Power sector moving towards deregulation
Transcript of Power sector moving towards deregulation
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
1/88
1
Dr. YOG RAJ SOODProfessor & Dean (R & D)
Department Of Electrical EngineeringNAT ONA! NST T"TE O# TE$%NO!OGY
%A RP"R ' **+ (%.P.)
POWER SECTOR
MOVING TOWARDS
DEREGULATION
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
2/88
2
Since the mid-1980 the e!ect"ic#! $%&e"'$$!( ind' t"( #"%'nd the &%"!d h#e)$e"ienced # $e"i%d %* "#$id #nd c"itic#!ch#n+e , "e+#"din+ the ( e!ect"icit( i+ene"#ted, t"#n mitted #nd di t"i 'ted.
The need *%" m%"e e/cienc( in $%&e"$"%d'cti%n #nd de!i e"( h# !ed t%
$"i #ti #ti%n, "e t"'ct'"in+ #nd 2n#!!(de"e+'!#ti%n %* the $%&e" ect%" in e e"#!c%'nt"ie t"#diti%n#!!( 'nde" c%nt"%! %**ede"#! #nd t#te +% e"nment .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
3/88
3
M#n( c%'nt"ie !i3e En+!#nd, United St#te %*Ame"ic#, C#n#d#, A' t"#!i#, Ne& 4e#!#nd, Chi!e,A"+entin#, Pe"' #nd C%!%m i# #"e #!"e#d(e)e"ci in+ &ith de"e+'!#ted e!ect"icit( ind' t"(.
Th%'+h the"e #"e %me $it*#!! he"e #nd the"e, theend ' e" %* the ( tem #"e en5%(in+ the *"'it %*
the de"e+'!#ted e!ect"icit( ind' t"( t"ee.
M#n( de e!%$in+ c%'nt"ie !i3e INDIA #"e #! %m% in+ t%"d "e t"'ct'"in+ #nd de"e+'!#ti%n %*$%&e" ect%".
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
4/88
4
Wheeling It is the use of transmission facilities of a system to transmit
power for other sellers and buyers .
Definitions;Wheeling is the transmission of power from a seller to a
buyer through the network owned by a third party. It may be defined as, the use of transmission ordistribution facilities of a system to transmit power of and
for another entity or entities.
It may also be defined as , Wheeling is the use of some partys (or parties) transmission system(s) for the benefit ofthe other parties.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
5/88
5
In traditional power system, go ernments mostly ownthe integrated electricity utilities, ha ing completecontrol o er generation, transmission and distribution.
!istorically, wheeling has not been a ery importantissue. Inter ening utilities ha e been in ol edformally as part of a contract path between a buyerand a seller utility.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
6/88
"
Whee!in+ i # m%n+"e! c%nce$t "e '!tin+ *"%mm#tin+ t&% inhe"ent!( di6e"ent ec%n%micc%nce$t 7 #n ide#! &%"!d %* "e+'!#ted 'ti!itie , #nd
#n ide#! de"e+'!#ted c%m$etiti e m#"3et $!#ce.It i #n im$%"t#nt !in3 et&een c%n enti%n#!inte+"#ted $%&e" ( tem #nd de"e+'!#ted $%&e"ind' t"(.In de"e+'!#ted en i"%nment, the t"#n mi i%n( tem %&ne" c%'!d e c%n ide"ed # the thi"d$#"t( t% $"% ide &hee!in+ *%" '(e" "et#i!e" %"'!3 !%#d cente" #nd e!!e" +ene"#ti%nc%m$#nie %" IPP .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
7/88#
$ie line
GENERAT ON
D STR ,"T ON
TRANS SS ON
%ig 1.1& $raditional integrated power system
$ie line
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
8/88'
$ie line
GENERAT ON
TRANS SS ON
D STR ,"T ON
%ig 1.1& $raditional integrated power system
$ie line
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
9/88(
$he necessary re)uirement for deregulation isrestr-ct-ring of electricity supply industry *+ I-whose basic feat-res are as follows&$o introduce competition into a hithertomonopolistic industry. In order to achie e this, toseparate * ertical unbundling- the functions of
power generation, transmission, distribution andelectricity supply to consumers.$o create se eral competing electricity generationscompanies *hori ontal unbundling-.$o recogni e that the power transmission system is
a natural monopoly and, accordingly, to ma/especial regulatory pro isions in this respect.$o allow consumers, to e0ercise choice betweensuppliers *generation companies- while still usingthe e0isting transmission facilities.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
10/881
Transco
enco enco enco
encoenco
I
$ie lines$ie lines
Disco Disco
Deregulated power system
ul/ consumers
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
11/88
11
Transco
enco 1 enco 2 enco 3
enco 5enco 4
I
$ie lines$ie lines
Disco 1 Disco 2
Deregulated power system
ul/ consumers
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
12/88
12
:ene2t *"%m the
de"e+'!#ti%nM#in ene2t *"%m the de"e+'!#ti%n#"e, che#$e" e!ect"icit( #nd e/cientc#$#cit( e)$#n i%n $!#nnin+.
