Real Estate Institutional Investor Survey - Probitas...
Transcript of Real Estate Institutional Investor Survey - Probitas...
2008 © Probitas Partners
Real Estate Institutional Investor Survey
N o v e m b e r 2 0 0 8
C o n t e n t s
Introduction ....................................................................................... 1
The Private Equity Real Estate Fund Landscape ...................... 2
Institutional Investor Survey of Real Estate Investing ......... 3
Survey Findings: Overview ....................................................... 3
Profile of Respondents ............................................................ 3
Geographies of Investor Interest ....................................... 7
Targeted Areas of Interest .................................................... 7
Structural Issues & Emerging Managers ......................... 18
Greatest Fears .......................................................................... 21
Conclusion ................................................................................ 24
Funds Currently in or Coming to Market ............................... 25
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.1
I n t r o d u c t i o n
Probitas Partners is a leading independent knowledge, innovation and solutions provider to private markets clients. It has three integrated global practices that include placement of alternative investment products, portfolio management and liquidity management. These services are offered by a team of employee owners dedicated to leveraging the firm’s vast knowledge and technical resources to provide the best results for its clients.
n. [from Latin probitas: good, proper, honest.] adherence to the highest principles, ideals and character.
probity ¯ ¯˘
On an ongoing basis, Probitas Partners offers research and investment tools on the alternative investment market as aides to its institutional investor and general partner clients. Probitas Partners compiles data from various trade and other sources and then vets and enhances that data via its team’s broad knowledge of the market. Also on an ongoing basis, Probitas Partners surveys institutional investors in order to determine more directly their perceptions of various aspects of the market; and the survey of real estate investors included here is part of that process.
Included within this Real Estate Market Institutional Investor Survey is our listing of Real Estate and Hard Asset Funds In or Thought to Be Coming to Market over the Next 12 Months. (Investors more specifically interested in details on the infrastructure market should refer to our Infrastructure Market Review & Institutional Investor Survey, just released during October 2008.) A few important user notes on the funds listing:
• The list does not track funds smaller than $100 million or €75 million, as these are not often targeted by institutional investors;
• Information is collected from various data sources, but dynamically and accurately tracking when funds are launched and when they are finally closed is a difficult business. We constantly interact with investors and other industry sources in an effort to keep the data updated, and Probitas Partners appreciates receiving any corrections or updates which will help keep this listing as up to date as possible; and
• Probitas Partners relies upon its knowledge of the investment pace of previous funds, informal discussions with institutional investors and general partners, and its knowledge of emerging managers. Specifically, we do not seek confirmation of these estimates with general partners in order to avoid SEC public offering prohibitions.
For the same reason, Probitas Partners does not include in this listing information on funds it is currently offering; qualified investors seeking information on Probitas Partners’ placed funds should contact Probitas Partners directly in order to have the most complete picture of all institutional funds currently in the market.
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 2
$
in b
illio
ns
$100
$90
$80
$70
$60
$50
$40
$30
$20
$10
$0
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Q3 08
The Real Estate Fundraising Landscape
The fundraising market for private equity real
estate has expanded significantly over the
last five years, as demonstrated by Chart I.
The growth of interest in fund investing
outside the U.S. is highlighted by a significant
and increasing portion of funds raised
globally being Euro-denominated (roughly
a quarter of the current year’s total). When
observed in combination with the recent rapid
fluctuations in currency values in the market,
calculating global fundraising totals in a
single currency becomes difficult. However,
the trends in the various geographic markets
are converging: there is increasing investor
interest in international markets, with a
noticeable shift in many large fund groups
from a North American to a Global focus.
The capital markets have become increasingly
turbulent with issues in the U.S. sub-prime
residential market quickly developing into
global issues of liquidity and recession.
The volatility of the public markets has
caused many institutional investors to
experience portfolio allocation problems; the
commitment pace to all areas of alternative
investment has begun to slow significantly,
though the impact of these effects will not be
fully evident until 2009.
Chart I Global Real Estate Fundraising
Source: Probitas Partners
$11.7
$24.3
$76.5
$42.3
$93.1
$76.0
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.3
Institutional Investor Survey of Real Estate Investing
During October 2008, Probitas Partners conducted an online survey to gauge investor interest,
opinions, and perspective on investing in real estate funds. We received responses from 100
senior investment executives from Public & Corporate Pension Plans, Fund-of-Funds Managers,
Family Offices, Endowments & Foundations, Consultants & Advisors, Insurance Companies and
other agencies. The survey was completed in the midst of the current turmoil in the capital
markets and therefore may not fully reflect evolving investor opinion about what has become
an increasingly difficult market.
Survey Findings: Overview
The following summarizes the top-line findings
from the survey on investor preferences,
perspectives and practices:
• The largest concern of investors by far
is that credit problems in Western or
mature markets will dramatically impact
performance globally.
• Investors are much more focused on
opportunistic and value-added funds than
they are on core strategies.
• In North America, interest in fund
managers pursuing distressed strategies
has doubled, making it the leading area
of focus.
• In Europe, interest in the United Kingdom
has increased significantly since our last
survey, with interest in Germany and the
Nordic countries decreasing.
• In Asia, interest in India has fallen
noticeably while interest in China and
pan-Asian strategies has increased.
• As far as fund structure is concerned, there
is a strongly renewed focus on the level
of general partner financial commitment
to fund vehicles, reflecting concerns over
alignment of interest.
• Investors are interested in emerging
markets; however, they are concerned
about the lack of experience of the
managers investing in these markets.
Profile of Respondents
The first series of questions in the survey
created a profile of the respondents in order
to provide context to the results.
Respondents represented a wide range of
types of institutional investors including fund-
of-funds managers, insurance companies,
state and corporate pension plans, family
offices, banks, endowments, and consultants
& advisers. Fund-of-funds managers led in
responses at 21%, followed by endowments
at 16%.
As noted in Chart III, the majority of
respondents represented firms that are
headquartered in North America, with
the balance of respondents from Western
Europe and Asia. It is important to note
that insurance companies constituted a
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 4
Chart II Respondents by Investor Type“I represent a...”
Source: Probitas Partners
Chart III Respondents by Location of Firm’s Headquarters “My firm is headquartered in...”
Source: Probitas Partners
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Fund-of-Funds
Manager
Endowment Family Office
Insurance Company
State Pension
Plan
Consultant or Advisor
Corporate Pension
Plan
Foundation Bank Other
21%
16%13%
8%
5%
3%
14%
4%
12%
4%
Asia 5%Australia 5%
Middle East 2%
Western Europe 22%
North America 66%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.5
much greater segment of the respondents
headquartered outside of North America,
along with fund-of-funds.
There was significant diversity among
respondents by size of allocation to real estate
private equity in 2009, as noted in Chart IV.
Just over 40% of respondents replied that
they would commit under $50 million dollars
to real estate private equity in 2009, while
just under 17% of respondents intended to
commit $250 million dollars or more to the
asset class. The respondents targeting the
largest amounts for 2009 commitments
were based in Western Europe and
North America.
As noted in Chart V, a substantial majority
of respondents plan to keep their 2008 real
estate allocations constant for 2009, while
over a third report that they will be increasing
allocations. And while 6% reported that they
will decrease their private equity allocations
(an increase from no investors looking to
decrease last year), private equity real estate
seems to be considered an integral segment
of investment portfolios despite the ongoing
credit crisis.
The responses vary based on the geographic
region of the respondents’ headquarters.
For Asian and Middle Eastern respondents,
64% were looking to increase allocations
to private equity real estate. On the other
hand, roughly 60% of Western European and
North American respondents were looking to
keep their allocations the same, most likely
reflecting the fact that they have been active
investors in the sector for a longer time and
currently have large, seasoned portfolios.
Chart IV Private Equity Real Estate Allocation Targets“In 2009, we are looking to commit across all areas of private equity real estate...”
Source: Probitas Partners
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
10%
5%
$0
< $50MM $50MM-$150MM $150MM-$250MM $250MM-$500MM $500MM-$1B > $1B
40.4%
30.3%
13.1%
7.1%
4.0%5.1%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 6
There was wide diversity among respondents
about their real estate allocations as a
percentage of their overall portfolios, and a
general upward trend is apparent. Though
last year 31% of respondents had real estate
allocations of 3% or less of their assets, only
19% this year have such allocations. On the
other hand, 22% have an allocation of 13%
and above dedicated to real estate, and
nearly 50% have allocations of 10% or more
to the sector.
Chart V 2009 Appetite for Private Equity Real Estate“In 2009, we anticipate...”
Source: Probitas Partners
Source: Probitas Partners
Chart VI Private Equity Real Estate Allocations“What is your private equity real estate allocation as a percentage of total assets?”
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
0%-3% 4%-6% 7%-9% 10%-12% 13% and Above
18.5% 19.6%
14.1%
26.1%
21.7%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Increasing Our Targeted Private Equity Real Estate Commitments from 2008
Decreasing Our Targeted Private Equity Real Estate Commitments from 2008
Keeping the Same Private Equity Real Estate Commitments from 2008
38.4%
6.1%
55.6%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.7
Geographies of Investor Interest
When reviewing geographic allocations,
it is important to note that generally
most investors surveyed are more heavily
committed to their local markets. As
comparatively few respondents to the survey
came from the emerging and Asian markets,
allocations to the emerging markets and
Asia are somewhat lower on an overall basis,
though these allocations also reflect that
these are newer markets for global investors.
Also, as expected, a majority of the European-
based respondents have no current allocation
to North America as a result of FIRPTA and
other tax and reporting-related issues. Tax
issues show up as a recurring theme when it
comes to vehicle structure or concerns about
the market.
The results show that a significant amount of
capital will be devoted to real estate in North
America, and to a lesser extent, Europe, Asia,
and then globally-focused real estate funds.
There is significant and growing interest in
putting smaller allocation percentages into
Latin America, Central and Eastern Europe,
and other emerging markets.
Targeted Areas of Interest
The next part of the survey was meant to
determine investor attitudes toward the
fundraising market and return expectations
for private equity real estate funds. As
expected, respondents were most heavily
focused on opportunistic real estate and
value-added funds at the higher end of the
Chart VII Geographic Focus“For 2009, what percentage of your private equity real estate allocation do you expect to place in...?”
Source: Probitas Partners
Global North America Europe Asia Latin America Central & Eastern Europe Other Emerging Markets
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
No Allocation 1%-25% 25%-50% 50%-75% 75% and Above
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 8
Chart VIII Private Equity Real Estate: Strategies of Interest“What types of private equity real estate funds are you currently pursuing?”
risk/reward spectrum, while only 20% of
the respondents are pursuing a core/core
plus strategy. There is slightly more interest
in core strategies amongst Asian & Middle
Eastern respondents (at over 30%), though
opportunistic funds attract most interest in
all geographic markets.
