations

    (the difference between the times at which two observations were recorded). To

    summarize, if Xt is a discrete time series, its distribution is described by its first two

    ments, which under stationarity must depend only on the lag:

    E[Xt] = t = ,

    V ar(Xt) = 2t = 2,

    Cov(Xt, Xts) = E[(Xt t)(Xts ts)] = t,ts = |s|,

    Corr(Xt, Xts) = t,ts 2 = t,ts.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    35/63

    35

    Since all time series data sets contain either deterministic or stochastic trends

    (or both), unit root tests and stationarity tests are a way of determining which kind of

    trends are present in the data. If only deterministic trends are present, then the series can

    be seen as being generated by some non-random, pre-determined function of time with

    some random error thrown in. On the other hand, if stochastic trends are present, then the

    generating model of the series combines a starting value and a sequence of random

    innovations with zero mean and constant variance, which form a more dynamic structure.

    In this case, each observation depends on its history of past random innovations, which

    greatly impact its current value. Thus, in the case of stochastic trends the value of a future

    observation depends on the values of present and past observations.

    Augmented Dickey Fuller Test-

    An augmented Dickey-Fuller test is a test for a unit root in a time series sample.

    An augmented Dickey-Fuller test is a version of the Dickey-Fuller test for a larger and

    more complicated set of time series models.

    The augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) statistic, used in the test, is a negative

    number. The more negative it is, the stronger the rejection of the hypothesis that there is a

    unit root at some level of confidence.

    Under the Dickey-Fuller test the null hypothesis that = 0, the estimated t value

    of the coefficient of Yt-1 in follows the (tau) statistic. The values are arrived from

    Monte Carlo simulation. This test is conducted by augmenting the preceding three

    equations by adding the lagged values of the dependent variable Yt.

    So the required regression is:

    Yt = 1 + 2 t + Yt-1+ i Yt-i + t

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    36/63

    36

    where is a constant, the coefficient on a time trend and p the lag order of the

    autoregressive process. Imposing the contraints = 0 and = 0 corresponds to modelling

    a random walk and using the constraint = 0 corresponds to modelling a random walk

    with a drift.

    By including lags of the orderp the ADF formulation allows for higher-order

    autoregressive processes. This means that the the lag length p has to be determined when

    applying the test. One possible approach is to test down from high orders and examine

    the t-values on coefficients. An alternative approach is to examine information criteria

    such as the Akaike information criterion, Bayesian information criterion or the Hannon

    Quinn criterion.

    The unit root test is then carried out under the null hypothesis = 1 against the

    alternative hypothesis of < 1. Once a value for the test statistic

    computed it can be compared to the relvant critical value for the Dickey-Fuller Test. If

    the test statistic is less than the critical value then the null hypothesis of = 1 is rejected

    and no unit root is present

    Where t is a pure white noise error term and the number of lagged differenceterms to include is often determined empirically, the idea being to include enough terms

    so that the error term in is serially uncorrelated. Dickey and Fuller (1979) found that the

    distributions of the t-statistics for the models given above are skewed to the left and have

    critical values that are quite large and negative. That means that if the standard

    t-distributions were used during testing; we would tend to over-reject the null hypothesis.

    One important element in the ADF test is the number of lags present in the model.

    It has been observed that the number of lagged factors has a great impact on the size and

    power properties of the ADF test and therefore it is important to precisely determine how

    many should be included in the model.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    37/63

    37

    Some advocate starting with a large number of lags, estimating their coefficients

    and eliminating the ones than are statistically insignificant at the chosen level. This

    process would continue until no insignificant terms are left in the model. we can include

    deterministic trends in the models (linear or non-linear) and the analysis goes along the

    same lines as in the case of the DF variants. The only modification is, once again,

    the presence of the lagged terms, which has to be determined with relatively high

    accuracy for the unit root tests to be effective.

    Then the test statistic T*(bOLS

    -1) has a known, documented distribution. Its value

    in a particular sample can be compared to that distribution to determine a probability that

    the original sample came from a unit root autoregressive process; that is, one in which

    b=1.