The de"e+'!#ti%n %* $%&e" ect%"$"% ide # *#i" c%m$etiti%n #m%n+
$"%d'ce" # &e!! # m%"e ch%ice#nd ette" e" ice *%" c%n 'me" %*e!ect"icit(.
T 2
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
13/88
13
13 12
L18 L17 L16 L15 L14 L11 L8
G3
L19
L20
L21
L22 L25
L27
L23
L24
11 10 9
8
7 4
G2
T 29T28
765KV
T 31T30
L12
L13
L10
L9
6
17
16G4
18
14
L26
3
L5
L4L3
G!
5
15
400KV
1
2
L2L1
T 1
T 1
T 2
T 2
T3
T 3
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
14/88
14
Wheeling transactions
It i de2ned # , ;the t"#n mi i%n %*e!ect"ic#! $%&e" *%" %the" entit( ie (# 'ti!it( th#t neithe" +ene"#te n%"intend t% ' e the $%&e" # # ( tem"e %'"ce *%" meetin+ it %&n n#ti e!%#d
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
15/88
15
T($e %* t"#n #cti%n
Feasible Transactions=e# i !e t"#n #cti%n c#n e
#cc%mm%d#ted &ith%'t i%!#tin+ thet"#n mi i%n net&%"3 c%n t"#int .Non-Feasible TransactionsUn*e# i !e t"#n #cti%n i%!#te
t"#n mi i%n net&%"3 c%n t"#int #ndhence c#nn%t e #cc%mm%d#ted*'!!(.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
16/88
1"
Firm Transactions The e #"e the t"#n #cti%n th#t #"e
n%t ' 5ect t% di c"eti%n#"(inte""'$ti%n . The e #"e #! % 3n%&n# "e e" ed t"#n #cti%n .
Non-frm Transactions The e t"#n #cti%n m#( e c'"t#i!ed#t the 'ti!it(> di c"eti%n. The e #"e#! % c#!!ed # -# #i!# !e t"#n #cti%n .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
17/88
1#
Bilateral TransactionsIt i # i!#te"#! e)ch#n+e %* $%&e" et&een #'(in+ #nd # e!!in+ entit(. The e)ch#n+e c#ne $"%$% ed, ched'!ed %" #ct'#!.Multilateral TransactionsIn # m'!ti!#te"#! t"#n #cti%n $%&e" i in5ected+ene"#ti%n #t di6e"ent ' e #nd t#3en %'t
!%#d #t %me #n%the" di6e"ent ' eim'!t#ne%' !(. S'ch th#t 'm %* #!!+ene"#ti%n i e?'#! t% #!! !%#d in thet"#n #cti%n, e)c!'din+ !% e . L% e m#( e'$$!ied ( +ene"#t%" %* the t"#n #cti%n %"
( the $%%!@'ti!it( # $e" $"e de2ned c%nt"#ct.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
18/88
1'
P"i #ti #ti%n
T"#n mi i%n O$en AcceTOARe- t"'ct'"in+
De-"e+'!#ti%n
Steps towardsSteps towards
deregulationderegulation
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
19/88
1(
Privatization:S#!e ( # +% e"nment %* it t#te-%&nede!ect"ic 'ti!it( # et , #nd %$e"#tin+c%m$#n(, t% $"i #te c%m$#nie .Transmission Open Access TOA!::ec#' e %* t"#n mi i%n %$en #cce ,
entitie th#t did n%t %&n t"#n mi i%n!ine &e"e +"#nted the "i+ht t% ' e thet"#n mi i%n ( tem. The #im %* TOA it% int"%d'ce c%m$etiti%n int% thet"#diti%n#! "e+'!#ted 'ti!itie &ith%'t+i in+ '$ the e)i tin+ "e+'!#tin+
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
20/88
2
"e-structuringRe- t"'ct'"in+ %* "e+'!#ted $%&e" ect%" it% e$#"#te the *'ncti%n %* $%&e"+ene"#ti%n, t"#n mi i%n #nd di t"i 'ti%n.#e-regulationIt i ch#n+in+ the m%n%$%!( *"#nchi e "'!e%" %the" "e+'!#ti%n %* "e+'!#ted ind' t"(,
th#t #6ect h%& e!ect"ic c%m$#nie d%' ine , #nd h%& c' t%me" m#( '(e!ect"ic $%&e" #nd e" ice .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
21/88
21
$OMPON%NT& OF #%"%'()AT%#$OMPON%NT& OF #%"%'()AT%#
&*&T%M&*&T%M
'eneration $ompanies 'encos!Buil+ Operate an+ Trans,er BOT! plant orn+epen+ent Po.er Pro+ucers PPs!Transmission $ompanies Transcos! an+Transmission O.ners Tos!#istribution $ompanies #iscos! an+"etailers
n+epen+ent &/stem Operator &O!Po.er %0changer P1!&che+uling $oor+inators &$s!