The majority of respondents believe top
quartile Vintage 2009 private equity real
estate IRRs will range between 15%-20%
for funds focusing on the North American
and European markets. On the whole, the
response curve was skewed towards higher
IRRs for Vintage 2009 funds. Respondents
Source: Probitas Partners
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Core/Core Plus (8%-12%) Value Add (12%-16%) Opportunistic (16%+)
19.8%
69.2%
89.0%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.9
also have expectations of higher IRR ranges
in Asia, with the majority targeting IRRs in
the 20%-25% range, and 25% and higher for
emerging market funds in light of a higher
expectation of risk.
It is interesting to note that endowment
and foundation respondents to our survey
have lower IRR expectations than pension
plans for opportunistic funds. A number of
respondents had no particular expectations
for returns on the various emerging markets
because they had not focused attention on
these sectors.
We decided to ask about performance
multiple expectations as well as IRR
expectations for top-quartile opportunistic
funds. The results are detailed in Chart X.
Respondents tended to be bullish, with
44% of respondents believing that Vintage
2009 opportunistic funds would generate
return multiples greater than 2x, while 48%
tended towards the 1.75x-2.0x range.
Chart IX Performance Expectations“For top quartile vintage 2009 opportunistic funds, I expect Net IRRs over their lives to be...”
Source: Probitas Partners
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
25% or Higher 20%-25% 15%-20% 10%-15% Less than 10% No Expectation
Global North America Europe Asia Latin America Central & Eastern Europe Other Emerging Markets
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 10
Chart XI reflects respondents’ average
commitment size to real estate funds. Over
40% of investors plan to commit between
$10 million to $25 million to each fund, while
34% typically commit $10 million or less.
Unsurprisingly, the respondents who intend
to commit $50 million or more to a single
fund are pension plans.
Chart X Performance Expectations“I would expect equity return multiples for opportunistic private equity real estate funds to range between...”
Chart XI Average Commitments“Our average commitment to any private equity real estate fund is...”
Source: Probitas Partners
Source: Probitas Partners
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
1.5x-1.75x 1.75x-2.0x 2.0x-2.5x 2.5x-3.0x 3.0x+
7.5%
48.4%
36.6%
6.5%
1.1%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
$0-$10MM $10-$20MM $20-$25MM $25-$50MM $50-$100MM $100+MM
34.0%
28.7%
12.8%
16.0%
7.4%
1.1%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.11
In the following question, we asked investors
what benchmarks they use to measure return
for their overall real estate portfolio. On the
whole, NCREIF hurdles and flat absolute rates
were used by the majority of respondents;
public market benchmarks and the Townsend
Chart XII Portfolio Benchmarks“What benchmarks do you use for the return of your overall portfolio?”
Source: Probitas Partners
Closed-End Fund Index were used to a lesser
extent. For Western European investors, flat
absolute rates were the dominant response
used by over 70% of respondents, while
responses in the “Other” category were quite
scattered and without a dominant trend.
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
NCREIF Hurdles
Flat Absolute Rates
Other Public Market Benchmarks
Townsend Closed-End Fund Index
42.0%
35.2%
25.0%
12.5%
5.7%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 12
In terms of selecting the most important
fund drivers for sector target focus, 72% of
respondents reported no particular internal
focus or direction aside from pursuing
the “best funds” in the market. Fifty-three
percent of survey respondents emphasize
maintaining established relationships with
fund managers returning to market.
This suggests that respondents are most
interested in maintaining relationships that
grant them specialized access to positions
in popular funds or proprietary information
about specific opportunities. A quarter of
respondents target funds that correspond
to their portfolio diversification needs, and
Chart XIII Drivers for Sector Target Focus“My sector focus in 2009 is being driven by...”
Source: Probitas Partners
only 2% of respondents are driven by the need
to deploy significant amounts of capital.
A dramatically increased number of investors,
22% (compared to 4% from last year), feel
the need to expand outside home markets.
Access to co-investments did not seem to
play a major role in investment focus of
survey respondents. Geographically, there
was a significant emphasis on portfolio
diversification and the need to expand outside
of home markets by Asian investors, whereas
North American and European investors are
more focused on maintaining established
relationships locally.
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
My Institution Will Pursue the Best Funds & Managers Available in the Market 71.7%
Maintaining Established Relationships with Fund Managers Returning to Market this Year 53.3%
My Institution’s Need to Diversify Its Real Estate Private Equity Portfolio 25.0%
Need to Expand Outside My Home Markets 21.7%
Investing in Emerging Markets 20.7%
Targeting Funds That Will Provide Access to Co-Investments 10.9%
Other 10.9%
My Strategic Focus on Joint Ventures & Direct Transaction 8.7%
My Need to Deploy Significant Amounts of Capital Allocated to Private Equity Real Estate 2.2%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.13
As shown in Chart XIV, investors in North
America today are focused on Distressed
Strategies (up to 59% from 31% last year),
the only sector to garner the interest of more
than 30% of respondents. As credit and
capital market corrections continue to be
felt across the real estate market, there is
continued interest shown in debt/mezzanine,
office, industrial, and multi-family strategies,
with weaker interest in retail, hotel & leisure,
and narrowly-focused geographic strategies.
Chart XIV North American Investment Focus“In the North American market, my focii are...”
Source: Probitas Partners
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Distressed Strategies 59.1%
Debt/Mezzanine 29.5%
Office 28.4%
Industrial 14.8%
Multi-Family 13.6%
Other 9.1%
Retail 8.0%
Specific Geographic Sectors 6.8%
Hotel & Leisure 5.7%
I Don’t Invest in North America 5.7%
Environmentally Friendly Strategies 4.5%
I Only Invest in North America Through Global Funds 3.4%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 14
Chart XV Europe Investment Focus“In the European market, my focii are...”
In the European market, the survey focused
on geographic as opposed to sector interest.
As detailed in Chart XV, the strongest area
of focus was the United Kingdom (likely as
a distressed opportunity) where 36% of
respondents are focused, a notable change
from last year’s survey where the United
Kingdom ranked only fourth. Conversely,
interest in Germany and the Nordic Region
declined significantly from last year. There
was also strong interest in Pan-European
and Eastern European funds and, as in the
previous survey, relatively little interest in
Southern Europe.
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
United Kingdom 36.4%
I Only Invest in Europe Through Pan-European Funds 29.5%
Eastern Europe 26.1%
Germany 21.6%
Central Europe 19.3%
Nordic Region 14.8%
France 14.8%
Spain 10.2%
I Don’t Invest in Europe 8.0%
Other 4.5%
Italy 0.0%
Source: Probitas Partners
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.15
China topped the list of most interesting
Asian markets at 40% of the respondents,
moving ahead of India which had topped
last year’s list. Certain investors felt that
too much money had been directed into
the Indian real estate market over the last
several years, and pan-Asian and Japan-
focused funds also moved up in the list to
pass India. Interest in real estate investing in
Southeast Asia, Singapore, Korea, Australia
and Vietnam trails significantly behind the
top three countries in the region. Twenty
percent of respondents invest in Asia only
through global funds, while 36% are focused
on pan-Asian funds.
Chart XVI Asian Investment Focus“In the Asian market, my focii are...”
Source: Probitas Partners
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
China Pan-Asian Funds
Japan India I Only Invest in Asia
Through Global Funds
I Don’t Invest in
Asia
SE Asia Singapore Korea Australia Vietnam Other
39.1%
35.9%
23.9%
13.0%10.9%
5.4%
29.3%
9.8%
20.7%
7.6%
1.1%
4.3%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 16
Chart XVII Secondary Investment Activity“In the private equity real estate secondary market...”
Source: Probitas Partners
Secondary transactions are relatively new to
the private equity real estate fund market,
though there are an increasing number of
real estate secondary fund specialists raising
funds to address this market as it matures.
The emergence of this secondary market is
illustrated by the fact that 17% reply that
they are in the process of assessing and/
or implementing a real estate secondary
program, while 7% actively invest in real estate
secondary funds and 4% purchase positions
directly in the market. In addition, 7% of
respondents have sold or are considering
selling positions from their own portfolios.
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
We Are Not Active in Secondaries in Any Manner
We Are in the Process of Assessing/ Implementing a Real
Estate Secondary Investment Program
We Actively Invest in Real Estate
Secondary Funds
We Have Sold or Are Considering a Sale of Real Estate Positions
in the Secondary Market for Portfolio
Management Purposes
We Actively Purchase Real Estate Fund Positions in the
Secondary Market
71.1%
16.7%
6.7% 6.7%4.4%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.17
While the previous numbers are not
surprising and reflect little change from
last year, Chart XVIII shows a remarkably
increased awareness in the market as 45%
of respondents indicated that they may
consider real estate secondaries at a later
date or after their programs are more fully
developed. This forecast for increased
activity mirrors the experience in the private
equity arena where the development of the
secondary market over the past five years
has been dramatic and reflects an earlier
maturity of that sector.
Chart XVIII Reason for Lack of Secondary Investment Activity“For those that do not invest in the private equity real estate secondary market...”
Source: Probitas Partners
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
We May Consider
Real Estate Secondary Investing at a Later Date
After Our Program is More Fully Developed
Our Current Portfolio Allocation Serves Our Needs
We Do Not Believe the Market is Currently Developed Enough to Warrant a
Specific Allocation
It is Not Within Our Investment
Mandate
We Find the Return Profile is
Unattractive
Other
44.9%
30.4%
13.0%
7.2%
4.3%
13.0%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 18
Structural Issues & Emerging Managers
The next section of the survey focused on
various structural issues as well as the
interest of investors in taking on new fund
manager relationships. As summarized in
Chart XIX, survey respondents indicated
that the most crucial structural feature of a
fund is the level of general partner financial
commitment to the vehicle, with 77% of
respondents marking this as a primary area
of focus -- the only issue to be noted by more
than 50% of respondents. The issue is one
that is directly linked to alignment of interest;
it represents a much greater area of focus for
respondents than it was on last year’s survey,
where the distribution of carry between the
senior professionals was the top ranked
concern. Not surprisingly, the second ranked
area of focus on this year’s survey was the
overall level of management fees, an issue
that is also strongly linked to alignment of
interest.
There was also a concentration of concern
within the “Other” category on tax issues or
tax structures. Though not expressed in more
detail, these concerns are likely to be focused
on FIRPTA (for overseas investors) and UBTI
issues that affect investments in U.S.-based
funds and ECI issues impacting investors
investing in European opportunities.
Chart XIX Preferred Investment Structures“The issues I focus on most as far as fund terms or structures are concerned are...”
Source: Probitas Partners
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%
Level of General Partner Financial Commitment to the Fund 76.7%
The Overall Level of Management Fees 48.9%
Distribution of Carried Interest Between the Senior Investment Professionals 42.2%
Carry Distribution Waterfalls 38.9%
Structure or Inclusion of a Key Man Provision 32.2%
Cap on Fund Size 23.3%
Sharing of Carry and/or Investment Decision Making With a Third Party Sponsor 12.2%
Other 10.0%
Structure or Inclusion of a No Fault Divorce Clause 8.9%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.19
As detailed in Chart XX, a significant portion
of respondents are anticipating investing with
new managers in the coming year. Seventy-
six percent of respondents projected one to
four investments with new managers, with
18% responding that they would invest in
more than four new managers in the coming
year. Only 8% felt that they would not invest
in new managers at all. However, since the
survey was completed, further declines in
public stock valuations have exacerbated
the “denominator effect,” causing certain
investors to be overallocated to real estate.
