Qurrent Proposal

17
CLEA(N) Solutions Courtney Jurd Laura Kenney Elly Wagner Aleix Nadal i6124360, i6140960, i6142580, and i6141282 Tongersestraat 53 6211 LM Maastricht, Netherlands Phone: 043 388 3768 E-Mail: [email protected] Web: www.CLEANovelSolutions.experts.net How do we get society to more quickly adopt renewables? 30 November 2016 QURRENT NL

Transcript of Qurrent Proposal

CLEA(N) Solutions

Courtney Jurd

Laura Kenney

Elly Wagner

Aleix Nadal i6124360, i6140960, i6142580, and i6141282 Tongersestraat 53 6211 LM Maastricht, Netherlands Phone: 043 388 3768 E-Mail: [email protected] Web: www.CLEANovelSolutions.experts.net

How do we get society to more quickly adopt renewables?

30 November 2016 QURRENT NL

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 1

Table Of Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................ 2 Various Entrepreneurs……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….………….3

Raising Awareness for Green Energy Adoption .................................................. 4 Negative Impacts of Gray Energy…………………………….………………………………………………..…………….………….4

Relatable Issues……………………………………………….………………………………………………………..…………….………….4 Emotional Need for Action……………………………………………….………………………………………………………..………..5 Empowering Everyone to Make a Difference…………………………………………….………………………………………...5 A Collective Community………………………………………….………………………………………………………..…………….…..6 It's an Easy Win-Win for Everyone…………………………………….………………………………………………………..……….6 Developing Another Market of Opportunities……………………………….………………………………………………………7

Attractive Marketing Ideas .......................................................................... 7 Young Generation - Age 20 - 30…………………………….………………………………………………..…………….…………….8

Middle Generation - Age 30 - 60……………………………………………….………………………………………………………….9 Older Generation - Age 60+……………………………………………….………………………………………………………..…….10 Organizations…………………………………………….………………………………………......................................10 All Together………………………………………………………….………………………………………………………..…………….……10

Measuring Our Impact Growth .................................................................... 11 Social Return on Investment (SROI)…………………………….………………………………………………..…………….…….11

Logic Chain Model………………………………………….……………………………………………………………………………………12 The Output Approach………………………………………….………………………………………………………………………………12

Conclusion ............................................................................................ 13

Appendix .............................................................................................. 14

Refernce List ......................................................................................... 15

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 2

Introduction

Of the many challenges businesses take on, operating in a responsible and sustainable

manner may be the most noble. Choices of resources, efficient processes, and consideration for

not only the parties directly affected, but the planet as a whole has become increasingly

expected of business leaders. This is not a extent of commitment; more so, many organizations

directly address the most pressing issues threatening the planet and society along with their

mission. They form solutions to rightfully counter society dangers and increase social and

environmental wealth.

One such challenge facing our planet today, is the reliance on nonrenewable energies and

the impacts of their consumption. Reserve to production ratios around the world have been

falling in recent years, raising concerns of future scarcity while significant climate change also

directs attention to the 0.1% increased global fossil fuel CO2 emissions last year (see Figure 1 for

a more detailed graph) (“BP Statistical,” 2016, p7). Meeting these issues in a fashion both

traditionally Dutch and technologically progressive, Qurrent combats the harmful effects of

human energy usage by harnessing the wind and solar parks to provide energy at a competitively

reasonable cost to customers. Studies have shown that wind energy provides a sustained output

second to only hydroelectric in the realm of renewable energies while also keeping in mind that

wind resources are abundant world-wide (Panwar, Kaushik, & Kothari, 2011, p1517). The question

then comes down not to how to create alternatives for consumers, but how to engender societal

adoption of the renewable alternatives currently available?

To generate a measurable impact, Qurrent seeks to aid customers in diminishing their use

of electricity and gas. This goal of lowering consumption runs counter to market practices in

which organizations’ pursue financial goals linked with increased consumption to improve their

demand. With the realization that consumption practices are altering and harming the planet,

individuals and organizations must reassess their choices and acknowledge the resulting

consequences. Oftentimes, this evaluation minimizes consumption of goods and services that

have harmful effects. While such downsizing may benefit the planet, a reduction in demand is

detrimental to traditional profit-based businesses; therefore, most organizations do not wish for

this lifestyle change. The resulting issue presents sustainability-oriented organizations with a

unique conundrum of financially surviving in order to maximize social and environmental impacts,

all the while attempting to persuade consumers to alter their ingrained consumption habits.