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
22/88
22
'eneration $ompanies'encos!Genc% #"e "e $%n i !e *%"%$e"#tin+ #nd m#int#inin++ene"#tin+ $!#nt in the +ene"#ti%nect%" #nd in m% t %* c# e , #"e the%&ne" %* the $!#nt . In %me c# eindi id'#! +ene"#t%" d% n%t m#"3etthei" %'t$'t, 't %n!( Genc% m#"3etthe %'t$'t %* #!! it +ene"#t%" .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
23/88
23
Buil+ Operate an+ Trans,er BOT!plant or n+epen+ent Po.erPro+ucers PPs!
:OT %" IPP c#n #ct # it %&n
+ene"#t%"- e" in+ entit( #ndinde$endent!( m#"3et it %'t$'t t% #t"#din+ entit( %" t% # !%#d e" in+entit(.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
24/88
24
Transmission $ompanies Transcos!an+ Transmission O.ners Tos!
T"#n c% m% e $%&e" in '!3 ?'#ntitie*"%m &he"e it i $"%d'ced t% &he"e it ide!i e"ed. In m% t de"e+'!#ted ind' t"(t"'ct'"e , the T"#n mi i%n c%m$#nie%&n #nd m#int#in t"#n mi i%n !ine'nde" m%n%$%!( *"#nchi e #nd #"ec#!!ed T"#n mi i%n O&ne" T% , 'tthe( d%e n%t %$e"#te them. Theinde$endent ( tem %$e"#t%" d% th#t.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
25/88
25
#istribution $ompanies
#iscos! an+ "etailersDi c% # 'me the #me "e $%n i i!it(%n the di t"i 'ti%n ide # in #t"#diti%n#! "e+'!#t%"( '$$!( 'ti!it(.B%&e e", # t"end in de"e+'!#ti%n ith#t Di c% m#( n%& e "e t"icted t%m#int#in the di t"i 'ti%n net&%"3 #nd$"% ide *#ci!itie *%" e!ect"icit(de!i e"( &hi!e "et#i!e" #"e e$#"#ted*"%m Di c% #nd #!e e!ect"ic ene"+(t% end c%n 'me" .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
26/88
2"
n+epen+ent &/stem
Operator &O! The ISO i the '$"eme entit( inthe c%nt"%! %* t"#n mi i%n( tem. The # ic "e?'i"ement%* #n ISO i di # %ci#ti%n *"%m#!! m#"3et $#"tici$#nt #nd# ence *"%m #n( 2n#nci#!inte"e t in the +ene"#ti%n #nddi t"i 'ti%n ' ine .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
27/88
2#
Po.er %0changer P1! The P h#nd!e the e!ect"ic $%&e"$%%!, &hich $"% ide # *%"'m t% m#tche!ect"ic#! ene"+( '$$!( #nd dem#nd
# ed %n id $"ice . The time h%"i %n%* the $%%! m#"3et m#( "#n+e *"%mh#!* #n h%'" t% # &ee3 %" !%n+e".
The m% t ' '#! i the d#(-#he#d
m#"3et t% *#ci!it#te ene"+( t"#din+ %ned#( e*%"e e#ch %$e"#tin+ d#(.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
28/88
2'
&che+uling $oor+inators &$s!SC #++"e+#te $#"tici$#nt in the ene"+(t"#de #nd #"e *"ee t% ' e $"%t%c%! th#tm#( di6e" *"%m $%%! "'!e .
In %the" &%"d m#"3et $#"tici$#nt m#(ente" #n SC> m#"3et 'nde" SC> "'!eth"%'+h i!#te"#! #nd m'!ti!#te"#!t"#n #cti%n .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
29/88
2(
%1 &T N' MO#%)& OF #%"%'()AT ON
P%%! M%de!
P%%! #nd :i!#te"#! M%de!M'!ti!#te"#! T"#de M%de!