As a practical matter, the amounts these
investors have to commit to both new
and existing fund manager relationships
may be restricted, and the full impact of
those restrictions may not be reflected in
the survey.
Chart XX Anticipated Number of New Fund Managers“I anticipate investing with how many fund managers in 2009...”
Source: Probitas Partners
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%0 1 to 4 5 to 9 10 and Above
7.8%
16.7%
75.6%
1.1%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 20
with new managers are heightened. Thus, it is
not surprising that respondents interested in
new managers are looking for differentiated
niche strategies and exceptional returns that
justify undertaking the lengthy diligence
process and the increased risk.
When selecting new managers, respondents
are heavily focused on track record and team
strength as key due diligence matters. Indeed,
for any investor, the due diligence involved in
underwriting new managers is extensive given
the risks associated with investing in funds
Chart XXI Key Characteristics of New Fund Managers“The key characteristics required to invest in a new manager are...”
Source: Probitas Partners
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Track Record Key Man and/or Team Reputation
Niche Strategy
Terms of Fund
Established Fund
Will Not Be Investing in Any New Managers
in 2009
Other
80.0%
50.0%
32.2%
25.6%
7.4%6.7%6.7%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.21
Finally, as far as investment vehicle structure
is concerned, although traditional investment
fund vehicles are most common in the
market, 58% of respondents would consider
investments in a “club” structure limited to a
handful of like-minded investors as opposed
to a standard fund with a broader limited
partner base. Club deals are often preferred
by larger, more mature programs seeking to
diversify or fill holes in their portfolio exposure,
or when management teams at such entities
have the experience and wherewithal to focus
energies on more concentrated strategies.
Often club deals bring the opportunity for
co-investment that again favors deeper
professional teams that can assess and act
on such opportunities.
Greatest Fears
The survey concluded by asking investors
about their greatest fears as we approach
2009. Not surprisingly, two-thirds of
respondents were worried that credit
problems in Western or mature markets
would dramatically impact performance. That
response was double that of the next greatest
fear: cap rate compression. Interestingly,
though a number of investors had expressed
interest throughout the survey in various
sectors of the emerging markets, one of the
fears that tied for the third greatest on the
list was the difficulty of finding quality and
experienced managers in emerging markets.
Chart XXII Club Deals“Would you consider investing in a club deal of 2-4 investors?”
Source: Probitas Partners
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Yes No
42.5%
57.5%
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 22
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
29.5%
23.9%
67.0%
20.5%
12.5%
10.2%
8.0%
2.3%
Credit Problems in Western or Mature Markets Will Dramatically Impact Performance
23.9%
23.9%
20.5%
12.5%
8.0%
8.0%
2.3%
2.3%
Capitalization Rates Will Compress, Significantly Impacting Existing Portfolio Valuations
I Want Exposure to Emerging Markets But There Are Too Few Quality or Experienced Managers in These Markets
Fund Structures and Underlying Property Management Fees Are Destroying Alignment of Interest Between Investors and Fund Managers
Too Much Money Is Chasing Too Few Quality Managers/Funds
Opportunistic Real Estate Is Most Effective As a Niche Strategy and Too Much Money Is Being Raised Overall in the Sector
Mega Funds are Flooding the Market With Capital; They May Not Be Able Effectively to Put the Money to Work
Currency Risk Will Impact Valuations of My Foreign Real Estate Portfolio
Other
Access to Top Performing Managers is Becoming More Difficult
Access to Managers With Operational Capabilities is Limited
I am Overallocated to Private Equity Real Estate (Predominantly Due to the “Denominator Effect”)
My Real Estate Allocation is Too Small to Have a Significant Impact on Overall Performance
The Number of Funds I Have in My Portfolio is Too Large for My Firm Effectively to Monitor
Increased Fund Sizes Are Limiting My Access to Co-Investments
Equity is The “New Debt,” Which May Lead to a Dilution of Return Potential
Only 8% of respondents were concerned
that they were overallocated to the market
due to the “denominator effect” — a result
that would likely change if the survey were
administered today.
Lastly, a couple of interesting comments have
been reprinted from the “Other” response
section:
• The presumptuousness of fund managers
versus the value they actually add.
• I am not concerned about the above, but
concerned about what I don’t foresee.
Chart XXIII Greatest Fears“My Three Greatest Fears In the Private Equity Real Estate Market Are...”
Source: Probitas Partners
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.23
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 24
C o n c l u s i o n
Private equity real estate continues to be a significant sector of the institutional alternative investment market even amidst the current credit crisis. Investors continue to both deal with and capitalize on an environment in turmoil vis-à-vis their portfolio exposure.
On the basis of our survey and ongoing discussions with investors, we have reached several conclusions:
• The dominant concern of investors is that performance of legacy portfolios will be hit hard by credit problems and cap rate compression.
• Investors are increasingly pursuing distressed strategies in order to take advantage of the current market.
• There is a strongly renewed focus on alignment issues, especially on the level of general partner financial commitment to fund vehicles and the overall level of management fees when negotiating terms, reflecting increased investor concerns over alignment of interest.
• Though investors are interested in emerging markets in order to increase diversification and capitalize on expected growth, they continue to be concerned about the lack of experience of the managers investing in these markets.
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.25
R e a l E s tat e F u n d s i n M a r k e t o r Th o u g h t C o m i n g t o M a r k e t O v e r t h e N e x t 1 2 M o n t h sAs of November 2008
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Global Funds
Dune Real Estate Fund II/ Dune Capital Management
1,250 727 In Market U.S./Europe Diversified
N/A 2004 New York
DLJ Real Estate Capital Partners IV/ DLJ Real Estate Partners
2,500 1,150 In Market Global Diversified
www.credit-suisse.com 1996 New York; London; Zurich;
Tokyo
HDG Mansur International Property Fund/HDG Mansur
200 N/A In Market Europe/U.S. Diversified
www.hdgmansur.com 1982 London
Hines Global Fund/Hines 1,500 N/A Coming to Market
Global Diversified
www.hines.com 1957 Houston
ING Real Estate Global Opportunistic Fund/ING Real Estate Investment Management
1,500 N/A In Market Global Diversified
www.ingrealestate.com N/A London
Morgan Stanley Real Estate Fund VII Global/Morgan Stanley
10,000 8,000 In Market Global Diversified
www.morganstanley.com/realestate 1969 New York
OCM Real Estate Opportunities Fund IV/Oak Capital Management
1,000 692 In Market Global Diversified
www.oaktreecapital.com N/A Los Angeles
Starwood Global Opportunities Fund VIII/Starwood Capital Group
2,000 1,475 In Market Global Opportunistic
www.starwoodcapital.com 1991 Greenwich, CT
Starwood Hospitality Fund II/ Starwood Capital Group
2,000 900 In Market Global Hospitality
www.starwoodcapital.com 1991 Greenwich, CT
Walton Street Real Estate Fund VI/ Walton Street Capital
2,500 1,547 In Market Global Diversified
www.waltonst.com 1994 Chicago
WCP Real Estate Fund 2/ Westport Capital Partners
500 500 In Market Global Distressed
www.westportcp.com 2006 Westport, CT; El Segundo, CA;
Mumbai
North American Funds
AEW Partners VI/ AEW Capital Management
750 686 In Market U.S. Special Situations
www.aew.com 1981 Boston
AEW Senior Housing Investors/ AEW Capital Management
500 N/A In Market U.S. Senior Housing
www.aew.com 1981 Boston
Alcion Real Estate Partners II/ Alcion Ventures
500 152 In Market U.S. Opportunistic
www.alcionventures.com 2005 Boston
APCA Property Fund II/ Ashforth Paradigm Capital Advisors
150 52 In Market U.S. Diversified www.ashforthparadigm.com 1896 Boston
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 26
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
AREA Investment Fund VI/AREA 1,000 700 In Market U.S. Diversified www.apollorealestate.com 1993 New York
Arden Real Estate I/Arden Group 125 N/A In Market North America Distressed Hospitality
www.ardengroup.com 1989 Philadelphia
Bay Area Smart Growth Fund II/ Kennedy Wilson
125 N/A In Market California Diversified
www.kennedywilson.com 1988 San Francisco
BCOM Ullico Southern Fund/ Union Labor Life
350 N/A In Market U.S. Sunbelt Diversified
www.ullico.com 1925 Washington, D.C.
Beacon Capital Strategic Partners VI/ Beacon Capital Partners
6,000 4,000 In Market U.S. Office www.beaconcapital.com 1998 Boston
Berkshire Multifamily Value Fund II/ Berkshire Property Advisors
600 334 In Market U.S. Multifamily www.berkshireapartments.com 1969 Boston
Berman Enterprises Opportunity Fund/ Giuliani Partners & Berman Enterprises
500 N/A In Market N.Y.C./ Washington,
D.C. Diversified
www.giulianipartners.com 2004 New York
Big Rock Partners Opportunity Fund II/ Big Rock Partners
350 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.bigrockpartners.com 2006 Los Angeles; Chicago; Seattle
BlueStone Real Estate Capital/ BlueStone Real Estate Capital
200 N/A In Market U.S. Opportunistic
www.bluestonecap.com 1998 Philadelphia; Palm Beach
Bond Companies Sustainability Fund/ Bond Companies
350 N/A In Market U.S. Sustainable www.bondcompanies.com 1987 Los Angeles
Brandywine Opportunities Fund/ Brandywine Financial Services
500 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.brandywine-financial.com 1972 Chadds Ford, PA
Bruin Fund/ Thompson National Properties
250 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.tnpre.com 2007 Irvine, CA
Bryanston Real Estate Opportunity Fund II/Bryanston Realty Partners
250 150 In Market U.S. Distressed www.bryanstonrp.com 2004 Chicago
Cabot Industrial Value Fund III/ Cabot Properties
700 450 In Market U.S. Industrial www.cabotprop.com 1986 Boston
Cantor Real Estate Fund/ Cantor Fitzgerald
325 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.cantor.com 2008 New York
Canyon Johnson Urban Communities Fund/Canyon-Johnson Urban Funds
1,250 600 In Market U.S. Diversified www.cjuf.com 2002 Beverly Hills, CA
Centerline Opportunity Partners/ Centerline Capital Group
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.centerline.com 1999 New York
Cerberus Institutional Real Estate Partners II/Cerberus Real Estate Capital Management
3,000 890 In Market U.S. Distressed www.cerberuscapital.com 1994 New York; Los Angeles
Ceres Urban Realty Fund/ BlakelyStern Investment Advisors
250 100 In Market U.S. Diversified www.blakelystern.com 2003 New York
CityView LA Urban Land Fund I/ American CityVista & Saybrook Capital
100 N/A In Market California Diversified
www.americancityvista.com N/A San Antonio; Santa Monica
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.27
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Colony Realty Partners III/ Colony Realty Partners
233 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.colonyrealtypartners.com 1991 Irvine, CA; Boston; New
York
Consortium 4/Bernstein Companies 100 N/A In Market Mid-Atlantic Office
www.thebernsteincompanies.com 1933 Washington, D.C.
