PPI Darren Gitelman

download PPI Darren Gitelman

of 105

Transcript of PPI Darren Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    1/105

    DarrenGitelman,

    MD

    [email protected]

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    2/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Functionalintegration Analysesofinterregionaleffects

    Whataretheinteractionsbetween

    theelementsofaneuronal

    system?

    Univariate&Multivariateanalysis

    Functionalintegration Analysesofinterregionaleffects

    Whataretheinteractionsbetween

    theelementsofaneuronal

    system?

    Univariate&Multivariateanalysis

    Functionalspecialization Analysesofregionallyspecific

    effects

    Whichregionsarespecializedforaparticulartask?)

    Univariateanalysis

    Functionalspecialization Analysesofregionallyspecific

    effects

    Whichregionsarespecializedforaparticulartask?)

    Univariateanalysis

    K.Stephan,FIL

    StandardSPM

    Effectiveconnectivity

    Effectiveconnectivity

    Functionalconnectivity

    Functionalconnectivity

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    3/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Functionalintegration

    Functionalintegration

    Functionalconnectivity Temporalcorrelationsbetween

    spatiallyremote

    areas

    MODEL-FREE

    Exploratory

    Data Driven

    No Causation

    Whole brain connectivity

    Functionalconnectivity Temporalcorrelationsbetween

    spatiallyremote

    areas

    MODEL-FREE

    Exploratory

    Data Driven

    No Causation

    Whole brain connectivity

    Effectiveconnectivity Theinfluencethatoneneuronal

    systemexerts

    over

    another

    MODEL-DEPENDENT

    Confirmatory

    Hypothesis driven

    Causal (based on a model)

    Reduced set of regions

    Effectiveconnectivity Theinfluencethatoneneuronal

    systemexerts

    over

    another

    MODEL-DEPENDENT

    Confirmatory

    Hypothesis driven

    Causal (based on a model)

    Reduced set of regions

    K.Stephan,FIL;S.WhitfieldGabrieli

    PPI

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    4/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    maineffect

    oftask

    maineffect

    ofstim.

    type interaction

    Confounds

    + error

    Task factorTask A Task B

    TA/S1 TB/

    S1

    TA/S2 TB/S2

    Stim1

    Stim2

    Stimulusfa

    ctor

    y

    y

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    5/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    T

    S

    A B

    SignificantInteraction

    (TxS)

    Factor Tissignificant

    FactorSissignificant

    FactorsT&Saresignificant

    Significant

    maineffectsandinteraction

    NomaineffectNointeraction

    A BT

    A BT

    A BT

    A BT

    A BT

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    6/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Two

    (or

    more)

    experimental

    /

    psychological

    factors

    Changein

    regression

    slope

    due

    to

    the

    differentialresponsetooneexperimentalcondition undertheinfluenceofdifferent

    experimentalcontexts.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    7/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Task:Lettersandtonespresented

    simultaneously.(PET

    scan).

    Factor1:Tonespresentedatdifferentrates.

    Factor2:Subjectsattendandrespond toeithera

    targetletter

    (A)

    or

    atarget

    tone

    (low)

    .

    Is

    there

    a

    differential

    sensitivity

    to

    the

    presentationrateoftoneswhenpayingattentiontotonesvs.payingattentiontoletters?

    Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    8/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Attention (A)Tones Letters

    )

    AT/R1 AL/R1

    AT/R2 AL/R2

    Stim

    1

    Stim2

    Pres

    entation

    rate(R)

    AT/R3 AL/R3Stim3

    Tonesvs.Letters

    Rateoftones

    interaction

    Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    9/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Activityinauditorycortexvariesbypresentationrateregardlessof

    whethersubjectspaidattentiontotonesorletters.

    Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    10/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Activityintherightthalamusisinfluencedbypresentationrateoftoneswhensubjectsattendedtotonesvs.attendingtoletters.