    Properties and Characteristics of Unit Root Processes

    Shocks to a unit root process have permanent effects, they do not decay

    Non-stationary processes have no long-run means to revert to after a shock

    Their variance is time dependent and it goes to infinity as it goes to infinity

    I(1) processes can be rendered stationary and used for OLS estimation by taking

    their first differences yt= y

    ty

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    38/63

    38

    In the sample time series data i.e., BSE Sensex, NSE Nifty and Exchange Rate

    data have been tested for their stationarity and the results are as follows

    NIFTY-

    Lags

    ADF T

    Statistic

    1% Significance

    value

    5% Significance

    value

    10%

    Significance

    value

    1 -48.90367 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    2 -42.01398 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    3 -35.34338 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    4 -29.68170 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    5 -26.74565 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    6 -24.85180 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    7 -24.41056 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    0 -59.47844 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    -1 -29.68170 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    In the analysis we find that the calculated Tau statistic is significant even at

    1% significant level

    Hence we can conclude that the data set (NSE Nifty) is stationary at first

    difference.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    39/63

    39

    Exchange Rate-

    Lags ADF T

    Statistic

    1% significance

    Value

    5% significance

    Value

    10%

    significance

    value

    1 -48.14002 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    2 -37.63418 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    3 -38.42542 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    4 -31.05203 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    5-27.54348 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    6 -24.18888 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    0 -66.07068 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    -1 -31.05203 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    The log naturals of Exchange rate is found to be stationary at 1% significance

    level using Augmented Dickey Fuller test

    The regression equation showed that the variables are stationary at 1% criticalvalue.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    40/63

    40

    BSE Sensex

    Lags ADF T statistic 1% significance 5% significance 10%

    significance

    1 -48.22602 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    2 -42.03703 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    3 -34.77614 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    4 -29.15550 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    5 -26.75253 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    6-25.14448 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    0 -61.03772 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    -1 -29.16495 -2.5671 -1.9396 -1.6157

    The data set of BSE Sensex is tested for stationarity using Augmented Dickey

    Fuller test

    The Test showed that the data is Stationary at 1st difference

    The test is stationary at 1% critical value

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    41/63

    41

    Testing for the distribution

    A frequency distribution is a list of the values that a variable takes in a sample.

    It is usually a list, ordered by quantity, showing the number of times each value appears.frequency distribution is said to be skewed when its mean and median are different. The

    kurtosis of a frequency distribution is the concentration of scores at the mean, or how

    peaked the distribution appears if depicted graphicallyfor example, in a histogram. If

    the distribution is more peaked than the normal distribution it is said to be leptokurtic; if

    less peaked it is said to be platykurtic.

    Normal distribution

    The importance of the normal distribution as a model of quantitative phenomena

    in the natural and behavioral sciences is due to the central limit theorem. Many

    psychological measurements and physical phenomena (like photon counts and noise) can

    be approximated well by the normal distribution. While the mechanisms underlying these

    phenomena are often unknown, the use of the normal model can be theoretically justified

    by assuming that many small, independent effects are additively contributing to each

    observation.

    The normal distribution also arises in many areas of statistics. For example, the

    sampling distribution of the sample mean is approximately normal, even if the

    distribution of the population from which the sample is taken is not normal. In addition,

    the normal distribution maximizes information entropy among all distributions with

    known mean and variance, which makes it the natural choice of underlying distribution

    for data summarized in terms of sample mean and variance. The normal distribution is

    the most widely used family of distributions in statistics and many statistical tests are

    based on the assumption of normality. In probability theory, normal distributions arise as

    the limiting distributions of several continuous and discrete families of distributions.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    42/63

    42

    A normal distribution in a variate with mean and variance is a statisticdistribution with probability function

    on the domain . While statisticians and mathematicians uniformly use the

    term "normal distribution" for this distribution, physicists sometimes call it a Gaussian

    distribution and, because of its curved flaring shape, social scientists refer to it as the

    "bell curve." Feller (1968) uses the symbol for in the above equation, but then

    switches to in Feller (1971).

    De Moivre developed the normal distribution as an approximation to the binomialdistribution, and it was subsequently used by Laplace in 1783 to study measurement

    errors and by Gauss in 1809 in the analysis of astronomical data.

