Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§"...

35
Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“ Q? .1§?§§§:§.$ ¥§§§§‘:?" .1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I§’°$*”§‘*§ §={}§.§§‘—">§’§°§",,. §§§°§§$ .;‘%&i§{§§s*iY W§.i.§.‘:‘.§‘1%‘«‘3£§ §~“5§asi*:*:§:¥v§:‘~.»’3;§§;~3£§as:: vs. §3§*~§§R§1{}?‘é7 E:‘a‘x’§{§'?s§‘§S €IE§‘“é'§”§E_§'*§*;,, §§‘&{Z. a W.“ 1 ,,_~. :‘ _' §~‘sg.:«;3§:<.:~3§ {'.‘;".i.Z:»*{}§§3~.3. T§“§£y2§ $3.3‘-”§${}.3§}{3 $sR§EF Q? .§§@§§§..$.£5‘§?é°§”,,. §—§*§§sR§§ Wfifififi §fi§.§»§§E€§§§ $§§§°§°§§R',..- §§§§§x §§§$:t&§1?»§3:~“£?”§ ;‘31%"s=es:*s°'1 Suréfiggssz §.zssw 835$? :«“:.:*z;=sa:‘::-§::§*i:0;s~, ifizayizssrss, v¢*1»E.§«=§‘§i~;$ v -.n-'- cw: c’\°’\ §_§.s,~<’} -§1s2.~§~=1$m3 {R313} ~'%32§.»’§?x‘§{§3 {”;:~'>»;:_s3::-a>§ 15:1: A00 3s~::*;%my' ‘<1:“<:‘§§§.Ee3.:"§°§$ E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C 1700511 fimaég 030%: isfifiaiifififi 3.31‘; ?13?m§1:$§* § iiafia 3% :Zis:‘?:m=.:~%:' s:".:=¥*:é:; v*%If%3;&§i} _,-. 1,.;»1.-~. wx.-Ei {“:»:>:ms3§s:i €01‘ ;?~.§.>.;3;..%$s°:*;,. N I‘;:¥‘§E3%’£§%”} ‘kg-*‘=¢,=°m:2z:*§ia {'l'<>§§§::.%::3:*= sifim, 3£:“::<:, / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Transcript of Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§"...

Page 1: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“ Q? .1§?§§§:§.$¥§§§§‘:?" .1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§°

§°§§a?**§§§I§’°$*”§‘*§ §={}§.§§‘—">§’§°§",,. §§§°§§$

.;‘%&i§{§§s*iY W§.i.§.‘:‘.§‘1%‘«‘3£§

§~“5§asi*:*:§:¥v§:‘~.»’3;§§;~3£§as::

vs.

§3§*~§§R§1{}?‘é7 E:‘a‘x’§{§'?s§‘§S

€IE§‘“é'§”§E_§'*§*;,, §§‘&{Z.

a W.“ 1 ,,_~. . :‘ _'

§~‘sg.:«;3§:<.:~3§ {'.‘;".i.Z:»*{}§§3~.3.

T§“§£y2§ $3.3‘-”§${}.3§}{3

$sR§EF Q? .§§@§§§..$.£5‘§?é°§”,,. §—§*§§sR§§ Wfifififi §fi§.§»§§E€§§§ $§§§°§°§§R',..- §§§§§x

§§§$:t&§1?»§3:~“£?”§ ;‘31%"s=es:*s°'1

Suréfiggssz §.zssw

835$? :«“:.:*z;=sa:‘::-§::§*i:0;s~,

ifizayizssrss, v¢*1»E.§«=§‘§i~;$

v -.n-'- cw: 1 ’ c’\°’\§_§.s,~<’} -§1s2.~§~=1$m3

{R313} ~'%32§.»’§?x‘§{§3

{”;:~'>»;:_s3::-a>§ 15:1: A003s~::*;%my' ‘<1:“<:‘§§§.Ee3.:"§°§$

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C 1700511

fimaég 030%: isfifiaiifififi 3.31‘;

?13?m§1:$§* § iiafia3% :Zis:‘?:m=.:~%:'

s:".:=¥*:é:; v*%If%3;&§i}

“ _,-. 1,.;»1.-~. wx.-Ei

{“:»:>:ms3§s:i €01‘ ;?~.§.>.;3;..%$s°:*;,.N

I‘;:¥‘§E3%’£§%”} ‘kg-*‘=¢,=°m:2z:*§ia {'l'<>§§§::.%::3:*= sifim, 3£:“::<:,

/ COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 2: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§es:.sms:§ $3:“ ‘ .

ss?$xgm3<*sm*:i

§~..m.=;;;‘2; ~<em2-:3 5.3;. s:stt<*.e:°maj,r ::3§§tT.‘§

1%..‘

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C170§0511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

3,

EEE.

;.i {as ¥.<=::;:'§.e2m'.

KJti<

{-3.

{Q

3%“;

.i

‘ii.. A

an

*2.-=°ss*‘§

3

{“ ~ »

S§t.aita=::ms\ 3‘ :3?‘ ER:. 3

S"3

§§ssig§§§.§§:§-Ems:3?

3% 3; 3 :9 2‘:

{Z .2 :2‘ as 3

mi _§3§3:‘3*:1§€t§2’sg;j; :sm‘:§: is

S §3:*§>s{<*:*.1:’i:&{*§§’r3;‘ §\‘s:2vi:‘2w a2m';‘§

i

-u=2:‘e fizem 3399;:

Si

‘is

.. {Eh :3

'tasi‘.i§2wr;§r 5:5 2:‘: ti§§ i2”i§3‘iC\.‘-ii‘

3*, {;¥§.2§:> .s°x;3jg;.i3;§. £2?

.1

§

€..2':§.§3m%'

§.ss§‘e:‘§ Fig»

.2» 2 ‘ r

'3

£3‘. 6§~E§%v :‘§€§§;3

(

:3‘; :3 %;§§a.i§3 s-mfg

><)9\v<>\A9:->\e»p\a«a4\;».-u\;.\

Ii .

~'\35-\'-~{‘:\I~IN‘-'~‘-'w\<w¢uesesw-ow‘-.~-.-um-xw-awn.-us.-n.-«~04so-aon<>9w.>.\

.~.-.-e...\..~.....-.....;,..-

"“““'-""".‘L‘i6()(P(!%i¢

».«..-.\‘unsw-at»:-u-‘Mn»u-um.-mun-.-.uuu....u

yaxa-.;s\u\.-»ra-\-I\1\.a\r.'~.'\.t\Avc-()1)-‘)9-9

’\"-“\‘*“<‘l‘(’I4}"}<}(‘\Ci)\)C;IGIJ\)\!§'\P\.?('.-\Iv\l\I-\.I\\r\o\Iu'.\h\i\\

‘ .. ‘ .§.

3:‘-.31} 3.}

2|3.5.

~:- "M We ix 9 M «m< ¢.-«5{.-,- ~~‘N5K» .“- w-4»; .§.. .~ w. \r\r\.-\u

4.} a V . .

\ -.}t\‘:bu N; z.»_\\\

s“\>\'\A"rI.\'\I\\r

a,\_.»:§3\..F. ,\}.. Kr} z.:.»\.¥., \ .

Mx .\« ‘x 3.. .3‘--:~ §->;3‘§k»§:¥ an><><»<n.>\n.-\‘w‘.\..

Q“\

‘<

‘.¢};.~

TDKI

.). r......

N‘:

...

1%. cv\.. ms.“ «.5. via. .3».

it .\\\A 3.:

fi~

‘sag é. .

‘§r,§3.€l~..f§£$

E‘.

Ag’

3s: :3? :fI:>.2‘;‘:‘§§:2

§. ‘hie s3’%f§I§‘§§T§§.é3€§§§T$3

mms§§;.,m§>§sm§s -ax? §£rrz;s:*

Fagaegag

Page 3: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

F...“

.x\.Fs... .....3...\..........H..\.2....3...“.

(\...xu..........x..\..w...“W....a......:5...ax...“M.....m

B

M...»

x.N)

Ax}....xxx./x......U.ms.“Mm.«NM....S4.x.....&._M)..3...3.}

gxN..,3\..w....,m<s.....x3xv...s.Mn.

0a. xvxxi.c.7\\19$5(xv..x.x.Yx...xm.....m.3}V....4....x.......x.R..S.........E... x;xxx.u“.3,.neat.n\xxxx.V.

Hat4».....3..3.W.W...we3.3h3........ iv.....D.

,«V..nx..a...xxx.uL.......r.x\s...).. ...........,P

.41:4..Rx.,.sax2..

..xc....xx.“x-VnU.o...3p.M\...c.u.-3A....ea....... .......... ..u..w.m0M...Mw.M,...M..n..W..13...new«axNP.H..F

..9...N.,.IM..x .._......on.......u..2?................. ........ z.H.3...x

NGENNE,.ox...N..N.3....mQin.3...x0anO

.. .,.....................

N.2..x.....armn“.3uHnA...n......x...._x.H3....“nx.._|

..x..o.x~\.................{ah..isY.“x.. ..3.....3.R

...x.v,.3......x....Y.Y,83..i.....x_

.\.._.....«...\x...Px..3,......Nu......fie.»U

i\.........xn.V.its...

.. xx...x..}..«.1..to... .»..\3.. .xi........U..+x\.xxxxv.....x...u.:3...o...u<w»ms....xVE«cf...u0RV.

HN....Nu..x...H.......R...V.x.2...._..,S.1.....3.C

........ ........ .

u.50Q......5.. ..,......5.M.B..u......a.E.“

..r\.\.......3.x.\. ..

N.3...3....“S..4.M.2...H.......,U.3..»..x...8.Man.“Q...Kw/

..am.H...........,mm.HB..8..4...xx.x.............5...».4.

..>..x..3....x...........1.H...........r...1a1

..x...“S..x....nNR..Rum.Lu.“...3.>».$5....x....nQ)..3.3"..|

.4.“mm.....x._.as.H2“..win.5.F....3...2..2....5....

anxx.K.M...H.......HV......1.H....R.»G...Y3.C.......2......3....3.Qq.u....\E....2.N...«am3...

vxx.5......x.+.....11.A.\\\Yx«ix.<Sm...7

.1....x....xi......$5.<2»..\..inW.....x§.fr....«.3.vs......xH-........3x...r.P....2..sM3.1

x..u.«s.\......9....... \\_..S:.5»\.A34.3.C

............n..S...H$3.0ms.VMW.§....x.W.......x..

.xx.x....15.... .xx..1%....x..l....x.}.. .xy...,..oi

3...8........m.U0...H......0w.MNM...8.........MN................u../L Xx...xxx>.....«xxx....x...Hax...‘..Sx..RumA...._...<s.,6..

A.“.1...2...u1...xx.._.,3..«Mwewe...R. ...x

.4...x.1\.\«...._.........

xxx..... ...9.3.»_..Exx..w..a..xx....9.....»x..O

wz..._3N.»H.....x.W..H.W83.......3S3....9..._.§.1.a.....u.n...xi.... .mm...H6...3.,.......u.Hin..2”,x...8.s.....n.<xv\...xH.Vlcc...\..3...!.xx).x\\.x...(...uxx...\..w.\<x..x\\x...1xx....\xxv.x....«J... ...xx.....vxa«.3....&x..xxxx......x.

xx.3.Gxx......5..we...»{X...s.....V...VJ.....x....x.x.M.J.f.VY69mm.2H....w. .6......wx.3........3..HN.Q.6

..........R...3.......“N...N...NV.....«.....,.3....}w.WQQ.5...........u.dHa............3..N

....x..S...3N..w.........z\...,.....3.v...x...x\..H.4.xx0as.3...3..5....H.2...E6V.3.s..s.............3I:tsxx_...¢<.3..1........x... ........xxx.>.(_ 3:...an0«M....mMnN...n..an.....M..5............W.Q...M

.5.4....H.....PHE.1N......_..3.........K..2...r.

\..s.._x..3.. _H“awFm1..........w...W...3a...»8.......4.,3....x2».M..3M......uv.mN...»x.xflw.u...§Wx..._\s............NSo.\xx_.finwt.V...V»38”mm)HexM...“R

.......... .... .....

........3....N.._.H.....m.....E.....H2....9..n.1H

.x. .vs..3.x.2....»x.3....$xxm.\\\\.xx)»

«Mm.xxx..1x........r.Cx.<\u«xx;\.\..3.“..x...«.3.x...<.#.xxxs3,.Max.Jn...»..wk.“. .W:N...3..x}F.,.....me...»xx.....x..2?.».3“3..........».x3........4....«rmis..9......&...«m..9.......,w..........“...«Ax...x...,.xQ...........,Ox....3.. .KV......5:3.R.3+&Qxvan.......M......nu...xxx.Paw..81x.‘MMis..m..fi.u.\..%x.xrv.1..,3.\\\.\x.“xx._x...«.3“L”Fof..aC2.xM.x.sum.xe.Aw:1.....S....<1.»,o.x%.“AV3.......3.... ..x34..mu3.}“ex...

..“MN..~\..c...33..A:J.3..x9!}3..3xd...2..s...x.x...

\.....x..A...3.9s$5....A.. .xxcr¢.xx«..>.{xas»p4.at3..xi«Km5fix}..3.../.>\....3.MW.ix.xv.....xexxaxv.3...>....any..w.u(.\5ix;.....x..x.....r\.33wx.xxx...3:xin...max.....xc...,L.3....1»t\..9....8...

...M.$\\.......“1;....I.... ..rx55..~M.v....x.....xxx....>\.V.m.......3...;..xi....v.9».

D:....3.3.\.3....xxx...xx33m.E....s..5.x....ms..M.Sc....5_..x.....H....ex.....x2..x. ...:2.M...1....P..3.r.S.......

3.r..2.........._...,..x....s.,3..C.an.....2.3....TQ...Q...31.3....,..-3..5L.P

5.x...x...>......V...>....F.“......k9.3...ex...x..V.1.».3»...w........Vw.... ..4.)

>2...xxxxx.3:v.“Mn1...»VinV..x.(J\.x..\.C.£3..x.ml3...39Q.Xv....<.32“>..4

M.....x...2...x.........5...x.._..3viR...2......”._..x...2.. .....d....x.3.x.....+.9..mm3.......3......x.333mu.2...3....fixF......0.....v.,....n..

...n...5...R«K;......xQP.3...1....1.x>&V».».xx_xr.\.vvx.3.31.......0

wk‘..“.3...21....

2.8H

1,

O2

/11/1ODELF_E

Page 4: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

.-w r.sm » gggra . .««.i.\ > 1. U \;‘.«.-gnu‘;-.nuusue.5-‘exnun..:~..uu..n.H,¢.¢.,.,,,,.,,,,,,“._.NH,_<,“_n”_"“ >_ £3

§3<3s,>:‘<‘ 2.-=; {.T£:§..m‘,§; 6?“ €I}§;§ss :'«.§L;‘.§t3_ 11:38, 5313; i%§I§~Z.;_'-;f.{§ ‘£33

.- , .. . ~‘ - ,\ ~.\ :' ,,_...~-,.$z’?z".~‘zs‘§~'&{.. \fs£~.‘§ 3: .<§'s.’€iT<§§-‘§‘§ s.-§.::_..;.‘§

W

x .

:3‘ 12

.4)

4./"

5~

55?!

W,

:3,

>-.

w-/

/Aw

,fu ~44?

/’*’

-.[#

4W

V"-

".1

I’

,‘,

/‘‘‘'‘

~1

4I‘

vyu

l

'; . . ~ 1. ’P 1 . Z, , ,. 2 . 1 . , . . . . 5 L C , L‘ 4 ,...

2-J

§-"i-"a3'é‘3f'£;§r:\.‘ iv: 3§;«.':é;:‘.. -*3.-‘;:-‘.23. sZ2?.“*“.¥€s‘.T<‘»‘:‘1§‘A:*.s13‘l'.',.*s‘Z#»*'1¥ gif‘2 .. A

.

.. . _ M ,.-'}‘‘';§ {.3 § ’\.",‘\..\rIt u_. x,._\W

...»

.

flu

‘Auk

.

:v2_

?.'a

.

' V V .‘ . 6*

r" ‘Y’ “ ‘ .4‘ ~.. .- - r:‘is’, we:“€§.1:ta::% cu m

" vs-~"~'*:*§‘x 1"’fig}; L1. { .3. ..\<.\>\)\>\r-u-A+\v\(\I~-t$l\(\¢3?\)s>\A\-.«t\1\9-)€)()-<‘Ga;-\a\-A-n-\I\A-r~a.\1\()¢,-e-()\Js.I\s . . .-'

*:£*~i V13“ anX > . >‘u.’\a\.-«so-‘.\\‘.\x‘)71.-\r\s\-At\i\(\>()<:(:¢A»>\.-\lI.‘I.vAI\A‘i»:->(>¢-<u¢\;x;.«\a-xos.-m.-‘t>(\<)onv» .3‘. 3.

‘}’‘CE. 91:2

ii??? -"-3-- ~-'v\-t'v()¢-¢(.><)\?.-.\\v\e\.-\.\r\<\{‘-)n)\)\nvAI\.o\»\\t>(\<t¢\>(.v\'Av\I\s\‘Ie\r\<'~éI§(>()¢JI\ .\ at.» -.}

x

(«,2

5..

s. as} «*§_g§...“{.*t\ x .v. nurune);\«x:\:w-1\-:s-ev<->~>e)~;uu-\.»~:\.-.--u-3.»);-o<><,-.,g‘.-\,.\....,..;.,,,.,,¢,‘_‘_.‘,‘,,._,_. _e— — _ _\

:§.'.'’E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / 634700511 / COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

Page 5: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

ii $m’§°.§§ §s§§§i*§’§° SF {Z.«‘§:S§I

_§s::~*e ?.«*‘.«*‘§§§§*m>.;ss,. {f§::=::"*ei'n EU .¥}a=:,fez*§»:ia;§t~»°:§gaaifizam,

$§}';.a:‘<:.-.*: ‘§=*€<3c:»:§5s— {I:‘3§ii§£§£‘:~‘§i tar, {§3§3:‘*e§:s;§§‘z:£4s" §:a:\:;§:*-.~~;'e;'§ar.2§; m:.a.:§ti§3§& §a§.‘~.2s;~:é$

W 4"?

M1

r»;

"'5?

La

\

isxaiiasziérng ‘§f‘;.:»:‘ ‘s.r§.:332;r:§m::: %{i:m:2u:::e:* F wciciatssefi skit, aiiw §‘e’¥’~;.%im* ‘%?§3§:ic3§-:

§§<v;3;~2i:—‘ §T{u§.e, 2:23:13 far us} ;:m*‘§ i‘;i§?§2&§‘§. his s»*»§3§§§c§:‘-3 in

§€:at'ex3§:2-Kg: {sf §m*is§:%§s:§‘:§e:3§:

"§’§:.I‘§:: .a=;.: gxeazfi was: ::2a?é%,* i‘3§@«:§ an i§:=3§3=i%a.2':2.i‘3~:3:* I;-ii}: 2?’, fmm ':’%:<§ mzzfi CDis'§*£‘.’:t‘é s:§~:>.»::-§:":;§:,2.::A

m‘~.*.w §¥.*§:;:§ $i§‘Cs‘;%§‘€:.€i ;§::gi§st ‘i %:r‘i2:§ aiexayiizg {$19 ms ‘cima Em‘

zzxwg §:;“:'.a.E a>2*i§;i::s;i. E>s:s:::3; Sf_§m:*§ 2: ;2;‘§§3ea2§2';«:§3§£%

ii. §~‘*‘r§as£:a§u¥a§ Rssmre

“§‘§*2§§ E?Ea::i.:;€i§‘§».§’s;3';§a.Zisszsaz, _§W‘, {1:3:r.2;é§<:.3lm. .:’::«.:* aiazme§§g:§s*s g§.sa§ tats\;

x

V§2E§i€§z*s. w.~a2':“e=: j§3:é:*§:1§.s:‘3‘i*;§3s;i as: i3‘§'}'§«"x-’3~I}§‘:T'§}‘3\Ei§‘§.E$355k?‘ rm§::.;*;m‘__. :*sss:m.§i:§.:*§§,~< in aiizr3*;'§z'3;3€.=ia>:z:;2 in *esi§.:e_.

vi'<>§;2t§a>m‘; t.§::§% {lassxszgxaaw §~‘;:‘a§§ii§C§3s; mt, §*«?§&‘§§:m‘ ‘é>"é¥?§§::‘.§€ §{c«.;3:a:'i.:* '§~1z§§£:§, §‘:§§§.‘§ fimzzii.

anti 537:3,

:m§:§::ze‘;‘ ‘£2: *::‘.i2:§ ‘:§e2“{.s:“@ ;c;:*<igz-;2 zasmi _§m*:«* an Sufi; 3 13., ‘SS

*»:i‘1:‘::>’ :.,_s_§§E1 §z.:;:fjg; £‘s:%¥3{is‘:s°§%§i its" “CZeyiiéct, :‘s':s;i¥a:s;ii:2g £§.?£§§V\?€¥‘:‘§3g 2: s;;'3ee;:~§ :13

§:3’:e:*:>a;ga*a., €3.:§§3i2’§-giaé-S vi:>§2:£is;>;§;§ :3? $322? {1:'3;:.::mmae'r Saiag E’ §3.o:’.?°{. amt?