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
30/88
3
P%%! M%de! The En+!#nd W#!e m%de! it($ic#! %* thic#te+%"(.
The
de"e+'!#ti%nm%de! %* Chi!e,A"+entin# #ndE# t A' t"#!i##! % *#!! in thic#te+%"( &ith%mem%di2c#ti%n .
GENCOS
PX TRANSMISSIO N TRANSCOS
RETAILERS
CONSUMERS
DISCOS
Energy sales Energy Flow Coordination
" #""L
%igure 1. 3& ower ool 6odel
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
31/88
31
P%%! :i!#te"#! M%de!
The C#!i*%"ni#m%de! i %*thi c#te+%"(.
The N%"dicm%de! #nd theNe& 4ee!#ndm%de! #!m% t*#!! int% thic#te+%"( &ith%mem%di2c#ti%n .
GENCOS
PX SCs
RETAILERS
CONSUMERS
Transco
DISCOS
Energy sales Energy Flow Coordination
"
%igure 1.4& ool and bilateral model
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
32/88
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
33/88
33
Sin+!e A'cti%n P%&e" P%%!U.F.
1 2 3 .. 7
81
82
83
8n
6ar/et 8learing rice
+nergy id
id rice 9oad %orecast
eneration:ffer rices
%ig 1."
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
34/88
34
D%' !e A'cti%n P%&e" P%%! Ne&4e#!#nd
1 2 3 7
D 1 D 2 D 6
6ar/et 8learing rice
eneration:ffer rices
id rice
+nergy id
urchase id rices
+nergy 8leared
%ig. 1.#
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
35/88
35
In #ct'#! $"#ctice id ch#"#cte"i tic #"en%t % im$!e.
In m( "e e#"ch &%"3, the $"%$% ed+ene"#!i ed de"e+'!#ted m%de! h#een #n#!( ed %n IEEE- 0 te t ( temA!! the i) +ene"#t%" #"e # 'med t%id *%!!%&in+ c% t ch#"#cte"i tic
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
36/88
3"
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
37/88
3#
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
38/88
3'
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
39/88
3(
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
40/88
4
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
41/88
41
? ub@ect to the following constraints after adding all firm transactions.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
42/88
42
%or each > bus m, notincluding the ref. bus.
%or each < bus i
@ g g
$he power flow e)uation of the power networ/
Ahere
-,* =" g
and are respecti ely specified real and reacti e power for < bus i.
and are respecti ely calculated and specified real power for > bus m.
and are oltage magnitude and phase angles of different buses.
}
}}
=
netmm
net
ii
netii
-*>, ,,
-g*>,
where& and are respecti ely calculated real and reacti e power for < bus i.i i#net
i net
i#
m net m#
"
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
43/88
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
44/88
44
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
45/88
45
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
46/88
4"
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
47/88
4#
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
48/88
4'
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
49/88
4(
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
50/88
5
SRMC %* t"#n #cti%n # dete"mined in the$"e i%' ch#$te", #cc%'nt *%" thet"#n mi i%n !% e in the ( tem.
:'t thi d%e n%t c%n ide" the em edded c% t%* #"i%' t"#n mi i%n *#ci!itie .Embedded cost is defned as the revenueEmbedded cost is defned as the revenuerequirements needed to pay or all existingre quirements needed to pay or all existingacilities plus any new acilities added to theacilities plus any new acilities added to the
power system during the li e o the contract or power system during the li e o the contract ortransmission servicetransmission service .
A))O$AT ON OF%MB%#%# $O&T
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
51/88
51
The em edded c% t #!!%c#ti%n i "e?'i"ed %th *%"inte+"#ted "e+'!#ted $%&e" ect%" m% in+ t%"dde"e+'!#ti%n # &e!! # de"e+'!#ted $%&e" ect%".
B%&e e" in de"e+'!#ted $%&e" ( tem thee!ect"icit( m#"3et i decided *%" #n h%'" in %mec# e %n!( *%" h#!* #n h%'" .S% the c% t #!!%c#ti%n *%" e#ch t"#n #cti%n h#een c#!c'!#ted in H@ h%'" %" R . $e" h%'" .In thi ch#$te" # ic meth%d "e$%"ted in the!ite"#t'"e h# e een "e ie&ed.
The e meth%d #!%n+ &ith $"%$% ed meth%d h# eeen #n#!( ed %n 18- ' S%'th A*"ic#n ( tem.
