Unit 9: Investigative Techniques Used in Terrorism Investigations
Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as...
Transcript of Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as...
![Page 1: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Practical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsinscience
ReporttoTheGatsbyCharitableFoundation
LyndaDunlop,KerryKnox,MariaTurkenburg--vanDiepenandJudithBennettMarch2019
![Page 2: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1
TableofContentsAcknowledgements.......................................................................................................................................2
Listofabbreviations......................................................................................................................................3
Executivesummary........................................................................................................................................4
Introduction...................................................................................................................................................7
Methods........................................................................................................................................................8
Theteachers................................................................................................................................................10
Findings........................................................................................................................................................11
Howdoscienceteacherapproachesvary?.............................................................................................11
Howisopen-endedinvestigativeworkcharacterised?.......................................................................11
Howisopen-endedinvestigativeworkorganised?.............................................................................12
Learningthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.............................................................................13
Enablersofopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsinthecurriculum...........................................................14
Casestudies.............................................................................................................................................15
BTECAppliedScienceinvestigativeproject.........................................................................................16
CPAC&CRESTAwards.........................................................................................................................17
FlyLab..................................................................................................................................................18
CRESTGoldAwardinsteadofafourthALevel....................................................................................19
NorthernhubfortheInstituteforResearchInSchools.......................................................................20
Antibioticsunlimited...........................................................................................................................21
IBInternalAssessment........................................................................................................................22
Summerwithwoodlice.......................................................................................................................23
Redoxtitrations,Salters’style.............................................................................................................24
AlegacyofAdvancingPhysicsbeforethelinearexams......................................................................25
Plantingideasinplantbiologyandpsychology...................................................................................26
RealWorldChemistry..........................................................................................................................27
Meetingthechallengesassociatedwithopen-endedinvestigativeprojects..........................................28
Challengesassociatedwiththeexternalpolicycontext.....................................................................28
Challengesassociatedwiththestudentexperience...........................................................................29
Challengesassociatedwithinfrastructure..........................................................................................30
Subject-specificobservations..................................................................................................................31
Biologyprojects...................................................................................................................................31
Chemistryprojects..............................................................................................................................31
Physicsprojects...................................................................................................................................31
Conclusionsandlimitations.........................................................................................................................32
Recommendations.......................................................................................................................................34
References...................................................................................................................................................35
Appendix1Questionnaire...........................................................................................................................36
Appendix2Interviewguide.........................................................................................................................37
![Page 3: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
2
ThisreportshouldbecitedasDunlop,L.,Knox,K.,Turkenburg--vanDiepen,M.&Bennett,J.(2019). Open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsinscience.ReporttoTheGatsbyCharitableFoundation.TheGatsbyCharitableFoundation,London.TheviewspresentedinthisreportarethoseoftheauthorsanddonotnecessarilyreflectthoseoftheGatsbyCharitableFoundation.
Acknowledgements
TheauthorsaregratefulforfundingfromtheGatsbyFoundationforthiswork.Theywouldalsoliketothanktheteachersandschoolsinvolvedfortheirtimeincontributingtothisreport.
![Page 4: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
3
Listofabbreviations
ALevel AdvancedLevelALPS AdvancedLevelPerformanceSystemAQA AssessmentandQualificationsAllianceAS AdvancedSupplementaryASE AssociationforScienceEducationBTEC BusinessandTechnologyEducationCouncil CPAC CommonPracticalAssessmentCriteriaCREST CreativityinScienceandTechnologyEPQ ExtendedProjectQualificationGCSE GeneralCertificateofSecondaryEducationIB InternationalBaccalaureateIRIS InstituteforResearchinSchoolsMOOC MassiveOpenOnlineCourseNQT NewlyQualifiedTeacherOfsted OfficeforStandardsinEducationOCR OxfordCambridgeandRSAPGCE PostgraduateCertificateofEducationPTA ParentTeacherAssociationRSB RoyalSocietyofBiologyRSC RoyalSocietyofChemistrySAC SaltersAdvancedChemistrySAPS ScienceandPlantsforSchoolsSHAP SaltersHornersAdvancedPhysicsSTEM Science,Technology,Engineering,UCAS UniversitiesandCollegesAdmissionsService
![Page 5: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
4
![Page 6: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
5
ExecutivesummaryThepurposeofthisstudyistoreportonteachers’useofopen-endedinvestigativeworkpost-16.TheGatsbyGoodPracticalsciencereportidentifiesopportunitiestocarryoutopen-endedworkasoneoftheirtenbenchmarksforgoodpracticalscience,yetthereiscurrentlynorequirementforstudentsinEnglandtohaveaccesstotheopportunitytocarryoutsuchwork,whichmeansthatsuchworkisoftenpushedtothemargins.Thisstudyaimedtofindoutwhyandhowteachersuseopen-endedinvestigativeworkwithstudentsinordertoidentifywaysinwhichitcanbepossibleinschoolsinEngland.Shortquestionnairesandextendedsemi-structuredinterviewswereusedtocollectdata.Atotalofseventeenteachersrespondedtothequestionnaireandtwelveteacherswereinterviewed.Allteachersinterviewedhadbeenteachingforlongerthan5yearsandworkedinschoolsorcollegesrated‘good’or‘outstanding’byOfsted.Teacherswereaskedaboutenablersandbarrierstothework,andthewaysinwhichtheynegotiatedthese.Findingsarepresentedascasestudiesinordertoberelatabletootherteachers.Thecasestudiesprovideinformationabouttheproject,whoparticipates,intendedandperceivedlearningoutcomes,theroleoftheteacher,schoolsupportandadviceforotherteachers.Open-endedinvestigativeprojectswerecharacterisedaccordingtotheirdegreeofopen-ness,i.e.whatwasprovidedtostudentsfromthefollowingdimensions:problemandbackground,procedures,designormethodology,analysisandconclusions.Projectsinwhichteachersprovidedalldimensions(confirmatoryprojects)wereexcludedfromthereport.Mostteachersinthesampleprovidedthetheoreticalcontext,withstudentsabletomakedecisionsaboutresearchdesign,analysisandconclusions.Ongoingorad-hocsupportwasafeatureofmanyprojects,andwhilstmostprojectswerenotassessed,theywereoftenusedtomeettheCommonPracticalAssessmentCriteria(CPAC)ormadeto‘count’inotherways.Mostprojectswerecarriedoutduringclasstime,sometimesincludingcollapseddaysinthesummerterm.Fivebigthemeswereidentifiedintermsofwhatteacherswantedstudentstolearn:‘real’science,thestateofthefield,researchdesign,iterationanddatahandling.Enablersofopen-endedinvestigativeworkinthecurriculumincludeteacherexperienceandautonomy,technicalsupport,supportfromseniorleadership,laboratoryspaceandequipmentbudget,examinationspecifications,andexternalsupportandrecognition.Challengesinprovidingaccessforstudentstoopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsincludeaccesstoliterature,laboratoryspace,expertiseandequipment,numbersofstudentsandtechniciansinrelationtonumberofteachers.Teachersinthesamplefoundwaystonegotiateortoovercomethesebarriers,whicharelikelytobeusefultoteachersconsideringofferingopen-endedprojectworkinthecurriculum.Timeremainsanintractableissueforallteachersinthesample.Thisreportincludesdataonlyfromteacherswhowerededicatedtoprovidingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectstotheirstudents;theremaybeadditionalbarrierstodoingthisthataffectthewiderscienceteacherpopulation.AlloftheteachersarebasedinschoolsorcollegesratedoutstandingorgoodbyOfsted,andmanyteachwithintheirspecialism.Theconditionsinother
![Page 7: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
6
institutionsmaycontributetobarrierstoopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsandcaremustbetakentoavoidwideningeducationalinequalitiesintermsofaccesstoopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.Whilstopen-endedinvestigativeprojectscanbeintegratedintothepost-16curriculum,wherethisisnotarequirementofthespecification,ittendstorelyonworkbeyondtimetabledhoursfromteachers.Severalteachersinthissamplefoundwaysofmakingprojectwork‘count’,forexamplebyrelatingittotheCPAC,linkingtoawardschemes,offeringasanalternativetootherscheduledteachingandlearningactivitiesandencouragingstudentstowriteabouttheirexperiencesonUCASapplications.Someteachersinthisstudybelievedthatopen-endedinvestigativeworkhadapositiveimpactonattainmentpost-16,andtheremaybevalueinresearchingthisclaimbecauseifevidencedidsupporttheclaim,moreteachersmaybeconvincedtointroduceprojectwork,evenifnotrequiredbyspecifications.Toincreasetheuptakeofopen-endedinvestigativeprojectworkatpost-16,werecommendarangeofactions.Exemplarsof‘makingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectscount,’couldbemadeavailabletoteachers,withattentiontowaysofminimisingrisk(particularlyinchemistryprojects),andteacherandtechniciantimeforprojectworkthroughworkloadmodelsandbuy-outcouldbevalued.Researchinvestigatingclaimsabouttheimpactofopen-endedinvestigativeworkonattainmentwouldbuildamoreconvincingcasetoteacherswhoarecurrentlyreluctanttointroduceopen-endedprojectwork.Assessmentisanimportantdriverforclassroompractice,andawaytoensurethatthishappensistochangepolicytorequireopen-endedinvestigativeworkinpost-16examinationspecifications.However,whereopen-endedinvestigativeworkistobeincludedinspecifications,caremustbetakentoavoidassessmentmethodsthatresultinaformulaicapproachtoinvestigativeprojectwork.
![Page 8: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
7
IntroductionOpen-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectshavebeenidentifiedasabenchmarkforgoodpracticalscience(Gatsby,2017)yetrecentchangesintroducedtotheAdvancedLevel(ALevel)specificationsmeanthatthereisnolongerarequirementformostpost-16studentsinEnglandtoundertakeopen-endedinvestigativework.Arecentstudyfoundfewteacherstobeundertakingopen-endedinvestigativework(Crammanetal.,2019).Thepurposeofthisstudy,drawingonquestionnaireresponsesandsemi-structuredinterviews,istoreportonthetypesofopen-endedinvestigativeworkundertaken,whyteachersdoit,howitisorganised,andwhatteachersperceivetheopportunitiesandchallengesofsuchworktobe.IncontrasttotherecentrapidevidencereviewonIndependentResearchProjectspublishedbytheWellcomeTrust(Bennett,Dunlop,Knox,Reiss&TorranceJenkins,2016)thisreportfocusesonopen-endedinvestigativeprojects(ofwhichresearchprojectsareonetype),andonwhatteachersdotomakethesepossiblepost-16.Investigationsaredefinedastasksinwhichstudentsdesignanexperimenttotestagivenquestion,carryitoutandinterprettheresults,allwithinafixedtimeperiod(Gatsby,2017).Ininvestigativework,studentscannotimmediatelyseeananswerorrecallaroutinemethodforfindingit(GottandDuggan,1995p.14).Thatistosay,thatwhilstproceduresandresultsmightbeknowntoscience,theyarenotfamiliartothestudentdoingtheinvestigation,andthereisnopre-determinedoutcome(Gatsby,2017).Investigationscanbeopentodifferentdegrees,andinthisreport,projectsthatareopeninatleastoneofthefollowingsixdimensionsidentifiedbyBuck,BretzandTowns(2008)areconsideredopen-ended:theproblem/question,theory/background,procedures/design,analysisofresults,communicationofresultsandconclusions.Confirmationprojectsinwhichtheproblem/question,theoryandbackground,proceduresanddesign,analysis,interpretationandconclusionsareprovidedforthestudentsareexcludedfromthisstudy.Thereisevidencetosuggestthatopen-endedinvestigationssupportstudentstolearnscienceideasandtodeveloparangeofskillsaswellasimproveattitudestowardsscience(seeforexampleBennettetal.,2018).Thisreportpresentsaseriesofcasestudiesfrom12teachersworkinginEngland.Eachcarriesoutopen-endedinvestigativeprojects,correspondingtotheGoodPracticalSciencebenchmark,withpost-16studentsinEngland.Fromthesetofcasestudies,intendedlearningoutcomeshavebeenextractedalongwithunderstandinghowteachershavenegotiatedthebarrierstoparticipationinsuchwork.Thecasestudiesproviderelatableexamplesofhowteacherscanprovideopportunitiesforopen-endedinvestigationsinademandingpost-16environmentandpresentwaysinwhichteachershaveovercomebarrierstoofferingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectwork.Thequestionsthatthereportanswersareasfollows:
● Howdoscienceteacherapproachestopractical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsvary?
