PPI Darren Gitelman
-
Upload
tomasgoucha -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
0
Transcript of PPI Darren Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
1/105
DarrenGitelman,
MD
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
2/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Functionalintegration Analysesofinterregionaleffects
Whataretheinteractionsbetween
theelementsofaneuronal
system?
Univariate&Multivariateanalysis
Functionalintegration Analysesofinterregionaleffects
Whataretheinteractionsbetween
theelementsofaneuronal
system?
Univariate&Multivariateanalysis
Functionalspecialization Analysesofregionallyspecific
effects
Whichregionsarespecializedforaparticulartask?)
Univariateanalysis
Functionalspecialization Analysesofregionallyspecific
effects
Whichregionsarespecializedforaparticulartask?)
Univariateanalysis
K.Stephan,FIL
StandardSPM
Effectiveconnectivity
Effectiveconnectivity
Functionalconnectivity
Functionalconnectivity
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
3/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Functionalintegration
Functionalintegration
Functionalconnectivity Temporalcorrelationsbetween
spatiallyremote
areas
MODEL-FREE
Exploratory
Data Driven
No Causation
Whole brain connectivity
Functionalconnectivity Temporalcorrelationsbetween
spatiallyremote
areas
MODEL-FREE
Exploratory
Data Driven
No Causation
Whole brain connectivity
Effectiveconnectivity Theinfluencethatoneneuronal
systemexerts
over
another
MODEL-DEPENDENT
Confirmatory
Hypothesis driven
Causal (based on a model)
Reduced set of regions
Effectiveconnectivity Theinfluencethatoneneuronal
systemexerts
over
another
MODEL-DEPENDENT
Confirmatory
Hypothesis driven
Causal (based on a model)
Reduced set of regions
K.Stephan,FIL;S.WhitfieldGabrieli
PPI
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
4/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
maineffect
oftask
maineffect
ofstim.
type interaction
Confounds
+ error
Task factorTask A Task B
TA/S1 TB/
S1
TA/S2 TB/S2
Stim1
Stim2
Stimulusfa
ctor
y
y
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
5/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
T
S
A B
SignificantInteraction
(TxS)
Factor Tissignificant
FactorSissignificant
FactorsT&Saresignificant
Significant
maineffectsandinteraction
NomaineffectNointeraction
A BT
A BT
A BT
A BT
A BT
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
6/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Two
(or
more)
experimental
/
psychological
factors
Changein
regression
slope
due
to
the
differentialresponsetooneexperimentalcondition undertheinfluenceofdifferent
experimentalcontexts.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
7/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Task:Lettersandtonespresented
simultaneously.(PET
scan).
Factor1:Tonespresentedatdifferentrates.
Factor2:Subjectsattendandrespond toeithera
targetletter
(A)
or
atarget
tone
(low)
.
Is
there
a
differential
sensitivity
to
the
presentationrateoftoneswhenpayingattentiontotonesvs.payingattentiontoletters?
Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
8/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Attention (A)Tones Letters
)
AT/R1 AL/R1
AT/R2 AL/R2
Stim
1
Stim2
Pres
entation
rate(R)
AT/R3 AL/R3Stim3
Tonesvs.Letters
Rateoftones
interaction
Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
9/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Activityinauditorycortexvariesbypresentationrateregardlessof
whethersubjectspaidattentiontotonesorletters.
Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
10/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Activityintherightthalamusisinfluencedbypresentationrateoftoneswhensubjectsattendedtotonesvs.attendingtoletters.
Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
11/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Two(or
more)
physiological
factors
(i.e.,
neural
activitysignals)
Changeinregressionslopeduetothedifferentialresponseofthesignal(neuralactivity)from
region1due
to
the
signal
from
region
2.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
12/105
D.Gitelman Bucheletal,CerebCortex,1997
Key
M=Dummyscans(discarded)
F=
Fixation(central
dot)
A=Attention:radiallymoving
dots.Subjectstoldtodetect
changesinspeedofdots(no
changesactually
occurred
duringscanning).
N=Noattention:radiallymovingdotsviewedpassively.