In the ne)t ch#$te" $"%$% ed meth%d h# een#$$!ied t% J- ' Indi#n $%&e" ( tem # &e!! #IEEE-118 ' ( tem.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
52/88
52
MATBEMATICAL =ORMULATION
="%m the T"#n mi i%n C%m$#n( c% t d#t#,t"#n mi i%n *#ci!it( c% t T=C * %* e#ch *#ci!it(* i c#!c'!#ted *%" the (e#" 'nde" t'd(.
The #nn'#! 2)ed ch#"+ed "#te A=CR ic#!c'!#ted *%" the (e#" 'nde" t'd( *"%m the'm %* $e" 'nit c% t d#t#, &hich inc!'dem#inten#nce c% t, t#)e , in '"#nce, inK#ti%n"#te, #dmini t"#ti e #nd +ene"#! e)$en e .
T"#n mi i%n c% t %* *#ci!it( * t% e #!!%c#ted t%t"#n mi i%n ( tem ' e", i.e. t%t#!t"#n mi i%n #nn'#! "e en'e "e?'i"ement *%"the *#ci!it( *, i +i en ( C * A=CR T=C *
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
53/88
53
ostage $tamp %ethod
$he postage stamp * - method also called Bolled in
method, is based on the idea that each party benefits fromthe use of the transmission system and total costs are
therefore allocated proportionally to transaction amount o
each party. $he cost 8a $ of the transaction w is calculated
as
'#"!
!a peak
w& = *5.1-
where&
! C $otal transmission annual re enue re)uirement
peak is the ma0imum acti e load of the completetransmission system.
= f
f ! !
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
54/88
MW Mile Method
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
55/88
55
MW Mile Method:
Dccording to 6A 6ile *6A6- method, embedded costs otransmission system are allocated proportionally to the change in theline 6A flows caused by transaction and length of the line in miles.$he transaction cost 8c $ is EFh for a transaction $ is gi en by thefollowing e)uations.
=
& f f & f
f f & f
& ) ' ) %W ( (
' ) %W ( ! !c
'#" *5.3-
where
&)ntransactiowithout ( %W )& ntransactiowith( %W %W f f f =
9 f C 9ength of transmission 9ine f
*6A f -$ C 6A flow in facility f due to transaction $.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
56/88
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
57/88
5#
oundary low %ethod*
oundary %low * %- method is used for calculating the
changes for transmission transaction across the borders of a grid.$he resulting cost in EFh allocation to a transaction $ is gi en bythe following e)uation
) (
) %W ( ! !d
loading ma+
ii
& '#"
21
= *5.4-
where&&)ntransactiowithout ( %W )& ntransactiowith( %W %W iii =
loading ma+ is the ma0imum acti e load transmission system *grid-
including wheeling transaction. i C boundary lines
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
58/88
5'
T&% $%&e" K%& , e)ec'ted 'cce i e!( &ith#nd &ith%'t the t"#n #cti%n, (ie!d the ch#n+ein indi id'#! %'nd#"( !ine .Once #+#in, th"ee c# e c#n e di tin+'i hed7:=-net, :=-$% #nd :=-+"% . B%&e e":=-net i c%n ide"ed in thi $#$e".:= meth%d i ' e*'! &hen m%"e then %net"#n mi i%n c%m$#n( i in %! ed in &hee!in+t"#n #cti%n. The di t#nce &hee!ed i n%t t#3en int%#cc%'nt in thi meth%d.
MVA Mile Method:
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
59/88
5(
$he transaction cost 85 $ is EFh for a transaction $ is gi en bythe following e)uations.
=
& f f & f
f f & f
& ) ' ) %"( (
' ) %"( ! !e
'#" *5.5-
where&
' f C 9ength of transmission facility f (%" f )& C 6> flow in facility f due to transaction & .
Depending on the direction of power flow, three sub methodscan also be distinguished in this proposed method. $he 6> netchange *6> 6 net-, 6> positi e change *6> 6 pos- and
6> gross change *6> 6 gross-. $he same sign con entionshold as for the 6A 6ile method.
transaction causing more reacti e power loading will beallocated more cost than other transactions, by this method only. othis method is most realistic and fair among all e0isting methods,including 6A mile method.