● Whatdoteacherswantstudentstolearnbycarryingoutpractical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsinscience,andhowdotheybringthisabout?
● Howdoteachersseetheirroleinsupportingstudentstocarryoutpractical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsinscience?
● Whatenablessuccessfulpractical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectworkinschoolsorcolleges,andwhatbarriersexist?
![Page 9: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
8
MethodsEthicalapprovaltoconductthestudywasobtainedfromtherelevantdepartmentalethicscommittee;andvoluntaryinformedconsentobtainedfromparticipatingteachers.InvitationstotakepartweredistributedviaprofessionalnetworksofteachersintheUK,invitingresponsesfromanyteacherswhocarriedoutopen-endedinvestigativeworkatpost-16.Aquestionnaireandinterviewwereusedtocollectdata.Thequestionnairewascirculatedelectronically.Thisconsistedofopenandclosedquestions(seeappendix1).TheclosedresponseitemswerebasedonBucketal.(2008)andwereusedtocharacteriseprojects(Table1).Notethedefinitionofauthentic,whichreferstothecharacterisationofinquiryandnot‘authenticscience’inwhichstudentsparticipateincutting-edgescientificresearchprojects.Theopenresponseitemsaskedteacherstoidentifytheirintendedlearningoutcomesandwhatstudentsneedtoknowinordertodosuccessfulopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.Atotalof17questionnaireswerereturned.
Provided? Provided?
Provided?
Provided?
Provided?
Problem/Question yes yes yes yes no
Theory/Background yes yes yes yes no
Procedures/Design yes yes yes no no
Analysisofresults yes yes no no no
Communicationofresults yes no no no no
Conclusion yes no no no no
Characterisation Confirmation Structured Guided Open Authentic
Table1:Characterisingopen-endedinvestigativeworkQuestionnaireresponseswerescreenedandonlythoseprojectsthatwerestructured,guided,openorauthentic(n=15)wereincludedinfurtheranalysis.Thesewereprojectsinwhichatleastoneofthefollowingwerenotprovidedtostudents:theproblemorquestion,theoryandbackground,proceduresanddesign,analysis,interpretationandconclusions.Allteachersdoingconfirmationprojectswereexcludedfromthesamplepriortointerviews.Questionnaireresponseswerethenanalysedindependentlybythreeresearcherstoidentifycentralconceptsinrelationtolearningthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.Thisresultedintheidentificationofthecentralconcepts,orkeythemes,whichcapturedtheessenceofthequestionnaireresponses.Followingreflexivediscussion,fivekeyconceptswereidentified.Theseinformedthedesignoftheinterviewguide.Selectioncriteriawerethenusedtoinviteteachersforinterview.Thesewereteacherswho(i)offeredandcarriedoutopen-endedinvestigativework(structured,guided,openorauthentic)withpost-16studentsand(ii)workedinstate(non-feepaying)schoolsorcolleges.Atotalof12teachersagreedtotakepartininterviews.Theinterviewguideisfoundinappendix2.Teacherswereasked
![Page 10: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
9
abouttheirproject,howitwasorganised,howtheysupportedstudentstolearneachcentralconceptidentifiedfromtheinterviews,andhowtheydealtwithvariousbarrierstocarryingoutopen-endedinvestigativework.Theinterviewguidedrewonquestionsusedtorevealteachers’pedagogicalcontentknowledge(Loughran,Berry&Mulhall,(2012)inrelationtothekeyconceptsidentifiedfromthequestionnaires.Interviewswererecorded,transcribedandthenanalysedtoidentify(i)howscienceteacherapproachestopractical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsvary;(ii)whatteacherswantstudentstolearnbycarryingoutopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsinscience,andhowtheybringthisabout;(iii)howteachersseetheirroleinsupportingstudentstocarryoutopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsinscience;and(iv)whatenablessuccessfulprojectworkinschoolsorcolleges,andwhatbarriersexist.Thetranscriptswereusedtocreatecasestudiesforeachteacher.
Thefollowingsectionidentifiesthecharacteristicsoftheteacherswhowereinterviewedandtheschoolsandcollegesinwhichtheyteach.
![Page 11: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
10
TheteachersAtotalof12teacherswereinterviewed,fourfemaleandeightmale.Theteachersworkedacrossthesciencedisciplines(Figure1)andtaughtdifferentpost-16programmes,withALevelsbeingthemostcommon(Figure2).Allteachersinthesamplehadbeenintheprofessionforlongerthan5years,andhalfhadbeenteachingforover15years.
Figure1:Sciencespecialisms Figure2:Post-16programmetaughtAllteachersworkedinschoolsandcollegesinthestatesector.Threeteachersworkedinpost-16collegesand9teachersworkedin11-18schools.Oftheschools,threeoperatedacademicselectionpoliciesforsomeorallentrants.AllschoolsandcollegeshadagoodoroutstandingOfstedrating,withthemajority(n=7)ratedoutstanding.TeacherswereworkinginschoolsandcollegeslocatedacrossEngland(Dorset,Kent,London,NorfolkandYorkshire)inarangeofneighbourhoodtypes,fromruraltownfringestomajorurbanconurbations.Themajority(n=10)werelocatedintheleastdeprivedneighbourhoodsinEngland(i.e.abovethefifthdecile)andonlyonewaslocatedinaneighbourhoodinthemostdepriveddecile.Teachers’reasonsfordoingopen-endedprojectsfellbroadlyintotwomaincategories,withsomeoverlap:teachersinvolvingstudentsinpursuingteachers’ownscientificinterests,andteachersdoingprojectsfortheireducationalvalue,eitherasalegacyfromspecificationsthatpreviouslyrequiredopen-endedinvestigations1orbecausetheymetcurrentspecificationrequirements.Althoughnotuniversalamongstthesample,therewerecleartendenciesforteachersinthefirstcategorytoprovideopportunitiesforstudentstolearnaboutthecurrentstateofthefield,andtoofferfreedomwithinateacher-definedfield.Forone,“it’salmostbeenanecessityformetodoitandit’skeptmeintheprofessionpossiblybecauseit’sopenedmymindanditallowsmetodoscienceinadifferentway.”Similarly,thereweretendenciesamongstteachersofferingprojectsfortheireducationalvaluetoallowstudentstodecideonthedirectionoftheproject,constrainedbytechniqueorresources.Teachersinbothgroupssawthepotentialforopen-endedinvestigativeworktomeettheCommonPracticalAssessmentCriteria(CPAC).
1ThespecificationsquotedwereSaltersAdvancedChemistry,SAC(OCRB)andSaltersHornersAdvancedPhysics(Edexcel)
![Page 12: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
11
Findings
Howdoscienceteacherapproachesvary?Thefindingsarepresentedinthreeparts.Inthefirst,thecharacteristicsofopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsforthecasestudyteachersaredescribedandthekeylearningoutcomesthatteachersdesiredthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsareidentified,alongwithenablersidentifiedbyteachersinthesample.Inthesecondpart,teachercasestudiesarepresented.Thesefocusonasingleproject;manyteachershadbeeninvolvedwith,orwereinvolvedwith,multipleprojectswithstudentsindifferentyeargroups.Finally,wepresentasynthesisoftheconstraintsonteachers’capabilitiestoofferopen-endedinvestigativework,andhowthesewerenegotiated.
Howisopen-endedinvestigativeworkcharacterised?Theprojectsdescribedwereuniquetoeachteacherinthesample,andthesewereopentovaryingdegrees.Figure3summariseshowtheprojectscanbecharacterisedusingBuck,BretzandTowns’(2008)rubric(Table1).Mostteachersinthesample(n=5)wereoffering‘openinquiry’projects,inwhichtheproblemandbackgroundareprovided,buttheprocedures/design/methodologywereforthestudenttodesign,asweretheanalysisandconclusions.Fewer(n=4)offeredstudentstheopportunitytodo‘authenticinquiry’inwhichtheproblem,procedures/design,analysis,communication,andconclusionswereallforthestudenttodesign:forsomethiswasthespecificationrequirement.Aminority(n=3)offeredstructuredorguidedprojectsinwhichstudentswereprovidedwiththeproblem,procedures,and(inthecaseofstructuredprojects)analysisbywhichstudentscandiscoverrelationshipsorreachconclusionsunknowntothem.‘Authenticinquiry’projectsweretypicallyconstrainedbyavailabilityofequipmentandresourcesasstudentswereonlyabletopursuetheirowninterestswhentheyhadthemeansbywhichtocollectandanalysedata.‘Openinquiry’projectsweretypicallyconstrainedbyteachers’interestsasintheseprojectstheteacherspresentstudentswiththeproblemorbackgroundinformation.Teachersinthesamplewhoofferedopen,guidedorstructuredinvestigativeprojectsdidsoforarangeofreasons,includingmanagingstafftimeinplanningandresourcingtheprojects,scaffoldingstudents’learningbyconstrainingchoiceandprovidingasatisfyingexperienceforstudentswheretheywouldcollectsufficientdatatoanalysemeaningfullyinthetimeavailable.Allteachersinthesamplevaluedopen-endedinvestigativeprojects,eventhosewhowereobligedtocarrythemoutaspartoftheirspecification(forexample,theIBDiplomaProgrammeandBTEC).
