PRINCIPLE OF SET – SET CIRCUIT DESIGN – COMPARISON...

26
NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 1 of 26 PRINCIPLE OF SET – SET CIRCUIT DESIGN – COMPARISON BETWEEN FET AND SET R. John Bosco Balaguru Professor School of Electrical &Electronics Engineering SASTRA University B. G. Jeyaprakash Assistant Professor School of Electrical & Electronics Engineering SASTRA University

Transcript of PRINCIPLE OF SET – SET CIRCUIT DESIGN – COMPARISON...

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 1 of 26

    PRINCIPLE OF SET – SET CIRCUIT DESIGN – COMPARISON BETWEEN FET AND SET

    R. John Bosco Balaguru Professor

    School of Electrical &Electronics Engineering SASTRA University

    B. G. Jeyaprakash

    Assistant Professor School of Electrical & Electronics Engineering

    SASTRA University

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 2 of 26

    Table of Content

    1. PRINCIPLE AND CONSTRUCTION OF SINGLE ELECTRON TRANSISTOR ……………………………………………………………….…..3 1.1 WHAT IS SINGLE ELECTRON TRANSISTOR? ………………………………………..3 1.2 CONSTRUCTION OF THE SET ………………………………………………………….6

    2. OPERATION OF SET …………………………………………………………..9

    2.1 OPERATION TEMPERATURE ………………………………………………………….11 2.2 THE DIFFERENT WAYS TO INCREASE Ec

    INCLUDE …………………………….…11

    3. APPLICATIONS OF SET ………………………………………………..……12 3.1 SET BASED FLIP-FLOP………………………………………………………...………..12 3.2 RING MEMORY ………………………………………………………………………....12 3.3 SET BASED HALF ADDER ………………………………………………………..……13

    3.3.1 Working …………………………………………………………………………14 3.3.2 Truthtable ………………………………………………………………....……15

    3.4 TIMING DIAGRAM ANALYSIS …………………………………………………..……15 3.4.1 Assumption ……………………………………….……………………….…….15 3.4.2 State changes analysis ………………………………………………...………..15

    3.5 SET BASED AND GATE …………………………………………………..………….…17 3.6 TIMING DIAGRAM ANALYSIS OF SET BASED AND GATE ………………………..19

    3.6.1 Assumption …………………………………………………………………..….19 3.6.2 State change analysis for AND gate …………………………………..…...…..19

    3.7 COMPARISON BETWEEN SET AND FET ………………………………………….…19 3.8 ANALYSIS ……………………………………………………………………………….21

    4. SOLVED PROBLEMS …………………………………………..…………….22

    5. REFERENCES ………………………………………………………………....26

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 3 of 26

    1 Principle and construction of single electron transistor 1.1 What is Single Electron Transistor?

    These are devices operating at the quantum/nanoscale that have switching properties controlled by the removal or injection of a single electron; a device through which only one electron can be transported at a time. Before discussing about the principle and construction of Single Electron Transistor (SET),Let us see why SET is important?

    • In electrometry: It provides the possibility of measuring the electron addition energies (and hence the energy level distribution) in quantum dots and other nanoscale objects

    • The SETs have also been used in the first measurements of single-electron effects in single-electron boxes and traps.

    • A modified version of the transistor has been used for the first proof of the existence of fractional-charge excitations in the quantum hall effect.

    • Low power logic gates and their derived devices

    • Applications in quantum computers

    • Straight forward co-integration with traditional CMOS circuits

    • Single electron transistors (SETs) have high input impedances. Besides this, these are also very sensitive to random background charges.

    The difference between a FET/BJT and a SET is shown in the following table:

    FET/BJT SET Based on its input current (BJT) or input voltage (FET), a transistor allows a precise amount of current to flow through it.

    The single electron transistor is a new type of switching device that uses controlled electron tunneling to amplify current or switch the state.

