RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650...

20
RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report Kavin Ammigan 1 , Nikolaos Simos 2 , Frederique Pellemoine 3 1 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory Batavia, IL 60510, USA 2 Brookhaven National Laboratory Upton, NY 11973, USA 3 Michigan State University, FRIB East Lansing, MI 48824, USA RaDIATE Collaboration Meeting 19 May 2014 1 / 17 RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Transcript of RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650...

Page 1: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Kavin Ammigan1, Nikolaos Simos2, Frederique Pellemoine3

1Fermi National Accelerator LaboratoryBatavia, IL 60510, USA

2Brookhaven National LaboratoryUpton, NY 11973, USA

3Michigan State University, FRIBEast Lansing, MI 48824, USA

RaDIATE Collaboration Meeting19 May 2014

1 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 2: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

BNL BLIP irradiation experiment

+ Proton energy ∼ 180 MeV+ Irradiation performed in

tandem with isotopeproduction

+ 9 weeks of irradiation ofvarious graphite grade andC/C composite specimens

+ PIE at BLIP target processinglaboratory

2 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 3: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Irradiated graphite grades

Graphite grades

POCO

IG-430

SGL R7650

C2020

3D C/C composite

Irradiation parameters

Proton energy ∼ 180 MeV

σx ∼ 10 mm, σy ∼ 7 mm

Peak DPA ∼ 0.1

Peak temperature ∼ 200 ◦C

3 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 4: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Irradiated graphite grades

Graphite grades

POCO

IG-430

SGL R7650

C2020

3D C/C composite

Irradiation parameters

Proton energy ∼ 180 MeV

σx ∼ 10 mm, σy ∼ 7 mm

Peak DPA ∼ 0.1

Peak temperature ∼ 200 ◦C

3 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 5: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

PIE equipment

Tensile tester and specimen fixture

3/4 point flexural test fixture

Ultrasonic system

Dilatometer and high temperature furnace

4 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 6: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

PIE status and recent results

3 Tensile and thermal tests already performed on various graphitegrades1

3 Additional testing:

+ Mechanical (flexural) tests on 3D C/C specimens+ Electrical resistivity measurements to evaluate thermal

conductivity

1LBNE target material radiation damage from energetic protons of the Brookhaven Linear Isotope Production (BLIP) facility,http://www-radiate.fnal.gov/downloads.html

5 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 7: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Initial 3D C/C flexural test results

3 Un-irradiated specimens+ Consistent failure at the middle of the gage with 3 point

bending+ Flexural strength dependent on number of longitudinal fibers

along specimen gage

6 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 8: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

3 Irradiated specimens+ Specimens irradiated in both water and argon environment+ 0.05 DPA+ ∼ 4 fibers along gage

Unirradiated Irradiated (water) Irradiated (argon)0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

Fle

xura

l str

engt

h (M

Pa)

Flexural strength of 3D C/C composite

Unirradiated Irradiated (water) Irradiated (argon)0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

Fle

xura

l Mod

ulus

(M

Pa)

Flexural Modulus of 3D C/C composite

+ More specimen tests to compare for DPA effects

7 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 9: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

EDXRD experiment at NSLSObjective:

+ EDXRD studies of irradiated novel materials and compositesunder consideration in next generation fusion/fission reactorsand high-power accelerators

Irradiated array of materials relevant to LBNE and RaDIATE:+ Graphite: POCO, IG-430, SGL R7650+ Carbon composite: 3D C/C, 2D C/C+ Other: Ti-6Al-4V

Experiment performed:+ April 29 - May 6

Other potentially relevant materials:+ Gum metal, Super Invar, Tungsten

8 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 10: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

EDXRD experimental stageMulti-functional stage capable of handling realsize irradiated specimens, under vacuum, fourpoint bending state of stress and eventuallyheating/annealing via a portable, collimated laserbeam

Experimental stage at X17B1 beamline at NSLS

9 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 11: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

10 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 12: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Preliminary results

Irradiated graphite (IG-430) Irradiated C/C composite

11 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 13: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Future tests

+ Further flexural tests on 3D C/C composite+ Thermal conductivity measurements

+ Next EDXRD experimental window (summer 2014)+ Monochromatic high energy X-rays+ Laser induced annealing of specimens

12 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 14: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

13 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 15: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

14 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 16: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

15 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 17: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

16 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 18: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Future plans

+ New irradiation runs to achieve higher DPA and gas production+ PIE of old/failed graphite targets 2, e.g. NuMI target fins

+ Challengeså Irradiation cost and timeå Irradiation facilities: BLIP, FETS?

2 Irradiated Materials Table, http://www-radiate.fnal.gov/downloads.html

17 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 19: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Future plans

+ New irradiation runs to achieve higher DPA and gas production+ PIE of old/failed graphite targets 2, e.g. NuMI target fins

+ Challengeså Irradiation cost and timeå Irradiation facilities: BLIP, FETS?

2 Irradiated Materials Table, http://www-radiate.fnal.gov/downloads.html

17 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report

Page 20: RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report · Irradiated graphite grades Graphite grades POCO IG-430 SGL R7650 C2020 3D C/C composite Irradiation parameters Proton energy ˘ 180 MeV ˙ x ˘

Future plans

+ New irradiation runs to achieve higher DPA and gas production+ PIE of old/failed graphite targets 2, e.g. NuMI target fins

+ Challengeså Irradiation cost and timeå Irradiation facilities: BLIP, FETS?

2 Irradiated Materials Table, http://www-radiate.fnal.gov/downloads.html

17 / 17RaDIATE: Graphite Status Report