PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid...

16
PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council Robert Baertsch - UC Santa Cruz [email protected] for California Air Resource Board ETAAC Sep 6, 2007

Transcript of PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid...

Page 1: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

PRT - Personal Rapid TransitGTS = PRT + freight

GTS - General Transport System

Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council Robert Baertsch - UC Santa Cruz

[email protected]

California Air Resource BoardETAAC

Sep 6, 2007

Page 2: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

What is PRT?• Personal Rapid Transit (Pod cars)• Created in 1970s, Morgantown, WV• 1-4 passengers• Driverless• Solar powered, electric drive• Non-stop to destination• Vectus, Sweden, 2007• ULTra, London Heathrow, 2008

Page 3: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

Freeway at Capacity

Page 4: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

Vehicles Removed

Page 5: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

PRT Passengers

Page 6: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

PRT System

Page 7: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

Solar on Rail

www.SolarEvolution.com/SkyTran

Page 8: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

SkyTran Solar

Solar SkyTran, with aesthetics emphasis and added power at stations

Page 9: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

ft wide solar panel to meet requirement 3.5

watts / sq ft, SunPower, most efficient on market 16

/mi $1,800,000

/watt x $6.00

kW/mile 120 x 2.5 = 300

solar factor = 2.5

hrs of peak sun equivalent (Coast = 4, Desert = 6) ÷ 4

hrs at peak operation equivalent 10

kw needed in a mile stretch = 120

kw @ operating speed x 2

vehicles/mi, separated by interval specified = 60

ft between vehicles = 88

sec (vehicle interval) x 2

mph, operating speed 30

Calculate Solar size, cost per Mile

Page 10: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

years, Payback for solar system to offset gasoline= 3.7 Cost of solar to cover fleet mileage $ 45,000,000 Annual cost to travel fleet mileage $ 12,318,750 Cost to travel fleet mileage daily = $33,750 /gallon fuel price x $2.50 vehicles/day 13,500 people/vehicle 2.0 passengers per day to match 27,000 mpg, average fleet mileage 25

Compare Solar to Gasoline at $2.50/gallon

www.SolarEvolution.com/PRT

Page 11: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

PRT advantages1. Faster (solves traffic)2. Safer 3. Quieter4. Cheaper5. Solar Power - zero (net) fossil fuels6. Helps transit-oriented development7. Driverless = enjoyable commute time

Page 12: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

PRT considerations• Requires government approval• Sometimes obstructs views • Upfront investment => long-term

savings• Complex software ~ air traffic control• Overcome entrenched interests

Page 13: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

Where is the PRT track?

Page 14: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

Transportation Energy for 100 People

750 watt (cd=0.1)7000 watt (cd=0.2)Aerodynamic Resistance (60 mph)500 watt5000 wattRolling Resist. (60 mph)

Very safe≈two 747s/week dieSafety

~50 (skytran)~150Energy use (watt-hr/mile)

Quality time in transit1 hr per day lostQuality of life

6275Parasitic energy Consumption

<1%15%Battery losses

150Embodied energy ratio

99%? %Recycle batteries

125Battery weight (tons)5200Total weight (tons)20100Number of Vehicles

PRT Electric Car

Page 15: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

“Back of the Envelope”Cost of PRT in a large city

• 400,000 population in 78 sq. miles• 500 miles of PRT track @ $5-10m/mile• 40,000 pod cars @ $10,000 each• Total cost $7,500-$14,000 per capita • $60-120 per month (financed over 20 yrs.)• << $400 cost of driving per month

Page 16: PRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS ... · PDF filePRT - Personal Rapid Transit GTS = PRT + freight GTS - General Transport System Ed Porter - Santa Cruz City Council

Clean-tech jobs

• Electronics technicians• Construction (guideways and solar)• Manufacturing• Finance• City planners• Civil Engineers• Software developers• Local operations staff• Parking lots -> parks and dense housing