Quid - Voice of Patient - Diabetes Type II
-
Upload
carlos-a-folgar -
Category
Healthcare
-
view
175 -
download
1
Transcript of Quid - Voice of Patient - Diabetes Type II
This report summarizes what you can find utilizing Quid to understand the issues
patients face and their attitudes towards the drugs they use during treatment.
We analyzed 40,000 patient posts from a leading forum for Type II Diabetes from
November 2006 through early March 2016.
See Appendix for more on how Quid works
18% Insulin Injections
11% Treatment Side Effects
10% Diet & Desserts
10%Cardiovascular Problems
7% Diabetic Neuropathy
7%Understanding Treatment Options
5% Insulin Pumps
6%Morning Blood Glucose Levels
6% Insulin Resistance
5% Dealing with Insurance
5%Weight Management
5% Hypoglycemia
4%Long vs. Short Acting Insulin
A network map of the forum posts reveals 13 key themes.
Percentage reflects proportion of posts in the network about that topic.
18% Insulin Injections
11% Treatment Side Effects
10% Diet & Desserts
10%Cardiovascular Problems
Top patient concerns are dealing with insulin injections, side effects, diet, and preventing cardiovascular problems.
TIGHTER CLUSTER
DISPERSED CLUSTER
A more dispersed topic cluster indicates more language diversity. The tighter a cluster, the more identical the terms.
18% Insulin Injections
11% Treatment Side Effects
10% Diet & Desserts
10%Cardiovascular Problems
These topics also generated a wider variety of discussion.
18% Insulin Injections
Let’s dive deeper to better understand the wide variety of issues surrounding insulin injections.
Insulin Injections sub topics
1Changing Needles & Picking Needle Gauge
2Confirming Frequency of Shots
4Switching from Pills to Shots
3Choosing Drugs & Dosages
“ I a m u p t o 5 s o m e t i m e s s i x s h o t s a d a y a n d w i s h i t w o u l d g o a w a y. ”
“ I f i n d i t i s a l o t l e s s o f a p r o b l e m w h e n I s k i p t h e p i l l s a n d u s e i n s u l i n o n l y. W h a t I w a s t o l d i s t h a t i n s u l i n m a k e s y o u f a t , w h i c h i s d e f i n i t e l y t r u e . ”
“ I w a s u s i n g L e v e m i r a n d w e h a d t o b u m p u p t h e d o s e b e c a u s e n u m b e r s w e r e n ' t r i g h t … F i n a l l y I s w i t c h e d t o L a n t u s . I t a k e o n l y o n e s h o t i n t h e e v e n i n g . ”
“ I s t a r t e d o u t w i t h 6 m m o n m y p e n , a n d a t f i r s t t h o s e n e e d l e s d i d n ' t s t i n g g o i n g i n m y a b d o m e n . Ye s t e r d a y, t h e y r e a l l y s t a r t e d t o s t i n g … ”
Across every region of the network, there is a relatively even mix of positive and negative sentiment.
Negative Neutral Positive
Let’s aggregate the posts by topic to see which skew more negative or positive in
terms of the sentiments expressed.
6 Diabetic Neuropathy
5Understanding Treatment Options
4 Diet & Desserts
2Treatment Side Effects
1 Insulin Injections
3Cardiovascular Problems
Negative Neutral Positive
Thickness of links represents the correlation in language used between two topics.
7 Insulin Resistance
8Morning Blood Glucose Levels
9Weight Management
10Dealing with Insurance
11 Hypoglycemia
12 Insulin Pumps
13Long vs. Short Acting Insulin
1
2
3
4
5
6
78
910
11
12
13Sized by volume Colored by overall sentiment
6 Diabetic Neuropathy
5Understanding Treatment Options
1 Insulin Injections
3Cardiovascular Problems
8Morning Blood Glucose Levels
11 Hypoglycemia
1
3
5
6
8
11
Six of the thirteen key topics are discussed with significantly more negative sentiment.
Insulin Pumps12The discussion surrounding insulin pumps is the only key topic with a more positive sentiment.
Now let’s take a look at how strongly the language of each post connects distinct parts of the
overall conversation.
Colored by betweenness centrality
Topics involving more unique issues are found isolated around the periphery of the network. Diabetic
Neuropathy
Insulin Pumps
Long vs. Short Acting Insulin
Cardiovascular Problems
Although Cardiovascular Problems is the third largest topic by volume, the language used in these posts is very different than for the other topics.
Posts mentioning drugs, grouped and colored by drug, sized by volume
1 Metformin/Glucophage
2 Lantus
3 Byetta
4 Levemir
5GlipiZIDE/ Glucotrol
6 Victoza
7 Actos
8 Januvia
9 Janumet
10 Avandia
11
12
Amaryl
13
14
Invokana
15
Bydureon
16
Farxiga
17
Riomet
Tradjenta
Afrezza
17
16
15
14
13
1211
10 9
8
76
5
4
3
2
1
Thickness of links represents the correlation in language used between posts.