    Frith&Friston,Neuroimage,1996

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    11/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Two(or

    more)

    physiological

    factors

    (i.e.,

    neural

    activitysignals)

    Changeinregressionslopeduetothedifferentialresponseofthesignal(neuralactivity)from

    region1due

    to

    the

    signal

    from

    region

    2.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    12/105

    D.Gitelman Bucheletal,CerebCortex,1997

    Key

    M=Dummyscans(discarded)

    F=

    Fixation(central

    dot)

    A=Attention:radiallymoving

    dots.Subjectstoldtodetect

    changesinspeedofdots(no

    changesactually

    occurred

    duringscanning).

    N=Noattention:radiallymovingdotsviewedpassively.

    S=Stationary:250stationary

    dots

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    13/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Task factor

    Attention No attention

    TA/S1 TN/S1

    TA/S2 TN/S2

    Nomotion

    Motion

    Stim

    ulusfactor

    SM

    NA

    SS

    TT )(

    SM

    NA

    SS

    TT )(

    Region1 Region2 interaction

    ActivityinRegion1

    ActivityinRegion2

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    14/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Task:Subjectsaskedtodetectspeedchangesinradiallymovingdots(fMRI).

    Doesactivityinposteriorparietal (PP)cortex

    (attentional

    area)

    modulate

    the

    response

    to

    V1

    (motionarea)activity(oristhereacontributionfromPPthatdependsonV1activity)?

    Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997

    Region1 Region2 interaction

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    15/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997

    modulationoftheV1V5contributionbyPP? modulationofthePPV5contributionbyV1?

    Z=5.77

    P

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    16/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    1Physiologicalfactor(neuralactivity)

    1Psychologicalfactor(experimentalcontext)

    Change

    in

    regression

    slope

    due

    to

    the

    differential

    responseofthe signalfromoneregionundertheinfluenceofdifferentexperimentalcontexts.

    Bilinear

    model

    of

    how

    the

    psychological

    contextchangestheinfluenceofoneareaonanother.

    Friston et al. NeuroImage, 1997

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    17/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Task factor

    Attention No attention

    TA/S1 TN/S1

    TA/S2 TN/S2

    Nomotion

    Motion

    Stim

    ulusfactor

    SM

    NA

    SS

    TTT )(

    SM

    NA

    SS

    TTT )(

    Taskfactor SourceRegion

    interaction

    Psychologicalfactor

    ActivityinSourceregion

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    18/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997

    Task:Subjectsaskedtodetectspeedchangesinradiallymovingdots(fMRI).

    Doesthetask(attention)modulatetheresponse,

    to

    V1

    activity,

    or

    does

    activity

    in

    V1

    influence

    the

    responsetoattention?[Inferenceontaskandregionaleffects]

    Taskfactor SourceRegion

    interaction

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    19/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Twopossibleinterpretations Modulation

    of

    the

    contribution

    of

    V1

    to

    V5

    by

    attention

    (context

    specific) ModulationofattentionspecificresponsesinV5byV1inputs

    (stimulusspecific)

    Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    20/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Activityinregion

    k

    Experimentalfactor

    Responseinregioni

    =k+ T + kx T

    k T

    + kx T

    Activityin

    regionk

    Experimental

    factor

    Responseinregioni

    =k+ T + kx T

    k T

    + kx T

    Contextspecificmodulationofresponsestostimulus

    Stimulusrelatedmodulation ofresponsestocontext(attention)

    Fristonetal,Neuroimage,1997

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    21/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    ArePPIs

    the

    same

    as

    correlations?

    No

    PPIsarebasedonregressionsandexplicitly

    discountmain

    effects (discountsimplecorrelations)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    22/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    KimandHorwitzinvestigatedcorrelationsvs.PPIregression

    using

    abiologically

    plausible

    neural

    model.

    PPI

    results

    were

    similar

    to

    those

    based

    on

    integratedsynapticactivity(goldstandard)

    Resultsfromcorrelationswerenotsignificantfor

    manyof

    the

    functional

    connections.

    Achangeininfluencebetween2regionsmaynot

    involveachangeinsignalcorrelation

    Kim&Horwitz,MagResMed,2008

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    23/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    AlthoughPPIsselectasourceandfindtargetregions,theycannotdeterminethedirectionality

    ofconnectivity.