Like many environmental enterprises, Qurrent acts to meet a triple bottom line: operating

under considerations of financial, social, and environmental impact. Often, these conflicting

goals can lead to difficulties simultaneously sustaining the business, attracting shareholders,

creating social value, and benefitting the planet. Both organizational and customer motives

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 3

deviate from typical self-interest and individual utility maximization. Qurrent’s value proposition

to customers is not solely one of value capture, but one of value creation with positive

externalities that improve the planet for all. Zahra describes this as “total wealth,”

acknowledging the economic and social benefits plus costs incurred, as well as the cost of

foregone opportunities. This equation allows ventures to shift resources to concentrate on

economic or social wealth creation while still increasing overall wealth (Zahra, 2009, p522).

Among individuals and organizations pursuing innovative solutions to generate overall wealth,

those who address ongoing social needs within broader social structures are qualified as “social

constructionists.” This Kirzenerian entrepreneur fills in the gaps where businesses and

governments are not providing adequate offerings. In Qurrent’s situation, the lack of green

energy providers in the Netherlands catalyzed the organization to provide existing technologies to

a country in need of renewable energy sources (Zahra, 2009). The crucial element of innovation is

delivered in their method of involving customers in strategic decisions as well as providing a way

to own the means of production through windmill share purchases or solar panel farms, as well as

monitoring energy production and consumption with the Qbox.

Various Entrepreneurs

Environmental entrepreneurs are set apart from other businesses due to their distinct

central drive for innovative social changes. Income is not the fundamental focus with these

entrepreneurs; it simple provides the means for achieving their social and environmental goals.

The balance between sustaining the environment and sustaining the organization is reached

through “perpetual reasoning.” This concept involves maintaining resource quality for as long as

possible, providing an array of benefits with each action, and making decisions with quality as the

objective (Parrish, 2009). A key amidst all of this is the continuance with resources, the

cornerstone of Qurrent’s business model and highest objective. As a sustainability-driven

enterprise, the perpetual reasoning has shaped it into an exclusive business model unmatched by

other energy providers currently in the Netherland market. A focus on enhancing and lengthening

the amount of time resources may be appreciated fits with the growing awareness of climate

effects and the desire to create a more livable planet for future generations.

As a young company (in operation for only two years), Qurrent represents a flexible

venture that is able to disrupt markets. Hockerts & Wüstenhagen focus on the impacts these

“emerging Davids” have on product innovation leading to new dominant designs, which are then

adopted by entire industries (2010). As new entrants to the industry, they are poised to provide

solutions without feeling trapped by a specific existing mindset or current assets, while refusing

to sacrifice their high standard goals. Of course the solutions provided are valuable in

themselves, but perhaps the greatest impact occurs when organizational “Goliaths” adopt the

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 4

technology and disseminate it with process innovation and economies of scale. Davids and

Goliaths simultaneously evolve and depend on one another; Davids provide novel solutions, with

Goliaths implementing them on a broader scale. The potential for Qurrent to alter the energy

industry and/or become a leader provides additional incentive for the organization to strategize

effectively, promote sustainability, and preserve its core mission. Though small, their impacts

may spread to larger organizations embodying the entrepreneurial saying of “reach exceed[ing]

their grasp” (Dees, 1998).

Raising Awareness for Green Energy Adoption

Society has being using conventional energy sources for years, slowly damaging the

environment, and subsequently human life. The negative externalities that result in the burning

of fossil fuels are finally getting recognized and consumers are responding in accordance to this

broadening awareness; however, most are still ignoring these harmful outcomes and continuing

with their habitual, unsustainable consumption. It’s a difficult task to convince individuals to

change their ways to experience a greener world, but it’s possible as we see the usage of

renewable energy sources slowly, but persistently increasing (“BP Statistical,” 2016, p5).