    The normal distribution is implemented in Mathematica as NormalDistribution[mu,

    sigma]. The so-called "standard normal distribution" is given by taking and in

    a general normal distribution. An arbitrary normal distribution can be converted to a

    standard normal distribution by changing variables to , so ,

    yielding

    Normal distributions have many convenient properties, so random variates with

    unknown distributions are often assumed to be normal, especially in physics and

    astronomy. Although this can be a dangerous assumption, it is often a good

    approximation due to a surprising result known as the central limit theorem. This theoremstates that the mean of any set of variates with any distribution having a finite mean and

    variance tends to the normal distribution. Many common attributes such as test scores,

    height, etc., follow roughly normal distributions, with few members at the high and low

    ends and many in the middle.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    43/63

    43

    Because they occur so frequently, there is an unfortunate tendency to invoke

    normal distributions in situations where they may not be applicable. As Lippmann stated,

    "Everybody believes in the exponential law of errors: the experimenters, because they

    think it can be proved by mathematics; and the mathematicians, because they believe it

    has been established by observation" (Whittaker and Robinson 1967, p. 179).

    Among the amazing properties of the normal distribution are that the normal sum

    distribution and normal difference distribution obtained by respectively adding and

    subtracting variates and from two independent normal distributions with arbitrary

    means and variances are also normal!

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    44/63

    44

    The data is tested for the distribution that it follows and the results are as follows

    Testing data for distribution- bse sensex

    Statistics

    Stock exchange bse

    Valid 1552NMissing 13

    Mean -.000759972Std. Error of Mean .0003616586Median -.001513471Mode -.0793110(a)Std. Deviation .0142476978Variance .000Skewness .677Std. Error of Skewness .062Kurtosis 5.494Std. Error of Kurtosis .124Range .1974027Minimum -.0793110Maximum .1180918Sum -1.1794769

    a Multiple modes exist. The smallest value is shown

    0.15000000.10000000.05000000.0000000-0.0500000-0.1000000

    stockexchangebse

    400

    300

    200

    100

    0

    Frequency

    Mean = -7.599722586E-

    4

    Std. Dev. =

    0.0142476978

    N = 1,552

    Histogram

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    45/63

    45

    Testing data for distribution

    Exchange rate- Statistics

    exchangerate

    Valid 1565NMissing 0

    Mean -.000044543Std. Error of Mean .0000558450Median .000000000Mode .0000000Std. Deviation .0022092326Variance .000Skewness -.623Std. Error of Skewness .062Kurtosis 10.505

    Std. Error of Kurtosis .124Range .0293786Minimum -.0167958Maximum .0125828Sum -.0697099

    0.01000000.0000000-0.0100000-0.0200000

    exchangerate

    500

    400

    300

    200

    100

    0

    Frequency

    Mean = -4.454304733E-

    5

    Std. Dev. =

    0.0022092326

    N = 1,565

    Histogram

    Test for Distribution

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    46/63

    46

    Nifty-

    Statistics

    Valid 1565N

    Missing 0Mean .000711871Std. Error of Mean .0003648690Median .001643323Mode .0000000Std. Deviation .0144342454Variance .000Skewness -.885Std. Error of Skewness .062Kurtosis 6.975Std. Error of Kurtosis .124

    Range .2102295Minimum -.1305386Maximum .0796909Sum 1.1140785

    0.10000000.05000000.0000000-0.0500000-0.1000000-0.1500000

    nifty50

    300

    200

    100

    0

    Frequency

    Mean = 7.118712216E-4

    Std. Dev. =0.0144342454

    N = 1,565

    Histogram

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    47/63

    47

    Analysis-

    As can be seen from the above results the data sets of BSE Sensex, NSE Nifty and

    Exchange Rate follows normal distribution. Hence the data is capable for further testing.

    The variance of the data sets are 00 which confirms the data as to its stationarity

    Test for Co-integration

    Cointegration is an econometric technique for testing the correlation between

    stationary time series variables. If two or more series are themselves stationary, and a

    linear combination of them is stationary, then the series are said to be cointegrated. For

    instance, a stock market index and the price of its associated futures contract move

    through time, each roughly following a random walk. Testing the hypothesis that there is

    a statistically significant connection between the futures price and the spot price could

    now be done by finding a cointegrating vector. (If such a vector has a low order of

    integration it can signify an equilibrium relationship between the original series, which

    are said to be cointegrated of an order below one).