    The word single electron means that one-electron-precision charge transfer through tunneling, which is based on the Coulomb blockade effect

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 4 of 26

    One of the most exciting challenges of microelectronics is the vision of realizing a

    switching device that can be controlled by single electrons. This had been realized by using the concept of coulomb blockade (conduction is achieved when potential is sufficient to overcome the energy of charge correlation)and electron tunneling that used to develop Single Electron Transistors (SET)

    Let us analyze the terms Coulomb blockade and electron tunneling to

    understand the working principle of SET: SET consists of a metal island of a few hundred nanometers across, coupled to

    two metal leads via tunnel barriers. At temperatures below 1 K, no current can pass through the island with low bias voltage. This effect is known as the Coulomb blockade, which is the result of the repulsive electron–electron interactions on the island. Coulomb blockade is the repelling energy of previous electron present in the island to the next electron coming towards the island. The concept of Coulomb blockade refers to the phenomenon that tunneling through an island may be inhibited at low temperatures and small applied voltages. The reason is that the addition of a single electron to such a system requires an electrostatic charging energy. In metals, the Coulomb-blockade oscillations are essentially a classical phenomenon, since the energy spectrum of the confined region may be treated as a continuum. This is not the case in semiconductor nanostructures which have dimensions comparable to the Fermi wave length.

    Electron Tunneling: Tunneling refers to the ability of using the quantum wave properties of an electron to allow transmission through a thin voltage-potential barrier. According to the laws of classical electrodynamics, no current can flow through an insulating barrier. But quantum mechanics says that there is a finite probability for an electron on one side of the barrier to reach the other side.

    When a bias voltage is applied, there will be a current. This tunneling current will be proportional to the bias voltage. In electrical terms, the tunnel junction behaves as a resistor with a constant resistance. An arrangement of two conductors with an insulating layer in between not only has a resistance, but also a finite capacitance. The insulator is also called dielectric in this context; the tunnel junction behaves as a capacitor.

    We know that for two conductors separated by an insulator, charge and voltage are proportional. Q =CV (1) where Q is the charge on the conductors, C the capacitance and V is the voltage between the conductors.

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 5 of 26

    The electrostatic energy stored in the conductors is given by

    2C21 22 Q=CV=E (2)

    The total energy E depends on the amount of charge on the capacitor and on the

    electric potential V. The energy of the capacitor C that is charged with n electrons is equivalent to

    Cqn=En

    22

    21 (3)

    The energy difference on the capacitor C for the two charge situations of n and

    n+1 electrons correspond to

    ( )12n2C

    2

    1 +q=EE n+n − (4)

    An electron can only pass the barrierthrough tunneling if this energy difference is less than or equal to the energy of the electron. The energy of the electron is expressed as E= qV (5)

    This implies that the value of Voltage V should not exceed the value

    ( ) .=n,+q=V ....1,2,3,4,..2C

    12n (6)

    For the normalized voltage the location of the steps is equivalent to

    ( )2

    12n +=q

    VC (7)

    1.2 Construction of the SET

    The single-electron transistor describes a single electron transport through a

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 6 of 26

    quantum dot. A quantum dot is a semiconductingnanoparticle whose electrons are confined in all three spatial dimensions

    There are many variations to the structure of the single-electron transistor. The

    main components of the single- electron structure are shown in Fig. 1.

    Fig. 1. Single Electron Transistor The island is the quantum dot which is connected to the drain and source

    terminals. Electron exchange occurs only with the drain and source terminals, which are connected to current and voltage meters.

    The gate terminal provides electrostatic or capacitive coupling. When there is no

    coupling to the source and drain, there is an integer number N of electrons in the quantum dot (island). The total charge on the island is quantized and equal to qN. (Since tunneling is a discrete process, the electric charge that flows through the tunnel junction flows in multiples of the charge of electrons e)

    The formulation of the Coulomb blockade model is only valid, if electron states

    are localized on islands. In a classical picture it is clear, that an electron is either on an island or not. That is the localization is implicit assumed in a classical treatment. However a more precise quantum mechanical analyses describes the number of electrons localized on an island N in terms of an average value,which is not necessarily an integer. The Coulomb blockade model requires.

    |N-|2

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 7 of 26

    If tunneling is allowed between the island, drain, and source terminals, then the number of electrons N adjusts itself until the energy of the total system is minimized.