S=Stationary:250stationary
dots
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
13/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Task factor
Attention No attention
TA/S1 TN/S1
TA/S2 TN/S2
Nomotion
Motion
Stim
ulusfactor
SM
NA
SS
TT )(
SM
NA
SS
TT )(
Region1 Region2 interaction
ActivityinRegion1
ActivityinRegion2
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
14/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Task:Subjectsaskedtodetectspeedchangesinradiallymovingdots(fMRI).
Doesactivityinposteriorparietal (PP)cortex
(attentional
area)
modulate
the
response
to
V1
(motionarea)activity(oristhereacontributionfromPPthatdependsonV1activity)?
Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997
Region1 Region2 interaction
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
15/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997
modulationoftheV1V5contributionbyPP? modulationofthePPV5contributionbyV1?
Z=5.77
P
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
16/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
1Physiologicalfactor(neuralactivity)
1Psychologicalfactor(experimentalcontext)
Change
in
regression
slope
due
to
the
differential
responseofthe signalfromoneregionundertheinfluenceofdifferentexperimentalcontexts.
Bilinear
model
of
how
the
psychological
contextchangestheinfluenceofoneareaonanother.
Friston et al. NeuroImage, 1997
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
17/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Task factor
Attention No attention
TA/S1 TN/S1
TA/S2 TN/S2
Nomotion
Motion
Stim
ulusfactor
SM
NA
SS
TTT )(
SM
NA
SS
TTT )(
Taskfactor SourceRegion
interaction
Psychologicalfactor
ActivityinSourceregion
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
18/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997
Task:Subjectsaskedtodetectspeedchangesinradiallymovingdots(fMRI).
Doesthetask(attention)modulatetheresponse,
to
V1
activity,
or
does
activity
in
V1
influence
the
responsetoattention?[Inferenceontaskandregionaleffects]
Taskfactor SourceRegion
interaction
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
19/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Twopossibleinterpretations Modulation
of
the
contribution
of
V1
to
V5
by
attention
(context
specific) ModulationofattentionspecificresponsesinV5byV1inputs
(stimulusspecific)
Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
20/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Activityinregion
k
Experimentalfactor
Responseinregioni
=k+ T + kx T
k T
+ kx T
Activityin
regionk
Experimental
factor
Responseinregioni
=k+ T + kx T
k T
+ kx T
Contextspecificmodulationofresponsestostimulus
Stimulusrelatedmodulation ofresponsestocontext(attention)
Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
21/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
ArePPIs
the
same
as
correlations?
No
PPIsarebasedonregressionsandexplicitly
discountmain
effects (discountsimplecorrelations)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
22/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
KimandHorwitzinvestigatedcorrelationsvs.PPIregression
using
abiologically
plausible
neural
model.
PPI
results
were
similar
to
those
based
on
integratedsynapticactivity(goldstandard)
Resultsfromcorrelationswerenotsignificantfor
manyof
the
functional
connections.
Achangeininfluencebetween2regionsmaynot
involveachangeinsignalcorrelation
Kim&Horwitz,MagResMed,2008
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
23/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
AlthoughPPIsselectasourceandfindtargetregions,theycannotdeterminethedirectionality
ofconnectivity.
Theregressionequationsarereversible.TheslopeofA BisapproximatelythereciprocalofBA
(notexactly
the
reciprocal
because
of
measurement
error)
Directionalityshouldbeprespecifiedandbasedonknowledgeofanatomyorotherexperimental
results.
Source Target Source Target
?
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
24/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
25/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Becausetheyconsistofonly1inputregion,PPIsare
modelsof
contributions
rather
than
effective
connectivity.
PPIsdependonfactorialdesigns,otherwisetheinteractionandmaineffectsmaynotbeorthogonal,and
the
sensitivity
to
the
interaction
effect
will
be
low.
ProblemswithPPIs
Interactionterm
not
formed
correctly
(as
originally
proposed)
Analysiscanbeoverlysensitivetothechoiceofregion.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
26/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
V1xAttention
Psychophysiological
interaction
term
originally
formed
by
multiplyingmeasureBOLDsignalbycontextvector(orby
anotherBOLDsignalinthecaseofphysiophysiologicalinteractions)
Friston,etal.Neuroimage,1997
xkx gp
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
27/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Regionalactivity
measured
as
aBOLD
time
series
=hemodynamicresponse neuralactivity
=convolution
InitialformulationofPPIestimatedtheinteractionterm
as
BOLD
xcontext
vector.