Negative Impacts of Gray Energy

Most people understand that fossil fuels emit greenhouse gases, and research on the

greenhouse effect is highly advertised. Despite all of this knowledge, the shift in thinking is very

gradual. With steady world population growth, total demand and consumption of energy is

projected to rise by two thirds in the next 15 years. If fossil fuels maintain their role as the

leading source of energy, this will result in continued rates of elevated emissions. It’s important

to share the negative impacts of these gray energies and capture the emission factor in a

quantitative value; coal releases 1.1800kg/kWh CO2 while wind for example releases a fraction of

that. To drive the issue even further, CO2 emissions are not the only contributors to the

heightened radiation within our atmosphere, but the great releases of SO2 and NOx from gray

energy sources also serve as indirect greenhouse gases (Islam, Hasanuzzaman, Rahim, Nahar, &

Hosenuzzaman, 2014, p2). Windmill and solar energy will cut these emission numbers immensely

as the gases are only released during the initial production of the sources and then sparingly

during usage.

Relatable Issues

Educating about these negative effects seems straightforward and simple, but in order to

truly trigger a response from the people there needs to be a personal connection. Yitshaki

discusses the role that passion, importance, and similarity play in evoking a committed effort

(Yitshaki & Kropp, 2016, p213). These qualities form a meaningful belief and help overcome

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 5

failures and uncertainties with intuition, all while remaining rational and consistent. These carry

over to the adoption of green energy. Consumers need to relate impact to their lives in order to

spark a desire for critical change; passion for this social and environmental energy issue will

motivate new behaviors. Comparing this climate change issue to other significant topics may

widen people’s eyes. The process of connecting and ranking importance allows for heightened

conceptualization resulting in a response, and for our case, exposes the detrimental effects of

fossil fuels. Take clean drinking water for example as it’s clear how tainted water negatively

effects on one’s body/life, yet the available alternatives that create a better situation are not

being globally accessed. Outlining and relating the causes and effects of separate well-known

problems will give individuals a new angle on the situation; they will have a framework to relate

this severe issue to. Individuals are triggered in many ways, so diversifying the delivery with such

analogies would broaden interpretations of gray energy’s costly outcomes.

Emotional Need for Action

Even with such knowledge, it’s easy for people to simply ignore issues like this. When

significant issues remain untouched it doesn’t only do an injustice to the individual, but also the

ones they love and society as a whole. With research showing global fossil fuel CO2 emissions

continuing to rise, we can’t ignore this issue forever (“BP Statistical,” 2016, p5). Social

movements led by confident change agents have developed in hopes of pushing green energy.

These people or groups serve as role models that are willing to attack critical issues (Dees, 1998,

p4). They don’t want to wait around and rely on others to make a difference, so they instead

take action. Sharing these brave advances forces others to realize their guilty of laziness.

Emotional pulls like this are used in a variety of situations and are quite successful in influencing

groups of people. Some people will react to the numerical data but personal experience and

classroom learning shows that others are solely influenced when they are mentally or emotionally

confronted. Framing the issue of gray energy as a challenge will arouse some people to act and

join the crowd around them. When others witness progress like this, fears dissipate and

previously insurmountable problems become practical. Clear examples of such established

groundwork should shift the ease of action perspective from destructive fossil fuels to attainable

and less harmful green energy (Dees, 1998, p5).

Empowering Everyone to Make a Difference

Knowledge is key, so quantifying, advertising, and relating the negative repercussions of

burning fossil fuels with our rising energy consumption while showcasing the ease of switching,

will assist change. Every individual makes a difference when it comes to green energy.

Campaigning on the basis that individual involvement is simple but contributes considerably to

the cause will appeal to people’s desire for direct impact. People yearn for empowerment, and

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 6

this situation opens the door to a choice that shows their influence on the environmental and

social world. Choosing to use green energy is similar to “voting” for a better the world;

maintaining the environment as well as changing the way one lives their life. People need to be

shown that investing in green energy is taking an individual but meaningful stance with many

others to shape the future of the world (Parrish, 2010, p517).