E‘«=fi:‘:§;»:3%:‘ ‘i:‘<~.=.}2§:;:§e §§i3§§?; mt. aw.-1::'n§ng 3:2 V§.‘z~.:vm" =3? tihe 34$§:'§~;%V;:;a-E.E;2:*;:, mz

t.I*;§§ ciazim fiw is‘:-mé. ‘s *3 :§‘_~‘3

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 6: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

}}§i§§§}£‘i§§,§§*§§.§[3:§}{‘§§§.?§3, _§’é:‘é‘, ‘iiiéesri. $2 far $§T=£‘ii‘.E3§'£}§‘jJ' Ekama §3:;:::;=sges.>

. .. .:~>. i'\\ ‘: -‘ . ..v..\ V‘ .,. - ~

_.»’§§.€.:_3r:;+e.3g am: L.z.s-Ks‘; m \«.~.V3im°»-~s.=.—§a 3;: am a... ..

7‘?

{Ze';:.:;*:: ms §ss..E§.-= -::§., :33, wk}: time i‘§3£§i§§3S?§3'i§;§; ‘§:*zm:s:a:.*ré;3t. ‘3C.<3l.,

‘T§‘%;as fiimsfic :*eque.<;*;e§_ s:§i;§;:§%a?§:*:s:é‘:3t.;z.§ :«.:::a§ €i‘§’£§3~"§":'3i§ ms filiw. }‘«€{>*:‘i£.sn

E62" .St.a§.m'zs:'3; zexmi §32s:m2gza$, .s‘§«tt{3.§‘§%€¥? $e%§;3i:ee:m‘ses*’ :i~E£}1£:v “S*ER

’§‘i“sé: fézsasi ,‘ét:£‘£g:mai'z*;' zm-‘§~* :=:-::i:m::,*é r:3’s:§.<:%3<~:r 1;. 2%} 'T§‘,:§, :38‘ ,=§;.>;:s§_2§.§.;~:%m:. SSW‘{R1, aeév

fiiezi. {:3 '?\»§‘:3*;‘i_:.m i‘§}:* ‘.‘:":*§a§ fx¥:3ss‘e;::.%5§2:‘ M, ‘E ‘mi; EM-__. w§:..ia:§: w;§3.< (3§?§"£.§{é{.§ Tm?‘ *f<§:.s_=.

i W“ ‘

§z..:§gs~: Etna" .m::§<A sex?-magi £3}? tize sgzii. 1 aw

»

/“'1V‘? W‘3;. E. he §:§.a:.t‘e:3 Sf :*e<:m*a§ am

'z‘§Z.mi'£‘;«‘ mi" .§?;.es<:2:;:‘;;§.§.. ii was reassigmzsjt ‘mi. 1?, 1.13., :e:‘:3:‘3 ;1ew§y s:;3;,m.i:1t&e;§

§=‘12»«:§ga2 3'§£}*{?£§€§ ;m:.u.2*‘ Em-{Ti amt itséaéaaz asst“-veii as §*§2;;:1'§_2'*e{$, an .E§::'i:r;‘ ?»‘§et3i‘.im3 far

rwf .«§4 ms} £~::§t§>:*<~.%si an ;?;§}:'i 1:1‘: 2. ‘;-+s-*1'7€§3 §§{3’§§€I%E§ i’:‘<‘::::1 {the imrza w§:i<:'§>.

?s*‘.~§m;;:e.2 :x§‘,«’i3:3=gasz<:§ §‘§§§?i§ 3;: Se§::§m':‘m=:v 26,. :12?‘. 1.: '

£1; Etaimaanfi §2>§ §‘=°a£t:s:

§'°%<"*>*’» ‘C319? iv»-°»'31»:%:‘ sf iii? §“s*?Eaa<i:23a2w§1§s:§“: i:2w;~§‘<:&s;§ in a .:‘§1z'3*;'m" w3§::§.:,:'ia§

::a‘:§I§’i.~t;issz3 ma. {?se;:t:3i§e=:r-‘ ‘$3,. Ei‘.I=:3.Z, '.‘2".‘.;'_-sf 113.8‘. e§.:;.2r;§, »::::':2t:'2s~t>:¢3{i. win‘; §}z:sfe:1:;iz231t~fi:;>;3eiizmig i3W'{iC,

ifs; ;3;a§1:"*:‘§.s{=: *i;;mz;§._§§es ii} ‘are.-§2i::§&, <i‘2“s»§3§e§:‘:§; i‘.§';s.é3 x«‘e3§1§::Ee afé’ ma. {}<:é;:»:>?:';:é3’:* .2€} E °3.‘g§._:z_. }.

9; ’?.;3. 3?}. i‘§%§‘_}£¥T§§*S were an '¥*.‘.:§>.:‘ 1:4, 2&3’: “ilgg, "£’Ei§§.

§'§'3.5‘}.§&=31"§{}i‘§.¥'E$3{‘§ i.n&'s§.:~m=:%. aria £§.i‘}s‘.‘§ §<~sarm:=.s;§ -tit:-£2 i“:::‘.€~.j{3*: atsf »:‘§§i‘:‘=.ii‘§iS§.§{=:¢“.§ me, ’_?’.;s..

1i.i:‘§‘.§«fi~“§~€.‘:,. aiii‘x‘iT§> ts: ifhe: i":~.utt veiaistie :§:a:§ §‘£.;‘££}. §‘}§3§}3’§. §.m-*<:Eve€§_ in ~::€}§§is3‘§.s'3:§

.- \

ami 5::<.:§§ sseiaicie wauisz‘; hzwe sriiminisghed xsasizze in Eiise cf {the

1‘

El‘? £§;:';t§.=‘§.§2i. ‘.<s’zs‘i:*-a2::§{‘{IL§*:ec§{{ :t3;:e?:.:";;:£ta§:>i Ffijg‘ vies:

3;?‘Z$§§.§§.2:ms=, ‘ts? w§3s3§:';: 31¢: i‘.€s{3§§ ixsis; Eziafie. Eh? §§}.5;*3£:?€.‘£§{33‘i aim‘: i§§§{3§§ i:*;s};>+2§:t'§{3::

5%.}

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 7: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

a

3”§2§se§.i3“.<; §:3e:§ §‘_:s-.~a=>.:‘1. ifs; acc:>:':;i;me;:=;=. wskih ‘Chi? 2':‘3a:i::3§:§::m:ra§:°’;§

S§3§3ifi‘§iCa3‘¥:i£3§'§.:§_, E ?i:sa%.§§=mr§::_;‘§ his vL*§::i<:'§§3 hzzaafi '%.>ee2':. §‘§3§3£ii§‘&E‘.iT§ {mlijs-* ‘$3 *§‘§§: w~s;§z§s baa:

2-viii} {fie mi‘ mi 'i'3»:3»::z.:Ii w%3§::§2 2->,e‘a.:: rm wit}:‘J

s‘§3es:i§ica2tim:s amsi 3 s:{3'§‘ss§~§?{f,§2.:§3i§éf:‘.§‘: §.'%:a WESS ti: eiriw, .»=.>:<;m2ssir;g his; '§Es;’.3.§§-‘Sf

=:§§‘::2 :23?‘ ‘:22 3;sf2::‘ wmz.A

. $34."

:I31% 2‘;yr]

rlw r

ms iziféfiai §‘}C.‘é m:<§2*:§s‘3:: as xix: i‘§3<‘5*1 *»>:~.:§.ue {if ‘s*-aiziciss ;3;‘:‘s--E.a‘;3>::; 'gm:t:a=:b

u»;

'}‘[.33¢ ;?§§..3.8§E§, aszai wsmlisfi :*Za=:i‘e,;* in §}s..\;-*ia‘§I ’>;«°§:‘§§.E§.:s%.§:‘;as :‘E.e°.%,*a:*mi:3a‘iis3§2 :3?’ §:s:‘3ti§ ;*m3~

i;t

amszi :3“

:§e§e;':32§:3ei the 3:33: is .<3§:e;?’§3‘ f§.$§§3.. _§*‘>?.~*=5 aé2>;;?»:“es:s‘e*.s,i am s;s§'§:.e:* m:°;:§3§:a:’§z'34t.<3

541:3 S§"€{ZAC m*.ga:§‘::ii3“3g s:§€3‘fi¥;§€~.:1?;3‘§?;}3§i‘S the *‘«‘£??‘:§§‘.§a‘=.‘.. 13.43; i‘§:.{~3 as?‘ as

h§§=.‘s:2§s§': xm*e%a=ta2ci %;§*;§3 fisay he ciwei up we "§‘;;§. ;I~§{2={3,

\

§'3:;:s«*§s;i.‘§31a2;3ec§§m at :‘.‘§.a as? ‘‘N, 3:::,:sim2st: *£r§

§«’a;".%:ee§s=::~;:;i>;:..:yg, {}§'1'i:; am 33,. ’§“.;:~.. 1-‘§“-(ii-.

m\§e:§'i.:~§:‘a'::a:..‘§ Eta; " ; ' ‘>.$"~i§:3 §“:u:>m ¥>’s‘;i.§§s:2 .s'§:*s.ei§e:‘::<m i§}‘}.s‘§. :*:.~}: ?»*3’:3:zt;::’::.z-.43

£3§’*xrs>'%m ifiém §e*=\'~:§:3.s1<:I.{:~e»'.;§.$.~ :2:-. ‘regsazéreci in §:i;e:it3I“£§a§§3C§3 wit}:

&3j§§£‘§v£'-§§.:§.€i2§‘€§xi§§}§§, m§,:z1*§ as‘: :.m*.=sr< s*§~::::.a3*;§i§§s5 gzmzer, ws=:.§§? 2':';:‘rm::smz_.ss

s‘}"C§‘££3‘§‘ zaesthetiat :§.z=:fa:i»:>.m‘:§:2s ;s‘%.2§.§3§§% is ifiza rfarsszezi 3:};

~ anA..r$‘;‘i.-“"z.*‘{IiT_‘.. ;'3msses.s1:»:21:3 *§:esE;§1.:'=.::{.:':s§:' %fm>s::: ?E‘.»m*3*:;

SW€ZC smci &%:;:e::**;s, ‘iii EI3=a2:m‘s,2‘; amt}. {}ve;°§¢23;, wiw :;§z§§:§2£:‘:'»ss:§ {£39 *»*'§E—§'3i<:§.i”—: a=:ami,.

A.

§.<é$%§i‘“§.£~3<Ii €.%3§> *.z.-=‘<.~.>.§_%.i:‘.::{~: ‘§‘:%;:3:a§:*e:‘.‘§ in ‘e‘¥—*%;?i"§!{3‘e?}.§§iT§§‘§.‘E~‘;1§‘. :::3;m::3e:" am? the :.=g¥:.i§:’~;~:~;ztim*: {sf 22::

:§§.§§*::23iW.s %.mm§., a:3':i§2.<3u;_§§'.x.. m>€. s§;:-ec=i.§§e{I, .:‘«;‘;3,. mi3‘‘§3:*:3§§i§3i:@e;i iimt\ u '

E13”: ‘::§;§% §;,~;:*-«;:it<n::‘iiim';, ix: .a2§°ii§:'E{:+’§3 {:3 1‘;§:ei'3f‘a{*§I§1§2si*»:fa=:

\ \.\

e:;;s'a§i§iify am: ma :;:;§-$33: §:?3e§ *§*:s":‘e M‘ E as

$4-3

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

m“c§<:as:s;i, E‘-*‘ras;i»:§es::.$. :s<>§e ::§mre§1:3is;§e:* csf

Page 8: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§§§,,. .«%.m§.g;ammt$ {sf §3T3~§*m* ami :%§*g:xz§:3e:§§"

$$§§—§ {§—?<§¥§§§ii‘§*§‘ £3333 £38i}R

'§.‘%i:a:§ {J2:s::ri‘ ~=3;':.*e:§ ix: :isi§‘rr§‘i‘m:g ts=3s;::‘:.::s3_:my ix: ¢r§§:2*;irz::::ia:3 \*;:§v;e.§

{ta =;:

Firsi. Eszsm“: §??§’&§:?§§§3§&?§‘3 fem‘ §§m:;§e&w aamti .3§a*ga;:ms;-.3:2j§.£‘

§3§:m:mr:s-.>;: in ‘~‘s:i.;Ez;.sv.2 :*az°s=a:::\:=.~:=; £~3‘1-"T§.¢§i?§1{f§é ‘§j§°-:'.?-'-‘§‘>i},".‘>.'\‘ $'*‘§§§§.§aE§_. §3::3s‘£.«

§.{.3$§$ §1”§€§§‘§~:£E*.“Ci <<:;:§';2'a§,. ' < "

’i‘§3a=: _.<°a.;"3j;:eL§§.&2a:‘. 3. ‘ii‘§:<‘s<z‘r;:‘ :‘§3;:{3~as‘»:>. <i§;‘:3i:3m‘.i:3;: in va.§::.e.. <:::;m;::§;:§m., ’}”.<‘§.

«.-

azmi. a§:"{°.m:§ £.zf~:*:a**:..i:mm3; §‘;:‘s;>m §1§:§vi.:i §~*’§*'§i§i2=i§‘=’3.<.:, ma 3:: zst§L§i:a§:agg ;>;§~csg:‘a:*;\; §{E.‘§-i‘.‘~>‘.«‘«-"":'} 35'

W:‘e“=c%‘»:{I§xa€:§s:_ ?:i:«s~: ‘§:1:2.:‘ :§e'ta*.3“z>.:‘siv::i:2g xmtis %<:ss.. S“;-*‘s«"{i{I iim ta‘; ‘i‘.§}s=:

*;;:;sst§::::cs:*3y szsf Sawiai. £"'W{Z{I i:§.:':1e*.;§,y :;‘;.m-°ed_ ~‘:.eé:s‘§i§T§:t_:%:>.::aj; itsss sit:‘°i:‘.§<a2L::,, "§‘.p, zgwwi

3I‘€?:3T_i‘m~‘-'W§3i1‘§. :3i:z-§ac~;fi:3-::. zxzgzmiz m:3vi:.§ mg‘ §3§§‘§3e;:*:-°.3 ‘Je:*s;i§m‘.. ma :i'§:~;»<.e ::§;2.i:":z §":':~':> &‘§.§§‘£§§'§3i§3§§€Z$‘§.“£ ii“:

S"E§.§3.§a$.‘._. “f{i§,3. ?§.EéI%«5Ts€§2§.5 31$ ‘£3~:3*i'§}§z>:sz* EW} .2"m.r“ §.:2.;;«‘ <>€.§;§3:“ ‘witr;<es:‘~: :3§Tf‘aa,mai. ‘Q3:

i?’j§:~.:§V:2’:.§§’;€’ sa>:.;3:‘&s:~.2§s:§ s‘3§}.§£3§.=3i‘3 -.2252 tics '£:§.§& V;;i§.§.i$ ;30s"i:~§»:§:;s 3 VEi§i§:.2

iii?:Tz¥3$.?$~.i§‘}?‘ as e§§3=:im'::1i::;z<::';>:: mi‘ 3:’ ;‘$_zs.m::;g.-,€aw :ia2*m§.g,;s22 in :::<st’:3:~ x:e%:§e;§zss«

-*::<aa::ess::s;w§_a ts: cs:>r::.;:s:2=':.& s;§'m':::s:gge §m‘ :;*i§::.'zi'm:=*:,‘§}:t3:: ‘i :1: x-ia.§::.;«:=...

“.§.‘§:z §=.~ mhs tiw iiéfifi :33:mi‘: ms. :3?’ tifruaz z'm'~%a.:zz::‘e ;*§.;3:.:':‘:e§.§;s%3 in 3. §§3~i§§:1:‘;3'§‘- v:2§:.ia:§:;°. is

x

2»-1 £2; ::3¥::i<.: :1 in

i‘%.:a=: zszarkat va.§;,§é;e 2. ;v§’:>;.‘:a*. £3 ;s§“§ia§;“ $1.1"; ;:§1'if.v<e:*::2:ftiv§3 r;§».:sa:=:::§'*e <31‘ ai.3.r:§ag§s‘:§

fa}? ;ts‘§‘£§§g3e:*::;.* ts?) ms;<I~::>:* 2133:‘ {sf2: téffrkz at " “ ‘

2? ,..~

,7.

Al

"*2

*3:

£22

"$3

{5}}

,._

..“'2 £1

.1'

157

!‘‘'‘

'.‘'-

.,._,

.()

2"4 W {Z F

1‘

eeriataesi -ms: mg: {;:.:m; 9.?" Em ;§z>:°§.~;-‘mi :s.si::.g;;‘ %7:wz*s §+“<:Eit::s=:*. s.§;i.‘L=";:':::?s;:$:=.> 5:;

2»: £ii<2s2*‘,. T? {‘.駑3is;: :~*s;:3;3v3a3‘ $3}. «<3-fi<'% ‘3\{f-*‘=9“~ §i§§:§4:.A ii

“§‘§%:<: ’.i‘°e:z.§.:E: £292}:-: {}s‘7§3x§:~};3§32£§$ if °I.:%*es:s2§2s:ji ;:§a.i';2:.: fan“ »:§§:31é::;§t§€;s*2 ssaskse in

‘W .\E» V.=.»_J. ~‘.v .« >.. .\ " . . .v.,,~,..\ _ . “ ‘ 6 i -2 6-‘ ' .- . .‘~‘ , ‘ <. ~* .~ ."‘"H‘.’ ,2 :.§§:£;§{s;.:§ x». .«~§.?.3:‘i}’s6?.*. Kass: em Mgascg, g S 3:22;: =~:;;§s,.s<:.. :. ¢::.k .-.‘.£}z3?»—€}:2.m«£’.I’ ties:

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 9: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

i’::.::,.:~a:3€£2‘;§.§.ss23

:3

3:2; ici {rm i‘§§=_,;‘.‘:

:3:“‘ €783‘ ’

if _\. ‘

.1 i"§._:,‘§

mafi 2::x

same §Ca‘i‘3£T‘<§ ‘i.

a%Z:'& ma :3.‘

1

11;:at

.~

:,

E.

is‘; 2"e;;};»§.?‘

ma

mm m ~;»‘:z§§s.:

§;i2*.:a 1“

§3:"§3~~.e2a:§.t§‘{Ee:3i'. $}EE%.{3{§i3=.§§€$

£3

; 1 >-

‘.4“m§;:1.:-itim“: in 02:11.30,

2* $?0‘.i..{:‘s_, $3-i},i}{3

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C 1700511

Olass Tam. ::;32‘:s*:—<::i:' .‘(§‘£€% xii

‘ .. ii§;‘§.{3‘§2 in va§»§n.~9. :i.<.:~§3s.: mt £:v.=3.§‘§:a;§

=*: :.:z<;:§cz:§;si.>:£s;§ iaaseéi zm ‘time »’.I{3§i‘i§:};3.i‘§S<3?i ’:fi§as vazixw §>a§k:s:“e stixxe

i§«~:*.3:“»°s-’~‘—=‘*.~3s"3 the §;3:‘§:

/ COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

12*.\G

«xxx

wt‘

\z*§23*:'

sriimiiziazize

§3$:§‘£:~§:§3i‘i:.: :1.

mstessi tizs are

303:2

123.51-c§1‘§e1:§t sag:

{E 1-‘.a§=.

;:>:§.:§ 312$: mé

§3fi‘€W$€*.l'§ i':§32‘°i>

§§}§<‘€%§‘§~’§‘.£§.

szismziai imé

::0:;.s:mm~:.:“ §;a:§.:§.

’t§:.2m {me 3:'%x;s{'.§1a;~a am

;*§2§:{3g§z:;§::.»<:£§ {Ea i§3§'::.:*§3**Z: :§;§2*'§§-*

$f’:‘»:~3;3a2§

:23 a

24:20:‘. v:-A300.

E {.2 $3 ‘

‘” ?\-‘w‘- ‘-* M \'\\

\>:¥.~‘£s...*£i_< 1%., §.ses:¢:..>:0

. . . \ \ .\\ <~:\...: . M3.{E03 Ems 01.2.; a%31§‘im3

we 0 :m::*§::~=

5:0 §3;§:g.=‘ 15:13‘ 3 :

=;-v;*s2‘s :30: ‘~1 ‘O

§be%£i c§1i.,::*:':

2:. v::‘:§

i

s':s:;.:;:3_:=s~

:‘fi-ass .A ;_-4“

mztéi-53:;

is‘: its *;.§'s=~;*. as *..-='§2§%2i»::E€;s $29.2:

’§.,§‘\¥ ism‘: b{.3§§‘.3 iii:

§{i§§§

~- az«.z;§§§i:\i:>.z‘;az~:1§. an-1»-“z~::‘a':E

:%1s.:;t-$0 the z':€.siE‘4

:‘§1v::§;:e 2§§?:§§§3E‘§?i‘§.t

r7‘. ': .A

'i}g‘.s3.§‘: 3{.\!-’i}§V~‘3.xi 1:32:

i... .~ I I

E;w':‘:»3*.sa=:§‘ 3 ::afs§fiiis§£;:3

’;.:§zm'-.3 :1 .310

Page 10: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

'§“§';e 2°eS§s;§s.§sE :§imi:2ut§‘s‘m 3;-*a§iu§s cam :§s.=.x-wag‘ be ‘:1 :32} these s:§if‘f§2:‘:~:%:'m.z3 §is§3i:w§2§3::

s.~*;»2L§ i’§¥§§?.€§%€§.§;%?.€.?§*‘ %es~:§'<:§*e Ei§‘}{§. aha .‘(EE., 3%; €:§:<~: £.?{}S§. {cf :’e;:z£’§r..