MVA Mile Method:
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
60/88
"
New Proposed Method In =!%&-mi!e meth%d the ch#n+e in K%& MW %" MVA inthe e#ch *#ci!it(, d'e t% # t"#n #cti%n #"e m'!ti$!ied (the !en+th %* e#ch *#ci!it(. It me#n *%" the #me t"#n mi i%n %* $%&e", #t"#n mi i%n !ine &ith !%n+ !en+th, &i!! h# e m%"e&ei+ht#+e % e" h%"t !en+th !ine.I* #!! the !ine h# e #me "#tin+ th#n the"e i n% $"% !em.:'t t&% t"#n mi i%n !ine &ith #me !en+th m#( h# edi6e"ent "#tin+ #nd hence di6e"ent c% t,S% the( h%'!d h# e di6e"ent &ei+ht#+e *%" c% t
#!!%c#ti%n.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
61/88
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
62/88
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
63/88
"3
& M()AT ON "%&()T&
A!! # % e meth%d %* #!!%c#ti%n %* em eddedc% t h# e een #n#!( ed %n m%di2ed 18- 'S%'th A*"ic#n $%&e" ( tem.Sin+!e !ine di#+"#m %* thi ( tem i h%&n in2+. J.1=%'" im'!t#ne%' i!#te"#! t"#n #cti%n #+i en in t# !e J.1 #nd h%&n in 2+.J.1 #"e#dded t% thi ( tem *%" #n#!( i .
1 3 1 2 1 1 1 0 9 7 4
T 2T 4
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
64/88
"4%ig 5.1& outh frica ower ystem
L 1 8 L 1 7 L 1 6 L 1 5 L 1 4 L 1 1 L 8
G 3
L 1 9
L 2 0
L 2 1
L 2 2 L 2 5
L 2 7
L 2 3
L 2 4
8
G 2
T 2 9T 2 8
7 6 5 K V
T 3 1T 3 0
L 1 2
L 1 3
L 1 0
L 9
6
1 7
1 6G 4
1 8
1 4
L 2 6
3
L 5
L 4L 3
G !
5
1 5
4 0 0 K V
1
2
L 2L 1
T 1
T 1
T 2
T 3
T 3
T 4
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
65/88
"5
$able5.1& *$ransactions->alue of
$ransaction$ransaction
%romus
7o.
$ous
7o. *6A- 6> B $1 4 13 1 . .$2 11 5 12. .$3 3 14 15. #.2"45
*pfC .(-$4 " 12 25. 12.1 #5*
pfC .(-
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
66/88
""
ostage $tamp %ethod*
$able 5.2& * ostage tamp 6ethod-$ransa
ction8ost
*EFhour-8ost*EF6
Ah-$1 1'.1# 1.'1#$2 21.' 1.'1#$3 2#.25 1.'1#$4 45.42 1.'1#
o method is easy to implement and does not re)uire a
power flow in the calculation process. 7either the distance wheeled,nor re erse flows are ta/en into account.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
67/88
"#
-. !ontract ath %ethod
$able 5.3& *8ontract ath 6ethod-
$ransaction
min
path
*6A-
8ontract ath 8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
$1 5 9ine ' 11 1415 1" 1# 1'
53.54 5.35
$2 5 9ine 1" 15 1411 ' #
" . 5.
$3 5 9ine 5 13 23 41.3' 2.#"$4 5 9ine 1 13 23
21 1'25. 3 1.
$he 8 method is easy to implement, but the embedded capitalcost of those facilities, which lies along the assumed path, is onlyta/en into consideration. 6oreo er neither re erse flows or parallelflows are considered.
$est roblem and Besults
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
68/88
"'
1 3 1 2
L 1 8 L 1 7 L 1 6 L 1 5 L 1 4 L 1 1 L 8
G 3
L 1 9
L 2 0
L 2 1
L 2 2 L 2 5
L 2 7
L 2 3
L 2 4
1 1 1 0 9
8
7 4
G 2
T 2 9T 2 8
7 6 5 K V
T 3 1T 3 0L 1 2
L 1 3
L 1 0
L 9
6
1 7
1 6G 4
1 8
1 4
L 2 6
3
L 5
L 4L 3
G !
5
1 5
4 0 0 K V
1
2L 2L 1
T 1
T 1
T 2
T 2
T 3
T 3
T 4
T 4
outh frica ower ystem
oundary low %ethod*
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
69/88
"(
$able& 5.4 * oundary %low 6ethod-$ransaction
8ost allocation of area
*EFhour- *EF6Ah-$1 2$663603 0$26636$2 %4$67021 %0$38918$3 2$678539 0$178569
$4 2$685305 0$107412
$he boundary lines are 12,13,22 and
23.Besult of this method is difficult to compare
with other methods, because this method has
been used for calculating the cost allocation
across the border of the grid only .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
70/88
#
1 3 1 2
L 1 8 L 1 7 L 1 6 L 1 5 L 1 4 L 1 1 L 8
G 3
L 1 9
L 2 0
L 2 1
L 2 2 L 2 5
L 2 7
L 2 3
L 2 4
1 1 1 0 9
8
7 4
G 2
T 2 9T 2 8
7 6 5 K V
T 3 1T 3 0L 1 2
L 1 3
L 1 0
L 9
6
1 7
1 6G 4
1 8
1 4
L 2 6
3
L 5
L 4
L 3
G !