Figure3:Characterisationofprojectsinthesample
![Page 13: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
12
Figure5:Assessmentofprojects
Figure4:Modeloforganisationwithpartners
Figure7:Optionalityofprojects
Howisopen-endedinvestigativeworkorganised?Theorganisationofopen-endedinvestigativeworkvariedacrossteachersinthesample.Someteacherswereworkinginschoolsorcollegeswhereopen-endedinvestigativeworktookplaceacrossthesciencesorinindividualsubject(i.e.Biology,ChemistryorPhysics)sections.Othersweretheonlyteachercarryingoutopen-endedinvestigativeworkatpost-16,oroneofasmallnumberofscienceteachersintheschool.Justoverone-thirdworkedinpartnershipwithexternalscientistsfromtheinceptionoftheprojectwhereasone-thirdworkedentirelyindependentlyandjustunderone-thirdsoughtadhocsupportfromoutsidetheschool(Figure4).Teachersofferedopen-endedprojectworktopost-16studentsinarangeofways.Inthreecases,projectworkwasarequirementbecausestudentswereassessed(Figure5)fortheIBDiplomaProgramme,theBTECandforaCRESTAward(thelatterofferedasatimetabledsubjectinaschoolwherestudentsarerequiredtodoeitherfourALevelsorthreeALevelsandanothertimetabledacademicactivity).Inaddition,someteachersusedopen-endedinvestigativeprojectstosupportstudentstomeettheCPAC.Mostprojectsinthesamplewereofferedintimetabledclasstime,withonlythreeexclusivelyusingextracurriculartime(Figure6).Thesethreeprojectswereofferedtoallpost-16students,butrequiredbothteachersandstudentstogiveupfreetimeatlunchorafterschoolorcollege.Teachersusedtimeoutsidetimetabledlessonswhentheprojectrequiredscarceequipment,equipmentthatrequiredspecialisttrainingtouse,whereexternalcollaboratorswereinvolved,ortheywantedtotestanapproachtolateruseinlessons.Someteachersrequiredstudentstocarryoutanopen-endedinvestigativeprojecteitherbecauseitwaspartofthespecificationortheirtimetabledrequirements(Figure7)orbecauseitwasdoneintimetabledlessons,eitherforallorforasubsetofstudentsinthelesson.Evenprojectsthatstudentswererequiredtodooftenincludedworkthattookplaceoutsideusualscheduledlessons,e.g.as‘collapsed’daysinthesummerterm.
Figure6:Schedulingofprojects
![Page 14: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
13
Learningthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsInordertofocusinterviewsonthehow,whyandwhatoflearning,questionnaireresponseswereanalysedtoidentifyasmallnumberof‘bigthemes’associatedwithlearningthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.ThesearepresentedinTable2,alongwiththecontributingdescriptionfoundinteachers’questionnaireresponses.
Centrallearningoutcomeor‘bigidea’
Description
‘Real’science
Thisideareferstothesensethatopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsgivestudentsthechancetofindoutabout‘real’science,orworkmoresimilartothethingsscientistsdo.
Datahandling
Thisideareferstoseveralaspectsofdatahandlingthatareimportantforstudentstolearnaboutincludingevaluationofdataandclaimsbyothers,decisionsaboutdatacollection(includinghowdecisionsaremadeaboutthesuitabilityandadequacyofdata),dataanalysis,interpretationanddatapresentation(forexamplestatisticsandgraphs).
Researchdesign Thisreferstothedecisionsstudentsmakeaboutthemethodstheywillusetocarryoutaprojectthatanswersaresearchquestion.Thisincludesdecisionsaboutexperimentaldesign,themethodsofdatacollectionandanalysis,equipment,safetyandethics.
Stateofthefield Thisidearelatestolearningabouthowknowledgeiscreatedinthediscipline,includinghowtosearch,andreviewtheresearchliteratureandunderstandhowtheirworkcontributestounderstandingthestateofthefield.
Iteration Thisreferstotherepetitiveandrecursive(ratherthanlinear)processlinkingdatacollectionandanalysisduringwhichstudentsmightnoticeunexpectedresults,testprocedures,gainexperienceoftrialanderror,ormakeamendmentstotheirmethods.
Table2:‘Bigthemes’thatteachersintendstudentstolearnthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.Inadditiontoidentifyingcentrallearningoutcomesspecifictoinvestigativework,someteachersusedprojectworkasacontextinwhichstudentscouldapplypreviouslylearntsubjectknowledge,practicaltechniquesormathematicsandstatistics.Therewasanappetiteforthinkingabouthowtobuildprogressioninunderstandingthese‘bigthemes’butteachersfeltthattherewaslittleopportunitytocarryoutinvestigativeworkatKeyStage4.Otherperceivedoutcomesofopen-endedinvestigationsforstudentsreportedbyteachersincludedresilience,confidence,motivation,organisation,independence,presentationandcommunicationskills,timeandprojectmanagement,leadership,problem-solving,improvedattainment,andawarenessofcareersinscience.
![Page 15: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
14
Enablersofopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsinthecurriculumArangeofenablersofopen-endedprojectworkwereidentifiedbyteachersduringinterviews,andthesearepresentedbelowinspheresofinfluence,startingwiththeteacher,workingouttothesciencedepartment,schoolseniorleadershiptolocalscientistsandfinallynationalpolicy.Scienceteachers’priorexperienceswereanimportantenablerofopen-endedinvestigativework.Somediscussedtheirownundergraduate,postgraduateorindustrialresearchexperience,andothersdrewontheirexperienceofteachingopen-endedinvestigativeworkthroughpreviousversionsofspecifications,mostnotablyOCRSalters’ALevel.Aswellasexperience,freedomtodecidewhattoteachandwhenwasidentifiedasenablingteacherstoplanandconductopen-endedinvestigativeworkwithstudents.Inthesciencedepartment,headsofdepartmentenabledopen-endedinvestigativeworkbyensuringtimetabling,roomallocationandstaffingforthiswork.Theavailabilityofskilledtechnicianswasalsoimportantinsupportingteacherswithfinding,testingandrefiningprocedures,carryingoutandsharingriskassessments,andmaintainingequipment,consumablesandlivingorganisms.Insomecases,techniciansplayedaroleintrainingstudentsinprocedures.Beyondthesciencedepartment,schoolleadersenabledprojectworkbyselectingapost-16curriculumthatvaluesopen-endedinvestigativeworkandallocatingstafftimeandspacetothis,includingtimeforplanning.Projectworkwasalsoenabledwhereschoolandcollegelibrarieswerewell-resourcedandstaffedbylibrarianswhocouldhelpwithliteraturesearchstrategies.Theyalsoenabledprojectworkwherepoliciessupportedteacherstoofferopen-endedprojectswithinorbeyondthecurriculum,andwheresingle-disciplineteachingwasprioritised.Delegationofdecision-makingtodepartmentsoverbudgetspendandwhenteaching‘year13content’startedwasalsoimportantinenablingscienceteacherstocarryoutopen-endedinvestigativework.Thescientificcommunityenabledprojectworkinschools.Thiscameintheformofaccesstoscientificsupport,forexampleinansweringteachers’questions,teacherprofessionaldevelopment,directworkwithstudentsand/orteacherstoplanandcarryoutprojectwork,andtheavailabilityofhands-onsupporte.g.inchemicalanalysis.Grantfunding(particularlywhenitinvolvedteacherbuy-out)alsoenabledteacherstocarryoutinvestigativework.Finally,theassessmentpolicycontexthadaroletoplayinenablingopen-endedinvestigativework.TeachersinthesamplewereconcernedthatpreviousiterationsofinvestigativeworkinGCSEspecificationshadresultedinaformulaicapproach.Theabsenceofinvestigativeworkinspecificationswasalsoseenasproblematic.Whereprojectworkwaswellintegratedintotimetabledlessonsatpost-16,teacherswerefollowingspecificationsthatrequiredthis(theIBDiplomaProgramme;BTEC),wereusingalternativeawardschemes(CREST)orwereusingopen-endedinvestigationstodemonstratethatastudenthadmettheCPAC.TeachersfeltthattheCPACofferedtheopportunityforcreativityintheassessmentofpracticalworkandmultipleopportunitiesallowedteacherstoplanforprogression,movingfromverystructuredpracticalworktoopen-endedinvestigativework.
![Page 16: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
15
CasestudiesThefollowingsectionpresentscasestudiesfromthetwelveteacherstodemonstratetherangeofopen-endedprojectsundertakenbyteachers.
![Page 17: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
16
BTECAppliedScienceinvestigativeproject
AlisonAckroydBTECSciencetutor,specialismBiologicalSciencesMidKentCollege
ProjectdescriptionPartoftheBTECAppliedSciencecurriculum.Allstudentschoosetopicsfromthethreemainsciencesubjects,withinreason,dependingonstaffavailabilityforsupervision.Thesemightinvolveapplyingpreviouslylearntproceduressuchastitrationsandaseptictechniques,orusingspecialistequipmentincollege,forexampleusingHPLC(highperformanceliquidchromatography)toanalysecaffeineindrinks.Theprojectsareinternallyassessedandthenexternallyverified.Projectworkiscarriedoutincurriculumtime,butstudentscanuseafreelabifamemberofstaffisavailabletosupervise.
Whoparticipates?AllBTECAppliedScienceLevel3students,intheirsecondyear,aspartoftheirstatutoryassignments.IntendedlearningoutcomesAlisonwantsstudentstolearntosynthesisetheory,toplanprojects,toberesilientanddevelopemployabilityskillsaswellasgainingabroaderperspectiveonscience.Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectAlisonseesherroleprimarilyastimekeeperandhealthandsafetymanager.Sheteachesaboutacademicintegrity(referencingandplagiarism)inpreparationforprojectwork.Shealsoprovideschecksandbalancestoensurestudentsremainfocusedontheirquestion.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsLookatwhattheprofessionalsocietiesprovide.AlsoinvestigateMOOCs,sciencelearningpartnerships,Twitter,STEMlearningandTeachMeets.
AboutthecollegeMidKentCollegeisoneofthelargestfurthereducationandtrainingprovidersintheSouthEastforpost-16students,offeringBTECScience.Teachersgenerallyteachwithintheirspecialism.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsConfidenceinthelab,whichAlisonseesasexcellentpreparationforfurtherworkandstudy,aswellasimprovedorganisation,resourcefulnessandcommunication.SchoolsupportThebiologytechnicianplaysanimportantroleinfinding,testingandadaptingappropriateprotocolstoensuretheywork.Alisonhasasupportiveseniorleadershipteaminthattheyhavededicatedtime(inthetimetable),equipmentandhumanresourcestothedevelopmentofnewtopicareas.Theprojectsalsohavededicatedlabspacewithanearbytechnicianandpreproom.
“TechniciansIthinkarekey,ifyoudon’tknowhowtodosomething,oftentherewillbesomebodytherethathasdoneitallbefore,andhaslookedtoseewhatyouhavegotinhouse”
![Page 18: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
17
CPAC&CRESTAwardsAbaAdebanjo,Chemistryteacher,CRESTAwardlead,CareersCoordinator(STEM)WestminsterCitySchool
ProjectdescriptionAbaprovidesstudentswithopportunitiestodoopen-endedinvestigativeworkthroughoutthesixthform(years12and13)incurriculumtime,andhasalsostartedtoworkwithImperialCollegeonofferingtheCRESTAwardforstudentsinyear12,whichtheycarryoutinanunoccupiedlabintheirfreeperiods.Fortheprojectscarriedoutincurriculumtime,Abamadeaconsciousdecisiontochangethewayshewasteachingrequiredpracticalstointroduceopen-endedness,andplanforprogressioninproblemsolvinganddecision-making.
Whoparticipates?Abamakestherequiredpracticalsopen-endedforallAlevelstudents.SheoffersadditionalCRESTAwardstoallyear12students,with30outof40applyingtotakepart.IntendedlearningoutcomesAbawantsstudentstolearnthejoyofdiscoveryinscience,developproblemsolvingandanalyticalskills,tolinktheorytoexperimentalworkandtounderstandhowtotestahypothesis.Studentshavecarriedoutopen-endedworkonreactionratesandtheidentificationofioniccompounds.SchoolsupportTechnicalsupport-thestudentscanspeaktothetechnicianstorequestanyequipmentfortheirprojectwork.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojects
● Teachthetheoryfirstsostudentsunderstand.