    It is often said that co integration is a means for correctly testing hypotheses

    concerning the relationship between two variables having unit roots (i.e. integrated of

    order one). series is said to be "integrated of order d" if one can obtain a stationary series

    by "differencing" the term d times. such that:

    C= Y dX(1)is stationary, where the parameterdis the cointegrating parameter that links the two

    time series together. Further, the relationship Y = dX is considered to be a long-run,

    or equilibrium, relationship suggested by economic theory. Under such

    circumstances these markets are said to be cointegrated. In contrast, lack of

    cointegration implies that the aforementioned variables have no link in the long-run.

    If two, or more series, are cointegrated, then there exist common factors that affect

    both and their permanent or secular trends, and so the series will eventually adjust

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    48/63

    48

    to equilibrium. The implications for diversification are that even if, in the shortterm

    the covariance between two series indicates portfolio benefits, in the long-run

    such benefits are spurious as the two series will eventually adjust to an equilibrium

    relationship.

    Hence, the existence of an equilibrium relationship between two or more variables,

    assuming that they all are integrated individually to the same degree, requires that

    the cointegration between them is of a lower degree. That is if both X and Y are

    stationary I(1) the cointegration vector must be stationary I(0). However, if X and Y

    are integrated to different degrees, there will not be any parameterdthat satisfies

    Equation (1). Thus a long-run relationship implies the requirement that the two

    variables should be (i) integrated to the same degree and (ii) a linear combination of

    the two variables should exist which is integrated to a lower degree than the

    individual variables.

    Testing for cointegration involves two steps.

    1. Determine the degree of integration in each of the series, a unit root analysis.

    2. Estimate the cointegration regression and test for integration.

    Assuming that each series has the same number of unit roots, the cointegrationtest can commence. Engle and Granger (1987) proposed seven tests for examining the

    hypothesis that two time series are not cointegrated. In cointegration tests, the null

    hypothesis is non-cointegration. Only two are used here both based on the using an

    OLS regression in the following form:

    Y = a + bX + m (3)

    where b is the estimator for the equilibrium parameter, d; a is the intercept; and m

    is the disturbance term. The first of the two tests of cointegration is based on the

    Cointegrating Regression Durbin-Watson (CRDW) statistic. As a simple rule of

    thumb for a quick evaluation of the cointegration hypothesis Banerjee et al (1986)

    proposed that: if the CRDW statistic is smaller than the coefficient of determination

    (R2) the cointegration hypothesis is likely to be false; otherwise, when CRDW> R2,

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    49/63

    49

    cointegration may occur. Alternatively the CRDW statistic can be evaluated against

    critical values developed by Engle and Granger (1987), if the CRDW statistic

    exceeds the critical value, the null hypothesis of non-cointegration is rejected.

    Suggesting that the series are not cointegrated.

    The test for cointegration involves the significance of the estimated l1 coefficient.

    Again the null hypothesis is that the error terms are nonstationary and acceptance of this

    hypothesis indicates that the series under investigation are not integrated. If the t-statistic

    on the l1 coefficient exceeds the critical value, the m residuals from the cointegration

    regression equation (3) are stationary and the variables X and Y are cointegrated. Critical

    values for this tstatistic are given in Mackinnon (1991).

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    50/63

    50

    Test for co-integration:

    Test : Johnsons Co-integration test

    Series : NSE Nifty and Exchange Rate

    Bse sensex and Exchange Rate

    Sample: 1 1567Included observations: 1547Test :Johnson co integration testSeries: 1. Exchange rate and NSE

    2. Exchange rate and BSELags interval: 1 to 4

    Likelihood 5 Percent 1 Percent HypothesizedEigenvalue Ratio Critical Value Critical Value No. of CE(s)

    0.169822854329 540.15012665

    19.96 24.60** None

    0.150445830265 252.22840788

    9.24 12.97** At most 1

    ** indicates the rejection of integration between series at 1% and 5% significance level

    Results-

    As per Johnsons Cointegration Test there exists no relationship between the two

    series i.e., Exchange rate and NSE Nifty and Exchange rate and BSE Sensex

    Through this test we can conclude that there is no short or long term relationship

    between exchange rate and stock indices.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    51/63