BUT:Interactionsactuallyoccurataneuronallevel! Thereforeneuronalactivitymustbeestimatedfrom
hemodynamicactivity
But,thisisdifficultbecausemappingfromBOLDsignaltoneuralsignalisnonunique(duetolossofhighfrequencyinformation)(Zarahn,Neuroimage,2000)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
28/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Hxyxhytt
yt =MeasuredBOLDsignalh=hemodynamic (impulse)responsefunctionxt =neuronalsignal
H =HRF
in
Toeplitz
matrix
form
Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
BABABA
xxHHxHxyy
AAA PxHHxHPHPy
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
29/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
HRF HRF
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
30/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
HRF
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
31/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Cantryusingamaximumlikelihoodestimator(i.e.,
leastsquares)
but
this
runs
into
trouble
with
high
frequencycomponents. Zarahnconstrainedtheestimatestoparticulartemporal
intervals.(Zarahn,Neuroimage,2000)
CantryusingaWeinerfilter,butthisrequireshighSNRandanestimateofthenoisespectraldensity.(Glover,Neuroimage,1999)
Useempirical
Bayes
deconvolution
to
finesse
the
noiseestimatesbysettingthepriorprecisionsonthehighfrequenciesto0.(Gitelman,Neuroimage,2003)
Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
32/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
33/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
BOLD
Neural
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
34/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
35/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
36/105
D.Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
37/105
D.Gitelman
Istheredletterleftorrightfromthemidlineoftheword?
group analysis (random effects),
n=16, pletterdecisions
Stephan et al, Science, 2003
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
38/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Bilateral ACC activation in both tasks
but asymmetric connectivity !
IPS
IFG
Left ACC left inf.frontalgyrus(IFG):increaseduringletter decisions.
Right ACC right IPS:
increase
during
spatial decisions.
leftACC(6,16,42)
rightACC(8,16,48)
spatialvs.letterdecisions
lettervs.spatial
decisions
groupanalysisrandomeffects(n=15)
p
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
39/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
PPI single-subject example
bVS=0.16
bL=0.63
Signal
in
left
ACC
Sign
alin
leftIFG
bL=0.19
Signal
inright
ant.
IP
S
Signal
in
right
ACC
bVS=0.50
LeftACCsignalplottedagainstleftIFG
spatial
decisions
letterdecisions
letterdecisions
spatialdecisions
RightACCsignalplottedagainstrightIPS
Stephan et al, Science, 2003
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
40/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal., ChemSenses,2007
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
41/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal., ChemSenses,2007
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
42/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009
Atalowerthreshold(Punc =0.005,influences
wereseenfromFEF,POandPPConAI/FO.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
43/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
44/105
D.GitelmanD.GitelmanVeldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
45/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
46/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Inkblottest
Common/frequent Infrequent
Rare/unusual
Increased
in
schizophrenia
and
certain
personality
disorders
Associatedwithunusualperceptionandhigherpercentageofunusualresponsesinartisticpopulations.
Sinceamygdala
activity
can
affect
perceptual
processinghypothesisisthatamygdalaisactiveduringinkblottest.
http://www.testderorschach.com.ar/en/inkblots.htmAsari
et
al.,
Psych
Res,
2010
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
47/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
VBMdemonstratedincreasedamygdala&cingulatevolumeinsubjectswithmoreunusualresponses.
Asarietal.,Cortex,2010
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
48/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
fMRIstudyresponsestoinkblottest [unique frequent]:temporalpole (p
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
49/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Temporalpolemaylinksensoryinputfromoccipitotemporal
regionswithtopdownfrontalcontrolandemotional
modulationbytheamygdalaAsarietal.,Neuroimage,2010
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
50/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2002
Saccade
Explore
Central
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
51/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2002
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
52/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2002
Areasshowingconnectivitywiththesuperiorcolliculusundertheexplore
butnot
the
saccade
condition
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
53/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Pros:
Givenasingle
source
region,
we
can
test
for
its
context
dependentconnectivityacrosstheentirebrain
Simpletoperform
Cons: Very
simplistic
model:
only
allows
modelling
contributions
fromasinglearea
Ignorestimeseriespropertiesofdata(candoPPIsonPET
and
fMRI
data) Inputsarenotmodelledexplicitly
Interactionsareinstantaneous
K.Stephan,FIL
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
54/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
NonfactorialPPIsareinefficient PPI termandP(psychologicalvariable)arehighlycorrelated (0.86)in
thematrix
shown
below.