    Theregressionequationsarereversible.TheslopeofA BisapproximatelythereciprocalofBA

    (notexactly

    the

    reciprocal

    because

    of

    measurement

    error)

    Directionalityshouldbeprespecifiedandbasedonknowledgeofanatomyorotherexperimental

    results.

    Source Target Source Target

    ?

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    24/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    25/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Becausetheyconsistofonly1inputregion,PPIsare

    modelsof

    contributions

    rather

    than

    effective

    connectivity.

    PPIsdependonfactorialdesigns,otherwisetheinteractionandmaineffectsmaynotbeorthogonal,and

    the

    sensitivity

    to

    the

    interaction

    effect

    will

    be

    low.

    ProblemswithPPIs

    Interactionterm

    not

    formed

    correctly

    (as

    originally

    proposed)

    Analysiscanbeoverlysensitivetothechoiceofregion.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    26/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    V1xAttention

    Psychophysiological

    interaction

    term

    originally

    formed

    by

    multiplyingmeasureBOLDsignalbycontextvector(orby

    anotherBOLDsignalinthecaseofphysiophysiologicalinteractions)

    Friston,etal.Neuroimage,1997

    xkx gp

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    27/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Regionalactivity

    measured

    as

    aBOLD

    time

    series

    =hemodynamicresponse neuralactivity

    =convolution

    InitialformulationofPPIestimatedtheinteractionterm

    as

    BOLD

    xcontext

    vector.

    BUT:Interactionsactuallyoccurataneuronallevel! Thereforeneuronalactivitymustbeestimatedfrom

    hemodynamicactivity

    But,thisisdifficultbecausemappingfromBOLDsignaltoneuralsignalisnonunique(duetolossofhighfrequencyinformation)(Zarahn,Neuroimage,2000)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    28/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Hxyxhytt

    yt =MeasuredBOLDsignalh=hemodynamic (impulse)responsefunctionxt =neuronalsignal

    H =HRF

    in

    Toeplitz

    matrix

    form

    Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

    BABABA

    xxHHxHxyy

    AAA PxHHxHPHPy

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    29/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

    HRF HRF

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    30/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

    HRF

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    31/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Cantryusingamaximumlikelihoodestimator(i.e.,

    leastsquares)

    but

    this

    runs

    into

    trouble

    with

    high

    frequencycomponents. Zarahnconstrainedtheestimatestoparticulartemporal

    intervals.(Zarahn,Neuroimage,2000)

    CantryusingaWeinerfilter,butthisrequireshighSNRandanestimateofthenoisespectraldensity.(Glover,Neuroimage,1999)

    Useempirical

    Bayes

    deconvolution

    to

    finesse

    the

    noiseestimatesbysettingthepriorprecisionsonthehighfrequenciesto0.(Gitelman,Neuroimage,2003)

    Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    32/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    33/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

    BOLD

    Neural

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    34/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    35/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2003

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    36/105

    D.Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    37/105

    D.Gitelman

    Istheredletterleftorrightfromthemidlineoftheword?

    group analysis (random effects),

    n=16, pletterdecisions

    Stephan et al, Science, 2003

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    38/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Bilateral ACC activation in both tasks

    but asymmetric connectivity !

    IPS

    IFG

    Left ACC left inf.frontalgyrus(IFG):increaseduringletter decisions.

    Right ACC right IPS:

    increase

    during

    spatial decisions.

    leftACC(6,16,42)

    rightACC(8,16,48)

    spatialvs.letterdecisions

    lettervs.spatial

    decisions

    groupanalysisrandomeffects(n=15)

    p

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    39/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    PPI single-subject example

    bVS=0.16

    bL=0.63

    Signal

    in

    left

    ACC

    Sign

    alin

    leftIFG

    bL=0.19

    Signal

    inright

    ant.

