PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson,...

17
PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer , Juan Trenado, Bianca Hinojosa Brown University, Providence, RI, USA Trying to produce a thin, thermally conductive bond between the CF base plate and the pixel sensor

Transcript of PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson,...

Page 1: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

PS Module Gluing Tests

USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop

Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado, Bianca Hinojosa

Brown University, Providence, RI, USA

Trying to produce a thin, thermally conductive bond be-tween the CF base plate and the pixel sensor

Page 2: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

2

Gluing Process

Apply glue to stencil Squeegee acrossMix and degas epoxy

Page 3: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

3

Gluing Process Continued

Set glass slide on top Place glass and weights on topRemove Stencil

Page 4: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

4

Epoxy Degassing

Vacuum• Recommended 28-29 in Hg, but our pump only capable of 25.5 in Hg.• Removes large bubbles, but produces many smaller bubbles.

Heat (peltiers on copper plate and heat gun)• Works well, but heat decreases viscosity and reduces working time of

epoxy.

Ultrasonic Bath• Works well and is our preferred method.

Other Issues• Because epoxy is too viscous to pour, removing from mixing cup

introduces additional bubbles.

Epoxy bubbles after mixing

After 20 minutes in sonicator

Page 5: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

5

StencilsKapton Stencil (75 um thick)• Issue with epoxy getting squeegeed under

stencil.→ Resolved by wetting glass with alcohol to keep stencil flat

• Grid Pattern ripped during squeegeeing.

Stainless Steel Stencil (50 um thick)• Very marginal amount of epoxy gets squeegeed

under stencil.• Stencil still in good shape although care has to

be taken to not crinkle the stainless steel.

Tear in Stencil

Page 6: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

6

Squeegeeing Issues

• Many factors affect quality of epoxy film.• When squeegeeing across, care must be taken to apply

no downward force as that causes the squeegee to flex resulting in less epoxy in the middle than the edges.

• If rate squeegee is dragged across stencil is too slow, especially when attempting to apply no downward force, the squeegee can almost get stuck and you get ridges.

• Viscosity of epoxy, which changes with time, is also a factor. Higher viscosities produce better epoxy films.

Ridges from slow squeegeeing

Page 7: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

7

Epoxy Uniformity

• When gluing glass slides on top we were creating large air pockets• This was due to unevenness of the epoxy layer.

Significant air pockets in the middle of both the grid square and the rectangle

Page 8: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

8

Epoxy Uniformity (Improved squeegeeing)

Epoxy Film Glass Slide on Top

Page 9: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

9

Epoxy Thickness MeasurementsMethod A• Used stencils to apply layer of Araldite to glass with both

stencils.• Measure thickness with profileometer (touch probe)• Good sensitivity, but can only measure 2 cm into the

sample.Method B• Glue glass slides to glass base.• Cut glass in middle of slides• Examine under microscope• Difficult to get cut in slides and cut in base to be aligned, and when uneven

microscope can not focus on everything at once.

Profileometer

Page 10: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

10

Epoxy Thickness (Method A, ~40 um)

Rect

angl

eG

rid

Kapton Stainless SteelStainless Steel

(Improved Squeegeeing)

Page 11: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

11

Epoxy Thickness (Method B, ~60-70 um)• Using known thickness of the glass (3/32”) calculate thickness of epoxy layer (Araldite).

• Likely due to uneven cuts and issues with the focus and neither the piece nor the microscope being strictly vertical there was a variation between 40-80 um for the measurements.

• Median thickness for kapton, 60 um, and for stainless steel, 70 um

Kapton, Rectangle Pattern Kapton, Grid Pattern

Page 12: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

12

Stamping

• Create and fill epoxy reservoir with tape (150 um)

• Stamp pattern onto glass base• Set glass slides on top and place weights

same as was done with the stencils• Can’t really clean between grooves so the

stamps slowly gum up.

Epoxy reservoir for stamps

Stamp Patterns

Page 13: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

13

Stamping

• Except for the epotek, epoxy is too viscous to merge together the patterned stamps to create a uniform layer.

• Solid stamp does not produce a solid layer of epoxy.• Awaiting the result of the glue thickness

measurements for the stamps.• Stencils preferable to get a solid uniform layer.

Solid Stamp

Epoxy doesn’t merge between gaps

Page 14: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

14

Gluing Aluminum “Sensors”• Also tried 250 um thick Al pieces cut to the size of the sensors.• Thin aluminum much less rigid than 3/32” glass (although also less

rigid than silicon)• Even placing foam under the weights to better distribute the pressure

still results in air pockets.

Page 15: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

15

Epoxies

Epoxy Working Time (hours)

Cure Time Viscosity (cps)

Thermal Conductivity (W/m-K)

CTE (ppm/C)

Glass Transition (C)

Cost

Araldite 2011 2 12 hrs @RT 45,000 .22-.25 85 63C $23/50ml

Epotek 301 8 2 days @ RT 225-425 N/A 61 80 C $36/30ml

3M TC-2810 (Boron Nitride)

1 24 hrs @RT 40,000 - 80,000

1.0-1.4 62 60-100C* $68/37ml

EP48TC 1.5-2 4-7 days @RT

Paste 2.88-3.6 13-15 149C? $550/30ml$800/240ml

Ablefilm 550K N/A 30 m @125C2 hrs @150C

film 0.8 50 102C $170/ft2

* Dependent on curing temperature (60C at RT curing)

Page 16: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

16

Conclusions

• Higher viscosity epoxies (Araldite and 3M) produce better films with stencils or stamps.

• So far Boron Nitride 3M epoxy has the best thermal properties and viscosity for using with the stencils.

• Process can still be improved to eliminate air pockets as much as possible.

Page 17: PS Module Gluing Tests USCMS Outer Tracker Workshop Ulrich Heintz, Meenakshi Narain, Bill Patterson, Sinan Sagir, Adam Lanman, Eric Spencer, Juan Trenado,

17

Further Studies

• Try using film adhesive, Ablefilm 550K• Try paste epoxy with excellent thermal conductivity and CTE (EP48TC)• Build a jig to set down mock sensors and apply pressure to replace

setting by hand and pressing down with weights on top of glass.• Start gluing silicon to carbon fiber base plates and do thermal

conductivity experiments.