● Discusstheusesofequipment.● Makeconnectionswithpriorlearning.
AbouttheschoolWestminsterCitySchoolisacomprehensiveacademy,educatingboysbetweenages11and16,andgirlsandboysaged16-18.StudentsareofferedA-levelspost-16,andteachersteachwithinsubjectspecialism.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsStudentslearnhowscientistsworkandabouttheimportanceofproblem-solving-it“getsstudentstothinkdifferently”.Abaisalsoconvincedthatithelpsthestudentstorediscoverthejoysofscience,whichshethinkscanbelostthroughtheformulaicnatureoftheGCSEsyllabus.Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectAbatriestoscaffoldstudents’learning,forexamplebyofferingachoiceofequipmentandhelpingstudentstoworkoutwhichisappropriateforthetask.Byyear13,shetriestogettothepointwherestudentscanbegivenaproblemandareabletoapplytheory,designaninvestigationandselectappropriateequipment.ForCREST,sheencouragesstudentstoworkinmixedsciencegroups.Laboratoriesarenotfullytimetabledsostudentscan-andareexpectedto-accesstheseinfreeperiods.
“Ithinkithelpsbetterifstudentshaveitopen-ended,thentheyarenotjustfollowingitlikearecipetobakeacake,buttheyareactuallyunderstandingwhytheyareapplyingcertainpartsinthemethod...studentswillappreciateit”
![Page 19: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
18
FlyLabDrMariaCourel,HeadofBiologyTheJuddSchool,Tonbridge,Kent
ProjectdescriptionOpenendedinvestigativeprojectworkisofferedaspartofFlyLab,ageneticsprojectinvolvingexperimentswithfruitflies.Year12and13studentsareinvitedtotakepartintheirsparetime.Itisinitsinfancy.Studentsareabletopursuetheirowninterests:theydecidetheproblemorquestion,thetheoryorbackground,thedesignandprocedures,methodsofanalysisandcommunicationofresults,andtheirconclusions.Mariasupervisesprojectsinherlab(openeverydayafterschoolforanhour)andhascreatedaGoogleclassroomtosupporttheproject.
Whoparticipates?Theprojectisofferedtostudentsinyears12and13.Therearecurrentlyabout40studentsinvolved.Mariathinksitis“goodforthestudentstogetexperienceofwhatscienceisactuallylikebefore,orwhilethey’remakingchoices.”
AbouttheschoolTheJuddSchoolisavoluntaryaidedstategrammarschoolforboysaged11-16,andgirlsandboysinthesixthform.Scienceistaughtwithinteachers’specialisms.TheschooloffersAlevelsandtheEPQ.
IntendedlearningoutcomesMariawouldlikestudentstolearnhowtoconductaninvestigationfromstarttofinish:planning,collectionofdataandanalysisofresults.Shewantsstudentsto“appreciatethechallengesandrewardsofcarryingouttheirownindependentresearch.”
PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsFlyLabisinitsearlydays.Mariaexpectsstudentsto“becomemoreconfidentininterpretingdata,identifyingvariables,andappreciatingwhyit’simportantthattheydoitinacontrolledmanner.”
Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectMariaseesherroleassupportingstudentstobecomeindependent.Sheorganisesinputfromexternalexperts,e.g.academicresearcherDrCamillaLarssenfromtheCentreforDevelopmentalNeurobiologyatKing’sCollege,London,andtrainingsessionsonthetheoreticalbackground.Mariaprovidespracticaltrainingonhowtohandleandanalysefruitflies.Shehelpsstudentstodiscussinterestingquestionstopursue,andisthenhands-off,takingherleadfromthestudents.
SchoolsupportMariaworksquiteindependentlyonFlyLabintheschoolcontext.Theprojectisconstrainedbyaccesstolaboratoryequipmentandtechniciantime,andthetypeofinvestigationthestudentscandoisprescribedbyequipmentandresourcesavailableinschool.Healthandsafetyrequirementsinrelationtomaterialsmeansthatitisonlypossibletoworkwithsmallnumbersatatime.
Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojects
● Don’texpectittobeperfectwhenyoustart-youwilllearnalotthefirsttime.
● Findsomeonewithscientificexpertisetoadviseyou.
“Ihopestudentswillappreciatethechallengesandrewardsofcarryingouttheirownindependentresearchwhichmightinvolvetroubleshooting,unexpectedresults,resultsthatopennewareastoinvestigate.”
![Page 20: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
19
CRESTGoldAwardinsteadofafourthALevel
MartinHampshirePhysicsteacherBournemouthSchool
ProjectdescriptionOpen-endedinvestigativeworkisbuiltintothetimetable,justasanAlevelsciencemightbe.StudentswhoelecttodoCRESTGoldinadditiontotheirthreeA-levelschoosetheirownproject,followingtheirowninterest,e.g.changesinheartrateduetoexercise.Studentshaveindividualsessions,15minutesperfortnight,duringwhichtheygetpersonalisedsupport.
Whoparticipates?StudentswhotakethreeA-levelshavetochooseanothercoursetofulfiltheschool’srequirementforpost-16studymatchingtheequivalentof3.5A-levels.CRESTGold(startinginYear12)isoneoption.
AbouttheschoolBournemouthSchoolisaselectiveacademyforboysaged11-16,andgirlsandboysaged16-18.StudentsareencouragedtostudyfourALevels,orthreeAlevelswithaCRESTGoldAward,oranadditionalmathematicsorPre-Uhumanitiescourse.
IntendedlearningoutcomesMartinwantsstudentstoseewhatrealscienceisandtolearnthatscienceisaccessibletoeverybody.Healsowantsstudentstogaintheabilitytoevaluatedataandclaims,tocommunicateideasandtoberesilientwheninitialmethodsfail.
PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsMartinbelievesthattheprojectsleadtoimprovedmotivationandattainment,abettersenseofwhatitmeanstodoscience,andgreaterinterestindoingsomethingtechnicalorscientificinthelongerterm.Hehasalsoseenstudentsdevelopasenseofprideintheirinvestigativeprojectwork.
Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectMartinseeshimselfinareactiverole,helpingstudentstoformulaterealisticresearchquestions,tosearchliteratureonlineandrespondwhenstudentscomeupagainstproblems.Heencouragesstudentstokeepalabbook.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsDon’tunderestimatethetimeandresourceneededtoofferfree-reinonthefocusofopen-endedprojects-studentsmakemistakes,reachdeadendsandwillneedtostartagain.
Schoolsupport● SchoolleaderssupportandvalueCREST.● Technicians’expertise,timeandenthusiasm
forprojects.● Theschoollibrarianteachesadvanced
literaturesearchingusingdatabases.● Space-asmalllabhasbeenallocatedto
projectworkandstoringassociatedequipment.
“forusit’sthatsecondstringandforthemjustmakingthemrealisethatit’snotthatthey’vedonetheexperimentbadlyandit’snottheirfaultorwhateverelsebutthatiswhatthenatureofscientificdataisandbeingabletohandlethatandcopewithit.”
![Page 21: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
20
NorthernhubfortheInstituteforResearchInSchools
NickHarrisBiologyteacher(alsoworkingwithotherlocalprimaryandsecondaryschools)
ProjectdescriptionNickisresponsiblefortheNorthernhubforIRIS.Post-16studentsareofferedtheopportunitytoparticipateinopen-endedinvestigationsbydoingarealscienceresearchproject(currentlyaboutMotorNeuroneDiseasestudiedinyeast).Regularmeetingsareonehouraweek,outsideschooltime,withpracticalactivitiesrunwhenevertheteacher,technicianandstudentscangettogetherduringtheschoolday.StudentsasktheirownquestionsofdataandparticipateinpracticalstepswithNickduringfreeperiods.
Whoparticipates?AnyA-levelstudentcanparticipate.IntendedlearningoutcomesAlthoughindividualstudentsmaynotbeabletoparticipateateverylevelofthepracticalaspectsoftheproject,Nickwantsstudentstolearnwhatitistobeimmersedinarealresearchexperience,undersupervision.Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectNickspendsmuchoftheprojecttimeondiscussingtheprojectanditsprocesseswiththestudents,andengagingthemwiththedesignoftheexperiments.Hetriestolimitittowhatthestudentsreallyneedtoknowtobeabletoparticipate.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsJustdoit-ifyouwanttocreateaculture,seminarandjournalclubsarequiteeasytosetupandthereareperksfortheteacherintheformofinvolvementwithexcitingnewscience,whichcanhelpincontinuingtofeelpartofthescientificcommunityandtofeelinspiredtocontinueteaching.
AbouttheschoolTaptonSchoolisacomprehensiveco-educationalschoolforstudentsaged11-18,offeringALevels.Teachersteachwithinsubjectspecialism.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsNickbelievesthatopen-endedinvestigationshelpstudentstoapplytheirAlevelbiologyknowledgeandtoexpandstudents’horizons.Henotesthatstudentsask“lotsofquestionsaboutwhatcoulditbeandthatwasencouragingsotheyareawareofhavingtothink.”Healsobelievesthatitinfluencestheircareerdecisions.SchoolsupportThereisaperceptionthattheschoolleadershipvaluesresearch,includingintheappointmentofnewteachers.Nickbenefitsfromtechnicalsupportwhenhecarriesoutthepracticalwork.Othersupportingstructuresincludearesearchseminarseriesandjournalclub.
“Theotherteachersintheroomarejustfallingovergoinghowcanyoudothat?Howdoyouhavetime?AndI’mlike,well,ifyouteachthemstuffthat’sbeyondthespecanditreallygivesthemadeeperunderstandingthenactuallythey’vegotatextbook,theydon’treallyneedmetotellthemwhat’sinthattextbookbecausetheycanreaditthemselves.”
![Page 22: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
21
AntibioticsunlimitedColinInglisBiologyteacherandSTEMcoordinatorBoroughbridgeHighSchool
ProjectdescriptionStudentsfollowtheirowninterests,almostwithoutlimits.Manyprojectsarebasedaroundfindingalternativesforantibiotics,becauseoftheissueofantibioticresistantbacteria.Startingpointishomework,askingrelativesaboutalternativestheyhaveheardabout,orremediestheywouldrecommend.Projectsrunafterschool,onehouraweek.Someprojectsrunformanyyears,drivenbythestudentsastheymoveuptheschool.Projectsarewrittenupandtakentoconferences,notlimitedtostudentconferences,and/orenteredforCRESTSilverAward.
Whoparticipates?Anystudentwhoisinterestedcantakepart,andtheycanworkontheirprojectovermultipleyears.IntendedlearningoutcomesPreparingforafutureinafastchangingpresent,Colinfeels“theydon’tneedtobetaughtknowledge,theyneedtobetaughtthinkingskillsandproblemsolvingskillsandcreativityandtonotbelimitedbythebookandwhateverelse”.Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectBecauseColindoesnotwanttolimitthestudentsinanyway,heoftenfindshimselfoutofhisdepthwiththescienceinitially.Heusesallhisteachingexperienceandpedagogicalknowledgebutallowsstudentstogowheretheprojecttakesthem.