    IP

    S

    Signal

    in

    right

    ACC

    bVS=0.50

    LeftACCsignalplottedagainstleftIFG

    spatial

    decisions

    letterdecisions

    letterdecisions

    spatialdecisions

    RightACCsignalplottedagainstrightIPS

    Stephan et al, Science, 2003

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    40/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal., ChemSenses,2007

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    41/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal., ChemSenses,2007

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    42/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009

    Atalowerthreshold(Punc =0.005,influences

    wereseenfromFEF,POandPPConAI/FO.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    43/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    44/105

    D.GitelmanD.GitelmanVeldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    45/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Veldhuizenetal.,OHBM2009

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    46/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Inkblottest

    Common/frequent Infrequent

    Rare/unusual

    Increased

    in

    schizophrenia

    and

    certain

    personality

    disorders

    Associatedwithunusualperceptionandhigherpercentageofunusualresponsesinartisticpopulations.

    Sinceamygdala

    activity

    can

    affect

    perceptual

    processinghypothesisisthatamygdalaisactiveduringinkblottest.

    http://www.testderorschach.com.ar/en/inkblots.htmAsari

    et

    al.,

    Psych

    Res,

    2010

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    47/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    VBMdemonstratedincreasedamygdala&cingulatevolumeinsubjectswithmoreunusualresponses.

    Asarietal.,Cortex,2010

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    48/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    fMRIstudyresponsestoinkblottest [unique frequent]:temporalpole (p

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    49/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Temporalpolemaylinksensoryinputfromoccipitotemporal

    regionswithtopdownfrontalcontrolandemotional

    modulationbytheamygdalaAsarietal.,Neuroimage,2010

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    50/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2002

    Saccade

    Explore

    Central

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    51/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2002

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    52/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman Gitelmanetal.,Neuroimage,2002

    Areasshowingconnectivitywiththesuperiorcolliculusundertheexplore

    butnot

    the

    saccade

    condition

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    53/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Pros:

    Givenasingle

    source

    region,

    we

    can

    test

    for

    its

    context

    dependentconnectivityacrosstheentirebrain

    Simpletoperform

    Cons: Very

    simplistic

    model:

    only

    allows

    modelling

    contributions

    fromasinglearea

    Ignorestimeseriespropertiesofdata(candoPPIsonPET

    and

    fMRI

    data) Inputsarenotmodelledexplicitly

    Interactionsareinstantaneous

    K.Stephan,FIL

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    54/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    NonfactorialPPIsareinefficient PPI termandP(psychologicalvariable)arehighlycorrelated (0.86)in

    thematrix

    shown

    below.

    This

    will

    reduce

    the

    sensitivity

    for

    estimating

    thePPIeffect(basedonattentiontomotiondataset)

    Tableof

    correlations

    between

    regressors

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    55/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Seethe

    paper:

    McLaren,

    D.G.,

    Ries,

    M.L.,

    Xu,

    G.,

    Johnson,S.C.,2012.Ageneralizedformofcontextdependentpsychophysiological

    interactions(gPPI):

    acomparison

    to

    standard

    approaches.NeuroImage61,12771286.

    NITRC.ORGsite:

    https://www.nitrc.org/projects/gppi

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    56/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Psychological

    regressor

    Regionalsignal

    PPI

    D.McLaren,Neuroimage,2012

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    57/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    SPMPPI SPMPPI2

    conditions

    gPPI

    A[fix](1condition) .9876 .9876

    AB(2conditions) .8675 .9889

    SPMPPI1

    condition

    SPMPPI2

    conditions

    gPPI

    A[fix](1condition) 3.6676 3.6676

    AB(2conditions) 6.4581 3.5447

    BetaEstimates

    SumsofSquares

    D.McLaren,personalcommunication

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    58/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman D.

    McLaren,

    Neuroimage,

    2012

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    59/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman D.

    McLaren,

    Neuroimage,

    2012

    k

    =

    #

    regressorsn=#timepoints

    RSS=residual

    sumofsquares

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    60/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    PlotofAIC:Lowerisbetter

    D.McLaren,

    Neuroimage,

    2012

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    61/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman D.

    McLaren,

    Neuroimage,

    2012

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    62/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    IncludingmaineffectsinmyPPIanalysistakes

    awayall

    the

    interaction

    results.

    Do

    Ihave

    to

    includemaineffects?

