Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad...

66
Water Distribution Systems & Analysis 1 Environmental Engineering-I Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Transcript of Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad...

Page 1: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Water Distribution Systems & Analysis 1

Environmental Engineering-I

Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan

Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Page 2: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

References

Water Supply & Sewerage (P-143 to 152)

by TERENCE J. McGHEE

Elements of Public Health Engg.(P-159 to 162)

by K.N. Duggal

Water Distribution Systems & Analysis

2

Page 3: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Content

Water Distribution Systems

Design of Water Distribution Systems

Pipe Network Analysis

Water Distribution Systems & networks

3

Page 4: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Part A

Water Distribution Systems

Water Distribution Systems & networks

4

Page 5: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Gravity Supply

• The source of supply is at a sufficient elevation above

the distribution area (consumers). so that the desired pressure can be maintained

Source

(Reservoir) (Consumers)

Supply System-Gravity

HGL or EGL

Water Distribution Systems

5

Page 6: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Advantages of Gravity supply

• No energy costs.

• Simple operation (fewer mechanical parts,

independence of power supply, ….)

• Low maintenance costs.

• No sudden pressure changes

Source

HGL or EGL

Water Distribution Systems

6

Page 7: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Pumped Supply Used whenever:

• The source of water is lower than the area to which we need to

distribute water to (consumers)

• The source cannot maintain minimum pressure required.

pumps are used to develop the necessary head (pressure) to

distribute water to the consumer and storage reservoirs.

Source

(River/Reservoir)

(Consumers)

Supply System-Pumped

HGL or EGL

Water Distribution Systems

7

Page 8: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Source

(River/Reservoir)

(Consumers)

HGL or EGL

Disadvantages of pumped supply

Complicated operation and maintenance.

Dependent on reliable power supply.

Precautions have to be taken in order to enable permanent supply:

• Stock with spare parts

• Alternative source of power supply ….

Water Distribution Systems

8

Page 9: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Combined Supply

(pumped-storage supply)

• Both pumps and storage reservoirs are used.

• This system is usually used in the following cases:

1) When two sources of water are used to supply water:

Source (1)

Source (2)

City

Gravity

Pumping

HGL

HGL

Pumping station

Water Distribution Systems

9

Page 10: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Combined Supply (Continue) 2) In the pumped system sometimes a storage (elevated)

tank is connected to the system.

Elevated

tank

Source

Pipeline

High

consumption

Pumping station

• When the water consumption is low, the residual water is

pumped to the tank.

• When the consumption is high the water flows back to the

consumer area by gravity.

Low consumption

City

Water Distribution Systems

10

Page 11: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Combined Supply (Continue) 3) When the source is lower than the consumer area

Reservoir

Pumping

Pumping Station

• A tank is constructed above the highest point in the area,

• Then the water is pumped from the source to the storage

tank (reservoir).

• And the hence the water is distributed from the reservoir

by gravity.

Gravity

City

HGL

HGL

Water Distribution Systems

11

Page 12: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Distribution Systems (Network Configurations )

• In laying the pipes through the distribution

area, the following configuration can be

distinguished:

1. Branching system (Tree)

2. Grid system (Looped)

3. Combined system

Water Distribution Systems

12

Page 13: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Branching System (tree system)

Branching System

Source

Submain

Main

pipe

Dead End

Advantages:

• Simple to design and build.

• Less expensive than other systems.

Water Distribution Systems

13

Page 14: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

• The large number of dead ends which results in sedimentation

and bacterial growths.

• When repairs must be made to an individual line, service

connections beyond the point of repair will be without water

until the repairs are made.

• The pressure at the end of the line may become undesirably low

as additional extensions are made.

Disadvantages:

Water Distribution Systems

14

Page 15: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Grid System (Looped system)

Grid System

Advantages:

• The grid system overcomes all of the difficulties of the

branching system discussed before.

• No dead ends. (All of the pipes are interconnected).

• Water can reach a given point of withdrawal from several

directions.

Water Distribution Systems

15

Page 16: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Disadvantages:

• Hydraulically far more complicated than branching system (Determination of the pipe sizes is somewhat more complicated) .

• Expensive (consists of a large number of loops).

But, it is the most reliable and used system.

Water Distribution Systems

16

Page 17: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Combined System

• It is a combination of both Grid and Branching

systems

• This type is widely used all over the world.

Combined System

Water Distribution Systems

17

Page 18: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Part B

Design of Water Distribution Systems

Water Distribution Systems & networks

18

Page 19: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Design of Water Distribution

Systems

Main requirements :

• Satisfied quality and quantity standards

Additional requirements :

• To enable reliable operation during irregular situations (power

failure, fires..)

