Presentation Janlokpall
-
Upload
kaushik-gupta -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of Presentation Janlokpall
-
7/27/2019 Presentation Janlokpall
1/6
-
7/27/2019 Presentation Janlokpall
2/6
UNDERSTANDING OF JAN LOKPAL/CITIZENS OMBUDSMAN BILL
Institution of
Jan Lokpal at Central Goverment Level
Jan Lokayukta in Each State
CorrespondinglyJan Lokpalto accept corruption complaints against Central
Government department and Jan Lokayuktaagainst State Goverment Department.
Each will have 10 Members and 1 Chairperson.
Will be completely independent
Politicians and Bureaucrats will not able to interfere in their functioning.
Will get whatever financial resources they ask and will be empowered to select and
employ any number of employees from within the government or outside.
-
7/27/2019 Presentation Janlokpall
3/6
ComparisonCURRENT SYSTEM PROPOSED JAN LOKPAL-JAN LOKAYUKTA SYSTEM
JUDGES
SC&H
C
No FIR can be registered against any Supreme Court or High Court
judge without the permission of Chief Justice of India.
It has been seen in the past that the Chief Justice of India tries to
protect his own fraternity of judges and rarely gives such a
permission.
Under Jan Lokpal Bill, the full bench of Lokpal will give permission to file a case against any judge.
No permission will be required from Chief Justice of India. Therefore, corruption in higher
judiciary will also be checked through Jan Lokpal Bill.
CURRENT SYSTEM PROPOSED JAN LOKPAL-JAN LOKAYUKTA SYSTEM
Whistleblowe
rs
Currently, people who report corrupt practices or raise their voice
against corruption are being threatened, victimized and even
murdered. There is no protection for them.
Jan Lokpal and Jan Lokayukta will be responsible for providing the whistleblowers, whether inside
or outside the government, protection from:
- Professional threat or victimisation
- Physical threat or victimisation
-
7/27/2019 Presentation Janlokpall
4/6
Comparison
CURRENT SYSTEM PROPOSED JAN LOKPAL-JAN LOKAYUKTA
SYSTEM
EVID
ENCE
In the current system, if anyone obtains
any benefit from the government illegally, it
is difficult to prove that the person did so
by paying bribes
If a person obtains any benefit from the government in
violation of a law or rules and regulations, that person along
with concerned public servants shall be deemed to have
indulged in corrupt practices.
CURRENT SYSTEM PROPOSED JAN LOKPAL-JAN LOKAYUKTA SYSTEM
M
ultipleAnti-Corruption
Agencies
Presently there are multiple anti-corruption agencies like:
CBI, CVC, ACB, state vigilance department
All these are controlled by corrupt officials and politicians
and are ineffective.
At central govt level, anti-corruption branch of CBI, CVC and all internal
vigilance wings of all dept should be merged into Jan Lokpal.
At state level, anti-corruption branch of state police, the state vigilance
department, internal vigilance wings of all departments and existing Lokayuktas
in states should be merged into Jan Lokayukta of that state.
This will do away with multiplicity of anti-corruption agencies.
-
7/27/2019 Presentation Janlokpall
5/6
Criticism Of Annas movement
I. Laws are made by the Parliament, not on the streets.
II. Form of Pressure can be seen as Blackmail.
III. Super Constitutional Body dangerous for the country.
IV. Prime Ministers inclusion under the Bill would weaken the Parliamentary system.
V. Inclusion of Judiciary would lead to a parallel system within India.
VI. CBI,CVC shouldnt be merged into Jan Lokpal Bill.
VII. Foreign and opposition parties sponsorship on Annas movement.
VIII. Anna Hazare and his alliances are not the Elected Representative.
IX. No Guarantee Jan Lokpal would totally eliminate corruption from India.
-
7/27/2019 Presentation Janlokpall
6/6