    Absolutely!Otherwise,theinferenceoninteractions

    willbe

    confounded

    by

    main

    effects.

    ShouldIincludemovementregressorsinmyPPIanalysis?

    Yes,include

    any

    nuisance

    effects

    you

    would

    normally

    include.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    63/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Whatdoes

    it

    mean

    to

    adjust

    for

    different

    effects?

    Adjustingforeffectsmeanskeepingeffectsofinterest

    andremovingeffectsofnointerest,e.g.,movement

    regressors,block

    effects,

    etc.

    InordertoadjustaneffectsofinterestFcontrast

    shouldbesetupbeforetryingtoextractthedata.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    64/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    ShouldVOIsbebasedontheexactlocationsof

    groupeffects

    or

    should

    they

    be

    subject

    specific?

    Both.VOIsshouldbesubjectspecific,butshouldbe

    closeenoughto amaximabasedonagroup

    analysis,

    the

    literature

    ,

    etc.

    Close

    enough

    depends

    onwherethemaximaisinthebrain,thesmoothnessofthedata,etc.Closeenoughinthecaudatemightbe5mm,whileintheparietalcortex,close enough

    mightbe

    1cm.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    65/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    HowdoIselectregionsthatarecloseenoughtoamaxima? Displayacontrastthatshowstheregionsofinterest. MovetheSPMcursortothegroupmaxima. Rightclickinthegraphicswindownexttotheglassbrain.The

    cursorwilljumptotheclosestmaxima,andthenumberofmmit

    moveswill

    be

    recorded

    in

    the

    Matlab

    window.

    Make

    anote

    of

    howfarthecursormoves. Nowclickeigenvariateandextractasusual

    HowbigshouldtheVOIsbe?

    Thisdepends

    on

    the

    smoothness

    of

    the

    data

    and

    the

    region.

    If

    youhavehighresolutiondata orareinasubcorticalnucleusyouprobablywantasmallersphere.Generallybetween4and8mmradiusspheresareused.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    66/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Howis

    agroup

    PPI

    analysis

    done?

    Theconimagesfromtheinteractiontermcanbebroughttoastandardsecondlevelanalysis(onesamplettestwithinagroup,twosamplettest

    betweengroups,

    ANOVAs,

    etc.)

    CanIrunaPPIbasedonasinglemaineffect? Yes,butthisisnotanoptimaldesign.Itisimportantto

    realizethat

    the

    interaction

    term

    will

    be

    very

    highly

    correlatedwiththemaineffectregressor,resultinginverylowpowerfordetectingtheinteractioneffect.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    67/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    68/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    RunastandardGLManalysis Includeconditionsandanynuisanceeffects(motion,etc.)

    Foreaseofanalysiscombinemultiplesessionsintoasinglesessionandincludeblockeffects

    Displaycontrastofinterest

    ExtractVOI

    (volume

    of

    interest),

    adjusting

    for

    effectsofinterest(i.e.,excludeanynuisanceregressors)

    PPIbutton

    (makes

    PPI

    regressors)

    SPM.matfilefromstandardGLManalysis

    SetupcontrastofPsychconditions

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    69/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    RunPPIGLManalysis

    PPI.ppi(interaction)

    PPI.Y(maineffect:sourceregionBOLDdata)

    PPI.P

    (main

    effect:

    Psych

    conditions

    that

    formed

    PPI) Contrastis[100]forpositiveeffectof

    interactionand[100]fornegativeeffect

    (assumingconditions

    entered

    in

    order

    listed)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    70/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Theanalysis

    directory

    should

    include:

    Directorynamedfunctionalwhichincludesthe

    preprocessedfMRIvolumes

    Directoryname

    structural,

    which

    includes

    aT1

    image

    Files:factors.mat,block_regressors.mat,

    multi_condition.matandmulti_block_regressors.mat

    Make3empty

    directories

    called

    GLM,

    PPI

    V2

    and

    PPIV5

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    71/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    FromMatlab

    command

    prompt

    >>cdpathtoanalysisdirectory

    MakesureSPM12isintheMatlabpath

    Start

    SPM:

    spm

    FromtheTasksmenuatthetopoftheGraphics

    windowchoose

    Batch

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    72/105

    D.Gitelman

    FromtheSPMmenuinthebatchwindow,selectstatsthenselect:

    fMRImodel

    specification

    Modelestimation

    ContrastManager

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    73/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Directory:choosetheGLMdirectory

