~1/

~Q

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

SUPPLEMENTAL (%DEk REGARDING DOCKET NUMBERVGOB 07-0515-1922

ELECTIONS: UNIT E-14(heem Stkbjtcct I rliling Umt)

REPORT OF BOARD

FINDINGS AND ORDER

Bus Sttpphuntalal Order is caused by tbs Bomd css spouts in 0» Sum sud»rhsd by the Board stbearings buhl on February 15, 1994 and tune 16, 1992; aad this Supplemeutsl Onhr is being n»ardsd for

tbe purpose of supphmcstting tbe order previously m the eaytioad maser cm January 13, 2008 which was

rccjuded st Document 080000258 in g» O15cs of the Chsk of d» Circuit Court of Buchanan Coasty,Virgima, oa January 23, 2008, (herein "Board Order") sad camphthg the tocatd~ lsctians.

Tbs Boetd Onhr dhecttd CNX OAS COMPANY LLC (hcceh "~~to n»B copim ofd» Board(hdtr te sg Respondents whose ~ifaay, wsce poalsl by g» sahl Boanl Onhr;

'Ibe~ Iged ih cdBdavh of ohcthas 'hat it hsd msged a tn» aad conectdhchsmgISatnps Onhr ts sg~— —u whose ~ifeay, wme poohd by said Bated Onhs;

Onhr teqshod each Incur ~whose ~ if ssy, worn poo1el by g» tenne of nddto mobs aa ehcthm wghh thhty (30) dtps agts g» chta of~ or~ as

'ofsetd Otdur, the afgdavh af ahathas IBnl hatch snd mmasml htsoto as~A stmuc (i)ealh Ratg»mhm hes nmde ar thged to n»hs a thudy eleethtv, (ii) d» ease of aay eh»dan(s)o ~.by K Ma I I@a ~ l4alydat sw R——=

d» htms af d» Boanps Onhr, to have leased all theh righh, thh, ~ sstutm sad~IJnh tu g» Appthtumtbu stfhhvh of ehodm» aansssd hereto whh d» ~~~~ ths

s) nnhhg a thusly ehcthn, if aay; ideattths g» Rospeuthmt(s), if auy, who me destuad tothe~htttsutm aod clahss whhh tutpdm sscsow; ideedges d» htsetts aad

atty, ~ escrow muhr Vhghia Ceh seothm 45.1-3612133.; ssd hhnggm g»5—IC masm of or cursed hto sesy, who stay be dhndn»d by havhg leased

Tbs~of slecthc» hdhetcu whether ar not ths escmw of lbnds is rcqnhsd with regsnl to Unit E-14;

By thh Onhr, tbe Boenl anhrs d»~Operator to sender, ~with sml iniwhhdte ~set fcsth at~2. above and g» aascsrsd algdsvit ofsleclons whh

Ibcbgdts ~asy fumh subject to escrow asd h»uucts the Escrow Agent, First Bank dc Trust CompanyFO Box 38'ogcport, TN 37664, Attn: Debbie Davis or ssy sucessso named by 6» Based to sstabthb

bsttrhg sscmw accmsu(s), B1S Tsx Ideadgeatha Numbcs 54-1629506, in~erich thciafermadsd mt gath ia d» atgdsvh of shethu» whh ~~to ceosivs ~cmd sccwsd to theBcuud ~w.

Mailnm of Order and Filius of @%davit The Desigaated Operator under the cspdoned Order or sbaB

file au aifidavit with tbe Secretary of the Board within ten (10) days aficr the date of receipt of this Order

stadag that a true aud correct copy of this Order was mafied to each Respondeat whose ~or claims

are subject to escrow aud whose address is known widdn seven (7) days fiom the date of receipt of this

Order.

Tberefiue, the findings aad afi tenne aud pmvisions set forth above be aad hereby ate

granted sad IT IS SO ORDERED.

Effecgve Dan t This Order shall be effective on the date of its eeecution.

DONE AND EEECUTED this P2. day ofmajority of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board~

2012, by a

Chairman, radley C~rtDONE AND PERPORMED this g+ day of (1AAP~n m, 2012, by

Order of the Board.

Ri.'ck Cobper /(Acting) Principal Executive to theStaff, Virginia Gas and Oil Board

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTT OF RUSSELL

Acknowledged on this /D day of ~~~, 2012,personally before me a notary public i d for the Eommonwealth ofVirginia, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn did depose andsay that he is Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, and appearedRick Conper, being duly sworn did depose and say that he is ActingPrincipal Executive to the Staff of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board thatthey executed the same and were authorised to do so.