‘£}'§§2 ;§§i3s<=::mt§,2 a‘;~:'"i‘§%s‘;;’i:3';<3s:3:= .35; an £‘§:.<~3 zflif ?.§'}9 :_.=::~;e§_2.§£§& gsazaaé. ausxfi gum. ;*§3.;m..*§z*, it

§sm;>:* triasfi <*:ms:*it :33 t&ss3:2’:3:.s:n§-‘ :3?’ ii}e§*;'§.s.i ‘;«’s§i§.§§2sm3 (Es? smy !‘;:2éS‘§.§'3“:‘§§3¥:j_§" it

:‘e§;§‘:.e2:s’ 12:2 £§:i'mi‘:.si§.§fi.{.m ix: \s'::.iu.~:=a 2:::<.f.%'3. m2.:§:'3L zm-ii ‘aim {iei‘.a%:*'§2r:§m=::«:§ :';3;';.s;§s5“:m2§. wit.§.z i.§::e

V‘

szwasam 23$‘ azasztmge in .-amszi .§§5£3§iT’§{;‘.r‘f fix‘ :;€&=:&=.:*:3:§’;‘;s§2‘;§i£.s§2 :3? s;a2.»::§§

Semmi §£§2‘§m'.° ?m§e:m:~§ far fi_m:§s:::w amwsi :$.3:’gr§>ms:§:m

/1,.

§s‘sfl3.z%m§ $.‘§s.¢§r§2 Ems ¥:>s§ez'~::i: xm :=s*;?i{:§m§<:<%= iiifi “Em §‘.‘.-§‘£i§'§i :>‘3.§=.:a<3, ;3:‘e«:"a;3z=:'i.:“,. :§'”i‘{.§_§§E'i.!‘_2

:':;:-3*; .fu§.fii§ ’;:sz‘s.:§ ta :§}}‘3.')"S{‘;‘ s:ii';;:3i4:m*;i:32§ in

S§W{3{Z. 3%: ’<:‘§*:.§s» a>:“.s">.§:>§§s.i§+;3§3"s: 3. 31;}. ='i~*

mz Ema i$;vs:.;§3 cs?‘ r;‘3.§i‘:€3§:m'?;fi§‘s-ii <>f*.»*§i§i.i§3»~'i‘f£§€§E; 3. :m:s‘z:i:e:_s* <;.s§’ kgsw .-f§;:3;3»§3§iiee km :3» :s=xs'tt;2i;§§3s;§

'i?s’;§2*‘s§ ta‘: in {Q :39 ‘am: ties :;*§<~:-.*am*;:§.§:‘;%§s%

\'

a§is‘;§i:*:i::i':§=.:;§ *3:-§§.:;re,.L s;:s§x‘;if=§cs;§§3,>i. 1-<.-*.‘z§:z.e*.s.;~: §‘§§i§3 i:&::i:i.::3<‘.s:;§«' ‘:31: me e"s: §3£;3S§.

Ivs::§1.2e gtsriztsr 3:13 :*e;:z§i:“ a.:'~:. R3<§s.z:‘:'sf*e<:§ 133;‘ 3-1. "3‘e>.§€a£:2 {'Z§.‘§E'S§’} {T§‘:1.é:> 13.3% 1I«3.:i

CZ

";

.s‘%x§3 £~.i§::‘§3$i§a§.€.z$.E cm;‘:‘%. zi§3;3§ie:~_: {fie zxgesm :~_:'t;::1£i;::3°s‘§ rx:2x>‘i.m.«.=‘, {H2 3. :\;mt§m: §m‘

"ii :§:.z§ss.2*§'.'i.:.m :3§"%§2sw; §.s1i?z3::=::f éé §?f§§?§1¥<€?3° €43. 3;-*. ‘.;‘.:m

sC<3.,, ¥§§S§ {iézia :':.‘’§ 3‘ "§’«é3¥’§ §?€.E§.2:i 2338 at <'§~ the. §3i.E_”§§3°{%i‘§Ei‘:‘i Cee:.:':.‘2”. amtezi:

““ "ii ':=*2<\i‘$’§"~¥v: f':':*' ‘K 3%‘ ,..,.;.~ -«~’i°<** v 3 >’ ~* f“ ‘ti ' i 5 iv 3 <2_. _ ..., . ,. .. ) , ; g a. ...t {..a«...€«».‘ \- \..§.€_.g, {_;§}z_.,. ..}{} \ ii}? t.§w§..§i\. .<§£.. \..3.r} >..Sat§.$..b . Li. >..

;§_:'..:es:g§:3;§ =3? Eazw, §2w3r *;.}5逧§.§g§";. in §«e<ti::§§::g' m<;:—%:‘im:\. it -

zmai the ef;=.visi§3:2.ca§,“ £}‘1{3:2_;.«‘ 1.1. ‘isi»’é2£>£.: {’}.¥3Z? €}§1:‘=a's

2:13. 238$} 4.1%" :‘;§2e s§;§i:a§3:;s.’

“F323 iT3’f§€?§’§¥{i {gs ff}:-§;31;}a}im2 a‘;::§_3,r £§}»;}'3?‘t?:::”sSs3~i§. :f3';*.s.is‘:*§m2:: as {:3 iiize

\.‘-

‘;3’:‘3§.‘s§C§.{:E’ vgsiw gmsi. 3§;;§a2z:i§‘“§;.::a§}§:,. §3£~.2i?§1 {}’f we wi<;fm=:::ses {§§}§ei‘§3£i 13;: £‘§}3;‘.>«-:‘~§§§.?§? {hizn

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 11: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

az-wl ‘;‘.§2:*ee -;==3:>:;:3e:'£;s;} ifs: §*.2:a<§ rm €,'s§}i'§ ‘.,‘§Q3"i aw ti: i:I§'m W-:<j§'::L::LEe»’:: 3;~,u'3s;t: aezmtji

3‘.“i§§}§;E§'§‘.

S)‘

3§3's*e3:'::3s §e’$.*‘§§§i:§ms;. twii :‘e:;*s:§§%;t‘ {sssst w:3:§.¥€§. e,:\‘:*;em% Si ~ar:a§:3'a>. :3? ma’ ~2.>‘a>.»§.:i:‘;’§.<.=.1” ‘§‘;§_>.

\ V

ime 3;?" 532;‘: 21:3: ;3TG=;a§i:3 C33“ fieek am estizzxam ésts c:3:":"ac£. anjmfiasigzaefi {§€e§;c'§e:'3t

3.88, smzi §':::‘:i‘:se2‘ in his {§§;%i'§}i§§i‘.i §T=r~§3 swizisgie xE¥$S§¥§1§§;§§§}’ ‘xx-*::;'§E2.Es°::=:22, ~':I%m* .

\sf :‘e;2e2.§.:3:a §.:_"§3 ta: Kw. 3‘§3—{§?_‘{¥ ax::'$:::.$§v§s %;.?:£~3. ve}:§£:§ w:*33"::§3 t::2m§}>'.” . J,

fviiize .é§Ii{§.€~3I“$;§3£§ 'i‘m:~i’§fis-2:1 in his; o;'3’§r:i:3~:3. *:i§:§:v W‘:-18 w‘z:‘s:ft;%3§§3:§:x; ’}".;'3.. cai»-<§-;

§v§::v§:t:a:'.2ez £.e:';i‘§§Ee»:§ €i;%‘:::i’:;2§s§=_e<‘i v;s3:.:e §zm§»:. sa§§ms;t:§, 3§s§vi.>s;;;: ;:sa':'§: am asrtietie ma

Ema? §§*£§»§;e:s&»:§eé:i ti} Ems: W35 his s:2;::ix';i»:::‘:. i::z:§§:cii31g«; it was :>;.e‘<.":a?u§<ms t§1;3<:

<;§§s:>'4§;§e§.t.ea2$ :;i§:::?: §.c3'ng;§:%s§' §»*s'.2u :.>twr:= 3.}: visixiatisé. ’§”.;rs. £3 §*"«*"§§f§§..:~.:m.«.: me §'::~.-mi mam

:‘3.€-Q*.7§.'§%’£‘i’.“K‘£.§i’§é3‘{i§€}}‘§. zéf §§‘.§‘.*. ~<«"§2%s.i§:%:=:‘s §:}7z*§%~§i¢3.~.2~s eigzé gmazt Lia: x~'.asI§a:.es$ §§.:‘>::2«‘:=:=:;‘3z~.:A§.§',. °§‘.'ps..

iiaimi {£3 :3.f§'$.r §>.:::.:is:is*.siz.;:»as: ta: i‘3:m>. gsssaez‘: 3:333 we--3.~@.;3;s§:‘ 2\':s<3m§, ii

:‘§.€2—’§.'.~s3:‘2'3§.§r3a‘€é{t=z'1 :1?" §‘a5;:is§s:zs‘:3 :.i;§'m§m.:iti§m in *<»‘2§3z.:e -\=‘.'.»;m}.{3 :'m1“.”§.>as;:;§Ii::";§};:z'£<é€i,

is‘; ‘she ::e;}i‘::.§:>r; ate?" §Z?zs':>‘i:i ‘¥x-"i§§‘=ia§2*~.%~;:§,.

es‘-,X.;3e:‘t an ai§.2“;;§:s'i.:§Zi1§3:§ sraiue, mas textiii sari as ta: §::"e»:§a:<<:’i:;§e;3i: zraizws 'i§}{3{‘:i mi N;-am

av;=2§’:2.a2.:i€;:’3, évféi’, 3;§::‘:iE1:is;‘i a:§zz=:‘:;:;=.~:“mi:1§2;§ gxagt _§3zf‘a=:-:t‘e}:}2:&§§‘ '§.‘,§:>. W7» ~<§-$3. £312‘:

we \s'§2i:.>§c3s:° §§a§e;§ E.Q~':;§} s;§imi§3is§3e;i via: :3? 3:1 .Te",»<§-‘i£i..{3*sLI=, 1?€%~‘<3'-Z?‘ 3. Ii§§'.3‘§<€> w=;3»z:§.Zci'

ma a~tt:*§‘£3:::s~:e§%3§aé t§:s: i:2§*:§::*<m+: aifirzxézaisiaegi. rzzsiae, tims %:*=§sv:%:*zs2:it::i::,<‘.§% §“‘~".;-”>is:‘§‘{.i§:§§ s;§.§;§3§V;§isEf:.::a:§ :«*:§.§z:s3

€§.{§L}‘.‘.§§§L‘e'iZi3{‘§ “'C.§‘.% w%m=:. :‘§e,<;::;:;:*-i‘:>i=.'sa‘§ _§u:§i:§* ::a*2w<*;s'2’*§-»:1*:*:::a:2iike :“§2§.sair, go «=i~$¥§‘,. Ti; Emi:

$:i:;:§.i‘§}.{}\~.-\«‘§&=5{§g;§E=:i he: ‘§.¥3.;aa‘i& ma ekaife:‘2‘3';i::a'€§m'; af ra‘:.:§:‘k§:~t v‘3§:§s:*. mast zmsi ;:s:*e«:*:e;1ai:'.

$8

$§§€Z#~}\%?§} .<9§$§§.§+{§¥§’§r§§?§’§‘ $33’

°i‘;*2e *§‘3*i;§§ {::;::m: $2‘. asw2m‘§§§3_g §§{‘§C.{ 3'~::.<z<.}; 313$ f<;:*:‘ $.29

smii .:*§2:§::§esi*m‘i¢

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 12: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§i22:m_s.‘~:% %F‘§‘%T£Si§3§§‘£&:'3§§ far R§%'$>*i«z=:~§=§.* ».s§§°g:§man$

9 §m:ss far :ri:>§;zv:§:3';:;§ <33’ ism: {Ij§;S§.~”i-‘ii fimiteai. ts: ‘iI§nT3t'>*§". ~;2‘i.<..:§z=:‘:‘:i::.::,z;»+.,.

Eimasi "‘§<:m'w§;r;g§3.*”.

101'

’.

Time €:';s>::;:;;3L¥es3s:2i: §'.‘t§.§§=.«.{'§. §;«:m.:2::‘7;' .1 sat §i>i’*i‘.§‘é :*s:z§Lit.i;:s.§a=.~: :3‘? acmm fm° re<::3ve:‘j,.r

‘in

:..:::.:t3e:* me fI:3m:1:_::':«s.鑧‘ :‘.§:~.23.«as §?2°a;t§:§.{;:e:s3 S;°.2~£¥€'i.§{T£:i§§}’. .‘;-a:_*_‘;"2:§}i£*;s.: Z, ,.

e-y~< *‘

.2m.:i s .01, 2. "§‘§§é: as3§@§§::z$'§is:xs as §"s:3;‘t§3 £32 §:;:z§*a§;3°;;s;::%:s; ami ti'39- ‘i‘3’§}§j_;5"

a<t‘:%§xs'itiee2; M’ Em-"{‘;iLT fmamé :2: £:ss9§3.:2 s:t<m‘:::t1ié;'=;:<2<§ “‘§x“§1<3zvsri:§:§‘~§:¥3§’”§ fizz? i’e1i§z:z':*et:3 ‘gum-‘$239 an

Eist. :'§=.+§3;:§;*s §3e~::*§‘a::‘rm2::§,. iaiwzti ;><22“~s:3n ;}€~32"%’§3i‘§r§'§¥3g {fie z“’§%§;5z'i§¥’ rs?‘

S:‘3'§”$'*‘.§€§3 23.21:? fixes fai§z§1*e 3:13 ti} Nix‘. ‘\>"‘~:’§i§ia.:"§\;.:?sN we §*e;3§e§<::e::E

f§:.2eat%i.:iE *~:e'a’:‘e 33:"-§3~sez*.ite<3 its $13532‘ 3"‘? :3?" v'ss::‘im,;s »~::¥ai:31:: 6.3%’

<‘§.z§mag§>. 23.§::s§%:‘§;::é{i by .e%.§3;}e%§§§%§a "§'§.‘=a§ fiury‘ tr: ;~;pe{t§ss.:§. si:.=J:.e;'r<2§;at:2;§r 1.§3s€§,» “§.‘[.s;§.. 83$

}‘:'sg3mti§§<:z::§..§y 'iTs:m.m§‘ :'S’v“u 63$‘; :t§_>:*:3j;’::.F§tt:~:d. s:;s:t§:z'~.‘.:' z‘3§.=.:::&;3*i‘.iv§% z§<.t§;zs' zmd: aims ass €.‘§:§~.

§‘::i§.=;.::*:~: ‘ire: %;:2“:w§e'i.ss;2 §‘.£«“§‘ w'£‘i'§§ sass. ii‘.<>;2§:.2‘_~:‘i.r.~?.e*.:‘§ $5: :33’ v~§'§§§§‘.§‘s §‘z'.§§%:§*£.§‘.i‘Ii-M tiw i.:*2.e:i.iv§=;i>~;:;z§ Wm

}3§§;°§a_>:*§:~m;\§ *;§—‘_~%: '§‘€:‘;§';¥.-’:Ei’§‘ am‘: Swiizi §;.~:.:- §.m2<i{~;«:“ rag: ;::s:m.::;, {i‘\~"’v‘&§\~'3“{i’§ <3;:2:s‘§:sg:v.::s in

;»3z§1.{.smfi‘ .’T§§:s.=:~:.-:i;~.2;E E:§f:.a2:‘mg2§.?.£;:‘;i*§am f{.{3.§;.. 1338, ’T{’.«:‘.§. §‘i‘}_, ’u:?{3r

'§’}‘:§% :I*‘m“£;§:e-*;::*~<;2<§ 2<s§:s.:"s’J~:2§‘:=5{;§ iE‘§.§§.¥'§‘E"{}gI;§tiifififié -£'.§i§:'§§i‘.‘{i${§. "iii: ;’:§§:_i§m§:‘§ $'.m§:~A‘:'.§L>;‘§s mi"

§‘s~’§i;"r‘Z§33‘ ‘s:‘se§3.it";'¥.s2s Re;:3>§:° §>‘d.§fE«z=;*._,! :2. “iii: §.i:;«:*£. SW 2 ;::2§§—s::'.i {(3

;3.z":_>°.»'.i§§,£ ::: wr'§.§.'§t§2‘:§ §§s.:'£ :'.s':'.’ mt-;?mu;‘2'; §.§e§z“§f{.::‘¥3':§§.§ w§';2'§.<.:§;z i:§.§s:r3+i“is?§.e{i t.2%.2e §Lz';sLi_§v:i.~:.‘§=.;3§ j;§s=:::°.'m“:r3’i.:s;§ *:.§2ea

-.

m§3;z§;* S;::e:‘:€a§ §mier':‘£3§g;e2‘§m";.* 16,, ’§“.«;i. '.i;'§1a§; Si‘-*‘i<*€.’{Z §";si§»2%:.§ m £'.~c'~r:‘:.1a;§.e:s“ ;:~:§,m:~,

imn‘; $123

Tiw _’i‘aT:‘_~\_',-‘ ‘s.«va:.s it; i§;,><§L‘<S:a:§. E:1§.es:“;":.sg2xt:::‘}¥ '§’,<;§.. , :=:;::.3,e‘ miimj-*

am af§‘;sfma- .*:§v§é§y 2:<s3':‘3*~:>g;:tm‘§es ‘E ‘€§1§“{}iig§‘§. :11 a:";<;i ii 4-, 3. am‘ if: was; aisznm

“£<m‘.<wi;1g§}*"‘; ‘%:§*2.§ _§:::‘y £i'.‘:"§.‘s‘-\T:§-’:-E‘.}"ié{§ §:.§s:':‘%:i§j;.*'i§:g ';w:‘3 e‘:<‘;2§“:‘;§'.2”;'§§:t§3:‘§ “;§§mwi::g§y” i‘.§'se=..\

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 13: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

2:i§‘;:;‘:~3 §‘§i'§3'V§§§&i‘. "{.§§§2 <::'3:*,:‘»‘1sa.*2';.~<.2:r w?~§§:§:% ax w¥'§‘i‘¥;§%§§ {sf wifi‘: ‘ck:-5 i.»:iaa:';*;.§.§.},v‘ am: p:=:z“s{3§3

§3«a:*§:3’:'m.§.:sg ma: 2‘<:2;*:e§.§:°, ami >:‘§.:£~: ’§.‘:§‘i§:s.:*~e ‘:53 tazagier gfiiazcexxzezité §‘32‘:‘:':‘ii§§; ?i7:3‘i'»2>:*:":>;;§z:m§‘;<;‘

-go}

(441

3

wt9

[p11-ii ‘aha §u:*_s;.=‘ in3{Eu-2 {i:~.m1;;§§§ss:: as:.i‘s§?cs1:§;s?;s.§e :22 the aim a‘:-:>:';:2‘::~§t;€:«.;%a*;

Hr

°’3;.m>w*§:3§;§§x“ $33" ms w:=::*e 23M-*a§.i"£‘§.::’.9£i

rg)\3

t:he §‘.:mm: *§:?.s»i:§‘::{:§.~:-sci t..l*:& §u.;‘:§; am wiaat ::m2sa:i.:‘::mi ".§<s.1{:wis:.;;s,_§;:".~

::<m.s*§.s:<=‘\:ami‘ w.é~:.'€::. {Wm} §:.:2‘3~*‘ §§15ii“m“-'ti§>:‘§.:§,. §'::s*t:“..:<::%i:zg s‘::§sa :.:s.s‘:::_ w§;‘.=;‘.§3 3 £3?‘ ‘£.'3.:1.

ties ~:;m=.e {'§‘:f?:'i'§“i.i{‘.’¥,'§€,Si‘3. imii-m'§i<§ me :§ef'i:1i’:i::3:§ af "‘§«:;§:'3x-x>':i:'.sg,2:§.3;s“ z'm§§_¢'

‘a

3:11 £‘§.2',~3§1s§'§‘i':£‘§..‘§ .::sa'_i‘%s.::z 9.?" ‘i-*s‘§‘§§:%‘§§§’.3i§i“ .1; §*§;::it3t§f§" amtitiiaési £1: uraaiea" ‘13=*§-§S»,§}*§3,

s‘a2§2s:.s.2“n iv‘, firs? :‘v§‘:::zf>:3s‘* {R}... {'3' «$5.? {.3§..;’:3 :§;.$'.?, £3

\Rilf§‘.§.3 {?:7~’} {2} :3§i:3w:s at Vim '.;“§a§. gm: :§:?at:::‘:=::§a'm ta: aw,-=:m.:3

atmrnefg if “V§:§‘§'i‘§§2 :~:.:§;::j;:§§§=.:‘ k:‘::;:wi‘ng§3: cczmrzxittgagi an act ar :3 €:.~3.z§t

x » ;;vi;3Vi2sm23 si:§';:a§_m=:r .. :'u:'i'§az:sr {§§§‘§.3‘§§’?ig i§«::z<3wf§e:i§;+e as "...V.s:u::t:.za1§ m.<:.ra:‘:,-3m§s.:.~2, 'i'3::§‘

3‘§‘§:~I~i3x" :13; *;«»~.=*§::=:m <>§>§e<::'iw.2 ;~;~;.a§.:>:§3"aa2:‘s'$e§>:'i{:':t3$ i:::i§::;§ts3 =§‘§1a§a:' ‘aim is*2z:?Ji?;~*'i€§.§;§a§

i.:2:r<3§m;ss;§ wi.*:.§.: :s“;s~:‘.§‘z ;:zwe§:°em3x::."‘ é‘.‘.m:;*::' ;‘3s;:t§_::§§' :m:- the

§egi$§;§‘§:iv§5 ;§:.:’;‘;t3a:se :33’ ’£:§n‘=.é .$i£:.§I in=::s: by £‘i.:iz:i.i.z:=. ?£.§T§§E"§' "’<3wi;:§;i.3~*‘“’ s:*csmI31§::*;§2?:g 323 33%:

x::?:a§;§t;i€s:2 mi‘ }2.{.‘.. ‘.i.Z:‘.«»<‘§~E's $333 5::_§.:=;:§ie:“ ::e=.a"s<i csnig 5I§i‘$‘{'§3§3iT§(}}'i2E‘:§.:§<‘ {its ";§::a=3 EE133: v.€a‘:i;-2-‘%:.a$:s3

§§'i§3 {ES §’g<°a.