Cornerstone Hotel Income and Equity Fund II/Cornerstone Real Estate Advisors
600 300 In Market U.S. Hospitality www.cornerstoneadvisors.com 1994 Hartford
Covenant Apartment Fund VI/ Covenant Capital Group
300 159 In Market U.S. Multifamily www.covenantcapgroup.com 2001 Nashville, TN
Coventry Real Estate Fund III/ Coventry Real Estate Advisors
400 330 In Market U.S. Retail www.coventryadvisors.com 1998 New York
Crocker Partners IV/Crocker Partners 250 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.crockerpartners.com 2005 Boca Raton, FL
Debartolo Community Retail Fund/ Debartolo Development
400 N/A In Market U.S. Retail www.debartolodevelopment.com N/A Tampa, FL
E2M Value-Added Fund II/ E2M Partners
600 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.e2mpartners.com 2004 Dallas
ECM Income & Growth Fund III/ Equity Capital Management
250 100 In Market U.S. Diversified www.ecm-funds.com 1989 Chicago
Equastone Value Fund 3/Equastone 350 172 In Market U.S. Diversified www.equastone.com 1993 San Diego
Fremont Strategic Property Partners III/ Fremont Realty Capital
750 500 In Market U.S. Real Estate Operating Companies
www.fremontrealtycapital.com 1997 San Francisco
Guardian Realty Fund III/ Guardian Realty Investors
500 114 In Market Washington, D.C. Office
www.guardian-realty.com N/A Bethesda, MD
Greater Washington Life Sciences Fund/JBG Real Estate Services
300 N/A In Market Greater Washington D.C.
Area
www.jbg.com 1960 Chevy Chase, MD
Grosvenor New York Multifamily Fund/ Grosvenor Investment Management
300 N/A In Market New York Multifamily
www.grosvenor.com N/A Philadelphia
Guardian Realty Fund III/ Guardian Realty Investors
500 113 In Market U.S. Diversified www.guardianrealty.com N/A Bethesda, MD
H/2 Special Opportunities/ H/2 Capital Partners
500 N/A In Market U.S. Special Opportunities
N/A 2008 Stamford, CT
Haveland Property Investors/ Haveland Estates
200 N/A In Market U.S. Office & Multifamily
www.havelandprop.com 2005 Stamford, CT
HDG Mansur Opportunity Fund I/ HDG Mansur
350 N/A In Market SE & SW U.S. Diversified
www.hdgmansur.com 1982 London
Heitman Strategic Finance Partners/ Heitman Real Estate Investment Management
300 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.heitman.com 1966 Chicago
Helios Real Estate Fund I/Adler Group 100 N/A In Market U.S. Commercial www.adlergroup.com N/A Miami
High Performance Green Fund/ Thomas Properties Group
275 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.tpgre.com 1996 Los Angeles
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 28
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
High Street Real Estate Fund III/ High Street Equity Advisors
350 400 In Market U.S. Diversified www.hsequity.com 2002 Boston
Hudson Realty Capital V/ Hudson Realty Capital
500 350 In Market U.S. Diversified www.hudsonrealtycapital.com 2003 New York; Portland, ME;
Miami
Hunter Chase Real Estate Opportunity Fund/Hunter Chase & Co.
250 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.hunterchase.com 2001 Irving, TX; Carlsbad, CA
Hutensky Capital Partners II/ Hutensky Group
150 N/A In Market U.S. Shopping Center
www.hutenskygroup.com 1979 Hartford
Integral Urban Fund I/ The Integral Group
150 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.integral-online.com 1993 Atlanta
Integrated Capital Hospitality Fund/ Integrated Capital
200 N/A In Market N. America Diversified
www.integrated-capital.com 2003 Buffalo, NY
JP Morgan Urban Renaissance Property Fund/JP Morgan Asset Management
500 N/A In Market U.S. Urban www.jpmorgan.com N/A New York
Kelton Real Estate/Kelton Companies 100 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.keltoncompanies.com 2008 Phoenix, AZ
Kennedy Wilson Property III/ Kennedy Wilson
1,000 N/A In Market U.S./Japan Diversified
www.kennedywilson.com 1988 Beverly Hills, CA
KMF Senior Generation Fund/ KMF Senior Housing Investors
300 N/A In Market U.S. Senior Housing
www.kmfseniorhousing.com N/A Chicago
L&B Diversified Strategy Partners/ L&B Realty Advisors
400 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.lbgroup.com 1981 Dallas
L&B Medical Properties Partners II/ L&B Realty Advisors
100 N/A In Market U.S. Medical Office
www.lbgroup.com 1981 Dallas
Lexin AmTrust Real Estate Partners II/ Lexin Capital
150 75 Coming to Market
U.S. Diversified www.lexincapital.com 2004 New York
Lincoln Multifamily Acquisition Fund/ Lincoln Property
250 N/A In Market U.S. Multifamily www.lincolnproperty.com 1965 Dallas
Lowe Hospitality Investment Partners II/ Lowe Enterprise Investors
350 266 In Market U.S. Hospitality www.loweenterprises.com 1972 Los Angeles; Denver;
Irvine, CA
Lowe Structured Investment Fund/ Lowe Enterprises Investors
150 N/A In Market U.S. Distressed www.loweenterprises.com 1972 Los Angeles; Denver;
Irvine, CA
LRG Capital Real Estate Partners Fund I/LRG Capital Real Estate Ventures
N/A N/A In Market California Commercial
www.lrgcapital.com N/A Larkspur, CA
Lubert-Adler Real Estate Fund VI/ Lubert-Adler
2,600 1,700 In Market N. America Diversified
www.lubertadler.com 1997 Philadelphia
MacFarlane Urban Real Estate Fund III/MacFarlane Partners
1,500 1,000 In Market U.S. Urban www.macfarlanepartners.com 1987 San Francisco
MacFarlane Special Situations Fund I/ MacFarlane Capital Partners
300 N/A In Market U.S. Distressed www.macfarlan.com 1984 Dallas
Metzler U.S. Real Estate Fund II/ Metzler Realty Advisors
300 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.metzlerna.com 1976 Seattle
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.29
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
MGRA Genesis Value Fund II/ MayfieldGentry Realty Advisors
N/A 150 Coming to Market
Southern U.S. Diversified
www.mayfieldgentry.com 2003 Detroit
Miller Global Fund VI/ Miller Global Properties
400 290 In Market U.S. Diversified www.millerglobal.com 1996 Denver; New York
Morrison Street Fund III/ NBS Real Estate Capital
100 26 In Market U.S. Diversified www.nbsrecapital.com 2003 Portland
Next Block Medical Fund II/ Valencia Capital Management
500 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.valenciacm.com 2004 Dallas
Omega Opportunity Fund I/Omega Commercial Finance Corporation
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Distressed www.omegafinancial.com N/A Miami
Onex Real Estate Partners II/ Onex Real Estate Partners
600 230 In Market U.S. Diversified www.onex.com 2005 New York
Page Mill Properties 3/ Page Mill Properties
500 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.pagemill.com 1993 Palo Alto
Palisades Regional Investment Fund II/ Palisades Financial
200 42 In Market U.S. Diversified www.palfi.net 1995 Fort Lee, NJ
Parmenter Realty Fund IV/ Parmenter Realty Partners
500 245 In Market Southern U.S. Office
www.parmco.com 1989 Miami
Perseus Realty Partners II/ Perseus Realty Partners
200 210 In Market U.S. Diversified www.perseusrealtypartners.com 2005 Washington, D.C.
Phillips Edison Shopping Center Fund IV/Phillips Edison & Co.