Diane Devi~, ~tery Public174394

My comaission expires: September 30,2013>g I I I I It Ie

~eeesseoaa<~

Exhibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

AN@cation ofCNX Gas Campsay LLC far Forced poolisg ofbusrcsts in CBM Unit E-14VGOB 074515-1922 m the Gnmdy District ofBuchanan County, Virginia

AFFIDAVIT'F CNX GAS COMPANY LLC (herein "Designated OpanleP) REGARDJNG

~ONS, ESCROW AND SUPJRXMENTAL ORDER

Amis D. Dary, bshtg Set duly sworn an oath, depows ssd says:

That your a&hen is emplayed by CNX Land~htc„as a Poohng upservistn aml is duly

atbariscd jb nmbs this a&hhwh on behalf ofcNx GAs coMFANY LLc, tbe~spenser,

That dtoOnhtr entered on January 13, 2008, by the Viqpnia Gss aad Oil Board (bneina&er "Boer)CBM Unit reqohcd Ibs Applicsat to msg a nec sad conect copy of saM Order to

~nshparnntt paehd by Ihs (hder,

Tint within scvtn (7)days of recipe ofas esscuted espy of the Onhn regursd to at~2.above,

yom n&hmt caused a nse and sanest oapy of sebi Ordtr to be ma&cd via the Um«td Sales Postal Service

«Wh.««« ''b ««««««AWI~M~~ heaLWII dl«««««««anyt, who vtnse added ss Rmpondstus st gm hewing beld in dut cspthmd maser, dmt proof af such amiTisg

bas~been tendertd to Ibs Dbrhian of Gas aml Og, gm O&hn of gm Gas aml Oil hwpacsw, stLebanon, IJhghthu

Tbtn the~ Ordtr of gte Bmml ia Ihe cspdoaed mansr nstpdmd ag perseus pooled gnseby to taadtc Stairwrinen ~ to Ihs Unit Opensus within thirty (30) days of tbs date dte Order wss recorded in the

caunthe ~above; that said Order wss recorded oa January 23, 2008;

That gnt'~ aperana CNX GAS COMPANY LLC has~~to review ag mail

tecotvtd ssttt ag wrh«m ~rsatdvsd ahtr dum by stag to a«onto@ whsgwr ptndes whose httetesnhave been Imshtd have made a wrh«m ehtaian, ia a tie«sly Sabha, as retpdred by tbs «w

'Order,

dnd sebi~wtse fo&owed to hhnttfy dte~if mry, made whb tegtud to ths Suhjetn Unit;

Cat dts~pstsnm a&Vented, by nm& ar~wrlnea clecnmn the Unh Opsrann, wigdn IhsIhh«y dsy~parhuk

Tbtu Jhttttamdents 'dsnti&ad in Eshgdt B-3 hence sre, bsvbtg Mod to mehe aay chedon, deemed tohave leased their can&ted msgumc rights, huenum ssd claims to Applicant, sll as provided in the Bosnl'sOrder ofJetuuuy 13, 2008;

Tbtn Ihe rights, mhaests aad chion of Ibe~persam me subject to escrow under Ihe Basnl'sOrdtr pe4ng dts cspineed Unit, Bamd Rcgnhuhsn aml tbs Cade ofVsrgtnhc

Tbst ager dte poegng hearing held m tbe eapionof mansr, tbe folkwkg persons base leased or~hno a vohmterf atyesuum wnh the Dssigtmted Opesshsr.

That m the esteat any of said pensee Bated m Extdbh $-2 hase riglns, inttsstm snd ekiws wbkh are

subkot to ttserow, they shouM be~ as .~ ~ the Oyeretm nxyunts that the ~pardons be~es Resixmdents:

'Ibat the perseus ~in Exbibh EE~hsseso have ennead into rt0edty sygt~that

aguw the AyplkantfDasigmusd Oyenme to pay tham dhetsly without the need to escmw fimds wbkh

wotttd otbsawke be k eongkt.

None

'lbet ~ to tbe yorisions of VAC 25-160'NA.10. aod C. and VAC 25-10000 tbe annexed

supyhsamsgd order sets Beth tbe tteewests aml ekhns tbm nquhe esetow of Bmds yunmaat to VirgkkCode seetkIte 45.1-30121.D.aad 45.1-30122%.3.aml 4.

Dated at Bhektd, west virginia, this day of 8 201L

~ AseD.Oaly

STATS Oft~VIRGMACOUNTY & PlI~ML

Taben, sebserlM and swam to before me by Anitn D. Duty as a yoogsg Suyervism Be CNX Land

ResousfeK ke., on behalf of dte eoryorek ~ Oyemsor, this dtrf of, 2012

My eonumasmn eayhse: 9/SW//9

ol ~ noise

80 ACRE UNIT

gI

.g I

gI

fll!(I)I

II..'tb'14l .'i L.