This
will
reduce
the
sensitivity
for
estimating
thePPIeffect(basedonattentiontomotiondataset)
Tableof
correlations
between
regressors
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
55/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Seethe
paper:
McLaren,
D.G.,
Ries,
M.L.,
Xu,
G.,
Johnson,S.C.,2012.Ageneralizedformofcontextdependentpsychophysiological
interactions(gPPI):
acomparison
to
standard
approaches.NeuroImage61,12771286.
NITRC.ORGsite:
https://www.nitrc.org/projects/gppi
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
56/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Psychological
regressor
Regionalsignal
PPI
D.McLaren,Neuroimage,2012
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
57/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
SPMPPI SPMPPI2
conditions
gPPI
A[fix](1condition) .9876 .9876
AB(2conditions) .8675 .9889
SPMPPI1
condition
SPMPPI2
conditions
gPPI
A[fix](1condition) 3.6676 3.6676
AB(2conditions) 6.4581 3.5447
BetaEstimates
SumsofSquares
D.McLaren,personalcommunication
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
58/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman D.
McLaren,
Neuroimage,
2012
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
59/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman D.
McLaren,
Neuroimage,
2012
k
=
#
regressorsn=#timepoints
RSS=residual
sumofsquares
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
60/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
PlotofAIC:Lowerisbetter
D.McLaren,
Neuroimage,
2012
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
61/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman D.
McLaren,
Neuroimage,
2012
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
62/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
IncludingmaineffectsinmyPPIanalysistakes
awayall
the
interaction
results.
Do
Ihave
to
includemaineffects?
Absolutely!Otherwise,theinferenceoninteractions
willbe
confounded
by
main
effects.
ShouldIincludemovementregressorsinmyPPIanalysis?
Yes,include
any
nuisance
effects
you
would
normally
include.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
63/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Whatdoes
it
mean
to
adjust
for
different
effects?
Adjustingforeffectsmeanskeepingeffectsofinterest
andremovingeffectsofnointerest,e.g.,movement
regressors,block
effects,
etc.
InordertoadjustaneffectsofinterestFcontrast
shouldbesetupbeforetryingtoextractthedata.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
64/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
ShouldVOIsbebasedontheexactlocationsof
groupeffects
or
should
they
be
subject
specific?
Both.VOIsshouldbesubjectspecific,butshouldbe
closeenoughto amaximabasedonagroup
analysis,
the
literature
,
etc.
Close
enough
depends
onwherethemaximaisinthebrain,thesmoothnessofthedata,etc.Closeenoughinthecaudatemightbe5mm,whileintheparietalcortex,close enough
mightbe
1cm.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
65/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
HowdoIselectregionsthatarecloseenoughtoamaxima? Displayacontrastthatshowstheregionsofinterest. MovetheSPMcursortothegroupmaxima. Rightclickinthegraphicswindownexttotheglassbrain.The
cursorwilljumptotheclosestmaxima,andthenumberofmmit
moveswill
be
recorded
in
the
Matlab
window.
Make
anote
of
howfarthecursormoves. Nowclickeigenvariateandextractasusual
HowbigshouldtheVOIsbe?
Thisdepends
on
the
smoothness
of
the
data
and
the
region.
If
youhavehighresolutiondata orareinasubcorticalnucleusyouprobablywantasmallersphere.Generallybetween4and8mmradiusspheresareused.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
66/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Howis
agroup
PPI
analysis
done?
Theconimagesfromtheinteractiontermcanbebroughttoastandardsecondlevelanalysis(onesamplettestwithinagroup,twosamplettest
betweengroups,
ANOVAs,
etc.)
