PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from...

15
PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES ACHIEVING SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOAL 11.7 14-Oct-2019 HCD2019, London. Dr.Sridevi Rao, Landscape architect. [email protected] 1

Transcript of PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from...

Page 1: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES ACHIEVING

SUSTAINABLEDEVELOPMENTGOAL11.7

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 1

Page 2: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Public Open Space: SDG 11.7

•  BeInclusive•  EncourageTrust•  PromoteSharing•  Percep8on•  Ac8veorpassiverecrea8on•  Facilitatoroftheabovethroughleisure8meac8vi8es

•  Community•  Culture•  Experience•  Memory

•  Associa8on•  DefiningElements•  Design

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 2

Page 3: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

ResidenCal Context

FACILITATORS•  Transi8onsbetweenlandform,water,vegeta8on

•  Temporary,permanentdefiningelements

•  Seasonalchanges•  Diurnalchanges•  LIFESTYLERECOGNITION

FACILITATION•  Responsestolight•  Responsestoshade•  Responsestorain•  Responsestowind•  Responsestodefinedspace

•  Responsestootherusers•  CULTURALRESPONSES–segrega8onoracommunity

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 3

Page 4: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Open Space Use

• Publicopenspacesandtheirnecessityandbenefitsarewellresearchedanddocumented• ParTcularly,publicopenspacesasculturalfacilitatorsandthereforeofasenseofcommunityiswellresearchedanddocumented•  Sotypologiesexist•  ThephysicalandenvironmentalroleisfulfilledwhenitsculturalroleisevidentasareflecTonofuserlifestyleandpercepTon

Reference:

Rao,Sridevi(2015).AMeasureofCommunity:PublicOpenSpaceandSustainableDevelopmentGoal11.7.Chennai,India.NoTonPress

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,LondonDr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 4

Page 5: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Public Housing - Indian Context

PradhanMantriAwasYojana(PMAY)ThePMAYmissionseekstoaddressthehousingrequirementsoftheurbanpoorincludingslumdwellersthroughthefollowingprogrammeverTcals:•SlumrehabilitaTonofSlumDwellerswithparTcipaTonofprivatedevelopersusinglandasaresource•PromoTonofAffordableHousingforweakersecTonsthroughcredit-linkedsubsidies•AffordableHousinginPartnershipwithPublic&Privatesectors•Subsidiesforbeneficiary-ledindividualhouseconstrucTon/enhancementEconomicallyWeakerSecCons(EWS):SlumDwellersLowerIncomeGroups(LIG)

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 5

Page 6: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Public Housing - Indian Context •  TemplatesasdesignsoluTons

•  CentralGovernmentfinancialmechanismsareavailabletotheStates.TheCentralGovernmentdoesnotimplementpublichousinginStatesbecauselandisaStatesubject.

•  Aminimumof30sq.m.coveredareaforaDwellingUnitor10sq.m.percapita

•  “AHousingClustershouldprovideaminimumspaceof5sq.m.percapitaeachforgreen/openspace/playarea,socialinfrastructureandtransport[roads]anduTliTes”*

Thatis,allinclusiveonly5sq.m.percapita

*RaviKanth.M.April2016.Editorial.Shelter.Vol.1No.1.www.hudco.org

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,LondonDr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 6

Page 7: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

THE PROBLEM HousingandUrbanDevelopmentCorporaTonorHUDCOhastemplatesforEWSandLIGHousingwhicharebasedonactuallivingcondiTons.

However,onlythecoveredareaofshelteristakenintoaccount.

Thebeneficiarylifestyleisirrelevantbecausetheemphasisisonthefinancialandlegalaspectsofpublichousing.

ThepsychosocialwellbeingiscriTcaltoensureasenseofcommunity.

ThepicturesareofpublichousinginIndia.

Buildingmaterials,land,servicesarequanTfiableandconvenienttoensureaccesstofinancial,legalmechanismsthatfulfilltargets.

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 7

Page 8: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

REFERENCE

•  PublicHousinginIndiaiswellresearchedanddocumented

•  BalakrishnaDoshiandCharlesCorreahavedocumentedandimplementedlayoutsthatencourageconTnuityoflifestylesofresidentsthroughdesign.

•  SotypologiesexistfortheIndiancontext.Thepicturesarefrom‘Aranya’HousingbyDoshiinIndore,intheStateofMadhyaPradesh,India

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 8

Page 9: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Case Study

TheHut(inaslum)LocaTonofHyderabad,TelanganaState,India

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 9

Onanaverage,Hutsarearound6sq.m.inarea.NearlyallacTviTes,oflivelihoodoroflifestylearecarriedoutintheopen.RecreaToninparTcularisreflectedintheuseofleisuretopaintandenhancepremises,sTtch,meeTngfriendsatwaterwellsorhandpumpsandcooking,drying,grindingingredientsforfoodisalsointheopen.