’§‘§':+s2 E§1:§m;2’:m {Ia-:;:‘¥. s:.:i>£se<'g §.:e:1§’§3;-‘ sir: .R:‘:3;31=e2r‘:a 4 :**:'~—:Z7:::zm 3.33: '}“:;>_;§»-‘:',>£»r.i. 31%,. {E 1:} 35%.

{‘3§‘§‘§.{_z *3:-€%~’%.«,

‘i»§='§§saz:*e, Emm, 3:2? cam ‘:§.~3 $»~:é§3.;22*2§te—ai ta :2: ciaiw 'f::3:‘ w§‘:§::§2 zasire

:*§2.<:s73's.r«.s3~2*z:ah~§a2 £T§a§.§}”§‘§. fax‘ 'wh§<:%: 3:} '§3§?éES Sfifé? ‘.‘§"i:z§é i‘.i'§Ef<§.

s.:s.:«u.r?;i :‘:::m;‘i' §.m a3;:s;§ §’s3r i;i§::2 csszmi‘ Git” ;m:‘$:.:'§:3g 3 s§aTis~::

2-2»'§i2i¢:§*3 3222:}: E35? awi::23‘{_ie&§.“. §”§.s‘§::‘.m»:<::; mi. 3.‘: 1

ygyn

.

~;»:. .‘i-’V§%‘\:“§2;2-.*"§<;=..e‘*2‘.} ~“~€‘;'é:$. ELS. 33, 3:33 {Z<;sm"~: ;?;*$3‘£3*:3‘t

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 14: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

A 3in 3»: ;$’:m".:?%2_, .»:.-as '13 -€);7§'§'i{3«I§.I£.§‘?_. §2*~“w1;3§3. §m;.:::‘i ‘§';=:‘:.:3§ cmzrt siiid mt:

\>aziszssaé its‘ aim >;-:r'.%;z§é§: Via‘: §i:‘i§i‘$€~.%s:§ the mi¥.{3';‘rsse.j; mi ts: we::"’§.»; §.>e:*§<;::*::‘:.~::§.% f:‘3‘r‘

izfim .;2‘§3.§}£”::«v&£§ ::m*.z.<;m‘:3:z=:.:" haw‘ v§<>§;s’§.i.x321s 2-mei mat s:=§:i:e§2* as“ s:am:‘t

m><:s:>i 3:: 13.1? ~z«»'§'.ém: s'a;é::as;:3::;§f%3§.::: ;-.:ét-:‘.<':3“.m<s§; ;m:*s:a.;:-mt RAE. 1%. {$2} iiéss:

sgmrt s§‘::;3L:.§si §E.=.*>:a°£ .£:;«:Li~2::§:~:.'i's tins ;3:.:;3:.?:§§3§‘ £33?" §1:>:m :‘§3;;5:smE'sE§r s‘3.Xf§3£§£3{.‘§£?{3i in the

'§.E3i3$§‘.§§‘§§§~§‘.-ii itay §*‘a:9.s;z3:3;§ §3a‘;.::‘.Z§<‘ ’§‘I%:a>. ::‘:.:m“t zmted in time §§}.§?§§E}eif1§i§§.ii.i§€§‘§'§.£}§} vim

ism? .::<.:m- :a:§2.<mi::i a=.:x.:::t§;=.: aux}? ?§>:}‘\§.?:‘E§ %c}:.at wm“a2 :m:‘sa2a.s:";:3;~1i‘:§§ é??xf'§3»E§§*»~€.§$v‘L‘§m.,?§§i&1{. ‘Ems

(:3:-mm: ::';m be iimm 1-s:§*:i.a>i‘§ §§2§%s :‘3::as~zre:*a§3$.sa :a:z.:§i 33:)? w§:§zr§2

~':‘~;+2 :;mm*. §§.‘:i§S§‘. {§i‘3§.:«‘" ;§'ee:° the m‘;:~;.s:.:gm2:' {?‘;-:?.‘§.}“§‘§§3 gcmxxt ix:

the ::3e:s;:*::z. Em“ wizizrk fees ir3§%a1waz":§a{3, cc;>:";s‘i::'ta:1:’: *»;«s.rit}.:: ‘Em: ::st3;::‘§_.":~.: §’§::<Zi:1g::1 ;§§f€T2?:‘3£3T.

\

§_.r2f>*<:.. it: this iiisass ex-°i:ie.:';.<;r:=.s ‘§3'.i”i~?S€%?§’§‘.$C§ at the s?;§::;:s§s§.¥ea‘s

iiimiz iifiasfifi rm aafistmm ‘ix: .¥:,as'w' ;*m.:a‘.f§i ti t3‘;‘}§¥§.’e§. §.i-%§ga=.%i§2.g am ;}a2;**:.im§.-mt‘

itiiiififié ittkszz,

{WN: x.E§§~“::~°x ms §::2.sm:§ sits‘: §'§{:a£-3: ar«::m§:‘2§:‘§'.se::§.K§'2‘::;>w§:zg§3I°° s‘§§§‘§ mist; ;::°es§.§2n?. ‘§1{3"s?é.3§

aiiezi mm

szmmaei 3“‘:‘<.m:: aa<7e;}§.i;‘zg {}§'§';E€?i' s1m3.w:.m.§ei§. m;:~2' :'~:;:;m:_:;:1E:n<.2:* §;:<::2.§:§:‘;ei wim I->;>::m:is‘s:.2s.: :‘;§::sT.m&

§i:::i§im'.§<:r3s. Sj;.>es:i§i<:a:§§_3:., Em s:st3'§r3§2ii§i‘§‘eai “§m<w»»*i.::g§y“’ 2-vsere .*:§:<§ é’:‘::*I§m‘**e ts: i:z=.sm%.ess*

.r&2;>§s2:m§:§a::‘i' ;”:‘3E”‘i‘.$ amszi the }§a2<:§.»: :33?‘ iiiam mi‘ the: §‘§3::§?::3=i::i2m in fimi ‘éé}§§E‘i.::§;§ §‘:*;;>.m'

f';§W£i“.A £3 ii :':‘_;'i.<,.i mt i€3r:>:r'ei%: 2%:-e :"*a;§;=..a§::‘»~‘.~*.:"3 _m.§:u‘::~g.2i§ ‘:s:%z;‘:§2‘:§.a:::.2§;«‘ am e>a;~:§2's‘t§.«_:e;

put:

.3; j§esrt>:I3§»‘4 5weas 23:2»: iaieiétéféséé.

Wi§I§i2i—i¥3:»‘~, ‘3’.§3« 131 .§;im2:§ ; 223 R’? fs~;zé..Eu:2*es {:3 i:iem*.§§3; the t§3::§i1;:’:a: ':‘«\:§;‘3V¥.2;.::s§;*:ze:§;%; §;3.:~%:-3,

§£%§‘e%3i?§v" ‘;=’$*"§T§§Viam‘:s;- i::ai:‘:‘:;¢§:a§~::E aw/£5 rm §‘§§3§‘%-‘X-*'i';?{;?§¥ §'3i';:'2s::s:§.f' amt? Si {sf

1-»)

:1}

?

E-F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 15: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

:a:w<:::_. '§‘,j§. :1 SR. §§I}'}§3$ '1, g) :1 Eimzs HZ ; iw; .§.§:§.§?‘a‘.§>:‘§i;s‘s;§ :iie:‘:.§:=.<.:'§ .i:::. M: <'£*§m:t*:'

t.ast.§:§:.:>ay..

£23 asfiaiétiusz, .~t":.g3;§a3ii§§2azz’:z: §Im:.~;L;3§;§‘=i3';’: at :»3.s;$§*::":ea‘3. f.\T‘;=‘§~"«{I~§T_Z .{'a§;E:=s{?£ {:3 §.:::z3;3:‘~::* £33.33

§‘e§3§::,2;‘.<~.a‘ ;;;::r'%.:s.. 37:3‘ §'§.«‘.-<‘ <‘.§.2::t3;::§.z4::*.e2»:§ §’st3m:: a2.:.2>§'§z.<.::‘§:=:§‘:sg ;‘SW§'Z€£ in §3e;*:':3:‘m

§}*5fa3r::z:a::1£’5 ‘§’s<‘§}${3;‘§‘§ i’:2€:Vimi:-3:3 3:3 msm. :9 he §3m:‘i<e=3»§£ izim {£3 wi3s=2§:%:a-*...:*‘ w‘§.:§}'.s¢2e:.§

W iv % M U‘:

V11 9% t”$'

52 ’‘‘?§ 3 (‘KS

21”»

.

’i.:

we &‘*?;v‘x~"§‘§.§e‘.’.§—‘§ Wm Esséi i~;éi;mE<‘. %wx>*'§2-sgg 3:-s:;:’::§: “is”: M34

€?;m2:§33,zé.§:‘§§: $33.: kn *:§§‘3.se §*i<}§;«:t.§::;*§.: 3:“ irfae i?v§i’s?'i§€..§~‘a. ;.2.:*§=.«s:.:§t 5 £.é;1:zc:'r3§.s

»::§"§°£:“a£i s:z3:3;te‘:‘:§'%.§§; ii: wane :§s;::;3e§§~2e’:s;: {‘§'¥.§’§.‘I},*‘ 23;; *i‘.§*§§3 time :‘mmt'~:~3 ii

e$!tzs‘:§§is‘%3i§3g Ei§‘£€3. ;::t‘a:vi.:ag s'::.»:°§3 °ei:;>§2:=;s’;i::>;§:: $.i§3£7i in §I§‘£&‘. a.:';_§_s" a.%:‘:'§s~r:';}>t ta ii-ex :‘"§2m:ie§‘s

{Em s.-zwemi af zs§tt:3:*§3a$«;«‘ Em: i‘.:'§ ::*.<:sz.a:*t; an asiszssm :1?‘ :1? is; £‘.}"§3'i‘.i<;‘>i“§.

4 \; V \ " r‘ .- _ .

€i‘.3~‘§'i$3‘§ {§}$ E-i‘€3“§{§‘t§.§}'§ £3‘? §‘€$-S 3§§~%‘$‘\§.§“3"§3{. 3?}lbw

§:m:.;';s;M§2§. as £%'ti‘£%.*;”§*§I§‘3“C ts‘) s-':;::’t;: :4

j§3§.§§“S§.§ii‘é§;€ tiw swims f<+:»:.2:“:s:§ a:<§mmi:*::ea; “R¥mwi::giiv”. A;:§3e§§»s.ésss' £*asi§:.m§ ‘(Q S$3}'3EE§‘&§i§3 s'a:a:§\; iime,\‘

< 2

am? time: :2<:>-t .-‘\.2§.3§$‘E2i;i§§ Eta‘ ‘mzriiem 2:-mi ’a‘.:*§£.s.§ §‘.::m.3*i‘. e;im.5<~>::3 ati§.s::.:‘a2:‘:‘.:..§2 £2“; a.w;mi.=::§;:.;:

sz:§~’;m“:1~e%§;' fin" 3&3 ;;:s:%:‘§3<;:‘z*::w:<3.

’3‘§w t:‘za§::§s:a°Ej;§€. :2? ::?£:m3:‘AE;\»‘ €.§:2e::* :2? we z2<:‘t.:: =f‘m.:mLi ta: §“:<€e2X»"§¥

i3€}i“§T<3Ti”§§§.'i7§%z§. m{.;2:.§m;i §.%§§‘;}€~fii”§‘ {3‘£%§,'V‘

’§.‘§§§R§:§ :%:5$§«§§§§¥»r§§°i§§’§‘ $:“.$3§<‘ Eififfififfi.

’?§:z§s Triai C.<;31.:§*t §2§"3'a::: §3%‘3£.§-$.‘§fs,€‘ .*§;3§3<2i§a:3t‘s: §‘<.s3“ ’§‘2“i2:§.

Emma §:-m~.»:§3:*§§;<:s€§ far Ifiesview ami §§r;g§.a.;:3§a:3§.

§°s: e:'m§* §s;e:‘ {Em §;:"§a.§ acszszt £9: aiaszagr the :::<:.i:> :1 fS§' fiéew ami:§::<:?;s }3T§‘§‘~:.,*§§¥§‘£§L&?~i‘§ €§‘\i.¥55§§§I.§{¥{§S 23%‘ §2§..a':§,, ‘W-‘§.:§<f‘§s wsz:-M‘ m :%:e Ema: *: a:§‘.s§§3;~=:rs§Iiee’e:

1-

itat‘ x>‘;2.§zs:x.r.~.=,.

§s~§a>%._‘§<3¥a fats?‘ §&§;~2w' was :;s§‘a‘~:r::s’::ea;‘E mi tiaai kiss: fizsyg muss: trzai §'§°§f s:»:%§§.§

\ \ ,_-‘

'¥;§:.z=‘s~ ‘J‘§¥§‘§.§i3i§3,. a -*'}':‘§:t§: azazai his :‘1.>;*ee ~<‘~:x;3e:": ¥i-‘§T‘~II§§:‘:‘Z‘$§T§?EE "ztes':i:%’:'.m:§ in mafia‘ a_;3§nie::2

32.

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 16: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§*:s‘:f;;z:§ §s'3§;S__. i§'§3$:-if-:‘5 ‘its: »:i3*iL'*¢;-we, 35:-3:3 ms ;$::>s;t ta‘; :*»=:a;;§a§;‘ €.‘\‘C§§§§§§.€:'€€§ tfiw fair :2-:a2;'~§<ejt *.»*;2z§.m§.\

’§’.;;:. 'i.§:§, E88, fig §s=f£.i§§e Kip. «M»; amzé. {}a:s<*.i:*; W=i.§§.§a§::';:s.,. ‘iigx

§§}§§}§2§.§§§§5 Exam :9. :i:3Tt3=' 1*.-2 ii‘.ig§:=:~‘;‘e ii-3.2‘: €I.§§%§i‘§3£§€§ €.’.§2';ii§.‘:“: .:“:§r-* .%si§u-:*'e ts‘:

§.:ss;e:‘3“az":‘:: :;§z.w<3r§rs:§sz§1§:i_§.<§~ _mzm.m2=.:f <}=:.§”:~>e.* a&§:;(.3§3 w§‘zi.<.f£*: 3:55 (:3:-.:§:;:2 xx {$25.53;}

swim 313:7 ‘m“ea::§1 {)§€?{‘:31'i‘.;‘€-§§.‘.‘§,, i»3§‘¥'C{1 %xa{§ m.~:' ;*»<s§,:zgi:'s fazr

w§:§afi§§ ii”. ‘x.-<3-;:_z.s; C~1§}.‘§.§‘i"E§€3§.§3I£§ ts‘: ;3:=3:‘*f£.::-‘m. §§m§‘.s:::‘° time 2~;':.i.‘:.igati»:m ais:>c.t.;"i:c;.s:, {Size ;3a3:*t3»*

that "gm-:§~:ez: 3 zziaiim am as c<mt:*:§<.:t §a:m:3ii dé-::trs:;age£s {ism it gtsmfizi isawez ;;m<.~>xs*;»“:_:‘:~:;e;§. E33;

~> ~\ \ ff: ‘n r\

;'z:=.s:zs»:m3..‘:s§e 2:?§§:*;§3;xt§w.=. a:ct§.=:m.. ii§.§:;:;; §3‘:1:::*§:362::sas:,§':¢rz:»‘§r<mma?::£:3{( .s*:;:;t; 2.»: i*§’e3££;§E£~t§s:? €..s:.>.s‘,, S3‘ ‘'13,

1.

§}§3ii‘s §&f§3‘~;};I3i:3. Li ‘B :1. { fifiizst. Eiiam, {la 1§..*‘E§€?*§}s am‘; wizixsh ms}-asixi. i}aw‘~a2

g3:"-e§*a:e:*r{e~a§ E33,!‘ rs;%a::<::s:*_:.;2§3§.es asaziierm w§¥:§2<:>u*:. ::2.§i3s,:t2::§s:i.a.§ its sszzscfiz ‘;>am‘.§«2 {I1:§:;°mé2§‘st§

E 12.13 {fihics éiiifi, £3?"-':§ ii? {$3-‘ T£}§$§~. {‘.u;s'a%2a§~;§: (3:39 I£‘$?§¥§3}.,at

“me Sims: {Ema m3't.ezi £5 gaaaty win‘: has 2-s-*;*:3::gs3s;§ ‘£33; 3 :33’ m:3%:r:§s‘.‘.i‘.

:.:m3<>‘ mi‘. §i$‘§.§"{E%£§£§{?駒i:>3§C§}§’ iafiy E332‘ aziéati a>;:i§§s:3:=z;-* ts: 3.ec=:s.>s:m§;::";§e Em: %i.>:3=::2*£:§e2a:;~§. ':m‘::s'i'.

a~':t=:~:r:'z;;><: mi:':imi:«:s22 §§i.s s.‘éa:':'sasge. §‘m§s, ‘ya "§e:;=£mr:"s_:z .s*;s.:2m§ ..3’z‘;nm<§§ +.~..‘::‘.

:3f§:“sz‘;,. 1§{}E§ {3%§:2§<> i?§;3:§ -\§'?‘§§, Z»§:=i'Bs“§S“=I3§3i.:>~;?i€3?i§«, $3332

_ s

~<§.?3.<:‘:L '3 £13‘ §~E;m1. iii)” ‘;i‘.3§%si3} tizer s;§.;§:*aa1g:%$ sa §°‘§:«:ii.>r;§‘§‘§f *L‘.a‘.3~'¥;i..§€§ ;>.+vst;s:‘:ie;§L mm

:*e:asss3m*:b§§2 w§::'%3<5:.:~:'. :.m<:‘£::.a§ mt‘ {.T;§,¥§‘£§~£T3‘£. Em {:§:;w=m§ §3Vz:s?l‘::2m‘i;azm,

é§W{;{I i‘§‘é{;¥‘%s*§3§.’§. $93‘ as mew t:*ie»;§.. ;i{3A=§:, g¥'<:mm‘§s ;:z.:':%::=\s.:§.:::‘. $3} {Iii-“'§.§i his:

‘-by»

?

M §=§i5{:;§:3:§.:.:;‘.§. 1}? ‘;’i:a=: ;>2°~<.—v»*‘::3}§‘i§..2&g; gtzavctgr;

{'3} §~§esw§3; «;;§V.?=s.‘:;:::;v..>'~:2Mm:;t.§ :=:w;.:'.§a;n':ae .:'§§:§.'§.ss33‘_i§2§~; .f‘<::2*~ {fie §3:a2‘:3:‘ a%§3§§§yi:1.§.f;. 3-*£i:1"a7§: w§.*:‘%a

:‘a;§:sa:sz2:«;2i:sjie cmzfiei mi‘. hzwe ize-es‘: aw L;-3‘:~:'s.:iL:::::';«:.‘; witmfi

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 17: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

W} E§‘3"Gi‘ ti? r;3-c>:::.;:;*:'.§T;;_,§g; zai‘ Ai;3?*£§::§;3§.t '41‘: rfize :1:-texxtfissn {sf ‘tim £:‘§;§§

'i‘%:e s\*§I«:>€i:>;*; :'“7'se2" ’§‘:*i:~:i. was f£"»i§}§.3§3§'§§3s;§. 3:33;‘ fixes: 2‘sff§*i2;~§v§§::; :,‘{};w.i<'3. ;”i}:~.2;:mtm,. 1‘;E.

13$ wa‘.-‘.§~': §.>§‘;=&-’§?'£s;>::‘§j; Em: -e:~:.;::§3=:‘§ts f{.¥§“ .s°s;3;§a=.§i§:~mt.arm {3$«‘E‘-i’§€‘._f,

“§‘§m ;~.’i°;Vr:§m2 miémeri {sf }‘W cfiaims were the Vfi §';1%.:::§§e itzza 1*; :*»e2;3ai:‘s:2~:i ‘§ am

i§.§.'£W‘£)i"}{§}i3£§i’1§.§3£&? :::~;:;:1‘m:f, ;‘§‘£:::* fa3;§§u:*»:? iv: f::§i:3w Ema gi-§3'z3i§‘i2i:;%?.§&s.§i§§ f0.:'*:§:. §¥§<}z‘.<:‘3:‘

azraai .32 car:ses.§u.e%::s:§s mat mzféjg‘ as §.iLi::si:n.2t.é:1a.:2. \="'>§§u§: it:1§'ii:e;-35 ,‘:‘§%;‘>W ‘a1”§‘é$&3f{? ts‘:

s:ir§v&,re*£;§‘:e *;»*?§:§*:§£;§ie vs-*£sr‘i‘§3iev;::.