CanIrunaPPIbasedonasinglemaineffect? Yes,butthisisnotanoptimaldesign.Itisimportantto
realizethat
the
interaction
term
will
be
very
highly
correlatedwiththemaineffectregressor,resultinginverylowpowerfordetectingtheinteractioneffect.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
67/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
68/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
RunastandardGLManalysis Includeconditionsandanynuisanceeffects(motion,etc.)
Foreaseofanalysiscombinemultiplesessionsintoasinglesessionandincludeblockeffects
Displaycontrastofinterest
ExtractVOI
(volume
of
interest),
adjusting
for
effectsofinterest(i.e.,excludeanynuisanceregressors)
PPIbutton
(makes
PPI
regressors)
SPM.matfilefromstandardGLManalysis
SetupcontrastofPsychconditions
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
69/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
RunPPIGLManalysis
PPI.ppi(interaction)
PPI.Y(maineffect:sourceregionBOLDdata)
PPI.P
(main
effect:
Psych
conditions
that
formed
PPI) Contrastis[100]forpositiveeffectof
interactionand[100]fornegativeeffect
(assumingconditions
entered
in
order
listed)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
70/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Theanalysis
directory
should
include:
Directorynamedfunctionalwhichincludesthe
preprocessedfMRIvolumes
Directoryname
structural,
which
includes
aT1
image
Files:factors.mat,block_regressors.mat,
multi_condition.matandmulti_block_regressors.mat
Make3empty
directories
called
GLM,
PPI
V2
and
PPIV5
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
71/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
FromMatlab
command
prompt
>>cdpathtoanalysisdirectory
MakesureSPM12isintheMatlabpath
Start
SPM:
spm
FromtheTasksmenuatthetopoftheGraphics
windowchoose
Batch
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
72/105
D.Gitelman
FromtheSPMmenuinthebatchwindow,selectstatsthenselect:
fMRImodel
specification
Modelestimation
ContrastManager
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
73/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Directory:choosetheGLMdirectory
Unitsfor
designs:
scans
Interscaninterval:3.22
Click
Data
&
Design
then
New:
Subject/Session Scans:choosethefunctionalscans
Wewilladdtheconditionsusingmultiplecondition
and
regressor
files.
The
files
are
called: Multipleconditions:multi_condition.mat
Multipleregressors:multi_block_regressors.mat
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
74/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Tolookatthefile(notnecessaryfortheanalysis,butjustfordidacticpurposes)
>>load
multi_condition.mat
ThentypenamesoronsetsordurationintheMatlabcommandwindow.
Contains3cellarraysofthesamesize(notallentries
areshown
below)
names names{1}=Stationary; names{2}=Noattention;
onsets onsets{1} =[80170260350];
durations durations{1}=10;(canbejustasinglenumberifalleventshavethe
sameduration)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
75/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Tolookatthefile(notnecessaryfortheanalysis,butjustfordidacticpurposes)
>>load
multi_block_regressor.mat
Thefilecontains avariableR.,whichisanNxMmatrix N=numberofscans M=numberofregressors
Blockregressors
model
different
sessions.
Use
this
command
to
set
up.
Canalsousevariouscombinationsofzerosandonesfunctions. >>R=kron(eye(3),ones(90,1));zeros(90,3)]); or >>R= [blkdiag(ones(90,1),ones(90,1),ones(90,1));zeros(90,3)];
1 2 3
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
76/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
HighPassFilter:192
Note:
most
designs
will
use
a
high
pass
filter
value
of
128.
Thisdatasetrequiresalongerhighpass filterinordernot
tolosethelowfrequencycomponentsofthedesign.
