Q ^iJ f n'E uv lT(y m ? q s a U F , 2549) tp ill u9s; lRQU...
Transcript of Q ^iJ f n'E uv lT(y m ? q s a U F , 2549) tp ill u9s; lRQU...
UTWI 4
@ H 1S1 cf a^ <=1 <=S gjgyaj o d a/ a^ C> as cSI a as a oij?nvimyi ]QS]flMij 3JQfi0nimirmQ^i 2 TURim iflEnmR ismmjnwm^anw (Survey
Research) ms^n^n? i ijni?f^n??5^i7i^ii iIn^nwnT^priiiJ1>aJEij'ii?i1v wvmvmna'Ejri'ii.n/j'lu
1<uiJ?s:i,7iPi1lvi i glQ'uf'UPi'a'U^gJ'a^iil'umfQ'CiiWftEU/nvi (Qualitative Research) t^Eii^mPiWFim?
@aiivmnnffjw (Focus Group) \ mnn^^fi}\ ^v,ni^^un^m^my\ ^unm^^z ii'[Bw^m
Issj'wnQviEjnatiJT'dJT/ji'mJ LViPi'lviEj Sil?s:ili<uww
2.jsi iinnT|^n^\ m^^wiIn^nien? imjiJ1iajy'iw jjcwnQvi!in^j?i6ii /]l'uiJ?s;i,viPilvi j
3.^4y^m^Qf^rTiinn?|^n?^wm^^Q iIn^ni ?si iii]ffijajiPr? jJvnQviEiiaEifi'iiJT/ji'uiJj^LviPliviii
1. tR^^ln^nnf|^n^^iviP( B T4n^n'MnfKmjil?a}ninR'l <wnQ'wanaa?Tfifl|jl<uiJ?si,viF!1lvi?i
ilf^mpllvitJ t iEjmjQipms'M'a-amJjsn'aiJ (Factor Analysis) UQst^fl'n^wiJfssviBfl'W^ajmifi
(Pearson's Product Correlation) innrn??)n'i?iQ-3mi?"niBiJ<W9h (Principal Component Method) ffla
a/u9S'ww,mm<uHQjQfi0'mam<3i' (Varimax Rotated) "Mil'WFnnjja^npii^fs^Qn 'uiViiln'a^ iJj^n'aufl
a-Q^ iJf^n'Eiuvi^nilEJQfT'u (fynmiinn? q^^s"uq^ ua^^^vis ^TUQfuFifiil, 2549) tpif^^n^
llfSikVIPitvitl-'lViJJ
<y 2/ 9/ 4/ 2/ 9/ 3/ 1ihvmnt Q^flTO QUitepftufl 0.50 will u9s; lRQU,il5ii?fti,ii?i 2 cfoliAil wwiiw'&wYi 4 S^huil?
mm 1 i Q i tiI<ura'!'i?i ^nRfy^nvi5;'iJjJ'ii?)?j'i@ 1 4tuqiaw1<u 3 mQ^Q> tUtiri
S/l '
v|qUAi,i<ii!.i6 nTliJKiiiiiAl!La?iti?i?iliili'a-afigi'aj49m'a<3li'U (*) (^qlhJ?^ 7) u9svnnSia-3rn?pl<uvn
51
2/ 1 3/ 3/ I I
3/i Iefowivi 2 ilfsnaiiliQEiiaQuiJs1 2 ^uiJf R-a <win^m??infg5'wmplfi2iffiJEijnliia^5'U'viTU
LFi jslfi'uivi'a?i'UPi6iiQ jRiuri'aT4tilviiiilfT!anjli4<iii3j'!!i<u (^builjvl 8) u^sm?lijpi<u^n?gii4mpi/iSirainji
1 1 1 1 3/ 1
2/i 1 3/
<snnlij^'in^i.il<uviu-3wipimue!TwS-3RniJ9 PiQfvn 'asjQ'snn'SSJ^wvlanwQij^nn'LiJ^nn (pfouilfvi 4)
i 3/ 2/ r t^ 3 Cm ^Q>iliTwm?nTM<m?iu9t;QfiinEia'i?4<uiviPi pi'a>3fn5v (pnn>3^ 3)
(mmn'WM 1) m^ummf(m@zvimi\ \ n\ mmfi Varimax
mtfsmamvimisH'uhflrm'i invmn
1. ^iii.'unilrcinYi 3. vnnliwm^wn,nniIryrynviQ lmlrm 0.797
m-nivistoanja'm.vifl anwirravhnlfaEipmn flnmi-nvnl^hnruoii'tafl
uat n?ULVi?ivi lyinuu (*)
@UnwQna 7. vnnllQ^mf6ni'?iuiyt?iri.3ifnjn:jnvi'a-3n<u vhu 0.728
1.428 20.406
TO35| l,1JQ>Jfl'U (*)
2. vtansaniJreiieni'u 8. vnnfe^m? ? mvi ;nifwfunra ?m vi-m 0.764
uarfhlwy mai fl'uiviafi'UPi'iiQL 'urifi'uT.iJviiiiJsTarfT.'u
6. rnj^iJfl'usni' uiviPi/ifiiftyyTMa<3?iu^nn 0.725
@Ma-3^H^niQ?iiJ?"Viai?i?in'L n!JiiasiOT!i3Jfl
@Mfnnwfnej
4. vnn^nn?vhrii<nm1tK<ffu[siifmm?aTU3. nivtuftmz 4. vnn^nnmiriirim?fiOTUi[sii'B'urn?aTU
Qsi_ra?m?mivifsivi >3flimnliJsnnvk9uHCkw fl/rmw*CkFhija
^rn? pnrwnl'Eiy.fi nn'BWTiviwsnwQii nniusnn
2. vnnKa^m?^n nqSi[rynjn^fi'u vhii
0.598
0.520
1.196 17.081
1.064 15.198
52
1 3/1 | %r
1 9/ 3/ 3/ 1/ S/ a/ 3/ S/ iwCmivmnpfoTmM^QiiiJfwuP1!' 0.50 timil uaswphiiiJfpMiipi 2 pmuliJ fa\ 'Uftfnrfftw&'\ \ }
1 3/ 3/ 3/
49mwrn 1 @\ ?zr\ \ mmru,{.\ '} 3 wqutJ? rb vnrm'TUfluvn jiSifqjfynfmasi.si'uyi'umfu
I3JVNI1 vhm nm4(*) (iaQu,il?vi 21) LSaviTu^jj/nwtuiaaja viTullimi n^j>3vinRf3 (RQuil^vi 25)
u?)i;'vnnviTuli'a^nn?Li>'a~3/i2ifajfijnvi'a-3n'u vinwjTni Ridn liyTnqj-Bunu ifluwnfiu (pTquiJ?vi 13) l-a
\ nitf&'Q rA^m\ 1 uq'h i Q?'f^lin<unn?iJ?ijn^EJvifim??)iJFi'uee]i>3ivi3Jii;?}3J