    The tunneling junctions (barriers) are made thick enough so that the electrons

    exist in the island, source, or drain, such that the quantum fluctuation in the number N due to tunneling through the barrier is much smaller thanone.

    The electrostatically influenced electrons traveling between the source and the drain terminals need to tunnel through two junctions (barriers). The island is charged and discharged as the electrons cross it, and the relative energies of the island containing zero or one extra electron depends on the gate voltage.

    Thus, the charge of the island changes by a quantized amount q. The change in the

    Coulomb energy associated with adding or removing an electron from the island is usually expressed in terms of the island capacitance C. The charging energy Ec

    Cq=Ec

    2

    can be expressed as

    (8)

    This charging energy becomes important when it exceeds the thermal energy kBT. The time Δt needed to charge or discharge the island can be expressed as Δt = Rt C, whereRt is the lower-bound tunnel resistance.

    From the Heisenberg uncertainty principle we have, Rt> ħ/q2. The quantity ħ/q2

    2qRt

    >>

    = 25.813 kΩ is called the quantum resistance or quantum conductance (G= 38.74μS). Thus, two conditions must be met to observe the charge quantization:

    and TkCq

    B>>2

    (9)

    The capacitance can be made small by reducing the quantum dot size since C =

    4πεsR for a sphere and C = 8πεsR for a flat disc, where R is the radius and s is the permittivity of the material.

    The gate voltage Vg is applied to change the island electrostatic energy in a continuous manner. The total gate voltage-induced charge on the island is expressed as q = CgVg. This charge is considered continuous.

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 8 of 26

    By sweeping the gate voltage, the buildup of induced charge will be compensated in a periodic interval due to the tunneling of discrete charges. The competition between the induced charges and the discrete compensation leads to so-called Coulomb oscillations.

    Consider that the gate voltage is fixed for the single-electron transistor while the drain-source voltage is varied. The current-voltage results exhibit a staircase-like behavior known as a Coulomb stair-case and is shown in Fig. 2.

    Fig. 2. Coulomb Stair-case

    In this case, the charge carriers i.e. electrons enter through one junction and then escape to second junction due to the presence of high resistance. Now, electrons moves from one junction to another very rapidly. Thus this rapid movement of excess electrons from one junction to another raises the total charge of the island. If the bias is increased, it will tend to increase the population of electrons in the island. In this case the IV- Curve represents Stair-like characteristics, which are commonly referred to as the “Coulomb Staircase”.

    7

    6

    5

    4

    3

    2

    1

    0 ec

    2ec

    3ec

    4ec

    5ec

    6ec

    7ec

    Drain voltage

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 9 of 26

    2 Operation of SET

    Continuing with our discussion on the working of SET, this lecture shall give further insights to its operation. The basic operation of the single-electron transistor is shown in Fig.1, where the tunneling junctions are presented as barriers. The island is represented as a valley or well between thetwo barriers.

    A mathematical understanding shall make the behavior of SET more authentic.

    The energy required to move one electron from the full top energy level to the

    bottom empty level in the island can be derived as follows. If we observe the working of SET, as described in Lecture -1, the entire discussion

    was focused on moving a single electron from Source to Drain. The Fermi energy levels of the island (dot), the drain, and the source are shown in

    the Fig. 1 as E F D, E F dot, and E FS, respectively. The Fermi energy level is the potential energypossessed by the electron, when it is in different regions

    When a drain-source bias voltage is applied, these Fermi energy levels are no longer aligned, as shown in the Fig. 1, as opposed to the case of absolute zero. At zero temperature (zero thermal energy), the current is zero as the gap between the bottom empty state and the top full state is aligned with E F D and E FS . This is called Coulomb blockade.