A Collective Community

Spreading green energy impact extensively within specific communities will generate a

unified view and a bond impossible to later break. When everyone surrounding is involved in a

specific movement, it’s hard to defy those established precedents. As a result, everybody follows

the group’s trends. Taking on the idea of thinking local and acting global will stimulate

involvement with people interacting together, as one, for a greater purpose. Attracting small

communities with such energy ideas will spur a contagious outlook to think locally and make a

difference in the group, while those actions also impact people around the world (Hockerts &

Wüstenhagen, 2009, p489). Numbers from the past year show a 1.8% global decline in coal

consumption. This decrease may have occurred due to certain policies, but many also believe

that it was compiled with green ideas catching fire in more and more social groups (“BP

Statistical,” 2016, p4).

It’s an Easy Win-Win for Everyone

Regardless of altruistic intentions, consumers are still self-interested; therefore, in

addition to a communal element, a win-win perspective will sway additional views. Individuals

must be interested in generating cleaner breathing air, experiencing more reasonable climate,

and relying on sustainable sources for their own personal benefit. Even with such personal focus,

their actions still positively affect the rest of the world. Green energy usage reduces the

environmental externalities of the greenhouse effect while socially allowing people to make a

statement. Everyone embraces win-win situations since they offer personal and external benefits.

In order for the mass to adopt green energy they need to realize that this decision is as such

(Parrish, 2010, p520). Referring to the decision making process, transitioning energy sources has

minimal opportunity costs. For those that analyze their consumption or the cost/benefit of

various energy sources, green energy conditions beg the question “Why not?” There’s no positive

effect of utilizing fossil fuels above the rising green supply so why not switch to a more

sustainable and eco-friendly progressive energy source? Some initial costs are slightly higher, but

when factoring in the personal and social benefits as well as positive externalities, the eco-

friendly green energy solution provides a simple answer to an ongoing challenge.

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 7

Developing Another Market of Opportunities

A final point of persuasion arises from a business and social view for this developing

industry. When beginning to use green energy, a great amount of jobs are opened to develop,

run, and service the system. With a persistently growing world that requires efficient and

effective systems, establishing this industry creates a new network. Acknowledgement of this

new industry will let people see the social benefits in addition to the highly advertised

environmental gains. Skeptical people that may have not been convinced by primarily

environmental aspects will appreciate the creation of jobs and another arm to the energy

industry. Stimulating and building upon sources of human and physical capital will allow for the

global economy to remain stimulated in such an arena.

Attractive Marketing Ideas

In Zahra, Gedajlovic, Neubaum & Shelman’s conceptualization of total wealth generation,

the economic proportion of this equation takes into account opportunity costs (2009). When

consumers spend marginally more money on renewable energy sources, they forgo the

opportunity to spend that money elsewhere. This is a challenge for Qurrent, as its green energy

prices are higher than other sources on the market. With that being said, the marketing strategy

should not focus on monetary measures, but rather emphasize the benefits of green energy

investments and becoming a part of social change. It’s more likely to be effective in convincing

new customers to use green energy sources when appealing through the intangible, non-pecuniary

benefits delivered. Qurrent’s practice of selling energy “at cost” reflects their passion to convert

consumers to green energy regardless of personal profit.

Qurrent is in an optimal position due to consumers supporting an increasing number of

businesses that aim to reduce environmental harm over the past few years (Dean & McMullen,

2007). Even though energy provision is traditionally a low-involvement product, this perception

can be altered through implementing correct marketing strategies and leveraging imperfectly

distributed information inherent to energy usage (Cohen & Winn, 2007). Dean & McMullen argue

that if a customer possesses imperfect information regarding a product or service, they are

unable to recognize all the positive social and environmentally desirable behaviors (2007).

Simply, current gray users need to be presented a comprehensive explanation of the effects of

energy use to thereby encourage the switch to alternate less harmful sources.

Community-based social marketing (CBSM) could be used as supporting framework. It

highlights the barriers faced when seeking to convince individuals to change their energy

consumption habits (Aronoff, Champion, Lauer & Pahwa, 2013). Lack of motivation, forgetfulness,

lack of social pressure, lack of knowledge, and structural barriers are addressed throughout our

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 8

suggestions. A marketing strategy that aims to combat these, along with the issue of imperfect

consumer information, is required to change Qurrent’s existing circumstances. In addition to this,

we have devised demographic specific marketing campaign actions to target various brackets of

consumers.