wq^q'pivI 2 ilysneuliQEipnLLiJ? 3 rquiJ? rq mjlliiFiujjCifcyfyivifi'Jti'u vii<m?iEjliJR'u
IHsnnmy'B'i'u (j quiJtvi 10) ni5> iJFi'Ufi2ifajnjnvi@'3n'uvin'u^jiijRiullisinmT'aiJ?jj (pTqutJ?vi
11) nn? iJ^^2ifqjqjnvi'Ei>3n'uvi'iuiPi jfliJfiut^nnnn?iQiJinjj/iiBnieii'i (pTquiJjvI 9) TMlwTi'BiiiM
ivumfljj3/I IpmoVm 3 lircrrauflQapfouiJ? 2 rquiI? Us vinnli'a~3ni5v5'ay^LnjQmjiJ?'i5!inj'!53J6ii<usL'u
mTanuaeij Vfimdn Tjwuai'm'aij (prmiJfvi 15) winlis^ni? Q3J9injQmjiln'Iiinj5d3J5ii\ l'unn^nlij
n^Ejyifirnfiuli'ulli
aTnl^RnQi jiCjiInjanvi'a^lm iilufopw, (pnuilfvl 12) ifi1"Q<3Salliiflu wta Search Engine @anifli'U
@ i i s/ i a/ a/sin World Wide Web (cmihfi 17) ^linta'B'ENprQiiQflvi 4 Sqi ^o'piiliTurn??Qfim?iiiR'u
gn3>j'umpiiEi'Ei<ula'u<M?m'infiQ<uaiJFi'uLi?i
a i i i
S'uivi'an'UPiili viTUiFitJiru^nTi'ajj^tQ'aTu'luFimw'un (^quiJjvi 22) Li, ^m'aviniUFi'u^n??i<ULVifsiJi2
i 1 1 1 2/ 1 3/iffy pjTvi'a^B'U'snni'utyi'afi'UPilli viTum jwsjvClila'i'u (pfouilfvi 23) ^ "L<M^<a<5i'EKi( Q^Qi?ivi 5 Sqt
53
TO03jF.Wn?tei!iB?T! l.@ningtwfi
2/as l *s
(34iPif5TU7l 2) ^WTumf^rTi?ii,i, svi3J<m,miuliQtJTfi Varimax
B/apnaQ^irmlshsamviFiii'a-atfn^n'm @UTWUn
lt.llsik'3'U
1. ilfiinKEJYism? 21. vnnviTumjwn jjMciJEynrmasifiwiuilifw 0.692
him vhiuanflu (*)
13. vnnviTu^rnfiifKi jfliftijcun^a-jn'u vhu 0.622
25. mavhu&jrntmmwfl vintjlliiTuwn^tj 0.614
2.297 14.354
2. iaanofirn?RU
laamnJTurm
10.nni-flijflurmifnjnnym fm vhmfltmupm 0.728
TJmnrmBTU
9. nn^ijfl'ujnjjifqjtinvifwlm vhmraaufiulli 0.532
^nnmt QiJcnH/ii'Qnian
11.mfiuwfiCiilaJUjnviQ^n'U vhrnpiti ufru 0.526
1.640 10.247
3. an-mas'Q'arui.iJU 15. 0.753
14. vnn^m?TOwmneomjiJrffinj iFiR4lu 0.696
rravhlwrniFi iwTh Iwrrn^i (*)
1.158 7.240
4. Jifirn^iiFm 12. vnnv@ Mm?dtawMnjqjTMH?ru vrm 0.787
slnl^m'n riSifriJtiJTTO Im iilwifi'u
17. m1lwS'a lJFiuMi"B Search Engine flam? 0.514
liu'snn World Wide Web
1.120 7.023
5. fiPi Qn si?irm
mmnan?amvi0vlfl
22.m/ayiiu 'u?n??iim,yi(3irifjiInjnjnviQ fit4 nn 0.725
amyiafmialfl vhmAiiiTuwnTOWfllQQTui.'u
23.iSevhufluanjamvifljiSfflqjEinfifMnwnn 0.699
1.036 6.477
54
I 2/ 3/ 2/ 2/ 2/ 8/ 3/ 3/ IviSwvmn[ Q^flTO Q!,i,iJf[ mi?i 0.50 iium uasajflQiiiifFfaui?]1 2 pfowtil i mii f o'pi ^i^'aj
I 2/ 2/ 4/anwiiunia^TU^ 3 ^TUTUvfaifo 4 ewdTA Uiuri
it i t i
wuilfo (i qiiiIs1 33) riB'ULaanHgi'is'gi'uiviPi vii'umy^sis'anim^TOi^Q^ii'awari'a'u (pfowilni 29)
I I I 2/ 1 2/
3/ I
3/I ipTQ^Tbi 2 iJ5't;n'Eiij|if3 j#3ti,iJ5v 3 RQuilf Us vii'ui>R ]i^i^i?i?n? <uiyiPi^l3J4ii,2<u'snnmf
ajj/i'WEU'a'an (pm,m?vi 34) vii'ULPiEinEJ'U'aBLnEJS^vi fiJjjnLviW'a'ui.inhl, ( qlliJs-vi 35) yiTuiPieiw
@ i l l 3/ 1 2/ 3/ilf^Llu^nnnwmjiJn^EU'fflsj'B'u'l'U'BEu^^ii/inti-Eulli (kquiI? 31) ^Xm'Qii^m^Qm 2 mim1^
t
3/ Irq^q>i 3 il frauliQiJ^QLLilf 2 cHQiiiJfM viiwi.Fiy'lwili'U'U'EinLVi inmQn <nS
1 I I t 5/ t 3/ 3/
2/ 1i il\WliQn^nnnwnnTliuFiQnwiliQ>3iJfiJi>iJ9 j<uM5i'alljJ
2/1 I
1 1 1 1 1 2/ 1 2/(RQail^ 27) viniui,Fi j<ui?in??iim,vi?i^lliiT<u^n3jn?Qij?Q3J (pTquiJ?vI 26) I^Iotqu'Ei rq^^^ 4 Cm
3/ I I Im^^linwnn?ifilT, RQnw9nRhj 1lliijnsnn2i'i??i'ui,7iPivi?Qii?'3Jj1lQ (i?n?i^^ 5)
55
@ a/ a/
funpu^n'u^ 3) v)W1n<um?anmi s<wwmfm$Qnfi Varimax
ft rmssmsJmi'ifliifi-s'unflmn
32.vhuAmimu^mpi'uiie flfleij'ii'a-a 0.682
33.vhmflmrif awmfwiPim -Mnnvilflli] 0.630
29. riQmaBn'liiflnffl'ui.Yifl vinui@'=n?an 0.582
i ^i ff| i/ _, ,,
28. rmma?
