Prairie Metropolis Centre & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

39
N. Ernest Khalema, Assistant Professor Faculty of Social Work - University of Calgary (Edmonton) George C. Ishiekwene, PhD Youth Programs - Catholic Social Services – Edmonton Prairie Metropolis Centre & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada April 20, 2009 Meeting the Integration Support Needs Meeting the Integration Support Needs of Refugee Youth: The Role of of Refugee Youth: The Role of Community-Based Participatory Community-Based Participatory Partnerships Partnerships

description

Meeting the Integration Support Needs of Refugee Youth: The Role of Community-Based Participatory Partnerships. N. Ernest Khalema , Assistant Professor Faculty of Social Work - University of Calgary (Edmonton) George C. Ishiekwene , PhD Youth Programs - Catholic Social Services – Edmonton. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Prairie Metropolis Centre & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Page 1: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

N. Ernest Khalema, Assistant Professor Faculty of Social Work - University of Calgary (Edmonton)

George C. Ishiekwene, PhD Youth Programs - Catholic Social Services – Edmonton

Prairie Metropolis Centre &

Alberta Employment and ImmigrationBrown Bag SeminarEdmonton, Canada

April 20, 2009

Meeting the Integration Support Needs Meeting the Integration Support Needs of Refugee Youth: The Role of of Refugee Youth: The Role of

Community-Based Participatory Community-Based Participatory PartnershipsPartnerships

Page 2: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Abstract

Agency, community, and institutional partnerships have demonstrated potential for improving the schooling experiences of youth from refugee, war-affected, and disrupted schooling back- grounds; but only recently have their multilevel impacts been systematically evaluated and articulated. This presentation profiles a case study that highlights the evolution, development, and implementation processes and outcomes of a community-based participatory partnership (CBPP) project entitled: Project Youth: Integration and Education (PYIE). PYIE began in 2004 and was aimed at supporting the educational needs of recently arrived refugee youth in Edmonton’s inner-city with an overall mandate of enhancing the adaptive/settlement capacity of refugee youth in ways that minimize distress and promote healthy and positive school experiences. The partnership between Catholic Social Services (CSS), St Joseph High School, refugee youth, and other community collaborators was explored using a multi-method longitudinal case study approach. The conversion of the Career and Life Management (CALM) curriculum, the use of school and community resources, the adoption of non-formal delivery styles, one-on-one counseling, a systematic practice evaluation component, and the adoption of a strength-based leadership development were among the strategies for which the partnership’s evaluative and implementation process bore substantial outcomes. Lessons and limitations for potential PYIE model replication in other contexts will be discussed in order to guide educators, researchers, and policymakers on the process of implementing effective school-based programs to support refugee youth in schools.

Page 3: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Presentation Focus

This presentation profiles a case study research that highlights the evolution, development, and implementation processes as well as outcomes of a community-based participatory partnership (CBPP) project entitled:

Project Youth: Integration and Education (PYIE)

Page 4: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Rationale and Motivation

• Growing desire and demand for educational resources that help build the knowledge and skills needed to develop and sustain effective partnerships to support the integration needs of refugee youth.

• Stimulate interest in community-based participatory partnerships as a novel concept for school-based interventions .

Page 5: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Key Questions in understanding CBPP

• What is meant by successful CBPP aimed at supporting refugee and immigrant youth?

• What are the factors that contribute to successful CBPP?

• What are the barriers and facilitators that impact successful CBPP?

• What ideas, recommendations and strategies can build the capacity of communities, youth, agencies, funders, and other stakeholders to engage in successful CBPP?

Page 6: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Partnerships & Collaborations: What is the Difference?

Partnerships Collaboration

Involves a contractual relationship Involves cooperation not necessarily contractual

Organizations partner officially, but people collaborate

CBPP involves both a partnership and collaboration

Page 7: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

CBPP Key Principles

• Multilateral collaborative approach

• Interdisciplinary

Page 8: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

CBPP Characteristics

• Synergistic collaboration• Community involvement• Stakeholder commitments

Page 9: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

CBPP Project Components

• Outcome Based• Logic Model• Evaluation• Informed by Literature• Process and Practice for Policy Reform• Academic Rigor

Page 10: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Definition

• Refugee vs. Immigrant

• Some challenges are specific to refugee youth, others are common among both immigrants and refugees.