L2a:*‘:*_3;»‘ §\=§’s:3::te=.ma2:, §%§'i§<e Anszgie-::*s:s'::», :~.z:z:.§ ‘§*"x_».“i§§§ams e;:=.<:§:

%.a2s£%§'.§£s;i. ‘£3.23 v:e§2.§€§r52 Ema? .:1s:3t'i::e<m ;‘£s;>a2§:‘aé¢i 1‘.-3 §s‘;'§£3£.t§.§‘§a;ti§§;?§.{;3?i§§ .3 as am};-:§:*ea§

u.§3s;aas‘§’és iii} ;§2*iw3,. s“es.z:§i§‘§T;t3g ism‘; {mi}; is: {§im§.::2:.:\:%m: ‘;f'2§ §‘zié? ‘:3 2.21% {E29 wsi'1§s.r§$ mi;-* :'§éi‘.;3§:§~a%~:§

52:32-*;::§,§<§ xx‘;-aim? {,3-ii}£:iL£3‘i%3t§§1ii£3-{Y%§1"§§§}*€€'S§3§3*C€?fi as }32a2';‘t .Q§}*°?x§3;§fi§§aa2§2’&: &f:3$3§%}, §s:s:<:%.: the

’z«**§?}‘£§C§—i:‘. max: z§I:~.a:a§’;:% ti: :3V§,:s§3:f;::‘:.a film: szragit ts; .:*es;t::.n"<:2 =':3t;§2 w.3':’i 53:2 11:3 ;;:z;§§s:zi:

maiitiaxgz V:=:.>’:::a§«\=::§sea_eT ;m°§3s»s.2:3i: va:§z.:e.\

it is §‘£é3i.1€3f3‘T€‘:§£§fi§.IT§3€= 5;~?§£~:=m§.a§2“<“.§ s:2»:’:*evii§2x=sr an 3 §?»’§i>¥;i€:¥} fm’ “§‘:~*.i.r.~.:§ 1:?"

£ii::s:re2:i.2:L:3 wi §£§1 af smam tfiizzm an af _§:§s;‘§.g1'§§.i?:¥3‘{T_: ;:mgi z:a:;2§:{.z?i;&s;~; <33:

'i‘.§‘§tf3 {sf tjim %_z.*iz§§ ~:?£;3§§i.*i‘ ititzsszi :;;.:3c::e:“a:ss:i<>;*;s?z’-:>§§, :3? 2§'§T§3‘§.§‘§‘§§}“ff. .¥§:‘e;:k

£1-ltrxizsrarf, {Ti

in ‘s‘.'§‘=.§§ 2§}‘.};3§§“.§§‘§I‘§3i.}§ {>5 *§..?;§e zamge ai§§::::‘a=':§cs:'3 :;'t;§:‘;:§au*:i :*§2i.=‘§.w.%, ‘§§?:'is: €1m32*£.{§rsa2s mm‘

\

:~?ss2.::::z‘$;i.:.::.:if.$ :’t.:'s‘ §:_.:t.:§§z::::m:.‘£. §;éxaz.t' ax‘? aim triai scram but is :‘:es;§3—e<:'ti‘;:§if s.aa:‘é:::*§i=::;m% ii: mass:

me £33: its <i.e%*»:»2*:2.*:‘:1>§;::s:% x-x~*%2.e*~:tf§'se;‘ ms '£:*§e§fi §:€.i§.1i‘t;3§3-Liséésfi :‘3is‘s‘::“3“§.“isf3‘£‘, in tine

£§s:%§3i;:§ {ref _§*z2‘.’£:x>tim: €76? 3: sass-:‘s;*3§2<:tf::§§j,v‘ s=:2_‘§*;r:‘:~§%;*;<;2:§ “-;‘}:-s ::'3a2t=:m* ’w:;s.e: é:z"§.a2:.é its 3

*:§1§2 §<*.'§€}t§fi'31 ta §\‘=m-;«" iffl-‘:‘i{3§§ a::s§‘i.;_:mé.<*l. 4§:z:;igz::. yx~*§1::s:a5s1H3etiI

t§“;»~;2 §3:i=§2‘.}C§7s ‘aha :'§':i.:§ ma*£ti‘a;* xvtgzs ..<.:a£ fay? €;1?*§s:§ was": :‘m§‘. i.m’-*<§§%:<é<;§ 3:33: ‘;:?i‘§3~i“.i‘i€§§

33

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 18: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§;:*c::t:<§<=:a‘§;'§t3g:; §‘:}’§{§ ~§.°.-fmze t::Em~=§2:a§3I:;:g‘ :‘::s~<.rz::’;£:%£3 M332‘: §:e;:3:*§ 3*:*::::2:%;s;§;*s. £31 :*v:~:s;3m:t rs‘; $:§:§.<; fii’-§§‘a1>._.. £3.

11.1’:-{}.. E§§2s:.a::s:§2 am: :33’ {five &§§§3&?;$2t.i.s;>;3s $2“; -ms f¥>«-‘§«s;=i':i::<:.: ‘§’:3:" §.\i<3a.-:2‘ ’}‘m‘:a§, fixeif. :*’§.<j§?1:f?*fi§§<‘-‘-%i‘-‘~

i:.>;«>s:*i:£.=fie& 21% 23$ affareci tes?:.is2'1:>-s1§e*§‘:‘:3m' :‘3‘iT§.‘s §~5.x;-;2a‘2:**:;s isés: x-*a=s§':‘§.z:3$ §‘:e::.§ ‘gm '£:*s:;=.:'ix“&i‘ 22;‘: :3 as

ss§:€mis;i §3:;;w‘£': §3;:i_§?' vaiazaé, said %:s*=g:.{:i§$< "‘q»‘~“.§§‘§§(.”§§.¥ §‘§§.a:§ was *2‘ iZ{>i’§§3§i§S§{)}’§

< 2t..§*:::2i' Sizesgamzg {£3 fs1rt§3e;' zziimv‘ s:.m§~2 R‘: .‘§wes§:s3;mai. am

§}:'§3$§3§3i‘.€::€§ 3-sri>:‘§*'§ §1:3§. §3::<;§§a2:t:3$;.€:m: in w}'.aai:a‘i‘ x- -ms §«:.:.;i:sw;‘:..

it §‘x2s;;;ez;:i'i‘:s3§%:‘ ;~m‘:m‘:‘§.‘:ts:%:.i 12%: at E3134 “§)§‘§}C§3§§1i§‘£ fI:3»i.§s‘s\-»:‘:=::f£ Viz}? tLi':e :::_m .‘§"t£.§§§‘£.C$. {.323.«

WC?

§.§1«a3 §<»‘§»;”§ii§»:‘3§‘= 53;‘ New .2 :**§a;§i wmse 3 s>iss;::3§zi§ £355’: am 35, 'w‘%.:§c.§"; x-v<::uE£§ an <3?‘

:f§iS:33“>§.?‘iTi£}i}. -m :.:rsm:"m§.z%2* .SW{Ii§’::s _¥\~'§{3::‘i.mx ff}: ’F:"§;:}, s:.;:am:m3 mkwexriaés-v far

£f(>i‘;;\"£'i.*'£3;i‘iii:;3i‘§;3i§I 21::;§§3;‘s§:s‘, i\e.; §;a=:r3~i:§§ :‘i1:e§§2.:*s.:;:§2s5., s‘.‘&<.;a.§.2"§%s% s=:§3;3§§.c2s~i‘.§a.‘3:‘; ai’ mixeéefi »C;_;1es3‘£i::3£‘§

<>§1"’eV§eW..Eaststaégétifiig§;§_st:i.sm:=s §‘:‘31::*ss.i Em <t.m:a*i;. if s1;§:§.s~s:>:':§3<;i ‘:23; s::€§§3“§[;§<*3i‘;s:?§z?';4-

<

<i‘:‘~:=:::?Ei’i.§'3ieevi»:3.§:§1ae%m:fi:is; {l:.:u..:”i‘ z':;m f=':3£§»a2§>e:‘;:§.e.::~:3_§-* “{.:'::3 its“; :;:<w.::. ::m2e§:2.s;§:3';.s '2.-\»'§'2e::.

-g . \

§ §:2c':ts=~. i13§*§1i:‘.§2§§3;i'§fe‘i¥ {Saga '§fé3"{}«~;‘;'.£%.<éiS 33 §'§.~;.:i:§ §.:{.>‘;§:tse;3‘§,;. €33 €Z}‘;‘:m as; ‘~§<3:‘§?§éz:::::§e2;:

{f.’§.*?§<§£i} ‘Ft’; {fihim ~i%§“>'*f3, <§~i§i?, sfiiiiiiig §«‘§?’<‘:§§5<§3‘i‘\.‘ $2‘. .-»-":::‘:3'. <‘;;-E’

%:‘€<s-af3;s:3‘r3:? ..‘§:::*§=':“ws“:~.; {:%.§3E§fi§} «*§~‘.?’Z§ $3.3. 3{3E{. i§2~§£}, :§.{‘§%3“:£ ~;}: ;‘§:‘£§%{f%_, :~§:§.€§‘§3«~I§1i_S$§. Tim .‘i£;‘éa~.w'§ts: :3?

itsm-*i}§; ’o’3"\=‘e;‘§.:~:%j{ amsfi. i§.‘.é;§m.«;>;*;, :i{¥2 azmzi m:-'§_. §3:a':‘§ie;‘ .<:2s=*s::s%3Té%§.:':}‘:e:§‘ me m;;:z~;:i.:';~.: Eazasi i:s§§s3:§. gnzsaiaz {raw

§'%3.a W§i§ie3:;‘:s €§;i3§§§i3i‘s :2: s$:a§.§<ar‘ at aim: w%::e:‘zas §§§3;f3é3.

i..»;§.:':*}*‘ am*{:am3s: ;1;§<.§ §::rcs.§<§33§ as w§2§::i wit}: it zsmai

§i%v§.¥ §\\;s§a:=. SSS? .m'3:t 3 %..‘:..§: at 2:: it :*<§<‘.§z.s.i§“<:'s:s ai-eafxxmtgzi

§.‘:ai:s‘.mes:2: :93’£§.‘;~£‘5 ‘r;-3;éss52:;i mezi ‘iihéfi ':I.:§:iii:s;e.s" $§1<.=.a:§:;i §s§‘:?:ez" ?::u<3=<3.:2 §3§‘£*.S€3}1"Z.€3{§ so

tizas >;s:L>siiii:2g i:a§'<:s:'*e wTém::_: $4322: §2‘sz«;i’ii§é:" was i::€;'.az;§ as air as ‘.ii_§.‘:‘i§_. ax. §xe3.:*§‘s;: €I€3§}§1E<‘.‘§§?i§

ta? >«.'i.::‘:t:?3§":‘:.:§i§Ls3 tin: fact $3} §3:‘%5{§i::3.$;&2s ss:sv£im*i§¥§§. in ::u§.:;‘:5.s§*§: GE‘ *:.1§ae j§‘»’§I»:r§‘§§.m ’§“:*§:§Z,

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 19: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

W. {2£}$§‘{I’£.§}$f§{3i%§

WV<::m;is; §:».;>§§.i:§i:i3:: (Is:-:";t;;:e.:‘ r .:S§_‘.¥&'s1:‘:i§3.‘.3§};.\’ mar {Z’m:3‘*‘z: frimfi the. aria: Cs:3i§§"iT

a>.%:"§-‘:'::" in 2:<§..r;:i2:s;§ :‘3ft.§1s.-3 s..rm2*:}>‘ {£3 {§§m1’;‘;.;:£§a:3 c;sf\~'z3§1.:e f.s*‘:<3m §f§:~‘w'§s:§

E«°L€‘§§3‘i.:i:z’§3, :';:e§t‘§}a>:;* ha NEE“ may ::3’:;§‘;T:s_s:-* xxsitmzszi §:‘i:e2::iti§’§as:% 2?. '_::<::s*: kassg we-;>;~.2i‘z‘ \;9‘:~.:i.s.:e 21212;?

w.ié:3:<::z:t i~‘£,is‘:§":, 3 ts‘<:s:2 23.2: :9 -:3;im‘i.m'z=:>§ in vazigze-.3 z:e§§’1m‘3§.‘ he §‘£3§:‘$i'§§.?miwim fishsaz

r

:1}: 3»: .-:‘gf§i?§§7??.3 .§§§.§§? £1’. $'E2;'as‘::f, {}§>.-Ea $2: §»‘3{§?~{}§3i€s-€.!?.£.‘§i§§3‘£.€3£.§ '€s‘:ss‘<‘;

5%-‘xfilii re;;m2».<.;zf~;‘s ":t§§.;§i:; ‘the {‘3s:2§.:z"*:' v.;2c2§te~ {Eras fim;ii:~;_;j;' <3?‘ 3:i§.:.>a‘::e§; as é:<:sz,s:*s~:;a%~§ f€Is'§“

s§:§;::§3§_§e<;'~: mazdés ms :a§:%3e*::'s‘;j;3=i in :‘§'i:‘s§‘i§:_ gu§sL§1 .a2c‘ti~2ri§:'§§3:‘s‘ :7:s:* as-i‘$’:;::‘§.ss ei.é‘:‘e::i‘.ec§ §£&‘.%§*s<‘;11“§.*;':¥ ¥;§}§?

<i§3£‘m'%::':§1*3;a2Vt§m31 23.?‘ §::ha=: v‘i.:3§.a.§?§£m;~.:» {sf gm i.ZSEl§>5?;;*§>’£‘°.«’%§§.§~‘.. m3'mm;i“;€&:‘§. “iiirzm-v§§2_gEy"“‘ :3"; 2321*: er:

rcamsgss :§»:is§-am 2:9? §k's:‘1‘;i‘: a..m;§ :s$.~::¢:«.:*';:;>§.-* §imi=;t€-safi E33; i§.3~i~3§.{}€} m :s.£,?i:¥ ::m:m‘:itt§ss;§

“i<._:m *‘»"§..‘:?§\ 4.

{.13ii‘ .i"a:.:*'§Ié1<:s:' i'i“z§§§§: m§'t<:.:a»:i, the :2"-*§:=:§. a::.:~uri:’::; {h-\;.¢:'i.2‘;Ti{>{2*§ aiesvrigeing the: mafia % m‘

x

.»"§-e*‘>..<*$ZZ {I ma‘ mgw $3“i2‘§3 33$ 3W ‘testi .;%i'§.£'§ $3162 '§.’§3§‘§’§3“i?z£}i‘sj§F <;>§t%3:':=a«;-3

\

Efis m&:§:::;:.§<:s was mm? am i.r3::§;§;§§§e :3? :*rev;::ai:*, E3193" ;;§mc§2a2:i‘=:sT; 3&3? ::uaf§': <n';»<3~p

w«ae§~: §3<.2sst»:::"fi2si( §§::.<:§*; ‘§.§3{?'»'_}.‘:'i.*'s‘.i}<.2'i':§*.‘s,‘.‘3'3. wi.€;§; %.i=E:»>e §seg~_z;;a§ €§";s=.%s.:>:*i &§“£‘§§’7s’:3i‘1£“.»~;’.‘.§‘.§§‘:‘a‘. ~:ria3

‘\Sm: mas‘, w:§:*;'a3:i: 3“:m-‘-*' ii"; mz§:§.i’§§;‘.

ii. is; :;’;:‘:§§2‘:'i.:.z‘;$;*§ ma: :‘.§asi::§_am {sf tbs: '=;:"§.s+Ii :‘:{3£.i'£‘t ix-: xs'a:;ta:‘e;i, amxi

2‘*s;;§§::':ea* §.‘:?3s<;z'§af§‘m‘3L~§%:*,§ $5.: {Ems fax? fmftiaea‘ ';*sV:’z?es:&§&‘:%§L§'.‘e'3‘j,‘:% s:m:£;%is.:=':=m2i: wi c§§3“eci.§xr§3s; an‘

‘i‘.§3“,i$— »*;?m::*£:.

;..k

ifs

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 20: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

Er‘.

ii §2§s:*a§33>‘ a~;.e:‘§;:i ':“::.zzt sa ${‘§§.:!«j§‘ {sf itixe f:>:“wg;:3i:x

{Ia:.Ei*§:§§~:.m. ilzésmfieer; '§.*:1.2=;:...,. wigs itsy ;*=~;sg*;:§2a31;*

3;};-3e§_E

;‘»«€Ea.:i§ ta"; §iE.i:e:eai>$::%s ‘i.«‘§_e’e.~§i.::

Res;§:<as.<i:.§"'az.0§ ssa:.i:1;~s;i:‘:‘e+;i,

5,3 §3:a=m§is>. A, §3#&!§‘.§{»s!‘¥‘

E}::rm.§:s $2., §‘§::~;:.:ii<::e-r{B§3§:.§{§s:‘ {Z2-s;*§£~:

SZ£.";€§e .9; €Za3me;"

L{3w2iz'af'::::'§., {.}i%;:’i0:.s 6&5": Lie:-£3

{_§§'1.3_ £§8£§-;3:32xx.-av N

;;s§3§§a2::t,SQ ~<

.$X.%.v;.m*ney *§‘<:s~;‘ i332:§m‘.i

s‘;;§m§: ‘vi-*‘€s:3d:~: E‘ i

€li$§%’§’i§*‘§€lS§'§‘E G»? S§iR§+*“§€I§i

;:;:‘:.:, §:§§:::m;>;3 ‘x.=‘Jg::3{‘§2s'

‘:30\

W:§s§'§i.§.:g§:(s§1-‘%:'§§§.a§:g£3 §‘.3;:;w;3::., ikiaies ‘_i..;-Em €i2’§§,9‘ §‘:~3:m:~;:‘:‘y,

g»;

Q’?

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C 1700511

‘° .

3%.. Be::§<‘§>.—»:‘ {-33 {ES . . i.i}[_§

;<*ait€.{;:’:‘m:; j§’*'ia§.;“:$;§.~§’fs§:};3;§§:.i§as:3t

Wa:<'3;§,<3 {.‘..~:.2§.1§i::2’i.:-m 3ZZ:mi;'»a;:‘..

/ COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

5.3%? .?:{;s !‘IIs3z;'§'<=3§‘;. E35321‘...

Page 21: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

%§§.§i"§%‘*§§§§§Xi

$3.E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 22: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§_j; {}§§R’§° Q? {§*i'}'£§‘§ i§'§{}i’*E ?§_si§:§‘3

‘§=§'a.=§.?§‘3 §'§JE‘€}N €{3§§N’§"§} €}§§E{3

$3 1%‘ §*E§}3’§¥‘.?§

.31»f,:m'«:ae§*.a* wz:..mm«§.$, : iigmss: N3. 5% 149$-3%

ie“§;$§.§a§§§‘f, fiagssiggggs '§‘;>m §é§§:a§.;i::

g, 2

$§§.z<i-,R{‘.¥§\" ‘&¥’€§{}§}’§3 £{§~§;-E.;§§§fi%*§ §§§‘锧‘§%‘£" E}-§1N¥§§§?{3 §«§§’§.‘§{}=‘;‘§

§V§Z§°€‘§‘E=?R,A : §<‘{§§§ §‘€§“..‘§’§*‘ “§‘R§;%§;

; g\§a,:gx,{ {,, Qga ”’3°‘%..m?

‘£§~e3§”am§ma§'. : g 5g §;§€§3

°i‘§:i$ :rz:$?~:::::t:‘ came §:a:i‘<m:* me Czmrt as‘: Siwms {3<}§3i$ie3§§ C$m§:r., §n<:.

{“?C}e€}.az:{§zs::::‘s”} “E»°§<>i§m:. ii»: New ’§‘r§:a£.“ fizrrémjg ‘£é3’i£§:i:§:::s {*‘§‘§2:E.mi$‘§‘°} xaggmm

§;3$*i’t:r;§:;2,;:i:’s §$*§t§§fi.£m. sasiiar mtviezrwizag iém m¢::s§<::am*§a, iiae {:*23$.3§‘§ fimis Evieziiszm $2: is:

{Rt w§:E.§— Es:§s:.a:;::,

§\ccs::rsiing§3:, E3‘ E3 €}??{?2s.‘§?.2§”< {W °i”?~i‘i3 ’{‘,"{';3»€..?§“.:°‘ $23: {B25623-;:§m§:‘£ §i»is§-iéam is

§:ea~:.§>:.;* i23EN§'§:Z¥3\

33: is sass %°}:‘eie:£‘§:£i.

am; ié -§~»:- 37$ 5/ j %%%%

' T §§_::::ev§:. ‘:*{>%«:' §r§§,E~Z§°<;3‘N.,

,1.-

.‘..

SK pp. 1

E-FILED O1/11/201801234 PM / CONFIRMATIG-N 691810 / C‘1700511 / COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

Page 23: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

gm“x jg“%%%%

¥3{.‘f§° 3 E’ 7§?i°§‘¥§f§§ §»t:i}«§ ii?-’{}

§‘iAjEi»‘§‘.§§;'§‘-Q18}? {‘lf{I}E§?€’i§:”¥‘ €f€}=E‘»’§}%*¥{}'}?~$' E~‘3£.;&§S {}§r§§‘i{}

:§§:2R;§~ZE§=L§‘§” ‘§‘s‘i§2’T§%§lg§‘§...\-M.E;.»‘1§§7#é:r?§§:’$ W73‘ 5%. L;{3s:33§:}§:§

?’}.£x§'1§3TEi?Ff§ 5 {.?.‘{}§-:’‘?. §3C§~_§‘ie‘%’E§E RT{R§2§§:‘e::i sitting Es}-* §::~L=;is;:1n3«:=.e::§}

.. 3:3 ..