Young Generation – Age 20 – 30

It would be advantageous to engage in activities whereby the information asymmetry is

experienced in order to properly combat it. We recommend that a Qurrent representative

routinely visits university campuses around the Netherlands in order to disseminate information

about Qurrent’s impact on the renewable energy space. This act will raise awareness with and

properly educate younger gray users in a relatively cheap way.

In addition to this, social media could be used more extensively to reach this

demographic. Further publishing of green energy’s positive gains, contrasted with gray energy

negatives remaining with fossil fuels can continue education. Qurrent already has a presence on

YouTube and Twitter, but a more diligent management of the YouTube account in particular

could be a creative mean through which to inform consumers about both relevant environmental

issues and Qurrent’s services. An active online presence is crucial in reaching the younger

generation today, and creative content that inspires individuals to change their behavior would

have direct impacts on followers. This impact wouldn’t stop at followers online, as the beauty of

social media enables effortless sharing capabilities on many platforms. Providing an avenue for

convenient communication of such information is of particular importance for this demographic

and should catalyze dissolution of information asymmetry (Aronoff, Champion, Lauer & Pahwa,

2013).

Well-known social pressures could also be exploited to persuade this younger generation

to adopt renewable energy sources. Research to find a prominent opinion leader in the online

community should be conducted (Solomon, 2015, p529). After this, offering a small sponsorship

reward or initial discounts on Qurrent services in exchange for regular public advocating of the

business would lock in celebrated representatives. The online social capital that some of these

individuals wield could be a tool with which to convince their followers to take action. Branching

out of the confined company circle with this is well worth exploring (Solomon, 2015, p501).

Getting people to feel the need for immediate action is the biggest hurdle for a marketing

strategy. A primary tactic to spur movement is tapping into this ‘legacy’ phenomenon that

previous Qurrent users quoted as being a primary driving force for adopting greener energy

(Mattijs Winter, personal communication, 3 November 2016). Qurrent should use their existing

Twitter account to get specific hash tags trending such as #graytogreen/#grijsnaargroen and

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 9

#myenergylegacy/#mijnenergieefgenis. With minima but key hash tags, Qurrent and its customers

keep a narrow dedicated vision driving their focus.

In addition to the existing friend discount of €50 that current Qurrent users get when a

friend switches, the new Qurrent user should also be rewarded. Beginning a small welcome

package for all new users that publicize their transition through social media and the hash tags,

can stimulate even more green energy excitement. Receiving a small gift, with sample objects

shown in the Appendix, new users will feel a part of a green energy family and movement. These

gifts won’t and shouldn’t be a huge cost to Qurrent, but the small action gives a warm feeling

while also staying away from solely monetary motivation of the existing invite a friend initiative.

Additionally, the media sharing and Qurrent gear provides avenues of showcasing an individual’s

positive deed to the public in both social and environmental areas. The advertisement also fulfills

any personal need for conscientious recognition as Qurrent’s name and services circulate more

(Solomon, 2015).

Middle Generation – Age 30 – 60

Targeting middle-age users with larger disposable incomes should be done through regular

community events. Given the Netherland’s cultural fixation on bicycling, an event could be a

cycling tour/race day organized and powered by Qurrent. This event would occur annually for

local cycling teams or groups of individuals wanting to compete in a one-day race held in

whichever region of the Netherlands seems to draw the most interest. A small registration fee

would be requested to cover costs, but Qurrent users would participate free of charge.

Collaboration with a well-known musician or band to provide entertainment at the end of the

race would be an excellent opportunity for Qurrent to demonstrate and advertise their services

by literally powering the event. This would also attract more attendance, particularly for non-

Qurrent users, and generate positive press around both the event and the company. It perhaps

would be helpful to seek out local government officials who have a pro-renewable energy

political stance to partially fund this event together with coordinating possible road closures.

Qurrent’s online presence could also be used to reach and engage potential participants.