II

III

IIXX i CBll-E14A

II

.PTAIIII

IIll

I3A

~3B

I

l /i.f Pr([ N 3Sa105.77

~ ~ E 971,443.00

...'Jrssas lo asaa

s sa.n

N54ÃlY LIKS QQw QOK TANIN Nsss nsss pRovlRDSY CQS SSSa~hs. NO WSK INT 5NVCYSD.<r

N QQ0.1Q.45

lli E QSQ 04QN2

'I

EXHIBIT AOAKWOOD F IELD

UNIT E-1dFORCE POOLING

VGOS-OT +gpgg~Coaaan7 G Ctananv LLC Qs I l Nasa and Nllber

lan Ggodr 4 Gl UndvTract Mo. Elavat onUW

400'ltvk 0+a final gQI

uuz2

CNX Gas Company LLCUNIT E-14

Tract ldonMhagons

'ConsogdatkmCcal.Company,.et at+tg-Vein Tv. 14 (64265 Acre Tract) - AH-NineraleoxceptOH, Qas snd CBM

Ptwn CrsokTtmberlsnds, LP„et aI-OH, Gss and CBNhhnd Creek Coal Compruty/Consol Energy, Inc. - Behw Dmlnage Coal LeasedJewog Smokeless Coal Corporagon —Tglsr and Above Coal LeasedAppahcblan Energy-OH snd Gas LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC- CBN LeasedJewsg Smokeless Coal Corporathn - SurfaceNL76 acres 6$JI$75%

1B. Consogdagon Coal Company, «t sl Blg Vein Tr. 14 (64L95 Acre Tmct) —AH Mtnerals exceptOH, Qas snd CBN

Plum Creek Tlmbedands, LP., et al —OH, Gas and CBNlshnd Cmsk Coal CompanylConsol Energy, Inc. - Below Drainage Coal LeasedJewetl Smokeless Coal Cortromtion -Tiger and Above Coal LeasedCNX Gss Company LLC- CBM LeasedJeweg Smokeless Coal Cmpomgon -Surface0.15acres 0.1875%

1C. Consogdagon Coal Company, et al Blg Vein Tr. 14 (542JS)-AH Nherah exceptOH, Qas and CBM

Plum Crook Timberlands, LP., et al —OH, Gas and CBMhhnd.Creek Cost C'ompanyIConsot Energy, Inc. -'Botcw Drainage Coal LeasedJewsg Smokeless Cost Corporagon —TNer snd Above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC - CBM LeasedUnknown Surface Owner0.01 acres OJrt25%

Jsy Rtfs, et al (21$AO Acre Tract) - CoalIsland Creek Coal CompanylConsol Energy, Inc. - Below Drainage Coal LeasedJmreg Smohehes Coal Corpomgon - Above Drainage Coal LeasedCNX Qss Company LLC - CBN Leased (76%)Appahchhn Nshual Ges Dlshlbugon Company —Ag Mlnerah except CoalChX Qss Ccnnpany LLC - CBM'Leased (7$%)Appahchhn Nstumt Gas Dlahgutlon Company - Surface?4.06acres 30.0026%

3A. Earl W. Tales, et aL (Heirs of Louha B.Yates) —AH Mineralslshnd Creek Coal CompsnylConsot Energy, Inc. —Coal Below Drainage LeasedCNX Qas Company LLC - CBM Leased ($4.0848%)Dansg Alvin Danish, et ux. - Burl'ace0JO scree 0.0375%

Page 1 of 2Aprg 8, 2OO7

0013

CMX Gas Company LLCUNIT E-14

Tract Idengftcagons

3B. Earl W. Yates, et al. (Hehs of Louisa B.Vates) —AN NtlneralsIsland Creek Coal CornpanyfConsol Energy, Inc. —Coal Below Drainage Leased

+iden Energy -ON and tfas Leased~n Ccrnpany~C -.CNB8~sed~0848 k)

Dunes Alvin Daniels, et ux. - Surface0.81 acres 0.0128%

Page2of2Aprg 9, 2007

Eshbh S4lhdt E"le

DochK ynySS 574HMSER

L chhaL

enunea aada~(1) Jay R5I, el at

(b) Janet Ih Haynes1102She5oo Shd) Hee!

VA 281N

e.olIH of 2C.05 euN

7.5155%

Earl W. Yeoa el al.(Rfctuud 8 Lou/ss B. Yslos Heirs, DsrrcssaSuccassm or assigns)