Thedefaultvaluesontherestoftheentriesarecorrect
ClickModelEstimation SelectSPM.mat
Click
Dependency
and
choose
fMRI
model
specification:SPM.matFile
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
77/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Contrastmanager
SelectSPM.mat
ClickDependencyandchooseModelestimation:SPM.matfile
ContrastSessions
NewFContrast
Name:Effectsofinterest
Weightsmatrix:eye(3)
100
010
001
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
78/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
ContrastSessions New
T
Contrast
Name:Attention
Weightsvector:[011]
NewT
Contrast
Name:Motion
Tcontrastvector:[211]
ClickSave
button
and
save
the
batch
file
ClickRunbutton(greenarrow)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
79/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
80/105
D.Gitelman
Thechange
in
the
designmatrix
comparedwiththe
previousslideisdue
tonon
sphericity
effects.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
81/105
D.Gitelman
ClickResults
SelectSPM.mat
ChooseAttentioncontrast
ApplyMasking:
None
pvalueadjust:None
Thresholdp:0.0001
&extentthreshold:10
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
82/105
D.Gitelman
ClickResults
SelectSPM.mat
ChooseMotioncontrast
ApplyMasking:contrast
SelectMask:Attention
Uncorrectedmaskp:0.01
Natureofmask:inclusive
pvalueadjust:FWE
Thresholdp:0.05
&extentthreshold:3
Exampleofapsychologicalinteraction
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
83/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
84/105
D.Gitelman
ResultsChooseSPM.mat Motioncontrast
ApplyMasking:none
pvalueadjustment:FWE
thresholdT
or
pvalue:
0.05
&extentthresholdvoxels:3
Gotopoint[15789]
Clickeigenvariate
Nameof
region:
V2
Adjustfor:EffectsofInterest
ROIdefinition:sphere
Sphereradius(mm):6
(TheVOIfileissavedtothe
GLMdirectory.)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
85/105
D.Gitelman
ClickPPI
button
SelectSPM.matintheGLMdirectory.
Analysistype:PPI
SelectVOI_V2_1.mat IncludeStationary:No IncludeNoAttention:
Yes
Contrastweight:
1
IncludeAttention:Yes Contrastweight:1 NameofPPI:V2x(Att
NoAtt)
(ThePPIfileisautomaticallysavedtotheGLMdirectory.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
86/105
D.Gitelman
Openbatchwindow
FromtheSPMmenuselectStats>Physio/Psychophysiologic
Interaction ForSPM.matselect
theoneintheGLM
folder
Typeof
analysis
:Psychophysiologic
Interaction
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
87/105
D.Gitelman
Typeof
analysis
:Psycho
physiologicInteraction
VOI:choosetheV2VOI
Inputvariablesandcontrast
weights
Column1isthecondition(seeSPM.Sess.U),column2
willusuallybe1,column3isthecontrastweight.
Name
of
PPI:
:
V2x(Att
NoAtt)
Savethebatchfile
Runthebatchfile
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
88/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
cdtotheGLMdirectory.
>>load
PPI_V2x(Att
NoAtt)
ThismustbedonebeforesettingupthePPIGLMsothevariablesareintheMatlabworkspace.
FromthetasksmenuatthetopoftheGraphicswindow
choose
Batch
Select
fMRImodelspecification
Modelestimation
ContrastManager
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
89/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Directory:choosethePPIV2directory
Unitsfor
design:
scans
(actually
doesnt
matter
in
thiscasesinceweuseonlyregressors).
Interscaninterval:3.22
AddaNew
subject/session
Scans:choosethefMRIscans
ClickRegressorsandadd3regressors
Regressor
1:
Name:
PPI
interaction,
Value:
PPI Regressor2:Name:V2BOLD,Value:Y
Regressor3:Name:Psych_AttNoAtt,Value:P
Cli k M l i l d h h
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
90/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
ClickMultiple
regressors
and
choose
the
multi_block_regressor.matfile
HighPassFilter:192
ClickModel
Estimation
SelectSPM.matClickDependencyandchoosefMRImodelspecification:SPM.matFile
Contrastmanager
SelectSPM.mat
ClickDependencyandchooseModelestimation:SPM.matFile ContrastSessions NewTContrast
Name:
Interaction
V2
x
(Att
NoAtt) Weightsvector:[1]
Savethebatchfile Run
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
91/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
PPI Y P
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
92/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
ClickResults
SelectSPM.mat
Choose PPIcontrast
ApplyMasking:None
Title:Interaction pvalueadjust:None Thresholdp:0.005(was0.01inspm8)
&extent
threshold:
3
GotoV5(39720)
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
93/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
Results Choose SPM mat
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
94/105
D.