To generate interest in the event, a competition to find the showcased musician’s ‘biggest fan’

should be conducted and advertised through the online channels previously mentioned. Qurrent

can use this phrasing to join the competition with their renewable windmills that generate such

masses of energy for their customers. Example marketing material for the event is included in the

Appendix. The taglines ‘Are you a fan of planet Earth?’ and ‘Celebrate our past. Protect our

future,’ along with Qurrent’s logo and the company hash tags on the posters will direct audiences

to investigate the event plus Qurrent, raising awareness and gaining a stronger following.

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 10

Any event that Qurrent sponsors or holds should be captured through both film footage

and photography as this could come in handy for future marketing endeavors. Up to date and

regular content from such hosting would amplify all existing social media interaction means that

already exist, especially YouTube.

Older Generation – Age 60+

In order to reach older gray users, this ‘legacy’ phenomenon should be primed through

alternative means. One of the main issues of capturing the mature market is that older users may

feel some futility in making the switch to green energy at such a late stage in their lives. Our

answer to this is to commence a program in which children and grandchildren can inherit

windmills, part of a windmill, or solar panels that their relatives have previously bought. This will

be a unique tradition that establishes a legacy known for positive social and environmental

impact.

Organizations

It would also be advantageous to explore the logistics of possibly gifting sections (or

entire) windmills and solar panels. This would work along the same lines as the charity gifts that

organizations such as UNICEF and World Vision frequently advertise. Individuals or companies

would have the opportunity to share and spread Qurrent’s green energy with others and make a

grand statement of investment.

All Together

For the consumers that already converted to green energy, it’s important not to forget

how difficult it was to initially gain their support; therefore, it’s crucial to not ignore them as

they could certainly fade in support. Reinforcing not only the positive environmental benefits,

but also the money and power that current users are saving could be achieved through Qurrent’s

current application. Push notifications and daily reminders of the positive externalities that are

generated from green energy is one way to reassure current users. Continuous reminders, not too

overwhelming but frequent enough, will assure users that their decision still holds significant

impact. From a financial and usage perspective, these notifications can give live updates on a

personal level as well as a company level to keep consumers continuously informed of progress.

Qurrent already tracks some metrics through their website and individual Qboxes, but a reminder

immediately on one’s cell phone requires no effort from customers. To be more creative and

interactive, the application can also create calendar events to house upcoming recommended

Qurrent social gatherings, anniversaries, birthdays, and other green and sustainable innovative

events occurring throughout the Netherlands. The application could also be enhanced with a goal

setting feature that would allow customers to personalize their usage and set notifications when

they get close to reaching their desired maximum consumption.

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 11

All the suggestions put forward will be fruitless in application if there are significant

structural barriers preventing individuals from converting to green energy sources. It would be

useful for Qurrent to research more extensively the key factors preventing users from making the

switch. This can be done through consumer/user surveys, interviewing adamant gray users,

investigating competition, and even discussing possible obstructions the government might see.

Compiling all of this data could then influence and better future marketing initiatives.

Measuring Our Impact Growth

Tracking social impact is a very difficult task that all social entrepreneurs face. There are

various methodologies in which groups decide to take, but each of them has their own advantages

and disadvantages depending on specific circumstances. With Qurrent’s triple bottom line

business model, significant evaluation of each method needs to be done.

Social Return on Investment (SROI)

As an expected return model, SROI, “a process of understanding, measuring and reporting

on the social, environmental and economic value created by an organization,” is the most popular

measurement tool used in social ventures, but has some downsides in relation to Qurrent (“What

is Social,” n.d.). It’s necessary to mention that the company has only one specific stockholder,

the DOEN Foundation, with remaining support coming from customers’ monthly subscriptions. As

a result, the legitimization benefit is rendered less effective for two reasons. To begin, there is

no need to secure existing funds as DOEN intends to be the sole investor for the long run. As a

funder of social ventures, they don’t require as financially intensive or frequent measurements as

for-profit investors to evaluate Qurrent performance. Additionally, since Qurrent doesn’t appear

to be seeking new investors, legitimization through the efficient and effective resource allocation

evaluation wouldn’t be mandatory. There’s no pressing need to showcase operational status when

having such a committed relationship with their trusting stockholder. At the same time,

customers probably appreciate the greenest energy award more than any financial ratio since

they joined the company with hopes for environmental impact. All this being said, using SROI to

improve external accountability would not be efficient.