Page 11: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

The Refugee Youth Literature • Mental Health • Sociology

• Social Work

• Cross-Cultural Psychology

Page 12: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Key Challenges facing refugee youth

• Specific challenges facing refugee youth

– Trauma– Settlement – Family– Community– language

Page 13: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Immigration Stages

Reception Adjustment Adaptation

Selection

Integration

Page 14: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Intervention Project Youth: Integration and

Education (PYIE)

Page 15: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Approach

“Positive” Youth Development (PYD) vs. “At Risk” Youth

Page 16: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Background

PYIE began in 2004 and was aimed at supporting the educational needs of recently arrived refugee youth in Edmonton’s inner-city

PYIE grew out of a shared desire to address the needs of students from refugee backgrounds enrolled at the school.

Page 17: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

• Target group (Sample):• Refugee students in St Joseph High School • In Canada at most 2 years • at risk (living on their own and/or socially vulnerable) • 17 – 20 years old, in grades 11 and 12 • little or no formal school experience

• Program Core Areas:– Basic Life Management Skills– Education Planning– Employment Skills Development– Career Goal Setting

Project Development

Page 18: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Model of Partnership

PYIE

St Joseph High School

Catholic Social Services

Community Resources

Page 19: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

INPUTS ACTIVITIES

PYIE Logic Model

OUTCOMESOUTPUTS

Page 20: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Research & Outcome-based Evaluation: Longitudinal Cohort Design

Short Term~ 6months

Medium Term~ 1-2 years

Long Term~ 2-4 years

Ultimate~ 5years or more

Page 21: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Gender Distribution per Year

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009

Gender (cohorts) 2004-2009

Female

Male

Page 22: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Gender Distribution For Five Years

2004-2009

Male

Female

Page 23: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Country Profiles of Cohorts 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007- 2008 2008 - 2009

Angola Afghanistan Colombia Afghanistan Colombia

Colombia Angola Ethiopia Angola EthiopiaSierra Leone Colombia Indonesia Colombia Liberia

Sudan Eritrea Sierra Leone Eritrea Sierra Leone

Ethiopia Sudan Ethiopia Sudan

Liberia Mexico Thailand

Sierra Leone Pakistan Turkey

Sudan Sudan

Tajakistan

Thailand

Page 24: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Social context

• Qualitative

• Quantitative

Process of Data Collection

Page 25: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Internal

External

Program Evaluation

Page 26: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Data Collection StrategiesQuantitative Qualitative

Examining and Tracking Records Individual interviews with students

Instruments:

Intake process and Exit program

Page 27: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Evolution of Partnership/Collaboration

Page 28: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

CBPP Processes

Social Context

Social Organizational

Processes

Individual/Community Outcomes

Page 29: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Thinking Outside the Box: CBPP

Community-based Participatory Partnerships :

Brings community resources togetherFacilitates activities for refugees and immigrantsProvides analysesHelps guide the process

Page 30: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Principles of Community-based Participatory Partnerships aimed to support Refugee Youth

Page 31: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Sustainable Impact

• Funding • Policies • Procedures • Partnerships

Page 32: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

CBPP Analysis

• Strengths• Weaknesses• Opportunities• Threats

Page 33: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Further Dissemination• There is a need for further dissemination of the

learning from the PYIE process.– Working on obtaining ethics approval at different

levels (i.e. CSS, St Joseph High School, and University).

• Academic & Working Papers – developed a publication plan to share learning about

CBPP, curriculum development, logic model development, and evaluative processes (3 papers in draft).

• Resource Development & Research

Page 34: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Further Dissemination: Resource Development

• Conceptual Framework• Curriculum • Expanded Model• Resource Tools for Teachers• CBPP Analysis

Page 35: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

• Development of a project investigating support needs of refugee students undertaking post secondary education and the barriers they face in meeting their educational goals (with Dr. Janki Shankar, Eugene Ip, and Dorothy Jacques-NorQuest College).

• Development of a project investigating policy implications for capacity building in CBPP for sustainability .