• To be economically and financially viable, ensuring income for

operation, maintenance and extension.

• To be flexible with respect to the future extensions.

A properly designed water distribution system should fulfill the following requirements:

Design of Water Distribution Systems

19

Page 20: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

The design of water distribution systems must

undergo through different studies and steps:

Design Phases

Hydraulic Analysis

Preliminary Studies

Network Layout

Design of Water Distribution Systems

20

Page 21: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Preliminary Studies:

4.3.A.1 Topographical Studies:

Must be performed before starting the actual design:

1. Contour lines (or controlling elevations).

2. Digital maps showing present (and future) houses, streets,

lots, and so on..

3. Location of water sources so to help locating distribution

reservoirs.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

21

Page 22: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Water Demand Studies:

Water consumption is ordinarily divided into the

following categories:

Domestic demand.

Industrial and Commercial demand.

Agricultural demand.

Fire demand.

Leakage and Losses.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

22

Page 23: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Domestic demand

• It is the amount of water used for Drinking, Cocking, Gardening, Car Washing, Bathing, Laundry, Dish Washing, and Toilet Flushing.

• The average water consumption is different from one population to another. It varies from 150 to 600 lpcd.

• The average consumption may increase with the increase in standard of living.

• The water consumption varies hourly, daily, and monthly.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

23

Page 24: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

How to predict the increase of population?

The total amount of water for domestic use is a function of:

Population increase

Geometric-increase model Use

P P r n 0 1( )P0 = recent population

r = rate of population growth

n = design period in years

P = population at the end of the design

period.

The total domestic demand can be estimated using:

Qdomestic = Qavg * P

Design of Water Distribution Systems

24

Page 25: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Industrial and Commercial demand

• It is the amount of water needed for factories, offices,

and stores….

• Varies from one city to another and from one country

to another

• Hence should be studied for each case separately.

• However, it is sometimes taken as a percentage of total

water supply (10-30%).

Design of Water Distribution Systems

25

Page 26: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Agricultural demand

• It depends on the type of crops, soil, climate…

Fire demand

• To resist fire, the network should save a certain amount

of water. • Many formulas can be used to estimate the amount of

water needed for fire.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

26

Page 27: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Fire demand Formulas

)01.01(1020 PPQF QF = fire demand US Gallon/min

P = population in thousands

ACQF *18.223QF = fire demand flow lit/min

A = areas of all stories of the building

under consideration (m2 )

C = constant depending on the type of

construction;

Minimum and Maximum Storage Required are 4 hours & 10

hours Respectively.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

27

Page 28: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Leakage and Losses

• This is “ unaccounted for water ”(UFW)

• It is attributable to:

Errors in meter readings

Unauthorized connections

Leaks in the distribution system

Design of Water Distribution Systems

28

Page 29: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Design Criteria

are the design limitations required to get the most efficient and economical water-distribution network

Velocity

Pressure

Average Water Consumption & Future Demand

Design of Water Distribution Systems

29

Page 30: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Velocity

• Not be lower than 0.25 m/s to prevent

sedimentation - WASA

• Not be more than 2 m/s to prevent erosion and

high head losses near large fires.

• Commonly velocity is kept in between (1 - 1.5

m/s).

Design of Water Distribution Systems

30

Page 31: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Pressure • Pressure which is required to be maintained depends

upon:

– Height of Highest Building

– Distance of locality from the distribution reservoir

– Supply is metered or not

– Pressure required for Fire Hydrants

– Funds available for project

Design of Water Distribution Systems

31

Page 32: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Pressure • Pressure in municipal distribution systems ranges from 150-

300 kPa in residential districts with structures of three stories or less and 500 kPa in commercial districts.

• Also, for fire hydrants the pressure should not be less than 150 kPa (15 m of water) to ensure proper flow in other buildings and to avoid infiltration in system.

• Moreover, the maximum pressure should be limited to 70 m

of water.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

32

Page 33: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Pipe sizes • Primary feeders form skeleton of distribution system. They convey water

from Pumping station to & from OHR to various parts of city. They should be provided with Air-Relief & Blow-off Valves. Size is generally 300 mm (12 in to 60 in).

• Secondary feeder carry water from primary feeder to various parts of city to provide normal supplies. These are located at a few (2-4) blocks apart to provide water for fire fight without excessive loss. Sizes are 200 mm, 250 mm, 300 mm.

• The size of the small distribution mains is seldom less than 150 mm (6 in) and dictated by fire flow.

• Sizes of Domestic Supply Lines are generally 100mm, 80mm.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

33

Page 34: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Design of Water Distribution Systems

34

Page 35: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Head Losses

• Optimum range is 1-4 m/km.