AbouttheschoolBoroughbridgeHighschoolisacommunitycomprehensiveschool,co-educationalforstudentsaged11-18.StudentshaveprovisiontostudyallSciencestoALevelthroughapartnershipwithKingJames'sSchool.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsAsenseof“researchculture”,and“whentheygotouniversitythey’remoreconfident”.SchoolsupportTechniciansandSMTneededsomepersuadingofthemeritoftheprojectandthetimecommitmentbutwerewonoverbyevidenceofthevalueforthestudents,aswellasColin’sacquisitionoftime-savingequipment.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsTakingSTEMthroughthelookingglass(https://www.ase.org.uk/system/files/SSR%20September%202017%20017-024%20Inglis.pdf)
“youseethemwhentheyarriveataconferenceandbytheendoftheconferencethey’reaboutsixfoottallerandthey’vegotallthecommunicationskillsandtheconfidence,they’vegotthevocabulary,andthey’rethencommunicatingtheirscienceandtheyarethescientistsforthemoment…givesthemsomethingtotalkaboutwhentheygotointerviewsandapplyforcollegesanduniversities”
![Page 23: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
22
IBInternalAssessmentPaulMcDaidHeadofScienceTonbridgeGrammarSchool
ProjectdescriptionOpenendedinvestigativeprojectworkiscarriedoutaspartoftheIBDiplomaProgrammeinwhichstudentsarerequiredtocompleteinternalassessment.Thisisbasedononescientificinvestigationlastingapproximately10hours,whichtheschoolschedulesinadayoff-timetablefollowingyear12exams.Lunchtimeandafter-schoolsessionsareofferedtohelpcompletelaboratorywork.Studentsareabletopursuetheirowninterests.ProjectshaveincludedaninvestigationintothedifferenceinwaterhardnessacrosstheUK(thestudentreceivedpostalwatersamplesfromrelativesacrossthecountry)andthecreationoflab-basedmodelofoceanacidificationbyinvestigatingtheimpactofpHonrateofdecompositionofcalciumcarbonate.
Whoparticipates?Almostallsixthformstudents.TheinternalassessmentformostoftheIBDPgroup4subjectsisanopen-endedinvestigativeprojectworth20%oftheirmarkforthesubject.IntendedlearningoutcomesPaulwouldlikehisstudentstolearn“howtoconductpracticalworkusingmanualdexterity”.Healsowantsthemtogain“planningandorganisingskills,abilitytomanipulatedata,reachconclusionsandevaluateprocesses.”Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectPaulseeshisroleassupportingstudentstopursuetheirowninterestsbutatthesametimeensuringthattheprojecttheydesignisfeasible.Paulgivesstudentsthechancetopractiseresearchdesignanddatahandling,andgivesfeedbackonearlyplans.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojects
● Allowstudentstheopportunitytocomeupwiththeirownideas.
● Providestudentswithalistof‘triedandtested’practicalsandencouragethemtomanipulatethevariables.
AbouttheschoolTonbridgeGrammarSchoolisaselectivegrammarschoolwithacademystatus,educatinggirlsaged11-16,andgirlsandboysinthesixthform.Teachersteachwithintheirspecialism.TheIBistaughtexclusivelyatsixthform.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsAccordingtoPaul,themainoutcomesarethatstudentscan“thinkindependently,theyhavetheabilitytoapproachaproblemandfindawaythroughittoseewhetheritactuallyworks.”SchoolsupportPaulidentifiedarangeofsupportthattheschoolprovides,mostnotablyprovidingextendedtimetabledtimeinthesummertermforinvestigativework.“Ithinkthere’llbeaknock-oneffecttoresearchersinthefuture.Yes,notallofourschoolchildrenaregoingtobescientists,butforthatpercentagethatareIthinkit’simportantthatwegivethemanopportunitytodeveloptheirhandlingskills,todeveloptheirskills,butalsotounderstandwhatthey’redoing,andwhy.”
![Page 24: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
23
SummerwithwoodliceSimonMooreBiologyTeacherWymondhamHighSchool
ProjectdescriptionOpen-endedinvestigativeprojectworkonwoodlousebehaviouriscarriedoutinsummertermattheendofYear12.Studentsspendapproximatelysixweeks(15-18lessons)conductinganinvestigationintowoodlousetaxisandkinesis.Simonintroducedtheprojectsbecausehebelievedthatstudentsweremissingimportantlearningopportunitiesfollowingthemoveawayfrominvestigativeworkinexaminationspecifications.Studentsinvestigatethesamesubjectarea,butaskdifferentresearchquestionsanddesigningprojectsindifferentways.
Whoparticipates?AllALevelBiologystudentsIntendedlearningoutcomesSimonwantsstudentstolearnthevalueofownershipofaresearchquestion,andtoappreciatethechallengeswithdoingresearch.Hethinksitisimportantforstudentstolearntheneedforalargevolumeofdata,howtocontrolvariables,andhowtousestatistics.Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectSimonsetstheprojectupbyintroducingsometheoreticalbackgroundtothebehaviourofwoodlice.Heprovidesstudentswithmethodsandanalyticaltechniques,butstudentsarenotprovidedwiththequestionorproblemtheywillinvestigate,althoughtheycanuseexamplesofinvestigationsfrompreviousyearsasinspiration.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsSimonencouragesinterestedteacherstofindatopicthatintereststhemandjustgetstarted.
AboutthecollegeWymondhamHighSchoolisan11-18co-educationalacademyinNorfolkwithapproximately1600studentsonroll.Post-16,WymondhamHighoffersALevels.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsSimonbelievesthattheprojectsenablestudentstounderstandhowtoaskagoodresearchquestion,i.e.tounderstandthescientificcontextandfindoutwhatisalreadyknown.Simon’sstudentslearnhowtomakedecisionsaboutexperimentaldesign.Simonfeelstheprojectsallowstudentstogettogripswithscientificreferencing,andtolearntherelativevalueofinternetreferencesandreferencesfrombooks.SchoolsupportTheschoolofferstechnicalsupportfortheproject(technicianslookafterthewoodlice).Post-16resultsaregood,studentsenjoytheinvestigationsandtheyareperceivedtobeagooduseoftime,whichreleasesthepressuretostartteachingtheyear13courseafteryear12exams.“Idoitbecauseit’stheonlyopportunitythattheygettodoanyrealscience:totakeaproblem,findoutaboutitandthencomeupwithananswer.Whatmattersistheygiveitagoandit’sarealquestionthatnobodyknowstheanswerto.”
![Page 25: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
24
Redoxtitrations,Salters’styleLisaNivenChemistryteacherAllSaintsRomanCatholicSchool
ProjectdescriptionRedoxtitrationsinvolvingiron.Open-ended,butlimitedstudentchoice-teachersetscontext,studentsworkingroupsandareassignedafoodgroup,afterwhichtheychoosetheirownspecificfoodtoinvestigateindividually.Bake-Offstyleinformation/recipeprovidedtostudents,includingbalancedequation(s)forstoichiometry.Curriculumtime,fortwotothreeweeks,allocatedjustbeforethesummerholidayinyear12.Studentsmayspendadditionaltimeinthelabduringfreeperiods,lunchandafterschool,dependingonlabspaceandsupervisionavailability.
Whoparticipates?AllAlevelChemists,eveniftheydonotpursuethefullAlevel;someofthosedropoutduetoASresultsandtheirfutureplans.
AbouttheschoolAllSaintsRomanCatholicSchoolisacomprehensiveschool,co-educationalforstudentsaged11-18.
IntendedlearningoutcomesLisawantsstudentsto“learntoberesourceful”,andtogetagoodtasteofcollaboration,talkingthroughproblems,andintheprocessofwritingaboutexperimentalwork.Thereshouldbeopportunitiestolearnfrommistakes,andtogainanunderstandingthatthatisacommonandusefultraitinscientists.
PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsBuildacommunityofA-levelstudents,fromwhatweredisparateandseparateclasses.Studentsbuildconfidence,become“morewillingtoaskquestions”.Potentialforpositiveimpactonthestudents’CPACendorsementandthesubstanceofaUCASreference.Openssomestudents’eyestootheroptionsoutthere(e.g.dieticianratherthanscientistordoctor).
Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectFacilitator,withminorscaffolding,sometimesreferringtostudents’labbooksofearlierwork.Signingoffplans,includingriskassessments.Guidanceprovidedonthekindsofquestionsthatneedtobeansweredinareport,butencouragingpeerdiscussionaboutallaspects.
SchoolsupportHeadtechnicianoutlineshealthandsafetyexpectationsatstart,showspossibleequipment,supportswithrestockingsupplyofchemicals.Asupportivedepartment,willingtomovearound,allowsforonelabdedicatedtotheprojects,aslongasitcanbesupervisedbyachemistanddoesnotoverruncapacity(“oneout,oneinpolicy”).
Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsProbablyunwisetotrybeforethesummerterminyear12,asyouneedtoknowyourstudentsfairlywell.Itwouldmakesensetohaveanexample,sayfromSaltersorNuffield,andexpandthat.“Don'treinventthewheel.”
“Don'tbeafraidtotryit.Ithinkthatwouldbethebigthing,isthatit'sveryscarytotrysomethingasbigasthis,particularlyifyou'veneverdoneitbeforeandyoudon'thavesomebodytosupportyou.ButthegainsfaroutweightherisksIthink.”
![Page 26: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
25
AlegacyofAdvancingPhysicsbeforethelinearexams
SimonPoliakoff,HeadofPhysicsandSpecialistLeaderinEducationDameAliceOwen’sSchool
ProjectdescriptionFollowingthelossofcourseworkfromtheAlevelspecification,thePhysicsdepartmentdecidedtoreintroduceopen-endedprojectsduringtheweeksbeforethesummerholidaysattheendofyear12.Studentschosefromaroundadozenprojectsonwhichtobasetheirowninvestigations,fromnewcontextsforunderstandingsimpleharmonicmotiontotheHalleffect.Theyworkindividuallyorasapair.Studentshaveanhourlongintroductorysession,fivehoursofpracticalworksupplementedbyhomeworkthentwohourstocreateaconference-styleposter.
Whoparticipates?AllA-levelphysicistsparticipate.Theschool’sbiologyandchemistrydepartmentsdonothavealegacyofopen-endedcourseworkaspartoftheirearlierspecification,anddonotcurrentlyoffersimilarprojectswithbiologyorchemistrystudents.
AbouttheschoolDameAliceOwen'sSchoolisapartiallyselectivemixedacademysupportedbyTheWorshipfulCompanyofBrewersoftheCityofLondon.ThesixthformcurriculumcomprisessolelyofAlevelsandteachersteachwithinspecialism.
IntendedlearningoutcomesSimonintendsstudentstolearnhowtomanagetheirtimeovermultiplepracticalsessions,howtoprogressaninvestigationbeyondaninitialplan,howtochoosesuitablegraphstoplotandtestrelationshipsandhowtopresentaconference-styleposter.
PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsExamplesofoutcomescorrespondedwithwhatstudentsneededtosucceedatAlevel,butmorebesides.Simonfeltthatstudentsgainedexperienceinmakingdecisionsabouttheirprojectandmanagingtheirtimeoveralongerproject.
Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectSimonstartsstudentsoffwithaquestionandsomesuggestedreferences.Heseeshisroleasaguidethroughtheproblemsthatmightcropup,eitherfromasub-optimaldesignorfromsub-optimalresults.SimonsharespossibleprojectsviaGoogledrive,readsplansinadvance,speakstostudents,providestrainingwhereneeded,troubleshootsandteachesrelatedpracticalssothatstudentscanplantheirownmethodforarelatedquestion.
SchoolsupportAllphysicsteachersareinvolvedwiththeopen-endedprojects,workingtogethertopreparetheprojectsandsupervisestudentswithsupportfromagoodspecialisttechnician.RemovalofASexamshasprovidedatimeforstudentstodotheirinvestigationsandfreedomfromhavingtodoinvestigationsascourseworkhasenabledteacherstosupportawiderrangeofprojects,andgivenmorescopeforstudentstoiterateandgreaterflexibilityinhowfindingsarepresented.
Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsItiseasiertostartbyhavingalistof10-12suggestedtitlesandreferences,becausestudentsoftenstagnatewhengivenacompletelyopenchoice.
“It'snownolongeracoursework,thoughwewereusingitasfurtherevidenceoffeedbackcriteriaastheinvestigativeskillsasthepracticalendorsement.”
![Page 27: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
26
Plantingideasinplantbiologyandpsychology
RichardSpencerHeadofScienceMiddlesbroughCollege
ProjectdescriptionRicharddoesdifferentprojectseachyear,dependingonhisinterestsandopportunitiesavailableatthattime.TheprojectthatranthisyearwaslinkedtoavisittoDilstonPhysicGardenwiththeRoyalSocietyofBiologyandtheSAPSplantsummerschool.Ittookplaceforanhouraweekoveraperiodofabout4months,inparallelwithfieldworkplanning.Studentsweregivenexperienceofexperimentaldesignandopen-endedinvestigativeworkinthecontextofherbalteas,oilsortincturesandtheninvestigatedtheeffectofherbalessentialoilsonmemory.RicharddesignedtheprojectincollaborationwithDrNicolettePerry,apharmacognosistanddirectoratDilstonPhysicGarden,followingadiscussionaboutmemoryandplantessentialoils.
Whoparticipates?Alevelbiologystudents.IntendedlearningoutcomesRichardwantshisstudentstolearnabout“realscienceandtoexperiencehowresearchraisesfurtherquestions,howtodesignaresearchprojectthatisfeasibleandhowtoprocessdata”.Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectRichardsaysthat“firstandforemostyouhavetobeenthusiasticaboutityourself.”Todothat,Richardfeelstheneedtohavegoodbackgroundknowledgehimself.Richardpresentsstudentswithabriefandarelatedresearchstudy,andthenstudentsdecideontheirquestion,methodandallthatfollows.Richardshareshisexperienceinresearchsciencewithstudents,empathisingwhentheyexperienceproblems.Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojects
● “Taketheriskandtheresultswillspeakforthemselves.”
● Useopen-endedprojectstodevelopCPACrelatedskills.
● Workinpartnershipsothatyouhavesomebodytohelpwiththedevelopmentandshareideas.
AboutthecollegeMiddlesbroughCollegeisalargefurthereducationcollegeforstudentsagedover16.Thereare14,000studentsonroll.Awiderangeofpost-16sciencecoursesareoffered,includingAlevels,vocationalcoursesandapprenticeships.Richardteacheswithinthesixthformdirectorate.PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsRichardidentifiedarangeofgainsforstudentsincludingdevelopinganinterestinandenthusiasmforscience(particularlyplants),tounderstandinghowresearchworksandmakingAlevelcontentmoremeaningful.Richardalsoidentifiedmoreinstrumentalgains,includingdistinctiveexperiencesthatcanbeusedinUCASapplications.SchoolsupportRicharddoesnothaveprotectedtimeforcarryingoutprojects:hesqueezesprojectsintohissparetimeandclasstime.Techniciansprovidesupportindesigningnewapproachestopracticalworkandadviceonhealthandsafety.“Tobeagreatteacheryouhavetobeagreatlearnerandyourstudentsneedtoseethatyou’relearning…that’soneofthemostimportantthingsaboutinvestigativework.You’renotjustdoinganexperiment:you’reexploring;you’refindingouttogetherandyoudon’tknowwhattheresultswillshow.”
![Page 28: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
27
RealWorldChemistryStuartStrathdeeGreenheadCollegeHuddersfield
ProjectdescriptionOpenendedinvestigativeprojectworkisofferedthroughRealWorldChemistry,anenrichmentprojectopentoallyear12and13students.StudentsranktheirpreferredprojectsfollowingshortpresentationsfromtheUniversityofHuddersfield’sSchoolofAppliedSciences.Stuartthenmatchesupstudents’interestswitharesearchgroup,payingattentiontomakingsureeachgrouphasstudentsindifferentyeargroupswithdifferentstrengths.Studentsworktogetherwiththeuniversitystafftoreviewresearchandsomecarryoutdatacollectionintheirareaofinterest.Theseincludedprojectsoncarboncaptureandindustrialprocessesandsafety.Projectstypicallyinvolvestudentsworkingacrossdisciplines,forexampleaprojectonsolarcellsinvolvedapplyingknowledgeofelectronics,organicchemistry,andpolymers.
Whoparticipates?Sixthformstudentsinyears12and13workingroups.In2017/18,28studentsparticipated.Ofthese,24arenowstudyingforSTEMrelateddegrees.UsingALPS,thesestudentsmadeoutstandingprogress(highgrade2).
AboutthecollegeGreenheadCollegeisasixthformcollegeeducatingyoungpeopleaged16-18,primarilyofferingAlevelaswellastheExtendedProjectQualification.Therearecurrentlyabout880studentsstudyingAlevelchemistry.
IntendedlearningoutcomesStuartwantsstudentstolearnresearch,analytical,presentationandteam-workingskills,aswellastogainanappreciationofinterdisciplinarityandofchemistryintheworld,inrelationtothepolitical,economic,social,technological,legalandenvironmentalcontext.
PerceivedoutcomesforstudentsStuarthasseen“massiveboostsinconfidence”andhashadmanystudentsgoontoSTEMdegrees.Stuartreportsthattheprojectshelpstudenttoworkaspartofagroup,topresentfindingsinaprofessionalsettinganddevelopemployabilityskills.
Teacher’sroleinsupportingtheprojectStuartseeshisroleasafacilitatoroftheprojects,makingsurethattheyaremakingprogresseachweekandliaisingwiththeuniversity.Stuartteachesstudentshowtofindabstractsusingpublicdomainsearchengines,howpeerreviewworks,andhowtojudgethevalidityandreproducibilityofresearchstudiesandsupportsstudentstointerpretscientificpapers.
CollegesupportThecollegedaycurrentlyallowssomeextranon-contacttimeforstafftodevelopnewenrichmentactivities,andallteachersareexpectedtocontributetoanextracurricularactivity.Theintellectualspacetofocusontheprojectcomesfrombeingabletospecialiseasateacherofchemistryandtodiscussideaswithchemistryspecialistcolleagues.
Adviceforteachersinterestedindoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojects
● Organiseregulartimetabledmeetings.● Involveacolleaguetoshareworkand
ideas.● Sharegoalswithpartnerorganisations.
“Ithinkit’sreallyimportanttheyrealisehowcollaborativeandhowinterconnectedallrealresearchis.[RealWorldChemistry]didmakethemrealisehowmanypeopleandhowmanydifferentfieldscontributetoadvances.”
![Page 29: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
28
Meetingthechallengesassociatedwithopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsTeachersinallschoolsandcollegesidentifiedchallengesthattheyhadexperiencedthemselves,orthatcolleagueshadsharedwiththeminrelationtodoing(ornot)open-endedinvestigativeprojects.Thesefellintothreemaincategories:challengesassociatedwiththeexternalpolicycontext,thestudentexperience,andschoolinfrastructure.Theteacherswespoketotendedtofocusonsolutionswhentheywereaskedtoidentifybarriersorchallenges.Thechallengeshavebeenmatchedwithresponsesfromteacherswithinthesample,demonstratingdifferentapproachestoovercomingperceivedandactualchallengesassociatedwithofferingopen-endedprojects.
Challengesassociatedwiththeexternalpolicycontext
Challenge Response
CurriculumandassessmentOpen-endedinvestigationsarenotthoughttobevaluedinthewayscienceisexamined.Teachersreportedthatassessmentregimesoftenencourage‘spoonfeeding’andasaresultstudentsstruggletothinkcriticallyandunderstandscientificmethods.
● Teachacurriculumthatvaluesopen-endedinvestigativework(e.g.theIBorBTEC).
● Valueinvestigativeworkbytimetablinglessonsleadingtoarecognisedaward(e.g.CREST).
● Useopen-endedinvestigationsasevidenceforstudents’practicalendorsement.
● Encouragecriticalthinkingandengagementwithscientificmethodsinalow-riskcontextthroughopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.
HealthandsafetyManymorestudentswanttoparticipateintheprojectsthanasingleteachercancopewithforsomeprojectswhereproceduresarehazardous.Projectswhichgivestudentsfreechoiceovertopicanddesignrequireindividualriskassessments,whichisanadditionalworkloadforteachers.Newinvestigationareasrequiretriallingandnewriskassessments.
● Carryoutsomestepsasanextra-curricularactivitywithasmallnumberofstudents
● Constrainchoicee.g.toasmallnumberoftechniques.
● AskCLEAPSSandequipmentmanufacturersforsupportwherebeyondtheusualscope.
● Moreexperiencedcolleaguessupportedlessexperienced.
● Testideasoutaloneorwithatechnicianduringtheholiday.
● AsktechniciansorPGCEstudentstosearch,testandrefineprocedures.
FundingforstafftimeLackofacknowledgementorrecognitionforteacherandtechniciantimeindepartmentalandinstitutionalworkloadmodels,andfundingmodels,includingschoolfundingandgrantsforprojectworkinschools.
● Teachersrespondedbyworkingvoluntarybeyondtheirtimetabledhours.
● Oneteacherhadbeeninvolvedinalargerscaleprojectthatpaidforteachertime.
● Treatopen-endedprojecttimeasanyothertimetabledsubject.
● Encouragestudentstowriteaboutopen-endedinvestigationsinUCASapplications.
● Relieveteacherswhorunopen-endedinvestigationsfromduties.
![Page 30: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
29
Challengesassociatedwiththestudentexperience
Challengeidentified Response:whatteachersdid
Theacademicdemandofprojectscanbeseentobeadistractionfrommeetingexamspecificationrequirements.
● Treatinvestigationsasameansbywhichstudentscanapplyknowledgeanddevelopadeeperunderstandingofspecificationcontent,particularlyinrelationtotheexaminationof‘requiredpracticals’.
● UseprojectstodemonstratethatstudentshavemettheCPACfortheirpracticalendorsement.
● Teachersarguedthatopen-endedinvestigativeprojectshadapositiveimpactonattainmentatAlevelandontheirabilitytomakemoreinformedcareerdecisions.
● Useschooldatasets(e.g.ALPS)tocomparecohortsdoingprojectworkwiththosewhoarenottomonitorimpactonattainment.