    From basics of semiconductor Physics, we know that the minimum energy required to add an electron to the dot is E F = E N − E N −1 where N is the total number of electrons in the dot (island). For the linear response time, E F dot

    ( ) ggo

    NdotF VC

    qCC

    NNq+E=NE −

    −−

    21

    2

    can be written as

    (10)

    Where No = Number of electrons in island VG = 0' N = Number of electrons at dot with gate voltage VG C = Cs+Cg+Cd

    The energy E (N) is single particle energy for the Nth electron measured from the bottom of the conduction band. When an electron is added to the island at a constant gate voltage, the Fermi energy becomes

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 10 of 26

    ( ) ggo

    +NislandF VC

    qCC

    NNq+E=+NE −

    −−

    21

    1 21 (11)

    By taking the difference between Eqs. (10) and (11), one can find that

    ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )Cq+ΔE=

    Cq+NE+NE=NE+NE FF

    islandF

    islandF

    22

    11 −− (12)

    where ΔE is the energy separation between the energy levels in the quantum dot.

    If ΔE is too small, then the energy gap between the filled (solid lines) and empty (dashed lines) states is approximately q2/C.

    The energy levels in the dot can be adjusted by applying a gate voltage as shown

    in Fig. 3b and c such that the electron can tunnel from the source to the drain.

    Fig. 3. Working of SET Note: Can be viewed only on Acrobat 9.0 and above

    2.1 Operation Temperature

    The smaller the capacitance C of the quantum dots, the larger the quantum confinement energy Ep, the larger is the coulomb energy Ec, thus the larger is the Operational temperature.

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 11 of 26

    2

    22

    lmπ=E op

    (13)

    TkE+q=E Bpc >>2C

    2

    (14)

    Where mois the effective mass, l is the diameter of the island or quantum dot, q is the effective charge, KB is the Boltzmann constant.

    To allow single- electron device operation, the Coulomb energy must be the dominating energy in the system. Depending on the error rate that can be tolerated, one shall choose how much larger the Coulomb energy should be compared to the thermal energy. The range in the literature goes from Ec> 3KT to Ec> 100KT.

    Thus, one shall have the aim of increasing the Coulomb energy for proper

    operation of a single electron device 2.2 The different ways to increase Ecinclude

    As we observe from our analysis, if we decrease the capacitance, Coulomb energy

    Ec

    • Reducing spatial dimensions

    and the quantum confinement increases

    • Using different dielectric materials with a lower dielectric constant to reduce the capacitance, or

    • Materials that show much higher quantum confinement energies than metals, such as semiconductors.

    3 Applications of SET

    As discussed in the previous lectures, the aim is to explore the possibility of producing circuits that combine large scale integration and low power dissipation. Though several single-electron circuits have been proposed, the fundamental designs are elaborated in the following sections: 3.1 SET based Flip-Flop One design possibility is to mimic conventional memory design with SET devices, such as a static SET memory cell or flip-flop .The operation is equivalent to a conventional flip-flop.

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 12 of 26

    In Fig. 4. Junctions J2 and J3

    • J

    form a SET transistor.

    1• C

    is the load resistance out the load capacitance is much bigger than the conventional capacitance C.

    which means that Cout• V

    /C represents one bit of information. IN=16mV (logic 1), and VIN

    • Tunnel resistance (Rj) is 100KΩ; =0V (logic 0)

    The free energy of the circuit should always be kept least possible, as otherwise, it may result in undesirable outputs.

    Fig. 4. A SET based Flip-Flop 3.2 Ring memory

    A different idea which is a generalization of the bistable quantum cell for cellular automata is shown in Fig. 5. On the circuit level it is also similar to the electron trap memory, because it is a trap connected to a ring, a so called ring memory cell. However the operation is different.

    outV

    Cout

    Vout

    Vin, reset Vin, set

    Cout J2

    J3

    J1 C

    C

    C C

    Vb

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 13 of 26

    Fig. 5. SET based Ring Memory.

    An even number n (in our case n=6) of tunnel junctions is connected to a ring, and

    n/2 electrons are inserted into the ring. Due to their Coulomb interaction, they will repel each other and thus can form two stable configurations. Applying positive or negative voltage pulses atVin will switch the state of the ring to either one of the stable configurations. The capacitors Co

    • The circuit comprises six islands N1- N6

    should be small compared to the capacitances of the tunnel junctions, so that the electrons have a large influence on their neighbors and keep their distance. 3.3 SET based Half Adder

    The single-electron half-adder is shown in Fig.6. The following design illustrates how SET can produce the effect of a half adder.