5
1 5
4 0 0 K V
1
2L 2L 1
T 1
T 1
T 2
T 2
T 3
T 3
T 4
T 4
outh frica ower ystem
8
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
71/88
#1
Flo.-mile Metho+ Thi meth%d i $% i !( the *#i"e t #m%n+#!! the # % e meth%d . B%&e e" it "e?'i"e!%t %* c%m$'t#ti%n , in $#"tic'!#" *%" !#"+en'm e" %* im'!t#ne%' t"#n #cti%n . The*%!!%&in+ t&% c# e #"e c%n ide"ed.
C# e17 =%'" im'!t#ne%' t"#n #cti%n# h%&n in t# !e J.1 &ith %n!( "e#!c%m$%nent h# een t#3en *%" #n#!( i .C# e 7 A!! t"#n #cti%n # in c# e1.
:%th "e#! # &e!! # "e#cti e c%m$%nent%* t"#n #cti%n T #nd T h# eenc%n ide"ed *%" #n#!( i .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
72/88
#2
MW-Mile Metho+
$able 5.5& *6A 6ile 6ethod-8ase1 8ase2ran
cti 8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
1 "#.(3 ".#( "#.'4 ".#'2 1 ".(# '.(1 1 #.32 '.(4
3 ''.3# 5.'( ''.34 5.'(4 5#.1# 2.2( 55.'' 2.24ool ( (.2' 1.'2 ( 11. 3 1.'2
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
73/88
#3
M2A-Mile metho+:
$able 5."& *6> 6ile 6ethod-8ase1 8ase2$rans
8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
$1 80$94 8$09 81$30 8$13$2 %110$75 %9$23 %111$33 %9$28$3 108$78 7$25 109$27 7$28$4 95$70 3$83 82$05 3$28ool 8941$10 1$80 8834$96 1$81
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
74/88
#4
Propose+ Flo.-cost metho+
$able 5.#& *proposed 6A 8ost 6ethod-8ase1 8ase2$ransac
tion 8ost*EFhour- 8ost*EF6Ah- 8ost*EFhour- 8ost*EF6Ah-
$1 70$97 7$10 70$91 7$09$2 %103$35 %8$61 %103$59 %8$63$3 87$03 5$80 87$01 5$80$4 33$91 1$36 33$32 1$33ool 9027$22 1$82 9028$12 1$82
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
75/88
#5
$able 5.'& * roposed 6> 8ost 6ethod-8ase1 8ase2$ransac
tion 8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
8ost*EFhour-
8ost*EF6Ah-
$1 80$33 8$03 80$74 8$07$2 %106$90 %8$91 %107$50 %8$96$3 102$26 6$82 102$83 6$86$4 63$39 2$54 50$42 2$02
ool 8976$70 1$81 8989$30 1$81
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
76/88
#"
&O Activities in Pool Mar3et The ISO i # m#in entit( *%" them#n#+ement #nd c%nt"%! %* $%&e"$%%!. It m#in #cti itie #"ec!# i2ed # 7
24-hours ahead of scheduleIn real time
After real time
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
77/88
##
24-hours ahead of schedule Recei e '$$!( c'" e *"%m e#ch+ene"#t%", dem#nd c'" e *"%m
!%#d #nd #! % &i!!in+ne t% $#($"ice *"%m n%n-2"m t"#n #cti%nne)t h%'"@ 8 h#!*-h%'" $e"i%d .Dete"mine # *e# i !e ched'!e th#tm#)imi e %ci#! &e!*#"e.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
78/88
#'
In real time
Di $#tche +ene"#ti%n, !%#d #ndt"#n #cti%n #nd net&%"3 e" ice .De i#ti%n *"%m ched'!e #"edete"mined #nd $en#!i ed
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
79/88
#(
After real time
C#!c'!#te n%d#! $"ice %* ene"+(,net&%"3 e" ice ch#"+e ,
em edded c% t #!!%c#ti%n, etc.C#!c'!#te 2n#! ett!ementinc!'din+ $"ice #nd $en#!tie .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
80/88
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
81/88
'1
&n'illary ser(i'es are needed to )ine t*nesyste+ energy needs , -ely )ir+ly on t.e+)or -elia/ilityar et 'o+ etition
! inning reser(eon%s inning reser(e-e la'e+ent reser(es
ilateral 'ontra'tsoltage s* ort -eg*lation * and down-ea'ti(e ower s* ort
Anci!!#"( Se" ice
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
82/88
'2
INDIAN POWER SECTOR Ti!! 1991, the $%&e" ect%" m#in!( 'nde" the+% e"nment %&ne" hi$ 'nde" #"i%' t#te #nd cent"#!+% e"nment %&ned 'ti!itie .In mid 1990 , O"i # e+#n # $"%ce %* *'nd#ment#!