Itcanbechallengingforstudentstocopewithandinterpretunexpectedresults.Somestudentsfindthisdifficult,orevendemoralising.
● Empathisebysharingtheirownexperienceofinvestigationsinindustryoracademia.
● Demonstratethattheyarelearningoutsidetheircomfortzonetoo.
● Explainthisasacharacteristicofdoingrealscience.
Thelevelofmathematicalorstatisticaldemandwasoftengreaterthanhadbeentaught.
● Provideworkbooksapplyingmathematicsandstatisticsinscientificcontextsfromthebeginningofthecourse.
● Teachstatisticsandaskstudentstoapplyinnewsciencecontextsthroughopen-endedprojects.
Studentssometimesstruggletounderstandscientificmethods.
● Useopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsasawayofteachingaboutrealscience,researchdesign,datahandlingandanalysis.
● Encouragecollaborationbetweenstudentsindifferentyeargroupsbyofferingafter-schoolsupport.
Motivationattheendofyear12insummer.
● Offeranopen-endedprojectwherestudentshavefreedomtoinvestigatesomethingofinteresttothem.
Instrumentalapproachestolearning,somestudentsreluctanttolearnbeyondthespecification.
● Useopen-endedinvestigationsasevidenceforstudents’practicalendorsement.
● Modelenthusiasm,loveoflearningandinterestinfindingoutabouttheworldorsolvingaproblem.
StudentsareverygoodatrecallbuthavehadlittlepracticeathandlingdataatGCSE.
● Createopportunitiesforstudentstoexperiencedatahandlingthroughlow-riskopen-endedinvestigativeprojects.
Notallstudentscanaccessextracurricularprojectwork.
● Createopportunitiesforprojectworkinclasstime,particularlyattheendofyear12.
![Page 31: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
30
Challengesassociatedwithinfrastructure
Challenge Response:whatteachersdid
Scientificliteratureandothersourcesareofteninaccessibletostudentse.g.recentpapersarebehindpaywalls.
● Collaboratewithuniversitycolleagues,whoprovidedaccesstostudents.
● SubscribetojournalssuchasChemistryReview.
Accesstoexternalpartners. ● ThoseincitieswereabletodrawonSTEMAmbassadorsanduniversityscientists.
Equipmentavailableinschoolconstrainsstudents’approach.
● Seekinternal(e.g.PTA)andexternal(e.g.RoyalSociety)funding.
● Liaisewithalocaluniversity.● Askforequipment(e.g.ex-displaymodels.)
Space.Manyschoolsandcollegeswerepreviouslyabletouseasparelaboratoryforprojectwork.
● Designateasinglelaboratoryasa‘projectlab’forpartoftheyear;protectthisinthetimetable.
● Redeploysmallclassroomsnolongersuitableforlargerclasssizes.
Time-boundedness.Fittingextendedinvestigativeworkintotimetabledlessonsischallenging.
● Requestadditionaltimetablinginthesummertermwhenstudentsareoftenoutofclassdoingexams,ontripsorconductingfieldwork.
● Encourage‘kitchen’orhomescience,withstudentsbringingdataorsamplestoschool.
Studentnumbers.Open-endedprojectsgeneratealotof(different)questionsfortheteacher;specialistequipmentcannotbeusedbylargenumbersatonce;consumablesareexpensiveforlargecohortsofstudents.
● Startsmallbyofferinganoptionalprojectorclub,moveintotimetabledtimeasexperienceisgained.
● Allocateaweeklyslotwhenstudentsarefreeandinvolveothercolleagues.
● Involveotherteachersofthesamesubjecttoco-planandsharesupervisionduties.
● Enlisttechnicians,visitingstudents,PGCEstudentsandNQTstosupportstudents’projects.
● Constrainchoice:identifyfamiliarproceduresthatcanbeadaptedtonewcontexts.
● Allowpairorgroupwork.● Rotateprojectworkwithothernon-practical
workduringthesummerterm.
Technicians:someschoolshavefewtechnicians,orahighturnover.
● Trainstudentstodotheirowntechnicalwork.● Makethecaseforgreatertechnicalsupport.
Teacherinexperienceorlackofexpertiseinstudents’areasofinterest.
● Shadowamoreexperiencedcolleague● Seeksupport,e.g.fromlocaluniversitiesviaan
outreachofficerorSTEMambassador.● Modellearningalongsidestudents.● Transferresponsibilityformostoftheworkto
students-adoptaresponsiverole.
![Page 32: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
31
Subject-specificobservationsMostteachersinthesampletaughtwithintheirspecialismatkeystage4andabove,andtheprojectstheyofferedpost-16tendedtobewithinspecialism.Here,subject-specificconsiderationsarediscussed.Teacherswhoofferedprojectsthatcutacrossspecialismstendedtoworkwithotherswithcomplementaryexpertise,whetherresearchersworkinginauniversitycontextorteacherswithadifferentscientificbackground(mostnotablypsychology).
BiologyprojectsAdistinctivefeatureofsomebiologyprojectswasthattheyinvolvedworkingwithlivingorganismsincludingbacteria,flies,woodliceandhumansubjects.Thisraisesanumberofissuesforteachers,mostnotablytheethicalissues,andthehealthandsafetyconsiderationsneededinordertohouseandcarryoutresearchonlivingorganisms.Someprojectshadresultedinnovelsolutionstodealingwithhealthandsafetyissuesthathadarisenduringopen-endedinvestigativeprojectwork.Havingownershipofalabwasanimportantenablerofbiologyprojectsasthisallowedtheteacherresponsibletostoreresourcessuchasapparatusbetweenusewithstudents.Teachersidentifiedstudents’statisticalknowledgeasaconceptualdemandofbiologicalprojects.
ChemistryprojectsForchemistryprojects,thelegacyofspecificationsrequiringopen-endedinvestigativeprojectswasevident,withteachersdrawingontheirexperiencesofsuccessfulSACprojects.Althoughhealthandsafetyconsiderationswereimportantacrossallprojects,thiswasmostnotableinchemistryprojects.Indeed,thedemandofriskassessmentsforopen-endedprojectswasidentifiedasoneofthekeyreasonswhychemistryprojectswerenothostedinaschoolwheretheywereofferedinothersciences.Chemistryteachersinthesampledealtwithworkloadassociatedwithriskassessmentsinanumberofways,forexamplebyconstrainingstudents’choiceofprocedureandreagent,orinvolvingtechniciansandotherteachersinprojects.Similarly,accesstospecialist(andoftenexpensive)analyticalequipmentwasimportantforchemistryprojects,anduniversitiesplayedaroleinprovidingaccesstoequipmentorofferinganalysisofsamplesforschoolstudentsconductingopen-endedinvestigativework.Forprojectsusingonlyschoolequipment,theset-upandclear-awaytimeneededforwetchemistryprojectswasanimportantconsiderationgiventimetablingconstraints.Mathematicaldemandappearedintheseprojects,mostnotablyforstoichiometriccalculationsandlogarithms,andsometeachershadbuiltappliedchemicalmathematicsintotheirAlevelprogrammesasaseparate,independentstrandofwork.
PhysicsprojectsThelegacyofexamspecificationsrequiringopen-endedinvestigativeprojectswasevidentforsomephysicsteachers,whowerebuildingonthelegacyofSHAP.Theyconstrainedchoice,allowingstudentstoselectprojectsofvaryinglevelsofdemandintermsofsubjectknowledgeormanipulativeskill.Alsoimportantforthephysicsprojectswasmathematicalcompetence.
![Page 33: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
32
ConclusionsandlimitationsThisreportdrawsoncasestudiesasmallsampleofteachersdoingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectwork.Open-endedinvestigativeprojectsaredefinedastasksinwhichstudentsdesignanexperimenttotestagivenquestion,carryitoutandinterprettheresults,allwithinafixedtimeperiod(Gatsby,2017).Allteachersinthesamplevaluedopen-endedinvestigativeprojectworktotheextentthattheywerewillingtodedicatetheirownnon-directedtime,andindeedpersonaltime,tosupportingit.Teachersallowedallstudentsintheirschooltoaccessopen-endedinvestigativeprojects,regardlessofpriorattainment.Howdoscienceteacherapproachestopractical,open-endedandextendedinvestigativeprojectsvary?Allprojectswereuniqueinoneormoreofthefollowingdimensions:subject,extentofopen-nessforstudents,useofexternalsupport,durationoftheproject,amountofclasstimededicatedtotheproject,involvementoftechnicalstaff,useofresearchliterature,assessment,andpresentationoffindings.Wheretheycould,teachersfoundwaystoformallyrecognisetheirstudents’work.Whatdoteacherswantstudentstolearnbycarryingoutopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsinscience,andhowdotheybringthisabout? Teachershadclearintendedlearningoutcomesforopen-endedinvestigativeprojectwork,mostsignificantly,learningtodo‘real’science,understandingthestateofthefield,researchdesign,datahandlinganditeration.Eachteacherhadadditionallearningoutcomescorrespondingtotheirspecificproject.PreparationforuniversityandtheUCASprocesswasalsoimportant.Teacherstendedtointroducethecontextattheoutsetandmovetowardsahands-off,responsivemodeofteaching.Someteachersscaffoldedpracticalworkoveryear12towardsindependentinvestigativework. Howdoteachersseetheirroleinsupportingstudentstocarryoutopen-endedinvestigativeprojectsinscience? Teacherssawtheirprimaryroleinplanningandintroducingtheproject,facilitatingstudentchoiceandlearning,ensuringriskswereminimisedandthattheworkcompliedwithhealthandsafetyrequirements,networkingwithexternalorganisationsandrespondingtostudents’needs.
Whatenablessuccessfulprojectworkinschoolsorcolleges,andwhatbarriersexist? Commonbarrierstoopen-endedinvestigativeprojectworkincurriculumtimewereteachertime(requiredofteacherstoplanprojects,assessrisksandsupportstudentsonanindividualorgroupbasis),schooltimetabling,thelevelofdemandforstudents,studentmotivation,andinstrumentalattitudes,wherebyactivitieswerevaluedinrelationtohowlikelytheyarethoughttoinfluenceexaminationsuccess.Forsome,lackofteacherexpertisewasconsideredabarrier.Resourcessuchasaccesstoliterature,labspace,equipment,technicalsupportandexternalexpertisealsoactedasbarriers,particularlyinsomelocations.Allteachersinthisstudyhadfoundwaysofnegotiatingbarriers. Enablersofopen-endedinvestigativeworkrelatedtotheteacher(experience,freedom),thedepartment(availabilityoftechnicalsupport),seniorschoolleadership(resources,policies,deploymentofstaffandspace),specifications,andexternalsupportandrecognition(STEMambassadors,CRESTAwards,grantfunding).
![Page 34: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
33
Itwasdifficulttofindteacherswhocarryoutprojectworkinclasstime,andasaresultthereportdrawsonasmallnumberofteacherswhowerecurrentlydoingopen-endedprojects.Noteachersinthesamplediscussedopen-endedinvestigationsinthecontextofoutdoorlearningorfieldwork;norbasedlargelyinuniversityoutreachlaboratoriesnorascontributingtoanEPQ.Onlyteachersinstateschoolswereincludedinthesample,andallwereworkingininstitutionsgraded‘good’or‘outstanding’byOfsted.Allhadatleast5years’experience,withthemajorityhavingmorethanten.Alloftheteachershadnegotiatedchallengessuccessfullytogreaterorlesserdegrees.Therearelikelytobeteachersinmorechallengingcontexts,withlessexperiencewhoexperiencedifferentbarriers.
