Reflection
-
Upload
jessica-henderson -
Category
Documents
-
view
6 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Reflection
-
In high school, it was a constant competition to see who could take the most difficult
classes, receive the best grades, and be admitted to the most prestigious universities. Due to this
overwhelming competitiveness, I took as many AP courses as my schedule permitted. It called
for a very difficult junior and senior year, but I knew if I made it into the school of my dreams it
would be worth it. Two of those AP courses were English courses: AP Literature and AP
Language and Composition; on both of which I ended up failing the AP exam. Needless to say,
when I achieved my goal to be admitted to my dream school, Florida State University, I wasnt
looking forward to taking English, at least not if I could expect it to be anything like the material
in the AP classes I had taken. The most prevalent problems with my writing according to my past
AP teachers were: developing a strong thesis statement, an interesting introduction, and a
conclusion which tied together each of the topic sentences in relation to the thesis. Surprisingly,
throughout the semester in which I took freshmen English Composition and Rhetoric (ENC
1101) I seemed to improve in each of these categories, with the help of my instructor, Ashley
Humphries, and my peers. I even managed to develop some of my former weaknesses into
strengths.
The first paper we were assigned was a Digital History Narrative in which we choose a
technological median and developed a story that showcased how this particular median affected
our lives or personality as a whole. I expressed how the element of photography affected my life
through a sequential description of the different devices in which I used to take photos. When
writing the paper I struggled the most with organizing it to where the transitions between the
analysis points and narrative elements didnt seem so abrupt and distract the reader. After a
meeting with my instructor, she suggested I use a more unique transition in order to display a
clear distinction between the narrative elements and the reflective analysis points. I then included
-
a ~ symbol as the transition from narrator to analysis. When moving forward in the course and
looking back at this essay, I decided that the ~ provided confusion as to who was supposed to
be speaking at what times. As a result of this, in the final revision I replaced the ~ with text
bubbles containing the analysis points, attempting to make it appear as though I was telling the
story and making small side notes reflecting upon the past, with my knowledge of the future.
This attempt would again make a more distinctive representation of who is saying what at what
time. Throughout the editing process of this particular assignment I realized that every essay I
write doesnt have to be the typical essay in which every professor expects from their students,
but that sometimes creating a more unique format or layout can benefit the quality of the work as
a whole. Where in this case, creating text bubbles with analysis comments made the essay more
effective in allowing the reader to understand the reflective points being made.
The topic of the second paper was a visual and textual analysis, which sparked my
interest in the class because what I wrote about and analyzed was completely up to me. For this
assignment we chose a video containing visual and textual elements and analyzed the manifest
and latent functions, which contributed to the message of the artifact as a whole. I chose to
analyze a cover video by Dani Shay, of the song Pumped Up Kicks in which points out the
possible catastrophes caused by bullying. At the start of this paper I had similar problems to that
of the first paper: organizing the outside sources to support my argument in an effective manner.
After visiting the ACE Reading and Writing Center at FSU, I overcame this issue with a simple
rhetorical analysis formula: topic sentence, data or example, explanation of why the data or
example proves my topic sentence, relation back to the thesis, and a transition between
paragraphs. With the help of this formula, I was able to create an essay in which all the points
worked together to form an argument. In this particular assignment, I feel I improved the most on
-
developing a strong thesis statement and introductory paragraph. The nature of the topic forced
me to embed context about the organization the video was made for and message of the video
itself, which allowed the base of a very strong introductory paragraph and thesis statement that I
then expanded with more details. The development of a strong thesis then caused the remainder
of the paper to be stronger and allowed it to be organized better to fit the argument.
My favorite paper was the third paper, where we were advised to pick an advertisement
which we thought had something wrong with it, we then recreated it in the form of an anti-ad,
either pointing out the issues in the original advertisement or fixing it to be a more efficient
advertisement. This paper presented me with the most difficulty, at the start of the assignment I
had chosen three different original advertisements before I finally settled on one, and even then I
had no idea if I would have enough to write about. This is where an assigned reading known as
Shift First Drafts helped me the most in the class, by pointing out that a first draft isnt going
to be written well, but rather a way to get ones ideas out on paper and decide what works well. I
created first drafts for each of the topics that I was considering and I ended up choosing an ad
from the Body by Victoria Secret campaign. The particular advertisement I chose overly
sexualizes women in an offensive nature, so I created an anti-ad that points out the various issues
which make this ad inhumane. I found it interesting to develop this argument and take apart each
and every detail of the original advertisement, which in result made it easier to complete the
assignment and contrary to what I had originally thought, it gave me more than enough to write
about. With this particular essay I believe the amount of time given to compose and edit each
draft is the cause for my improvement. It gave me enough time to contemplate and discuss with
my instructor and peers: which ad would I have the strongest argument for, which arguments
should be my main points, how I should organize and order the analysis points, and what creative
-
concept would best contribute to the anti-ad in order to place the largest emphasis on my
argument. Within this assignment, I feel as though I developed my former weaknesses:
introductory paragraphs and organizational elements, into what is now my strengths. I worked
hard to set up a strong introduction with describing the cause and effect of advertisements like
these on women of all ages and then I went on to organize my points to where each paragraph
led to the next with smooth transitions and relating ideas; something I had a problem with before
the start of this class.
Contrary to the expectations I had developed in my high school AP courses, I enjoyed
this class and believe I learned a great deal from it. Even though I still feel as though I need
improvement in my writing, specifically when writing conclusions, I have a better understanding
of what belongs in the ending paragraphs or conclusion of a piece, and how to lead up to it,
which is a better understanding than when I had began the course with. Each paper we wrote, I
felt as though I improved in my writing styles. In the first paper the organization of my writing,
in the second paper the organization, cohesiveness, introductory paragraph and developing of a
strong thesis statement, and in the third paper I was able to build on my improvements and create
a strong argumentative essay. At the end of the course I feel as though I am a completely
different writer than I was when I started, a more developed and complex writer.