    Unitsfor

    designs:

    scans

    Interscaninterval:3.22

    Click

    Data

    &

    Design

    then

    New:

    Subject/Session Scans:choosethefunctionalscans

    Wewilladdtheconditionsusingmultiplecondition

    and

    regressor

    files.

    The

    files

    are

    called: Multipleconditions:multi_condition.mat

    Multipleregressors:multi_block_regressors.mat

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    74/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Tolookatthefile(notnecessaryfortheanalysis,butjustfordidacticpurposes)

    >>load

    multi_condition.mat

    ThentypenamesoronsetsordurationintheMatlabcommandwindow.

    Contains3cellarraysofthesamesize(notallentries

    areshown

    below)

    names names{1}=Stationary; names{2}=Noattention;

    onsets onsets{1} =[80170260350];

    durations durations{1}=10;(canbejustasinglenumberifalleventshavethe

    sameduration)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    75/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Tolookatthefile(notnecessaryfortheanalysis,butjustfordidacticpurposes)

    >>load

    multi_block_regressor.mat

    Thefilecontains avariableR.,whichisanNxMmatrix N=numberofscans M=numberofregressors

    Blockregressors

    model

    different

    sessions.

    Use

    this

    command

    to

    set

    up.

    Canalsousevariouscombinationsofzerosandonesfunctions. >>R=kron(eye(3),ones(90,1));zeros(90,3)]); or >>R= [blkdiag(ones(90,1),ones(90,1),ones(90,1));zeros(90,3)];

    1 2 3

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    350

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    76/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    HighPassFilter:192

    Note:

    most

    designs

    will

    use

    a

    high

    pass

    filter

    value

    of

    128.

    Thisdatasetrequiresalongerhighpass filterinordernot

    tolosethelowfrequencycomponentsofthedesign.

    Thedefaultvaluesontherestoftheentriesarecorrect

    ClickModelEstimation SelectSPM.mat

    Click

    Dependency

    and

    choose

    fMRI

    model

    specification:SPM.matFile

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    77/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Contrastmanager

    SelectSPM.mat

    ClickDependencyandchooseModelestimation:SPM.matfile

    ContrastSessions

    NewFContrast

    Name:Effectsofinterest

    Weightsmatrix:eye(3)

    100

    010

    001

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    78/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    ContrastSessions New

    T

    Contrast

    Name:Attention

    Weightsvector:[011]

    NewT

    Contrast

    Name:Motion

    Tcontrastvector:[211]

    ClickSave

    button

    and

    save

    the

    batch

    file

    ClickRunbutton(greenarrow)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    79/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    80/105

    D.Gitelman

    Thechange

    in

    the

    designmatrix

    comparedwiththe

    previousslideisdue

    tonon

    sphericity

    effects.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    81/105

    D.Gitelman

    ClickResults

    SelectSPM.mat

    ChooseAttentioncontrast

    ApplyMasking:

    None

    pvalueadjust:None

    Thresholdp:0.0001

    &extentthreshold:10

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    82/105

    D.Gitelman

    ClickResults

    SelectSPM.mat

    ChooseMotioncontrast

    ApplyMasking:contrast

    SelectMask:Attention

    Uncorrectedmaskp:0.01

    Natureofmask:inclusive

    pvalueadjust:FWE

    Thresholdp:0.05

    &extentthreshold:3

    Exampleofapsychologicalinteraction

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    83/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    84/105

    D.Gitelman

    ResultsChooseSPM.mat Motioncontrast

    ApplyMasking:none

    pvalueadjustment:FWE

    thresholdT

    or

    pvalue:

    0.05

    &extentthresholdvoxels:3

    Gotopoint[15789]

    Clickeigenvariate

    Nameof

    region:

    V2

    Adjustfor:EffectsofInterest

    ROIdefinition:sphere

    Sphereradius(mm):6

    (TheVOIfileissavedtothe

    GLMdirectory.)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    85/105

    D.Gitelman

    ClickPPI

    button

    SelectSPM.matintheGLMdirectory.