Gitelman
ResultsChooseSPM.mat
Motioncontrast
ApplyMasking:none
pvalueadjustment:FWE
thresholdT
or
pvalue:
0.05
&extentthresholdvoxels:3
Gotopoint[39720]
Clickeigenvariate
Nameof
region:
V5
Adjustfor:EffectsofInterest
ROIdefinition:sphere
Sphereradius(mm):6
(TheVOIfileissavedtothe
GLMdirectory.)
Click PPI button
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
95/105
D.
Gitelman
ClickPPI
button
SelectSPM.matintheGLMdirectory.
Analysistype:PPI
SelectVOI_V5_1.mat IncludeStationary:No IncludeNoAttention:
Yes
Contrastweight:
1
IncludeAttention:Yes Contrastweight:1 NameofPPI:V5x(Att
NoAtt)
(ThePPIfileisautomaticallysavedtotheGLMdirectory.
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
96/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
cdtotheGLMdirectory
>>load
PPI_V5x(Att
NoAtt)
ThismustbedonebeforesettingupthePPIGLMsothevariablesareintheMatlabworkspace.
FromthetasksmenuatthetopoftheGraphicswindow
choose
Batch
Select
fMRImodelspecification
Modelestimation
ContrastManager
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
97/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
Directory:choosethePPIV5directory
Unitsfor
design:
scans
(actually
doesnt
matter
in
thiscasesinceweuseonlyregressors).
Interscaninterval:3.22
Add
a
New
subject/session Scans:choosethefMRIscans
ClickRegressorsandadd3regressors
Regressor
1:
Name:
PPI
interaction,
Value:
PPI Regressor2:Name:V2BOLD,Value:Y
Regressor3:Name:Psych_AttNoAtt,Value:P
Click Multiple regressors and choose the
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
98/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
ClickMultiple
regressors
and
choose
the
multi_block_regressor.matfile
HighPassFilter:192
ClickModel
Estimation
SelectSPM.matClickDependencyandchoosefMRImodelspecification:SPM.matFile
Contrastmanager
SelectSPM.mat
ClickDependencyandchooseModelestimation:SPM.matFile ContrastSessions NewTContrast
Name:
Interaction
(V5
x
(Att
NoAtt)) Weightsvector:[1]
Savethebatchfile
Run
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
99/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
ClickResults
SelectSPM.mat
Choose
PPI
contrast ApplyMasking:None
Title:Interaction
pvalueadjust:None
Threshold
p:
0.001 &extentthreshold:10
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
100/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
IfyouhaverunthroughboththeV2V5andthe
V5
V2sections
you
should
now
have
2VOI
files:
VOI_V2_1.matandVOI_V5_1.mat.
Ifyouhavenotrunthroughbothsectionsthen
goback
to
either
the
slides
titled:
Extracting
VOI:V2V5orExtractingVOI:V5V2andcreatetheVOIs
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
101/105
D.
GitelmanD.
Gitelman
Create4PPIs(ClickPPIbutton,thenchoosepsychophysiologicalinteractionasthetaskto
perform.) V2xNoAttention(UsetheV2VOIandincludeNoAttention
withacontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,Attention).Saveasv2noatt
V2xAttention(Use
the
V2
VOI
and
include
Attention
with
acontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,No
Attention).Saveasv2att V5xNoAttention(UsetheV5VOIandincludeNoAttention
withacontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,Attention).
Save
as
v5noatt
V5xAttention(UsetheV5VOIandincludeAttentionwithacontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,NoAttention. Saveasv5att
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
102/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
LoadthePPIsyoujustcreated(TheywillbeintheGLMdirectory.)
>>v2noatt
=load('PPI_v2noatt.mat');
>>v2att=load('PPI_v2att.mat');
>>v5noatt=load('PPI_v5noatt.mat');
>>
v5att
=
load('PPI_v5att.mat'); PlotthePPIdatapoints
figure
plot(v2noatt.PPI.ppi,v5noatt.PPI.ppi,'k.')
holdon
plot(v2att.PPI.ppi,v5att.PPI.ppi,'r.');
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
103/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
Draw
the
regression
lines >>lsline
Labelit
>>legend('NoAttention','Attention')
>>xlabel('V2eigenvariate')
>>ylabel('V5
eigenvariate')
>>title('Psychophysiologic Interaction')
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
104/105
D.GitelmanD.Gitelman
-
8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman
105/105
D.Gitelman