S§<‘l;‘«‘;R{}E\¥ ‘i=‘-:¥’{;¥{}'.§3§% {I3{i}§.._&L;§;§§§f§I{}’:\? “‘.¥..‘.E=IR, §§§${§-E§§iE§§\§7§T §iN“.§‘;‘€;“f

{}i§¥iI§§“§§3§§Z§:'§NT

‘$333 z::m£;:%:;;~ mix;-=§:;g; 3£3§3v=“£E1 triad it: it jnrjgs gr; 5; a. ”>.-'a51"€§i£:t ra>:¥;;:§?m'.<i_, 2323.5? 22}? »<;3.a'%.:;z::aa magi.

. ;§£;:&£‘ %;.r'§§ézi .m@~::§§:~m ‘izzwizsg mm-‘ §.}{¥€!’§ m.§e{ii z;:§,1<cm_, is Ezza-'::3:%£§§3-= =;<317;.<;i§>.:°e:{§ §u§§s;>w:§:

£3§..:=si:§*£i;§i‘7 §€3.‘£*'§'i?i*eLj§ §=‘e’§§?§.§;3.:3::::s is gramieaxsi §§.§€.g;:r:::a‘;§t .g:;.3;;§.§.m:”~: }:}§§§,=2;‘:e;§,a€§1?; S;§3ar=:m

fiifmsis Cc:§§iss§m“§ C.e::§e.:‘, mg. $13. was mm} i§.‘£3“§!‘.I+'$§i‘1§ at? $m5,a,€:'«:.::.. '§:1<:2uss§’x-=<~: :33”

‘E131 s;§:im}, s%$§:.3§::3:‘y, asizi ‘§3{§§§.‘£-€3€$~f.¥*s‘3€§~§3’§§<£3 fiaaizfig mzei §§§‘§V£$é,f?f.~§{§.§€é:2 ix: 2;’tt€:::*z'§z:a}-° f{°3€:S:‘é

magi §:i-~:’§g.<:tis:§::: ztmss, £31333 eazgri: aezs-$33.: .s~3.m:§ §‘£§?‘€§.‘£‘§2:‘~§‘§‘. '§:§3‘$: {§;>:4.t:<~:< e‘3f;§{£s{§gm.fi§3t at ska mrirss sf

923% {Ff ".€§3§;& {sage rzsyw §m§; atsmszségziiszaig {E33 {‘.s3s.;:§‘t :§*3.;3M*§1§2§.*a=‘: it's‘ ms 3’”:_18$.

23:33:? far \<:2:e:‘§a§s mu} this is §3‘izx:a‘: z§::::i§gm.e::1§ I§*;§:=li§%§;'.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. ~

. 32. .%ss<am».$_ mas‘» km gs w:»w»::s~e 3.4::-miw.1»-=as.mss"s §e;‘§_s'~*sIi:*-;—:x. U

mg“3. 9

§.§3’3§# :_

x

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 24: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

msfi :~:g:»§g3:‘s:we:<§. E339:

:2:;§?;;a:;§a3‘:%~§.:a§§§::§:s §x?§°.§‘.:..$ {:s:::s§§3:m:s

.R€.éi*éA§..I‘s2”§ L. §$¥JR§.‘>1€§i§« {::sa:;:5i§m§}

.+‘§tta>m§2}*~s fan? §~‘§3im§f%"

a~=;:g§ i‘izs§§a:2§§:=:E3urg~{:e:1ta:%xr§3§as Rami‘§Z3a‘}r%<m_, {.3§7§§{§ x;3;§,§§;e»38 3.?

’§‘eE£a;3§rs{m.€~3: §§:}j;ax§;§.§:.£§§€}{3

§*’—:§:3$i§:3§ie': §;3:r..=;3£.§;g<:s3

Eimaiiz §3§.?‘§§”§—{§3‘§3§”3§§§:§;.€E5¥i‘}£)§i§.é?<$‘€<C€I3i‘£}

{}i§3::5t~:§NE:S§r A '}§§.{3§i§§E¥. {s3m§;5::;.}' A“£§€:§.’3‘3§.%}-° {gr i3§.>;§m3:ia::3§;

..»"& ‘a>’s§'aré%s £3<:s>:“:‘;$:‘

‘im~'e§:=mc£;, ‘i3°§"2i§> .g,g:.g.<:s

1 .‘e§e2§.>§:s3:*a{2: {$513} €Eé%¥;§«.:2;:;2§3

I§*‘a<3$im.§.§es: {$13} €:3§:§3.«:&:;%§?

E-§'s§.a§§:§: in-. .r..1;J§»:a3%»:‘éi.~.‘:f<’a§&:.;,:3a_<:§}:_.i;‘

2£:.'§_<§a$22‘gw‘i§3§ss;::s, \§i3S?%.‘.7$;‘c\§*Y§'3‘§£i§\Y'3-1C{‘.X§‘I{(‘. :‘~*i.m~.:2 Juégmmxi Efisztty "sw.w7;s>;§

§§;>;:sg

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C 1700511 COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

Page 25: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

\

mg gm ;<%e:3:5§:*§*{::2¢‘ {‘..€}?<e§‘§»»%ii{)’:§‘ ::s::O.¢§ms; ggg 3 3» gmf§4§§&g*§'§§§;’§’{T#N {Z§§3{;?:\E"§"‘f,A €§§§§§i{I§ E

,§Ei-§§£§.-§*e§‘?:’" ‘‘3¥'§{.*§I,I§A}?s\*§If~.§,, : {R333 Nil A 3£$€§§}?’e={}3

M ‘§*§.a‘i:?3*;§f§:” ‘ -‘

;§?£_§§§}~;;-‘xii: §°»s’§;<X§°i§€;

{R§<?..i:"<>:§ aittézzg §‘3§J.e~’5.S.&s‘.3.\$.;:_}ii1‘::i:s$:*Itii’.__\.=

: 7§f}§{I»§-‘$§{}',§*<3 ‘{}§\§ }>§,».s§§E‘\§’§’§I§9§‘”§S s‘>a‘§*ZI§'f§T§}{}N

S§§.%§§?.{}i\? \?£-"{}{}§}S {‘§i€}§L.-E;-§Si§{}N : §*‘{}§{ '.§.‘i§{s§3i§:‘:j§I.i§E'€ {}A?1x«§A W-‘*1.3132: K; 5

{.:3}?l3l\§‘:§7§§~§{, : »“3.‘.T‘§‘{}§?§.'E“f§§‘§"‘ E: {.‘i{}$'§‘I,‘§

2‘ ‘

'§‘3:..is.2 m.s:i‘£::r.:.* £:)“C§§3~i{°* §5e§‘§‘{§.rz§' £321? éiiamsfi. .¥{>§§:m>'§.§:.g ::._§m.’y txéai. wimreizz 231:? _j§x.:§.'3»* f&§.z::>:§e<§. as

mzfaiiat fizw ?i.aim:i~:‘-E in. ii:-x:°. ma} éi3K§€31m§$§?§§_5}?9§?8 asmi :.'§ts\;>{>;:éa<§ ziiéfiaéaimixrefijg {:3

%3;§ar:raga.‘:m:i.§:s we: me I§{}e'fe.::s;§;s§3': §‘.i3;€§ 'v§s:>is2_;R-2:3. £§'§£-I {ffi:;2:3:«:::::m‘ §:‘ra2:c=:i “sf.?i°$i-“A":} E33,;

::43:r;§3';%:ié.z1g;_ <:s':.r$‘.:&§::. §§3 *»'i{:s§2%.i‘§m2 mi’ Ra‘A.«‘§sss.;*zai {“I<é<it: smtéiasxz ,8} :33‘ amil ¥i<§§2s>:»::—:i -*-.i§‘;::*.

§x~*’3‘0€.<}:‘ ‘€’e;:%’:_.is;:§a: 'i‘{§:§:z§‘§;r Riki:-;\ {_"‘7f>e§‘s’i§»‘;{{‘*‘:} <:.m:nm§.£€inggA es.-rizairs acérsa in 2.-‘§a§.ss.é§A£.<ss3 <>§T€_‘§?s\{f ii {3_‘}:~€»3~

$3‘ £?£?{§. ‘EM f§?i§ti;:§.§i‘§‘ E73223. mcsikm :<:.<.;:a2»a~:s—i:<:{3 the, €I§.:—'z$:rE to gx'.§::~.:>: €<::‘3_ii3«:-.sv'i.ng,:

3... ‘Ya ’:m'%:«§»:: M-_,‘§§§c$,‘?{§ &”_8‘f *:i:<.‘. .T.§m';sr"‘s $3,{}?§.,‘?§ bzttzzsai s1w.s:*«;§ ssg2;3.§‘ns;3: §.}s:£’e.§::.‘§z2:::‘¥.

ft}: ‘s*‘§{>§§:ti<>:§$ 3%’ i?.‘¥s.t: {IS-§‘:’5x §‘7a:r 2: miai 2m3<:2::'.as: mi" 58% ?9§??§§¥§..3»€} in axazfszasi and tréitsiasai

am

$54’

’3‘};a amsrssrgi ‘§~‘£z=.s£nt;i gm z::i<i.iOi:‘;:“;.«:3:;:§ t‘§€§{3{§ ‘in S$€§§§.§.{s3E?}’ i§I};::<;*~:::»:‘£g:.:a~:§: .§*m:

\"‘i.2'}§e3€fi£.m mi“ s\-*.§.‘s:‘”R§%, am ‘§¥;$ ami

":¢§

i

"$0 §.:w.a:~cji r$a§s<>.:1a§1§e :§::.e=me:,=‘ fgazs ef ami ;‘eaas<:31a§:s'i~:: §.§tiga§.i<:n- ~;::;3sé'3 §.3§"

§§s.:s; éiafigiiiimxzai. ‘§<'¢st:§. ami §:3.c.m*:‘§::§ "rs3§.ar£%:::g ::§:s:; _~g>-:r<>s»~;°.c.z§§im1 mi’

ii:'*g'x:é%i§§.a;1i§2i§1a $:i‘£§‘3$.¥§:£§3?2 :3?” zm ii}‘.i£.i€-‘E.’ ‘s‘,§:e: :ie::§§:§sm in

.§§:'££m2:* ?}*£-»{T:3§3;-3;}; ':§Vs1?}‘:i?Ie1§.f®I{?.4;. {:§$‘.3*§§'3_} imiiz» ascsd

"‘ ‘ ' ~; «' ~~ \ xx“-xx '$ ‘.‘\‘ me’ ‘:i4:'-Z,’ " ‘ \" }‘‘a V ‘I? ' 1 " ‘°~ ‘:-‘ a‘ 7 ‘ii=3. 1:‘: .§x2駧me:2i ::§,am~.«§. :}§»£K»§,!3».;§§‘§‘\.v. my ‘z~i§.}m~..i\‘.e3i (1% its, £jS§i<§ am} im. I\z§‘s.’,§»2.:“§.»..

5-‘spp. 53;-

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 /-COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

Page 26: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

"§.‘:.*eE3§.e ifiaikxages

§’§ai§;i.€.f§‘»::§_aa§::7ss ii} zaemé tats tram: éamsigm far ifizm‘: :§sg>zmz:=::: 3-°_ie;>§$‘{§{mS- <>.fi%§s': {Zi~’~%I§-‘:52

i}a§’e::dam as; :§x':£e:;stm.§::es3 £31;-‘ i'§3{%_§{§i‘}" in ix§§.em;:ga§»::r§.es ami t§§e::re

W{%§“€? axssamgzrxxéa an rmrzcis Eaim: iii ,»‘§ZEfé;i€S§~ '.§.3:m.=‘;:::mi €3<>éa-2 :$§.a:::§:i.2:3

3.3£%§.{}§§ {B} §m:.:v~§.c3e:x. +;_‘:;::' tfim £:»:f§.i’_:‘:$§33”§}€i§.’ ‘£5 mi: .f<§r ‘*§.§m:::2: :i:*..z¢s iias a:.nm::.z'i m‘ the

;=:<:;ixsz-:3. :';~=s::ms:3:2§.§a:. or ’;~;>.»s';> i*.1m*z<ira::<i. ;is3§i.a::‘~s, g;:‘az:§::~:.:“‘* ‘*w§.z::§%§3 =:.§::e >.=§{>i;::v:.ia:n

3:2 aci er ff)‘ in £7}? ::m:»;m::c:£<>4:m§§}<: mie é§ii—i3;‘.i‘§;£§{‘} xsnfier z:§.i>«§s.i:>::

{E§}{?.} :5: ?::£a€.ém iiffiifi tixe s:‘:£}:i*:‘s'£3§.3?.‘:§3§‘ €:‘a:‘z:sa¢\iis'3:3 {.s.:':: w§:zia:.E3. i§§zF.‘-

RC-‘i‘is.‘§1§ ikaiti-?<$s§$ 0;‘ an ac‘: <32‘ ;::‘;3.c:i§.e:e. sis::t::m:iO:'mi E:;«' at {3i‘s‘ii£‘.ii mi? sixties ks x-‘iwzris: $<=:«;:3:§<>::.

up»!3 er ‘s.1 af 2:1-Tm mafia e:«a:::mi:*se:¥: zaéitar fixer: s‘3$£:§$‘.3&?3i‘§ %&~i§§E§'€§§§'§§§E§§j

iféaéz ;3,eis~;er;:z:§::szii<>;§ hem; ;ms.»;§:: 33;-=z2;i§é::§:sTia fats: gzsssbiic i.;ES§3{’;s:i‘-.i{m :.::3<i.e:“ a:‘zi.vis§m; {;~X}{f§} :33?

§1‘i¢§~::?.{}§ a:§"i;%::§:= :;:3s:§<:”

fmr. , 38} §I}§i:§z.: i'Si.3v::i 5, ;'2i?é§}§§«{}:¥':§at~§§§é¥¥}, ‘ihw vE<>§;3'i§e:fr;:1 £38 “s_a:.:3:§:x=i:::::i§a3§.},-‘ .I~.2§m;i§.e;r"° to

:32: 32:1: :3: ;:s.n<::e:%é*iaé£~::- _;?§‘{3»V'f§>f..?’§35§§}“ a§t:a;§.am;§. its c§::e:<.->§iiiv<::i by sf {hat §‘I3£>€‘}.isT3s‘§.§§ .i:;§<::f:::'is“§<-2:? in

{ ‘'§T‘T§::: s§3§“£.9‘?’£3§?E£? §T§§S§’.‘- 22236; fiiansa s::§i'{i§‘i§_a; Iii a§§ msimz “.O§O‘h.‘i..<; §.:?§.e<1:'t;::2i

Esficzmsaeg in {}E3;§:>? umtfisaz‘ $s'::::%.§;sm §3»';3—f.‘¥..£}‘§} tizeggz am mm-*:i.<;=.§e;3::*,» in ‘Exit: 23. gzhzszs z§.<::i:>;:: uizti-er ‘£3

z

€3f;§E’.»'*+. m‘;§<:sa 3:£:~—:.a ::::e-aw: §§R'».‘3'¥‘§Si§3§,‘£§ sf {E}, E321: z‘.§*;-2: $1 c.x>:§:s';:m::2r mm: ixti zg

":“*i:3»:§ix-‘ieiuai a»::.€im2” s;1ri.:;i§’:.r‘ R3; i3s3S,{;‘éE3 mg. Sa~;ciie:s.:'s {fife} {<2 s;4f§§<>\*;-" a:.s:cs.:'1:§z:sne~§ii-as am

§3’x::iiv‘i<:33..2§§§ §:s:i‘i§.m ‘ii; m~:§:e§e ai:x:m2.§g,'—e-3 if {£29. ac‘: us‘ ;:‘:‘;z.c:§i<:§ §.§::g§,§:<§ m§3—:':t$ {he <:.a>m:i§‘ii.:t:-ms

m::§i:'2s:e:§.. 22:1-<§¢;* xzeaiiesm {'.&\} ztsi’ $«e§t~¥;i.s;s::: E Z—§s%:‘.<.§1=?.~§, if3% 3:2: mt ;33*.as:.§'i::::*. is;

-.,.3 u..

i.‘<;?;:1::;:;§_‘:£? {i?§3§3- tixai §s.j;::‘:§f§‘:éE3ites§.E3}= i§?{.{Z3.. gstatisan E3-:3:?,€}:2_§ ‘i at §3°'%3.\{}\ J i:§:xsi¢.§;:r::1<é:z

i%:§: <:mm’:. im-t§::.c,§»2::£§ 3;§i§.§‘S§‘z'£i§3$ to £1?‘ E. 3. sagas} >::<‘.>:1:=;‘1Si?;e§&‘£ wésm 's‘3'§a*.‘:

iv-3

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C 1700511 _ / COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

Page 27: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

ET}>;:;£%::e§é:s3t‘s; §§s‘&};¥:‘§:>s»*3£§ §z:;:j3_2‘ §:1si*:a:.<:8;§a—.:'::§. §.}':'::3f:.::‘ 2:€<*:;£‘i<5s:3. {Bl} fR.{;‘.. }3¢%-§.3.‘}¥‘},. *;'§m ce;:~;zs:::*::<:':* mm

?s<%‘?:s§.s: aigzzzazzigeaz i'f2:§*;»a “‘>.-ia>§:zi§e:m‘Z 5:3 €§.€fi:3-.!‘s‘3‘:§§‘§£~.\§‘§. ~;::::§es_~ ;s£3a3{‘§s,‘3§3 .§‘s;§i:‘s x=w3§;.}m

s:j§*2s$s3:“~. €.s*s‘7vi?a3§.ra.i':§:3r;s p‘£‘<33fis3'§§.S}}~’ daétsminad {:3 z:3§m;1s§:':'<.-*::.. I§’r:'::A.‘:m.:§z§2i}=',. :32: i§1::?§‘:352.-$323}siémmggfis

an-‘. ass.-2 i‘a§t3s‘§ the Z}a:;f<~::.:d.a.::§ «-535 5§.§isZ9§.3§€§ "Ewes: zm<::::";°— fimi its sass:-:2 “'<g‘§.et;s§a:~i<:s2s"

*l*i5?§5t“ Lifiwo ’3I‘§:s:. .~*§<:*1:s?*?‘£}é3a‘ GL3’ ?',§3i.$ $3: m“ “*.s‘:.2:i’°}“§:;:.§=-an? its me s';:;>;:Ei::.:*. ‘ffiiis

.<:.m:;;'£. mi :awszsr{: csf wizetra aim ifsttsra-*<=>;1t% a::*:a§y:sis;. my :3 “§a::%:§:ix«§e:i-2.321% ;za»;:ti:'m:" E23; .==;_

cazasazmzzx‘. IE-§ms.»‘»:<.\-*e.:g is §?s‘§.§§,.ri3£Z»§T;i$’:2. $.21 sarmeéaimtitag m.§‘fi“‘s

2:.§.ai-:nt:sM §.£: «:i.am2_.§§i§e:.§. a:s:.m::*£ *<.:s.-‘élii s:»<>z}$i:iar ii‘ ms: §I}«:%f<.~;<;1da;;§§ aaisaeié §‘ea:$<>.2m‘:}§§'

R3 .‘mw<=:. ..'~;m“:'L‘§ei§::':2: naiice £31312: its mzis w§trs~:: 1«‘.i<.>§2:&:.Em> :3’? z:3i>;e. §;m=. {:33-'$*.ret&‘€‘€é1.¥§?§<¥?'ri3”.i~‘;? {:.::sm*’: szaiai,

m‘.$$ Em:

€::;:::§§iii{>;::..*:s.

\

En arsiea‘ $3 gérsssaaé w;ii%;: iis: mm: §§‘£.i;‘- mm‘: .iV6.e=:.:£i§‘".§.-* fie. ::T3§3§3.:‘2§\iT.i‘ :£*.;ax:.ts, ‘tin:

s'3§:¥‘€:2-£§£‘;2S§§i§i~§:>§?£§ <3: «a:m:.<iji£§.M::s§':s;V, Iiecazsfizxg in the {§:?§§%‘£‘§E‘3i3‘}£i§§{?§'§ {sf §2,;_:i§_e=' in" s:<:2c.§<:: £;“§iv§‘§i:§':«

"§'§_:i.:s é:‘a-‘t:¥§‘£=‘$;§$ émrzs. in: suit} am {}a:':::3%3m°‘ ’§.E‘:‘, xx-=22.-«an §’i§:i.:'::i'i‘f’{“s

was iizx-=a>.‘:"vm:§ .i:.amz1sr:{z a.<:x:i.<§mt. aw} E{3'§.=i¥‘ §{\«<L<a:x-isama was :§:em::.r-s§§s;?<§ in '§ss:s::.§§ ‘£522 fsmzt

zmc3 ;r<\:.m7 »;:sa>;‘§§::3§z$ as‘? X-"$§:§s:§.e, 333:‘: ‘§1i3s:21:»s 2:? ma: §~‘§.a£ni'§;3‘3":§ s:tE§:i¥§3;s is {he §‘$‘;:='a§.:‘a as,-‘mt:

:‘3‘i2r‘.z{i& ms §}::§’»:<;:£3.&;3:*i :s:2 the. raa: af vezixiexissa.

i**Ea:§.m;i'fs3" tsiaimsz fimr: ifs: ja:"y‘*:: (§€X‘§?f?§3.§.i‘§3i'§.§?Z”§ in §.I"§?ii§§‘£‘{}§§3i‘.~m‘}’ :mmi>e:' :5, i§'m.i‘ mu

(-3§}L‘.§$§3:§;~:§2i fazsimé “:23 §§erfem';. :‘e§3z3§m 2: xx-‘z';:rE;:.at2z\mi§.ii>:.:~.\ ma::.:3s::*“‘ as v§<3i.:»2.;‘im sqsf {Em {Z$I~§*.«=\,A 13.x.