500 N/A In Market U.S. Shopping Center
www.phillipsedison.com 1990 Baltimore
Prescott GNLP Corporate Partners/ Prescott GNLP Capital
200 N/A In Market U.S. Office www.prescott-gnlp.com 2007 New York
Prudential Senior Housing Partners IV/ Prudential Real Estate Investors
500 300 In Market U.S. Senior Housing
www.prudential.com/prei N/A Parsippany, NJ
Ram Realty Partners II/ Ram Development Company
350 N/A In Market SE U.S. Diversified
www.ramrealestate.com N/A Palm Beach Gardens, FL
Residential Income and Value-Added Fund II/Tuckerman Group
375 150 In Market U.S. Residential www.thetuckermangroup.com 1998 Rye Brook, NY
Rockwood Capital Real Estate Partners Fund VIII/Rockwood Capital
1,000 1,094 In Market U.S. Diversified www.rockwoodcap.com 1995 San Francisco
RP Retail Entrepreneurial Fund III/ RP Realty Partners
400 50 In Market U.S. Retail www.rprp.com N/A Beverly Hills, CA
RXR RexCorp Real Estate Opportunity Fund II/RXR Rexcorp Realty
800 N/A In Market New York Area Diversified
www.rexcorprealty.com N/A Uniondale, NY
Schuster Realty Partners I/ Schuster Group
100 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.theschustergroup.com 1989 Seattle
Sentinel Multifamily Value-Added Fund/Sentinel Real Estate Corporation
350 N/A In Market Southern U.S. Multifamily
www.sentinelcorp.com 1969 New York
Sentinel Realty Partners VII/ Sentinel Real Estate Corporation
250 141 Coming to Market
U.S. Diversified www.sentinelcorp.com 1969 New York
SKB Real Estate Investors 2/ ScanlanKemperBard Companies
500 161 In Market U.S. Diversified www.skbcos.com 1993 Portland
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 30
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Southwest Next Fund I/ Southwest Next Capital Management
500 N/A In Market SW U.S. Distressed Residential
www.southwestnext.com 2008 Phoenix, AZ
Square Mile Partners III/ Square Mile Partners
850 561 In Market U.S. Distressed www.squaremilecapital.com 2006 Greenwich, CT
STAG Investments V/ STAG Capital Partners
400 50 In Market U.S. Diversified www.stagcapital.com 2003 Boston
Stockbridge Real Estate Fund III/ Stockbridge Capital Partners
2,500 1,000 In Market U.S. Diversified www.sbfund.com 2003 San Francisco
Strategic Partners Urban Fund/ Strategic Capital Partners
100 N/A In Market U.S. inner city www.strategiccapitalpartners.net 2005 Chicago
Strategic Partners Value Enhancement Fund II/Strategic Capital Partners
500 250 In Market U.S. Diversified www.strategiccapitalpartners.net 2005 Chicago
Sunbelt Residential Distress Fund/ Askenazy & Agus Ventures
250 N/A In Market U.S. Distressed www.aaventures.com 1991 Boca Raton, FL
TA Associates Realty Fund IX/ TA Associates Realty
1,750 1,500 In Market U.S. Diversified www.tarealty.com N/A Boston
TIAA-CREF U.S. Real Estate Fund I/ TIAA-CREF
300 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.tcasset.com 2004 New York
TriContinental Fund X/ Tricon Capital Group
CAD 200 N/A In Market Canadian Diversified
www.triconcapital.com 1988 Toronto
TriGate Property Partners/ TriGate Capital
350 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.trigatecapital.com N/A Dallas
Trinity Restoration Fund/ Trinity Investment Partners
300 N/A In Market U.S. Environmentally
Responsible
www.trinity-ip.com 2007 Stockton, CA
Western National Realty Fund II/ Western National Realty Advisors
300 50 In Market U.S. Diversified www.wng.com 1981 Irvine, CA
European Funds
Aberdeen European Shopping Property Fund/Aberdeen Property Investors
€ 525 N/A In Market Europe Retail www.aberdeenpropertyinvestors.com
1986 London
Aberdeen Property Fund France & Southern Europe/ Aberdeen Property Investors
€ 500 N/A In Market S. Europe Retail www.aberdeenpropertyinvestors.com
1986 London
Aerium Fairfield Special Opportunities Fund/Aerium & Fairfield Greenwich Group
€ 500 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.aerium.com 2003 London
AIG European Real Estate Partners II/ AIG Global Real Estate
€ 500 € 180 In Market Europe Diversified
www.aiginvestments.com 1987 London; Moscow
Alternative Property Income Venture/ AXA Real Estate Investment Managers
€ 400 N/A In Market France Diversified
www.axaprivateequity.com 1996 Paris
Ariosto/Aedes Real Estate € 375 N/A In Market Italy Diversified www.aedes-immobilaire.com N/A Milan; Rome
Blackstone RE Partners Europe III/ Blackstone Group
€ 3,000 € 1,550 In Market Europe Diversified
www.blackstone.com 1992 London; Paris
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.31
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Bluehouse Accession Property III/ Bluehouse Capital
€ 250 € 150 In Market SE & E. Europe Diversified
www.bluehousecapital.com 2005 Athens
Bouwfonds Germany Residential Fund/ Bouwfonds Asset Management
€ 300 N/A In Market Germany Residential
www.bouwfonds.com 1946 Netherlands
BPT Hansa Lux/Baltic Property Trust € 300 N/A In Market Germany Commercial
www.balticpropertytrust.com 2001 Copenhagen
CA Immo New Europe/ CA Immo International
€ 400 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Commercial
www.caimmointernational.com 1999 Vienna
CapMan Hotels RE/ CapMan Real Estate
€ 400 N/A In Market Scandinavia Hospitality
www.capman.fi 2005 Helsinki
CEE Residential Fund/ Realkapital Partners
€ 200 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Residential
www.realkapital.no N/A Oslo
Central and Eastern Europe Real Estate Fund/Faisal Private Bank Real Estate
€ 150 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Diversified
www.faisalfinance.com 1982 Geneva
Cordea Savills German Retail Fund/ Cordea Savills
€ 1,000 N/A In Market German Retail www.cordeasavills.com 2005 London
Cordea Savills UK Property Ventures I Fund/Cordea Savills
€ 400 N/A In Market U.K. Property www.cordeasavills.com 2005 London
Core Italian Property Fund/ AXA Real Estate Investment Managers
€ 200 N/A In Market Italy Diversified www.axaprivateequity.com 1996 Paris
Corestate German Commercial/ Corestate Capital
€ 500 N/A In Market German Commercial
www.corestate-capital.ch 2006 Zurich
DIB Real Estate Fund/ Dubai Islamic Bank
500 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.dib.ae 1975 Dubai
Domani Sereno Real Estate Fund/ Fondamenta
€ 150 N/A In Market Italy Senior Housing
www.fondamentasgr.com 1998 Milan
ECM International Real Estate Fund/ Equity Capital Management
250 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.ecm-funds.com 1989 Chicago; Bern
Endurance Health Care/ Orco Property Group
€ 200 N/A In Market Germany Healthcare
www.endurancefund.com 2005 Luxembourg; Prague; Paris
Endurance Logistics and Light Industrial/Orco Property Group
€ 200 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Industrial
www.endurancefund.com 2005 Luxembourg; Prague; Paris
Endurance Office II/ Orco Property Group
€ 200 € 150 In Market C. Europe Office www.endurancefund.com 2005 Luxembourg; Prague; Paris
European Hotel Ventures/ AXA Real Estate Investment Managers
€ 450 N/A In Market European Hospitality
www.axa-reim.com 1999 Paris
European Logistics Income Venture/ AXA Real Estate Investment Managers
€ 300 N/A In Market Europe Warehouses
www.axa-reim.com 1999 Paris
European Retail Income Venture 2/ AXA Real Estate Investment Managers
€ 500 € 700 In Market Europe Retail www.axa-reim.com 1999 Paris
Evans Randall Opportunity Fund/ Evans Randall
£1,000 N/A In Market U.K. Commercial www.evansrandall.com 1993 London
Fondo Azzurro/ Henderson Global Investors
€ 250 N/A In Market Italy Retail www.henderson.com 1934 London
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 32
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Forum European Realty Income III/ Forum Partners
€ 500 € 251 In Market European Opportunistic
www.forumpartners.com 2002 London
Frogmore Real Estate Partners II/ Frogmore Real Estate Partners
£400 £330 In Market U.K. Diversified www.frogmorefund.com 2001 London
German Aktiv Property Fund/ Teesland iOG
€ 370 N/A In Market Germany Diversified
www.teesland.com N/A London; Berlin; Frankfurt
German Retail Investment Property Fund/Morley Fund Management
€ 300 N/A In Market Germany Diversified
www.morleyfm.com 2004 London
German Shopping Centre Fund/ Henderson Global Investors
€ 1,200 N/A In Market German Retail www.henderson.com/property 1934 London; Frankfurt
Global Emerging Property Fund II/ Global Finance
€ 350 € 150 In Market S. Europe Diversified
www.globalfinance.gr 1991 Athens
Griffin Property Finance Fund/ Griffin Property Finance
€ 250 N/A Coming to Market
Poland Diversified
N/A N/A Warsaw
Gulf Atlantic Real Estate II/ Gulf Finance House
N/A N/A In Market U.K. Commercial,
Sha'riah Compliant
www.v2.gfhouse.com 1999 Bahrain
H1 Hotelfund/H1 Hotelentwicklungs € 275 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Hospitality
www.h1hotelfund.com 2007 Vienna
Heitman European Industrial Property Partners/Heitman
€ 200 N/A In Market Europe Industrial www.heitman.com 1966 Chicago
Heitman European Property Partners VI/Heitman
€ 600 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Diversified
www.heitman.com 1966 Chicago
Hexagone/Aviva Morley Property Funds Management
€ 210 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.avivainvestors.co.uk 1968 London
Iberia/Norfin € 200 N/A In Market Iberia Diversified www.norfin.eu 1999 Lisbon
IMO Pan-Iberian Retail/ Imorendimento
€ 200 N/A In Market Iberia Diversified www.imorendimento.com 1992 Porto, Portugal
ING Property Fund Eastern and Central Europe/ ING Investment Advisors
€ 400 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Diversified
www.ingim.com N/A The Hague
IVG European Core+Office/ IVG Immobilien
€ 250 N/A In Market W. Europe Office www.ivg.de 1916 Bonn
JP Morgan Greater Europe Opportunistic Fund/ JP Morgan Asset Management
€ 500 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.jpmorgan.com 1895 London
Kenmore Europe Fund/ Kenmore Property Group
£400 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.kenmore.co.uk 1986 Glasgow; Edinburgh
Kenmore French Regional Office Fund/ Kenmore Property Group
€ 100 N/A In Market French Office www.kenmore.co.uk 1986 Glasgow; Edinburgh
LaSalle European Ventures III/ LaSalle Investment Management
€ 1,250 € 335 In Market Europe Diversified
www.lasalle.com 1978 Chicago; Paris
LaSalle UK Ventures II/ LaSalle Investment Management
£400 £240 In Market U.K. Diversified www.lasalle.com 1978 Chicago; Paris
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.33
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
LogAxes/ Morley Fund Management Property
€ 158 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Diversified
www.morleyfm.com 2004 London
Logistis III/AEW Europe € 350 € 218 In Market Europe Logistics www.aeweurope.com N/A Paris; London
Mesa West Real Estate Income II/ Mesa West Capital
