PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in...

61
SAFEGUARDING PRIVACY WHILE INNOVATING WITH OPEN DATA SETS Meghan Land, Staff Attorney, Privacy Rights Clearinghouse Sheldon Lee, Assistant General Counsel, Intuit Abhi Nemani, Chief Data Officer, City of Los Angeles Timothy Yim, Director of Data & Privacy, Startup Policy Lab #PSR15 @timothy_yim @abhinemani @intuit @privacytoday Privacy. Security. Risk. 2015 Conference Presented by IAPP & CSA Congress

Transcript of PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in...

Page 1: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

SAFEGUARDING  PRIVACY  WHILE  INNOVATING  WITH  OPEN  DATA  SETS

Meghan  Land,  Staff  Attorney,  Privacy  Rights  Clearinghouse  Sheldon  Lee,  Assistant  General  Counsel,  Intuit  Abhi  Nemani,  Chief  Data  Officer,  City  of  Los  Angeles  Timothy  Yim,  Director  of  Data  &  Privacy,  Startup  Policy  Lab

#PSR15  @timothy_yim  @abhinemani  @intuit  @privacytoday

Privacy.  Security.  Risk.  2015  Conference  Presented  by  IAPP  &  CSA  Congress

Page 2: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Privacy.

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 3: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Open Data.

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 4: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

1. Benefits of Open Data2. Risks of Open Data3. Open Data in Cities4. Open Data in Corps5. Privacy by Design6. Resource Scarcity

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Agenda

Page 5: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Open Data.

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 6: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Automatic License Plate Readers

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 7: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

ALPRs

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 8: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 9: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 10: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 11: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 12: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Benefits

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 13: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Risks

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 14: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 15: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Benefits of Open Data

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 16: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Data-driven Decision Making

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 17: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 18: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 19: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Better Governance

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 20: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Better Governance

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 21: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Better Governance

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 22: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Data Science Research

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 23: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Trend Identification

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 24: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Outbreaks

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 25: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 26: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 27: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Risks of Open Data

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 28: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Re-identification

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 29: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Netflix Prize Contest

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 30: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Netflix Prize Contest

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 31: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Ask Questions

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 32: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Vulnerable

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 33: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Outliers

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 34: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Non-Consensual Transparency

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 35: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Data Retention & Time

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 36: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Physical Dangers

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 37: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Perpetuating Discriminatory Models

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 38: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Accountability

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 39: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 40: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

X

Page 41: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 42: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Open Data in Cities

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 43: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Open Data Initiatives

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 44: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

City of LA Use Case

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 45: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Privacy Concerns

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 46: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Challenges for Privacy Pros

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 47: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Open Data in Corporations

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 48: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Commercial Use Case

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 49: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Contractual Obligations

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 50: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Re-identification

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 51: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Data Breaches

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 52: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Onward Transfer

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 53: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Privacy by Design

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 54: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

PbD & Privacy Engineering

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 55: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Resource Scarcity

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 56: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Red Team

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 57: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Red Team

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 58: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

• Independent of any city or organization • Focused on:

• Privacy risks • Re-identification risks

• Cost • Reduced per data set cost • Outsourced Model • Trustworthy

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Open Data: Red Team Concept

Page 59: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

THANKS TO:

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

IAPP & Audience Members

Page 60: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Panelists

Safeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

Page 61: PSR15 Privacy + Open Data | v4 · 1. Benefits of Open Data 2. Risks of Open Data 3. Open Data in Cities 4. Open Data in Corps 5. Privacy by Design 6. Resource Scarcity Safeguarding

Session Feedback:

For updated slidedeck:

Timothy Yim Director of Data & Privacy [email protected]

Twitter: @timothy_yimSafeguarding Privacy while Innovating w/ Open Data Sets #PSR15

via PSR15 Conference App (short link)