    Analysistype:PPI

    SelectVOI_V2_1.mat IncludeStationary:No IncludeNoAttention:

    Yes

    Contrastweight:

    1

    IncludeAttention:Yes Contrastweight:1 NameofPPI:V2x(Att

    NoAtt)

    (ThePPIfileisautomaticallysavedtotheGLMdirectory.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    86/105

    D.Gitelman

    Openbatchwindow

    FromtheSPMmenuselectStats>Physio/Psychophysiologic

    Interaction ForSPM.matselect

    theoneintheGLM

    folder

    Typeof

    analysis

    :Psychophysiologic

    Interaction

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    87/105

    D.Gitelman

    Typeof

    analysis

    :Psycho

    physiologicInteraction

    VOI:choosetheV2VOI

    Inputvariablesandcontrast

    weights

    Column1isthecondition(seeSPM.Sess.U),column2

    willusuallybe1,column3isthecontrastweight.

    Name

    of

    PPI:

    :

    V2x(Att

    NoAtt)

    Savethebatchfile

    Runthebatchfile

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    88/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    cdtotheGLMdirectory.

    >>load

    PPI_V2x(Att

    NoAtt)

    ThismustbedonebeforesettingupthePPIGLMsothevariablesareintheMatlabworkspace.

    FromthetasksmenuatthetopoftheGraphicswindow

    choose

    Batch

    Select

    fMRImodelspecification

    Modelestimation

    ContrastManager

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    89/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Directory:choosethePPIV2directory

    Unitsfor

    design:

    scans

    (actually

    doesnt

    matter

    in

    thiscasesinceweuseonlyregressors).

    Interscaninterval:3.22

    AddaNew

    subject/session

    Scans:choosethefMRIscans

    ClickRegressorsandadd3regressors

    Regressor

    1:

    Name:

    PPI

    interaction,

    Value:

    PPI Regressor2:Name:V2BOLD,Value:Y

    Regressor3:Name:Psych_AttNoAtt,Value:P

    Cli k M l i l d h h

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    90/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    ClickMultiple

    regressors

    and

    choose

    the

    multi_block_regressor.matfile

    HighPassFilter:192

    ClickModel

    Estimation

    SelectSPM.matClickDependencyandchoosefMRImodelspecification:SPM.matFile

    Contrastmanager

    SelectSPM.mat

    ClickDependencyandchooseModelestimation:SPM.matFile ContrastSessions NewTContrast

    Name:

    Interaction

    V2

    x

    (Att

    NoAtt) Weightsvector:[1]

    Savethebatchfile Run

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    91/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    PPI Y P

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    92/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    ClickResults

    SelectSPM.mat

    Choose PPIcontrast

    ApplyMasking:None

    Title:Interaction pvalueadjust:None Thresholdp:0.005(was0.01inspm8)

    &extent

    threshold:

    3

    GotoV5(39720)

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    93/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    Results Choose SPM mat

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    94/105

    D.

    Gitelman

    ResultsChooseSPM.mat

    Motioncontrast

    ApplyMasking:none

    pvalueadjustment:FWE

    thresholdT

    or

    pvalue:

    0.05

    &extentthresholdvoxels:3

    Gotopoint[39720]

    Clickeigenvariate

    Nameof

    region:

    V5

    Adjustfor:EffectsofInterest

    ROIdefinition:sphere

    Sphereradius(mm):6

    (TheVOIfileissavedtothe

    GLMdirectory.)

    Click PPI button

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    95/105

    D.

    Gitelman

    ClickPPI

    button

    SelectSPM.matintheGLMdirectory.

    Analysistype:PPI

    SelectVOI_V5_1.mat IncludeStationary:No IncludeNoAttention:

    Yes

    Contrastweight:

    1

    IncludeAttention:Yes Contrastweight:1 NameofPPI:V5x(Att

    NoAtt)

    (ThePPIfileisautomaticallysavedtotheGLMdirectory.