il n.fl.rimj
vnmpmvmsan 0.575
2.764 23.030
2. ^nAnnfl/wnw 34.in'mfltjra^^mviflYilw^iilmnnrm 0.665
iirnmuflan
35.vhmRm1itmfiBinjiwafi]ynT$ijpm!h'ta 0.664
IS31. vinui.REii 3il?"i w4hEnunljil?TaEy'Bjj'B'u 0.582
1.449 12.074
3. pMi/bVli^h
fhmwrmlrufW
lI'uli'eM'LlfmiJamj
36.@M'nmflaBflnFmuamwufmnph'h 0.849
jiSikijanyiwIm mphon wimeHfm
37.@Mnmflai nRwemTO'EmnmQn 0.829
1.158 9.652
4. afiThFrnw
h
26.vhmmuiemgmmfl iTwinjjnsQimw 0.807
27.wnmflaihflnfflmviflwlfliamnjj'iYha^il 0.616
1.081 9.010
56
t 2/I \ s
, 3/ 9/ S/ 1/ 3/ 2/ 8/ 1* 1
S/ 2/aivitiJNnp Tuvi 4 stutuwSw 3 p tSta TJilmA9
9/> I I
Tiifij^nHlunnsifllrajjnnf'ihia'Uf) (Gfouilsvi 38) viTuififjilnanj 'umFi Sifqjcijnvi'Ei S'uvI'llifijjjni
i it a-1 r t
i av i av %/
a*i i
Iilmnnj PowerPoint (#3uil?^ 44) vin'umy' iin^ans'i.nEiQnii jwifEijnjnvi n'u (^quiI?^ 43) uas;
i > l i r a/
PWdoVifi 3 il^fraijIiQEJ^buiJT 2 ^QUilfpiQ viTuiPi i'un infiwi,npl,n5ifynj'ivi'a <uvi
tliliJwnW.'u Qi?iil5i nT''u (i quiJ?^ 41) uasvi'i'ui.PiEi'una'ija'utviPifjSifEyEijnvi'Ei Q'u 'llinjjjn'l 'l'u
i I ) 2/ I 2/ Ss
-Ci?i<wni,il<unJi.i,iiii'lvf3Jm'am?i,w!Juri3' (i?n?n-3^ 6)
57
(ajipifjiti 4) ^m'umsan'imAnwmm'ulnfjQfi Varimax
tibo (wjj uiJnJfTUTifwrmlanyflmYi 0
1. nmsftuwflwuf 38.vimfltJthflni'flmYiflnSiftijanvifHfmYi 0.701
39.vhmwihanjamYiflniMryrynvi'E ti'um 0.686
WijmWlwmvhrimnu
47. viTuwyun?n?S'uivi(3iriSliIfijnjnvi'a^ri'uvl 0.630
46. vi'numEj'unsnTS'uiviPiriwifajainyiQ^fi'u^ 0.597
lHfujjnlili, n'l'MS;Buvf lw
2.509 25.087
X-dimimvuiul@
fiEn-jiwjnsfljj
2. uiflnjamvifliwjj 44. vhuiPm^vhflJilrjWLfryEinYia-Jtm qej 0.718
lil fi?n?mjwa'ulw Tiljun?w PowerPoint
atin-3iMJ4i^}j 45. vhm ihsnmuv)0vili^nn,n2ilnjan 0.706
43. vi'i'UL EJ' i'MnsfiflisLnEnmjjifiilrutijn 0.698
3. ihensflmvipAvm
liKprnialufiJuiJiJ
lvm'ir!flrn?i,cjmi,n?
41. vhmfl!Jih nmRvi0,njJifryryn#Q>3riwi 0.793
40. vhmflmnanfftmviflmfflnjry'l'vi'EKfmfi 0.727
1.393 13.933
1.141 11.405
58
63
<utiTwun
UllflifTU
I 9/I 1 2/
I 2/ 2/ 2/shvinjjjnpis'f'ruvi 5 ^tuqww 'u 2 wnw IKuri
2/I I
feNfmw'nmQij'hpC (^quiJ?^ 53) yinwLFi Jiliwa^i^ 'a^iJn'idfy'!djj'sd<u3jni1i j<utpi jll3JiJianjnwifnjnjn^fmwnmQij'hpC (RQuitefi 53) yinwLFi j'U'iwa^'i'U'!ii'a^iJn'idfyedjj5d<u3jnii j<utpi jll3JijQn
uvi^viwi (flQuitevi 50) vhmflmwmimgns'ssmYiflTwjJ villi infiSifEijajnvi'Ei n<uwTULFi1"a<!in j 3Pi5J
aWUm (Social Network) (pfouitavi 54) uarvhmflmwmmffl'it'flmYiFi'tom vilU'snnjnSifajanvi'Euimi i i a/ i 2/ 2/ iwtu e-Mail (mutteyi 55) -Aw&'nm-iW'nim 1 q'h ^T^Iin<unisvT, Li'w^(?in^']T,<uni3vi'B^i5>w^^Tu
f'ay^i jj'a (kquiI?^ 51) f-3iOT@i'5i'a-3#3^Q'i?i 2 wQnm^obiliTurns'Liinl u^siJ ijliynjjn/) ^mju
59
WBtnjmjwiOYiaifFBiTMTgTiu ?