"e t"'ct'"in+ %* the t#te $%&e" ect%".Unde" the W%"!d :#n3 W: !%#n, the t#te decided t%#d%$t-&h#t i 3n%&n # W:-O"i # m%de! %* "e*%"m. Thic%n i t %* *%!!%&in+ th"ee t"#te+(.
i Un- 'nd!in+ the inte+"#ted 'ti!it( in th"ee e$#"#teect%" %* +ene"#ti%n, t"#n mi i%n #nd di t"i 'ti%n.
ii P"i #ti #ti%n %* the +ene"#ti%n #nd di t"i 'ti%nc%m$#nie
iii E t# !i hment %* inde$endent "e+'!#t%"( c%mmi i%n t%"e+'!#te the e 'ti!itie .
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
83/88
'3
S%%n #*te""d e e"#! %the" t#te'ch # Andh"# P"#de h, B#"(#n#,
Utt#" P"#de h #nd R#5# th#n #! %em #"3ed %n imi!#" "e*%"m #nd#! % # #i!ed !%#n *"%m m'!ti!#te"#!de e!%$ment #n3 'ch # the W:
#nd A i#n De e!%$ment :#n3. L#te" t#te %* F#"n#t#3# #nd De!hi#! % 5%ined the #nd+%n.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
84/88
'4
The E!ect"icit( Re+'!#t%"( C%mmi i%nAct, 1998 %* the cent"#! +% e"nmenten# !ed t#te t% e t# !i h inde$endent"e+'!#t%"( c%mmi i%n #!!e i#tin+ theneed *%" # t#te !e e! !e+i !#ti%n. Se e"#! t#te 'ch # M#h#"# ht"#,
T#mi! N#d' #nd P'n5# h# e e t# !i hed"e+'!#t%"( c%mmi i%n 'nde" thicent"#! !e+i !#ti%n.
In A'+' t 001 the cent"#! +% e"nment
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
85/88
'5
In A + t 001, the cent #! +% e nmenth# int"%d'ced # i!!, The E!ect"icit( :i!!001>.
It $"% ide *%" inc"e# ed c%m$etiti%n inthe $%&e" ect%" ( *#ci!it#tin+ %$en#cce t% t"#n mi i%n #nd di t"i 'ti%n+"id, $%&e" t"#din+, #nd #! % #!!%&in+ettin+ '$ %* c#$ti e $%&e" $!#nt&ith%'t #n( "e t"icti%n.
A*te" !%t %* m%di2c#ti%n , the e!ect"icit(#ct 00 $# ed ( the Indi#nG% e"nment.
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
86/88
'"
The *"eed%m %* +ene"#tin+ c%m$#nie t% e!!e!ect"icit( t% thi"d $#"t(.
The #ct &i!! im$"% e the e/cienc( %* the"m#!$%&e" $!#nt i# im$"% ement in $!#nt !%#d*#ct%".V#"i%' $!#(e" IPP &%'!d c%me *%""d *%"$"%d'cin+ e!ect"icit( in the Indi#n M#"3et.In thi #ct the"e i # $"% i i%n %* Re+'!#t%"(C%mmi i%n.
The "%!e %* "e+'!#t%" &%'!d n%t c%n2ne %n!( t%t#"i6 ette" 't &%'!d #! % e t% ee &hethe"+ene"#ti%n i t#3in+ $!#ce *"%m di6e"ent$"%d'ce" in 'ch # ( th#t it i !e#din+ t%%$tim'm 'ti!i #ti%n %* di6e"ent %'"ce %* ene"+(.
T/e importance of t/e electricit0 Act 1**23
-
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
87/88
'#
D". %+ R#5 S%%dM% i!e7 09 180-J8J0JPh%ne7
019 - J J O/ce Re .
019 - J J=#)7 019 - 8Em#i!7 (" %%d +m#i!.c%m
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/9/2019 Power sector moving towards deregulation
88/88
7ational 8onference
Decem4er 156 1 7 1**8
We Site7 &&&."#ee 008.&%"d$"e .c%m
E-m#i!7 "#ee 008nith +m#i!.c%m
http://www.raee2008.wordpress.com/http://www.raee2008.wordpress.com/