400 150 In Market U.S. Mezzanine www.mesawestcapital.com N/A Los Angeles
Meyer Bergman Eastern Europe Retail Fund/Meyer Bergman
€ 600 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.meyerbergman.com 1970 London; Paris; Berlin
Moor Park Real Estate Fund III/ Moor Park Capital
€ 1,500 N/A In Market W. Europe Diversified
www.moorparkcapital.com 2005 London; Oststeinbek,
Germany
Mosaic Central and Eastern European II/Mosaic Property
€ 200 € 100 In Market C. & E. Europe Diversified
www.mosaicpropertyllp.com 2005 London; Budapest
NIBC European Real Estate Fund I/ NIBC
N/A N/A Coming to Market
W. Europe Diversified
www.nibcapital.com N/A The Hague
Nordic Aktiv Fund II/Teesland IOG € 150 € 300 In Market Nordic Region Retail
www.teesland.com 2004 London; Copenhagen; Stockholm;
Malmo
Orion European Real Estate Fund III/ Orion Capital Managers
€ 650 € 476 In Market Europe Diversified
www.orioncapman.com 1999 London
Parc d'Activites/Valad Property Group € 500 N/A In Market France Industrial www.valad.com.au 1995 Sydney; London
Poteza Real Estate Fund/ Poteza Equity Management
€ 150 N/A In Market Eastern/Central Europe
Diversified
www.poteza.si N/A Lubljana, Slovenia
Pradera Central & Eastern Fund/ Pradera - AM
€ 400 N/A In Market Central/Eastern Europe
Diversified
www.pradera.com 1999 London; Madrid; Milan; Athens
Pradera European Retail Fund II/ Pradera - AM
€ 400 € 500 In Market S. Europe Retail www.pradera.com 1999 London; Madrid; Milan; Athens
Realkapital European Opportunity II/ Realkapital Partners
€ 250 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.realkapital.no N/A Oslo
Realstar European Capital I/ Realstar Group
€ 300 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.realstargroup.com 1974 Toronto
Rynda en Primeur II/ Rynda Property Investors
N/A € 140 Coming to Market
France Diversified
www.ryndaproperty.com 2005 Paris
SGAM AI France Property Fund/ SGAM Real Estate
€ 250 N/A In Market France Diversified
www.sgam-ai.com 1999 Paris
Sierra Portugal Fund/Sonae Sierra € 300 N/A In Market Portugal Shopping Center
www.sonaesierra.com 1989 Lisbon
St Wenceslas Property Fund/ Hunter Property Fund Management
€ 350 N/A In Market C. Europe Diversified
www.hunterpropertymanagement.co.uk
1999 Edinburgh
Symmetry II Fund/aAim Group £200 £200 In Market Europe Commercial
www.aaim.com 2008 London
Tellesma Fund/Tellesma £1,000 N/A In Market U.K. Sustainability
N/A 2008 London
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 34
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
The Sava Fund/Chayton Capital € 150 € 115 Coming to Market
S.E. Europe Diversified
www.chaytoncapital.com N/A Bucharest; Sofia; London
Tritax Polska No. 1 Fund/Tritax Group € 92 N/A In Market Poland Diversified
www.tritax.co.uk 1995 London
UK Actively Managed Property Shopping Fund/ Protego Real Estate Investors
€ 250 N/A In Market U.K. Diversified www.protegorealestate.com 2004 London
Valartis Real Estate Opportunities Income Fund/Valartis Group
€ 200 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.valartis.ch 2006 Zurich
Valartis Residential Healthcare Fund/ Valartis Group
€ 125 N/A In Market Europe Medical www.valartis.ch 2006 Zurich
Weinberg Real Estate Partners I/ Weinberg Capital Partners
€ 150 N/A In Market France Diversified
www.weinbergcapital.com 2005 Paris
West Balkan Real Estate Fund/ Illyria Capital
N/A N/A In Market E. Europe Diversified
www.illyriacapital.com 2007 Kastel Novi, Croatia
Asia Funds
aAIM India Real Estate Fund/ aAIM Group
2000 N/A In Market India Diversified www.aaim.com 2003 London
Actis India Real Estate Fund/ Actis International
300 N/A In Market India Diversified www.act.is 1948 London; Cairo; Beijing; Mumbai
Aetos Capital Asia III/Aetos Capital 2,500 2,200 In Market Asia Diversified www.aetoscapital.com 1999 New York; Tokyo; Hong Kong
AMP Select Property Portfolio III/ AMP Capital Investors
AUD 300 200 AUD In Market Australia www.ampcapital.com.au N/A Sydney
Ashington Development Fund III/ Ashington Capital
AUD 200 80 AUD In Market Australia Diversified
www.ashingtongroup.com.au 1999 Sydney
Asia Pacific Property Fund/ Morley Fund Management Property
£105 N/A In Market Asia/Australia Diversified
www.morleyfm.co.uk N/A London
Australia Opportunity Business Space Fund/Ascendas
SGD 500 N/A In market Australia Office www.ascendas.com 2001 Singapore
Banyan Tree Fund Indochina/ Banyan Tree Holdings
400 N/A In Market Vietnam Diversified
www.banyantree.com 1984 Singapore
Banyan Tree Fund China/ Banyan Tree Holdings
700 N/A Coming to Market
China Diversified www.banyantree.com 1984 Singapore
Capital Asia Partners Real Estate Fund/Capital Realty
JPY 150,000
N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.capserv.com 1998 Tokyo
Capmark Asia Real Estate Partners/ Capmark Financial Group
750 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.capmark.com 1999 San Mateo, CA; Shanghai; Hyderabad; Tokyo; Taipei
Carlyle Asia Real Estate Fund II/ The Carlyle Group
1,000 410 In Market Asia Diversified www.carlyle.com 1987 Washington, D.C.; Beijing
CholaLand Fund I/CholaLand Advisers 100 N/A In Market Malaysia Diversified
N/A 2008 Malaysia
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.35
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
CITIC Capital China Real Estate Investment Fund III/ CITIC Capital Holdings - Real Estate
500 N/A In Market China Diversified www.citiccapital.com 2002 Hong Kong
Colony Asia Investors II/ Colony Capital
500 151 Coming to Market
Asia Diversified www.colonyinc.com 1991 Los Angeles; Seoul; Shanghai;
Hong Kong; Taipei; Tokyo
Cordea Nichani Indian Opportunities I/ Cordea Savills & Nichani Group
200 N/A In Market India Diversified www.cordeasavills.com N/A Maharastra
CPI Capital Partners Asia Pacific II/ Citi Property Investors
1,500 1,291 In Market Asia Diversified www.citigrouppropertyinvestors.com N/A New York
CR Al Rajhi China Real Estate Growth Fund I/Harvest Capital Partners
500 N/A In Market China Diversified www.harvestcapital.com.hk N/A Hong Kong
DaVinci Japan Real Estate Partners V/ KK DaVinci Advisors
3,500 N/A In Market Japan Diversified www.davinci-advisors.com N/A Tokyo
DHFL Venture Capital Fund/ Dewan Housing Finance
250 N/A In Market India Residential www.dhfl.com 1984 Mumbai
Duet India Hotels/Duet Private Equity 200 N/A In Market India Hospitality www.duetgroup.com 2005 London
Duet Japan Special Situations Fund/ Duet Private Equity
300 N/A In Market Japan Diversified www.duetgroup.net 2002 London
Enterprise Fund/Pacific Star Group 1,000 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.pacificstargrp.com 2000 Singapore
Fortress Asia Realty Fund/ Fortress Investment Group
1,000 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.fortressinv.com 1998 Hong Kong; Shanghai; Tokyo;
New York
Forum Asia Realty Income Fund III/ Forum Partners
1,000 792 Coming to Market
Asia Diversified www.forumpartners.com 2002 Beijing
Fudo Capital II/ CLSA Capital Partners - Fudo Capital
750 430 In Market Asia Diversified www.clsacapital.com/fudo 2004 Hong Kong
IL&FS Milestone Fund/IL&FS 255 N/A In Market India Diversified www.ilfsindia.com N/A Mumbai
Indiareit Offshore Fund II/ Indiareit Fund Advisors
600 200 In Market India Diversified www.indiareit.com 2006 Mumbai
Indochina Land Holdings 3/ Indochina Capital
500 265 In Market Vietnam Diversified
www.indochinacapital.com 1999 Ho Chi Minh City; Hanoi;
Danang
Indospace Logistics Parks/RealTerm Global & Future Capital Holdings
385 N/A In Market India Industrial www.realterm.com 1990 Mumbai
ING Real Estate Asia Retail Fund/ING Real Estate Investment Management
600 N/A Coming to Market
Asia Supermarkets
www.ingrealestate.com 1996 Hong Kong; Beijing; Seoul
ING Real Estate China Opportunity Fund II/ING Real Estate Investment Management
700 600 Coming to Market
China Diversified www.ingrealestate.com 1996 Hong Kong; Beijing; Seoul
ING Real Estate China Residential Fund II/ING Real Estate Investment Management
700 350 Coming to Market
China Residential
www.ingrealestate.com 1996 Hong Kong; Beijing; Seoul
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 36
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
ING Real Estate Japan Property Fund/ING Real Estate Investment Management
910 N/A Open-Ended
Japan Diversified www.ingrealestate.com 1996 Hong Kong; Beijing; Seoul;
ISG China Real Estate Fund/ ISG Capital Management
100 N/A In Market China Diversified www.isgfn.com 2002 Shanghai; New York
Japan Value Added Fund III/ RREEF Real Estate
JPY 30,000
N/A In Market Japan Diversified www.rreef.com N/A New York
KBC Japan Property Fund/ KBC Asset Management
€ 350 N/A In Market Japan Diversified www.bkbcam.com 2000 Dublin; London; New York
Kotak India Real Estate Fund II/ Kotak Mahindra Investments
350 160 In Market India Diversified www.kotak.com 2005 Mumbai
Limetree Capital Partners II/ LimeTree Capital Partners
500 200 In Market Emerging Beachfront
www.limetreecapital.com 2007 Hong Kong
Mapletree India-China Fund/ Mapletree Investments
1,500 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.mapletree.com.sg N/A Singapore; Shanghai
Mekong Brahmaputra Clean Development Fund/Dragon Capital
100 N/A In Market Asia Environmentally
Responsible
www.dragoncapital.com 1994 Ho Chi Minh; Hanoi; Bath,
U.K.
Milestone Domestic Scheme II/ Milestone Capital
INR 5,000
N/A In Market India Diversified www.milestonecapital.in 2007 Mumbai
Millennium Spire Fund II/ Millennium Spire Asset Management
300 N/A In Market India Diversified www.millenniumglobal.com 1994 New Delhi; Singapore; New York
Ostara China Fund/ Ajia Partners
400 N/A In Market China Shopping Centers
www.ajiapartners.com 2002 Hong Kong; Tokyo; Seoul;
Beijing
Pacific Alliance China Land Fund/ Pacific Alliance Group
1,000 N/A Coming to Market
China Diversified www.pacific-alliance.com 2002 Hong Kong
Pacific Star Arrow Vietnam Fund/ Pacific Star Holdings
340 N/A In Market Vietnam Diversified
www.pacificstargrp.com 2000 Singapore
Pacific Star Asia Fund Select Concept/ Pacific Star Holdings
2,000 N/A In Market Asia Value-add www.pacificstargrp.com 2000 Singapore
Pradera China Retail Fund/ Pradera AM
250 N/A In Market China Retail www.pradera.com 1999 London; Athens; Istanbul; Milan;
Prague
Protego Qudos Vietnam Property Fund/Protego Real Estate Investors
200 N/A In Market Vietnam Residential
www.protegorealestate.com 2004 London; Singapore
Raffles City China Fund/ Capitaland
1,000 N/A In Market China Hospitality
www.capitaland.com 2000 Singapore; Hong Kong; London
Real Estate Capital Partners Asia II/ Real Estate Capital Partners Asia
400 221 In Market Asia Diversified N/A 2008 Singapore
Red Fort Real Estate India Fund II/ Red Fort Capital
550 350 In Market India Diversified www.redfortcapital.com 2006 New Delhi; Mumbai