(%im3f\ ,r\ 5) m^un^mnm@zvimiiinv,e\ mfi Varimax
Qfl nnsfflisamvipfij'a-atmpmin ihwuh
i.l uwi<ap!i'vr|1'u 53. vhm^wmimehfettjivirilvisj viTJmn 0.785
qj o< a/55. vhmraiwmmjflnsamvifl'lviw vflimn 0.760
rjSiftyainvi'Q-qti'UHTU e-Mail
54. vhmflmwEiiimflnmuiviFi'l@ wl ^nn 0.731
rjwiftyruTvia-jn'utJTm.RlfninEi piwfiatiia'u
(Social NetAori^
50. "VinULR!J'Unwa-3TU'B'El lJ?1eiity5fliJTiU3JniTO'U 0.666
^fjT.jJuaniLvia-Jviw'i
2. Lii iLa^ilguw 52. iwfivhrfymtmliJr^nfow'im uaQvinu 0.717
^???nij?fiu1urn? 49. vinui,f5iau'a'auajnKiJmiry'!ajjiiuria'U'Mnm? 0.663
miftumfl 51. M@v\ wuwvi@i3&uw\linmf\ iwmnm 0.582
WBWti l'ULQij'l^Rvi'TmjQnuvi MJj'ni'Ei-Jiiaws
LlSJJfl
2.563 32.034
1.454 18.173
60
Ha?^au>niK)8'saff5T3Bg'BVJijf
2. ?smjnn?|$n?flmvimiB3iIn^nyn?s:mjiJ?EyqnDil 3JvnQvisn ?ifTsffl jol<uil?s(,<MP(tvifi
a/ a/ a/stuqu 398 flu nn*jiriQvmn^?wT{]wiwnwu 8 ulvi-4 snniTwu'miJijaQiimjjjj'iils' QQU^s:
QiFinnH'awa ilni.a'U'Eiwarns'Qipms'OTawaRQEin'ifiJffEi'isjiJjsn'Enjpnn^ w^
iTn^nH-if^mjiUnjnjnMi1 wwoQvifj'iaEJj'i jT/j'l'uiJ^mpi'lT'iEi^Pi'aiiuiiiia'aiiEinjJS'i'UQ'u
398 fiij R^iilw-Eitias: 100 wamfQi.pifnsmnEJQniJTi'awari'u 'i'udQ'ui Q viuqh <un^ni*nto<utvinjill<u
meivi^ Ri?ii, l'u?'a i9s; 67.6 m^^n^Tae^Eu^PiS'Pii^^f Rpiiflw-aEias 39.9 ^Stiil 2 pimilw'aEjas
41.7 Swanifis'yw^viQn^ 2.51-3.00 m\ ft\ im'8& 35.9 i,Fi Ji1'j<uQ5inm?jQmjm^nmlitu^QTwfQ
rn?H<M'Ei>a?iJjpi ^i?il2<u5"Bj?i^ 67.3 LPifjT. 'aaj^QLPi-af Qejpi<u '>? <m,vipi/jSiTEijqjnvia>3nu m\ \ vm
@z 70.6 ^Qui.vinjfi^n^wm .nSifEijfynvi'a^n'ULvifi'Mnj'im'i'u 'j'Ei'i^ns'ET m\ \ @mz 64.3 ua^
i f^u^LQann'iffi'utpiEJL'aaEJ il^wnru 31 "uivi-1 "fgtjj^ i?ii9'u?'a j?i^ 35.2 ^tmam'Wflfmil'qjqj'i
TO 'w^tlifiJ^d'i^^RNniJ^QnwIi'a^nn??^^^ 70-80 Hpii I<u?iqej s; 55.2 (gwwvi 8)
pmn-avi 8 ??imzym%^mrA'i}'%'Ei-i'C{nftn'8r\ zwu'iIfzuq}'\ ? NinQYmn &m^/T{)lmJ?siv]fil,vi ]
4ra$javnh]'iiQ-a'uh3n%n ^tutu (f\ ) saeias
1.mfi
TIEI 129 32.4
Vink 268 67.6
SQI4 398 100.0
QviEnpn iafLiatmRMaS 76 19.1
uifttvpnmimz&iniimm? 76 19.1
Qvinfn? nn? 74 18.6
QU"|l ii.m lyiPiMafjQPi^TMnfJwd) QvifjnaeiWQatviEi^nu-nuat 13 3.3
rnju.nvtmi.w'ulvm (5) QviEnflnflflf (1) iviR'E'uIaarnfinHKfiieis
i,viflTut9'aPiisnvin??3J (2) iviRtufeS (1) QViEnstiuTUTaipirn?
viQ-JlMEJO (3)
?QW 398 100.0
61
76
76
74
159
13
19.1
19.1
18.6
39.9
3.3
pmn-avi 8 jey^^fi ^fiyswtiJ 'Ei-3'iIn^ntn?r^iji]fiifynpi5' NtnQvm^ri^ArfluiJs'sivifl'lYiEj(pie)
@M'awaifa'hhia-aij'n rmT iiinu (ru)faaas;
3. @if'uilvirha'-jplntn
miilvl 1
DUllvi 2
miilvl 3
futlvl4
TUllvl 5
?@ 398 100.0
ufianrnmuvhmj 2.00 22 5.5
JSUd'U 2.00-2.50 108 27.1
JZVm-J 2.51-3.00 143 35.9
JSWTVJ 3.01-3.50 100 25.1
JSVm-J 3.51-4.00 25 6.3
5Q34 398 100.0
5.il?^aijnn?nIn'i?d>j'UQTinnnj rii!nRU?iQ'ivi!flni?'lwe'3a3J?i
IR!J 268 67.3
Qnnm^nwiftuflQnwarm'lTiMB-afljjfl (t fjpi?-i) 168 62.7
Q<iinQ<u'] myQTO-3ua^tlnnn?R'U(5iQn (ti?i!JiJ?anmy) 100 37.3
liJlRfJ 130 32.7
SQJJ 398 100.0
6.il?t?iijm5>nIrn?l^R'a}4^oii?i0f'iiQ!J?i'u^n??)'uivi^ri3i[fiJnjT
l ltl 281 70.6
1-5 HW 169 60.1
6-10 m< 59 21.0
wnnndn iorntoIiJ 53 18.9
himv 117 29.4
SQW 398 100.0
62
82
166
100
49
1
20.6
41.7
25.1
12.3
0.3
22
108
25
5.5
27.1
35.9
25.1
6.3
268
168
100
130
67.3
62.7
37.3
32.7
169
59
53
117
70.6
60.1
21.0
18.9
29.4
enrnvi 8 jana -a^flyavfolih^wiflnwreiCiJiJmjtuim iiv\ @m@m^nr}\ \ sz\ y\ t\ m(pi'q)
^@aaa'vi'jUJiifwuhfirmT STUTU (fit!) semas
7. ^mi^mmithu^^mYimii-Q^uni m-mu
yhn?WTUfa'En'nra
vhimil ? tin iimis
^i?iuvi??pirn?