• Maximum head loss should not exceed 10

m/km.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

35

Page 36: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Design Period for Water supply Components

• The economic design period of the components of a

distribution system depends on

• Their life.

• First cost.

• And the ease of expandability.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

36

Page 37: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Network Layout

• Next step is to estimate pipe sizes on the basis of water demand and local code requirements.

• The pipes are then drawn on a digital map (using AutoCAD, manually) starting from the water source.

• All the components (pipes, valves, fire hydrants) of the water network should be shown on the lines.

Design of Water Distribution Systems

37

Page 38: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

References

Water Supply & Sewerage (P-143 to 152)

by TERENCE J. McGHEE

Elements of Public Health Engg.(P-159 to 162)

by K.N. Duggal

Water Distribution Systems & Analysis

38

Page 39: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Part C

Pipe Network Analysis

Water Distribution Systems & networks

39

Page 40: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Pipe Network Analysis

Pipe Network Analysis

40

Page 41: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Pipe Networks

• A hydraulic model is useful for examining the impact of design and operation decisions.

• However, more complex systems require more effort, but, as in simple systems, the flow and pressure-head distribution through a water distribution system must satisfy the laws of conservation of mass and energy.

Pipe Network Analysis

41

Page 42: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

The equations to solve Pipe network must

satisfy the following condition:

• The net flow into any junction must be zero.

Inflow should be equal to Outflow.

• The net head loss a round any closed loop must be

zero.

Pipe Networks

0Q

Pipe Network Analysis

42

Page 43: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Node, Loop, and Pipes Node

Pipe

Loop

Pipe Network Analysis

43

Page 44: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

After completing all preliminary studies and

layout drawing of the network, one of the

methods of hydraulic analysis is used to

• Size the pipes and

• Assign the pressures and velocities

required.

Hydraulic Analysis

Pipe Network Analysis

44

Page 45: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Hydraulic Analysis of Water Networks

• The following are the most common methods used to

analyze the Grid-system networks:

1. Hardy Cross method.

2. Equivalent Pipe Method.

3. Sections method.

4. Computer programs (EPAnet Software,...)

Pipe Network Analysis

45

Page 46: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Hardy Cross Method

In this method, the rate of flow is ASSUMED and

the ERROR in the assumed flow is computed on the

account of IMBALANCE OF HEAD LOSSES IN

THE CIRCUIT/LOOP. After correcting the flows,

final head loss through various pipes is checked to

assess the adequacy of the design. If needed, the

pipe diameters are changed to result in REQUIRED

PRESSURE AT THE OUTLET.

Pipe Network Analysis

46

Page 47: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Hardy Cross Method

This method based on:

0 0Loop

f

Junction

hQ

1- A distribution of flows in each pipe is estimated such that

the total inflow must be equal to the outflow at each junction

throughout the network system

The interflow in the network has +ve sign

The outflow from the network has -ve sign

Pipe Network Analysis

47

Page 48: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

2- Neglect Minor loss

3- In each loop

4- If the direction of flow is clockwise it take +ve sign,

otherwise it take –ve sign

5- If the flow is correct other wise, the assumed

flow must be corrected as the flowing:

0 Loop

fh

0 Loop

fh

Pipe Network Analysis

48

Page 49: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

WilliamHazenn

kQh n

F

85.1

)1(

)2( oQQ

....

2

1

2& 1

221

f

n

o

n

o

n

o

n

o

n Qnn

nQQkQkkQh

from

1

f n

o

n

o

n nQQkkQh

0

0

1

nn

o

n

loop

n

loop

F

nkQkQkQ

kQh

Neglect terms contains 2

For each loop

Pipe Network Analysis

49

Page 50: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

o

F

F

n

o

n

o

Q

hn

h

nkQ

kQ

1

6- After calculation correct Qo and check 0 Loop

fh

Pipe Network Analysis

50

Page 51: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Assumptions / Steps of this method:

1. Assume that the water is withdrawn from nodes only; not directly from pipes.

2. The discharge, Q , entering the system will have (+) value, and the discharge, Q , leaving the system will have (-) value.

3. Usually neglect minor losses since these will be small with respect to those in long pipes.

4. Assume flows for each individual pipe in the network.

5. At any junction (node), as done for pipes in parallel,

outin QQ Q 0or

Pipe Network Analysis

51

Page 52: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Assumptions / Steps of this method:

6. Compute head loss in each pipe.

7. Find out SUM of total Head loss in pipe having

CLOCKWISE DIRECTION of flow---call it as ∑H1.