Rutley Indian Property/ Rutley Capital Partners
500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.rutleycapitalpartners.com 2005 London; Mumbai
Saffron Real Estate India Fund/ Saffron Asset Advisors
500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.saffronadvisors.com 2005 Mumbai
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.37
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Secured Capital Japan Residential Fund IV/Secured Capital Japan
1,250 758 In Market Asia Diversified www.securedcapitalco.jp 2006 Tokyo
SGAM AI Japan Property Fund/SGAM Alternative Investments Real Estate
€ 200 N/A In Market Japan Diversified www.sgam-ai.com N/A Paris
Standard Chartered Istithmar Asia RE Opportunities Fund/Standard Chartered Istithmar RE Management
750 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.standardchartered.com 1969 Singapore
Tishman Speyer GSC China Fund/ Tishman Speyer
500 N/A In Market China Diversified www.tishmanspeyer.com 1978 New York; Beijing;
Shanghai
Tishman Speyer India Fund/ Tishman Speyer
1,000 350 In Market India Diversified www.tishmanspeyer.com 1978 New York; Chennai
Triangle Real Estate India Fund/ Old Mutual Investment Group Property Investments
500 N/A In Market India Retail www.omigpi.com 1845 Cape Town
Trikona India Real Estate Fund/ Trikona Capital
500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.trikonacapital.com 2006 New York
Triseas Korea Property Fund II/ Doran Capital Partners
600 210 In Market Korea Diversified www.dorancapital.com 2002 Seoul
Trump Organization India Fund/ Trump Organization
1,000 N/A In Market India Luxury www.trump.com 1980 New York
UBS Gemdale China Real Estate Fund/ UBS Realty Investors
300 N/A In Market China Diversified www.ubs.com/realestate N/A Beijing; Guangzhou;
Shanghai
UBS K Rajeha Corp. India Real Estate Fund/UBS Realty Investors
500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.ubs.com/realestate N/A Mumbai
Unitech International Realty/ Unitech Realty
500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.unitechgroup.com 1974 Haryana, India
Urban Infrastructure Opportunity Fund II/Reliance Industries
1,000 50,000 INR
In Market India Diversified www.ril.com 1993 Mumbai
Vietnam Property Fund/PRUPIM 500 N/A In Market Vietnam Diversified
www.prupim.com N/A London
Vinaland Fund I/Vinacapital N/A N/A Coming to Market
Vietnam Diversified
www.vinacapital.com 2003 Ho Chi Minh City; Hanoi; Hong Kong
Walton Street Capital India Fund I/ Walton Street Capital
1,000 N/A In Market India Diversified www.waltonst.com 1994 Chicago
Latin America
Americas Real Estate Opportunity Fund/Falcon Real Estate
500 N/A In Market Latin America Diversified
www.falconreal.com 1991 New York
Carlyle Latin America Real Estate Partners/The Carlyle Group
425 N/A In Market Latin America Diversified
www.carlyle.com 1987 Washington, D.C.;
Mexico City; Sao Paolo
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 38
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
JER Latin America I/JER Partners 750 N/A In Market Latin America Diversified
www.jer.com 1980 Maclean, VA; Sao Paolo
LaSalle Mexico Fund/ LaSalle Investment Management
500 N/A In Market Mexico Diversified
www.lasalle.com 1978 Chicago; Mexico City
Latam Residential Fund/ Pramerica Real Estate Investors
1,000 N/A In Market Mexico Hospitality
www.pramericarei.com N/A Parsippany, NJ
Paladin Realty Latin America Investors III/Paladin Realty
500 200 In Market Latin America Diversified
www.paladinreit.com 1995 Los Angeles
Patria Brazil Real Estate Fund II/ Patria Investimentos
400 N/A In Market Brazil Diversified ww.patriainvestimentos.com.br 1988 Sao Paolo
PLA Retail Fund I/ Prudential Real Estate Investors
425 N/A In Market Mexico Retail www.prudential.com/prei 1970 Parsippany, NJ
Vision Brazil Real Estate Opportunities I/Brazil Real Estate Opportunities Manager and Moore Capital Management
250 N/A In Market Brazil Diversified www.visionbrazil.com N/A Sao Paolo
Walton Street Mexico Fund I/ Walton Street Capital
350 N/A In Market Mexico Diversified
www.waltonst.com 1995 Chicago
Middle East/North Africa
DIB Real Estate Fund/ Dubai Islamic Bank
500 N/A In Market Middle East Region
www.dib.ae 1975 Dubai
Easy Property Investment Fund/ Easy Property Group
100 N/A In Market Middle East Region
www.easypropertygroup.com N/A Dubai
Global GCC Real Estate Fund II/ Global Investment House
500 100 In Market GCC Diversified www.globalinv.net N/A Safat, Kuwait
Hospitality Development Fund/ Abu Dhabi Investment House, Ithmaar Bank & Gulf Finance House
300 N/A In Market GCC Hospitality www.adih.ae 2005 Abu Dhabi
Lewis Charles Abu Dhabi Property Fund/Lewis Charles
100 N/A In Market Abu Dhabi/ Dubai Diversified
www.lewischarles.com N/A London
Markaz Real Estate Opportunities Fund/Kuwait Financial Centre Real Estate
200 N/A In Market MENA Region www.markaz.com 1974 Safat, Kuwait
Nauerz & Noell Advanced Property Fund/Nauerz & Noell
€ 2,000 N/A In Market Abu Dhabi/ Dubai Diversified
www.nauerz-noell.de 2000 Frankfurt
SGAM Almak Development/SGAM Real Estate Investment Management
100 N/A Coming to Market
Morocco Diversified
www.sgam-ai.com N/A Paris
SHUAA Hospitality Fund I/ Shuaa Capital
500 N/A In Market Saudi Arabia Hospitality
www.shuaacapital.com 1979 Dubai
Siraj Hospitality & Tourism Fund/ Siraj Capital
SAR 1,000
N/A In Market GCC Diversified www.sirajcapital.com 2006 Dubai; Riyadh
TNI Real Estate Development Fund/ The National Investor
200 100 In Market GCC Diversified www.tni.ae 1995 Abu Dhabi; Dubai
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.39
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Other Emerging Markets
Amstar Global Property Fund II/ Amstar Global Partners
350 340 In Market Emerging Markets
Diversified
www.amstarglobal.com 2007 Hamilton, Bermuda
Aberdeen Property Fund Russia/ Aberdeen Property Investors
€ 500 N/A In Market Russia Diversified
www.aberdeenpropertyinvestors.com
1986 Copenhagen; St. Petersburg
ACCEPT B.V./AKRON Group 300 N/A In Market E. Europe Diversified
www.akron-group.com N/A Vienna
Amstar Ukraine Property Fund I/ Amstar Europe
€ 250 N/A In Market Ukraine Diversified
www.amstareurope.com 2007 Kiev
Capital Alliance Property Investment Company/Capital Alliance Real Estate
479 N/A In Market W. Africa Diversified
www.aca-web.com 1997 Lagos
Capitalworks Real Estate Fund/ Capitalworks Investment Partners
500 N/A In Market South Africa www.capitalworksip.com 2008 Benmore, South Africa
Duet Golden Horn/Duet Private Equity 150 N/A In Market Turkey Diversified
www.duetgroup.net N/A London, UK
East Capital Russian Property Fund/ East Capital
€ 200 N/A In Market Russia Retail www.eastcapital.com N/A Stockholm; Moscow; Paris
EPG East Euro Asia Property Fund/ ACTEEUM Group
300 N/A In Market E. Europe Diversified
www.acteeum.com 2006 Netherlands
Hansa Baltic Real Estate Fund/ Hansa Investment Funds
€ 100 N/A In Market Baltic Region Diversified
www.hansa.ee/funds 1994 Riga, Latvia
Jensen Russian Real Estate Fund 2/ Jensen Group
350 101 In Market Russia Diversified
www.jensen.ru 1991 St. Petersburg
Kenmore/Watan Real Estate Fund/ Kenmore Property Group & Watan Investments
N/A N/A Coming to Market
GCC Diversifed www.kenmore.co.uk 1986 Dubai; London
MIL Equity Partners Eastern Europe/ EquityInvest
250 N/A In Market C. & E. Europe Diversified
www.eifunds.com N/A Boston; Budapest
Paladin Realty Eurasia Investors/ Paladin Realty
300 N/A In Market Turkey Diversified
www.paladinreit.com 1995 Los Angeles
PIK Real Estate Fund/ PIK Capital Partners
1,000 N/A In Market Russia Diversified
www.pik-capital.ru N/A Moscow
Rutley Capital East African Property Fund/Knight Frank & ICEA Asset Management
300 N/A In Market E. Africa Diversified
www.rutleycapitalpartners.com 2005 Nairobi
South Africa Workforce Housing Fund/ International Housing Solutions
280 N/A In Market S. Africa Residential
www.intlhousingsolutions.com N/A Johannesburg; Baltimore;
London; Boston
UFG Real Estate Fund II/ UFG Asset Management
300 130 In Market Russia Diversified
www.ufgam.com 1997 Moscow
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 40
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Mezzanine and Debt Funds
AREA European Commercial Property Debt Fund/AREA
1,000 N/A In Market Europe Debt www.apollorealestate.com 1993 New York
Basalt Capital CMBS Fund/ Basalt Capital
500 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.basaltcapital.com 2008 Chicago
BlackRock Carbon Capital III/ BlackRock Realty
750 380 In Market U.S. Mezzanine www.blackrock.com 1998 New York
BlackRock Mortgage Investors Fund/ BlackRock Realty
2,000 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.blackrock.com 1998 New York
Blackstone Real Estate Special Situations Fund/Blackstone Real Estate Advisors
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Mezzanine www.blackstone.com 1992 New York; Chicago;
Los Angeles
Duet European Real Estate Debt Fund/ Duet Private Equity
€ 300 N/A In Market Europe Debt www.duetgroup.net 2002 London
Fillmore West Fund/ Fillmore Capital Partners
1,000 420 In Market U.S. Debt and Mezzanine
www.fillmorecap.com 2004 San Francisco; Worthington,
OH
FSI Credit Opportunity Fund/ Capitaline Hill Partners
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Distressed www.fsicapital.com 1995 New York; Cincinnati
Goldman Sachs Real Estate Mezzanine Partners/Goldman Sachs
2,500 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.goldmansachs.com 1996 New York
Guggenheim Structured Real Estate Fund IV/Guggenheim Real Estate
1,500 875 In Market U.S. Debt www.guggenheimrealestate.com 2001 New York
Hillenbrand Global Mortgage Fund/ Hillenbrand Partners
750 N/A In Market Global Debt www.hillenbrandpartners.com 1995 Chicago; Auburn, AL
ING Clarion Debt Opportunity Fund III/ING Clarion
1,000 500 In Market U.S. Debt www.ingclarion.com N/A New York
Investcorp Real Estate Credit Fund/ Investcorp
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.investcorp.com 1982 Bahrain
LoanCore Capital Fund I/LoanCore Capital & DivcoWest Properties
3,000 N/A In Market U.S. Debt N/A 2008 Greenwich, CT
Lowe Real Estate Income and Growth Partners II/Lowe Enterprises Investors
200 201 In Market U.S. Mezzanine www.loweenterprises.com 1972 Los Angeles; Denver;
Irvine, CA
LNR Archetype Real Estate Debt Fund/ LNR Commercial Property Group
N/A N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.lnrcpg.com 1997 Newport Beach; Miami Beach
NYLIM Real Estate Mezzanine III/ NY Life Investment Real Estate
500 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.nylimrealestate.com N/A New York
OWS Mortgage Opportunity Master Fund/One William Street Capital
500 N/A In Market U.S. Debt N/A 2008 New York