jnaurnfYm ifi\ "\
3
176
256
20
47
20
5
44.2
64.3
5.0
11.8
5.0
1.3
8.1'SEisiofnrmFm'EaeR'Mfl
@uatirn'n30wivi
il?rmtu3i-1fotw^
il? wnru1tTqIah-1.30'SoTw-3
iJf^wnoi1.31folw^-2Mim
wnnm'n2"ifotwfulil
9.RQnwR? i]Q^^n? uiviPiJiMrufijnvi'a^?i<u^l !:ijpif3dn5i?i
?0Oft 50-60
raEjat;70-80
?atia^90-100
398
86
140
91
36
45
398
310
119
171
20
88
398
100.0
21.6
35.2
22.9
9.0
11.3
100.0
77.9
38.4
55.2
6.5
22.1
100.0
2.2 ?^mjnn?l?)nf)%4ivipj'ii'a-3<uh3n n ;mj'ijfcytiinpi jJvmyiEnsTasn .n'.g'l'uiJsti.vifl
m?^ranm?|fln?amvi0^fl^un3niri?smjiJ?qjqjw
iJ^n-aiiliQEJ 5 jjnwf^Tu l mciijj 46 la ^nuuniCI-ujjiPi?jnuvi 1 mtnjjsTUQ'u 6 lie 3JiPi?5n"u^ 249P. _flinjj<!nuQU 13 to a-jiflsjrmvi 3 Fhtn jj tiuquh !jq jjip jpuvi 4 phtnimuQu 9 ita nas
ijjipujtuvi 5 Ritnjm'UQU 7 to warmQiflnnwiim iln^n n?~ij*iijill'njanpii1r uwnQviEJiaEiym/T/]
T,wiif^mpitvi ]Cinn?fan?ai4m linuj35ifcynjn^lut !jfQij'By'l<u?s ijjjnn (m\ @ 33 ntu'U'uwiiJ
sinFiEU'umliJj 46 flriL'uu) Ri?ii9<u5"aj ^ 49.5 ai'Ei^sni>ainni?|?n? 'ui>vi(3 iTUfi5iffijajivi'a-3n<u'5i'a-3
ilTunan-3 (J!i^u,<u<u5i vnln-3 3-4 stu'U'u 'mn^timv, 6 fi^uwu) PSpnCI<u?fi J9t 58.8 unpif Tuvi 2
il?j;3vifirnvi uatilTrlviews itu^ ijiJTunsn-j (Pi^uiu<u?sviQn>3 6-9 fisuwu snnpisu'U'u 13 foum)
ii?iiS<u?'aEJ9j; 53.0 umJiff^iuvi 3 <un^nyi2iQ<uT,'Mai2FiQ'i3J?ii3jn?oil?i;m'u?Jn? 'ULnf3i uatuvia^
an^wivi^T,liQ jn<iSQ^n?niqjnfULL9siJ5ininnn?flnfauiviPil!nw^5iLfqjqjnviB^!iu^
f\ viu5r)v,mr)u?\ ft'U'ii'B-iF\ \ ,?z(?\uu^n (pisuwuftvn'n^ 8-11 pislwu snnFi^ti'U'u 11 fieu.'U'u)
piL?l<u?'a J9^ 61.1 jjiw^Tuvi 4 aIn^n nd^uT.viySRQn^^iwn?nT, ?i'i??i<umpili'i<uri2irajfy'ivi'a^n'u
@adn^fliJT^lvifi/Ti'VN ivtau??a'TpimiJ?sa>jfivm'iiNifl1lQ liif^mjiJnunsn^ (Fi^ii'U'us'tvn'n^ 4-7 fisuwu
^nnFituwu 9 Fi^Lfuu) H(?n,2'u?'afjsr 61.8 uatu'iPijjp'uvi 5 "uh^m^i^Quivifu^nwnfnL ni L Tti-jn^
i ll 1 3/n/)^J4n JU^^^^3J^myQtWQ^nijnn?l^Lm^nnTL ^snf^tiLVi^lin^iifajqjnviQ-3Bw 5"3JJVnH
n? iitviPi^n^S^fynviQ^!iusyn<iSs1iEi6f?jJii9tfiripi'Ei<3Piinj4n{)'M}jny 1<uf^mJll @un n 3 (Rttrnw
? vm~3 3-5 rsu'U'u snnFisii'uij 7 pcumi) m&us-emftz 50.5 (mnovi 9)
64
1) ftmuiifi (faftzuMVfiQizwiw 3-n) 3.8
2) reeiijih'una'N (ninzmiifiifozvi@ 18-32) 46.7
3) j pTuwnn (fi'npisuwu jiipi 33 fmamimlil) 49.5
(f\ \ UWm 46 Fl UTO) 100.0(398)
Mean=31.83 S.D.=7.244 Min=4 Max=46 $m@zy@<lP\ ;m\ \ 'mm'')nf!\ tt,\ \ \ FiU=69.20)
65
1)
2)
3)
?rmji)nunan^
(asilu'uiIw6ftzuxm)
Mean=4.05 S.D.=1.128
1)
2)
3) jrmjwnn
(R lLUUl 3413fCU/UIJ)
Mean=9.16 S.D.=2.172
1) :
2) '
3) :
(Firuw'uily11 Fi-umO
Mean=7.75 S.D.=2.318
(pin^ti.i.'uufiafrH'ii'j1-2)
(mflniwafji'tvm-a3-4)
(Fi'iRtu'U'U'adjtviQn^5-6)
iMin=i Max=6 "aja^Q-Jf!t i,L'uui'a^Jsnn?itLm'utifw=67.