Page 10: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Singam Cheruvu Tanda, Nacharam, Hyderabad* Eachflatconsistsof2bedrooms,akitchenand2toilets.Theflatsarebuiltwheretheslumexisted.Thereare11blocksspreadovertwoacresor8094sq.m.EachFlatoccupiesanareaof560sq.qor52sq.m.Thelayoutdiffers.Whereastheslumhadacentrallylocatedopenspacewithhutsaround,nowthefamilieswillliveaboveeachother.Theopenspaceistheareaaround.Itisgreen!ArepresentaTvebeneficiaryprofileisasfollows:BanamTariyaisadailywageearnerwithhiswifeandfourchildren,TejawatRavirunsasmallfancystore.Hesupportsafamilyof9.*NiTn.B.176Lambadafamilies2BHKhousesinHyderabad.April8,2018.www.thenewsminute.com

Ref:NiTn.B.176Lambadafamiliesget2BHKhousesinHyderabad.April8,2018www.TheNewsMinute.com

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 10

Page 11: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

The Lambada •  TheLambadaisalsoknownasBanjaran.•  TheyaretradiTonallynomads.PerhapsthisisthereasontheirhousesintradiTonalhabitatsknownasTandaarewhitewashed.

•  However,richembroideryandjewelleryadorntheasreofwomen.•  Historicallytheytradedinsaltandgrain.HowevertheycanbeseenattheroadsideandtrafficsignaljuncTons,sellingpouery,flagsonRepublicDay,toys,umbrellasduringthemonsoonandsoon.

•  TheircelebraTonsarecommonwithHindufesTvals.Ref:www.TelanganaToday.com

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,London.Dr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 11

Page 12: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Lifestyle •  TheLambadamakethemaximumuse

oftheareaoutsidethehut.

•  Dryingfoodingredients,spendingTmewithfamilies.

•  FesTviTesandcommunitycelebraTonsaredependentonthecentralopenspace.

•  TheynowhavevoterIDcards.SotheyreturntotheirTandawhentheyhavetovote.ThisgivesthemGovernmentbenefits.

•  Itisdifficulttoimaginetheirpsychosocialhappinessintheirnewflatswhichonlyneedslayoutappraisal.

Ref:hup://www.haT.ch/Projects/ATVillageProject

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,LondonDr.SrideviRao,[email protected] 12

Page 13: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

Public Open Space as Amenity

•  PublicOpenSpaceisseenasafacilitytoenablelegalfinancialrelatedinstruments.

•  Facilitysegregates.Itisphysicalonly.Itgeneratesincome.Represents‘municipalsterility’(Mumford)

PublicOpenSpaceisapricelessamenity

•  Amenityintegrates.Experiencedandexpressedasculture.

•  AmenityisarelaTonshiptonaturethroughVegetaTon,LandformandWater

•  Amenityemergeswhenpeoplecometogether:

ThroughVisualorPhysicalaccessThroughtangibleorintangibleexperiences

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,LondonDr.SrideviRao,Landscapearchitect,[email protected] 13

Page 14: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

RaConale

The Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, Government of India, cannotrestrict itself to providing a house but needs to fulfill the dream of womenchildrenandtheagedofahome.Reuse,Recycle,ReduceareinherentintheirrichtradiTonalhumblelifestyles.

Minimisingtheecologicalfootprintofpublicopenspacescouldbeachievedbyminimizing thecultural footprintofpublicopenspacewhichotherwise forcepauernsinuseincompaTblewithlifestyles.It is thesenseofcommunitynurturedoutside thedwelling facilitatedby thepublicopenspacethatpublichousingmaynotcapturebecauseoftheabsenceofanopenspacepolicyfacilitaTngandfulfillinglifestylesofbeneficiaries.

InthebroadestsenseSustainableDevelopmentGoalswhichreducetheimpactof climate change begin by the acTviTes of a person ‘drop by drop’ toeventuallyhaveaNaTonalandaglobalimpact.

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,LondonDr.SrideviRao,Landscapearchitect,[email protected] 14

Page 15: PUBLIC HOUSING AND PUBLIC AMENITIES · • Community • Culture • ... pictures are from ‘Aranya’ Housing by Doshi in Indore, in the State of Madhya Pradesh, India 14-Oct-2019

14-Oct-2019 HCD2019,LondonDr.SrideviRao,Landscapearchitect,[email protected] 15

Itisnotdifficulttofindutopiainadystopiansesng,providedrulesallow.