Ponte Capital/Infinity Funding Group 1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.infinityfundsgroup.com 1993 Bohemia, NY
PREI Mezzanine Fund/ Pramerica Real Estate Investors
500 N/A In Market U.S. Mezzanine www.pramericarei.com N/A Parsippany, NJ
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.41
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
RCG Longview Debt Fund IV/ Ramius Capital Group
700 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.rcglongview.com 1999 New York
Selene Residential Mortgage Opportunity Fund/ Selene Investment Partners
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Debt N/A 2008 Uniondale, NY
Starwood Debt Fund II/ Starwood Capital Group
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.starwoodcapital.com 1991 Greenwich, CT
Sterling American Property VI/ Sterling American Property
700 610 In Market U.S. Debt www.sterlingamerican.com 1991 New York
TCW Credit Opportunities Fund/ TCW Real Estate
3,000 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.tcw.com 1971 Los Angeles
Transwestern Mezzanine Realty Partners III/Transwestern Investment Company
500 300 In Market U.S. Mezzanine www.transinvestco.com 1996 Chicago
Tremont Special Opportunity Debt Fund/Tremont Realty Capital
300 N/A In Market U.S. Debt www.tremontcapital.com 2000 Boston; Hartford; New York; Chicago;
Annapolis; Newport Beach
True North High Yield Investment Fund II/True North Management Group
500 110 In Market U.S. Distressed and Mezzanine
www.tninvestors.com 2004 White Plains, NY
Wilshire Income Fund/Wilshire Finance Partners
100 N/A In Market California Bridge Loans
www.wilshirefp.com 2008 Los Angeles
Secondaries
Belveron Real Estate Partners Fund/ Belveron Real Estate Partners
200 N/A In Market Real Estate Secondaries
www.belveronpartners.com 2006 San Francisco
CS Strategic Partners IV RE/ Credit Suisse
420 300 In Market Real Estate Secondaries
www.credit-suisse.com N/A New York
Landmark Real Estate Fund VI/ Landmark Partners
750 369 Coming to Market
Real Estate Secondaries
www.landmarkpartners.com 1989 Simsbury, CT; Boston
Madison Harbor Secondary Real Estate Fund of Funds/Madison Harbor
150 N/A In Market Real Estate Secondaries
www.madison-harbor.com N/A New York
Infrastructure
aAIM Infrastructure Fund/ aAIM Infrastructure
£2,000 N/A In Market United Kingdom www.aaim.com 2004 London
ABN AMRO Global Infrastructure Fund II/ABN Amro
€ 2,000 € 1,100 In Market Global Diversified
www.capital.abnamro.com 1994 Amsterdam; London
Actis Infrastructure Fund II/Actis 1,000 N/A In Market Asia and Africa www.act.is 2004 London
ADIC IL&FS Middle East Infrastructure/Abu Dhabi Investment Company
1,000 N/A In Market MENA www.adic.ae 2006 Abu Dhabi
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 42
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
ADIC-UBS Infrastructure Fund/ UBS Global Asset Management
600 N/A In Market MENA www.ubs.com 2002 Zurich
Alterna Core Capital Asset Fund/ Alterna Capital
1,000 N/A In Market U.S. Diversified www.alternacapital.com 2007 Westport, CT
AmKonzen Water Infrastructure Fund/AmKonzen Water Investments Management
320 N/A In Market Asia Water www.konzengroup.com 2008 Singapore
Ampere Equity Fund/Evelop € 500 N/A In Market W. Europe Diversified
www.evelop.com N/A Utrecht
Antin Infrastructure Partenrs Fund I/Antin Infrastructure Partners & BNP PAM Group
€ 1000 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
N/A 2007 Paris
Asian Giants Infrastructure Fund/ AMP Capital Investors
750 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.ampcapital.com.au 1998 Sydney
Atherstone India Invest Infrastructure Fund/Atherstone India invest
1,000 N/A Coming to Market
India Diversified www.aii-group.com N/A Geneva
Axis Infrastructure Fund/Axis Bank 500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.axisbank.com 1994 Mumbai
Baer Capital Infrastructure and Real Estate/Baer Capital Partners
500 N/A Coming to Market
India Diversified www.baercapital.com 2006 Dubai
Bunyah GCC Infrastructure Fund 150 N/A In Market MENA www.instratacapital.com 2007 Manama
Challenger Mitsui Emerging Markets Infrastructure Fund/Challenger Financial Services & Mitsui & Co.
1,200 N/A In Market Global Diversified
www.challenger.com.au 2008 Sydney; Tokyo
Citi Infrastructure Investors/Citigroup 3,000 N/A In Market U.S./Europe Diversified
www.citigroupai.com 2007 New York
Central American Mezzanine Infrastructure Fund/EMP Global
150 N/A In Market C. American Diversified
www.empglobal.com 2005 Washington, D.C.
CVC/Vineburg Infrastructure Fund/ CVC Capital Partners
€ 2,000 N/A Coming to Market
Europe Diversified
www.cvc.com 1981 London; Paris; Luxembourg;
Brussels; Milan
Darby Mexico Infrastructure Fund/ Darby Overseas Investments
200 N/A In Market Mexico Diversified
www.darbyoverseas.com 1994 Washington, D.C.
DIF Infrastructure Fund/ Dubai Investment Bank
500 N/A In Market Middle East Diversified
www.dif.eu 2005 Schipol, the Netherlands
Emerald Infrastructure Development Fund/Emerald Development Managers
€ 750 N/A In Market U.S. and U.K. N/A 1994 Belfast
Equiitx Fund I/Equitix £125 N/A In Market United Kingdom www.equitix.co.uk 2007 London
Eredene Capital India Infrastructure Fund/Eredene Capital
400 N/A In Market India www.eredene.com 2005 London
Fondi Italiani Per Le Infrastrutture/ F2i SGR
€ 2,000 N/A In Market Italy Focused www.f2isgr.it 2007 Milan
GS European Infrastructure Fund/ Goldman Sachs
€ 3,000 N/A Coming to Market
Europe Diversified
www.gs.com/pe 2006 New York; London
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish.43
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
GS Infrastructure Partners II/ Goldman Sachs
7,500 N/A In Market N. America, Europe
Diversified
www.gs.com/pe 2006 New York; London
Gulf One Infrastructure Fund I/ Gulf One Bank
2,000 N/A In Market GCC Diversified www.gulf1bank.com 2006 Bahrain
HBG Infrastructure/HBG Holdings 200 N/A In Market India/Pakistan Diversified
www.hbgholdings.com N/A Dubai
Henderson Infrastructure III/ Henderson Equity Partners
£600 £584 Coming to Market
Europe Diversified
www.hendersonprivatecapital.com 1985 London
India Infrastructure Advantage Fund/ ICICI Bank
1,000 N/A In Market India Diversified www.icicibank.com N/A Mumbai
IDFC Private Equity Fund II/ IDFC Private Equity
1,250 440 In Market India Diversified www.idfc.com 2004 Mumbai
IFC InfraVentures/International Finance Corporation
100 N/A In Market Emerging Diversified
www.ifc.org/funds 1956 Washington, D.C.
Indochina Infrastructure Holdings/ Indochina Capital Corporation
500 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.indochinacapita.com 1999 Ho Chi Minh City
ING Atlas European Infrastructure Fund/ING Real Estate Investment Management
€1,000 N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.ing.com N/A London
Israel Infrastructure Fund II/ Israel Infrastructure Fund
£200 N/A In Market Global Diversified
www.iif.co.il 2006 Tel Aviv
JP Morgan Asia Infrastructure Fund/ JP Morgan
1,500 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.jpmorgan.com/infrastructure 2006 Hong Kong; Singapore; Mumbai
KKR Infrastructure Fund/KKR 4,000 N/A Coming to Market
Global Diversified
www.kkr.com 1976 New York; Menlo Park; London;
Tokyo
LODH Macquarie Infrastructure Fund CHF 1,500
N/A In Market Europe Diversified
www.macquarie.com.au 2000 Sydney; London
Macquarie European Infrastructure Fund III/Macquarie
€ 5,500 € 4,600 In Market Europe Diversified
www.macquarie.com.au 2000 Sydney; London
Macquarie Global Infrastructure Fund III/Macquarie
500 AUD 490 In Market OECD www.macquarie.com.au 2000 Sydney
Macquarie India Infrastructure Opportunities Fund/Macquarie
2,000 N/A Coming to Market
India Diversified www.macquarie.com.au 2000 Sydney; Mumbai
Macquarie Infrastructure Partners II/ Macquarie
6,000 4,000 In Market North America Diversified
www.macquarie.com.au 2000 New York; Sydney
Macquarie Renaissance Infrastructure Fund/Macquarie & Renaissance Capital
1,500 N/A In Market Russia & Central Asia
www.macquarie.com.au 2000 Sydney; Moscow
MENA Infrastructure Fund/Dubai International Capital & HSBC Bank
500 N/A In Market MENA Region www.dubaiic.com 2005 Dubai
Millenium Private Equity Infrastructure Fund/Milennium Private Equity
500 N/A In Market Middle East Diversified
www.mpefunds.com 2006 Dubai
Confidential & Trade Secret © Probitas Partners 2008 Do not circulate or publish. 44
Fund Size (MM) in $U.S. Unless Marked
Note: Does not include funds currently being placed by Probitas Partners
Fund/Parent Current Last Market Status Strategy Web Site Year
Founded Offices
Mubadala Infrastructure Partners/ Mubadala Development Company, GE & Credit Suisse
N/A N/A In Market MENA Region www.mubadala.com.ae 2007 Abu Dhabi
Pan African Infrastructure Development Fund/South Africa Public Investment Commission
1,000 N/A In Market Africa Diversified N/A 2005 Pretoria
Perpetual Diversified Infrastructure Fund/Palisades Investment Partners
AUD 250 N/A In Market Australia Diversified
www.palisadespartners.com.au 2007 Sydney
Q India Fund/Quantum Equity Advisors
500 N/A In Market India Diversified www.qindiafund.com 1993 Mumbai
Rabo Bouwfunds Communication Infrastructure Fund/Bouwfunds Asset Management
€ 375 N/A In Market Netherlands Communications
www.bouwfunds.com 1946 Hoevelaken
RREEF North American Infrastructure Fund/Deutsche-RREEF
500 N/A In Market N. America Diversified
www.rreef.com N/A New York; Sydney; London
Santander Infrastructure II/ Capital Grupo Santander
€ 1,500 € 185 In Market Global Diversified
www.santanderprivateequity.com N/A Madrid
Saratoga Asia Fund II/ Saratoga Investama Sedaya
330 N/A In Market Asia Diversified www.saratoga.co.id 1998 Jakarta
Saudi-Spanish Infrastructure/ Arox Infrastructure
1,000 N/A In Market Saudi Arabia & Spain Diversified
N/A 2008 Zurich
SC IL&FS Asia Infrastructure Growth Fund/Standard Chartered and IL&FS
1,000 N/A In Market China & India Diversified
www.standardchartered.com 2008 Singapore; Mumbai
Transport Infrastructure Investment Company Fund/Transport Infrastructure Investment Company
€500 N/A In Market North America, South America,
Europe
N/A 2008 Lisbon
Troika Infrastructure Fund/ Troika Capital Partners
1,000 N/A In Market Russia Diversified
www.troika.ru 2006 Moscow
Vision Global India Infrastructure Fund/Vision Global Investments
1,000 N/A In Market India Diversified www.globalvisioninvestments.net N/A Financial Harbour, Bahrain
S a n F r a n c i s c o 425 California Street
Suite 2300
San Francisco, CA 94104
Tel 1.415.402.0700
Fax 1.415.402.0052
N e w Yo r k 1251 Avenue of the Americas
Suite 2390
New York, NY 10020
Tel 1.212.403.3662
Fax 1.212.403.3537
L o n d o n
Dudley House
36-38 Southampton Street
1st Floor
London WC2E 7HF
Tel 44 20 7845 5400
Fax 44 20 7240 3339