iin?at!lnn>3 'i?e5imyi?i li'a'3rn?Blli0i'i>3flil? Sv)fi/nviiiiPi"
(pnnznv.um'izvi'in2-5)
(A'nRtuti'UQ vn'n-j6-9)
(ftlF\ UM\ 'e\ '}Z'Wi'\ 10-13)
7.8
58.8
33.4
100.0(398)
50)
4.5
53.0
42.5
100.0(398)
Min=2 Max=13(m@z^mftz\ mi&@'c}H'')riftz\ ,mimi\ 70A6)
mj^n? 'mvi?i iaQn?)??a Q'l'Hmniiw'ujTu Qnmi,liwii'Q-3Pi
(HiPi uuu'EidjrptQ'n^0-3)
(mfi\ \ \ @fpzwi'w4-7)
(pinAt:im'UQ^?tMQ1n-38-11)
urn
4.5
34.4
61.1
100.0(398)
Min=O Maxell(jQ]at<Ilfl^fl^LL'U'UL'aS?J'=nnR^UU'Ul 3J=70.45)
jnfltgTuvi 4tTn3nifn^n?suiviPifl }jn?tiT, ^n?swiviR0tin^SiJ?"ivifirin^w9ij?? 'fpiqil5'tfl-3R
y\ nvnie\
1) s imM (rinfoo!'Uf) irc:vm>5 0-3) 8.8
2) jrpmiJTunan-? (Rn^ imuemrviw 4-7) 61.8
I' is3) rcflijann (i5in ^uiuui iii?i 8 pi iwutoIiJ) 29.4
(RtiwuJjj 9 e\ \ u) tQW 100.0 (398)
Mean=6.30 S.D.=2.003 Min=0 Max=9 (?QElRtiaa-3?itU'U'Ul'aa!l inR ll'Ul4lK3J=7O.O)
npi??Tuvi 5un^ni=n ein i4ivi^^n34n?ni!inT. iPi?i n^n/ivi3jnEJii9s^RH^LniQiufi>jfTunn?T, uas
1) stmjuetJ (HnPisiwufi viQn-a 0-2) 13.3
2) ?"fli]ih'un6m (R'npisimua^ vtdn-a 3-5) 50.5
3) refllJWnn (pinR^UWU^LLPl 6 Fl lWUlimil) 36.2
{P\ \ VUmU7ftZUU\) Y1X 100.0(398)
Mppn=4_fiR R.D.=1.880 Min=0 Max=7 (?Qy0rra-3PiaiTOmaU'Snnflnujml)W=65.O)
66
as a v _ O-3 if fi if5flQ^fi mjnn?|^nf^umpf a4iurn3nwn?s;mjiJlnjsi!np)t NvmyiansTHnif/f/jVu
^nnm?QiAr"i~wmnAn/a!jyraflni (Multiple Regression Analysis) mia<mFh$iJil? flYilj
avi in'vufivi'HFifutpiy'l^i.viPiUR Stepwise WB^nmpTQUiJfviflnprtyviflPi yum ih^mnEnfeaniirm
ilrcaiirns-nlrnsmi: \ z$mi?v\ n^?\ miimimHwftu@^@u\ ftmi\ tuniw?iATiu?si<@*iiift'd
nvuz: 'un^n nvi^n'i?ifiEutQYiEjnpinfli?ifuasLvifltiit9a uasanpTuflfl'yhflflfl'Tnqiljs^Rn'ifflU:
ilf^LVi(3ilvt it^ j/nri?Q3jS4TUQ'u4 cfouil? Iliuri 1) ?inis: @un^nH-i^^n' Fiai QvitinpngiPifi.i, ^
iSiasni,i,'un?i J3snpi?jTum?5'?in?a'ULViPiy<iJQi SiIs'Cej^i'uq'u 8 pfouiJs1 vimtJQTi'a^niJ
Qvitjnpinawma i.viFiTuIaa ifl'uiIssi'yviLnEJQ fi-jniJjJiPif^Tuvi 1, jjnpif^i'uvi 3 uasunPiT^Tuvl 4
%/ S/ i I) I I is i2) futl: @un^naniml^ 3 Liluif'S'SEJvlinyQTifi-jnijjjnpiyjTufl 2 uatunwf^iuvi 5 uasilnpln^nfuilvi
5 iiliuifs' EJvim!JQ!ia<inijj4'iP!iMTUvi 4 3) mj^wlEJ^^jj: xinfln-ttiYimmfti'&tusz'wiii 3.01-3.50
i2<uif^4JV)i,n jQl'a-3rnjjjnPi?p'uvi 5 4) iJ?saiirnnurmt!iEi'u: iIn^n iiRJi?j'UQ'inm?^nH-nR^?iQn
vi1"ann?l, 'a^^wpi iil'uiIs'Cfjviin?jQ^'a<3niJjj'iPi?5Tuvi 2 3jtpi?jtuvi 4 u ^jjnpi?^TUvl 5
5) il?tsiirn?nIfn5iR'u: \ n^n nmyT. ^QjJWQkPiQf5iiQ!JFi'ugin??i<ui,vif3irjCii[njajnvi'B-3B'u iS"uif^stjvi
mtJQTi'aoniiJj'iPiy^niivi 2, jjnw?^nuvi 3 uqsjjipi tuvi 4 6) -fpimJrca-amrnfl'u: iTn^na-i^ -u
an?^wivi^2^iji!'ivi?i^n'ULviQvinc5inQil?^iin^Vi'mifi iil<uif':i4'j^i)njQ?'a>3n'iJ3jnpi?|TU^ 1 ua^
jjiPij^Tuvi 3 ^n^?iJTln^nw^R^n?^^LViPi 2i[Ufyi<M'a^n'umavinfn j>3n'u?i 'an^'i?tf iil'uifssEJvi
inem^nimnFiS'jn'uvi 2 uarunPif^Tuvi 4 uasiTn^nw'iviFi'uanya'uiviPifjSircynjnvi'Ei-jti'ULvi'as'pi
OviJfPimj kil'uif syvlLnEjQ^Q'jniJjjnpiJjTuvi 4 durru 7) srtisnsnrmmi: <un^fn*'ivi1^n n1'urn?