    • The islands are bounded by nine tunnel junctions J1- J9, with the capacitance of

    each junction being 10-18

    F.

    • Junctions J8 and J9 are less transparent in order to prevent electron transport from the ground (Vss

    ) to islands N5 and N6 respectively, and vice versa.

    • The voltage Vdd From Fig.7

    is constant and its value is 0.095 V.

    Voltage source Voltage (V) Logic Level V1 0.0 Logic ‘1’ V2 20.1 Logic ‘0’

    0

    e

    e

    e

    e

    e e

    1

    Vin

    Vout

    Co

    Vout

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 14 of 26

    3.3.1 Working

    The presence of positive charge corresponds to logic `1', whereas no charge corresponds to logic `0'. The following table illustrates the arrangement and the subsequent table explains the working:

    Input Voltage Nodes to which voltage is applied Voltage applied through the Capacitor(s)

    V1 N1,N2 C1,C2 V2 N3,N4 C3,C4

    All four capacitors have the same capacitance, 10-18

    Fig. 6. SET based half adder.

    3.3.2 Table 1: Truth table

    F. The output signals of the half-adder are taken from nodes N5, which is the Sum, and N6, which is the Carry.

    Input A Input B Sum Carry 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0

    V1 | +

    C1

    Vdd

    J1

    N1

    N2

    V2 | +

    Vss

    +

    C2

    C3

    C4

    J2 J3

    J4

    J7 J6 J5

    J8 J9 N5

    N3

    N4

    N6

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 15 of 26

    The timing diagram for the half adder operation is shown in Fig. 5. 3.4 Timing Diagram Analysis 3.4.1 Assumption

    During the first time step it is assumed that one of the two input vectors [0 0] or [1 1] is applied to the circuit in order to have a logic ‘0’at the Sum output(and hence no positive charge is present at N5) 3.4.2 State changes - Analysis Time Step

    Input Vector Working Effect on Sum Effect on Carry

    2 [1 0] or [0 1] • The input vector changes and hence an electron is transported from N5 to N3(through J5)

    • The free energy of the system increases

    1 Since the free energy increases

    0

    3/4 [1 1] or [0 0] (The complement of the first state)

    • Electron is transported from N3 to Vdd• Hence a positive charge is present at node5

    through J1

    • Free energy decreases

    0 1/0 • Electron is

    transported from N2 to Vdd

    through J3 (hence logic 1 shall be present at the carry output)

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 16 of 26

    Fig. 7.Operation of the Half-adder. (a) time variation of input voltage V1, (b) time variation of input voltage V2, (c) time variation of the charge at the sum output node N5, (d) time variation of the charge at the carry output node N6

    Fig. 8.Free energy history of the circuit for the output transition from ‘0’ to ‘1’. (a) Sum output node N5 to Vddthrough N3,

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 17 of 26

    (b) Sum output node N5 to Vdd through N1, (c) Carry output node N6 to Vdd

    • Four islands, N1-N4, with N4 corresponding to the output node.

    .

    3.5 SET based AND gate

    Now, let us analyze the single-electron three-input AND gate. Consider Fig. 9. The circuit comprises of:

    • The presence of a positive charge on this island (N4) corresponds to the logic `1', whereas the absence of positive charge corresponds to the logic `0'.

    • The islands are bounded by five tunnel junctions J1-J5 and three capacitors C1-C3.

    • The tunnel junctions J1-J4 are identical. • Tunnel junction J5 is less transparent, in order to prevent electron transport from

    the ground (Vss

    ) to island N4 and vice versa.

    Table: Resistance and Capacitance of the tunnel Junctions

    • The voltage Vdd• V1, V2 and V3 are the inputs to the AND gate.

    = 0.115 V, which is a constant.

    • It can take only two values, -0.1 V, which corresponds to the logic `1', and 0.1 V, which corresponds to the logic `0'.

    The input voltages are applied to the corresponding nodes through the capacitors C1, C2 and C3.

