8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

1/10

NCCRTRADEWORKING PAPER 2006/01 1

T

: P

Y . S . I , . B . I , , ,

. I , .

1. CW 1758, E V: L A P C E. 1 E , I ( )

. G .2

T, S () , ( ?), , ( ) , .3I , , . T .

1 E V, (L, 1758, . C I, W, 1916), I, .III, 27 ( 31).

2 W ( )

, ,

, ,

,

, .

3 C. G J, (B, O H, 1914) 505: D V S R R, O S

, A S, V W

, S S.

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

2/10

2 THE CONSTITUTIONALIST RECONSTRUCTION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW:PROS AND CONS

. T ( )

. I ( ) ( ) . A ( ) . I , , . I , () , .

A .4H, 17/18 ( ). T ( ) ,

, . I , , / . I ( ) : C , , .5C () .

I

, , , , , .

4 O B, C P R S R (), (P, Q/PUF, 2003) 133142; G C, C LW

L (), V. 2 (N Y/L, M,1986) 473480; UK P, C E C (), V. 2 (L, R, 1998) 618622; R., K J R (), V. 4 (B, S, 1989) 10051006.

5 C ( 4) 747. JH W M W

. C ... ,

, .

A , ,

, , I G ,

,

K , (JH W M W,I, (), (C, C UP,2003) 1 3). S B ( 4) 136

142.

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

3/10

NCCRTRADEWORKING PAPER 2006/01 3

2. O

A .T , .

L ?

O () . 6A , . T

, () . C, .7B , .

H, , . F , G G , .

O?

A .8T .9T , , . T . A . 10 S

. C

6 U H, I V (2003) 128 511556.

7 53334, B A, (L, V, 1983).8 R MD DM J, I (),

: (L, M N, 2005,, ).

9 . DZ C, (O, O UP, 2005) 208 WTO.

10 . C ( 9) 237 ( WTO).

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

4/10

4 THE CONSTITUTIONALIST RECONSTRUCTION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW:PROS AND CONS

.

H,

11 .I , , , .

U?

A . T ,

.12R , 13 K L.14

T , . T , , , . I

, , .15 F , (W) , , . L, UN , , . 16T : I , .17

11 J K, C L (2004) 1 31 48.12 S S, L C N U C M? JP C ,

: V 1 (3 , P, E, 2005) 29 32.13 M N, (B, D & H, 1998).14 K L, (T, J.C.B. M, 1959) 15253.15 W K, D M UNO: E B K

V? W K T C (), : 65. . (2005) 42 47.

16 49.17 F M, (B, D & H, 2003)

132.

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

5/10

NCCRTRADEWORKING PAPER 2006/01 5

T , I . F, . A

. H, . T . I, . I , .18

B, , , . T , , ,

.

E ?

T , .19A , , , . I , : , ( ) .T () 20

H, . T, ( ). I . G , .

W ,

18 . S ( 12) 32: E , ,

.

19 K ( 11) 47.

20 T V, C L T: C G T C

J (), (O P O,H, 2004) 29 35.

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

6/10

6 THE CONSTITUTIONALIST RECONSTRUCTION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW:PROS AND CONS

, .21L . I ,

. I , , , ( ).

P ?

A .22

T

. W , () , , . T .

C ?

A . G , , , , . 23 A 24 .

T . F, , WTO, UN S C,

UN.

21 N L, (F .M., S, 1993) 407439.22 P A, T E I A (2002) 35 N

308 336. A : T K

, , . T U.N. C,

,

23 C ( 9) 245 WTO.

24 S ( 12) 49 (. 26).

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

7/10

NCCRTRADEWORKING PAPER 2006/01 7

A . A, A

. A : I , . I . B WF, .

E?

A . C E. T . I . T T W C .25

I , ; ,, . W E, . I 18 19 E, .

A , , .T , , ( ) . T .26

I .H, . A

, . I , .

A E ,

25 C H, G A L: T Q P V (2006) 17

187 189.26 A B, C I L: C P

G (2006) 47 223 241 . 85.

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

8/10

8 THE CONSTITUTIONALIST RECONSTRUCTION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW:PROS AND CONS

A , .27

H, .

E E , F B .T USA . T . E , , E USA , E USA ; USA R F, T F, FR. T, AM S, J N.

A ?

G . T , .28

H, , , . T

. G .

F, . I . T B , ,. H, . M, ,

. A , , . A , .

27 . DM J, W C T I L MD J ( 8) 20.

28 J ( 27) 19.

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

9/10

NCCRTRADEWORKING PAPER 2006/01 9

3. T

A A .29D, M K , , .., K .30

A , , , .31S

, , .

C

S, .32G . G ,

. P , , , . M, ( ) , .33 A .

29 J H, H K V C? , : (F M., S, 2004) 113 115.

30 T E C R F K

, (I I C K, : , , (N Y, O UP, 2000) 185198, . 186).

31 .R I, P II, (5 , L, B H, 1898) 471: D F

F W, Z F. D F V

F Z G, F B,

, , , . F F

S Z O F S

A , .

32 S A P, C C: T F P

F I N S (2006) 19 .33 I US I 2003/04,

(B USA, K I., C B, T ) ,

, , .

8/12/2019 Pro and Con Constitutionalization Final

10/10

10 THE CONSTITUTIONALIST RECONSTRUCTION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW:PROS AND CONS

T . T, . N

, , ; . T , , , .34I , , .

C

M , , .35B , . T . I ( ) .36 I , , .

34 A P, T G S C A N (), (2007 ).

35 B ( 26) 242.

36 M K, T L I L: A C F

A (2004) 15 907 929.