Fiuans'fl'uivifiriSifqjEii'ivi'a li'uTpifJWiayily^unEU 1 fotwo - 1.30 fitu-3 til'uif siivii.nyQTifi nii
3jipi?^nwvl 4 u tj4ii?i?2 'u^ 5 u.a 8) pmwRMniiwTijjpifi m?: iTn^nti-nviFi'ufl'iwui.viPifjJiiftiJtun
vi'E)<3n<ullpii?i?-aniJflQnjjpifi-an'i? tSmls^mnyQ^mj^n jnwi 2 uatjjnpij Tuvi 4 (pinn^vi 10)
67
NiflSfTUvl
msfmvifl
1. mfl
2. ftniz
0.015* 0.001* 0.009* 0.008* (2)
3. fuil
fully) 5
0.021* 0.003*
0.030*
@warmi/viPi} * fl?) Sig. < 0.05
68
3.01-3.50
5.iJj ijmi-nJrn?^^
6.il? iJfn?iurn?Ru
0.008*
0.002*
0.032*
0.007*
0.001*
0.015*
0.001* (1)
4. fdimijnnfJa^nnf|^n?^ui,vip(TiB-3iTn3nwn? mjilffiJcunRf jjvnQyitnaafTa/T/ji-u
llfSWIPflviej
nn?^ni ?iluiJijnn?flQunnf|an?flwivifiiia4irn3ni f^mjiJfijy'ipis' jJinQYifnaay'iTi/T/jlii
ltasiinfliviEj Snn?^nan!iQ 9^nnjs ijnn?fanf0uiviPlTifl'3Tln^n nys iJi]?ijnjni?f5i jJimYiEnatj
w^nnfQ'CyviijQ'n i[qjvn^viijl\ nn?^unvrn rn'i5'jan?aui,vifii n'uri5i!fcyynvia-3n'u
@ i ilinw^Siffynjn^B-3n<u^siinPiu^^"uiJ?i'iimvi'a^r'u/iJ?iaiicy5d^8ii<u ajnnvi RPnil-uTayas 48.5
5-a^^^3jnpi'a S(!iTi3Ji,'MiiQn!r-3tnpiTi?i3siai,Lvi9'ailEJUf1iU'BjJiiw ^ni'StjJvmiJQnssR'usnnvlt'M'u ri?ii,2u
jqej^s; 47.0 L ^nn?^njnnilnjajn^nuj4niJ?njnnn?l lijnn?Livj'uni??)'a<u<U'aj m\ \ ??m@i; 46.5
iunjjanpTij (pmfuvi 11)
ilfst^uifnjvn snugti (Fit!) l-aaat;
i.in vrn tu rnayvi^m?flviMn n?fl\ iviPirj2ifnjtiJ'iviQ-3!it! 179 45.0
2.Tin^TOWsim^ilymlmjJTJ'u'M'il'Hljj'vinij'in^^Fi'u nn l.vi'u 187 47.0
3.<anmiflamJ?nDfy'fta<anWiJ?nncyijj-iTiT4 193 48.5
4.Tin?iFiQnjjpi?^TOnn-3m'iJjanmyTifl>3 jSifnjnjTyie'3nu 156 39.2
5.Jlnn?'unriCLftijfynvi'Ei-5tiiiW'njjanrn?HT.urn?i?yurn?a@ivi'UfltJ 185 46.5
6.iin^^iJiJ?rwnrulunnf ^w^nwnmjiJ?n'Bcyvifl>3n'u/iJfn'!iitu'B}Jii<u 168 42.2
7.mr]1mi,ri w}4-3ij >3viu1'urn? niuu'3nu 1 0.3
(pi'Qulli^nnnQn 1 wnweu) sqjj 398 100.0
69
179
187
193
156
185
168
1
45.0
47.0
48.5
39.2
46.5
42.2
0.3
f)$0 ft@tt}vfe'Bt}@z 67.6 fmswuiA'a ft?ft$@uftQ?mzv\ nti3ftQ^ii@iftQ] '&3ni\fisusur)V\a3?\
m\ \ \ @mz 53.0 pnwanmj
m?jQfTiinnfH^n^^a^^n?i!jyiBnn?H'i5^?ii??ii5tviPi/tCiiffUfiJivi'a^ncu uaspn?^'io'iiQiillgimivigi>3
i i %r i
i?ii,Si45"a?j^^ 51.8 iuc 51.3 pnwsimj
jjnnvi^Pi fi^iilwlfitis^ 70.9 ?'B^^^3Jil!'Ei wiilvin^Q?Swt!JLinijHiJn^^iQijn'U5'Q3jffu4'i?in^nf?J4
Gkm| mi.llm'QtlftZ 55.5 ivhfTU (flir^Yl 12)
70
mn-avi 12 jfiH9 @i-3yiJimijnn?aQwnn?ffln? iiiYiPi Qwn^ni^?"wiJiJjqjy'ipi5'
1. f\ UlH%M
1.1 FiQ??i?t'W'iInn-3FiQ'i}j 'iR'ryiifi^ri2iLlrLjajivi'a^n'u 236 59.3
1.2pn?'unrin'Lffyfunyi'a>3fi<u}4iiJ?annn?l 'lunni'i1'i'um??i/au 269 67.6
1.3^Q? QUuiiiJiJ?ai'irin?n'i3'|?i'i? uiv)f3imliJT,uvinritjQ'iinviaeu 211 53.0
1.4 pm'Cirmn 5"iyQ<Bnmj? n??iui,vi?i iilu 1 fntiQini vns meiilvi 156 39.2
vTnw^vlu^Tui'MnijntJOins'uii v i i1.5qu-] tpiuri ^Qjl'M'un^nwnlfe 'VNwme^nnsnffw 1 0.3
^reimiiisiinnrn'i 1 ni>i?iii'> 5QJ4 398 100.0
2. usmmnw
2.1 FiQ?wfi n??WMB^awiavi iaj3JpiQn}janm]j'5ia^3iIrijiJ'ivie-5nvi 265 66.6
2.2 fn?s' ^rnnu'3(?iaQjJTi0'5Ma-5 wpiiMiafiPiiQrn?i i'in-3fln?ai4iYi?i 242 60.8
nJjiIairLJ'ivia^ri'uatin 'fpiis'u
2.3 pn?1'MFnnjjJi,ntnnijmjT, i v!u ^na!jvifirn?i!inn>ian?atimpi 206 51.8
fjCifajnjTvi'a fiu
2.4FiQ?4^wniQijT,^Ruvi?i-3L!tJU| 'i? v!iviPirj5irnjnjnvia-3nu'lu jjii'uvi 204 51.3
jjvmyiyiatiPNati maiwtju.vi?u9tij?rn?
