Potential Tool for Development
Transcript of Potential Tool for Development
Presented by : Arthur Wood
Founding Partner Total Impact Advisors [email protected]
IMPACT INVESTING Potential Tool for Development
UNESCAP MEETING – THAILAND - May 19th 2013
THE KEY MESSAGES
• THE SCALE OF THE PROBLEMS WE FACE AND THE
INADEQUACY OF THE CURRENT SOCIAL CAPITAL MARKET • IMPACT INVESTING IS SIMPLY THE INJECTION OF NEW
CAPITAL MARKET TOOLS TO CHANGE INCENTIVES TO SCALE AND COLLABORATION
• OUTCOME MODELS - FINANCIAL TOOLS THAT ALLOW A TRANSITION FROM BILATERAL TO TRUE MULTILATERAL COLLABORATIVE SOLUTIONS AND OTHERS THAT ALSO OPEN ACCESS TO NEW CAPITAL SOURCES
• SANITATION HAS MANY ASPECTS THAT MAKE IT
ATTRACTIVE CROSS CUTTING AND METRICS
3
In the Developed World (and China)- Things are worse than we think!! 66% of the debt is unaccounted for - 50% + of Budgets are in Health and Pensions
4
Foreign Aid is Hitting a Plateau
Source: OECD
Country Programmable Aid: Actual and Planned $ Billions
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
DAC Countries Multilateral Agencies
5
DEVELOPING WORLD – The Second Pincer of Demographics – Youth Radicalisation or Youth Empowerment ?
6
MIND THE GAP - Philanthropic Trends (USA) - Current Plateau + Largest transfer of Wealth in Human History($41 Trillion by 2050) – BUT Only Creates $5-10bn per annum.
Source: Giving USA 2010 Report
IMPACT INVESTING MARKET TODAY
Injecting New Capital Market Tools
New Players
What are the New Capital Market Opportunities ?
Foundation Core Funds
$1 Trillion >Redirected To Mission Related Investment MRI
Social Impact Bonds Multi Trillion (WSP/ WSFF TEEB/ WHO)
Capturing the Value of Externalities
Local Pension Funds in Developing World. $1.3 Trillion
> Capture and Leverage (AMF)
Social Finance Tools Multi Billion
SRI Circa $10 Trillion
Metrics
Mainstream “For Profit” Investments $285bn
Historically 1/5th
VC/ PE Impact Invest
Govt DFI’s Circa $45bn
GRANT & AID (NFP)
THE NEW BLENDED OPPORTUNITIES
FOR PROFIT
Low risk
Sources : TIA, Hudson Institute, McKinsey, AMF, WHO,WSP
9
ABCD – “Normal Investment” Are current investing positions on a
normal efficient frontier Cost of Raising Capital: 0% - 10% EF – “Traditional Philanthropy” Are Philanthropic Grant Investments
reflecting two projects F being riskier than E
Cost of Raising Capital: 25% - 85% GH – “Impact Investing” and with
Externalities (SIBs) = GH plus Are Impact Investing Positions – offers
both social and economic return Cost of Capital: < 10%
THE NEW INVESTING FRONTIER - EXAMPLE – The SIB / Impact “Bond”
Source: TIA / Aquillian / McKinsey
10
CREATING A SOCIAL ECONOMIC BENCHMARK – McKINSEY AND WSP
IDENTIFY – ECONOMIC IMPACT (PROFITABLE UNDER CURVE) IDENTIFY INNOVATION AND SCALE (SIZE OF BLOCK)
Source: McKinsey
11
COST CURVES – ALLOWS YOU TO IDENTIFTY A ROAD MAP – INNOVATION, COLLABORATION AND ECONOMIES OF SCALE
COST CURVE 1 – SOCIO - ECONOMIC BENCHMARK – Innovation / Impact COST CURVE 2 – IDENTIFY VALUE OF DOING NOTHING – Externalities 2-7% GDP COST CURVE 3 – EXIT STRATEGY – Subsidy and Take Out Status Quo
Source: McKinsey
12
DRIVE AND MAP BY A COMMERCIAL PERSPECTIVE - BUSINESS LINES AND FINANCIAL TOOLS APPLICABLE
13
THE FRAME WORK OF MOVING TO OUTCOME MODELS – Real Multi-Stakeholder solutions based on the Delivery of Auditable Tangible Social Outcomes
CAPITAL MARKET INNOVATION– Impact Investing – Injecting Modern Capitalism into Social Market
OUTCOME MODELS - Contingent Models Capturing Future Cash flow (Social Impact Bonds ) x 10+
INTERMEDIAIRES – Capable of Blending Different Sources of social capital
LEGAL Structures – Corporate (B Corp / CIC) and Partnership Structures (L3C / SELLP)
ENTREPRENEURSHIP – Social Entrepreneurship the R&D of Society
DISTRIBUTION – Leveraging Civil Society and Hybrid Corporate Delivery Mechanisms
Grants Recoverable Grants
Investment Plus Mainstream Investments
no financial return blended market returns market return
Programme Related Investment
Sources: TIA / Bates Braithwaite / Bolton
14
Political consensus across the Party Lines - but Action ?
Paul Martin – Ex PM of Canada
“ We have learned that entrepreneurship is an unbeatable force. Government unleashed the power of business entrepreneurs when it provided them with the wherewithal to succeed. What I would now ask, is that government unleash the
power of social entrepreneurs.”
Gordon Brown – Ex PM of UK with UN Sec Gen Banki Moon “Our objectives cannot be achieved by government alone however well intentioned, or
the private sector alone, however generous, or NGO’s or faith groups, however well meaning or determined. It can only be achieved in a genuine partnership together”
David Cameron – UK PM
“ I believe that this generation could see a revolution in our social economy comparable to the revolution in the commercial economy in the 1980s. That is the revolution that I
want to lead…Don’t we need the same transformation in the social sphere that we have seen in the economic sphere? “
TOTAL IMPACT ADVISORS THANK YOU!