8. Find out SUM of total Head loss in pipe having

ANTICLOCKWISE DIRECTION of flow---call it as ∑H2.

9. Find out ∑H1 - ∑H2 .

10. Around any loop in the grid, the sum of head losses must

equal to zero:

Pipe Network Analysis

52

h floop

0

Page 53: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

10. Around any loop in the grid, the sum of head losses must equal

to zero:

– Conventionally, clockwise flows in a loop are considered (+) and

produce positive head losses; counterclockwise flows are then (-) and

produce negative head losses.

– This fact is called the head balance of each loop, and this can be valid

only if the assumed Q for each pipe, within the loop, is correct.

• The probability of initially guessing all flow rates correctly is

virtually null.

• Therefore, to balance the head around each loop, a flow rate

correction ( ) for each loop in the network should be

computed, and hence some iteration scheme is needed.

Pipe Network Analysis

53

Assumptions / Steps of this method:

Page 54: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Assumptions / Steps of this method:

11. Calculate hf / Q0 for each pipe and sum for loop S hf / Q0 .

12. Calculate using:

NOTE:

For Common members between two loops:

Pipe Network Analysis

54

0

85.1

Q

h

h

f

f

12

21

2 loopin member common for

1 loopin member common for

Page 55: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

13. After finding the discharge correction, (one for each loop) , the assumed discharges Q0 are adjusted and another iteration is carried out until all corrections (values of ) become zero or

negligible. Q = Q0 + ∆ 14. Repeat the procedure till:

<0.2m3/min or

<10% of flow in that pipe

is satisfied.

h floop

0 0.

Pipe Network Analysis

55

Assumptions / Steps of this method:

Page 56: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

• Note that if Hazen Williams (which is generally used in this

method) is used to find the head losses, then

h k Qf 185. (n = 1.85) , then

0

85.1Q

h

h

f

f

• If Darcy-Wiesbach is used to find the head losses, then

h k Qf 2

0

2Q

h

h

f

f(n = 2) , then

o

F

F

n

o

n

o

Q

hn

h

nkQ

kQ1

Pipe Network Analysis

56

Page 57: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

• Assigning clockwise flows and their associated head losses are

positive, the procedure is as follows:

Assume values of Q to satisfy Q = 0.

Calculate HL from Q using hf = KQ1.85 .

If hf = 0, then the solution is correct.

If hf 0, then apply a correction factor, Q, to all Q.

For practical purposes, the calculation is usually terminated

when Q < 0.2 m3/min.

A reasonably efficient value of Q for rapid convergence is

given by;

Summary

QH

HQ

L

L

85.1

Pipe Network Analysis

57

Page 58: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Example 1

D L pipe

150mm 305m 1

150mm 305m 2

200mm 610m 3

150mm 457m 4

200mm 153m 5

1

2 3 4

5

37.8 L/s

25.2 L/s

63 L/s

24

11.4

Solve the following pipe network using Hazen William Method CHW =100

Pipe Network Analysis

58

Page 59: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Solve the following pipe

network using Hazen William

Method CHW =120

Example 2 Pipe Network Analysis

59

Page 60: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Example • The figure below represents a simplified pipe network.

• Flows for the area have been disaggregated to the nodes, and a major fire flow has been added at node G.

• The water enters the system at node A.

• Pipe diameters and lengths are shown on the figure.

• Find the flow rate of water in each pipe using the Hazen-Williams equation with CHW = 100.

• Carry out calculations until the corrections are less then 0.2 m3/min.

Pipe Network Analysis

60

Page 61: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

61

Page 62: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

62

Page 63: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

General Notes • Occasionally the assumed direction of flow will be incorrect. In such

cases the method will produce corrections larger than the original flow and in subsequent calculations the direction will be reversed.

• Even when the initial flow assumptions are poor, the convergence will usually be rapid. Only in unusual cases will more than three iterations be necessary.

• The method is applicable to the design of new system or to evaluation of proposed changes in an existing system.

• The balanced network must then be reviewed to assure that the velocity and pressure criteria are satisfied. If some lines do not meet the suggested criteria, it would be necessary to increase the diameters of these pipes and repeat the calculations.

Pipe Network Analysis

63

Page 64: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Example • The following example contains nodes with different

elevations and pressure heads.

• Neglecting minor loses in the pipes, determine:

• The flows in the pipes.

• The pressure heads at the nodes.

Pipe Network Analysis

64

Page 65: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Assume T= 150C

65

Page 66: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad ...msenvengg.weebly.com/.../7/3/8/...system__analysis.pdf · Prof. Dr. Muhammad Zulfiqar Ali Khan Engr. Muhammad Aboubakar Farooq

Assume flows magnitude and direction

66