2.5 qu] l^iuri f=n?Snn?'C wvi??pim?<l'HRQn3J| gsm? intnrTu 2 0.5
rmifriJanvi'ENri'u (1) u t(5n?flt^r1'Hijlim?nn}j-^ain,vlaiiQtj^i'u^nn
iQuiwuas OPAC (1)
(waulwjjinm'n 1 anpieu) ?qjj 398 100.0
3. [email protected] RQ?fluttJijntjlviil?n^Mnoiin<uJQwn''u4'i?insn??jjn'i?i1'tjt4i' 259 65.1
3.2^n?wutyunjiMi.?tiJiJ?iiitiJTnQijniJm3jn4'pimn??3jrn?wyw 221 55.5
3.3piQ?fiti1!yijnti1.Mun'un^nmllily'>3uvia4utJU? fliftyEijnvie-33vi 282 70.9
3.4 wQyflutEJiintj'l'MPij'liJaiiJWPin'u jSifrijai'ivia^nuustwnwnm'urn? 221 55.5
3.5ai4 1wi.iri ^Q?lMiTn^nitil, wnfi^n??wintjQmj/iSifnjtijnvie>3nuvi 3 0.8
iiluuvia-JWEJ'uj (1) mwmftu^uxAtiii^tAwft^imVsviftnm-iniinu
ifnjnjTvwnu (1) uat^n^wjtMunaK-jRtuRTBa^ iwilcytynviajnvi (1)
/rasiiiislinnrn'n 1 phut flirt ^QJ4 398 100.0
71
236
269
211
156
59.3
67.6
53.0
39.2
^nnil'uwQ'f^nif 'uyi'unn^ (Focus Group) ^nnnfjwwLWQTiqjftTunnflemfmLYif3!
WL?jQ^nfullnwflSilyEunvi'a 'U'Mii'EiiJneiiy'Idi'3ijn'u uaswniimnulhunn?flflW?ilu,iJijrni>flfl'u
liTUf)fiiInjfynlia^a<upn?wnnf?iJuiJijni 'a'U'a in^l?
4.1 Qsmsv4>inn?ilj'u5'/na!jvism 'aii m^n^S'ULVi^lii'UfjDirajajnvi'a^fi'u piQ?mjQf fi-3
jrmvi 6 ^nnsi4'i?irn?fl'a'Ufm|en?flmYm IhunfMnjELnwewcm
72
@utyiiiEJ(Policy)
Input
1.umv,
2.wilkm
-mfliriK
-@ailpi.
-@BUS.
5.UVi ^li'tlWfiU0]
-iweruwf
-visfljjiau.w'jni
-mnmmwm
-vQ-jasjpiilst'iin'du
6.llfTSEU
Process
3.1'Kmywawusu'u/u'us'un
4.iMrnstinavifi^
^>
Output
a/
-@aia
-uvi??pirn?
4.2 $ikimm?flawn?|fln?amY)0An jjtfq^nviiEw!m pmi,il<u'a?hVta
l-3llif'ilLmiini? 'Ei'uni?|?n5' 'uivtFil)Turi2iffynjnvi'a-3Bu w'nunsnjQmrnQiFtrirtfa'in
wiwFiniQiCi!h'uni??fm$mY)0 fiw!JQ^nfyi^iwS fUfiJivi'Ei 'U'Mii'Eiil?i'iiicu5ii'iQij'i<u u,a~wi'iininnj
Ihurma'a'u/nJu.Liijrma'Em anJdi mm@u\ if\ wi\ nftzm&@immY\t\ if!\ 'd\ V)nftr)V, (5
utpit|tu) mswfijjwanwiqwjfma'a'U'iii'M Bloom flQjufannnsmMQ'umju'UQpifl Big 6 ?^^^
|ilLmum??i'a'um?|?!nT^<uivi^liiuriniIajfijnvi'E]^o'u mimrm "TAEPE Model" ilf^nBijIiQy 5
fufl-a-u (wrnn^ 7) IHuri
1) ni?mmi0jm^nmifiai'W?Nfl'i?amY)fl (Task Definition and Identify Potential
Sources) viwnjn>3 nn?mvty^/in?^nw?wnyhjjfru?^viQi'3w 'Ei'ui,i i;SLf?j<u vfiai?l<urn?j4@iijvi>j'i j
@an-uTM-uin^ninvh
2)rnjwin^fln 'uivipi (Accessing) vijjiiin~3 nn?>n'TVi'u^in9?jvifirnTtTinw^n??i\ tviPi
3) nifil? m'UUfi^i?i?'is^n? 'UtViPl (Evaluation and Synthesis) vmn fk nn?
4)niTU'ii.aw'EiflnffliiiviPl (Presentation) VttJiEJtta nn?<unan?i'mviPilvijJiiJI'Eifln?niJ
WQ'ulli'aEi'Kii.viJjnsfljj ua ' iio'iiS'uyiJuiiij'LvisJirlaiwuuvij
5) s?jfi??jjeL1um?'l ?n? 'UkVi^ (Ethically and Legally to Use) vunatk nifiia
rn?rnvi'UflrmiTifvj
?m?smvi0
rm
use
mrm 7 ?ilii,ijijnn? 'aiurn???nf?i'uiviPili'Turi5i[ainjnvi@) Bti (taepe Model)
73