    51

    CHAPTER IV

    DISCUSSIONS

    AND

    CONCLUSIONS

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    52/63

    52

    Discussions-

    Theory says that exchange rates should have a direct impact on the companies

    with heavy import or export activities and thus affecting the profitability and hence the

    stock prices. An exchange rate has two effects on stock prices, a direct effect through

    Multi National Firms and an indirect effect through domestic firms.

    As the index is nothing but weighted average of the share prices of various

    companies from different sectors, the sensex has been considered to see the impact of ER

    on it. Both Sensex and Nifty are considered to see where they move in the same direction

    or not.

    After analyzing the data by using correlation coefficient, we found that in the

    short run or in the long run Exchange Rate does not affect the share prices. The

    results show that there was no significant relationship between the Exchange Rate and

    any index.

    From the results obtained by carrying out various tests, we can see that there is

    very less relation exists between exchange rates and stock prices. The possible reasons

    for such behavior could be as follows:

    One interpretation could be that investors do not use all freely available

    information, like past changes in the rupee and the past relation and firm performance,assets and liabilities of company, etc, to predict changes in firm value. More specifically,

    at the end of fiscal quarter investors observe the change in the value of rupee over the

    period and see what impact the rupee changes has on firm performance, assets and

    liabilities. Based upon this information, investors should be able to form an unbiased

    expectation about the economic impact of the recent change in rupee on the firm and

    incorporate this effect into firms value and share prices. However, at the end of fiscal

    quarter, investors systematically underestimate or perhaps overlook this impact.

    This underestimation may be corrected only when additional information that directly

    relates to the impact of past change in rupee on the firm performance, asset and liabilities

    is disclosed during the following quarter.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    53/63

    53

    On the other hand, it can be said that because of using only a single variable,

    namely exchange rate, the impact on stock prices was not felt. If more of independent

    variables like interest rates, money supply etc. could be added, then possibly a very

    good relation could have been established. In reality, stock prices and exchange rate are

    affected by a myriad of factors such as fiscal and monetary policy, interest rates,

    inflation, money supply, political factors, international events, fundamental performance,

    forex reserves, BOP, exchange control, etc.

    The non-existence of relationship may also be because of Indian markets not yet

    being highly integrated or sensitive to the new information. Also the Indian companies

    comparatively may not be exposed to a lot of forex exposure, like companies in

    developed countries.

    Alternatively Indian managers are highly cautious and hedge to a good extent of

    their forex exposure.

    Another very important reason can be that Indian stocks are highly sentiment

    driven and stocks of certain companies may start soaring for no reason. There are few

    qualitative factors that influence stock prices like speculation and investor confidencelevel.

    High volatility introduced in the exchange market due to floating rate regime

    nurtures the speculative activities, makes it difficult to pinpoint the precise effect of

    exchange rates on stock prices.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    54/63

    54

    Conclusions:

    In this paper, we have examined the long-run and short-run dynamics between

    stock prices and exchange rates in India. Our main concerns were to examine whetherthese links were affected by the existence of foreign exchange controls, floating rates and

    raising value of Rupee and raising indices in India.

    We have examined these issues by applying stationarity tests and cointegration

    methodology, which tests for a long-run relationship between the stock market and

    exchange rate of the country ie., its real exchange rate.

    The following conclusions have been derived from our analysis:

    There is no significant cause and effect relationship between the two variables. As

    the relationship occurred between the variables during different periods is because of

    chance factor and not because of cause factor.

    There is no significant relationship between any of the company

    share prices with exchange rates individually.

    Hence, we can reject the hypothesis that there is relationship between the

    exchange rate and stock indices and the two are affected by various factors in spite of the

    increasing integration between the two markets.

    In conclusion, in the era of increasing integration in financial markets one should

    take sufficient care while implementing exchange rate policies. Furthermore, indicationsare that the existence of foreign exchange restrictions does not isolate the domestic

    capital markets. The general increase in international trade and the resultant increase in

    economic integration have also increased financial integration and reduced the benefit of

    international diversification.