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    96/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    cdtotheGLMdirectory

    >>load

    PPI_V5x(Att

    NoAtt)

    ThismustbedonebeforesettingupthePPIGLMsothevariablesareintheMatlabworkspace.

    FromthetasksmenuatthetopoftheGraphicswindow

    choose

    Batch

    Select

    fMRImodelspecification

    Modelestimation

    ContrastManager

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    97/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    Directory:choosethePPIV5directory

    Unitsfor

    design:

    scans

    (actually

    doesnt

    matter

    in

    thiscasesinceweuseonlyregressors).

    Interscaninterval:3.22

    Add

    a

    New

    subject/session Scans:choosethefMRIscans

    ClickRegressorsandadd3regressors

    Regressor

    1:

    Name:

    PPI

    interaction,

    Value:

    PPI Regressor2:Name:V2BOLD,Value:Y

    Regressor3:Name:Psych_AttNoAtt,Value:P

    Click Multiple regressors and choose the

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    98/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    ClickMultiple

    regressors

    and

    choose

    the

    multi_block_regressor.matfile

    HighPassFilter:192

    ClickModel

    Estimation

    SelectSPM.matClickDependencyandchoosefMRImodelspecification:SPM.matFile

    Contrastmanager

    SelectSPM.mat

    ClickDependencyandchooseModelestimation:SPM.matFile ContrastSessions NewTContrast

    Name:

    Interaction

    (V5

    x

    (Att

    NoAtt)) Weightsvector:[1]

    Savethebatchfile

    Run

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    99/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    ClickResults

    SelectSPM.mat

    Choose

    PPI

    contrast ApplyMasking:None

    Title:Interaction

    pvalueadjust:None

    Threshold

    p:

    0.001 &extentthreshold:10

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    100/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    IfyouhaverunthroughboththeV2V5andthe

    V5

    V2sections

    you

    should

    now

    have

    2VOI

    files:

    VOI_V2_1.matandVOI_V5_1.mat.

    Ifyouhavenotrunthroughbothsectionsthen

    goback

    to

    either

    the

    slides

    titled:

    Extracting

    VOI:V2V5orExtractingVOI:V5V2andcreatetheVOIs

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    101/105

    D.

    GitelmanD.

    Gitelman

    Create4PPIs(ClickPPIbutton,thenchoosepsychophysiologicalinteractionasthetaskto

    perform.) V2xNoAttention(UsetheV2VOIandincludeNoAttention

    withacontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,Attention).Saveasv2noatt

    V2xAttention(Use

    the

    V2

    VOI

    and

    include

    Attention

    with

    acontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,No

    Attention).Saveasv2att V5xNoAttention(UsetheV5VOIandincludeNoAttention

    withacontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,Attention).

    Save

    as

    v5noatt

    V5xAttention(UsetheV5VOIandincludeAttentionwithacontrastweightof1,donotincludeStationary,NoAttention. Saveasv5att

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    102/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    LoadthePPIsyoujustcreated(TheywillbeintheGLMdirectory.)

    >>v2noatt

    =load('PPI_v2noatt.mat');

    >>v2att=load('PPI_v2att.mat');

    >>v5noatt=load('PPI_v5noatt.mat');

    >>

    v5att

    =

    load('PPI_v5att.mat'); PlotthePPIdatapoints

    figure

    plot(v2noatt.PPI.ppi,v5noatt.PPI.ppi,'k.')

    holdon

    plot(v2att.PPI.ppi,v5att.PPI.ppi,'r.');

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    103/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

    Draw

    the

    regression

    lines >>lsline

    Labelit

    >>legend('NoAttention','Attention')

    >>xlabel('V2eigenvariate')

    >>ylabel('V5

    eigenvariate')

    >>title('Psychophysiologic Interaction')

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    104/105

    D.GitelmanD.Gitelman

  • 8/9/2019 PPI Darren Gitelman

    105/105

    D.Gitelman