Sentiment
Volu
me*
Negative Neutral Positive
442
96
21
5
*Log scale
Metformin/Glucophage
Lantus
Byetta
Levemir
GlipiZIDE/ Glucotrol
Victoza
Januvia
Actos
JanumetAvandia
Amaryl
Invokana
Riomet
Farxiga
Afrezza
Bydureon
Tradjenta
Metformin/Glucophage
Lantus
Byetta
LevemirVictoza
Januvia
Actos
Among drugs with a significant number of mentions, Lantus is included in posts expressing the most positive sentiment.
GlipiZIDE/ Glucotrol
Metformin is mentioned most frequently, and in every topic in the network…
Posts mentioning Metformin, colored by topic
…but mainly in understanding treatment options, insulin injections, treatment side effects, and weight management.
Posts mentioning Metformin, colored by topic
…but primarily in insulin injections and long vs short acting insulin.
Posts mentioning Lantus, colored by topic
Posts in the Treatment Side Effects discussion mentioning Byetta
2Initial Side Effects Upon Switching (e.g. sickness & weight loss)
1 Appetite Suppression
“ B y e t t a h a s s o m e p r e t t y n a s t y s i d e e f f e c t s w h e n y o u f i r s t s t a r t i t . . . a t l e a s t i t d i d f o r m e . I w a s s i c k f o r t h e f i r s t 3 w e e k s I w a s o n i t w i t h v o m i t i n g , s t o m a c h p a i n s , a n d h e a d a c h e s . ”
“ I t i s i m p o r t a n t t o w a i t a t l e a s t 1 5 m i n u t e s a f t e r t h e s h o t b e f o r e e a t i n g t o g e t t h e m a x i m u m e f f e c t f o r a p p e t i t e c o n t r o l . ”
We’ve seen that the conversations between diabetes patients can shed light on their
experiences as they treat the disease.
From here, we can explore many more questions to better understand the concerns
of the diabetes patient.
Quid can decipher any large set of text records related to your brand, whether product reviews,
survey results, blogs, or reports in the press.
H O W Q U I D W O R K S
Quid reads any text to identify key words, phrases, people, companies and institutions.
Then it compares words from each document to create links between them based on similar language.
Quid repeats the process at immense scale, producing a network that shows how similar all the documents are to one another.
H O W T O R E A D A N E T W O R K
Similar nodes typically cluster together, and clusters are grouped by color
Example network, colored by cluster, sized by degree
Less distance between clusters indicates a high number of inter-related documents
Greater distance between clusters indicates a low number of inter-related documents
Centrally located nodes are core to the overall network, indicating central topics and a bridging of ideas
Peripheral clusters are less central to the overall network but could represent niche takes on the topic
Dense clusters contain highly similar documents
Spread-out clusters contain highly differentiated documents
A node bridging two clusters can indicate a document that is the intersection of two concepts
Connections represent similar language used across nodes
Each node represents a document; node sized by degree represents number of connections (i.e., similarity) to other nodes
W E I D E N T I F Y PAT I E N T N E E D S F R O M F O R U M P O S T S A N D T H E N P R I O R I T I Z E T H E M B A S E D O N S E V E R A L M E T R I C S , W H I C H Q U I D U N I Q U E LY C A L C U L AT E S
DRIVERS JUSTIFICATION & DESCRIPTION OF METRIC
1 VOLUMEHow often patients reference this topic; number of posts on this topic + Is a relative indicator of how many patients are affected by this topic
2 ENGAGEMENTHow many comments a topic received + Indicates how interested in a topic patients are
3 CENTRALITYHow connective a topic is; represents topics that are tied to many others + Indicates if development on that topic could be used to address other topics as well
4 SENTIMENTCombination of amount of negative and positive language used + Indicates how strongly the topic affects patients
W E U T I L I Z E A PAT I E N T J O U R N E Y L E N S T O T R A C K H O W PAT I E N T S ’ N E E D S C H A N G E T H R O U G H O U T T H E I R E X P E R I E N C E W I T H C A N C E R
Pre-Diagnosis Diagnosis Treatment Post Treatment
Patient develops or notices symptoms, but does not know if they have the condition. Patient tries to interpret symptoms and self-diagnose
Patient seeks HCP counsel and diagnosis. Patient finds a physician, goes through one or more tests, and receives diagnosis.
Patient follows course of action prescribed by the HCP, including lifestyle changes and medication.
Patient receives rehabilitation in conjunction with treatment. Patient may relapse or communicate with others within the community.
Voice of the Patient