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    55/63

    55

    CHAPTER V

    BIBLIOGRAPHY

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    56/63

    56

    Bibliography:

    Text Books

    Multinational Business Finance,

    David K. Eieteman, Arthur I. Stonehill and Michel H. Moffett, (Tenth Edition)

    Research Methodology

    Donald Cooper and Pamela Schindler , (Eighth Edition)

    Financial markets and services

    Gordon and Natrajan, (Second Edition)

    Websites

    www.investopedia.com

    www.nseindia.com

    www.bseindia.com www.exchangerate.com www.emeclai.com

    www.icicidirect.com www.iciciresearch.com www.easy-forex.com

    www.indiainfoline.com

    Database of Capital Market Publishers (India) Ltd., Capitaline 2000

    Jstor Database

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    57/63

    57

    Reference:

    Articles ofICFAI

    (The Institute of Chartered Financial Analysts of India)

    Integration between Foreign Exchange and Capital Markets in India: An

    empirical exploration" by Golka C Nath and G P Samanta, the ICFAI Journal of Applied

    Finance vol. 9 No. 6, Pg. 29 to 40

    Dynamic Relationship between Exchange rates and stock Prices: an empiricalstudy in the Indian context by Meera Pratap Thakker and Vijay R Chary, the ICFAI

    Journal of Applied Finance vol.10 No.8 Pg. 54 to 68

    Causality between stock prices and exchange rates: some evidence for India by

    M Venkateshwaralu and Rishab Tiwari , the ICFAI Journal of Applied Finance vol.11

    No.3, Pg. 5 to 15

    Stock Prices and Exchange Rates interlinkages in emerging financial markets:

    the Indian perspective by Alok Kumar Mishra the ICFAI Journal of Applied Finance

    vol.11 No.4,Pg. 31 to 48

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    58/63

    58

    CHAPTER VI

    ANNEXURES

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    59/63

    59

    Regression- BSE Sensex and Exchange Rate

    Descriptive Statistics

    MeanStd.

    Deviation N

    stockexchangebse -.000759972 .0142476978 1552exchange rate -.000034925 .0021643662 1552

    Correlations

    Stockexchange

    bse

    Exchange

    ratePearsonCorrelation

    stockexchangebse1.000 .019

    exchangerate .019 1.000Sig. (1-tailed) stockexchangebse . .229

    exchangerate .229 .N stockexchangebse 1552 1552

    exchangerate 1552 1552

    ANOVA(b)

    Model Sum ofSquares df Mean Square F Sig.

    1 Regression.000 1 .000 .552 .458(a)

    Residual .315 1550 .000

    Total .315 1551

    a Predictors: (Constant), exchangerate

    b Dependent Variable: stockexchangebse

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    60/63

    60

    Regression- NSE Nifty and Exchange Rate

    Descriptive Statistics

    Mean Std. Deviation N

    nse .00071187 .014434245 1565

    exchrate -.00004454

    .002209233 1565

    Correlations

    nse exchrate

    Pearson Correlation nse 1.000 -.032

    exchrate -.032 1.000

    Sig. (1-tailed) nse . .103

    exchrate .103 .N nse 1565 1565

    exchrate 1565 1565

    Model Summary(b)

    Model R R SquareAdjusted R

    SquareStd. Error ofthe Estimate Durbin-Watson

    1 .032(a) .001 .000 .014431444 1.808

    a Predictors: (Constant), exchrate

    b Dependent Variable: nse

    ANOVA(b)

    ModelSum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

    1 Regression .000 1 .000 1.607 .205(a)

    Residual .326 1563 .000

    Total.326 1564

    a Predictors: (Constant), exchrate

    b Dependent Variable: nse

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    61/63

    61

    Coefficientsa

    .001 .000 1.925 .054

    -.209 .165 -.032 -1.268 .205

    (Constant)

    exchrate

    Model

    1

    B Std. Error

    Unstandardized

    Coefficients

    Beta

    Standardized

    Coefficients

    t Sig.

    Dependent Variable: nsea.