To pool on the other strong benefit of SROI, it seems that Qurrent’s model still doesn’t

significantly align. Organizational learning is undoubtedly beneficial, but SROI analysis solely

taken for this aspect would be too costly (Maier, Schober, Simsa, & Millner, 2015). Finally, an

inherent characteristic of the ratio is the use of discount rate for future revenues; this translates

into placing more importance on the present rather than the future. However, it would appear

that Qurrent’s mission consists of ensuring the sustainability of the planet for future generations,

contradicting the discount rate’s underlying idea (Mulgan, 2010).

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 12

Logic Chain Model

The Logic Chain Model lays out the inputs and activities of a company that lead to a series

of outputs, outcomes, and in the end, to certain social impacts (Ebrahim & Rangan, 2010). To

relate this with Qurrent, inputs encompass the funds from the DOEN Foundation, the internal

financing coming from the monthly subscriptions of the customers, the wind farm, and the

knowledge/technical expertise. The next stage, activities, includes the supply of green energy at

the cost price, the smart energy contract, the choice of collective buying, and of products to help

generate a costumer’s power, wind credits, and measurement of consumption on the Qbox. As a

result there are outputs, which could be represented by the reduction of CO2 emissions. This

output should lead to medium and long-term outcomes. These outcomes consist of attaining

independence from fossil fuel energy by turning green energy into an easily obtainable dominate

source, and making people aware of consumption rates to decrease superfluous usage. Finally,

Qurrent’s sustained significant change would be contesting global warning.

The impact stage measure has already been discarded as beneficial to Qurrent since it

interrelates to the SROI just discussed. Furthermore, the outcome approach can be dropped as

well. Looking at the market size of Qurrent, environmental impact cannot be easily predicted.

They do not enjoy a monopolistic situation; therefore, their effect should be isolated from other

competitors. The outcome approach also looks at a medium to long-term time span, but with

starting activity only two years ago Qurrent is unable to properly assess. Given these

explanations, output seems to be the appropriate approach for social evaluation. In other words,

looking at the CO2 emissions saved by consuming Qurrent’s green energy is valuable.

The Output Approach

Although Qurrent already measures output on their website, it would be advisable to

complete this information with a comparison against green energy and fossil fuel energy

companies. This purpose develops two measurement to commendably follow.

The first sizing is a ratio that would study the relationship between Carbon emitted per

watt and cost per watt of various energy sources. Showing the differences of Carbon emissions

across numerous energy alternatives, enables consumers to easily compare both gray and green

energy companies. The higher the ratio, the more that harmful energy resource is to the

environment. For example, in spite of the fact that oil is cheap, it emits a great amount of

Carbon compared to windmills and would then generate a higher ratio. This ratio also prevents

consumers from focusing solely on price comparisons, and holds it on impact options.

The second measurement would focus on the impact of green energy companies. Qurrent

would gather all the data concerning the amount of funds invested in such companies (both

Qurrent and its immediate competitors), and then evaluate the CO2 emissions saved per

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 13

consumer in each company. This would link both a customer alliance with Qurrent over

competition and environmental CO2 emissions savings. This ratio consisting of how much CO2

emissions are saved per company customer may appear to be investor-focused, but it serves

consumers well. Consumers are also stockholders of the company, so offering them information

on how much they are contributing to the carbon emissions savings, and in comparison to

competition, they become reassured on their monthly subscriptions for social utility. Broadcasting

this information could also attract new consumers that see individual impact and/or competing

consumers to switch from other green energy companies.

Conclusion

In order to convince society to adopt renewables at a faster pace, there are many areas to

address. It’s crucial that individuals are given all of the relevant information regarding both the

negatives of gray energy and the benefits of green energy. In order to make sure of this, a

significant focus on education and varied analysis is crucial. This education should occur at

various levels, impacting each market segment based on age and lifestyles. With tailored

marketing initiatives specifically for these demographics, Qurrent can increase their effectiveness

to overcome barriers and gain more support. For optimal success, multiple approaches should be

taken, concentrating and capitalizing on the differing motivations and personalities. Individuals

will vary in terms of responsiveness to numerical statistics, emotional appeals, and social trends.