    Junction Resistance (Ω) Capacitance (F) J1-J4 10 105 -18

    J5 10 10 7 -18

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 18 of 26

    Fig. 9. SET based AND Gate

    Fig. 10. The operation of three-input AND gate, (a), (b) and (c) time variation of input voltagesV1, V2, V3, respectively, (d)

    Time variation of the charge at the output node N4

    +

    V1 | +

    C1

    Vdd

    J1

    J2

    N1

    N2

    N4

    V2 | +

    V3 | +

    C2

    C3

    J3

    J4

    N3

    Vss J5

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 19 of 26

    3.6 Timing diagram analysis of SET based AND gate 3.6.1 Assumption At first time step, one of the seven input vectors, apart from [1 1 1], is applied to the gate so that no positive charge exists. Hence the output is zero. During the input vector [1 1 1] the output changes in the following steps 3.6.2 State change analysis for AND gate

    Time step Node to which electron is transported

    Effect on free energy

    Output

    2 N4 to N3 through J4 Increases

    3 N3 to N2 through J3 Decreases slightly 4 N2 to N1 through J2 Increases slightly

    5 N1 to Vdd Significant increase shall be

    observed

    through J1 ‘1’

    3.7 Comparisonbetween SET and FET

    Though, the structure of Single electron transistors [SETs] is almost same as that of MOSFETs (in terms of source, drain and gate) but still there are some differences between the SETs and MOSFETs. The following table illustrates the differences and similarities between them.

    SET MOSFET

    • SETs have tunnel junction • In the case of MOSFETs, it is a p-n junction

    • A small conducting island [quantum dot] • Has a channel region • the tunneling electrons are transferred one-

    by-one through the island from source to drain due to the effect of Coulomb blockade

    • Number of electrons is transferred through the channel at a time. Thus many electrons simultaneously participate to the drain current.

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 20 of 26

    • Due to the Coulomb blockade effect, an electron approaching a small negative charged region experiences the electrostatic repulsion by the previous electron in that region. This regulates the number of electrons one-by-one in the channel and hence the drain current varies accordingly.

    • In case of SETs, the drain current (Id) does not depend on the number of electrons transferring through the channel or on the Fermi velocity. The Id-Vg

    characteristic of SET is periodic which shows a finite drain current only for the specific gate voltages where the energies for N and N+ 1 electron in the channel are degenerated

    • In case of FETs, the drain current (Id) depends on the number of electrons passes through the channel. i.e. more electrons in the channel, larger the drain current

    The common phenomenon in both of these two devices is the electrostatic effect

    that rules on both of them (i.e. SETs & MOSFETs). But in case of SETs, electrons are not free to move from source to drain due to the presence of tunnel junctions. Unlike ideal FETs, the source and drain of the SETs are separated from the channel by sufficiently large resistances which are acting as tunnel barriers.

    Note: Can be viewed only by Acrobat 9.0 and above The comparison between FET and SET as well as their circuit designs, within the

    power-delay diagram, is a very interesting issue. Although the power-delay diagram only offers a simplified view of both concepts, the fields for the potential applications can be derived.

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 21 of 26

    We observe from thisFigure that the FET behavior is recovered when the

    temperature exceeds the charging energy. 3.8 Analysis

    The switching energy of a FET decreases as the device dimensions decrease,

    because the number of electrons in the channel as well as its capacitance scales with the factor α2

    Therefore, the switching energy scales from this point on with α

    . When the scaling procedure is continued until the last electron in the channel, the FET model turns into the SET model, since the charge of the last electron in the channel cannot be scaled.

    -1

    T=300K 1/α

    , which actually

    10 1 0.1

    1

    210

    10

    310

    410

    S0

    W

    WS

    0.1

    1

    100 electrons

    FET

    SET

    S0

    50kTW

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 22 of 26

    means that the switching starts to increase for smaller dimensions. To operate CMOS circuits at 300 K the SET device dimensions have to be very small, while the FET device dimensions have to be relatively large. In between these two extremes a save operation is only possible via cooling. This consideration is of fundamental relevance for nanoelectronics: For relatively large device dimensions the energy stored in the capacitor can only cope with the above-mentioned constraints if the thermal energy is reduced via cooling. For smaller device dimensions the switching energy becomes higher than the thermal energy and no additional cooling is necessary. 4 Solved problems 1 . For the tunnel junction with C = 1.2 aF and Rt = 100 kΩ, what is the temperature at

    which coulomb blockade is expected to occur?