    Residuals Statisticsa

    -.001932 .00421963 .00071187 .000462621 1565

    ******** ******** ******** .014426830 1565

    -5.716 7.582 .000 1.000 1565

    -9.024 5.472 .000 1.000 1565

    Predicted Value

    Residual

    Std. Predicted Value

    Std. Residual

    Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation N

    Dependent Variable: nsea.

    Unit Root test for BSE Sensex

    ADF Test Statistic -31.05203 1% Critical Value* -2.56715% Critical Value -1.939610% Critical Value -1.6157

    *MacKinnon critical values for rejection of hypothesis of a unit root.

    Augmented Dickey-Fuller Test EquationDependent Variable: D(SER07,2)Method: Least SquaresDate: 05/15/07 Time: 16:46Sample(adjusted): 7 1565Included observations: 1559 after adjusting endpoints

    Variable Coefficient Std. Error t -Statistic Prob.

    D(SER07(-1)) -3.658002 0.117802 -31.05203 0.0000D(SER07(-1),2) 1.820555 0.101674 17.90575 0.0000D(SER07(-2),2) 1.108887 0.078794 14.07318 0.0000D(SER07(-3),2) 0.562906 0.051964 10.83259 0.0000D(SER07(-4),2) 0.124101 0.025584 4.850666 0.0000

    R-squared 0.805946 Mean dependent var 9.87E-06Adjusted R-squared 0.805447 S.D. dependent var 0.005313S.E. of regression 0.002343 Akaike info criterion -9.271309Sum squared resid 0.008533 Schwarz criterion -9.254145Log likelihood 7231.986 Durbin-Watson stat 2.004107

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    62/63

    62

    Unit Root test for Exchange Rate

    ADF Test Statistic -31.05203 1% Critical Value* -2.56715% Critical Value -1.939610% Critical Value -1.6157

    *MacKinnon critical values for rejection of hypothesis of a unit root.

    Augmented Dickey-Fuller Test EquationDependent Variable: D(SER10,2)

    Method: Least SquaresDate: 05/15/07 Time: 16:50

    Sample(adjusted): 7 1565Included observations: 1559 after adjusting endpoints

    Variable Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.

    D(SER10(-1)) -3.658002 0.117802 -31.05203 0.0000D(SER10(-1),2) 1.820555 0.101674 17.90575 0.0000D(SER10(-2),2) 1.108887 0.078794 14.07318 0.0000D(SER10(-3),2) 0.562906 0.051964 10.83259 0.0000D(SER10(-4),2) 0.124101 0.025584 4.850666 0.0000

    R-squared 0.805946 Mean dependent var 9.87E-06Adjusted R-squared 0.805447 S.D. dependent var 0.005313S.E. of regression 0.002343 Akaike info criterion -9.271309Sum squared resid 0.008533 Schwarz criterion -9.254145

    Log likelihood 7231.986 Durbin-Watson stat 2.004107

  • 8/7/2019 Relationship Between Exchange Rate and Stock Indices

    63/63

    Unit root test for NSE Nifty

    ADF Test Statistic -29.68170 1% Critical Value* -2.56715% Critical Value -1.939610% Critical Value -1.6157

    *MacKinnon critical values for rejection of hypothesis of a unit root.

    Augmented Dickey-Fuller Test EquationDependent Variable: D(SER05,2)Method: Least SquaresDate: 05/15/07 Time: 16:41Sample(adjusted): 7 1565Included observations: 1559 after adjusting endpoints

    Variable Coefficient

    Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.

    D(SER05(-1)) -3.357618 0.113121 -29.68170 0.0000D(SER05(-1),2) 1.623331 0.098130 16.54270 0.0000D(SER05(-2),2) 0.922058 0.075729 12.17568 0.0000D(SER05(-3),2) 0.408524 0.049648 8.228373 0.0000D(SER05(-4),2) 0.120220 0.025206 4.769520 0.0000

    R-squared 0.774702 Mean dependent var -1.23E-05

    Adjusted R-squared 0.774122 S.D. dependent var 0.032278S.E. of regression 0.015341 Akaike info criterion -5.513389Sum squared resid 0.365722 Schwarz criterion -5.496225Log likelihood 4302.687 Durbin-Watson stat 2.026764