![Page 35: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
34
RecommendationsTeachersPracticalsuggestionsformakingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectspossible:
● Useopen-endedprojectsasawayofteachingrequiredpracticalsandprovidingopportunitiestomeettheCPAC.
● Planinadvance:identifygoodcandidatepracticalsthatcanbemadeopen-ended.AskaPGCEstudentorNQTtohelpwiththiswork.
● Takeitslowly-tryitwithonegroupandworkthroughanyteethingproblems.● Enlisttechnicalsupportinrefiningprocedures.● Whenyougetstuck,contactascientist-universitiesaregenerallywillingtohelpteachers.● Students’workcanberecognisedwithCRESTAwards-thiscanhelpconvinceschool
leadershipthatopen-endedinvestigationsarevaluable.● Requestdifferenttimetablingarrangementsforthesummertermtofacilitateextended
investigations.SchoolsSchoolscantakeanumberofstepstomakeopen-endedinvestigativeworkpossible:
● Adoptcurriculathatrequireopen-endedinvestigativework. ● Ensurethestaffing,estateandfundingofsciencedepartmentsisadequatetoprovide
opportunitiesforopen-endedprojectwork. ● Givescienceteachersautonomy,particularlyafterexaminations(wheretheyexist)inthe
lowersixth(year12). ● Valueteachertimebytimetablingopen-endedinvestigativeworkandcountinginworkload
models. ● Adoptflexibletimetablingmodels,e.g.allowingforperiodiccollapseddaysforopen-ended
projectworkandreleasingteacherstoplanandsuperviseprojects. ● Fundtechnicalsupportforopen-endedinvestigativework.● Encourageteachingwithinspecialism,andspecialisttechnicalsupport.
SystemsAnumberofsystemicchangesarelikelytosupportmakingopen-endedinvestigativeprojectspossible:
● Teacherandtechnicianbuy-outforcollaborativeprojectscouldbefunded. ● Inclusionofopen-endedandextendedinvestigativeworkinexaminationspecifications. ● Extend/formalisenetworks(ofpeople,portableequipment)acrossEnglandtoensurethat
schoolsinallareashaveaccesstoSTEMexpertise. ● Workwithexaminationboardstodevelopexemplarmaterialfordemonstratingstudents
meettheCPACthroughopen-endedinvestigativework. ● Commissionresearchtoinvestigatetheimpact(ifany)ofopen-endedinvestigativeworkon
post-16attainment.
![Page 36: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
35
ReferencesBennett,J.,Dunlop,L.,Knox,K.J.,Reiss,M.J.,&TorranceJenkins,R.(2018).Practicalindependentresearchprojectsinscience:asynthesisandevaluationoftheevidenceofimpactonhighschoolstudents.Internationaljournalofscienceeducation,40(14),1755-1773.BuckL.B.,BretzS.L.andTownsM.H.,(2008),CharacterizingtheLevelofInquiryintheUndergraduateLaboratory,JournalofCollegeScienceTeaching,38,52-58.Cramman,H.,Kind,V.,Lyth,A.,Gray,H.,Younger,K.,Gemar,A.,Eerola,P.,Coe,R.&Kind,P.(2019)'Monitoringpracticalscienceinschoolsandcolleges.',ProjectReport.DurhamUniversity,Durham.TheGatsbyFoundation(2017)GoodPracticalScience.London:TheGatsbyCharitableFoundation.
Gott,R.andDuggan,S.(1995)InvestigativeworkintheScienceCurriculum.Buckingham:OpenUniversityPress.
Loughran,J.,Berry,A.,&Mulhall,P.(2012).UnderstandingandDevelopingScienceTeachers’PedagogicalContentKnowledgeVol.12.SpringerScience&BusinessMedia.
![Page 37: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
36
Appendix1QuestionnaireTeachingthroughopen-endedinvestigativework(AdaptedfromGoogleForms)AresearchteamfromtheDepartmentofEducationattheUniversityofYorkiscarryingoutaprojectontheteachingofopen-endedinvestigativeprojectworkwithpost-16students.Weareinterestedinfindingoutwhatteachersintendstudentstolearn(andhowtheydesignlearningexperiencestoachievethis)whentheydoopen-endedinvestigativeworkwithpost-16students.Byopen-endedwemeanthatalthoughtheoutcomesmaybeknowntotheteacher,theyarenotknowntothestudents.Theresearchwillinvolvethefollowingbriefsurveyincombinationwithsemi-structuredinterviewstobeheldlaterthisyear.Ifyoudoopen-endedinvestigativeworkwithyourstudentsandareabletohelpbytakingpartinaninterviewlaterthisyear,pleasewouldyouanswer(briefly)thequestionsonthissurveyusingshortsentencesorbulletpoints.PleasedirectquestionstoDr.MariaTurkenburg([email protected])orDr.LyndaDunlop([email protected]).
1. Whatconceptsorideasisitimportantforstudentstoknowinordertodosuccessfulopen-endedinvestigativework?
2. Whatdoyouintendstudentstolearnthroughopen-endedinvestigativework?3. Pleasestatewhetherornotyouprovidethefollowingtothestudent(s)whenyoudoopen-
endedinvestigativeworkwiththem.Forexample,ifstudentswereresponsiblefordevelopingtheirownprocedures,select‘NOTprovidedtostudents’for3.Below.
Providedtostudents NOTprovidedtostudents
1.Problem/Question
2.Theory/Background
3.Procedures/Design
4.Analysisofresults
5.Communicationofresults
6.Conclusions
4.Ifyouarehappyforustoinviteyoutoafollow-upinterview,pleaseselect'Yes'below.
● Yes● No
Thankyouforyourtime.Yourresponsestothesequestionswillinformtheinterviewquestionsweasklaterintheyear.Ifyouwouldbecomfortabledoingso,pleaseforwardthelinktothissurveytoanyoneyouknowofwhocarriesoutopen-endedinvestigativeworkwithstudents.
![Page 38: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
37
Appendix2InterviewguideContextualquestions
● HowlonghaveyoubeenteachingAlevelscienceinEngland?● Whatdoyouconsideryourspecialism?WhatisyourhighestqualificationintheAlevel
sciencesubjectyouareteaching?● Whatexamboardspecificationdoyoufollow?Why?Doyouhaveexperienceofothers?
Questionsaboutwhatteachersdotosupportlearning(foreachkeyideaidentifiedfromthepre-interviewquestion:‘real’science;datahandling;researchdesign;stateofthefieldanditeration)
● Whyisitimportantforstudentstolearnthis?● [Howdidyoulearntodothis?Wherewouldyougotofindoutmoreaboutthis?]● Whatelsedoyouknowaboutthisthatyoudon’tintendstudentstoknowyet?● Whatarethedifficultiesorlimitationsforateacherassociatedwithteachingthisidea?● Whatknowledgeaboutstudents’thinkinginfluenceshowyouteachthisidea?● Whatteachingproceduresorstrategiesdoyouuse?Whatareyourreasonsforusingthese?● Whatotherfactorsinfluencehowyouteachthisidea?Forexample,knowledgeabouthow
studentsthinkorhowtheylearnscienceinfluenceshowyouteachthisidea?● Whatstrategiesdoyouusetoascertainstudentunderstandingorconfusionaroundthis?
Questionsaboutthepracticalopen-endedextendedinvestigativeproject
● Pleasedescribethenatureofthepracticalopen-endedextendedprojectsyoudowithsixth-formstudents.
● [askforexamplesofstimulusorothermaterialsprovidedtostudents]● [Remindofresponsestolevelsofinquiryquestion]
○ Forthedimensionsthatwereprovided,howaretheyprovided?○ Forthosethatarenotprovided,howarestudentssupportedtodothis
independently?● Howlonghaveyoubeendoingthese?● [ifinan11-18school]isprojectworkcommoninscienceatKS3andKS4?● Whydidyoustartdoingthese?Whydoyoucontinue?● Doyouexpectthewholeyeargrouptoundertakeprojectsorjustsome?Ifitisoptional
whichstudentstendtochoosetodothemandwhy?● Isthereanyconceptualknowledgerequiredforstudentstoparticipateintheproject?How
dotheygainthis?● Howdoyouseeyourroleinpracticalopen-endedextendedinvestigativeprojects?● Howdoyousuperviseandmanagethese?● Howdoyouworkwithothermembersofthesciencedepartment,orschool,todeliverthis
(teachers,technicians)?● Howdoyouknowtheextenttowhichyouhavebeensuccessfulinpromotinglearning?
[probehowtheyassessstudents’knowledgeorpractice–ifyoudoassessstudents]
![Page 39: Practical, open-ended and extended investigative projects ... · Investigations are defined as tasks in which students design an experiment to test a given question, carry it out](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022041617/5e3c22b613a2de711e7b1516/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
38
Concludingquestions
● Whatadvicewouldyougivetoateacherconsideringdoingtheseprojects?● Whatconditionsdoyouthinkareneededforpracticalopen-endedextendedinvestigative
projectstobesuccessful?[mightneedsomeprobeshere–facilities,technicians,teacherCPD,expectationsofawardingorganisations…]
● What,ifany,challengeshaveyouexperienced?(How)didyouovercomethese?● Whatcanstudentsdodifferentlyasaresultofcarryingoutpracticalopen-endedand
extendedinvestigativework?● Howdoyouseepracticalopen-endedextendedinvestigativeprojectscontributingtothe
aimsofpost-16scienceeducation?● Isthereanythingelseyouwouldliketotellusaboutpracticalopen-endedextended
investigativeprojects?
Notesonkeyideas
Thesearethekeyideasthatteacherswhoparticipatedinthequestionnaireidentifiedasintendedlearningoutcomesofopen-endedinvestigativeprojectwork.
RealscienceThisideareferstothesensethatopenendedinvestigativeprojectsgivestudentsthechancetofindoutabout‘real’science,orworkmoresimilartothethingsscientistsdo.DatahandlingThisideareferstoseveralaspectsofdatahandlingthatareimportantforstudentstolearnaboutincludingevaluationofdataandclaimsbyothers,decisionsaboutdatacollection(includinghowdecisionsaremadeaboutthesuitabilityandadequacyofdata),dataanalysis,interpretationanddatapresentation(forexamplestatisticsandgraphs).ResearchdesignThisreferstothedecisionsstudentsmakeaboutthemethodstheywillusetocarryoutaprojectthatanswersaresearchquestion.Thisincludesdecisionsaboutexperimentaldesign,themethodsofdatacollectionandanalysis,equipment,safetyandethics.StateofthefieldThisidearelatestolearningabouthowknowledgeiscreatedinthediscipline,includinghowtosearch,andreviewtheresearchliteratureandunderstandhowtheirworkcontributestounderstandingthestateofthefield.IterationThisreferstotherepetitiveandrecursive(ratherthanlinear)processlinkingdatacollectionandanalysisduringwhichstudentsmightnoticeunexpectedresults,testprocedures,gainexperienceoftrialanderror,ormakeamendmentstotheirmethods.