Further Dissemination: Research

Page 36: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Acknowledgements• Youth Participants, Mentors & Volunteers • Current and former CSS staff (Alice Colak, Mary Gallivan, Tigist

Dafla, Linda Lam, Mary Fiakpui, Frank Bessai, Taro Hashimoto & Pauline Mukashema)

• Partners at St Joseph High School (Lynn Smarsh, teachers and support staff)

• PYIE Advisory committee members (Clare Denman, Keri McEachern, Emilie DeCorby, James Garang, Dwain Tymchyshyn, Karen Bardy, Sandy Mitchell, Andrea Burkhart, & Judy Carter)

• PYIE external evaluator (Ann Goldblatt-Centre for Health Promotion Studies-University of Alberta)

• Funders (Alberta Learning and Alberta Employment & Immigration)

Page 37: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Selected References Bowen, G., Martin, J., Mancini, J.A. , & Nelson, J. (2000). Community capacity: Antecedents and

consequences. Journal of Community Practice, 8, 1-21.Fleisher, C.S. (1991). "Using an agency-based approach to analyze collaborative federated

interorganizational relationships." Journal of Applied Behavioural Science 27 (1): 116-30.Khalema, N.E (2002). “Reconceptualizing Racialized Teaching Pedagogies: The Transformative Capacity

of Visible Minority Teachers in Alberta” In Richardson, Annette, Saradhi Putttagunta, and E.Alice Halvorsen, (Eds.) The Canadian Multicultural Experience: Myths and Realities. The International Cultural Research Network Press.

Khalema, N. E., George Ishiekwene, Tigist Dafla, Frank Bessai, & Roz Zulla (2008). “Realities, Challenges, and Intervention Strategies to Support Refugee & Immigrant Youth in Edmonton” Alberta Teachers Association Conference, Edmonton, Canada , May 01, 2008

Mancini, J.A., & Marek, L.I. (2004). Sustaining community-based programs for families: Conceptualization and measurement. Family Relations: Interdisciplinary Journal of Applied Family Studies, 53, 339-347.

Mancini, J.A., Martin, J.A., & Bowen, G. (2003). Community capacity. In T. Gullotta & M. Bloom (Eds.), Encyclopedia of primary prevention and health promotion (pp. 319-331). New York: Plenum.

Uhlik, K.S. (1995). "Partnership, step by step: A practical model of partnership formation." Journal of Park and Recreation Administration 13 (4): 13-24.

Rush, B. & Ogborne, A. (1991). Program logic models: expanding their role and structure for program planning and evaluation. Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation. 6 (2), 95-106.

Selsky, J.W. (1991). "Lessons in community development: An activist's approach to stimulating interorganizational collaboration." Journal of Applied Behavioural Science, 27 (1): 91-115.

Wood, D.J. and B. Gray. (1991). "Toward a comprehensive theory of collaboration." Journal of Applied Behavioural Science 27 (2): 139-62.

Page 38: Prairie Metropolis Centre  & Alberta Employment and Immigration Brown Bag Seminar Edmonton, Canada

Presenters’ Biography

• N. Ernest Khalema is a community-based researcher in Edmonton and currently an Assistant Professor of Social Work at the University of Calgary (Edmonton division). He has worked as an immigrant and refugee youth settlement counselor, research coordinator, and project manager for a number of non-for-profit organizations and post-secondary institutions in Alberta. Some of his research publications include: Enhancing Settlement Services and Supports for African Immigrant Youth in Edmonton: A Needs Assessment (2001); The Aftermath of September 11 in Edmonton (2002); Hope (Elikya) Youth Project Supporting Disadvantaged Immigrant Youth in North-East Edmonton (2002); Towards an Educational Equity Policy in Edmonton Schools (2003); Employment Experiences of African-born Professionals in Alberta: An Analysis of the Economic Status in Relation to their Academic Credentials (2005); Project Youth: Integration and Education (2003-2008); and Retention and Recruitment of Personnel in the Human Service Sector (2008).

• George C. Ishiekwene is a trained physicist with a Master of Education in Science Education and a PhD in Physics. George currently works on several community development projects in Edmonton to empower and build skills for immigrant and refugee youth. He has worked as a youth settlement counselor for the Catholic Social Services for more than five years implementing the Project Youth: Integration and Education program. He has initiated several youth projects within the immigrant community, and has also coordinated a homework program within the Edmonton Mennonite Centre for Newcomers.