    Cs<q2

    k BT

    Answer

    We know that

    from which we have the temperature as

    T= q2

    kBCs So, the temperature is 1549.372K.

    2. Assume that initially there are n = 100 electrons on the quantum dot. If Ca= Cb = 1.2

    aF. What is the on Vs for the electron to tunnel?

    21

    2C+nq>Vs

    Answer

    We have

    Therefore the condition on Vs is given as

    Vs > 6.709V

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 23 of 26

    3. For a SET with Ca = Cb = 10 aF and gate capacitance Cg = 1.4 * 10-16 F, and gate

    voltage Vg as 0.1 V with initial electrons n = 175, what is the condition on Vs for

    tunneling to occur.

    Answer

    We have the condition for Vs

    ( )

    −−

    211 +nqVC

    C+C>V gg

    bgs

    as

    upon substitution of the given data we get, Vs > 0.2797V

    4. Atoms are arranged in a cubic lattice where the smallest distance between any two

    atoms is r0 . Assuming one free electron per atom, what is the Fermi energy? Calculate

    EF in eV when r0 = 0.5 nm.

    32

    83N

    2m

    2

    ΠV

    h=EF

    Answer

    We know that

    whereVN=n is the number density

    EF

    32

    32

    83 nπ

    =EF

    can be written as

    therefore n can be given as

    n= 1r 0

    3

    , therefore the Fermi energy is given as

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 24 of 26

    20

    2 132

    83

    2m rπh=EF

    upon substituting the given values we get the Fermi energy as

    EF = 1.5eV

    5. Consider a single-electron transistor with a gate capacitance that can be represented

    as two parallel plates with a material having a dielectric constant of 13 and an area of 100

    nm2 . Calculate the separation between the plates that can yield a capacitance of 1.0aF.

    dεA=C

    Answer

    We know that

    where A is the area and d is the distance between the plates.

    Upon mathematical manipulation we get

    CεA=d

    substituting the values of ε and A we get

    d = 1300 nm

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 25 of 26

    6. For the tunnel junction C = 0.5aF and Rt = 100kΩ, what is the RC time constant.

    CR=τ tτ

    Answer

    The Time constant is given by

    Therefore the value of the time constant is given as

    ττ= 0.005 * 10 -11

    8. Build an programmable logic gate using SETs.

    s

    this denotes the switching speed of the SET.

    7. Apply the concept of SET to design an Inverter.

    VDD

    A OUT= A.B For CTRL=0

    B

    CTRL

    VDD

    A Ā

    “P-type

    “N-type

  • NPTEL – Electrical & Electronics Engineering – Semiconductor Nanodevices

    Joint Initiative of IITs and IISc – Funded by MHRD Page 26 of 26

    9. Design a Memory device using SET and explain its operation

    A .

    A small number of electrons, or even just a single electron, is stored on a single

    quantum dot. Their presence on the quantum dot QD corresponds to logical ‘1’ and their

    absence to ‘0’. The line of tunnel junctions introduces an energy barrier for electrons

    entering or leaving QD. Thus, stored electrons residein a local energy minimum.To write

    in this cell a voltage pulse is applied at Vg , which eliminates the energy barrier. Vg

    1. George W. Hanson, Fundamentals of Nanoelectronics, Pearson, 2011

    forces electrons to tunnel through junctions positive pulse onto island QD.

    5 References

    2. K. Goser, P. Glosekotter, V. Dienstuhl, Nano electronics & Nano Systems,

    Springer, 2004.

    3. Omar. Manarseh, Semiconductors, Heterojunctions and Nanostructures, TMH. 2005.

    4. C. Wasshuber, A comparative study of single-electron memories, IEEE Transactions on electron devices, 1998.

    J1 J2 J3 J4 J5 J6 Cg QD

    Vout