33-<§:’5Li3E {§3~}{‘7>‘;}, 23a:‘§~;‘3 :2':.s=:::§f; §>:3.=;;‘-2': {$3-'§.%;:‘-§‘.§?3‘i§§*:zz‘2*;<.§ s7mw::=. V:t;«3?"§.:§.<; s;ta2.’:s': ;::sr§»:;:2.* R} ?.§‘.T\£¥~ gig‘-:s::~

4

:::§‘:§3<3: acts; in ms; .<;‘3;$§:. {:3 :}1«.~;s §21c:—2m‘;~.r2a;1€iu:2'; a:a;tm's:;:mz3*i;:g ifsici §3'i:‘3’£§€§1‘;t Ii-’3.P<:::1.£i'§i’§:* zmfiiigaiaa

§*::*s:cs.;“<‘i¢‘x‘i Es‘: t§:<~:: gmifiia §§3$§_T?<‘Z‘Cii‘§(3i‘3 .§§z::;: {f}3§'.{?} <‘:.*§":%::3 €.I§..{*.zi<s ..«‘s.§.%<xr;3::;s {i$=a:‘.*::§::;:¢;»:§_\. e:aami*Ez~;2 . a.:.a_;2§»::::e

L;.‘c

_,.\

.£3zpT,;> . ax

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 28: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§s‘£’W‘}3'i€:}‘i wséw: _~;;3:*m,-‘§.<:i:ex:i 2:} {kg il’.§}'¥.§§"§" im: §’§a£:3’£§:'§i "‘i§’x':r"%7§;3:‘:.:-:i‘z*:§;_g ;~e:§aI=;::s $353 xwrisr::.;a::§§‘§s'§:

m.z3:2;s:<:~.:*" as s:a;m§a:‘<§ @332 am. he a:g:;3§.i{2»;¥ va=:r;9‘ §>mas;§§y $0 §.:3%:j;.=' :§L:.n§§s§:r Sf mgnazir E: v.<‘m3§ai

sex->321 i‘§{§3"iS£§T§S§C~§i§ ‘fix 1%}: §a\;s-*‘ ‘{3} ms 'i%2;~a'§. $2 awe}13$: 233:.w'm:i§::‘mr:§i§as~: :'=':_‘gt<2:.i:‘ fz;‘:=s: §Oi;*:ig::m<i am

\

_2*§:e<>:‘cT:e.:i. §:2:;::v§?‘§m;>.— imfbée: gizmzzagas x:s=:.m§s§ éémtux. 2~a3Vi.{§i;§§§ weuiai <55: .§§:3‘;\’-‘-.‘. »::.§a§::§:mt

x:§>§3:‘3fiE. f;?§“ émzzszggs §§‘:§:i meevirzia §'§t‘i ;3<><§§‘ ;>$§‘i'i.v;r§at:i§3§’§, ::m;§;:3§i§:r §.}.r{}{§°.=§.2?.§€}.i§ £331; £3312 :33‘?

ms =:::3§}z§‘{:’s2-§\ §:‘>s.:.:a.=";z:;:sI§e, this the _E?‘§a.§§1ti§if ciisrze t§3§t§’csji.i<;3=.>.s*i3tag' £22533 {(1% §=.3;§;'3ig3s3§’i fixis ifiiiiiriif’

*9 "§..‘.§‘;:~.‘. ¢3‘«‘§i‘3§i3'i$Z<i :§§és;>ws:r<.*Z mas: ;~e;>;:§r-5 ta ‘ihrz. rear hssiaiy ;::3;;§e§ amt §}§3-t‘§';3m1§‘fi-Ii in :3

w:;s~:§<:3'a2:ra3.ii£a %:2e;t:am.*5§t: {E} ‘£§'ae;‘.:s«‘ 3i:m.3seri‘7<2;t‘s3i::3.«§ aa—e:2=:‘<§jin§_; ‘aw iiize

ms3::::::i’e§a:i1:;‘e;r’::» £\‘v;.'»*%‘;‘3&?.§.‘fif>T5'?1i1§'§;¥§T‘£$ .‘m:<:2m2;~‘* 2:=::m::i'am:§ h<m:3i.:3g.;: zsfiixesi Q.-§'a‘?.‘L§£ xa=§':are

33:32: :‘;i§:§§>f€3‘\=‘<3i‘§. by‘ t§.:.-8. r3:.e§s3.:§‘§72‘:»:m.:er:, N§.<.:2>.\a:.:, ‘$35’: ‘s»\i.=£t§};‘§$ *4-<.=‘v».~;’::*§;: ~<:x‘im.s'm:}§>' ;s{3£.:§',. mic? in

E93; ff‘<=‘is:2e,;:, am @353 swssng tj.-‘§:s~;*.5 csf ‘<5:-*§:i§.d;<:§ 2333:? if iL;:‘:;>-;*e§a‘::‘

::i§§?i7s3S§<;>§1 §r<>ts":.sr,i'S:'»:.m xrmsz §2;:§§3§is3<i.

as "i"'§::§: §W§<3.~i?3‘§£?tY tiaai‘. .zf~2t;3a§§$; 33;} iiie truafi: fi<><>;“ 23:21:‘ §::::::‘3‘1:s:2"s3¢:%<§ $31 as

we:‘§ama;:e§i§.<s3 ;::a:..m:::r {E} ;$;:ra§*a§33at was §M:’;:\:ts;xm? af

’i:n:;«;§mEfe:§e, ;:u::§pas:bi§e mama anti {3} this: .$<*:.:-3m :.\..i1§7.r::.§"}§3.§§§1e‘.t3‘..

as tI51s>;‘: 311:: §‘e_§3£;i 2:s::;::"§: ;:i§fii :m:2=m2<i. w£§2*Z<.A

as "E‘he an-'.ia:§e::.c-<3 sfizmwcxi :sa§.<:33§;}ja‘, s§m<i<i§.«‘, and in1:;:m;~n~:r the yezar =:m;.,-

gxamgei. :2‘;§2ai§.° ithaé x»*»;-::ifi<>3'§% 212:3; $33 éyive,

§§§§1::m§si tbs sa2;_r;>§i£z:' be a1§:s‘§.—a it: i“::*e-§3§& s'i£3§2'i§£§,§3$ fires‘ m3‘a»=2.«°:;}:*3<::-;z.2§:~:..ii‘§:\;':: :‘a‘:;mi’:fs if gm gsgimr

Ems ‘§3s::<:=.ni. iimfixtai. an grsssm xwiaési, er §—:3§:;>§2r<>;>:r§;:§:¢:= ax? s§mc£s.=.:s'.°':=.:§ i><>;':.sfi.§:‘;§.~;. .£:.{‘¥iV:.::s.ix-‘<A,‘., {F}:

Qf§£:{}§”£{}:ii§£}}‘.§ §3miea:&‘é;::-zrfi m.a§:*>€ %.*sm‘i:§ ‘£333: §.m:i%: 9; 3;:*.v§:.§ :t:’f%::i:13i[§-.m*i::,»* :2-‘mi mu: :1:

..,-

'§.1t;:1m;§\ ‘FE:-z-2 .i”§§~‘ ::"i:-ed E33‘ E’§asf§:z“:ii;~‘T§T, $:::§a:=~ an {kw-33423;.‘ ’x §§3§‘\.«‘i-i?"£? ?§E~‘ Sé‘£:;::’s

V

m’. 3‘<"f::'§::>;r xx 3?E2§2£s’:s::m:y F§§*‘ }3{§3_; S&'?:‘£f§¥ £4223.‘ .s%f&;2§rg::;:-Lav}: v. §2¥"‘§2M.z’—2‘.::‘;»:% sfiza: §£:‘m=e~t.-s‘s' 3 am:

-,§s‘§I>‘ L‘

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511" / COURT OF APPEALS / BRI

Page 29: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

§3:>:€_3-* »?¥s‘2<:;s i§’i§° mrs. ;;3:2*s:3vis;§§: s:.:§3§s:§e§.:: miticx ‘ix’: at‘ in :3-arr.

xiais: if}his;s it§2;‘-xx §E:‘e:£im*a {:3 ;:-r:'_m‘.:§§: a:s.ms:;:m:r ‘in. 3 wm‘.§:m:a::.¥§i<e ms,m\;1e.r $3 :1 §3&°::‘

vi{:§3’iim ::«f‘§'.§§i%. {‘.l$.§fi~*% 323:3 :3x:i:_§£s*t :3 izefiiiixg mi‘ ’§":3am<i E332‘ lifha >‘.:‘i.a:‘ sf mgasciiiesfi :1?"

{ma .::{3::.~:§iua:?§. £1?

§";§;r§.::§i £135‘ {mat *;i‘::?:,_§ €3z:<£:::§‘:—';3.i§§§:{§€§.{§ {in r§.:&t<:$.’:<:g§2s{»:.ht3s-' mm':e'i:.>m7 SEW §3c~.=a-1

£_}~:::‘7a:::3{im*.zi <§£1§ajs‘s:2\t§ 332$ ?Ci=‘§3‘ii‘.§§3»‘2§ Q5‘ :;:§$<~::.r;g::.$.=¢:§. is‘: §z%»'£§.i{§ 2: ks-gai e:ts§i.§gz;£i:_m is: :3. vi.csEa£'im§

avi.‘ {he »§I’3E*=3i'-‘Ex, §1:‘:=.s;§ $‘~;2.<L‘-§§ has :*‘-333%.;-:te<§.§}r §'.3§.’.2’E:£'§ s:Ee's‘;m‘:‘:‘;§:.2§:s;§ E3-jg <:.m:'r%‘s :1? 5;%:%.:1§‘§t ;>z‘$§<>.;* is {$322 ziaiit sf

in 2:.’::i$ E‘°§:«xi::’:§4§3T Esix mvsi: i‘.2:s%‘i:.z:<::;‘:}_v as ms £3211; ‘§§:§;‘a§:a:‘<i, tiss mf

‘§}ef:::2:;§§§:§;iV, sfaijiiczuii 331$. in 3x:‘.s.::{33*¢‘§:§.g ‘£391? axzszimy g3£3S§‘ §‘t‘§§;§i°.<§1' ;m2~a;:;;i§, rm: §‘22:;:.§:ua§

‘£3a;~:§:»: §};«r éisis c‘£3.im.\ §:§3.§ii3“;§;, {§€:$£§}3EE3:g? amiai an-‘<>§;‘3.i-gag ax z:té§2§.r;§.:i§::1g ‘ists a:.w_i:§ a

€§§Ts§.§3;»53§Li{t%3‘§ :3 ‘S33§i3Ti{§§i:i:‘i§. $1233.: ca}: a.§;3§§s:°.d \:‘<=>ry‘ t::fa;3z:.:§§}'-' ix; $a:33j§' §§R§33.‘¢§‘§&Xi‘ «sf s::€;;:1.&.2:;:m3:°

The <iec§sim;:s ci>:;~:§ Es}; §*i2:i;:-‘aifri’ ;3;‘<;wi{§§5 s-z§§3:£:§§z:1§ m>2'ié:sz:: ‘lie: ;~.:s;:;;:=;::§é::-:;:.~,e af :.am:stmz.-er

$31 112:? $i‘§if§€.‘3 {'}§:.i—9« i§1~:=:'£ w.‘§*sa.~*:::‘<~: 3 sszggiier has i‘s§}§i§§2EEf§-{\.§§i¥ in $‘5i‘§!‘.i:3”§}§‘;EiE:§TS:, amé w§m*.::§°.

i§:;§::m~: $.29 »‘.=‘a;§§<i < @1333" am: §.m‘§7m~.:atzist:g; i"%m.:::s: mi’:-§:1.§:“~**:§:>31ss, a rzzxagzkpiiaasz‘ win} ;;r~.~'<3is;§s s':.«r

&‘€i‘:::m;::¥.s,=. to aswiai é%1m.z::»::«¥::§T§gg;z.{i::2sr2:s: ea‘ figeéaya §§€1’i‘fC$3‘L§’£§§§‘s§§ i:§;1:;>s;<~:: :3§}i§g,e§§i{331S-{>£3§31i?:':.i‘iS :3

sig:a:.ge;;za’% sami ;;::‘:sc§.i»:.:: me? a $333: vio’E:a‘§i.cs;:3 <>i“§i%:§: amé. is s::.‘zfis:s;r: is: €:se§:§s;:iz2g :33’

{‘§£S§31Eif§ ‘ts ..‘<ms:a:i {ts}-‘ '=:%m ‘ix*i.s:s‘~ :1?‘ 'fias;*-z rregarzfiimss s3'i" s:€s.:'§<=§§,:£:‘£ a.f=:E§.s: :x*:.:p;.~3§.iez% {gr fiaa

izs «am e;::\s§e§3ic§§:: mgzxaair the E1-s:a‘:+:§::_, es‘ §3£‘st§£=.{’.:§‘§s:$§£Zi .S£¢2:Ie:«: ear s°t§?§I. .3§§m:sw.2

19. E}-<;:>s:s ;¥’E§?»’ i{}i}-{}~{}3-§§<§» ; <3: }1¢::2"ii:§_§§. smai azgxzasfiiifizxfigig, .S‘%<~s*.;».2 rm‘, .€n:>w.>: ma $;m~:rr.£ FEW?‘

§§}£}€}%}«*=A{33.

1-“§:.:1éz‘;>:;i’ff ci§;zi.m.s; {mi {'33: —§i§te;rm§21s§tis:2§2V is‘; i§3i‘§:3'mga:<ts:}=‘ ;3m";§§?3»::é:> $32.30;’ {Em

'§3:~:ffm‘§x:§2mt :r§.=>-§.::<i§r’A~:7’:<i'.’1'§‘?.‘s4é:: ‘£’§.;r:§::i‘i.%.’§T‘s W:-%3i::§<: e2;m‘i it ta £213 §*f§a.i§:3¢;i£f is: am z:::1s.s2fa ¢:»:s:a;;§ii§o;:

m._:»:.:§§ ragxzaaafiii 3, ‘ifiazi §‘§:‘?<i‘é3i”§3‘§i£E€«‘{1i. ixy saizgria air? this .sm:_e::% tsrim‘ its éai‘:-‘- cs? vim ‘:?a3.is§%

s‘s§>p%

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 30: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

casiz. in zhia s:;»:.;:s@.:‘€. éazwe :;:‘§*.:s_>w::<§. the §.:‘9;§.:\4;3s::r ir;s‘i‘saE§::2:i<>:§. mzfi .:‘¢:;>:asi:“x $11: me :'em’~' {wk}:

9:33:23 fix": v<:i:;i:::§.:;< zszzsesfi-2 ta s;iz:'*i‘<.-K2 avfixxsm it was ‘:‘<~:~‘a:m=.:»:'+:-:3 3.1: ‘aim FE:-.:is:~:::§;*‘E'. .¥>?§;«2izr2-'iif:‘.‘

3-:s$‘.?rs‘es‘:f' v fNm §.{§{}§3‘Z‘-,~<$§S time s‘:m3§‘§ :;:;f3m:i'§3 s::%.i3«‘ 33:2-;z;::c:. ifxzit ‘°;‘e;*i§e;§-sizigg fise w.‘§:‘§:;is: is: {£32.

<:»:.:«§3su:°;1s§, aims? Ezrsiawinggigs zsfiiamiggg Exit}: :9 firm: it in .22 =2-«;:mi§::§.<m w§m:§:. tee S22:

::<3;rse;u:23L:er :ms;§ w %;?§'§1§32!"‘S tin _:xr;2;=s:ti” 3. x-*ia:%§e=:ti:'m e~.e:‘? {i3_3F'é“~..

ifiaaad mi. 31:: {ma ?§.i¥.i§:’,3‘§'§.f§ §:;n:§'é.3<:a§ €13 Emsmi am the

£.§€:§‘§:m°.3§3.;i‘§‘§.Cs.nS ii: §.z§§%m‘;;;z2:=:<>ri::s 355.6% 3 $€3?9£}6."E’;€}, a“.i.«*“{‘%,='-K. {§§’§‘£${S.{$‘.T 3

M‘

Eu3 .5“

‘jg. ansi Eifiéfix {$9 i>~‘.§~‘£S.:§<=§~ 3 33‘

afiemay‘

j§’§s§§m§.§7}T’;\~:a§:3::$¥s .%'§s§.2:'i s2s:sm.'t award §‘:i“.2&§§§£}§‘§é‘§(§.§§i z:t§"»:a:"m2}-* in %‘i::~: amazkazm‘ {sf

r°’~

.,

$S’_3_.S.3§ K“? aw :*§2as.m:.;3i>§::= §i.tig§:f:%a:: is: me a‘x:§3m1n3i £'.’$‘f grams ;3.d.o§i‘iim12§3 aszsi

¢"\

.5azmtza iisiiiiifiiti :9e:§a§£§:3g its ;:s:‘a:a.es:.:::ia>:: 2335:: {£323 _g:sm:':€;i.::s::z in >:§§e axmmz-rs: mi" am; at §'ua§%§

:v3::'1hs‘-::'*;::':s~:.“;T2‘:§;~..:"’:z: s;:.::s§3:€.s‘~it::::i "y§~"i7§§1 ifizat f‘as:é:<:.r's fiisteai in §}i§~%.f3.~a €}£‘§:{§§} z-:::<§ =2'im‘i§§§,3¥.3€3 .§Ik’§?7:é.?.?"

:5. I%’7r‘ia?€}:.;,::,S}= . >t3)}*‘sZ?§‘Q,. Elms‘; {}§::§§.> the f§>§.::i:§§:i‘§’§" amri a;:i€.ea the

§§£:‘m:ar as; {Em s:z§:*s*’:t:§t Ems: :'eLgai‘§§in;g: :-:at§:m~m:y -§Tm~: am:r»;¥:< in {T:SE“.«‘§ maxi}. :‘.‘.::.§,s:.

:‘.0i:§E% ‘§m}-* en»:-“arzfi in iiafia ~a.x.-as .-<3: first giaawr. csm: §3T§§§§§’§ tisizxk §3:;sAi tiara:

§*§a§né:ii:‘fs ycqszasz miss E‘-:;>£‘.‘:‘».ii sf $S§§5f?V2€é..§i.2 in ami msxizs gm <m‘§r:~,:-;;§::a>us -zmxrs in ::°:3»§;~3‘i;§>;1:::«‘.i1i;3

“ta: =3§§e. _§:::‘§ s::w;::\<£., E-§;>xs.>x<:x-*a>::‘, in :'i‘a§: 3.s":‘;"§:r {3§1i.t-:fC§i£§:iic:2= i.<‘§£3§:‘:3§" <ii$'::a>;6s;xi $231‘ szmz

i.:::1::2::~.a§§§§§*.§'§*‘ i3‘12:§'§3‘.2§§,‘,, "Kit 121$“ a:m:t's<:i‘,., We 2%} ‘am: ¢<3?.:'is‘:.:';i;ia>s: iimt ‘£§‘§s‘:= §:::ta£;s:.:n§ <;>3‘7a1‘.§.{3;s%;1'u\'§:°

ax-x§'a;‘{3a::ai §3':2r;=m;:2§ §i.{I;’:. §Z§<%5S.§}$?{E?} :m:;x’§ may 2; §§;§1'§~:e';-it ?&?§£S§i:3i}S}1i§> its —aie駧ziii‘ 3,§3‘i§3'a:33;i. ex?‘

gs-<§'§‘£;§e:2*;§::;‘:, filfii c.s.:}:2‘;2;:.:2m°.a*‘ ::;z§;§g3;i§:2r. '3iT§#:§:v .«.‘-$2.3‘ »=.=*aa2‘s 21z::m2§.<'}.<:‘.§.i:2 ii?‘?‘.8 2:3 §i§C§§3§3i¢ {hit

1>§‘z:::=:cx;*::z;*:j;.~* 'f$§::>s "“‘*'*‘ta:~ ;g3rs3»*-seas}: *;::.:§3:i.:‘, 2:3£:s.xi_§3ii.x*1€°,, ami axxxcaszxaumiezaaixfie am? ‘;?é;‘a2:;::.i<:§:‘&>;,

§3rm=§‘;§e. :>‘§i§.“F£3:§1g etifaaiiva iezssissaiieésg, T:3e='£;§% .:.§::.‘z3§§£. gmxi ;:a.:'i;*a‘;§i1g iE1a§.;:me::‘s= wiiji

S§*;s;;s.—~

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOFAPPEALS / BRI

Page 31: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

!‘::*.€;{W{?:3‘.’ :§m*:§a;_g;e.s: ~L‘~?.%£§’:‘>'<'.f>§.§ 5:12:23: §s§3{§.}:?§.‘§1sI€i£ttY:3, sitmi 1:0 i':i::i:::3:t:*: may ::1m3@.*i:::.'§='

ia§a:.e:m%s-“<23 "fax $1,z;>p§i.ms £0 in 23.36. yrzaxétifias. ”° §¥§:: 333-0 xazrid, “'§F*;m.§1§’0ii:§ ;§:*§x-‘ate

V fmm i”:;:;:* the Kin»: 1&2}: if:~‘§§._‘:£t 0:; 3. ctamsursnézr §3.z‘{3§§%a;’.E§Qi§ 0213:: £E£3{i%2—3“§3‘i§E‘3§i‘<

?.is>::;»:‘§‘;_ the ‘;}{£:*g§£§&;£;‘. szansi ::’§*§’::c§. 05 I320 ;\.<:.:*° 3T§a£3:'2.ar,, 021;: §?§?.f£‘;;%:§?:- <:s.'3';::r:1. §m:m;=.a:is:«-si $20: ifszzi

9:13:00? 001002110213 an :ag:-33-;*:3‘sg:s2"i:s;€:‘;:» .a§.‘s":m2.:.:': 1:3 <is:':::,>.2i:*s:i:1§:sg the .rz:;:n?,~s:;~ mi‘

§1<:smi&.re:;2sa::ma1E1§y e:<.m;§:ie;a§ 0:: ma §.§i‘éga‘£éa;>::. :::ui~ei;>§2e.s:. 3 m-;«1s<::2a3§§e jh:m;r§y “§.‘§\;e::: ::‘§}.a§€: '

am0z:a*;>: $3.:-m2E,ai itze xzzaiztazi ‘*'1.:;m=z;;r<§ :32" si§:«w:3~:¢s-‘a*::*s;§" §3§.iS§:>£§ an the 1e. 0?‘ Q§“i¥§tT:‘

;;m:ve:sé3§§3;§‘ gsariy :10: witix §3§‘§} mm ,1‘ cf s3§f€i§3$':§,i§t«.:}:% $02‘ «;ii.>:a1‘,§m::§.

w§2:2:§'<;*. $3 2: ffias $ias;3&:§s.*§a1.a‘:: ire §:*ms:'2;§<:s:i {E12323 §30$:5§§::§1: by

‘Ja;:epEi:02s£§iam =;3’f’ tirm 353105; in L§}R :;~'§. ”£:§_jI§?§}.

fl‘

00021303 ;:ii‘s:;Wi£:§€:é cmzfi wifié. an §:ix:rmi2>e£3 iisaing, 0§§§1s;°. £30-ms.