Heyo Yeses sohyer Hoha Dedoeee,Sucseoeoe e Aedye

(a) T)neosnd Senhor Hase, Declasse,uoceebeo or Aed5ra

(a2) Thoees L Sehhe2212 Hhhy~A(hdsnond, VA 2822C

0.00021/12$ of 0.08acres

sehedaeh YA 280so

(ac) Chrhye S.Sauce10N Hsnbyh 8555o Road

Iotes5ehh VA 2N82

m L c.ve Hoha~ucceehee or Ae5$ ns

0.00021/Iyl dO.NesN

0.0002 O.ON8%1/125 of 0.08aces

O.OON1/120 of 0.08acres

(5}Anre Hhde 8, TeooneP.O. Sdn 82CSooIslel~, VA 5lN5

O.OON O.OON%I/120 d 0.08euN

5)ui W. Yesa alai(Aehsrd 5 Louhe B. Yslss Heirs, Dsvisssa~or Assiyns)

hhsye Yeso Sshher Hole, Dwleoeauoooehse or Aedye

(a) Thunoehd sehhef Heha Dessoeaucceeeoe e Aedye

(a2) Theees L Sender2lt12 H/by EoodHhheond, VA 2828C

(aa) Deysy IL Sohtsu2N Searle tnfe Heel

sebedang VA 28NO

(ae) ChdNne E Senses15N Henley Ihhhte Road

~sts/cant VA 28582

0.01 aces

0.00011/125 of 0.01 ause

0.00011/IN of 0.01aces

0.0001IM2$ of 0.01sees

PeSs1ds

0.0001%

0.0001%

0.0001%

12i21/2010

(7) Louse. Tales)mba fan(essacoeeeonn or Ass((pm

(f) CmlSA HomN1 Paul DrtveSsmdorl, SC 2N02

0.00011/120 of 0.01 maes

((0 Auml&rto S.TrmermrP.O. Sax SSSScenes M. VA SN86

O.ON11/120 ot 0.01mms

0.0001%

(1) ApeafeoNen Nehuaf Sae Qfab0nNon company10N Ofs Sony CMeAbm0don, VA So211

8.01 acme1H of SS.05eorm

(only 1/s mmrtrm urdeesed)

7.612frt/r

Sml w. Ysasa al al.(Rhhord 8 Louise S. Yotss Hsss, Deviseon,

uccossow cr Assigns)

O.OS75%

(a) Thummnd sekhor Hsba, owioeeaar Aee(8/m

(a2) Tlmmes L safcher2212 fdrby RoadRichmond, VA 23224

(a.3) Gre0my S.Setter2N Sports Lake RoadCuhalend, VA 230SO

(ao) Chrlemm S. fhoverm10N Newbys SrldSe RoadChests/dokL VA 23N2

(7) Lmm C. Ymca Heka Omdsem,Sucoeeeom or Ase(6/m

(1) Cnal8A Hom001 Pmd WveSeaukuk SC 28N2

0.00021/128 o/O.osacrss

0.00021/128 ot 0.0$ acres

0.00021/128 of 0.03sees

O.OON

1l120 of 0.03mcus

0.0003%

0.0003%

0.0003%

(0) Anna Iaarto S.T/NorwP.O. Sec/ RHSmmeaNI, VA SOON

O.OON

1/120 of 0.03nues

Eert W. Yaaea el al./lbchord 8 Lolnoo 8. Yalell Ho/fs, f)ev/sass,~or Asngns)

(2) SSNSfe Teem Sobber Heka Can(essa,Success/N «Aae(0ne

(e) Thummnd Sefchsr Hoss, Oevlsees,coeseore or Aee)0rm

(a2) Thomas L Sefcher2212 Idrby RondRichmond, VA 2322S

0.01 maes

0.00011/128 of 0.01 maes

0.0125%

0.0001%

IQ12/21/201 0

From:Sent:To:Subjeot:

VITASHARE Syslam [vhasharavgavirginia.govjWednesday, February 28, 201212:48PM

Hegy, Sharon (DMME)New Transeo5on HWDLY1 TQHQOQ JKDQ

Transaction details for Sharon Hagy(user shagy 1)

3ob Id: %IDLYITQHQOQ3KDQ

Date: wed, Feb 29, at 12:46

Transaction Details:

Acknewledge Security Policy: I understand that this system is not intended for sensitivedata,Recip1ent's Email example- user1&virainia.aov, user28virainia.aov:

AnltaDutvrgconsolenerav. com. Rior la. clarkgdmme. virainia. aov. hllarevmulllnsgconsolenerav. c

ogFlessage - Describe file attachment: Please see the follow1ng recorded orders for dockets:2778 3888 3889 1922 8688 1938 Let me know if you are unable to download the files. Thank you,Sharanitotify me when the file is downloaded?: Yesi in: 82492

Files2778 Pooling-Original. tif3889 Pooling-Original. t if3888 Pooling-Original. t if1922 Supplemental-Original. tif8688 Supplemental-Original. tif1938 Supplemental-Or iginal. t if

View details here<httO: //vitashare. vita. virainia. aov/f cweb/view3obLink. do?308IDX ?%83LYITOH9003KDQ>

Total Estimated File Size: 1712 KB

Total Number of Files: 6Estimated Upload Time: 88:82:86