Creatively intertwining these will allow for marketing efforts to spark a variety of passionate

consumer themes (such as #myenergylegacy or #graytogreen) throughout the Netherlands.

Despite these optimistic marketing plans, there are still limitations. Funding may be

missing in order to amply pursue such ideas and hence prohibits the efforts to fully synergize

together. Other structural barriers such as convenience, forgetfulness, and empathy will also

remain as deterrents for some people moving towards green energy. We face a significant issue

when it comes to global warming and research shows that the simple switch to green energy

diminishes environmental destruction, but more social barriers need to be broken in order for

Qurrent and others of its kind to really rise as industry leaders setting the norm of society.

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 14

Appendix

Figure 1:

Figures 2:

Stickers, Decals,

Tote Bags

Figures 3:

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 15

Reference List

Aronoff, J., Champion, B., Lauer, C. & Pahwa, A. (2013). Teaching Old Dogs New Tricks. IEEE Power & Energy Magazine. Retrieved from http://magazine.ieee-pes.org/files/2013/01/jf2013_olddogs.pdf

BP p.l.c. (2016). BP Statistical Review of World Energy June 2016. Retrieved November 18, 2016, from http://www.bp.com/content/dam/bp/pdf/energy-economics/statistical-review-2016/bp-statistical-review-of-world-energy-2016-full-report.pdf

Dees, G. (1998). The Meaning of Social Entrepreneurship. Stanford: Stanford University.

Cohen, B. & Winn, M. I. (2007). Market imperfections, opportunity and sustainable entrepreneurship. Journal of Business Venturing, 22, 29–49.

Dean, T. J. & McMullen, J. S. (2007). Toward a theory of sustainable entrepreneurship: Reducing environmental degradation through entrepreneurial action. Journal of Business Venturing, 22, 50–76.

Ebrahim, A., & Rangan, V.K. (2010). The limits of nonprofit impact: A contingency framework for measuring social performance. Harvard Business School Working Paper, 10-099

Hockerts, K., & Wüstenhagen, R. (2009). Greening Goliaths versus Emerging Davids – Theorizing about the role of incumbents and new entrants in sustainable entrepreneurship. Journal of Business Venturing, 25(5), 481-492. doi:10.1016/j.jbusvent.2009.07.005

Islam, M. A., Hasanuzzaman, M., Rahim, N. A., Nahar, A., & Hosenuzzaman, M. (2014, August 27). Global Renewable Energy-Based Electricity Generation and Smart Grid System for Energy Security (H. Bai, Ed.). The Scientific World Journal, 2014, 1-13. doi:10.1155/2014/197136

Panwar, N., Kaushik, S., & Kothari, S. (2011). Role of renewable energy sources in environmental protection: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15(3), 1513-1524. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2010.11.037

Maier, F., Schober, C., Simsa, R., & Millner, R. (2015). SROI as a method for evaluation research: Understanding merits and limitations. VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 26(5), 1805-1830.

Mulgan, G. (2010). Measuring social value. Stanford Social Innovation Review Summer, 38-43.

Parrish, B. D. (2010). Sustainability-driven entrepreneurship: Principles of organization design. Journal of Business Venturing, 25(5), 510-523.

Solomon, M. R. (2015). Consumer Behavior: Busing, Having and Being (11th ed.). Harlow, Essex, England: Pearson.

What is Social Return on Investment (SROI)? (n.d.). Retrieved November 28, 2016, from http://www.mihconsultancy.co.uk/resources/

Yitshaki, R., & Kropp, F. (2016). Entrepreneurial passions and identities in different contexts: a comparison between high-tech and social entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 28(3-4), 206-233.

30 November 2016 CLEA(N) SOLUTIONS Page 16

Zahra, S. A., Gedajlovic, E., Neubaum, D. O., & Shulman, J. M. (2009). A typology of social entrepreneurs: Motives, search processes and ethical challenges. Journal of Business Venturing, 24(5), 519-532. doi:10.1016/j.jbusvent.2008.04.007