013:3. §':a:«m#i§: .ms‘.¢:e: agsgxiimfi ix: hat c.2s§::::§.;2s;i:::s;1 :>§‘%:s:r zmei '§.‘§~§ee §i{::§.i¥’i

f':‘.¢X-‘i-t§w€:{‘§. [£30352 ;§f’§£§ 3:231-' a‘.t?s§1.§§::t¥3g§>$ 33'-:30: ms a§:.1.f‘e:n:§;2:2:§', ‘i’§‘3£.'?}" ap;;>e:ar ~:a:302:.:zs§§§a2.

’§T§3§: ;§a2Mzai:11::: s:..i15;i§er.:3e \:§1e:~:::}::0xit¢a;§ é1i‘§}{>i§£'§i .§3y 1i:§$i:§f:'é.2‘:g i’§m%. ‘S312: <;>::.§§.r €:1§z=§§ms; fox"

\s.-x-*:‘§';i<:}: hezay-1132300 am: 503:’ ihmzs: =::0§.ai§2*;$ %.=«}1em iiize gm-3.» imgzai {fiat £311: »:iei}:.::0lzm§‘

’E‘§§§;a a:;§1a.§§&:.§:g% is basiré an {$12 §3<£5.€{§ {E-“} w§1i::§1,. 225 .§:_3:s;‘:«§..ie<;'§ :9: 21.13:; fitiiistt,

-fi:3§.:‘: sii;§:~5.%:1'§3£:}* ‘§.‘s:—ss ms; a:».2*:§.;;« m -‘:=§2‘&‘§s3*<‘i if, 11511;: :;~:1.2_;::;::§i.0;r '§ms:2w.i;:g};~* g£{t$!§3§}.“:.~;§.¥i§§§g 3;;

:33“ §3.r2‘~.'a£::§i;s‘:z':- %:§z.as.'§' 'v§<z§z2é:s:s izfiis s:§ha;m\r..“ E:$§:a€}:s:.ei2s::z‘ c;~0.rrea:.:i¥.}g argxzcs {$133 131% .%3éf:m::* cmari;

i'::s':::1;::ts-ézis £{&}:::“£ 12;: ;m§:§§'<‘:‘« 211211233 331. &a:{§-usizazzeai. meat figs: §**§;::i:z;2’:'.:E:‘.‘:%.“‘:a' c:0:m:5s;:.§ ism: _;,m3vis§s:sfi :30

.i’is'::'§2:§:.>‘;:§§i<3::. 1%?" kg: $313: wmzki. a.~:»;i§s:s§:;1::::§. in s:1§3_:§»:ct§w:; §:'3z=i:‘i§3£z\ ‘$30:

£3§$‘i“i§§£ii}§§>'i‘e :3‘;-2:160; is §;’%::: :§i‘i%:~a:: 0£§é:ma§\»'s3 13:3? §3e%::g 200111131000

a;:?:.<:i. in §§3§§::ir<»3z5g;aw:m-as 3.? §.:;r;;;§;im:§ 0??’ %§‘s:~ w§':§§:§2: ss:em.:::g;:§712_§ 302:3 is: in Ex: 00212301122‘ 3:3

2 Apgp. if,

E—F|LED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 32: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

3"§'§3s‘: gémfgr :*$3n;w3§3s;§e§ ‘in ‘$123: ’§_:':s§x~:::1-“:3 §;zsi'»;;ar§= <m.§:_s=‘ €39: *“Ii*’;:a.§ to» ;::r:_w§s.§-:2 ma:

:.:£T.33T.i:‘>‘3;$;m.%3¥.' w§&‘.§§ wi‘§i§:‘.§§ iaazzwzixastfii iisi <35 :r:;:s&§:‘ 2>;rE{i': §i3§§;ii§‘ £55 §‘§‘s€ x<‘E:.;‘£1:.;s=§.; 1*‘ :23 iasi im zens:§{t:‘

.zx~:;g§.§:+;::ss<i mam.” .e*;a:i;.ii:§{:m2.iE:g: i%1€3§’u:'y ‘fmmi ’;§%.2zr Eerazfizzara. ms ma Frazzd ;%;z;;;;g3;~;}§.;~;gg.3v~;s!

ms §}=~:.f‘em§:::x':{ £§1ai'§:it:£: §*.ia;ir.s‘:"§.2‘?£*7 s§1£s:.s§.s:§ <>::2E’§; m::3v<-:3" aatiaarzxey’ :m:.§ $132‘ "<§}£§ .

\si<}.i§:§.§<>;22;:s tizai _§u;z‘:« “<mm'i <;‘:<:mm§2*.‘§.e:s;§ };':*:s:>win,<;_;:‘§'§-‘ mi Saar 8'2~2;:‘§8‘i‘e..<.2a.'~‘.;

Ei$S&‘1~e:§£3€<‘§{§ wéiéts we §‘:‘em<i <;:§a.§m .:1»z‘3§*’ £13: ‘i‘.§3{_3svet §;3‘¥.§Y='t§'i‘ ::§_a;.i§>:;s x\<‘§*se:*r;: the ;33e;§:;ii§‘i‘ 33:<3w.:i.1ie;§ Vim: ’£§‘i:":

,_§a:<:*;.~' éiai mm §:i.<:n§‘i.:‘}* as 3<:mwi2*x‘s;g;§;;»‘ s:m22mi.t=;‘§.°.z:‘z 2339 ‘mg §L}€%3“3:%‘§:{‘§§i:=.’i.

{Em me» '§.‘é:s.:‘~;sv .«:2:.§s;ms:.*:i;z:.,;_: aim s:§:i::i.:*::1$ ‘£31 fiizis §:1}£w%_:§t:<i amd

imm a s.?{is.¥‘§§i‘£1.{§§§.§)€}3‘.‘fi mi‘ zmci :*>::§.ai€::t>z:i- §{3§,_~:i‘-333 ms»:-':.:*§eé.;— and m§3‘i*§>i§'i‘()3.§;E§ x-ssiir:»~::;:‘-a aim:

:21“: {iii :30: 333:3 ;3a;:1:‘»°.°-2: aa<:<:.:m§iz“;§,' :9 :1 §<:i§£§W‘§.!‘§g;§3}i §.":m§.ix:g. Exist} maxi‘ file ;3{ia:§.:::

‘£'e2‘1-:‘i§31§.§ ax” *§§§'1<.~3 {.‘..§‘§».§-‘A. Eetxw at §.3si§.i}§}{§~‘} wemiai aiiauxse‘ fictas :,-am s:;><.;::s:;n.::s:<s .i>I‘sf§‘;=~;e ;\’:i;l;".?§§§£~‘-‘s“ iigas

imiws-i::g_:§ mmmiited as 1«‘i{>3ai£i<§;n, $z::a:';:2;te::i.z:g 3:55: iszw {:3 22:3: i‘$§;t§§§‘§3 :2. se:‘§t§::g <3: §‘l>es a=.§.s‘§€E

"¥7§1i:2 if-:.‘3$.§;t‘i fimés ti-;at'.:§1e s:'3.§iit3&:>.; is: i'§?;:i$ s:§<;: .$‘it‘;§}t‘= i”:t:.:=m :3 €::ats§';‘si‘.'}<:>§‘3 of magi

ii’§§':m‘§€.5; amé. $3-gait aim Piia:imi.§§}"h.<.:s z::v:2m°Em§:;1§::gi§3= prevzafijiefi &‘;8{} §1§$ X’é<*‘.§$3”}

_§ur;,e iigaxiizxg a‘3;\;~e kE‘::s§l}<>w§.:1§.g; >e='i::§.a:i§a$:':s; s;:‘§’i:§3:: {3§§§*,s‘§:

rn1

//-. Tism‘. rifimsz fffisasfatzaciexsxf s;§§€§ 'i‘€‘.‘-j§.\'_i‘€-‘.‘~S!'c:?i‘¢$ the :‘§:;:e>s§: §‘321.=i S§‘3s3k‘3:S4f3rS§}§§:>:, gsgzgzscm»-gs},

_§3§ti’§;?Em>;:§i£ts: «;:i'ir:;i"‘°"z:«€.<.*§“i:‘<‘{is:$, 2r3:'i:<zs:1a2.*éE‘is tiaai‘ §.i: giisfi mi:

2. ’§“§1a:' :E:.«>::M {}a:é“<:m§mz’iL aiéai §{?§.?§f{%Si%m' {Em ms: w§.s:§ ass? 22. §.2§m:;im:§§:3‘ :;a>::m€£a.~;‘<§. 23:“

ih.-52$ ia mist;

3.4;

)

'§TE*:szz£. E}a:§s:§c§a:;2:i, siéé rejgmsezzt that ‘me .ra;3ai:‘ §‘.éii=€i<§.‘s {.3t3;:‘§i'3§§31§:iiiE3aficsfifiiéififitt

vssitis 2; j;:z:'a§.«‘§m;s.s.>. m;::‘es;m>::2::i.<'sra, ‘<.v§*;:.::m it '§3a:t§ ;m's£.;

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOFAPPEALS / BRI

Page 33: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

~+.— 3&3: 33:2‘. §.}:;~‘::§’:;t3:s§.:;:‘:2: s;§.isi‘§ _r§?;}:‘a%§§€::tE.€ that it Ezaii 2: 5§§3€_%31S<>:‘&3§3‘§};3, 2:§3_;.:r;m.:§., 232*‘ ;3‘:‘“:‘E3§;2?:é<§1r:‘i2*:zs,£

$2: ciiaé mm‘5.

}! R13: fizse §i.?8e'f%3m;i;m*§. ;§§a;§ ‘fgii $10 ;:§:r%:‘i3m1 ::<:;33i.:‘2: in 3 wI::<2*=§{::'a2:r:;§§i<::: anszawzer‘,

S, Tiaéai i.%3.<°:: }:§£§-'§"‘.-I‘§(§3{3'i‘ aiifi 323:3 ami am? z=:\$s':§M<§::>:§ as-r a§.i‘i§s:f3'§§§‘§\:<3-£,i§. to ssmsiai :3

{}§3§.ig;iiQi{}i§j;

,2. iifie Zikefemaiani :§.i»a‘§ {.t§T3a};£‘§§€ j§;:.%><>;:* %3z=:$>.<::§ zgpmzz am .~:::s:i:'::—;m: <7.>:‘{":§§m°. §.2‘;:“<;i§:a:i s;.>’§'::%:§:

.m;§.::2:.§ €’i:::.:: iz=:3»:.&31‘§$ psrfmm {Ease :'e;_>2;§r;

3. ‘ma? me j£}e'£7e:”n:3:~m€. wixiciat ém»:,§ ;*c:mr:1. ii }‘i2:ai:2%i‘§‘f am mzssgfe

e;m:»;3ii’£§.a:‘;;;

§. "§{’T§1a%.2:?E“:.x«~: EI>a:§72;m:§§zz1: §‘§.i:;§_, in $IC&Ié,Fi?i§5$.1§‘§.{i3§ii with {ha Er‘:-§3iéiii‘_, 3‘Et§'§§‘§i$§3;ii§ iimt the‘

Vgyerikwrztzszzfi vs<‘i:§::: sasasix. am‘ the

ii}. T§‘1at\i§3e§§I}e§%m:§.§2£3§ aiiai , ix‘; c.::3n:§ec:.io:§ wi§'i%i'3 t§§e ¥‘§i§m§}‘.'_,.. E. m gsm-*e'§sir;t am»; E3}

"~'-\*‘§§§'§\ as K-$*3‘§‘{:§‘§’.~:E'i $33: :3? ;;2§::*f2:smm<§ sx*§}is§: iaigiztiiissi étise i::;*§§‘v'§s;im:'§

\

}3t‘5f§{1~.!f2“§}‘§§3§§ 2* lg,

:“:2‘§32“:§i‘ Q2‘ .s*<~:rv;i<;§:;

‘CEL '"§‘§3z‘§‘£ ‘;'}tb.§";t3£3{§§i§3‘§‘(*;§{‘§», in :>a;knm3a;:t.§m2. V»-‘iih mks ;'a;:a:,‘s:; Elsi? is: §ii%~§'i%;§§¥3' its tfiae §*:;a§;:§ii’§’

am;-' refiiaacssi g:~z1:‘§:«2.

\

€II§t.s::s?é:i.¢:%.::g, we gxraa-amssa C$1i3f§i§3€:s:§ Tia: §3.:1t‘ria:,~;2;sr {case *£§2i.:>: ::am,r3:.'{is1:s3£s i};§§=‘:. §*j§-ai'_m,§§ >1/

-\

.2: csnmsai

was §:§gi*.:§§-' s§:§:2;:ms:§i"’u§ is} iser ;3m7$i:1éEi eff i‘i3x:s<‘: $::.¥§:%.x‘m~‘. an ‘$<::§3>‘.ii‘§ {Rf $12 §"§.a;i:3§i.}‘§’. E"§':s s;:mm. M§’§m.¥$ ?§:a.§‘

aim ;>r<>ss:»=;xs;iis:>:; MT mic: €:’E3:13€? x§is;§ §.m-es§.v:2 smci <3e§.a§i:::s;§ fete-‘i2,i2‘:1§ as i.§§§3‘:«‘§;:‘;;i§$Z£i

\

its}: the ~«z‘2x:‘im::e imiififieai amsi 333:: i?*§21§V;:2.it§f§"’s -x=<.>as .’§.i‘£fil‘i.e:.‘-’s'3<:?.3‘:&§

§2‘i3§.i.§%;~' Ea §’m:.1:s "iii: _§m*§-* aim ziwtivaifimi. its ii‘.-<2. §?Ea£z::.i‘fi* <':i;::£_s::~::~.:. '.?*$m:a:$V¥:§t§§sxs, ‘§i§“:i._s».

emm‘. mist ‘§.m‘:.i is z-§<:3{§us§' rm: an «gm? its?‘ §3:£.§L<.srm‘?3e i’e§%$ zmii ;T$L2.E“S3.§.3§)§ 1:-e §;§";»::~. in

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOFAPPEALS / BRI

Page 34: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

35333 3"V5{3§{§3I? 7i¥<iZv‘i3'¥15» ‘3'§"33‘*' ‘°’3“3‘§‘m“‘3 Vi-‘Ev’ I¥*§afi2:ii.r:‘:§.“:: ~::<>z:m=.::§? .:"§j:\.<i..§:rsg a::<\ur:1e2:y 223$.

C§éiii‘:§.<3s:§ ta} .a2¥:2:;azz-ms as §t:§§;e' c<>::2;}e::;.s;:§:.t cs;s§:§2.\3z§{ fm‘ .<.§$w§<:;§°. 3\>§}<i8}‘.‘e3€3

§§s;t::m‘c§.i’:sgfi §’§iii'§3§'§?§f =13-.§°g§i£i:'3\“§‘E3-ji3{ig;§3§tf3§ aga§.:i2:’: *:¥f::t. {3»:eii:;1s§as§>: in 3i‘<:§§.:?<vs«‘§:zg

§i§}3i‘3§.3§.“i'iC

5,.»

.-. §§§¥i?§'f§3g§ii{}f}-’ MK 3; <;’_3’:§;;»;

2-42

iLr:§::rr<>g;2£e;3z*§:= 23f§f}’;3Vs§} _

’-VJ

; §:3§‘arrcsg§§;:<>z*;; 3 S§}‘{}§}

I€;}.ifs;~'::fm§;at%‘:e:s§'§: S; §3,§}{}{g,‘:‘§

2}’.

im;::rmga§.u_:}= €%f€§;~‘g ;”$;~3'{},{§}

1‘;

3'§§%erra§;;1£;3L§§> §;z.=*::;.,='a 3? xi "3. skiE

.,___

;j

§'~§‘;.~“i=i};;§E§ if ifems ii} H Iv3ve§:3w'_}

g.r2mi1<i=~:i: ‘cm mg-‘;s:*<i :3?$3 ‘§‘7<>:' csiiwr §§<%a:s~:;3?:.iv<t

‘gimt §}.§:;: S2é3§"£Zt§i: x»-§{>§2:£.i<>:::=.' 33 £m1nai§:2§L_n€$m>ga£:>ri2s <i%:‘:\1:“§\

Waist .§3‘§§2.i.:3f£i§:“f asiestaafi ’§§‘§i? :5-f§2’i‘;:‘§.c31"§;-‘ the ax-m:*:t§.

S. §;3E§:rm;:g§:i23r}'~' §fE\§‘:a::~<x:s;>§3:>::3i:: {)a;::ags:a_} 4'5 :3~i%{}.€§{}

’-4':

§:i£s:%rwg§.:§a>:‘}*' 3:3 Siaiizizasy ..»*m=ss:.m::é* :3{}{;_£}»:}

H}. §Lsx=:=v::r:<:ga‘£<:r};‘ L3 §:"§§:ai::i.<*..:.a°j;' ‘.»’:m<::2.;:*s§ $ §€}€},i.‘}€}

4-13

’:ii. T§1:§t::3rr<>ga::£n§:y‘ 35$ S::::::tm‘§=‘ :‘3\_m»;mza§.

R.e:§:§<§m35i:«Ee .e’§3.m.r,mz=:;g»‘ .¥:£‘$£r‘3:‘§ igx. ¥.§V§i§g3£:§s3n ES? 3‘

13». §'{£as§3§32~.b§;& ii:§g.a:£§<§2-;

3. _§%;:::a.s*<.ss:2z;§:s‘§::: '§7:;:=s:a semi. msts 6,?§~{}.{§»=§

;>ei$t§s:>::

‘E«‘::«%a.§L ii

E-“'.iu$ <2-mm: .Fm:§ isxiersxii

:1

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI

Page 35: Q? Wfifififi - Repairer Driven News · Efii "§°‘§”§§" §-§}§.§R'§“Q?.1§?§§§:§.$.1§§$§V§‘.‘§.1§a“’£°§ §§§°§'°§.E€’§° §°§§a?**§§§I

i3'::rs:.ss1.::t £23 Ii-maxi. miz-:. $73, csazsmeai far §?‘.iair:§iiT£*‘s}§;s3§_ §§a:‘$§}:~3£f{% a§<:s:;:3~.m:i §::’§*a2‘*v a<>;;g;§:g;:;§s;;§:

w§&“§:: €3&is- aiécéziimiz .2s.m§. g:3§‘€:§.<¢:‘::}.i‘ ii" it» {Em {Zmtrt m':<:c<mi;i:ag§§~1.

Jr

—2.w§=.2;\m"¢' V

* myI J’

{I.s:2§3§.: ‘its:

.«‘xt$.o:‘;::$3;e‘ .§"m*

§{e«z:a§:§. L §§‘£i:§.'§§3

§§i§.i2t.::“m>t3§. ‘>e’z:‘e§§—s.>.

Z3i‘§E$‘.3?‘§ ix‘-§I;i§2::§§3§m=:g~{3¢:::3.iissrviEia Rafi

1§f3::},=*i<s:s::*;,% {}§§j§'{‘2 ~‘i.‘E¥&‘§§f£s?»3§§ if

,«.‘-"s:.§.m‘r2e:°.:«;:~‘ 3123:‘

§;}e‘;§3:}.§:«‘» R.A {31s.;::..'m:=2". Rd.

E,€_:v£:}s:::a§._} £i}%:i{§ ‘$5; 4&3

Ti}§>..;::{3 ¢ Rs

E-FILED 01/11/2018 01:34 PM / CONFIRMATION 691810 / C1700511 / COURTOF APPEALS / BRI